Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
1.
The Indian National Congress,
(Sikkim Pradesh),
5th Mile, Tadong, East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Tara Kumar Pradhan (Shrestha),
Aged about 54 years,
Son of Shri Prem Kumar Pradhan,
Treasurer, Indian National Congress
(Sikkim Pradesh),
5th Mile, Tadong, East Sikkim.
… Petitioners.
versus
1.
The State of Sikkim represented by the
Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok.
2.
The Secretary,
Department of Home,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok.
3.
The Director General of Police,
Police Headquarter,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
4.
The District Magistrate,
District Administrative Centre,
East District, Gangtok.
5.
The Superintendent of Police,
District Administrative Centre,
East District, Gangtok.
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
6.
The Sub-Divisional Police Officer,
District Administrative Centre,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
7.
The Station House Officer,
Sadar Police Station,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
8.
Mr. Bijay Subba,
Inspector of Police,
Sadar Police, Gangtok.
… Respondents.
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Pratap Khati, Advocate for the Petitioners.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Addl. Advocate General and Mr.
Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate with Mr.
Santosh Kr. Chettri, Asstt. Government Advocate for
the State-Respondents.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
(29.05.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
The first petitioner is a national political party and the
second petitioner is the Treasurer of the first petitioner. Assailing
the alleged action of the eighth respondent by interfering with
the public announcement system used by the petitioner-party in
the street corner meeting held at Kanchanjunga Shopping
Complex, Gangtok, East Sikkim, the petitioners have come up
with this petition seeking directions to the official respondents to
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
take action against the eighth respondent and also to pay
compensation to the tune of Rs.3.00 lakhs to the petitioners for
damages caused.
Further, a security is sought to the entire
family of the petitioner No. 2.
2.
The brief facts, as projected by the petitioners, are the
petitioners organized a street corner meeting at Kachanjunga
Shopping Complex, Gangtok on 13th November, 2016 for the
purpose of creation of awareness of rights and liabilities through
public announcement system between 1000 to 1600 hrs. at the
Kanchanjunga Shopping Complex, with prior permission dated
11th November, 2016 of the competent authority. It is submitted
that the meeting was organized as per schedule, complying with
the conditions of the permission granted by the fifth respondent.
It is alleged that the eighth respondent, who is also arrayed as
seventh respondent in official capacity, came to the venue of the
meeting at around 1300 hrs. with some police personnel and
started using abusive, unparliamentary and filthy language
against the leaders and also disconnected the wire connection to
the public announcement system, which was widely published in
the electronic and print media on the next day.
It is further
contended that the action of the eighth respondent was unlawful,
violative of fundamental rights guaranteed under the provisions
of Articles 14, 19 read with Article 21 of the Constitution of India
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
and also has caused irreparable damages to the prestige and
status of the petitioners.
It is further stated that the first
information report (FIR) was lodged before the fifth respondent
vide letter dated 14th November, 2016, which yielded no
response.
Thereafter, a representation was also made to the
third respondent and further representation was made through
advocate’s notice dated 24th January, 2017 to all the concerned
authorities. Finding no response/action from the authorities, the
petitioners were constrained to file the instant writ petition
seeking the aforestated reliefs.
3.
Mr. Pratap Khati, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners, would contend that the eighth respondent has
exceeded his jurisdiction and violated the fundamental rights of
the petitioners enshrined under Articles 14, 19 (1) (a) (b) and 21
of the Constitution of India.
The said respondent disconnected
the wire connecting the public announcement system, knowing
fully well that the meeting was conducted with due permission
from the competent authority. Thus, the petitioners are entitled
to compensation to the tune of Rs.3.00 lakhs and also a direction
to the authorities to take stringent action against him. Referring
to a decision of the Supreme Court in Anita Thakur & Ors.
vs. Govt. of J & K & Ors.1, wherein Rs.3.00 lakhs in total as
--------------------------------1
AIR 2016 SC 3803
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
compensation was awarded to the petitioners
therein,
the
learned counsel would submit that the petitioners are also
entitled to the compensation as prayed for.
4.
Per contra, Mr. J.B. Pradhan, learned Additional
Advocate General appearing for the respondents would contend
that on receipt of representation dated 15th November, 2016,
addressed to the second respondent, the fourth respondent was
directed to submit a report.
