Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
19.08.2026
Court No. 12
Item No. 06
Sandip
FMA 54 of 2024
With
CAN 1 of 2023
Indian Bank
Vs.
Sri Sandeep Kabra & Ors.
Mr. Shiv Mangal Singh,
Ms. Anjali Mishra
…for the Appellant.
Mr. Rajashree Dutta,
Mr. Avishek Guha,
Ms. Mayuri Ghosh,
Ms. Arunika Dutta
Mr. Ankush Majumdar
… for the respondent nos. 1 to 3.
1.
The appeal arises out of a judgement and order dated
September 5, 2023, passed in WPA 5778 of 2023. The
Indian Bank/secured creditor is the appellant. The
request for Look Out Circular (LOC) against the
respondent nos.1 to 3 was originated by the bank on the
ground that the writ petitioners/respondent nos.1 to 3
being wilful defaulters were likely to leave the country.
The
wilful
default
indicated
an
intention
to
misappropriate public money and non-payment of the
loan affected the economic interest of the country.
2. Mr. Singh, learned advocate for the bank submits that,
the decision of the bank declaring the respondent nos. 1
to 3 as wilful defaulters had not been interfered with
either in the writ petition or in the appeal. The necessity
to prevent foreign travels of the respondent nos. 1 to 3 is
imperative, to protect the country’s economy. It is
further submitted that, the LOC was issued by the
Ministry
of
Home
Affairs,
Foreigners
Division,
Government of India under the Office Memoranda
issued from time to time. The memoranda laid down
guidelines to be followed while making a request for
issuance of LOC. The parameters were satisfied. The
allegations against the respondent nos. 1 to 3 warranted
stringent measures due to the exceptional circumstances,
and departure of the said respondents from India would
be detrimental to the bilateral relations of India with
other countries also and/or adversely affect the strategic
and economic interest of India.
3. Under such circumstances, it is submitted that the
learned Single Judge failed to appreciate that the
exceptional situations under which the LOC had been
issued were covered by the memoranda. The LOC was set
aside only at the ground that the declaration of wilful
default was merely a regulatory measure adopted by the
Reserve Bank of India to notify stakeholders, creditors
and public lending authorities about the antecedent of
borrowers in the commercial sphere.
4. It is urged that His Lordship erred in holding that
declaration of wilful default had a limited connotation.
The finding that, economic activities of an individual was
not akin to commission of a cognizable offence was not
true purport and meaning of the memoranda.
5. Mr. Dutta, learned advocate for the writ petitioners
submits that, the reason for issuance of the LOC was
explicitly stated in the communication dated February 9,
2023, issued by the Assistant General Manager, Indian
Bank. Classification of the respondents/writ petitioners
as wilful defaulters could not have been a valid ground
for issuance of the LOC. As such, the parameters under
the office memorandum dated February 22, 2021, had
not been satisfied. The LOC was rightly quashed and set
aside by the learned single Judge. It is further submitted
that, unless any cognizable offence has been committed
by the persons against whom the LOC had been issued
and they were required for trial, departure of such
person cannot be prohibited. There are no flight risks in
this case.
6. The facts urged by the bank in a nutshell are that, on the
basis of the default in repayment of the loan amount
extended by the bank, proceedings to declare the
respondent Nos. 1 to 3 as wilful defaulters were held and
the said respondents were declared to be wilful
defaulters. As per the memorandum dated November 22,
2018, issued by the Deputy Director, BOII, Government
of India, Ministry of Finance, the Heads of Pubic Sector
Banks were empowered for issuance of LOC.
7.
Under the memorandum of 2018, a specific request
under Clause 2(c) for issuance of LOC was made, as the
departure of such persons would be detrimental to the
bilateral relations of India with other countries and the
economic interest of India would suffer.
8. According to Mr. Singh, the quantum of money that was
payable by the said respondents is not of much
relevance. It is the intention and the concerted ploy on
the part of these respondents in not repaying the bank,
which led the bank to originate a request for LOC. They
cheated the public authority by mis-utilisation and
misappropriation
of
public
money.
Under
such
circumstances, in order to protect the economy of the
country, the LOC was issued.
9. What falls for decision before us is whether the learned
Single Judge was right in holding that declaration of the
said respondents as wilful defaulters could not be a
ground either under the office memorandum dated
February 22, 2021 or the office memorandum of 2018,
for issuance of LOC. Further consideration is, whether
setting aside of the LOC was in accordance with law or
not.
10. In the matter of Vishambhar Saran vs Bureau of
Immigration & Ors. decided in WPA 6670 of 2022,
a Single Bench of this High Court had analysed and
discussed the policy behind issuance of LOC and its
development, in the following paragraphs:“29. The general objective for issuance of LOC
is to control the arrival/departure of persons
against whom criminal cases are pending or
who are either avoiding judicial proceedings or
evading arrest or not co-operating with the
investigating agencies and there are specific
inputs that such person(s), would flee the
country.
30. The first comprehensive policy was framed
and found its release in the office memorandum
dated October 27, 2010. The authorities who
could issue LOC, the ingredients necessary for
issuance of LOCs, the agencies who could make
a request for issuance of LOCs and the various
parameters required to be fulfilled before such
request could be made, was provided therein.
