Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 31st AUGUST, 2019
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
:
Appellant
Jabber Bardewa
versus
:
Respondent
State of Sikkim
Appeal under Section 374(2) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. B. K. Gupta, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. S. K. Chettri,
Respondent.
Assistant
Public
Prosecutor
for
the
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Aggrieved by the impugned Judgment dated 30-07-
2018, convicting him of the offence under Section 7(a), read
with Section 14 of the Sikkim Anti Drugs Act, 2006 (for short
“SADA, 2006”) and Section 9(d) of the SADA, 2006, and with the
Order on Sentence, dated 31-07-2018, the Appellant assails
both before this Court.
The Appellant was ordered to undergo
simple imprisonment for a period of six months and fined
Rs.3,000/- (Rupees three thousand) only, under Section 7(a)
read with Section 14 of the SADA, 2006. He was also sentenced
to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of one year and
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
fined Rs.5,000/- (Rupees five thousand) only, under Section 9(d)
of the SADA, 2006. The sentences were ordered to run
concurrently
2.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant advanced the
argument that the provisions of Section 24(1) of the SADA,
2006, which requires the Appellant to be searched either before
a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate has not been complied with,
the search and seizure was conducted sans either of them.
P.W.2, the Head Constable who apprehended the Appellant was
unaware of the search and seizure of controlled substances,
although he claims to have found the Appellant in a state of
slight intoxication at around 3 p.m. and detained him in the bus
he was travelling in. Contrarily, the Seizure Memo records the
time of search and seizure as 14.30 hours, half an hour prior to
detention of the Appellant by P.W.2, while P.W.3 the Doctor
claims to have medically examined the Appellant at 14.50 hours,
also
prior
in
time
to
the
Appellant‟s
detention.
These
circumstances are a ludicrous proposition in the Prosecution case
for which the Appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt.
P.W.3
who medically examined the Appellant found no signs of
intoxication and declared the Appellant clinically fit for detention.
The Prosecution case is that P.W.3 witnessed the search of the
belongings of the Appellant but he failed to recall or identify the
Appellant or the controlled substances purportedly recovered
from the Appellant.
That, the evidence of P.W.6 raises doubts
on the authenticity of the Prosecution case as he has variously
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
described the colours of the seized controlled substances as
„green‟ in his statement to the Police and „blue‟ before the
Learned Trial Court.
Hence, on the anvil of the discrepancies
enumerated above, the Prosecution case is doubtful and the
Appellant deserves an acquittal.
3.
In repudiation, the Prosecution strongly urged that,
the presence of P.W.5 an independent witness at the time of
search and seizure along with another witness and P.W.3,
establishes recovery and seizure of the controlled substances.
That, the allegation of non-compliance of Section 24(1) of the
SADA, 2006, is an erroneous proposition as P.W.3 a Gazetted
Officer and two other independent witnesses were present when
search and seizure were carried out. That, 6 files of “SpasmoProxyvon plus” capsules containing 144 capsules, 17 loose
“Spasmo-Proxyvon” capsules and 22 loose tablets of “Nitrosun
10” were recovered from the pocket of the Appellant and seized
as proved by the evidence of P.W.5 and the Investigating Officer
(I.O.) P.W.6,. The samples of the seized substances which were
chemically analysed by P.W.1 is proof of the fact that they
contained controlled substances. No explanation was furnished
by the Appellant for being in possession of such a large quantity
of controlled substances neither did he put any facts to rebut the
case of the Prosecution or state that the controlled substances
were for his own consumption.
The only inference therefore is
that substances were meant for sale and hence, the impugned
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
Judgment and Order on Sentence of the Learned Trial Court
warrants no interference.
4.
The rival contentions of the parties were heard at
length. Meticulous perusal has been made of the evidence and
documents on record as also the impugned Judgment and Order
on Sentence.
5.