The fourth respondent in turn
directed the Additional District Collector, East to make an enquiry
and submit a report.
On enquiry, it was found that the eighth
respondent has not exceeded his power and also not violated the
condition of the permission granted therefor.
That a public
complaint was received around 1155 hrs. on 13th November,
2016 for the loudspeakers used by the organizers of the meeting
which was causing nuisance to the general public.
The eighth
respondent with other police personnel visited the venue and
requested
the
organizers
to
change
loudspeakers towards the venue.
loudspeakers
were
changed
the
direction
of
the
On finding refusal, the
towards
the
venue
without
disconnecting the wire, which resulted into decrease of the public
nuisance caused due to high volume of loudspeakers.
Referring
to the affidavit dated 24th April, 2017 filed on behalf of the third,
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
fourth, fifth and sixth respondents, Mr. Pradhan would submit
that the organizers have flouted the conditions of permission
dated 11th
November, 2016.
The volume of
the public
announcement system was beyond the permissible limit and the
loudspeakers were directed towards outside the venue causing
nuisance to outsiders. On a complaint received from the public,
the
volume
of
the
loudspeaker
was
regulated
without
disconnecting the wire, as alleged.
5.
It is further urged by Mr. Pradhan that in the enquiry
conducted by the Sub-Divisional Police Officer, it was found that
the eighth respondent has not exceeded his power as on going to
the site, he requested the organizers to minimise the volume and
turn the speakers towards the gathering. On finding no response
from the organizers, the eighth respondent turned the speakers
towards the gathering. The aforestated report is supported by an
affidavit.
Predicating submission on the counter affidavit dated
22nd April, 2017 of the seventh and eighth respondents, Mr.
Pradhan would further contend that the SHO has taken all
necessary precautions without disturbing the ongoing meeting
and turned only the direction of the loudspeakers to the
gathering. They were advised to comply with the conditions of
the permission. Wire of the loudspeaker was never disconnected
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
and the meeting was never disturbed.
Thus, the allegations
made by the petitioners are baseless and meritless.
6.
It
is
also
submitted
by
Mr.
Pradhan
that
the
permission granted on 11th November, 2016 by the competent
authority clearly provides for having the volume of mike at low
pitch and no inconvenience should be caused to the general
public.
The volume was also higher than the permissible limit.
Thus, it was not a case of violation of fundamental rights to
speech and expression as pleaded by the petitioners.
The
meeting was organized in clear breach of conditions stated in the
permission dated 11th November, 2016. Accordingly, the petition
deserves to be dismissed with cost.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the
pleadings and documents appended thereto.
8.
The undisputable facts are that the petitioners made a
request for grant of permission to hold the meeting and use
loudspeakers at the rooftop of Kanchajunga Shopping Complex,
Gangtok on 10th November, 2016.
The petitioners were duly
granted permission vide order dated 11th November, 2016 to
hold a meeting at the desired place between 1000 to 1600 hrs.
on 13th November, 2016. The conditions of the permission, inter
alia, provide as under: -
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
“3.
4.
5.
6.
The volume of mike should be low volume and no
inconvenience should be caused to the general public.
Mike should not be installed above 8 ft. from the
ground. (it shall be at a maximum height of 8 ft. from
the ground).
Extension of wiring is not allowed beyond the venue of
programme/meeting.
If at any point it is found that reason given for seeking
mike permission default from original application same
will be deemed cancelled immediately.”
9.
It is revealed in the enquiry that a complaint was
received from the general public, stating that the meeting was so
loud as to cause nuisance to the public at large, who were not a
part of the meeting.
10.
On receipt of the representation and complaint from
the President and General Secretary of the Sikkim Pradesh
Congress Committee, the Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Gangtok
was directed to conduct an enquiry and submit a report.
The
Sub-Divisional Police Officer conducted an enquiry and on
examination of several witnesses, held in his report dated
24.01.2017, as under: “5.
Further, as per the GD Extract taken from GD Vide No.
