Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
HCP No.89/2025
CM No.2927/2025
Reserved on: 16.04.2026
Pronounced on: 22.04.2026
Uploaded on: 23.04.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced:
Full
Ishfaq Ahmad Sheikh
S/O Gulzar Ahmad Sheikh
R/O Chakoora Tehsil Litter,
District Pulwama.
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Adv. S.R.Hussain.
Vs.
1. Union Territory of J&K through
Principal Secretary to Govt.
Home Department,
Civil Sectt. Srinagar.
2. District Magistrate, Pulwama.
3. Superintendent, District Jail, Udhampur.
…Respondent(s)
Through: GA Furqan Yaqoob Sofi.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. Vide detention Order No. 05/DMP/PSA/25 dated 30.04.2025 (for short
‘impugned order’) passed by respondent No.2-District Magistrate,
Pulwama the petitioner was ordered to be detained under preventive
custody in terms of Section-8 of J&K Public Safety Act, 1978 (for
short ‘the Act’) with a view to prevent him from acting in any manner
prejudicial to the ‘security of the State’.
2. Through the medium of the present petition, petitioner is seeking
quashment of the said detention order on the grounds that the detenue,
Page |2
in terms of the impugned order, has been detained under the Public
Safety Act on false and flimsy grounds without any justification; that
the grounds of detention are vague and mere assertions of the detaining
authority and no prudent man can make an effective and meaningful
representation against these allegations. Further plea of the detenue is
that he has not been provided the material/documents relied upon by the
detaining authority, so as to make an effective representation before the
detaining authority; that he was not informed that he can make a
representation before the District Magistrate, therefore, a valuable right
of the detenue stands defeated; that the Detaining authority, while
passing the impugned order, has relied upon the stale grounds,
therefore, the same is not sustainable. It was prayed to quash the
impugned order for the afore-stated grounds.
3. Counter affidavit has been filed by respondent No. 2-District
Magistrate, Pulwama, vehemently, resisting the petition. It is contended
that detaining a person under the provisions of Public Safety Act is
always preventive in nature and its sole aim is to prevent a person from
pursuing anti-national/anti-social activities, which are prejudicial to the
maintenance of public order/security of the State. In the instant case
there is enough material against the detenue which is highly suggestive
of the fact that the normal law of the land is not sufficient to prevent
him from continuing with his anti-national activities and it is evident
that the detenue is highly motivated and is not likely to desist from antinational and unlawful activities.
4. Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the detention record
produced by learned counsel for the respondents and considered.
Page |3
5. Perusal of the detention record would indicate that the detenue was
earlier arrested in a case registered vide FIR No.39/2020 under sections
120-B, 307 IPC, 4/5 Explosive Substance Act, 7/25 Arms Act and 13,
18, 39 UA(P) Act at P/S Litter and was released on bail on 07.05.2022
by the competent court of law. Thereafter, again the detenue was kept
under preventive measures on 19.09.2024 and 27.04.2025 under section
126/170 of BNSS, for his involvement in anti-national activities. The
aforestated reasons persuaded the Detaining authority to curb his
activities to order detention of the detenue under the provisions of
Public Safety Act.
6. Right of personal liberty is a most precious right guaranteed under the
Constitution of India. A person is not to be deprived of his personal
liberty, except in accordance with procedures established under law and
the procedure as laid down in the case ‘Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of
India, (1978 AIR SC 597)’, is to be just and fair. The personal liberty
may be curtailed where a person faces a criminal charge or is convicted
of an offence and sentenced to imprisonment. Where a person is facing
trial on a criminal charge and is temporarily deprived of his personal
liberty owing to criminal charge framed against him, he has an
opportunity to defend himself and to be acquitted of the charge in case
prosecution fails to bring home his guilt. Where such person is
convicted of offence, he still has satisfaction of having been given
adequate opportunity to contest the charge and also adduce evidence in
his defense.
