Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC010269232018
2026:GAU-AS:6220
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/8422/2018
INLAND WATER WAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA (ASSAM SECTOR) MARINE
WORKERS UNION
PANDU JAHAJGHAT
P.O. PANDU
GUWAHATI - 781012
(REP. BY ITS GENERAL SECRETARY)
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND 2 ORS.
REP. BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND EMPLOYMENT)
SHARAM SHAKTI BHAWAN)
RAFI MARG, NEW DELHI- 110001.
2:INLAND WATERWAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA
A-13 SECTOR-1 NOIDA
UTTAR PRADESH- 201301
REP. BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR.
3:THE DIRECTOR
INLAND WATERWAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA PANDU PORT COMPLEX
PANDU GUWAHATI- 781012
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR A DASGUPTA, MS. B DAS,MR. K BORA,MR. R SARKAR
Advocate for the Respondent : ASSTT.S.G.I., MS. I DAS (R2, R3),MR. SURAJIT DUTTA (R2,
R3),SC, IWT,MR. Y DOLOI (SR. C.G.C., R1-R3)
Page No.# 2/12
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
Date of Hearing
:
06.01.2026
Date of Judgment
:
29.04.2026
Judgment and Order (CAV)
Heard Mr. A. Dasgupta, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Ms. B.
Das, learned counsel, appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S. Dutta,
learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Mr. S. Dutta, learned counsel, appearing
for the respondents.
2.
The Petitioner Union has instituted the present writ petition assailing
an Award dated 06.02.2018, passed by the Central Government Industrial
Tribunal (CGIT)-cum-Labour Court, Guwahati, in Ref. Case No.02/2016.
3.
The Petitioner Union has projected that its members were employed
directly by the Inland Waterways Authority of India (IWAI), against various
posts on contingency basis and/or on payment of lump sum monthly wage,
on verbal agreements till 2007, and thereafter although they were continuing
to be so engaged under the direct control of the Inland Waterways Authority
of India, their wages and salaries were being paid through the Inland
Waterways Authority of India (Assam Sector) Marine Workers’ Development
Society. Thereafter, the IWAI authorities had engaged the members of
petitioner Union by way of issuance of appointment letters for a period of 89
(eighty nine) days and the members of the Petitioner Union were working in
Dhubri to Sadiya stretch of river Brahmaputra which is identified as Inland
Waterways No.2 by IWAI. It is further projected that in the year 2013, the
IWAI entered into agreements with contractors for manning, maintenance
and operation of 5 (five) numbers of vessels of IWAI, along with the workers
Page No.# 3/12
deployed in the vessels, which includes the members of the petitioner Union.
It is submitted that although 25 (twenty five) members of the Petitioner
Union were so employed, the remaining 61 (sixty one) members of the union
continued to be employed directly by the IWAI.
Being aggrieved by the inaction on the part of the IWAI authorities to
issue orders engaging the petitioner and having required their services to be
placed under the contractors, the petitioner Union raised an industrial dispute
for protection of 94 (ninety four) numbers of marine vessel crews in
consequence of the decision of the IWAI for engagement of contractors to
man, operate and maintain vessels owned by IWAI. A 10 (ten) point charter
of demand was so raised in the conciliation proceedings held. It is projected
that the competent authority had issued a conciliation notice dated
30.04.2013, fixing 08.05.2013, for the conciliation proceedings. However it is
projected that in the said conciliation proceedings, a settlement could not be
arrived between the parties. On the failure of the said conciliation
proceedings, the matter being referred to the Appropriate Government, the
Appropriate Government vide notification dated 13.01.2016, referred the
dispute to the Central Government Industrial Tribunal (CGIT)-cum-Labour
Court, Guwahati, for adjudication. The reference being so received by the
CGIT, the same was registered as Ref. Case No.02/2016. The CGIT after
considering the evidences coming on record and upon hearing the parties to
the proceeding, proceeded vide Award dated 06.02.2018, to hold that the
IWAI did not act in the matter in any unjustified manner and that the
members of the petitioner Union were not directly employed by the IWAI on
casual basis or temporary basis for discharging works which were perennial in
nature. Accordingly, the Tribunal held that the members of the petitioner
Union were not entitled to any relief as claimed by them and accordingly, the
Award was answered against the Petitioner Union.