403/404 dated 13.11.2016 Time 1155/1230 hrs. of Sadar
Police Station, Gangtok it can be seen that on receipt of public
complaint regarding use of loudspeaker at Kanchenjunga
Complex SHO Bijoy Subba had proceeded at the venue to
inspect the same. On reaching the venue he then requested
the organizers of the meeting namely Dorjee Ongdi and Gyurmi
to kindly lower the volume and to also change the direction of
the 4 nos. of speakers towards the venue. But the request fell
on deaf ears and then the SHO was compelled to change the
direction of the speakers and also lowered the volume of the
speakers. The SHO then booked the organizer of the meeting
i.e. Shri Tara Kr. Pradhan (Shresthra), General Secretary,
SPCC, U/S 160 of Sikkim Police Act, 2008 for violating the
terms and conditions of the permission issued from the office of
SSP, East vide provision of S.158(1) of SPA, 2008 and Memo
No. 31/POL/SPE/ RDR/2006/897 dated 11/11/2016 for his trial
in the Hon’ble Court of Law.
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
6.
The independent witnesses have also supported the
version of SHO/Sadar PS and the allegation of disrupting of
meeting by disconnecting the line was found baseless. In fact
the police officer had acted lawful and without any mala fide
intention. Despite being requested to the organizer to lower
the volume and turn the speakers towards the gathering the
organizers did not listen to the lawful orders of SHO/Sadar PS
and he was compelled to turn the speakers himself as shown in
the photographs.
7.
It is, therefore, submitted that PI Bijoy Subba,
SHO/Sadar PS had acted as per law and not violated the
freedom of speech of any individual as alleged in the complaint,
please.”
11.
It has come on record that the President, Sikkim
Pradesh Congress Committee has made a representation to the
Chairman, National Human Rights Commission, New Delhi, on
28th
November,
2016.
Taking
cognizance
of
the
said
representation, the National Human Rights commission has
sought for an enquiry report from the Director General of Police,
Sikkim. The Addl. Superintendent of Police, East District Police,
it appears, was directed to conduct an enquiry into the
allegations made by the President, Sikkim Pradesh Congress
Committee. In his enquiry report, the Additional Superintendent
of Police, East, has observed as under: “An enquiry on the already mentioned incident was conducted
whereby the
examined:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
following
witnesses
to
the
incident
were
Pappu Mallik 30 yrs. S/o Mohan Mallick R/o Indira Bye
Pass, Gangtok. Profession: Journalist.
Chung Chung Bhutia, 30 yrs W/o Milan Gurung R/o
Rongli. Profession: Government Employee.
Ongchen Bhutia 36 yrs S/o Sonam Bhutia R/o Machong,
Gangtok. Profession: Government Employee.
Yogendra Gurung 28 yrs S/o N.L. Gurung R/o Tashiding.
Profession: Government Employee.
Sanjay Kr. Prasad 38 years S/o Rama Shankar Prasad
R/o Lall Bazar, Gangtok. Profession: Businessman.
Satish Kumar 29 years S/o Moti Lall Gupta R/o Gangtok.
Profession: Businessman.
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
7.
Amit Kr. Prasad 26 yrs S/o Lt. Rama Shanker Prasad R/o
Gangtok. Profession: Businessman.
All the above witnesses have mentioned in their statement that
the volume of the mike/speaker was too loud which was
causing them inconvenience and that the SHO and his team
had done what needed to be done legally. Copy of statements
of the witnesses attached herewith. Annexure ‘D’.
Conclusion
After observing all the evidence on paper, it can be seen that
Shri Tara Kr. Pradhan (Shreshtra), SPCC has clearly violated
the conditions of the permission of use of mike under the
provision of Section 158 (1) of Sikkim Police Act, 2008 and that
the SHO PI Bijoy Subba had rightfully booked him U/s 160 of
Sikkim Police Act, 2008.”
The said enquiry corroborates the finding recorded in the earlier
enquiry conducted by the Sub Divisional Police Officer.
12.
On perusal of various reports, it is found that the
meeting was conducted as per the permission, however, the
loudspeakers installed by the organizers were directed outside
the venue, blaring in loud volume so as to cause public
inconvenience.
The eighth respondent, accompanied by other
police personnel, visited the venue and advised the organizers to
lesser the volume of the loudspeakers and also to turn the
loudspeakers towards the venue, which it appears, was not
heeded, and accordingly, the loudspeakers were turned towards
the venue.
