Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC010182662019
2026:GAU-AS:8597
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5624/2019
INSAN ALI
S/O- LATE SAHARUDDIN SEIKH @ SAFUR ALI, R/O- VILL- BECHIMARI,
MOUZA- PUB SILMARI, P.O- SILBORI, P.S- DALGAON, DIST- DARRANG,
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 6 ORS
REP. BY THE SECRETARY, MIN OF HOME AFFAIRS, GOVT OF INDIA,
SHASTRI BHAWAN, NEW DELHI
2:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
REP. BY CHIEF ELECTION COMMISSIONER
NIRVACHAN SADAN
ASHOK ROAD
NEW DELHI- 110001
3:THE STATE OF ASSAM
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
DEPTT OF HOME
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 6
4:THE STATE COORDINATOR
NRC
OFFICE ADDRESS AT ACHYUT PLAZA
G S ROAD
BHANGAGARH
GHY- 5
KAMRUP (M)
Page No.# 2/10
ASSAM
5:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
BAKSA
ASSAM
6:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
BAKSA
DIST- BAKSA
ASSAM
7:THE OFFICER IN CHARGE
BAKSA P.S
DIST- BAKSA
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
PAUL
: F BEGUM, MR. L MOHAN,MRS. B CHAKRABORTY,MS. S
Advocate for the Respondent : ASSTT.S.G.I., SC, F.T,SC, NRC,SC, ELECTION COMMISSION.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRANJAL DAS
JUDGEMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
For the Petitioner
: Ms. S. Paul
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. J. Payeng, SC, Home Deptt. & NRC, Mr. P.
Sarma, GA, Assam, Mr. N. Kalita on behalf of
Mr. A.I. Ali, SC, ECI.
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 18.05.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 12.06.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Page No.# 3/10
operative part of the judgment ?
: N/A
Whether the full judgment has been
: Yes
pronounced?
(Pranjal Das, J)
Heard Ms. S. Paul, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. J. Payeng, learned
Standing counsel, Home Department & NRC; Mr. P. Sarma, learned Government Advocate,
Assam; Mr. N. Kalita, learned counsel appears on behalf of Mr. A.I. Ali, learned Standing
counsel, ECI.
2.
Invoking the provisions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner
Insan Ali has challenged the impugned judgment and opinion dated 31-05-2019 passed by
the learned Member, Foreigners Tribunal, Baksa, Tamulpur, Assam, in F.T. Case No.
1782/BAKSA/2016 [arising out of S.P.(B), Nalbari reference : IM(D)T Case No. 60/2001] –
whereby the prayer of the petitioner for time was allowed earlier and on the subsequent
dates, when the petitioner as proceedee, failed to submit his evidence, the learned Tribunal
referring to the legal mandate of disposing of the reference within the period of 60 days –
proceeded to answer the reference and did so in the affirmative, holding that the petitioner
as proceedee/opposite party was a foreigner who had illegally entered into India from the
specified territory on or after 25-03-1971. He also directed certain consequential steps
pursuant to rendering of such opinion.
3.
Before proceeding further, the facts contended by the petitioner may be narrated briefly.
The petitioner is stated to be the son of one Lt. Saharuddin Sheikh and Ayatun Nessa. It is
stated that a reference was made regarding his nationality to the Foreigners’ Tribunal, Nalbari
by S.P. Reference No. 1104/2002 in which notice was issued by the learned Tribunal. But due
to his non-appearance, the learned Tribunal proceeding ex-parte passed opinion dated 18-012013, holding him to be a foreigner. Subsequently, the petitioner submitted an application
Page No.# 4/10
along with a delay condonation petition for setting aside the ex-parte order. But both the
petitions
were
dismissed.
Thereupon,
the
petitioner
approached
this
Court
vide
WP(C)/7770/2017, seeking interference with the order dated 18-01-2013 passed by the
learned Foreigners’ Tribunal, Nalbari in the aforementioned case of 2007. This Court, vide
order dated 08-01-2018, was pleased to set aside the aforementioned impugned order and
remanded back the matter for fresh determination.
