Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
&'
& (
!"
%
%
$
)*
&
)
+
!"
!
#
$
$
$
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
# "
%
&
$
'
'
$
$
# !
")
!
*
#
$
$
(
-2-
# !
%
&
'
$
!
+
(
# !
!
&
&
(
(
&
(
# ! !"!#
'
, !"!#
$
#", #!"
& (&-(
& (&0(
!
&!(&./(
#", #!" "#
& (&-(
&!(&./(
& (&1(
#
'
$
'
'
781 908:8;/< =>48482; 81 ?8<>@ 3;@>0
7/0/48A/
/-/08B
=029>>@8;-1
=< &
/-/8;14
/;784/ !"!
47>
/;.8
>1182;1
2<89>
'3@->
4/482;
/89730
08:>
!
2?
42 C3/17 47>
=>48482;>01
( 2 # ! !"!# &/0818;- 234 2?
0>-814>0>@ DA
@@<
30/B17/
>9482;
8;
, !"!#
/89730( 2; 47> ?8<> 2?
?20
47>
2??>;9>1
-3-
=3;817/D<> 3;@>0
>9482;1 #", #!"
>9482;1
& (&0( &1(
&!(&./( 2?
4029848>1(
:>;@:>;4
94 !"
!
)"
"#
# 2?
/;@
& 0>.>;482; 2?
7> ?/943/< :/408E 2? 47> 9/1> 81 47/4
,,
:D>@B/0
/<<244>@ ! /90>1 2? </;@ 8;
>.><2=:>;4
A
"# F
2;
2/0@ 7/1
# 1843/4>@ /4
30/@8 .8<</-> 8; 47> ;/:> 2? :247>0 2? 47> 92:=</8;/;4
; 47> D/181 2? 1/:> 47> 0>.>;3> 0>920@1 G>0> >;4>0>@ 8;
7>0 ;/:> /;@ 18;9> ?02: 47> /<<24:>;4
17> G/1 8;
=211>1182; /;@ 93<48./482; 2? 47> 1/:>
;
17>>4( 2;>
21 ! /;@
", !"!! /9931>@
&/1 =>0 97/0->
/H/0/::/ ?8<>@ /; /==<89/482; D>?20> /9931>@
8 > =>48482;>01 7>0>8; 8 > 47>A /0>
;1=>9420 /;@ $8<</->
>.>;3>
9923;4/;4 0>1=>948.><A ?20 97/;->
2? B7/4/ 2? 47> 1/8@ =02=>04A 8; 47> 0>.>;3> 0>920@1
9920@8;-<A
0>920@1
7>0 ;/:> G/1 >;4>0>@ 8; 47> 0>.>;3>
-4-
#
3D1>C3>;4<A
/9931>@
/H/0/::/ 9/:>
42 B;2G 47/4 47> </;@ G/1 G02;-<A :34/4>@ 8; 7>0 ;/:>
7>0>?20> 17> 20/<<A /==02/97>@ 47> 0>.>;3> /3472084A ?20
9/;9><</482; 2? 47> :34/482; >;40A
7>;
/34720848>1
13-->14>@ 47/4 47>A /0> ;24 7/.8;- /3472084A 42 9/;9>< 47>
1/:>
/;@
/@.81>@
7>0
/==02/97
47>
11814/;4
2::81182;>0 ?20 9/;9><</482; 2? 47> :34/482;
7>0>?20>
/H/0/::/ ?8<>@
/;
2;
!"!!
/9931>@
/==<89/482;
D>?20> 47>
2::81182;>0 42 9/;9>< 47> :34/482; >;40A
7/1 D>>; =/11>@ DA 47>
/==<89/482; /;@ 47>
11814/;4
11814/;4
34 ;2 20@>0
2::81182;>0 2; 47>
/:> 2? /9931>@
92;48;3>@ 8; 47>
0>.>;3> 0>920@1
/4>0 47> 92:=</8;/;4 9/:> 42 B;2G /D234 47>
G02;- >;40A 2? :34/482; 8; 47> ;/:> 2? /9931>@
8::>@8/4><A
/718<@/0
92:=</8;/;4
/;.8 /;@
/==02/97>@
>.>;3>
/;@
0>C3>14>@
;1=>9420 42 0>1420> 781
:247>061 ;/:> 8; 47> 0>.>;3> 0>920@1
0>1=2;@>@
/;@
34 ;2;> 2? 47>:
-5-
)
!5#
4 81 ?3047>0 /<<>->@ 47/4 2; !" ") !"!# /4 /D234
=:
47> 92:=</8;/;4 G>;4 42 0>;4>@ 022: 2?