Being aggrieved the Petitioner Union has instituted the present proceedings.
4.
Mr. A. Dasgupta, learned Senior Counsel, has submitted that from the
Page No.# 4/12
materials brought on record it was apparent that the members of the
Petitioner Union were engaged by IWAI for works of perennial nature. The
appropriate Government appreciating the said aspect of the matter had in
terms of reference required the Tribunal to examine as to whether the action
of the management of IWAI was justified in making employment on casual
basis by engaging the marine vessel crew only for 89 days in one spell with
one day break when the work involved was of perennial nature. He further
submits that the terms of reference also required the Tribunal to adjudicate
as to whether the Management of IWAI was justified in not formulating terms
and conditions for vessel crew working since long years in works of perennial
nature. He submits that considering the terms of reference, the Tribunal
could not have proceeded to draw a conclusion to the effect that the
members of the Petitioner Union were not engaged for works which were of
perennial nature. Accordingly, he submits that the Tribunal had proceeded to
adjudicate the reference made to it by the appropriate Government by
proceeding beyond the confines of the terms of reference so made. The
learned Tribunal having failed to exercise its adjudicatory powers in
accordance with law, it is submitted that the Award would mandate an
interference from this Court.
5.
Mr. A. Dasgupta, learned Senior Counsel further submits that the
conclusion drawn by the learned Tribunal that the members of the petitioner
Union were not under direct employment of the IWAI, to be a perverse
conclusions, inasmuch as, materials brought on record had highlighted that
the members of the Petitioner Union were being engaged by IWAI for 89
(eighty nine) days on contract basis and the members of the Petitioner Union
so engaged were never disengaged. Accordingly, he submits that the
continuation of the members of the Petitioner Union by IWAI, even after the
engagement of the contractors for manning, maintenance and operation of
the vessels involved, the members of the petitioner Union not being
disengaged, the conclusion drawn by the learned Tribunal that the members
Page No.# 5/12
of the petitioner Union were not directly employed by IWAI, was a perverse
conclusion. He submits that the learned Tribunal failed to lift the veil to
examine as to whether the engagement of the contractors was only a paper
arrangement made so as to deny the workers their entitlements under law.
6.
Mr. A. Dasgupta, learned Senior Counsel, has further submitted that
the Management having not adduced any evidence in the matter, the
evidence adduced by the Petitioner Union being not disputed, there being no
material that the members of the Petitioner Union, were engaged by the
contractors in the matter, the learned Tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction in
drawing a conclusion that the members of the Petitioner Union were being
employed by the contractors and not by IWAI authority.
In the above premises, Mr. A. Dasgupta, submits that the materials
brought on record having demonstrated that the Petitioner Union to be under
the direct employment of the IWAI, the reference made by the appropriate
authority ought to have been answered in favour of the Petitioner Union.
Accordingly, he submits that the conclusion drawn by the learned Tribunal in
the impugned Award being perverse, the same would mandate an
interference from this Court.
7.
Mr. S. Dutta, learned Senior Counsel, appearing for the IWAI
authorities, after reiterating the grounds of challenge made in the present
proceedings by the Petitioner Union to the impugned Award, has submitted
that from the pleadings brought on record it had emerged that workmen
were so employed for the purpose of dredging the river bed so as to maintain
flow in the river channel. He submits that it was also evident from the
materials coming on record that the work, in question, was outsourced to
contractors. He submits that after the term of the engaged contractors had
expired, and tenders were issued for engagement of fresh contractors, in the
interregnum for the purpose of maintaining continuity of the work, in
question, workmen, being required to be engaged for the works involved,
Page No.# 6/12
members of the Petitioner Union came to be engaged on contingency basis
for 89 (eighty nine) days. He submits that on contractors being appointed in
the matter in pursuance to a process of tender, the workmen involved having
not handed over the vessels, in question, to such contractors, a dispute
having arisen, the workmen had proceeded to raise a dispute before the
jurisdictional Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central). He submits that from
Exhibit-A, brought on record before the Tribunal, the above aspect of the
matter would be evident. He submits that from Exhibit-A it is not evident that
the workmen involved were so involved in works of perennial nature. He
submits that the dredging activities involved are seasonal in nature.