4.
The matter had, in the meantime, reached the learned Foreigners’ Tribunal, Tamulpur at
Baksa. The said learned Foreigners’ Tribunal, after adjudication, rendered its opinion dated
05-04-2018, holding that Md. Insan Ali was not a foreigner. It is further stated by the
petitioner that despite being declared as not a foreigner by the aforesaid order – a notice was
again served on him on 08-12-2018 with regard to fresh reference which was registered as
F.T. Case No. 1782/BAKSA/2016 [arising out of S.P.(B), Nalbari Reference : IM(D)T Case No.
60/2001], alleging that he had illegally migrated to India after 25-03-1971 from Bangladesh.
5.
Pursuant thereof, the petitioner appeared before the learned Tribunal and filed a petition
on 06-03-2019 stating that he had been declared as not a foreigner in F.T. Case No.
6/BAKSA/2018 and prayed that the subsequent proceeding be closed. However, the learned
Tribunal opined that as the reference has been preferred, it has to render an opinion and
asked the petitioner to submit his response. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted his written
statement along with documents and on 27-05-2019 sought some time to submit additional
written statement.
However, the same was rejected and the petitioner was declared a
foreigner vide opinion dated 31-05-2019 as already mentioned at the outset.
6.
In the impugned opinion dated 31-05-2019, the learned Tribunal stated that the prayer
for additional written statement was allowed and thereafter, in between, unfortunately the
case record was misplaced and subsequently, the matter was taken up on 27-05-2019. It is
stated that by then 5(five) months had elapsed and the petitioner as proceedee had not yet
filed his evidence and considering the legal mandate of disposal within 60(sixty) days, the
learned Tribunal proceeded to dispose of the matter rendering the opinion against the
petitioner as mentioned at the beginning.
Page No.# 5/10
7.
The primary and main contention of the petitioner in the writ petition is that having
been declared not a foreigner by the opinion dated 05-04-2018 by the learned Foreigners
Tribunal, Baksa,Tamulpur, Assam, in F.T.(Nal) B. Case No. 2351/2007 – the subsequent
impugned opinion could not have declared him as a foreigner by stating that he had illegally
come into India from Bangladesh after 25-03-1971.
8.
Ms. Paul, the learned counsel for the petitioner supporting the said contention in the
writ petition submits that the determination regarding the petitioner had already been done in
his favor by holding that he is not an illegal migrant or a foreigner who had come into India
illegally from specified territories. Therefore, the subsequent reference is bad in law and nonmaintainable and rendering of such an opinion and that too without giving him any
opportunity to adduce evidence is unsustainable and should be set aside in this writ petition.
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the petitioner had cogently proved
his Indian nationality in the earlier proceeding and that he is the same Insan Ali who was
declared to be not a foreigner by the learned Foreigners Tribunal in the earlier proceeding.
9.
Mr. Payeng, learned Standing counsel, Home Department & NRC does not dispute that
in the earlier round of reference proceeding, the learned Foreigners Tribunal had rendered
the opinion dated 05-04-2018 in favor of the petitioner. He, however, submits that in the
written statement submitted by the proceedee, in the subsequent proceeding, there is no
mention of the earlier case. It is also submitted that there is no voters’ list figuring the name
of the petitioner from the period from 1973 to 1997. It is submitted that once a reference has
been made, the learned Foreigners’ Tribunal was obligated in law to give an opinion and
therefore, there is no infirmity in the order of the Tribunal.
10.
Now, the question is when an opinion is rendered in favor of the proceedee by learned
Foreigners’ Tribunal, whether the same can be reopened by way of a subsequent reference.
And in the context of the same, if such reference is made, whether the learned Foreigners’
Tribunal is compulsorily required to render an opinion stating whether the referred proceedee
is a foreigner or not. In this context, the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Abdul Kuddus vs. Union of India & Ors ., reported in (2019) 6 SCC 604 may be referred
Page No.# 6/10
to.
11.