Before embarking on an analysis of the evidence on
record, a brief narration of the facts as per the Prosecution is
essential. On 03-07-2016 at about 1405 hours, P.W.2 HC Lakpa
Sherpa, deployed at the Rangpo Check Post telephonically
informed P.W.4, the SHO of the Rangpo P.S., that during routine
checking of incoming vehicles at the Rangpo Check Post, he
suspected the Appellant, who was travelling in the Siliguri to
Gangtok bound „Apsara Bus‟, bearing Registration No.WB 73 B
8496, of being in possession of controlled substances. Based on
the information Rangpo Police Station Case, FIR No.38(07)2016,
Exhibit 7, dated 03-07-2016, under Sections 7(a)(b)/9(b)(d)/14
of SADA, 2006, was registered against the Appellant and
endorsed to P.W.6 the I.O. for investigation.
6.
The Appellant and his family, it was revealed during
investigation, were residents of Singtam.
The morning of the
incident
purchase
he
had
gone
to
Siliguri
to
controlled
substances worth Rs.1,500/- (Rupees one thousand and five
hundred) only, for personal consumption and sale, which he
concealed in his trouser pocket. On his return journey in the bus
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
the facts as cited in Exhibit 7 supra, the FIR transpired.
Pursuant thereto the I.O. reached the spot and in the presence
of P.W.3 and two independent witnesses recovered controlled
substances comprising of M.O. II five strips of Nitrosun 10
tablets, M.O.III plastic packet containing eight blue “SpasmoProxyvon
plus”
capsules,
M.O.III„A‟
six
files
of
“Spasmo-
Proxyvon” capsules, M.O.IV loose “Spasmo-Proxyvon” capsules,
M.O.V Nitrosun 10 tablets in strips, from the possession of the
Appellant.
These were sealed and later forwarded to RFSL,
Ranipool for chemical analysis. Thereafter, Charge-Sheet came
to be filed against the Appellant under the above provisions of
law.
7.
The
Learned
Trial
Court
framed
Charge
under
Section 7(a) read with Section 14 of the SADA, 2006 and under
Section 9(d) of the same Act on which counts the Appellant
entered a plea of “not guilty” upon which the trial commenced.
For convenience, the said provisions of law under which Charge
was framed are extracted hereinbelow;
“Prohibition of certain operations
7.
No person shall –
(a) sale (sic, sell), stock for sale or
trade in any controlled substance; or
…………………………………………………………….”
“Punishment for offence for which no punishment
is provided
14.
Whoever contravenes any provisions of this
Act or any rule or order made thereunder for
which no punishment is separately provided in this
chapter, shall be punishable with imprisonment for
a term which may extend to six months, or with
fine which may extend to twenty thousand rupees,
or with both.”
[emphasis supplied]
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
“Punishment
substances
vs. State of Sikkim
for
contravention
of
controlled
9.
Whoever, contravenes any provision
of this Act or any rule or any order made
thereunder shall be punishable – .........................
(d) where the contravention involves
a person using a mode of transport or
any other form of conveyance, either
inter-State or intra-State, such person
shall be liable to imprisonment for a
term which may extend to five years
or with fine which may extend to one
lakh rupees, or with both, and the
vehicle as used, shall be liable to be
seized and confiscated, which may be
released on payment of twenty
thousand rupees;
…………………………………….”
8.
[emphasis supplied]
The Prosecution is to establish beyond a reasonable
doubt that the Appellant was carrying the controlled substances
for sale, or was stocking the articles for sale or trading. For the
second offence, the Prosecution is also required to establish that
the controlled substances were being transported either interState or intra-State. As Section 7 does not provide for penalty,
the provisions of Section 14 have been invoked which have
already been extracted hereinabove. Section 16 is also relevant
for the present purposes as the SADA, 2006, carries a reverse
burden of proof with a culpable mental state of the accused. For
convenient reference the provision is extracted hereinbelow;
“Presumption of culpable mental state
16.
(1) In any prosecution for an offence under
this Act which requires a culpable mental
state of the accused, the court shall
presume the existence of such mental state
but it shall be a defense for the accused to
prove the fact that he had no such mental
state with respect to the act charged as an
offence in that prosecution.
Explanation: In this section “culpable mental state”
includes intention, motive, knowledge of a
fact and belief in, or reason to believe a fact.
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
(2) For the purpose of this section, a fact is
said to be proved only when the court
believes it to exist beyond a reasonable
doubt and not merely when its existence is
established
by
a
preponderance
of
probability.”
