Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C ) No.41937 of 2023
In the matter of an application under Article-226 & 227 of
the Constitution of India
………………
Jalen Surin
….
Petitioner
-versus-
State of Odisha & Others
For Petitioner
….
Opposite Parties
:
M/s. V. Mallick, Adv.
For Opp. Parties :
M/s. C.K. Pradhan,
Addl. Govt. Advocate
PRESENT:
THE HONBLE MR.JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
----------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing: 13.02.2026 and Date of Judgment:13.02.2026
----------------------------------------------------------------------------Biraja Prasanna Satapathy, J.
1.
This matter is taken up through Hybrid Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties.
3.
Petitioner has filed the present Writ Petition inter
alia challenging rejection of his claim to get the benefit
// 2 //
of 2(two) advance increment because of having the
Degree qualification under Annexure-11.
4.
It is contended that Petitioner was appointed as
a Jr. Engineer vide order of appointment issued on
08.06.1999 under Annexure-1 series issued by the
Chief Engineer, RWSS, Odisha, Bhubaneswar.
contended
that
while
so
continuing,
It is
Petitioner
acquired the B.E qualification in Civil Engineering vide
Annexure-2 from Janardan Rai Nagar Rajasthan
Vidyapeeth University, Udaipur(Rajasthan) India, the
result of which was published on 25.06.2009.
4.1. It is contended that in view of the Resolution
issued by the Finance Department on 14.05.2008
under Annexure-4, Petitioner on acquiring the Degree
qualification became entitled to get the benefit of
2(two) advance increment. Resolution dt.14.05.2008
prescribing the guideline, more particularly Para-(iii)
reads as follows:
(iii) The financial benefits on account of grant
of advancement increments will be available
from the date of award of such degree or
with effect from 01.04.2008 which ever is
later.
// 3 //
4.2. Placing reliance on the aforesaid provision,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
Petitioner
contended that since Petitioner acquired the Degree
qualification, result of which was published on
25.06.2009, he became entitled to get the benefit of
2(two) advance increment from the date of award of
such Degree. However, when such benefit was not
extended
in
his
favour,
Petitioner
moved
the
Departmental Authority under Annexure-5 series,
claiming extension of the benefit.
4.3. It is also contended that similarly situated Jr.
Engineers after acquiring their Degree qualification
were extended with the benefit of 2(two) advance
increment,
basing
on
the
self-same
resolution
dt.14.05.2008 vide Office order dt.24.04.2012 under
Annexure-7.
made
However, such claim of the Petitioner
under
Annexures-8
ultimately
under
Annexure-10 was rejected vide the impugned order
dt.19.10.2022 under Annexure-11, so issued by Opp.
Party No.4.
// 4 //
4.4. Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner
contended
that
since
Petitioner
admittedly
has
acquired the Degree qualification on 25.06.2009,
under Annexure-2, in view of the resolution issued
by the Finance Department on 14.05.2008 under
Annexure-4, Petitioner is eligible and entitled to get
the benefit of 2 (two) advancement increment.
Not
only that persons similarly situated have been
extended
with
the
benefit
vide
Office
order
dt.24.04.2012 under Anenxure-7 and Office order
dt.22.03.2017 under Annexure-9. However, claim of
the Petitioner has been rejected without proper
appreciation of the stipulation contained in
the
resolution dt.14.05.2008 under Annexure-4.
4.5. Making all these submission, learned counsel
appearing for the Petitioner contended that rejection
of the Petitioner’s claim so made vide the impugned
order under Anenxure-11 is not sustainable in the
eye of law.
5.
Mr. C.K. Pradhan, learned Addl. Govt. Advocate
on the other hand while supporting the impugned
// 5 //
order made his submission basing on the stand
taken in the counter affidavit so filed by Opp. party
Nos.2 & 4.
5.1. It is contended that since Petitioner acquired
the Degree qualification through Distance Mode,
Petitioner is not eligible and entitled to get the same,
in view of the letter issued by the Department of
Water Resources on 07.11.2013 under AnnexureH/1.
5.2. It is also contended that since Petitioner has
acquired the Degree qualification from an institution
through Distance Mode and the said Institution got
the affiliation of the AICTE-UGC, Pursuant to the
order passed by the Apex Court on 22.01.2018,
Petitioner is not eligible and entitled to get the benefit
and the same has been rightly rejected.
Stands
taken in paragraphs-7 & 8 of the counter affidavit
reads as follows:
7. That, the Petitioner joined service under
Public Health Engineering Organization, Odisha as
Junior Engineer having qualification as diploma in
civil engineering. While in service, he acquired
degree in Civil Engineering from the JRN Rajasthan
// 6 //
Vidyapeeth University, Udaipur in the session/
Year Aug-2008 in distance Mode. But in pursuance
of the order dtd. 22.01.2018 of Hon'ble Supreme
Court in CA Nos. 17869-17870 of 2017, the degree
of B. Tech in Engineering awarded by JRN,
Rajasthan Vidyapeeth University, Rajasthan,
Udaipur to Sri Jalen Surien was validity by AICTEUGC Special Examination having reference No.
