The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. [CW-2014/2018] In view of discussion made hereinabove, S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.2014/2018 filed by RSRTC is hereby dismissed but S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.19222/2017 is partly allowed and the award dated 28.08.2017 is modified to the extent that the workman Jagdish Prasad is entitled for a compensation of ₹1,50,000/instead of ₹1,00,000/- as determined by the Industrial Tribunal. The workman is also entitled for interest as directed by the Tribunal. The workman is not entitled for any order of reinstatement.
23. With the aforesaid, the writ petitions stand disposed of with pending application, if any. (ASHOK KUMAR JAIN),J MR/39 and 40
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:1132]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 2014/2018
Chief Manager, Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation, We
Depot, Alwar Rajasthan Through Its Officer Incharge.
----Petitioner
Versus
Jagdish Prasad S/o Shri Sohan Lal, Resident Of Village Bhusawar,
Tehsil Weir, District Alwar, Presently Residing In Kumher Gate,
Opposite Picture Palace, Mali Mohalla, Bharatpur Rajasthan
----Respondent
Connected With
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 19222/2017
Jagdish Prasad, Son Of Sohan Lal, aged about 53 years, Resident
Of Village Bhusawar, Tehsil Weir, District Bharatpur At Present
Resident Of Kumher Gate, Behind Picture Palace, Mali Mohalla,
Bharatpur (Raj.)
----Petitioner
Versus
Chief Manager, Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation,
Alwar, V-Depot, Alwar.
----Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. Manjeet Kaur in SBCWP No.
2014/2018
Mr. Devendra Kumar Bhardwaj in
SBCWP No.19222/2017
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Devendra Kumar Bhardwaj in
SBCWP No. 2014/2018
Mr. Nitin Sinsinwar in SBCWP
No.19222/2017
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK KUMAR JAIN
Order
08/01/2026
1.
Arising out of award dated 28.08.2017 in LCR No. 663/2006
(Old No. 25/1999), passed by the Industrial Tribunal cum Labour
(2 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:1132]
[CW-2014/2018]
Court, Alwar, in a reference under Section 10 of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 (Hereinafter referred as ‘the Act of 1947’),
these writ petitions were filed firstly by the RSRTC and other by
the workman Jagdish Prasad.
2.
By this order, we are disposing of both the writ petitions.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that the workman was
appointed on the post of conductor on daily wage basis vide order
dated 28.05.1985 and after completion of 180 days, he was
appointed on probation for a period of one year vide order dated
31.03.1986. When the work of workman Jagdish Prasad was not
found satisfactory, his probation period was extended for a period
of six months and one penalty was imposed vide order dated
18.06.1986. After inspection on 17.08.1986, it was found that
fourteen and half passengers were traveling without tickets, when
the workman Jagdish Prasad was discharging his duty as
Conductor then his services were terminated on 20.08.1986 and
the workman has invoked provision of the Act of 1947 and a
reference was made on 03.12.1998 by the Labour Department.
4.
After filing of the statement of claim by workman and reply
by the employer (RSRTC), statements of AW1 Jagdish Prasad
(workman) and NAW1 Sharifan Meena (employer) were recorded.
The workman has exhibited three documents whereas employer
has exhibited eight documents. Vide order dated 28.08.2017, the
Tribunal has found that the termination order dated 20.08.1986
was illegal and contrary to provisions of law, but instead of
reinstatement,
the
Tribunal
has
directed
compensation of ₹1,00,000/- to the workman.
and
awarded
(3 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:1132]
5.
[CW-2014/2018]
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of RSRTC (employer)
has submitted that the workman was on probation and his
services can be terminated if his performance in probation is not
as satisfactory. She further submits that the termination order was
simplicitor and not a stigmatic order and it does not warrant an
enquiry. She also submits that the Industrial Tribunal has awarded
compensation in exorbitant manner and same is contrary to
settled norms. She further submits that the workman has raised
the dispute after eleven years and the Tribunal has not considered
this
fact
but
the
workman
has
filed
a
writ
petition
for
reinstatement which is not maintainable as the workman has
rendered less than two years’ of service in all manner.
6.
Aforesaid contentions were opposed by learned counsel
appearing on behalf of workman and he submitted that initially
the petitioner was appointed on daily wage basis and he has
completed 240 days. He also submits that the services of the
workman were terminated only on ground that the workman has
committed a misconduct. He further submits that a civil suit is
filed by the workman, and delay is explained by him before the
Tribunal. He also referred the award and submitted that when the
termination is adjudged as illegal and arbitrary, the natural
consequence is reinstatement in service. He further submits that
the workman is entitled for reinstatement with back wages.
7.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of RSRTC in connected
matter has opposed the contentions of the learned counsel
appearing for the workman and submitted that the workman is not
entitled for any relief of reinstatement.
(4 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:1132]
8.
[CW-2014/2018]
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material placed on record.
9.
A perusal of award dated 28.08.2017 indicate that when a
reference is made then two questions were referred and they are
as under:I. Whether is it appropriate to raise issue dispute after 11 years?
