Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:20944
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 4697 of 2022
Jadhav Sagar Ramchandra S/o Shri Jadhav Ramchandra Nagnath Aged
About 35 Years Presently Working As Divisional Forest Officer, Forest
Division, Sukma, District : Sukuma, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Chhattisgarh State Information Commission Through - The
Commissioner, Sector - 19, North Block, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur,
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Shri Sharad Singh R/o Flat Number 17, 18, Block - 1, Lalbaug
Housing Board Colony, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh...
... Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For the Petitioner
: Mr. N. Naha Roy, Advocate.
For Respondent No.1 :
Mr. Shyam Sunderlal Tekchandani, Advocate.
For Respondent No.2 :
None.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Hon'ble Mr. Amitendra Kishore Prasad, Judge
Order on Board
05/05/2026
1. By way of this petition, the petitioner has prayed for following
reliefs:“10.1 Issue an appropriate writ and set aside the
order dated 07.09.2022 (Annexure P/1), whereby the
second appeal preferred by the respondent No.2
under Section 19(3) of the RTI Act, 2005, has been
allowed without affording minimum opportunity of
hearing to the petitioner in utter violation of provisions
of the RTI Act, 2005 and of natural justice.
10.2. Grant any other relief, which is deemed fit in
the circumstances of the case.”
2. Brief facts of the case, are that, the petitioner is presently working
as ‘Divisional Forest Officer’ at Forest Division, Sukma, District :
Sukuma, Chhattisgarh. Respondent No.2/information seeker filed
an application Annexure P-2 dated 24.06.2021 under the Right to
Information Act (for short, ‘RTI Act) seeking supply of photocopy of
cheque drawn register having the withdrawal and expenses details
pertaining to the amount received from the State Campa Account in
the financial year 2018-19, to which, the petitioner has responded
by a communication letter/reply Annexure P-3 dated 05.07.2021
stating therein that the information sought by respondent No.2 was
not specific as no particular work related withdrawal/expenses
were mentioned in the alleged application. It has been informed to
respondent No.2 that in case he files a new application exactly
specifying the particular work related withdrawal/expenses, he will
be
supplied
with
the
information.
Being
aggrieved,
appellant/respondent No.2 (herein) preferred an first appeal on
11.08.2021 under Section 19 of the RTI Act before the concerned
Appellate Authority, which came to be dismissed vide order
Annexure P-5 dated 22.10.2021 on the ground that information
sought by respondent No.2 is not specific and the Cheque Drawn
Register cannot be supplied in light of Section 6(1)(b) of the RTI
Act as the application does not specify the particulars of the
information sought by respondent No.2. Against which, respondent
No.2
preferred
the
second
appeal
on
09.12.2021
before
respondent No.1/Chhattisgarh State Information Commission and
on the first date of hearing, ie, on 07.09.2022 respondent No.1
passed an adverse order against the petitioner with following
direction:
“1. The petitioner would supply the information
sought to respondent No.2 within a period of 30
days by the present incumbent.
2. The loss to the state exchequer in the context
would be recovered from the petitioner at the rate of
Rs.2.00 per page.
3. The petitioner was then issued with a notice
asking to show cause as to why a penalty under
Section 20(1) of the RTI Act may not be imposed
upon him and his department may not be
recommended for a disciplinary enquiry under
Section 20(2) of the RTI Act.
4. It was, thereafter, observed if the petitioner failed
to file his reply or if the reply is not satisfactory or if
the petitioner failed to appear at the next date of
hearing, the Appellate Authority shall pass an exparte order.