8.
Mr. S. Dutta, learned Senior Counsel, appearing for the respondents,
by taking this Court through the deposition of the workmen witness before
the Tribunal, has submitted that the said witness had make a categorical
statement to the effect that they were seeking employment under the IWAI,
and
in
this
connection
had
also
preferred
a
writ
petition
being
WP(C).No.5410/2066, before this Court. He submits that from the crossexamination of the workmen witness, it would be evident that no material
was brought on record by workmen to justify their contention that they were
under direct employment of the IWAI. He had highlighted that the workmen
witness during his cross-examination had deposed that there was no
document except Exhibit-D, to support the case of the workmen and further
no document was exhibited to show that the workmen involved in the
present case were/are employees of IWAI. He submits that it was further
elicited from the workmen witness that he had not submitted any document
to show that either he or any other workmen were receiving salaries from
IWAI. Accordingly, Mr. S. Dutta, submits that no material having been
brought on record to highlight that the nature of works for which they were
so engaged was perennial in nature and further that they were directly
engaged by the IWAI authorities, there was no requirement for adducing any
further evidence from the part of the IWAI authorities. He submits that the
Page No.# 7/12
obligation of the IWAI, to adduce evidence before the Tribunal would have
arisen only if the workmen had discharged their initial burden with regard to
the establishment of the fundamental facts, which he submits were not so
established.
9.
Mr. S. Dutta, learned Senior Counsel, further submits that the
projection by the Petitioner Union of its members being engaged by a
contractor to be only a paper arrangement was not established during the
proceedings before the learned Tribunal and accordingly, the occasion for
lifting of the veil by the learned Tribunal in the matter had not arisen.
10.
With regard to the contentions raised by the learned Senior Counsel
for the petitioner, that the learned Tribunal had passed the Award, in
question, going beyond the terms of reference, the learned Senior Counsel,
for the respondents, has submitted that the workmen were required to
establish the foundational facts i.e. (a) that they were engaged directly
under the IWAI; and (b) the work for which they were so engaged was of
perennial nature. It is submitted that the foundational facts, for adjudicating
the terms of reference, was found to have not been established by the
workmen, herein. He submits that mere paraphrasing of terms of reference
cannot be projected to be a conclusion to the effect that the workmen were
so engaged in works of perennial nature and were engaged directly by the
IWAI. He submits that the said aspects of the matter being foundational in
nature was required to be established by the workmen and thereafter only
the onus would have shifted upon the IWAI authorities to dispel such
projection made by the workmen. The foundational facts not having been
established by the workmen, the onus involved cannot be held to have been
shifted upon the IWAI authorities. Accordingly, he submits that the learned
Tribunal having adjudicated the matter strictly basing on the materials
coming on record, the impugned award would not mandate an interference
from this Court.
Page No.# 8/12
11.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
materials available on record.
12.
The Petitioner Union in their pleadings before the learned Tribunal,
had contended that from the date of joining by the members of the Petitioner
Union in their services, till 2007, all of them were employed without
employment letters, as contingency staff of vessels of IWAI at lump sum
monthly wages, under the direct control and supervision of the IWAI
authorities. It was further projected that the wages were initially being paid
directly to the workmen by the IWAI authorities. However, subsequently, such
payment of wages was being made through the Inland Waterways Authority
of India (Assam Sector) Marine Workers’ Development Society. The said
procedure was also given up and the IWAI authorities had entered into
agreements with 02 (two) private entities namely M/s A C Roy and Co,
Kolkata, and M/s Chinar Shipping and Infrastructure (India) Pvt. Ltd. Mumbai,
for manning, maintenance and operation of 5 (five) survey vessels of IWAI.