II. If yes, whether termination by employer on 20.08.1986 is
proper and legal, and if no, what relief the workman is entitled?
10.
The Tribunal has referred order dated 20.08.1986 (Ex.M8)
and observed that the services were terminated as work and
performance of workman was not found satisfactory. A cheque of
₹1237.50/- was enclosed and the Tribunal has drawn a conclusion
that it was a retrenchment. The Tribunal has also referred
deposition of NAW-1 Sharifan Meena, wherein he admitted that
due to indiscipline and causing loss to Corporation, the services of
workman (Jagdish Prasad) was terminated. The Tribunal has also
considered that when the passengers without ticket were found,
then no inquiry was conducted whereas the standing orders issued
by the Corporation provides that an enquiry is required to be
conducted.
11.
The evidence on record were considered by the Tribunal in
light of judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court and this Court, and
the Tribunal has drawn a conclusion that a probationer is also
entitled
to
certain
protection
and
his
services
cannot
be
terminated arbitrarily and certainly not in a punitive manner
without complying with the principles of natural justice.
12.
Having taken note of the material placed before the Tribunal,
it is apparent that the Tribunal is a final authority as regard to fact
(5 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:1132]
[CW-2014/2018]
finding inquiry is concerned, as no appeal is prescribed from the
award passed by the Industrial Tribunal or by Labour Court.
13.
The invocation of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is only on legal grounds and this Court
cannot enter into a factual controversy. The judgment/award itself
indicate that on basis of evidence, both documentary and oral,
the Tribunal has drawn a conclusion that the termination was
stigmatic and the services were terminated without giving
opportunity of hearing and defend to workman, there is no legal
ground
for
interference
in
the
conclusion
about
impugned
termination order.
14.
The second ground raised before us is - Whether delay
frustrate the case of workman?
15.
The workman has filed a civil suit on 18.08.1986 soon after
the remark dated 17.08.1986 on apprehension but afterward the
suit was withdrawn and a dispute was raised before the Labour
Authority and ultimately, a reference was made. The Tribunal has
found that the dispute was raised just after three years and same
is not a substantial delay on this ground the workman is not
entitled to reinstate in service.
16.
We agree with the proposition as observed by the Tribunal in
para No.20, that there was delay of three years and not 11 years.
The annexure-1 (A copy of plaint) filed in S.B. Civil Writ Petition
No. 19222/2017, indicate the workman has filed a civil suit, before
raising labour dispute. Thus, the case of workman is not frustrated
on ground of delay as perusing a remedy before Civil Court is also
not barred, considering the judgment in case of RSRTC Vs.
Balmukund Bairwa : (2009) 4 SCC 299.
(6 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:1132]
[CW-2014/2018]
17.
Considering totality of facts and circumstances, it is apparent
on
record
that
the
workman
has
rendered
services
from
28.05.1985 to 20.08.1986, but the dispute is raised after some
delay and there is no explanation of delay of three years. Thus,
agreeing with the reasons as assigned by the Tribunal, the
workman is not entitled for reinstatement in service.
18.
The only issue before us is award of compensation. It is
apparent on record that the workman has rendered service of
more than one year but less than one year and three months.
19.
In case of Allahabad Bank Vs. Krishan Pal Singh : 2021
SCC OnLine Sc 751, Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that
reinstatement with full back wages is not automatic in every case,
where termination/dismissal is found to be not in accordance with
procedure prescribed under law. It was held that the ends of
justice
would
be
met
by
awarding
lump
sum
monetary
compensation and directed payment of lump sum compensation of
₹15,00,000/- to workman within a period of eight weeks failing
which the workman is entitled for interest @ 6% per annum, till
payment.
20.
In case of Amit Kumar Dubey Vs. M.P.P.K.V.V. Co. Ltd. &
Anr. : Civil Appeal No. …… of 2025 (Arising from SLP (Civil)
No.20902/2024)
and
other
connected
matters,
Hon’ble
Supreme Court has directed payment of compensation at the rate
of ₹1,50,000/- per year for the period he has worked.
21.
Considering overall facts and circumstances, it is appropriate
to enhance compensation from ₹1,00,000/- to ₹1,50,000/- and it
will meet the ends of justice.
(7 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:1132]
22.
[CW-2014/2018]
In view of discussion made hereinabove, S.B. Civil Writ
Petition No.2014/2018 filed by RSRTC is hereby dismissed but S.B.
Civil Writ Petition No.19222/2017 is partly allowed and the award
dated 28.08.2017 is modified to the extent that the workman
Jagdish Prasad is entitled for a compensation of ₹1,50,000/instead of ₹1,00,000/- as determined by the Industrial Tribunal.
The workman is also entitled for interest as directed by the
Tribunal.
The
workman
is
not
entitled
for
any
order
of
reinstatement.
23.
With the aforesaid, the writ petitions stand disposed of with
pending application, if any.
(ASHOK KUMAR JAIN),J
MR/39 and 40
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review