/9931>@
42 >;C380> /D234 47> :34/482; /4 47/4 48:>
/9931>@
/D31>@ 47> 92:=</8;/;4 DA 4/B8;- 47> ;/:>
2? 781 9/14> /;@ =317>@ 78: DA 72<@8;- 781 17804
7>0>/?4>0 47> 92:=</8;/;4 <2@->@ 47> 92:=</8;4 /-/8;14
=>48482;>01 /;@ /9931>@
0>1=2;@>;4 =2<89>
0>-814>0>@
/1>@ 2; 47> 92:=</8;4 47>
47>
9/1>
, !"!# ?20 47> /?20>:>;482;>@ 2??>;9>1
8;
08:>
7>0>/?4>0
47> 0>1=2;@>;4 =2<89> 8;.>148-/4>@ 47> 9/1> /;@ </8@
97/0-> 17>>4 /-/8;14 47> /9931>@ =>012;1 DA /00/A8;- 47>
=>48482;>01 /1 /9931>@
21 ! /;@
422B 47> 92-;8I/;9> 2? 47> 2??>;9>
>/0;>@
/-8140/4>
>8;- /--08>.>@ DA 47>
1/:> 47> =0>1>;4 =>48482;
>/0@ <>/0;>@ 923;1>< ?20 47> =>48482;>01 /;@
47> <>/0;>@
8-7
4/4>
3;0>=0>1>;4>@
2.>0;:>;4 <>/@>0 ?20 0>1=2;@>;4
>1=2;@>;4
2!
4723-7
1>0.>@
-6-
,
=/04 ?02: 30-8;- 1>.>0/< 92;4>;482;1
47>
<>/0;>@ 923;1>< ?20 47> =>48482;>01 =08:/08<A 92;4>;4>@ 47/4
=>48482;>01
81 47>
2 ! 81 47> $8<</->
>.>;3>
9923;4/;4 /;@ 47>A G>0> ;2G7>0>
92;;>94>@ 42 47> /<<>->@ 8;98@>;4
923;1>< /9931>@
;1=>9420 /;@ =>48482;>0
9920@8;- 42 47> <>/0;>@
G/1 G02;-<A ?8<>@ /; /==<89/482; 42
>;4>0 7>0 ;/:> 8; 47> 0>.>;3> 0>920@1 8; 0>1=>94 2? </;@
D><2;-1 42 47> 92:=</8;/;461 :247>0 /;@ 13D1>C3>;4<A 17>
?8<>@ /; /==<89/482; 42 0>948?A 47> 1/:>
4 47/4 48:> 84 G/1
13-->14>@ DA /9931>@
42 /==02/97 47>
11814/;4
21 ! /;@
2::81182;>0 DA ?8<8;- /; /==>/<
=2G>0 G/1 .>14>@ G847 47>:
18;9> 47/4
>1=84> / ?/<1> 92:=</8;4
7/1 D>>; <2@->@ /-/8;14 47>1> =>48482;>01 3;@>0 47>
=02.8182;1 2?
>;9>
7> =0/A1 42 /<<2G 47>
=>48482;
"
<>/0;>@
8-7
2.>0;:>;4
<>/@>0 2==21>@ 47> =0/A>0 2; 47> -023;@ 47/4 ;2G 47/4
97/0-> 17>>4 7/1 D>>; </8@ /-/8;14 47> =>48482;>01 /;@
-7-
47>0> /0> 14/4>:>;41 2? G84;>11>1 /./8</D<> 2; 0>920@ ?20
47> /94 92::844>@ DA 47>1> =>48482;>01
1 923<@ D> -/47>0>@ ?02: 47> 0>920@1
0>1=>94 42 47> </;@ D>/08;30/@8
.8<</->
4723-7
A
/<<244>@
8;
"# F
# 1843/4>@ /4
8;
;/:>
47>
2?
