Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 23
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 197/2024
CM No. 461/2024
CM No. 5498/2025
Inhabitants of Village Jhajjar Kotli,
Tehsil Dansal & District Jammu
Through Daya Krishan, Age 65 years,
S/o Sh. Suraj Ram,
R/o Vill. Jhajjar Kotli, Tehsil Dansal,
District Jammu
…. Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Through:-
Mr. Joginder Singh Thakur, Adv.
Vs.
1. Union Territory of J&K
through Principal Secy. to Govt.
Power Development Department,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu
2. Jammu Power Distribution Corp. Ltd.
through its Managing Director,
Ambedkar Chowk,
Panama Chowk, Jammu
3. Chief Engineer (Distribution)
Jammu Power Distribution Corp. Ltd.
Canal Road, Jammu
4. Superintending Engineer (Elect.)
O&M Circle-III
Batote, District Ramban, J&K
5. Executive Engineer,
Sub-Transmission Division,
(JPDCL), Udhampur,
MH Morh, Udhampur
6. Sagun Gupta,
S/o Sham Lal Gupta,
(Prop. JCM Constructions)
R/o H. No. 85, Phase-II,
Housing Colony, Udhampur
Through:-
…..Respondent(s)
Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG with
Ms. Jagmeet Kour, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
ORDER
01.04.2026
Page |2
1. The instant petition has been preferred by the petitioner on behalf of
inhabitants of Village Jhajjar Kotli in a representative capacity, who had
unanimously passed a resolution authorizing the petitioner to institute the
present petition, seeking the following relief:
“Writ of Mandamus directing the respondents to complete the work
of shifting of 33 KV DC Line from Grid Station Jhajjar Kotli to
Panthal towards Katra and Jib towards Udhampur maintained by
the official respondents, as per the proposed alignment, within strict
timelines by exercising the powers accorded to the official
respondents under Section 164 of the Electricity Act, 2003 read with
Section 10 of the Telegraph Act.”
2. The grievance projected by the petitioner in the instant petition is that
the respondents have deliberately delayed the shifting of 33 KV DC line
from Grid Station Jhajjar Kotli to Panthal towards Katra and Jib towards
Udhampur despite the fact that funds to the tune of Rs. 68.70 lakhs stand
sanctioned for the said shifting work in two phases, i.e., Rs. 10 lakhs and
thereafter Rs. 58.70 lakhs.
3. The petitioner has further projected certain instances in the petition,
wherein loss to life and property of the villagers residing in the said
village has allegedly been caused due to the said transmission line as a
consequence of which an FIR was registered way back in 2002 and
another FIR bearing No. 34/2019 also came to be registered at Police
Station Jhajjar Kotli in this regard.
4. It has further been submitted that owing to apprehension of further
mishappenings, inhabitants of Village Jhajjar Kotli submitted various
representations since the year 2016 before different competent authorities
Page |3
seeking shifting of the said line to some safer place and in order to
substantiate the claim, the petitioner has placed on record various
representations moved from time to time.
5. It is further submitted that on the basis of the representations so made,
a projected new alignment was proposed by the respondents and an
estimate of Rs. 12 lakhs was initially framed. It is the stand of the
petitioner that the respondents themselves declared the said 33 KV line as
unsafe and recommended immediate shifting and alternate alignment was
also proposed.
6. It is further pleaded that on 25.09.2018, respondent No. 4 accorded
sanction for Rs. 10 lakhs from Capex Budget 2018-19 for shifting of the
said transmission line. However, nothing was done on ground,
constraining the petitioners to submit further representations.
7. It is also pleaded that after further representations and delegations,
another amount of Rs. 58.70 lakhs came to be sanctioned for shifting of
the aforesaid 33 KV DC line and respondent No. 5 invited tenders for
execution of the shifting work. It is submitted that on 30.12.2021, the
tender was awarded to M/s JCM Constructions, respondent No. 6 herein,
and the execution of the work was required to be completed within 45
days from the date of award of contract.
8. It is the specific case of the petitioner that even after passing of more
than one year from the award of contract, the contractor failed to complete
the work. Feeling aggrieved, the villagers preferred complaint before SSP
Jammu, who directed SDPO Nagrota to conduct enquiry into the matter.
