Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC010231782017
2026:GAU-AS:8806
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/18/2017
INDRAJIT DUTTA CHOUDHURY and 4 ORS.
S/O- LT. DR. RATISHMOY DUTTA CHOUDHURY, COLLEGE ROAD, SILCHAR,
DIST.- CACHAR, ASSAM.
2: ON THE DEATH OF JAWHARLAL CHAKRABORTY
HIS LEGAL HEIR- SMT MITALI CHAKRABORTY
W/O- LT. JAWHARLAL CHAKRABORTY
SHIBBARI ROAD
SILCHAR
DIST. - CACHAR
TARAPUR
ASSAM.
3: PRABIR KUMAR ROY CHOUDHURY
S/O- LT. RASAMOY ROY CHOUDHURY
PADMANAGOR
BILPAR
SILCHAR
DIST.- CACHAR
ASSAM.
4: GOURANGA CHANDRA SARKAR
S/O- LT. NAKUL CHANDRA SARKAR
N. S. AVENUE
SILCHAR
DIST.- CACHAR
ASSAM.
5: PROJESH DEB
S/O- LT. PROMODE CHANDRA DEB
N. S. AVENUE
SILCHAR
DIST.- CACHAR
ASSAM
Page No.# 2/10
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 3 ORS.
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM,
URBAN DEVELOPMENT DEPTT., DISPUR, GHY- 6.
2:THE SILCHAR MUNICIPAL BOARD
REP. BY IT'S CHAIRMAN
SILCHAR
DIST.- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788001.
3:THE CHAIRMAN
SILCHAR MUNICIPAL BOARD
SILCHAR
DIST. - CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788001.
4:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY
GOVT. OF ASSAM
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6
Advocate for the Petitioner
DAS,MR.S DEY,MR.T ROY
: MR B SARKAR, MR. J SARMAH,MS S BHOWMICK,MR.N C
Advocate for the Respondent : MS. N MODI, MR. H. SARMA, ADDL. SR. GA, ASSAM,GA,
ASSAM,MR.C SHARMA(R- 2&3),MR.S DUTTA(R- 2&3),MR.SIDHANT DUTTA(R- 2&3),MR P
NAYAK (SC, FINANCE, R-4)
Linked Case : WP(C)/5618/2017
INDRAJIT DUTTA CHOUDHURY and 3 ORS.
S/O- LATE DR. RATISHMOY DUTTA CHOUDHURY
R/O- H NO. 220D
COLLEGE ROAD
SILCHAR
DIST- CACHAR
PIN- 788004
2: PRABIR KUMAR ROY CHOUDHURY
S/O- LATE RASAMOY ROY CHOUDHURY
R/O- PADMA NAGAR
Page No.# 3/10
BILPAR
SILCHAR
DIST- CACHAR
ASSAM
3: GAURANGA CHANDRA SARKAR
S/O- LATE NAKUL CHANDRA SARKAR
R/O- H NO. 30
SUKANTA SARANI
NS AVENUE
SILCHAR- 788005
DIST- CACHAR
ASSAM
4: PROJESH DEB
S/O- LATE PROMODE CHANDRA DEB
R/O- H NO. 7
MOHANAM BRATA SARANI
NS AVENUE
SILCHAR
DIST- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788005
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 4 ORS.
REP. BY THE ADDL. CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
URBAN DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006
2:THE DIRECTOR
MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION
ASSAM
RUKMINIGAON
BYE LANE NO.2
GUWAHATI- 781006
3:THE SILCHAR MUNICIPAL BOARD
A BODY CONSTITUTED UNDER THE ASSAM MUNICIPAL ACT
1956 AS AMENDED FROM TIME TO TIME
REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN
SILCHAR
DIST- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788001
4:THE CHAIRMAN
Page No.# 4/10
SILCHAR MUNICIPAL BOARD
P.O- SILCHAR- 788001
DIST- CACHAR
ASSAM
5:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY
GOVT. OF ASSAM
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6.
-----------Advocate for : MSB DEVI
Advocate for : GA
ASSAM appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM and 4 ORS.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
ORDER
18.06.2026
Both the writ petitions have been analogously heard and are disposed of by
this common judgment and order.
2.
The petitioners are retired employees of the Silchar Municipal Board
(presently Silchar Municipal Corporation) and they had retired from service in
the period from 2010 till March 2013. The Board vide a Resolution dated
29.08.2011 had resolved to give the benefit of the Revision of Pay Rules (ROP)
2010 to all the staff. It was also resolved that such benefits be calculated from
01.01.2006. However, such benefit was not given to the petitioners and in the
meantime, they had retired. Accordingly, they had instituted the first writ
petition i.e. WP(C)/4675/2016 in which, there was an order dated 08.08.2016 to
consider and dispose of the representation.