Connecting wire to the loudspeakers were not
snapped as alleged.
13.
It is not a case of the petitioners that the meeting was
disrupted or any untoward incident had happened or the police
have exceeded its power more than regulating the direction of
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
the loudspeakers.
The petitioners have failed to establish any
breach or infringement of any fundamental right guaranteed to
the petitioners under Articles 14 and 19 read with 21 of the
Constitution
of
India.
Thus,
the
petitioners’
claim
of
compensation is unfounded and deserves to be rejected. In the
case of Anita Thakur (supra), cited by the petitioners, a
peaceful march was stopped by the authorities, which resulted
into pelting of stones and due to some lapses on the part of the
authorities, it took an ugly turn. In such view of the matter, the
compensation was directed to be paid. But, in the case on hand,
no such situation has occurred and the meeting was carried out
peacefully without any violence or untoward incidents and as
such the observation made in the case is not applicable to the
facts of the case.
14.
So far as relief to grant security to the second
petitioner and his family members are concerned, it is the
concern of police agency in case of threat to the person or/and
property, on verification of a representation, if any, made to the
concerned police authorities. In the fact of the case, no direction
to grant security is warranted.
15.
It is imperative to state herein that the Supreme
Court in Noise Pollution (V), In Re2, observed as under: ------------------------------------2
(2005) 5 SCC 733
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
“11.
Those who make noise often take shelter behind Article
19(1)(a) pleading freedom of speech and right to expression.
Undoubtedly, the freedom of speech and right to expression are
fundamental rights but the rights are not absolute. Nobody can
claim a fundamental right to create noise by amplifying the
sound of his speech with the help of loudspeakers. While one
has a right to speech, others have a right to listen or decline to
listen. Nobody can be compelled to listen and nobody can
claim that he has a right to make his voice trespass into the
ears or mind of others.
Nobody can indulge in aural
aggression. If anyone increases his volume of speech and that
too with the assistance of artificial devices so as to compulsorily
expose unwilling persons to hear a noise raised to unpleasant
or obnoxious levels, then the person speaking is violating the
right of others to a peaceful, comfortable and pollution-free life
guaranteed by Article 21. Article 19 (1) (a) cannot be pressed
into service for defeating the fundamental right guaranteed by
Article 21. We need not further dwell on this aspect. Two
decisions in this regard delivered by the High Courts have been
brought to our notice wherein the right to live in an atmosphere
free from noise pollution has been upheld as the one
guaranteed by Article 21 of the Constitution. These decisions
are Free Legal Aid Cell Shri Sugan Chand Aggarwal v. Govt. of
NCT of Delhi : AIR 2001 Del 455 and P.A. Jacob v. Supdt. of
Police : AIR 1993 Ker 1. We have carefully gone through the
reasoning adopted in the two decisions and the principle of law
laid down therein, in particular, the exposition of Article 21 of
the Constitution. We find ourselves in entire agreement
therewith.”
16.
In the State of Sikkim, honking horns in vehicles and
bursting firecrackers in festive occasions are proscribed. Keeping
in view such a spirit, the organizers of the public meeting ought
to have taken care not to create excessive noise to cause
unnecessary nuisance to the general public.
17.
In fine, it is well settled principles of rule of law that
regulation of volume of loudspeaker is necessary to contain noise
pollution as the public at large are entitled to protection from
excessive noise pollution.
constrained to observe that:
In the aforestated analyses, I am
W.P. (C) No. 18 of 2017
Indian National Congress (Sikkim Pradesh) & Anr. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
(i)
the police before taking any action to regulate
noise pollution be directed to issue necessary
instructions;
(ii)
in a case of meeting like this, prior notice ought
to have given to the organizers in writing;
(iii)
in the event, the notice is not responded or not
complied with, the police is entitled to take
appropriate action in accordance with law;
(iv)
the organizers of such meetings are directed to
observe conditions enshrined in the permission
strictly; and
(v)
the
permission
granted
be
specific,
unambiguous, clear in understanding.
18.
Resultantly, I do not find any merit in the case and
accordingly the petition fails and is dismissed.
19.
No order as to costs.
Chief Justice
29.05.2017
jk/
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review