The Petitioner Union has further projected that the engagement of the
members of the Petitioner Union under the said contractors were only a
paper arrangement and they continued to discharge their respective duties
under the direct control and supervision of the IWAI authorities and only the
monthly wages were being paid through the above contractors.
13.
The Petitioner Union by contending that its members were
discharging their duties which were of perennial nature for a long period of
time, had raised an industrial dispute for protection of 94 members of marine
vessel crews, accordingly, a 10 point charter of demand was raised. The
Petitioner Union had approached the Regional Labour Commissionder (C)
Guwahati. A conciliation proceeding was, thereafter, held which had not
resulted in any settlement, which is projected by the Petitioner Union to be
on account of the non-responsive attitude of the management of IWAI. The
Page No.# 9/12
failure report of the conciliation proceeding being sent to the Appropriate
Government by the Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central) Guwahati, a
reference came to be made in the matter. The Petitioner Union had raised an
issue of unfair labour practice being resorted to by the IWAI authorities. The
terms of reference was projected to be with regard to 87 (eighty seven)
members of the Union who were stated to have been effected adversely due
to the anti labour attitude adopted by the Management of IWAI.
14.
The appropriate Government had vide notification dated 13.01.2016,
referred the dispute to the CGIT, Guwahati. The terms of reference being
relevant is extracted, hereinbelow;
“"Whether the action of the management of Inland Waterways
Authority of India, Regional Directorate, Pandu Port Complex,
Guwahati, Assam, is justified in making casual system of working by
engaging the marine vessel crew only for 89 days in one spell with one
day break in perennial nature of work of IWAI ? If not, what relief
these workmen are entitled to ?" "Whether the management of IWAI
is justified in not formulating terms and conditions of service of these
vessel crews working since long years in a perennial nature of work ?
If not, what relief these workmen are entitled to by the IWAI?"
"Whether the management of IWAI is justified in not paying the
marine vessel crew consolidated pay as per the 6th Pay Commission as
recommended in the meeting of the chairperson with the field
directors of the IWAI on 04.05.2011 ? if not, what relief these
workmen are entitled to by the IWAI ?"
15.
The Petitioner Union in support of its stand had adduced the
evidence of one Jiten Deka, before the learned Tribunal, as the workmen
witness. The workmen witness during his cross-examination had deposed
that there was no document except Exhibit- B, enclosed with his evidence on
Page No.# 10/12
affidavit, to support the case of the workmen. He further deposed that in his
evidence he had not exhibited any document to show that the workmen
involved in the present case were/are employees of IWAI and further to show
that either he or any other workmen were receiving salaries from IWAI. From
the cross-examination of the workmen witness, it is clear that the Petitioner
Union had failed to bring on record before the learned Tribunal any material
to demonstrate that its members were directly employed by IWAI and further
that they were receiving their salaries from IWAI.
16.
A perusal of Exhibit-I, as exhibited by the workmen witness, it would
be evident that the grievance of the members of the Petitioner Union in the
present matter was on account of the problems faced by them regarding
release of salaries and other service benefits by the contractors involved in
the matter. And accordingly a prayer was made before the IWAI authorities
for absorbing their services in IWAI.
As noticed, hereinabove, the Petitioner Union during the proceedings
before the learned Tribunal had not endeavoured to bring on record materials
to demonstrate that the nature of works discharged by them were perennial
in nature. Further, there was no materials to indicate that they were under
direct employment of the IWAI authorities.
17.
The learned Tribunal on appreciating the evidences brought on record
by the workmen had drawn a conclusion to the effect that there was nothing
brought on record to show or suggest that the engagement of the
contractors was only a paper arrangement and further to suggest that the
duties performed by the members of the Petitioner Union were of perennial
nature. Basing on the said conclusions drawn, the learned Tribunal had
answered the reference made in the following manner;
14. The first issue in the reference is whether the management is justified in
employing the workmen on casual basis to perform works of perennial nature.