92:=</8;/;461 :247>0 /;@ G7>; 17> G/1 8; =211>1182;
:814/B>;<A /9931>@
B7/4/ 8; 7>0 ;/:>
21 ! /;@
?8<>@ /; /==<89/482; ?20 97/;-> 2?
/1>@ 2; 47> /==<89/482;
97/;->@ 47> B7/4/
/4>0 /9931>@
/; /==<89/482; 42 0>948?A 47> :814/B>
8;?20:>@ DA /9931>@
47>
11814/;4
21 ! /;@
/9931>@
2G>.>0
?8<>@
84 G/1
47/4 17> 7/1 42 /==02/97
2::81182;>0 /;@ /9920@8;-<A 17> ?8<>@ /;
/==>/< D>?20> 47>
11814/;4
2::81182;>0
7> 1/8@ /==>/<
G/1 /<<2G>@ /;@ 47> :814/B> G/1 0>948?8>@ DA 0> >;4>08;47> ;/:> 2? 92:=</8;/;461 :247>0
!
7> /<<>-/482; /-/8;14 47>1> =>48482;>01 81 47/4
47>A D>8;- 47>
>.>;3> ;1=>9420 /;@ $8<</->
9923;4/;4
/D31>@ 47> 92:=</8;/;4 DA :>;482;8;- 781 9/14> ;/:> 8; /
022:
1 1397
84 81 9<>/0 47/4 47> /<<>->@ 2??>;9>
-8-
92::844>@ ;24 8; 47> =3D<89 .8>G 20 /;A =</9> G8478; 47>
=3D<89 .8>G
7>
2;6D<>
=>E
2304 8; 47> 9/1> 2?
0>=204>@
8;
7><@ 47/4 47> 2??>;9> 3;@>0
>9482;
& (&0( 2? 47>
94 G23<@ 8;@89/4> 47> 8;-0>@8>;4 2?
8;4>;482;/< 8;13<4 /;@ 8;48:8@/482; G847 /; 8;4>;4 42
73:8<8/4> / :>:D>0 2? /
08D>
97>@3<>@
/14> 20 /
97>@3<>@
<< 8;13<41 20 8;48:8@/482;1 42 / =>012; G8<< ;24 D> /;
2??>;9> 3;@>0 47>
94 3;<>11 1397 8;13<4 20 8;48:8@/482; 81
2; /9923;4 2? .8948: D><2;-8;- 42
97>@3<>@
97>@3<>@
94 81 42 8:=02.> 47>
08D>
7> 2DH>94 2? 47>
12982 >92;2:89 92;@8482;1 2? 47>
97>@3<>@
/14> 20
/14>1 /;@ 47>
97>@3<>@ 08D>1 /1 47>A /0> @>;8>@ ;3:D>0 2? 98.8< 08-741
731 /; 2??>;9> 3;@>0 47>
94 G23<@ D> :/@> 234 G7>; /
:>:D>0 2? 47> .3<;>0/D<> 1>9482; 2? 47>
298>4A 81
13DH>94>@ 42 8;@8-;848>1 73:8<8/482;1 /;@ 7/0/11:>;4
7>
/11>0482; 2? 484<> 2.>0 47> </;@ DA >847>0 2? 47> =/048>1 81
;24
@3>
>847>0
47>
8;@8-;848>1
73:8<8/482;1
-9-
7/0/11:>;4
.>0A 9848I>; 7/1 / 08-74 42 /./8< 47>80
0>:>@8>1
/9920@/;9>
8;
G847
</G
7>0>?20>
8?
47>
/==><</;4 20 781 ?/:8<A :>:D>01 7/.> 8;.2B>@ H3081@89482;
2? 47> 98.8< 92304 20 47/4 0>1=2;@>;4
2 ! 7/1 8;.2B>@ 47>
H3081@89482; 2? 47> 98.8< 92304 47>; 47> =/048>1 /0> /./8<8;47>80
0>:>@8>1
8;
>14/D<817>@ DA </G
0>1=2;@>;4
#
/9920@/;9>
G847
47>
=029>@30>
397 /9482; 81 ;24 ?20 47> 0>/12; 47/4
2 ! 81 :>:D>0 2?