3. The order dated 07.09.2022 was passed by respondent No.1
without affording any opportunity of hearing to the petitioner and
even though the order was passed in the first hearing itself, it has
recorded conclusions adverse to the petitioner causing civil
consequences to him which is a flagrant infringement of the
principles of reasonability as well, thereby compelling the petitioner
to approach this Court.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that since application of
appellant/respondent No.2 filed under the RTI Act was vague and
lacking in necessary particulars, the information sought could not
be furnished and accordingly a reasoned reply to that effect was
communicated vide letter Annexure P-3 dated 05.07.2021, however,
despite such clarification, the information seeker neither appeared
before the concerned authority to file a proper and specific
application nor sought for any assistance from the Public
Information Officer to obtain the information in accordance with the
procedure prescribed under law; it is further submitted that said
response of the petitioner was duly affirmed by the First Appellate
Authority upon consideration of first appeal preferred by the
information seeker and, thereafter, second appeal was filed
by
respondent No.2 before the State Information Commission; it is
contended that the Second Appellate Authority without appreciating
the aforesaid factual and legal aspects and without recording any
finding to the effect that the petitioner had deliberately or mala fide
withheld the information, proceeded to hold that the information
had not been supplied and that the provisions of Section 6(2) of the
RTI Act were not attracted, and consequently directed furnishing of
information alongwith imposition of penalty; it is also submitted that
although an opportunity was purportedly granted to the petitioner in
relation to imposition of penalty, the reply submitted by him was not
duly considered, and the penalty was imposed mechanically, which
is contrary to the settled principles of law and is liable to be set
aside. He has placed reliance upon the judgment passed by this
Court in the matter of Nitin Singhvi vs. Chhattisgarh State
Information Commission in WA No. 215/2020 on 12.6.2023.
5. Learned counsel for respondent No.1 submits that the impugned
order has been rightly passed by the State Information
Commission, as the petitioner failed to furnish the information
sought by the information seeker and incorrectly invoked the
provisions of Section 6(2) of the RTI Act; it is contended that the
petitioner, being the Public Information Officer, was under an
obligation to assist the information seeker by calling him and
facilitating the filing of a proper and specific application, which the
petitioner failed to do; and therefore, in view of such lapse and noncompliance with the statutory duties, the imposition of penalty by
the State Information Commission is justified and in accordance
with law.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
7. From the bare perusal of the record, it appears that the application
which has been filed by the information seeker is vague and does
not disclose the specific information sought, and accordingly, the
Public Information Officer issued a reply/memo Annexure P-3 to the
concerned information seeker stating that आपके ቛኋ रा आवेदन ेሰ रा ज्य
केቘኋ ेሰद से ቚኋ प्त धनरा शि के निनके से एवे ख्ቊ के Cheque drawn registar के
छा य ቚኋनित ्ቊ ही गई ही, जि%सेेሰ आपके ቛኋ रा यही Specific तरा के से उल्लेख नही निकेय
गय ही, के)न से परिराቌኔ्ቔ एवे के य से सेबंधिधत के छा य ቚኋनित ्ቊ ही गई ही, इसेके
निवेशि ቖኍ य1 निवेनिनቖኌद3ቖኍ नही4 के गई ही, के5पय निवेशि ቖኍ य1 निवेनिनቖኌद3ቖኍ केरात हुय प5थके से
आवेदन केरा, जि%सेसे आपके8 निनयेሰ न9से रा % नके रा दिदय % सेके।"; even if
Section 6(2) is not applicable, it has been clearly communicated
that the application lacks clarity regarding the specific information
required to be furnished by the Public Information Officer, and once
such intimation was given, it was incumbent upon the information
seeker to approach the concerned authority and file an appropriate
and specific application to seek the desired information; however, it
appears that the information seeker was not genuinely interested in
obtaining the information but was rather inclined towards pursuing
appellate remedies, as is evident from the filing of the First Appeal
and thereafter the Second Appeal; in such circumstances, where
the application itself was vague and incapable of being acted upon,
there arose no occasion for furnishing information, and the Second
Appellate Authority ought to have afforded a proper opportunity to
the petitioner to have the application clarified and thereafter to
furnish the information, if required; however, without considering
these material aspects, the authority has erroneously concluded
that the petitioner deliberately withheld the information and
proceeded to impose penalty, which is not in accordance with law.
8. Considering the aforesaid aspect, the concerned authority ought to
have duly considered the provisions contained under Section 20 of
the RTI Act, which specifically govern the imposition of penalty; it is
well settled that penalty can be imposed only when the statutory
conditions prescribed therein are clearly attracted, and unless a
definite finding is recorded that the Public Information Officer has,
without reasonable cause, refused to receive an application, failed
to furnish information within the stipulated time, or has malafidely
denied the request, no penalty can be levied; therefore, the State
Information Commission cannot impose penalty in a casual or
mechanical manner without satisfying the mandatory requirements
of Section 20 and without recording cogent reasons to justify such
imposition.
9. In view of the aforesaid discussion/observation, the impugned
order dated 07.09.2022 (Annexure P/1) is hereby set aside.
10. In the result, the writ petition is hereby allowed.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
J.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review