7. Framers of the Constitution, however, have, by incorporating Article
22(5) in the Constitution, left room for detention of a person without a
formal charge and trial and without such person being held guilty of an
Page |4
offence and sentenced to imprisonment by a competent court. Its aim
and object are to save society from activities that are likely to deprive a
large number of people of their right to life and personal liberty. In such
a case it would be dangerous, for the people at large, to wait and watch
as by the time ordinary law is set into motion, the person, having
dangerous designs, would execute his plans, exposing general public to
risk and causing colossal damage to life and property. It is, for that
reason, necessary to take preventive measures and prevent a person bent
upon to perpetrate mischief from translating his ideas into action.
Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India, therefore, leaves scope for
enactment of preventive detention law.
8. Having glance of the grounds of detention, it is clear that right from the
year 2020 till 2025, the detenue was kept under preventive measures for
his involvement in criminal/anti-national activities. It was found that the
detenue was involved in the subversive activities and was working as
close aide/hardcore OGW of killed terrorists Riyaz Ahmad Naikoo and
Dr. Saif-ullah. It is also found that the petitioner is the brother of
hardcore terrorist of LeT outfit namely Irfan Ahmad Sheikh of
Pulwama, who was eliminated on 06.02.2019 to whom the petitioner
was providing all assistance, logistic support and transportation
facilities involving him in the case FIR No.39/2020 under sections 120B, 307 IPC, 4/5 Explosive Substance Act, 7/25 Arms Act and 13, 18, 39
UA(P) Act at P/S Litter. Accordingly, the detenue was arrested in the
said case. However, after his release, he was alleged not to have
desisted himself from indulging in anti-national activities. The detenue
was involved in carrying various anti-national activities and as per the
inputs, the detenue was working as OGW for active terrorist namely
Page |5
Adnan Shafi Dar of Zainapora affiliated with a banned terrorist
organization ‘TRF’ and managing his safe movement from one place to
another. The detaining authority after keeping in view the activities of
the detenue highly prejudicial to the security of the State, detained him
under preventive custody, in terms of the impugned order, which is
under challenge in the present petition.
9. The record, produced by the State, reveals that the detenue was
informed to make a representation to the detaining authority as also to
the Government against his detention order if the detenue so desires. In
compliance to District Magistrate’s detention order, the warrant was
executed by SI Mohd. Yousaf of DPL Pulwama, by supplying the copy
of detention warrant, notice of detention, grounds of detention, dossier,
copies of complaints, copy of surety bond, FIR copy and Beat report
against a proper receipt. Further the execution report reveals that the
detenue can make a representation to the Government. It is also
revealed that the detention warrant and grounds of detention were read
over and explained to the detenue in Urdu/Kashmiri language which the
detenue understood fully and signatures of detenue were also obtained.
Thus, the contention of the petitioner for not supplying the material
incapacitating him from making an effective and meaningful
representation, is not sustainable.
10. Referring to the observations made by the Constitution Bench of the
Supreme Court in the case of ‘The State of Bombay v. Atma Ram
Shridhar Vaidya AIR 1951 SC 157’ would be advantageous. Para- 5
of the said judgment lays law on the point, which is profitable to be
reproduced hereunder:
Page |6
“5. It has to be borne in mind that the legislation in
question is not an emergency legislation. The powers of
preventive detention under this Act of 1950 are in
addition to those contained in the Criminal Procedure
Code, where preventive detention is followed by an
inquiry or trial. By its very nature, preventive detention is
aimed at preventing the commission of an offence or
preventing the detained person from achieving a certain
end. The authority making the order therefore cannot
always be in possession of full detailed information when
it passes the order and the information in its possession
may fall far short of legal proof of any specific offence,
although it may be indicative of a strong probability of
the impending commission of a prejudicial act. Section a
of the Preventive Detention Act therefore requires that
the Central Government or the State Government must
be satisfied with respect to any person that with a view to
preventing him from acting in any manner prejudicial to
(1) the defence of India, the relations of India with
foreign powers, or the security of India, or (2) the
security of the State or the maintenance of public order,
or (3) the maintenance of supplies and services essential
to the community ......... it is necessary So to do, make an
order directing that such person be detained. According
to the wording of section 3, therefore, before the
Government can pass an order of preventive detention it
must be satisfied with respect to the individual person
that his activities are directed against one or other of the
three objects mentioned in the section, and that the