97>@3<>@
/14>
;247>0 B>A 8;-0>@8>;4 2? 47> =02.8182; 81 8;13<4
20 8;48:8@/482; 8; J/;A =</9> G8478; =3D<89 .8>GK
7/4 81 42
D> 0>-/0@>@ /1 J=</9> 8; =3D<89 .8>GK 7/@ 92:> 3= ?20
92;18@>0/482; D>?20> 4781
/1
2304 8; 47> H3@-:>;4 0>=204>@
!
!
"
7>
2304 7/@ @0/G; @8148;9482; D>4G>>;
47> >E=0>1182; J=3D<89 =</9>K /;@ J8; /;A =</9> G8478;
=3D<89 .8>GK
4 G/1 7><@ 47/4 8? /; 2??>;9> 81 92::844>@
23418@> 47> D38<@8;- > - 8; / </G; 23418@> / 7231> /;@
47> </G; 9/; D> 1>>; DA 12:>2;> ?02: 47> 02/@ 20 </;>
23418@> 47> D23;@/0A G/<< 47>; 47> </G; G23<@ 9>04/8;<A
- 10 -
D> / =</9> G8478; 47> =3D<89 .8>G
; 47> 92;40/0A 8? 47>
0>:/0B 81 :/@> 8;18@> / D38<@8;- D34 12:> :>:D>01 2?
47> =3D<89 /0> 47>0> &;24 :>0><A 0></48.>1 20 ?08>;@1( 47>;
84 G23<@ ;24 D> /; 2??>;9> 18;9> 84 81 ;24 8; 47> =3D<89 .8>G
7>
2304 7><@ /1 3;@>05
!!
" #
$%
!
!
&
!
!
!
!
'
!
'
'
!
'
(
'
!
!
'
!
!
*!
*!
!
&
#
'
)
!
!
'
!
!
!
$
!
!
!
!
'
'
$
! '
'
!
+
!
, '
%
#
! '
%
$
! '
- 11 -
4 81 /@:844>@ 9/1> 2? 47> 92:=</8;/;4 47/4
/9931>@
G/1 /D31>@ 78: DA :>;482;8;- 781 9/14>
;/:> 8; 47> 022:
022:
7>; 2;<A D247 G>0> 47>0> 8; 47>
/1 =>0 /<<>-/482; /-/8;14 /9931>@
2 ! 47/4
7>
:814/B>;<A 97/;->@ 47> :34/482; >;40A 8; 47> ;/:> 2?
/9931>@
D/1>@ 2; 47> /==<89/482; /;@ 13D1>C3>;4<A
/9931>@
8; 430; ?8<>@ /; /==<89/482; 42 0>948?A 47>
:814/B>
; 1397 98093:14/;9>1
47>0> /0> ;2 2??>;9>1
:/@> 234 /-/8;14 47> =>48482;>01 ?20 47> 2??>;9> 47>A 7/.>
97/0->@
7> >;480> /<<>-/482;1 4/B>; 2; 841 ?/9> ./<3>
/<12 ;2 2??>;9> :/@> 234 /-/8;14 47> =>48482;>01 G72 /0>
/9931>@
21 !
/;@
;
98093:14/;9>1
47>
92;48;3/482; 2? 47> =029>>@8;-1 /-/8;14 47>1> =>48482;>01 81
;2478;- D34 /D31> 2? 47> =029>11 2?
9920@8;-<A 47> =>48482; 81
)
21 ! /;@
2?
@@<
""
7> =029>>@8;-1 /-/8;14 47> =>48482;>01 /9931>@
8;
=< &
(
>1182;1 '3@->
2 # ! !"!# =>;@8;- 2; 47> ?8<>
/89730 /0818;- 234 2?
08:>
- 12 -
, !"!# 0>-814>0>@ DA
/;.8
2<89>
4/482;
81 7>0>DA C3/17>@
,*
&
%
)
%
4+0H
5 #
/89730
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review