Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 456 of 2018
Date of Decision: 14.12.2023
Shri. Jagat Bahadur Khawash
Vs.
Union of India & 4 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. R. Jha, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv.
i)
ii)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
This writ petition has been preferred by the petitioner seeking quashing
and setting aside of the impugned order issued vide letter No.81021/1
AR/IMB/2018/Adm-VI/555 dated 27-08-2018 whereby the petitioner was
discharged/released from service on medical ground w.e.f. 30-11-2018.
The petitioner also prayed for grant of disability pension/invalid pension
considering the other circumstances of the case.
1.
The brief fact of the case is that the petitioner was enrolled in the
service of Assam Rifles on 03-10-2010 as a Rifleman (General Duty) in
1st Assam Rifles and he was posted in Aizawl, Mizoram from 2001 till
2004.
The petitioner was thereafter posted in Kamjong, Manipur from
2004 till 2008. The petitioner was again posted in Tuensang, Nagaland in
2008 where he continued till 2012. From 2012 to 2015 he was posted in
Khonsa, Arunachal Pradesh and, thereafter he was posted in Lunglei,
Mizoram in 2015. On 27-08-2018, the discharge/release order of the
petitioner was issued on medical ground which is under challenged in this
writ petition.
2.
Mr. R. Jha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner was never placed in Low Medical Category of P - 4 or P - 5
at any point of time in his service career. Referring to the report of
medical board proceeding dated 26-07-2018, the learned counsel submits
that the petitioner was placed under P- 2 (P) category, which would not
lead to discharge/ release of the petitioner from service as per the related
rules of the service.
3.
The contention of the petitioner raised in the writ petition is that the
petitioner was placed directly in permanent Low Medical Category of S- 5
without placing him first in temporary Low Medical Category of S- 3 in
gross violation of norms and instructions issued from time to time. It is
contended that as per paragraph 23 (f) (ii) of the Health Care System in
Central Paramilitary Force instructions for Medical Examination and
Classification in CPMFs dated 28-09-2007, it is obligatory to observe a
person in temporary Low Medical Category in S- 3 (T- 24) initially before
he can be categorized and placed in S- 5 and invalidated out of service.
The case of the petitioner is that though he was discharged/release from
service on account of alcohol dependency, the respondents could not have
done so without adhering to the aforesaid procedure contained in
paragraph 23 (f) (ii). The impugned order, as such, cannot be sustained.
4.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI appearing for the respondents, on the
other hand submits that though the petitioner has never been placed in
Low Medical Category of P- 4 or P- 5, he was placed in Low Medical
Category S- 5 which resulted in his discharge/release from service in
terms of the related provisions of Assam Rifles Medical Examination
(Categorization and Invalidation) Rules, 1988 and instructions issued with
regard to the Health Care System in Central Para-Military Forces. He
submits that the petitioner when in service developed the habit of
excessive liquor consumption and became addict to alcohol.
The
petitioner was briefed and counseled on a number of occasions, but
petitioner did not pay any heed to the advice. The learned DSGI by
drawing attention to the various documents submits that because of the
downfall of the health condition of the petitioner and dependency on
alcohol, he had to be hospitalized on number of occasions and after
detailed medical investigation was diagnosed as a case of “Alcohol Liver
Disease and Seizure Disorder (Alcohol Withdrawal)”.
He submits that
the petitioner was placed under Low Medical Category P- 3 (Temporary)
vide Medical Board proceeding dated 22-08-2017 for 24 weeks.
Thereafter, again on 30-01-2018 the petitioner was placed in Low Medical
Category P- 2 for the same ailment for another period of 24 weeks. The
petitioner was further downgraded to Low Medical Category P- 2
(permanent) by the Medical Board on 26-07-2018. He submits that while
the petitioner was categorized in „P‟ class for Alcohol Liver Disease and
Alcohol Withdrawal Seizure, he was also diagnosed with „S‟ class for
psychological disability and was placed in Low Medical Category S- 3
(Temporary) for 24 weeks w.e.f. 20-11-2017 for disability of Alcohol
Dependence Syndrome.
He further submits that the petitioner was
ultimately placed in Low Medical Category S- 5 category on the basis of
the evaluation of the psychiatrist which was approved by the Invalidating
Medical Board proceeding dated 01-08-2008. The learned DSGI submits
that once any member is placed under SHAPE- 5 for any medical
condition, he is considered as permanently unfit to be retained in service.
He further submits that the petitioner has also not preferred any appeal
against the order of the Invalidating Medical Board under Rule 13 of the
Assam Rifles Medical Examination (Categorization and Invalidation)
Rules, 1988 and, as such, cannot have any grievance to be redressed by
this Court.
5.
In the light of the submissions made by the rival parties, averments
made in the writ petition and the affidavits filed in the matter and on the
scrutiny of the documents available on record, it transpires that the
petitioner, while in service developed the habit of excessive liquor
consumption and became an addict to alcohol. He continued with the
habit inspite of all the medical treatments and advises which resulted in
awarding of 7 days rigorous imprisonment to the petitioner on 16-04-2015
in Assam Rifles custody under Section 35 of Assam Rifles Act, 2006.