detaining authority was satisfied that it was necessary to
prevent him from acting in such a manner. The wording
of the section thus clearly shows that it is the satisfaction
of the Central Government or the State Government on
the point which alone is necessary to be established. It is
significant that while the objects intended to be defeated
are mentioned, the different methods, acts or omissions
Page |7
by which that can be done are not mentioned, as it is not
humanly possible to give such an exhaustive list. The
satisfaction of the Government however must be based
on some grounds. There can be no satisfaction if there
are no grounds for the same. There may be a divergence
of opinion as to whether certain grounds are sufficient to
bring about the satisfaction required by the section. One
person may think one way, another the other way. If,
therefore, the grounds on which it is stated that the
Central Government or the State Government was
satisfied are such as a rational human being can
consider connected in some manner with the objects
which were to be prevented from being attained, the
question of satisfaction except on the ground of mala
fides cannot be challenged in a court. Whether in a
particular case the grounds are sufficient or not,
according to the opinion of any person or body other
than the Central Government or the State Government, is
ruled out by the wording of the section. It is not for the
court to sit in the place of the Central Government or the
State Government and try to deter- mine if it would have
come to the same conclusion as the Central or the State
Government. As has been generally observed, this is a
matter for the subjective decision of the Government and
that cannot be substituted by an objective test in a court
of law. Such detention orders are passed on information
and materials which may not be strictly admissible as
evidence under the Evidence Act in a court, but which
the law, taking into consideration the needs and
exigencies of administration, has allowed to be
considered sufficient for the subjective decision of the
Government.”
11. In accordance with the legal position, afore-stated, settled by the SixJudge Constitution Bench way back in the year 1951, the scope of
looking into the manner in which the subjective satisfaction is arrived at
Page |8
by the detaining authority, is limited. This Court, while examining the
material, which is made basis of subjective satisfaction of the detaining
authority, would not act as a court of appeal and find fault with the
satisfaction on the ground that on the basis of the material before
detaining authority another view was possible.
12.The courts do not even go into the questions as to whether the facts
mentioned in the grounds of detention are correct or false. The reason
for the rule is that to decide this, evidence may have to be taken by the
courts and that it is not the policy of the law of preventive detention.
This matter lies within the competence of the advisory board.
13.Those who are responsible for national security or for maintenance of
public order must be the sole judges of what the national security,
public order or security of the State requires. Preventive detention is
devised to afford protection to society. The object is not to punish a man
for having done something but to intercept before he does it and to
prevent him from doing. Justification for such detention is suspicion or
reasonable probability and not criminal conviction, which can only be
warranted by legal evidence. Thus, any preventive measures, even if
they involve some restraint or hardship upon individuals, as held by the
Supreme Court in the case ‘Ashok Kumar v. Delhi Administration &
Ors., AIR 1982 SC 1143’, do not contribute in any way of the nature of
punishment.
14. Observing that the object of preventive detention is not to punish a man
for having done something but to intercept and to prevent him from
doing so, the Supreme Court held in the case ‘Naresh Kumar Goyal v.
Union of India & Ors., 2005 (8) SCC 276’, and reiterated in the
judgment in a case titled ‘Union of India and another v. Dimple
Page |9
Happy Dhakad’ (AIR 2019 SC 3428) that an order of detention is not
a curative or reformative or punitive, but a preventive action,
acknowledged object of which being to prevent anti-social and
subversive elements from endangering the welfare of the country or
security of the nation or from disturbing public tranquility or from
indulging in anti-national activities or smuggling activities or from
engaging in illicit traffic in narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances,
etc. Preventive detention is devised to afford protection to society.
Rulings on the subject have consistently taken the view that preventive
detention is devised to afford protection to society. The object is not to
punish a man for having done something but to intercept before he does
it and to prevent him from doing so.
15. In view of the foregoing discussion and the settled legal position,
impugned detention order is upheld and the petition is found devoid of
any merit and is, accordingly, dismissed along-with pending
application(s).
16. Scanned detention record, as produced, be returned to learned counsel
for respondents.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
Srinagar
22.04.2026
Muzammil. Q
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review