In the said decision, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held in para 23 that the opinion
rendered by a foreigners tribunal is a quasi-judicial order and not an administrative order. It
was also held that whenever a judicial or quasi-judicial tribunal gives a finding on law or fact,
such findings would be binding unless reversed in a proceeding (appeal or writ petition)
before a higher forum. It was clearly held in para 24 that the opinion of the Foreigners’
Tribunal and the consequential order passed by the registering authority would operate as
res-judicata. The relevant paras 23 and 24 may be reproduced herein below –
“23. The procedure prescribed by the post 2012 amendment under the 1964 Order
mandates compliance with the principles of natural justice. All the allegations and
grounds are required to be served by the Tribunal in the form of a show-cause notice
to the person who is alleged to be a foreigner [see para 60 in Sarbananda Sonowal
(2)2]. Thereupon, the person has to be given a reasonable opportunity to file
representation and also produce evidence. The Tribunal has been authorised to
consider and allow prayer for production and examination of the witnesses which can
be refused if found to be vexatious, or made with the intent to cause delay, etc. The
evidence produced by the Superintendent of Police can also be recorded. The person
concerned has to be heard before the Tribunal gives its opinion. The person concerned
may appear in person or can be represented by a legal practitioner or an authorised
representative. Opinion is to be given within a period of sixty days after the reference
from the competent authority. No doubt, the Rules do not prescribe and require an
opinion of the Tribunal to be a detailed judgment, nevertheless. it is obvious that the
opinion rendered must state the facts and reasons for drawing the conclusions. It is a
decision and an order. Fixing time-limits and recording of an order rather than detailed
judgment is to ensure that these cases are disposed of expeditiously and in a timebound manner. The opinion by the Foreigners Tribunal is a quasi-judicial order and not
an administrative order. The expression "quasi-judicial order" means a verdict in
writing which determines and decides contesting issues and question by a forum other
than a court. The determination has civil consequences. Explaining the meaning of
Page No.# 7/10
quasi-judicial body in Indian National Congress (1) v. Institute of Social Welfare³, it
was held that when anybody of persons has a legal authority to determine questions
affecting the rights of subjects and a duty to act judicially, such body of persons
constitute a quasi-judicial body and decision given by them is a quasi-judicial decision.
It would also be a quasi-judicial order if the statute empowers an authority to decide
the lis not between the two contesting parties but also when the decision prejudicially
affects the subject as against the authority, provided that the authority is required by
the statute to act judicially. Further, what differentiates an administrative act from the
quasi-judicial act is that a quasi-judicial body is required to make an enquiry before
arriving at a conclusion. In addition, an administrative authority is the one which is
dictated by policy and expediency whereas a quasi-judicial authority is required to act
according to the rules.
24. The opinion/order of the Tribunal, or the order passed by the Registering Authority
based upon the opinion of the Foreigners Tribunal, as the case may be, can be
challenged by way of writ proceedings. Thus, it would be incorrect to hold that the
opinion of the Foreigners Tribunal and/or the consequential order passed by the
Registering Authority would not operate as res judicata. Both the opinion of the
Tribunal and the order of the Registering Authority result in determination of
rights/status under the statute and by an authority after a contest on the merits which
would necessarily operate as a bar to subsequent proceedings before the same
authority for redetermination of the same issue/question. This Court in Ujjam Bai v.
State of U.P.4 has held that the principles of res judicata equally apply to quasi-judicial
bodies. Whenever a judicial or quasi-judicial tribunal gives a finding on law or fact, its
findings cannot be impeached collaterally or in a second round and are binding until
reversed in appeal or by way of writ proceedings. The characteristic attribute of a
judicial act or decision is that it binds, whether right or wrong. Thus, any error, either
of fact or law, committed by such bodies cannot be controverted otherwise by way of
an appeal or a writ unless the erroneous determination relates to the jurisdictional
matter of that body.”
(Emphasis supplied)
Page No.# 8/10
12.