[emphasis supplied]
9.
The provisions of Section 24 of the SADA, 2006,
which deal with conditions under which search and seizure of
suspects can be conducted is akin to Section 50 of the Narcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act, 1985).
Section 24 of the SADA, 2006, specifically provides for conditions
under which search of persons viz., suspects shall be conducted
and reads as follows;
“Conditions under which search of
persons shall be conducted
24.
(1) When any officer duly authorized
under Section 21 is about to search
any person under the provisions of
Section 20, Section 21 or Section 22,
he shall, if possible, take such person
to the nearest gazetted officer of any
of the departments mentioned in
Section
or
to
the
nearest
Magistrate.
......................” [emphasis supplied]
Since other Sub-Sections of this Section are superfluous
for the present purpose, they are not being extracted herewith.
Section 24(1) thus lays down inter alia that when the authorised
Officer is to search the Appellant, he shall do so in the presence
of a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate. The evidence on record is
to be carefully assessed to verify whether there was compliance
of the mandatory provision of the Statute.
10.
P.W.3 is the Doctor who was posted at the Rangpo
PHC.
The Prosecution asserts that he is the Gazetted Officer
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
before whom the search and seizure ensued.
Indubitably he
holds a Gazetted rank. P.W.3 stated that he received a written
requisition from P.W.6 the I.O., vide Exhibit 3, on the relevant
day requesting him to be present at the Rangpo Check Post to
witness the search of the belongings of an individual, in
connection with a case under SADA, 2006. He does not deny his
presence at the Check Post for the above stated purpose, but
was unable to recollect the details of the bus or the controlled
substances that were recovered by the Police at the relevant
time and whether the articles were already at the Check Post or
seized from the Appellant at the spot.
Above all, he failed to
identify the Appellant as the person from whom the alleged
recoveries were made. In other words, neither was the identity
of the Appellant established by P.W.3 nor were the alleged
seized articles said to be controlled substances, identified by
him.
The evidence of P.W.3 read along with P.W.5 and P.W.6
indeed establishes the fact of presence of P.W.3 at the place of
seizure.
P.W.6 sought the presence of P.W.3 vide Exhibit 3
which is not denied.
Vide Exhibit 8, P.W.6 also obtained a
written option of the Appellant as to whether he sought to be
searched in the presence of a Magistrate or a Gazetted Officer.
The Appellant consented to be searched in the presence of a
Gazetted Officer, though the consent is rather unhappily worded,
nevertheless it suffices for the present purpose.
Thus far the
evidence of P.W.3, P.W.5 and P.W.6 pertaining to the presence
of P.W.3 and P.W.5 at the place of seizure is not demolished.
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
The Prosecution is however to prove the exact place of seizure.
P.W.5 the seizure witness stated that he went to the “Check
Post” where he saw the Appellant was also present and later
P.W.3 also arrived there, i.e., at the Check Post, upon which the
search and seizure of the controlled substances was made.
P.W.3 on this count has also stated that he went to the Rangpo
Check Post.
The evidence of P.W.3 and P.W.5 do not
corroborate the evidence of P.W.6 the I.O. as regards the place
of search and seizure. P.W.6 deposed that, on arrival of P.W.3,
he conducted the search of the person of the accused, who was
on a seat in the middle portion of the bus, during the course of
which he recovered M.O.II, M.O.III, M.O.IIIA, M.O.IV and M.O.V.
Thus on comparison of the evidence of P.W.3 and P.W.5 with
P.W.6 an anomaly emerges about the place of seizure as evident
supra. It is now settled law that minor discrepancies which are
insignificant do not affect the Prosecution case, on this aspect
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Shamim vs. State (Government of
NCT of Delhi)1 held as follows;
“12. ............................ The prosecution
evidence may suffer from inconsistencies here and
discrepancies there, but that is a shortcoming from
which no criminal case is free. The main thing to
be seen is whether those inconsistencies go to the
root of the matter or pertain to insignificant aspects
thereof. .................”
However, in the instant matter the discrepancy as detailed
above is neither insignificant nor can it be brushed aside as it
goes to the root of the Prosecution case.
anomaly has to be extended to the Appellant.