Two aspects are involved in this. Firstly, whether the concerned workmen are
Page No.# 11/12
under direct employment of the management on casual basis; and secondly,
whether the nature of work they perform is of perennial nature. Meanwhile, it
may be mentioned that no notification under CLRA Act prohibiting
engagement of contract labour was issued by the concerned Government in
respect of the present management/industry, Since it has been claimed on
behalf of the workmen that they have been performing duties of perennial
nature, the burden of proving the same is upon them. The argument of the
workmen side that since the management side did not adduce any evidence,
the claim of the workmen has to be accepted to be proved. The claim of the
workmen definitely would have been accepted to be proved had they been
able to lead at least some admissible evidence to that effect. But there is
absolutely no evidence to show that the workmen have been under direct
employment of the management on casual basis and have been performing
duties of perennial nature. In the entire evidence of the workmen side
including the evidence adduced in the Miscellaneous application, there is
nothing to support the claim. On the contrary, there is straight forward
material to show that the workmen have been engaged in the concerned
company through contractors.
15. In view of the above it is held that the management did not act in an
unjustified manner. Since the workers are not in direct employment of the
Company on casual basis or temporary basis in perennial nature of work, the
workmen don't appear to be entitled to any relief as claimed by them. The
reference is answered accordingly. Send the no relief "Award" to the
concerned Government.”
18.
This Court has perused the conclusion drawn by the learned
Tribunal in the light of the evidences adduced by the Petitioner Union
before the Tribunal. On appreciating the said conclusions, this Court finds
that the learned Tribunal had appreciated the evidences in its proper
perspective and in absence of any materials brought on record by the
Petitioner Union to the effect that their members were under direct
employment of IWAI and the work they were so discharging was of
Page No.# 12/12
perennial nature, the answering of the reference against the Petitioner
Union, in the considered view of this Court was not erroneous. The
materials brought on record clearly reflects that the members of the
Petitioner Union were not engaged directly by the Management or IWAI,
but for a short period when the contract for manning, maintenance and
operating the 5 (five) numbers of vessels of IWAI, in question, had expired
and the tender process was under way. The members of the Petitioner
Union are found to have been engaged by the contractors and there being
no prohibition for engagement of contract labour issued by the concerned
authority in respect of the IWAI, this Court is of the considered view that
the conclusion drawn by the learned Tribunal in the impugned Award would
not mandate an interference.
19.
The contention of the learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner
Union, that the management not having adduced any evidence before the
Tribunal, the Tribunal ought to have answered the reference in favour of the
Petitioner Union, was appreciated by the Tribunal and it was concluded that
the workmen had not lead at least some admissible evidence in the matter
to establish the foundational facts and on the contrary there was material
brought on record that the workmen were engaged through contractors.
This Court has appreciated the said conclusions basing on the materials
available on record and finds such conclusions drawn by the Tribunal to be
not erroneous. Accordingly, the said contentions raised by the learned
counsel for the Petitioner Union stands rejected.
20.
In view of the above conclusions reached by this Court,
hereinabove, the present writ petition is held to be devoid of any merit and
the same stands dismissed. However there would be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Ranu
Boro
DN: c=IN, o=Personal,
postalCode=781005, l=Kamrup Metro,
st=Assam, street=HOUSE NO 25
JAPORIGOG, KRISHNANAGAR,GUWAHATI,
Japorigog, Dispur Assam India 781005
NEAR MASJID, title=0094,
2.5.4.20=c747c5c0d257d22064ef564859e
1ebec92d7edcfa1fcc678cbde562c68c9e9
4f,
serialNumber=e8ee80fb826c508f1dcf373
32bc0b9e247dba00f5758c2dde86f2e3615
9f37d6, email=bororanu15@gmail.com,
cn=Ranu Boro
Date: 2026.05.07 14:52:36 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review