SE/Dec 2018/11800386
8. That, per Finance Department Resolution
No.24942/F, dated 14.05.2008, some Junior
Engineers acquiring degree qualification in
engineering through distance education mode have
been allowed two advance increments on the
recommendation of the Expert committee during the
year 2012. Subsequently, during the year 2013,
Government in Water Resources Department as
Nodal Department for Engineering Service, decided
that Bachelor Degree acquired through distance
mode of Education in Engineering field may not be
considered sufficiently of higher merit and
accordingly instructed that the Junior Engincers in
the regular scale of pay working under various
Engineering Department of Govt having degree
qualifications through distance mode of education,
henceforth will not be considered for grant of two
advance increments. Thereafter, Junior Engineers
having degree qualification in engineering field
through distance mode of education have not been
allowed two advance increment. The petitioner has
acquired degree qualification in Civil Engineering
through distance mode of education which is not
considered sufficiently of higher merit and therefore
deserve no consideration for grant of two advance
increment as provided under FD Resolution dated
14.05.2008. Moreover, in the present Writ Petition,
the Petitioner has not challenged the decision of the
Govt. vide letter No.28664/WR, dated 07.11.2013.
5.3. It is accordingly contended that since the
institution from which the Petitioner acquired the
Degree qualification was recognized by AICTE-UGC,
pursuant to the order passed by the Apex Court on
// 7 //
22.01.2018, Petitioner’s claim is not covered by the
resolution issued by the Finance Department on
14.05.2008 under Annexure-4. It is also contended
that in view of the subsequent resolution issued by
the Water Resources Department on 07.11.2013
under Annexure-H/1, Petitioner is not eligible to get
the benefit.
6.
To the submission made by the learned Addl.
Govt. Advocate, learned counsel appearing for the
Petitioner contended that the ground raised in the
counter affidavit with regard to rejection of the
Petitioner’s claim since is not the ground indicated in
the impugned order, the same is not permissible, in
view of the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of Mohinder Singh Gill & Another Vs. the
Chief
Election
Commissioner,
Others, AIR 1978 SC 851.
New
Delhi
&
Hon’ble Apex Court in
Para-8 of the said judgment has held as follows:“8. The second equally relevant matter is that when
a statutory functionary makes an order based
on
certain grounds, its validity must be judged by the
reasons
so
mentioned
and
cannot
be
supplemented by fresh reasons in the shape of
affidavit or otherwise. Otherwise, an order bad in the
// 8 //
beginning may, by the time it comes to court on
account of a challenge, get validated by additional
grounds later brought out. We may here draw
attention to the observations of Bose J. in
Gordhandas Bhanji (AIR 1952 SC 16 (at p.18):
"Public orders, publicly made, in exercise of a
statutory authority cannot be construed in the light of
explanations subsequently given by the officer
making the order of what he meant, or of what was
in his mind, or what he intended to, do. Public orders
made by public authorities are meant to have public
effect and are intended to effect the acting and
conduct of those to whom they are addressed and
must be construed objectively with reference to the
language used in the order itself."
Orders are not like old wine becoming better as they
grow older:
A Caveat”.
7.
Having heard learned counsel appearing for the
parties and considering the submission made, this
Court finds that Petitioner was appointed as a Jr.
Engineer vide order of appointment issued on
dt.8.04.1999 under Anenxure-1 series.
While so
continuing as a Jr. Engineer, Petitioner acquired the
Degree qualification, result of which was published
on 25.06.2009 under Annexure-2, Petitioner claiming
the benefit of two (2) advance increments in terms of
the
resolution
issued
on
14.05.2008
under
Anenxure-4 of the Finance Department, raised his
claim.
// 9 //
7.1. As found from the impugned order, Petitioner’s
claim has been rejected only on the ground that such
a provision is not reflected in ORSP Rules, 2008 or
2017. It is however found that similar benefit basing
on Annexure-4 Resolution has been extended vide
orders issued under Annexures-7 & 9. Since similar
benefit has been extended in favour of similarly
situated Jr. Engineers vide orders under Annexures-7
& 9, and the ground of rejection taken in the counter
affidavit is not the ground taken in the impugned
rejection, this Court following the decision in the case
of Mohinder Singh Gill, is of the view that no such
ground can be taken which is not the ground in the
impugned order.
7.2. Since admittedly, Petitioner has acquired
the
Degree
the
qualification
on
25.06.2009
and
institution in question, as per the order of the Apex
Court has been recognized by the AICTE and UGC,
this Court is of the view that the ground on which
Petitioner’s claim was rejected vide the impugned
order under Annexure-11 is not sustainable in the
// 10 //
eye of law.
counter
No document is also enclosed in the
showing
recognized
during
that
the
the
institution
period
was
not
Petitioner
was
prosecuting his Degree.
7.3. Therefore, this Court is inclined to quash the
impugned order dt.19.10.2022
under Annexure-11
and quash the same accordingly. While quashing the
same, this Court directs Opp. Party No.3 to extend
the benefit of two (2) advance increment in favour of
the Petitioner from the date of his eligibility and
extend the differential entitlement as due and
admissible with passing of an appropriate order.
This Court directs Opp. party No.3 to complete the
entire exercise within a period of 3(three) months
from the date of receipt of this order.
8.
The Writ Petition accordingly stands disposed
of.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SANGITA PATRA Dated the 13th February, 2026/Sangita
Reason: authentication of order
Location: high court of orissa, cuttack
Date: 17-Feb-2026 17:10:40
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review