Page |4
Pursuant thereto, SDPO Nagrota conducted enquiry and recorded
statements of witnesses, wherein it surfaced that respondent No. 6 had
sub-let the contract to another person and whatever work was carried out
was done through a lineman and even after passing of two years and
release of part payment, the work was not completed and various
representations were thereafter submitted before higher authorities.
9. Per contra, objections have been filed on behalf of respondents No. 1
to 5, wherein it has been submitted that the 33 KV line was laid way back
in the year 1980 and the department has been regularly maintaining the
said line. It is further admitted by the respondents that considering safety
of inhabitants of the village, proposal for shifting of 33 KV line was
submitted and funds were sanctioned and the work has been completed up
to 70-80% approximately. However, the stand of respondents is that the
remaining work could not be completed due to objections raised by
certain villagers.
10. Mr. Raman Sharma, learned AAG, appearing on behalf of
respondents has drawn the attention of this Court to an application (CM
No. 5498/2025) filed by the petitioner seeking permission to place on
record fresh report of Tehsildar Dansal which would facilitate this Court
to clinch the controversy.
11. Heard Mr. Joginder Singh Thakur, learned counsel for the applicant.
12. For the reasons stated in the application bearing CM No. 5498/2025,
coupled with what has been argued at the Bar, the same is allowed. The
Page |5
documents annexed with the application are taken on record subject to all
just exceptions.
13. From the perusal of communication dated 24.04.2025 issued by the
Tehsildar, Dansal, to the Assistant Commissioner (Revenue), Jammu, it
transpires that the report of the field staff reveals that the existing 33/11
KV line is passing over 34 houses, whereas the newly proposed line
passes through Khasra Nos. 638 and 271 situated at Village Jhajjar Kotli.
Khasra No. 638 is under the ownership of Shamlat Deh Khud Kasht,
measuring 129 Kanals and 02 Marlas, and the kind of soil is recorded as
Gairmumkin Dev Sthan. Khasra No. 271 is under the ownership of one
Kaka Ram and others, Khud Kasht, measuring 8 Kanals, and the kind of
soil is recorded as Warhyal Doam and Banjar Qadeem. No house or any
other construction has been found on the said Khasra numbers.
14. It has further been recorded that approximately 80% of the shifting
work has already been completed and that the inhabitants of Village
Jhajjar Kotli have expressed their desire that the 33/11 KV line should
pass through the Nallah and since one landowner, namely, Kaka Ram has
objected to the same, report of the field staff has been sought from the
appropriate authority.
15. Heard Mr. Joginder Singh Thakur, learned counsel for the petitioner,
at length and Mr. Raman Sharma, learned AAG, appearing on behalf of
the respondents, and perused the record made available.
16. From an overall perusal of the record and the stand taken by the
respondents, this Court is of the considered view that since approximately
Page |6
80% of the work relating to shifting of the 33/11 KV line has already been
completed, the respondents are under an obligation to ensure completion of
the remaining work expeditiously, subject to there being no legal impediment.
17. The only impediment projected by the respondents pertains to the
objection raised by Kaka Ram and others. The said objection is required
to be examined and decided in accordance with law by the Assistant
Commissioner (Revenue), Jammu, after affording adequate opportunity of
being heard to all stakeholders, as the delay in deciding the objection
raised by landowners is in nobody’s interest.
18. Accordingly, this Court deems it appropriate to direct the Assistant
Commissioner (Revenue), Jammu, to consider and decide the objections
raised by Kaka Ram and others within a period of four weeks from today,
after providing an opportunity of being heard to all stakeholders,
including the petitioners and the persons who had raised objections and
any other affected persons. Subject to the decision so taken by the
Assistant Commissioner (Revenue), the respondents shall take necessary
steps for implementation of the said decision and ensure completion of the
remaining work of shifting within a period of two weeks thereafter.
19. Needless to observe that the project in question, for which
approximately 80% of the work has already been completed and requisite
funds stand sanctioned, deserves to be completed in toto while dealing with
the objections expeditiously, particularly when the Government has already
sanctioned the requisite funds for shifting of the 33/11 KV transmission line
Page |7
to a safer alignment, keeping in view the safety of inhabitants of the village
and to avoid any potential risk to life and property.
20. The petition along with connected application(s) is, accordingly,
disposed of in the manner indicated above.
(Wasim Sadiq Nargal)
Judge
Jammu:
01.04.2026
Michal Sharma/PS
Whether the order is speaking
Whether approved for reporting
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review