(2018) 10 SCC 509
The benefit of this
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
11.
vs. State of Sikkim
That having been said, Exhibit 4 the Property
Seizure Memo reveals that another witness besides P.W.5
appears to have signed on the document in proof of seizure of
the controlled substances. This observation finds fortification in
the evidence of P.W.6, the I.O., who stated that he seized the
above described controlled substances in the presence of two
independent witnesses besides P.W.3.
The Prosecution has
produced P.W.5 who was one of the alleged independent witness
who identified Exhibit 4(b) as his signature on Exhibit 4 the
Property Seizure Memo. The second independent witness whose
name appears in Exhibit 4, Shyam Chhetri, was not produced by
the I.O. despite the I.O. No reasons for such non-production of
the witness was furnished by the Prosecution. As per P.W.5 the
recovery and seizure of the controlled substances was made by
the Police in his presence and that of P.W.3 the Doctor, he
makes no reference to a third witness in his evidence, thereby,
casting a doubt on the presence of any other person during
seizure at the relevant place.
On the other hand, P.W.3 for his
part makes no mention of the presence of either P.W.5 or any
other witness at the time of the alleged search and seizure. This
witness has only specified that when he went to the Rangpo
Check Post the Police seized the articles from a person who he
was unable to indentify before the Court.
The absence of the
alleged second independent witness leads this Court to draw an
adverse inference under Section 114(g) of the Indian Evidence
Act, 1872. It may thus be stated that although the search and
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
seizure was made before P.W.3 a Gazetted Officer, but the
Prosecution case finds no substantiation on the failure of P.W.3
to identify the accused or establish the search and seizure.
12.
That apart, under Section 7 of the SADA, 2006,
prohibits the sale, stocking for sale or trading in controlled
substances. The Prosecution contended that the Appellant failed
to explain the reason for his possession of the Material Objects
detailed hereinabove, it is worthwhile therefore to revert to the
principle of rebuttable presumption.
The provisions of Section
16 of the SADA, 2006, will only come into play should the
Prosecution be successful is establishing proof against the
Appellant beyond a reasonable doubt. It is then and only then
that the burden shifts on the accused.
13.
In Mohan Lal vs. State of Punjab2, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court while considering a matter under the NDPS Act,
1985 held as follows;
“13. Unlike the general principle of criminal
jurisprudence that an accused is presumed
innocent unless proved guilty, the NDPS Act carries
a reverse burden of proof under Sections 35 and
54. But that cannot be understood to mean that
the moment an allegation is made and the F.I.R.
recites compliance with statutory procedures
leading to recovery, the burden of proof from the
very inception of the prosecution shifts to the
accused, without the prosecution having to
establish or prove anything more. The presumption
is rebuttable. Section 35(2) provides that a fact can
be said to have been proved if it is established
beyond
reasonable
doubt
and
not
on
preponderance of probability. The stringent
provisions of the NDPS Act, such as Section 37, the
minimum sentence of ten years, absence of any
provision for remission, do not dispense with the
2018 SCC OnLine SC 974
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
requirement of the prosecution to establish a prima
facie case beyond reasonable doubt after
investigation, only after which the burden of proof
shall shift to the accused. The case of the
prosecution cannot be allowed to rest on a
preponderance of probabilities.”
In this context, we may also refer to the ratio in Hanif Khan
@ Annu Khan vs. Central Bureau of Narcotics through Inspector L. P.
Ojha
wherein the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed as follows;
“………………………… He is presumed to be
guilty consequent to recovery of contraband from
him, and it is for the accused to establish his
innocence unlike the normal rule of criminal
jurisprudence that an accused is presumed to be
innocent unless proved guilty. But that does not
absolve the prosecution from establishing a prima
facie case only whereafter the burden shifts to the
accused. In Noor Aga v. State of Punjab, (2008) 16
SCC 417 it was observed as follows :
58. Sections 35 and 54 of the Act, no doubt,
raise presumptions with regard to the
culpable mental state on the part of the
accused as also place the burden of proof in
this behalf on the accused; but a bare
perusal of the said provision would clearly
show that presumption would operate in the
trial of the accused only in the event the
circumstances contained therein are fully
satisfied. An initial burden exists upon the
prosecution and only when it stands
satisfied, would the legal burden shift. Even
then, the standard of proof required for the
accused to prove his innocence is not as high
as that of the prosecution. Whereas the
standard of proof required to prove the guilt
of the accused on the prosecution is “beyond
all
reasonable
doubt”
but
it
is
“preponderance of probability” on the
accused. If the prosecution fails to prove the
foundational facts so as to attract the rigours
of Section 35 of the Act, the actus reus
which is possession of contraband by the
accused cannot be said to have been
established.