Thus, the aforesaid ruling of the Hon’ble Apex Court lays down the law in no uncertain
terms that the principles of res-judicata would apply to an opinion rendered by Foreigners
Tribunal and any such opinion rendered by the Foreigners’ Tribunal can be challenged only in
an appeal or writ proceedings wherever applicable. And thus, when the said opinion attains
finality – the same cannot be reopened as a matter of course to the prejudice of the person,
in whose favour the opinion has been rendered.
13.
Such an approach indicated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Abdul Kuddus (supra) is
also very sound public policy as otherwise despite a person being held to be not a foreigner
by an opinion of the learned Foreigners’ Tribunal, the question of nationality with regard to
him would continue to be in a state of flux and uncertainty in the future, to considerable
prejudice of the proceedee.
14.
However, we are of the opinion that the only situation when a fresh reference can be
preferred against a person, declared not a foreigner by an earlier opinion – is when the
reference holds that the reference seeks a determination on the ground that the said person
against whom the subsequent reference is made is not the person of the same name against
whom the earlier favourable opinion was passed.
15.
Before preferring such a reference, the referring authority is expected to know or verify
as to whether any previous reference has been answered in favour of the person earlier. In a
situation, however, where the referring authority makes a reference overlooking any previous
opinion in favour of the proceedee – then it will be open to the said proceedee to place the
materials including the previous order before the learned Tribunal in support of his contention
about an existing opinion in his favour of being an Indian citizen or alternatively, not being a
foreigner. In such a situation, the Foreigners’ Tribunal has to first adjudicate regarding the
identity of the proceedee and as to whether, the proceedee in the subsequent reference is the
same as the proceedee in whose favour, the favourable opinion was rendered in the earlier
proceeding. Only in the event of the learned Tribunal finding that the subsequent proceedee
is a different person from the proceedee of the earlier reference – that, it can take up the
adjudication of the matter and then call upon the subsequent proceedee to submit his
Page No.# 9/10
defence/evidence. In such a situation, what would happen to the disposal time limit of 60
days vide Order 3(14) of the Foreigners’ (Tribunals) Order, 1960, would be another matter.
Some flexibility may be necessary. However, the said point is kept open in this lis.
16.
Coming back to the facts of the instant case, there is no material to indicate that the
opinion dated 05.04.2018 has not attained finality. Therefore, the said opinion in favour of
Md. Insan Ali S/o Lt. Saharuddin Sheikh and Ayatun Nessa, still holds. Now, since another
opinion has been rendered against Md. Insan Ali, stated to be S/o Lt. Saharuddin Sheikh and
Ayatun Nessa, without adducing of any evidence, the said opinion is required to be interfered
with.
17.
Accordingly, the impugned judgment and order dated 31-05-2019 passed by the
learned Member, Foreigners’ Tribunal, Baksa, Tamulpur, Assam, in F.T. Case No.
1782/BAKSA/2016 [arising out of S.P.(B) Nalbari Reference: IM(D)T Case No. 60/2001] is
hereby set aside and the matter is remanded back to the learned Tribunal to make a
preliminary determination as to whether the petitioner Md. Insan Ali is the same person with
regard to whom opinion dated 05.04.2018 was passed by the learned Member, Foreigners’
Tribunal, Baksa, Tamulpur, Assam, in F.T. Case No. 06/BAKSA/2018 [arising out of F.T. (Nal) B.
Case No. 2351/2007(old)] – holding him to be not a foreigner. If such a determination is
made in favour of the petitioner, the subsequent reference would be liable to be answered in
favour of the petitioner.
18.
In the event that the petitioner is found to be a different person than the proceedee in
F.T. Case No. 1782/BAKSA/2016 [arising out of S.P.(B) Nalbari Reference: IM(D)T Case No.
60/2001] – only in that event, the learned Foreigner's Tribunal would proceed to determine
the question of nationality on the basis of evidence.
19.
The writ petition stands disposed of on the aforesaid terms.
20.
Send back the original records.
21.
Interim order passed on 06.11.2019 stands modified to the extent that the petitioner
Page No.# 10/10
Md. Insan Ali shall not be deported till adjudication of the matter afresh by the learned
Tribunal upon remand vide this judgment and order.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review