3.
The stand of the Board, as would reflect from the communication dated
18.05.2016 is that such benefit would be given as and when funds are made
Page No.# 5/10
available to the Board. The petitioners had instituted a second writ petition i.e.
WP(C)/6030/2016 which was also disposed of vide an order dated 03.10.2016
directing
for
consideration
of
the
representation.
The
Board
vide
a
communication dated 31.10.2016 had made their position clear that if and when
the Government makes the funds available, the payment can be made. As the
benefits were not given, the present writ petitions have been filed wherein the
contesting respondents have also filed their affidavits-in-opposition.
4.
I have heard Shri J. Sarmah, learned counsel for the petitioners. I have also
heard Shri J. K. Goswami, learned Addl. Senior Govt. Advocate, Assam; Shri S.
Dutta, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Shri Siddhant Dutta, learned counsel
for the Silchar Municipal Corporation and Shri R. Borpujari, learned Standing
Counsel, Finance Department.
5.
It may be mentioned that when the writ petition was instituted the
nomenclature was Silchar Municipal Board which was subsequently made a
Corporation.
6.
Shri Sarmah, the learned counsel for the petitioners, by drawing the
attention of this Court to the Resolution dated 29.08.2011 has submitted that
once such Resolution was taken, it was incumbent upon the Board to give the
benefit to the petitioners. He has highlighted that so far as the subsequent
employees are concerned, such benefit has been given and only the petitioners
who had retired before March 2013 have been left out. He has submitted that
though the Board/Corporation is required to generate their own funds, there is a
provision for seeking grants from the State. He has submitted that in fact, the
benefit to the subsequent employees have been made on the basis of grants
provided by the State. He accordingly submits that there cannot be any
discriminatory treatment so far as the petitioners are concerned vis a vis the
Page No.# 6/10
employees, who were serving at the time of retirement of the petitioners.
7.
Shri Goswami, the learned Addl. Senior Govt. Advocate on the other hand
has submitted that the salaries and other expenditures of the Board/Corporation
have to be generated by its own as there are various mechanism of revenue
generation. He has however submitted that at times, grant is given by the State
which has to be properly justified. He has also drawn the attention of this Court
to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent no. 1 on 02.02.2023
wherein the provisions of the Constitution namely, Articles 243 (Y) and 243 (I)
have been dealt with. He has submitted that the Board/Corporation is an
autonomous body and has to generate its funds and on meeting the pre
requisites, the State may provide for grants-in-aid.
8.
Shri Borpujari, the learned Standing Counsel, Finance Department while
endorsing the submissions of the learned State Counsel has contended that the
Resolution itself appear to have been taken without any proper application of
mind. He has clarified that the benefits of ROP would not be per se applicable to
the employees of the Board/Corporation and if at all the same is adopted, the
same has to be done by doing an extensive exercise more particularly, with
regard to the fund position.
9.
Shri Dutta, the learned Senior Counsel for the Corporation has candidly
submitted that it is not in dispute that Resolution No. 8 was indeed adopted on
29.08.2011. He has however submitted that it is not clear from the records as to
under what circumstance such Resolution was adopted. He has submitted that
the fund position of the Corporation is not sound and even the monthly salaries
are not being able to be released on time. So far as the submissions made that
certain employees who were serving have been given the benefit, the learned
Senior Counsel has submitted that grants-in-aid was provided by the
Page No.# 7/10
Government on 01.10.2014, that too, for a period of 6 months whereafter such
grants-in-aid was not provided. He has reiterated that though the benefit has
been given to certain employees, those are also done in a most irregular
manner as the fund position of the Corporation is unstable and poor.
10. From the materials available on record, it is not in dispute that Resolution
No. 8 was adopted by the Board/Corporation on 29.08.2011. For ready
reference the said Resolution No. 8 is extracted herein below:
“Resolution No.8.
The Government of Assam vide its Notification NO.FPC-85/2009/1 dated 04-022010 reconstituted the pay structure of the employees of the State. The
employees of the Silchar Municipal Board have been enjoying the Scale and
allowances as per State Government employees since 1974. The "Drain
Labourers" "Sweepers” of the Silchar Municipal Board, though have been
enjoying the pay scale but still it is not at par with the scale of pay and
allowances as per Govt. employees for which there arose discrimination in the
case of reconstitution of the pay scale. In view of keeping parity for the all
Municipal employees of the state a "study committee" has been constituted.