Because there is a reverse burden of proof,
the prosecution shall be put to a stricter test for
compliance with statutory provisions. If at any
Order dated 20-08-2019 passed in Criminal Appeal No.1206 of 2013
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
stage, the accused is able to create a reasonable
doubt, as a part of his defence, to rebut the
presumption of his guilt, the benefit will naturally
have to go to him.”
These observations hold good for Section 16 of the SADA,
2006, and therefore for the purposes of the instant case as well.
No proof emerged to establish that the M.Os were in the
possession of the Appellant or that he sought to sell the articles.
None of the ingredients of Section 7 of the SADA, 2006, were
proved by the Prosecution.
14.
While dealing with Section 9(d) of the SADA, 2006,
according to P.W.2, he detained the Bus bearing registration
No.WB 73B 8496 for reasons as enumerated supra. He informed
P.W.4 the SHO, Rangpo P.S. of his suspicion, asking him to take
necessary action. The bus along with the Appellant remained at
the Rangpo Check Post till arrival of the Police team including
P.W.6 upon which he handed over the Appellant to them and
returned to the Check Post for duty.
P.W.4 substantiated the
evidence of P.W.2 with regard to the information having been
given to him by P.W.2 upon which he drew up the FIR, Exhibit 7,
registering
a
case
against
the
7(a)/9(d)/14 of the SADA, 2006.
alleged seizure.
Appellant
under
Sections
P.W.2 was not witness to the
No passengers of the bus however were made
witnesses to the case, either to establish search and seizure of
the controlled substances from the person of the Appellant or
that he was in the possession of controlled substances.
No
evidence could establish the allegation of the presence of the
Appellant in the bus. This lacuna in the Prosecution case cannot
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
vs. State of Sikkim
be wished away, more so when both P.W.3 and P.W.5 have
stated
that
the
seizures
were
made
at
the
Check
Post
contradicting the evidence of P.W.6.
15.
P.W.3 is said to have medically examined the
Appellant but found no traces of intoxication which P.W.2 had
suspected the Appellant of being under. Although P.W.1 the
Junior Scientific Officer at RFSL, Saramsa opined that M.O.II and
M.O.III
tested
positive
for
„Nitrazepam‟
and
„Tramadol
hydrochloride‟ respectively which are controlled substance in
terms of the Notification No.16/HC-HS&FW, dated 06-06-2007
and
Notification
No.16/HC,HS&FW,
dated
01-06-2015,
respectively, this fails to garner support for the Prosecution in
the absence of proof of search, seizure and possession. There is
no proof that the Appellant was travelling in the said bus with
the controlled substances nor is there proof that the alleged
controlled substances were seized from him.
The Prosecution
also failed to furnish any proof of sale of controlled substances
by the Appellant or that he had stocked it for sale or trade.
16.
In view of the anomalies and shortcomings in the
Prosecution case as emanate from the foregoing discussions, the
impugned Judgment and Order on Sentence is liable to be and is
accordingly set aside.
17.
Appeal allowed.
Crl.A. No.27 of 2018
Jabber Bardewa
18.
vs. State of Sikkim
The Appellant is acquitted of the offences under
Section 7(1) read with Section 14 and Section 9(d) of the SADA,
2006.
19.
The Appellant is on bail vide Order of this Court
dated 17-09-2018 in I.A. No.01 of 2018. He is discharged from
his bail bonds.
20.
Copy of this Judgment be transmitted forthwith to
the Learned Trial Court for information along with the records
related to this case.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Judge
31-08-2019
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review