The Medical Board proceeding dated 22-08-2017 indicates that the
petitioner was placed under Low Medical Category P- 3 (Temporary) for
Alcohol Liver Disease and Seizure Disorder w.e.f. 09-08-2017 for 24
weeks. Again, the petitioner was examined by the Medical Board 30-012018 and he was placed in Low Medical Category P- 2 (Temporary) for
the same ailment for a period of 24 weeks. Subsequently, on 26-07-2018,
the Medical Board on examination of the petitioner further downgraded
him to Low Medical Category P- 2 (Permanent) for principal disability of
Alcohol Liver Disease and Alcohol Withdrawal Seizure w.e.f. 16-07-2018
for a period of 2 years.
6.
The materials on record further reveal that while the petitioner was
suffering from the aforesaid disabilities for which he was categorized in
factor „P‟ on account of Alcohol Liver Disease and Alcohol Withdrawal
Seizure, he was also placed in Low Medical Category S- 3 (T) for 24
weeks from 20-11-2017 for disability of „Alcohol Dependence
Syndrome‟. It appears that the petitioner was referred to the psychiatrist
on 11-06-2018 for recategorization and opinion. After evaluation of the
health condition of the petitioner, the Commandant (CMO/NFS), MD
Psychiatry, Assam Rifles Composite Hospital, vide his opinion dated 1106-2018 found that the petitioner was a relapse case and recommended for
placing him in Low Medical Category S- 5 for Alcohol Deficient
Syndrome relapse.
Relying on the opinion of the Psychiatrist, the
Invalidating Medical Board vide proceeding dated 01-08-2018 placed the
petitioner in Low Medical Category S- 5 and recommended him to be
invalidated out of service. The recommendation was approved by the
DIG (Medical) Director General Assam Rifles and confirmed by the
Additional Director General Assam Rifles.
Thereafter the impugned
order dated 27-08-2018 was issued discharging the petitioner from service
w.e.f. 30-11-2018.
7.
As explained by the respondents in their affidavit dated 15-09-2023,
under the Assam Rifles Medical Examination (Categorization and
Invalidation) Rules, 1988 the following factors of fitness are taken into
consideration:
(i)
S
:
Psychological
(ii)
H
:
Hearing
(iii)
A
:
Appendages
(iv)
P
:
Physical Capacity
(v)
E
:
Eye Sight
Further, the efficiency of each factor is again denoted in numerals 1, 2, 3,
4 and 5 as follows:
8.
(1)
:
Fit for all duties.
(2)
:
(3)
:
Fit for all duties but may have limitations
as to type of duty and area of
employability.
Excepting „S‟ factor, fit for sedentary
duties but may have limitations of
employability at high altitude (beyond
2700 Mtrs, extreme cold/hilly areas” for
long assignment.
(4)
:
(5)
:
On Sick Leave/In Hospital (Temporarily
unfit for force duties).
Permanently unfit for duty in the Force.
It appears from the above that the different factors collectively are
referred to as “SHAPE” classification and the various grade under each
factor are to be awarded to officers depending on their physical capacity.
It is also clear that if any officer is categorized in numerical Grade 5 in
any one of the factors of “SHAPE” classification, the officer will be
rendered permanently unfit for force duties. Further, as per the policy on
Health Care System in Central Para-Military Force dated 31-07-2007, if
any member of the force is placed in Low Medical Category SHAPE - 5
for any medical condition, he becomes liable to be invalidated out of
service.
9.
The petitioner in this case was placed in composite category of S-5,
H-1, A-1, P-2(P), E-1. Before the petitioner was placed in Low Medical
Category S-5 on 01-08-2018, he was placed in Low Medical Category S-3
(T) for 24 weeks w.e.f. 20-11-2017.
Therefore, it is clear that the
petitioner was kept under observation in temporary Low Medical
Category of S-5 as per the requirement of the instruction dated 31-072007 contained in the Health Care System in Central Para-Military
Forces. The contention of the petitioner that he was directly placed in
Low Medical Category S- 5 without placing him first in Low Medical
Category S- 3 for observation is factually incorrect and, therefore, not
acceptable.
10.
With regard to the other contention of the petitioner that he was
never placed in Low Medical Category P- 4 or P- 5, it can be seen from
the proceeding dated 01-08-2018 of the Invalidating Medical Board that
the petitioner was recommended to be invalidated out of service on
account of his placement in Low Medical Category S- 5 and not because
of his placement in Low Medical Category for factor „P‟ of “SHAPE”
classification. Thus, the contention has no impact in the merit of the
present matter.
11.
It is submitted by the learned DSGI that the petitioner has already
signed the required pension paper and the same has been processed by the
department. In view of the submission, no order is called for at this stage
with regard to the release of disability pension/ invalid pension of the
petitioner.
12.
For what has been discussed above, there is no merit in this writ
petition and the same is accordingly dismissed.
13.
There will be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
14.12.2023
“Biswarup-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review