The Government of Assam, following amendment of section 50 of the Assam
Municipal Act is going to constitute "staffing pattern" and related by laws that
will be binding of the part of Silchar Municipal Board. Abiding by the direction of
the aforesaid "staffing pattern" and "study committee" the Silchar Municipal
Board decided /resolves to pay the allowances of the Silchar Municipal
employees as per the Assam Services (Revision of Pay) Rules, 2010 it is also
resolved that the drain labourers and Sweepers working under Silchar Municipal
Board will get the minimum scale of pay of Rs.4560-15000 along with grade pay
of Rs.1500/- per month.”
11.
The Resolution would reveal that the employees of the Board were
Page No.# 8/10
enjoining the scales and allowance of the State Government employees since
1974 and accordingly the benefits of the ROP 2010 were sought to be extended.
While this Court is not raising any issue with regard to the bona fide of the said
Resolution adopting the ROP of 2010, it is not clear as to how and from where
the funds would be generated to be paid to the employees in terms of the said
Resolution.
12.
At this stage, it would be relevant to mention the Constitutional provision
connected to the issue. Article 243 (Y) is with regard to a Finance Commission
which is constituted under Article 243 (I) which would also review the financial
position of the Municipalities and make suitable recommendations. Such
recommendations would also be on the aspect of providing grants-in-aid to the
Municipalities from the consolidated funds of the State. As noted above, the
Finance Commission is constituted under Article 243 (I). For ready reference
both the Articles are extracted herein below:
“243 I. Constitution of Finance Commissions to review financial
position
(1) The Governor of a State shall, as soon as may be within one year from the
commencement of the Constitution (Seventy-third Amendment) Act, 1992, and
thereafter at the expiration of every fifth year, constitute a Finance Commission
to review the financial position of the Panchayats and to make
recommendations to the Governor as to—
(a) the principles which should govern—
(i) the distribution between the State and the Panchayats of the net
proceeds of the taxes, duties, tolls and fees leviable by the State, which
may be ided between them under this Part and the allocation between
the Panchayats at all levels of their respective shares of such proceeds;
(ii) the determination of the taxes, duties, tolls and fees which may be
assigned to, or appropriated by, the Panchayats;
(iii) the grants-in-aid to the Panchayats from the Consolidated Fund of the
State;
Page No.# 9/10
(b) the measures needed to improve the financial position of the Panchayats;
(c) any other matter referred to the Finance Commission by the Governor in
the interests of sound finance of the Panchayats.
(2) The Legislature of a State may, by law, provide for the composition of the
Commission, the qualifications which shall be requisite for appointment as
members thereof and the manner in which they shall be selected.
(3) The Commission shall determine their procedure and shall have such powers
in the performance of their functions as the Legislature of the State may, by
law, confer on them,
(4) The Governor shall cause every recommendation made by the Commission
under this article together with an explanatory memorandum as to the action
taken thereon to be laid before the Legislature of the State.
243 Y. Finance Commission ―
(1) The Finance Commission constituted under article 243-I shall also review
the financial position of the Municipalities and make recommendations to the
Governor as to —
(a) the principles which should govern—
(i) the distribution between the State and the Municipalities of the net
proceeds of the taxes, duties, tolls and fees leviable by the State, which
may be divided between them under this Part and the allocation between
the Municipalities at all levels of their respective shares of such proceeds;
(ii) the determination of the taxes, duties, tolls and fees which may be
assigned to, or appropriated by, the Municipalities;
(iii) the grants-in-aid to the Municipalities from the Consolidated Fund of
the State;
(b) the measures needed to improve the financial position of the Municipalities;
(c) any other matter referred to the Finance Commission by the Governor in the
interests of sound finance of the Municipalities.
(2) The Governor shall cause every recommendation made by the Commission
Page No.# 10/10
under this article together with an explanatory memorandum as to the action
taken thereon to be laid before the Legislature of the State.”
13.
As would be clear from the aforesaid provisions, the Commission would
have the power to recommend to the State for providing grants-in-aid to the
Municipalities from the consolidating funds of the State. Though the act of
adopting the ROP 2010 vide the Resolution dated 29.10.2011 cannot be said to
have vested an indefeasible right to the petitioners, taking into consideration
that certain employees have been indeed given the benefit of such adoption,
interest of justice would require that the Board/Corporation would write to the
appropriate authority for providing grants-in-aid to the Corporation so as to take
care of the situation which has arisen out of the Resolution dated 29.08.2011.
14.
The Silchar Municipal Corporation is accordingly directed to place the
entire matter before the appropriate authority along with the relevant
information informing the requirement of funds which would be considered by
the appropriate authority in accordance with law and by passing a speaking
order.
15. Both the writ petitions accordingly stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review