31. Paragraph 8 (a) and (b) of the office
memorandum dated October 27, 2010 are
quoted below:“a) The request for opening an LOC would be
made by the originating agency to Deputy
Director, Bureau of Immigration (BoI), East
Block VIII, R.K. Puram, New Delhi – 66 (Telefax:
011-2619244) in the Proforma enclosed.
b) The request for opening of LOC must
invariably be issued with the approval of an
officer not below the rank of
i. Deputy Secretary to the Government of India;
or
ii. Joint Secretary in the State Government; or
iii. District Magistrate of the District concerned;
or
iv. Superintendent of Police (SP) of the District
concerned; or
v. SP in CBI or an officer of equivalent level
working in CBI; or
vi. Zonal Director in Narcotics Control Bureau
(NCB) or an officer of equivalent level (including
Assistant Director (Ops.) in Headquartrs of
NCB); or
vii. Deputy Commissioner or an officer of
equivalent level in the Directorate of Revenue
Intelligence or Central Board of Direct Taxes or
Central Board of Excise and Customs; or
viii. Assistant Director of IB/BoI; or
ix. Deputy secretary of R&AW; or
x. An officer not below the level of
Superintendent
of
Police
in
National
Investigation Agency; or
xi.
Assistant
Director
of
Enforcement
Directorate; or
xii. Protector of Emigrants in the office of the
Protectorate of Emigrant or an officer not below
the rank of Deputy Secretary of the Government
of India; or
xiii. Designated officer of Interpol.”
Sub-paragraph (b) of paragraph 8 did not
include the heads of public sector banks at the
relevant point of time.
32. The policy also provided that LOCs could
be issued on the direction of a Court in India.
Sub-paragraph (c) provided the parameters and
the details to be filled up including the reasons
in Colum IV of the Proforma enclosed to such
policy. Column IV is quoted below:-
“REASON FOR OPENING OF LOC:
a. CRIMINAL CASE:
i) FIR NO.
ii) DATE
(specify full details)
iii) SECTION OF LAW (Where applicable):
iv) POLICE STATION:
v) DISTRICT:
vi) STATE:
b. WANTED BY ANY OTHER COURT/JUDICIAL
AUTHORITY:
i) NAME OF THE COURT:
ii) ORDER BY WHICH SUBJECT IS WANTED:
c. LOC RETENTION DATE:
(As per MHA guidelines. LOC will remain valid
for at most one year)”
33. Sub-paragraph (g) and (h) of the same laid
down the conditions under which opening of
LOCs could be made. The same are set out
below:“g. Recourse to LOC is to be taken in cognizable
offences under IPC or other penal laws. The
details in column IV in the enclosed Proforma
regarding ‘reason for opening LOC’ must
invariably be provided without which the
subject of an LOC will not be arrested/detained.
h. In case where there is no cognizable offence
under IPC or other penal laws, the LOC subject
cannot be detained/arrested or prevented from
leaving the country. The originating agency can
only request that they be informed about the
arrival/departure of the subject in such cases.”
34. A combined reading of sub-paragraph (g)
and (h) of the said 2010 policy indicates that
recourse to LOCs could be taken when the
subject was guilty of commission of a cognizable
offence under the Indian Penal Code or other
penal laws. The details in Column IV of the
Proforma enclosed regarding the reasons for
opening of LOC were to be provided without
which the subject of an LOC could neither be
arrested nor detained. If there were no
allegations of commission of any cognizable
offence, the LOC subject could not be detained
or prevented from leaving the country. In such
cases, the originating agency could only request
that
they
be
informed
about
the
arrival/departure of the subject in such cases.
35. In a general sense, the policy of 2010
restricted the reasons for opening an LOC to
cases of pending criminal investigation or
proceedings relating to commission of any
cognizable offence under the Indian Penal Code
or other penal laws. Sub-paragraph (j) of Office
Memorandum of 2010 made an exception to
such parameters. The same is set out herein
below:“j. In exceptional cases, LOCs can be issued
without complete parameters and/or case
against CI suspects, terrorists, anti-national
elements, etc. in larger national interest.”
In cases where no criminal investigation with
regard to commission of any cognizable offence
was pending, a request for LOC could be made if
the subject of the LOC was either a CI Suspect
or a terrorist or an anti-national.
36. By the amendment in 2017, persons
whose actions were detrimental to bilateral
relations of India with other countries or
detrimental to the strategic and economic
interest of the country and were likely to flee the
country as per intelligence inputs, were
included as subjects of LOCs. Sub-paragraph (j)
was substituted. The amendment as notified by
office memorandum dated December 5, 2017.
The same reads as follows:“In exceptional cases, LOCs can be issued even
in such cases, as would not be covered by the
guidelines above, whereby departure of a person
from India may be declined at the request of any
of the authorities mentioned in clause (b) of the
above-referred OM, if it appears to such
authority based on inputs received that the
departure of such person is detrimental to the
sovereignty or security or integrity of India or
that the same is detrimental to the bilateral
relations with any country or the strategic
and/or economic interest of India or if such
person is allowed to leave, he may potentially
indulge in an act of terrorism or offences against
the State and/or that such departure ought not
be permitted in the larger public interest at any
given point in time.
Instead of:
‘In exceptional cases LOCs can be issued
without complete parameters and/or case
details against CI suspects, terrorists, antinational elements, etc in larger national
interest.’ ”
37. The object of such amendment was to
prevent persons guilty of offences which were
harmful to bilateral relations of India with other
countries or detrimental to the strategic and
economic interest of the country, from fleeing
the country.
38. In the opinion of the Court, the
interpretation of the expression ‘bilateral
relations between two countries’ would mean
the conduct of political, economic or cultural
relations
between
two
sovereign
states.
‘Strategic and economic interests of the country’
would mean relationship between two countries
which would be mutually beneficial and the
expression ‘economic interest’ would include in
its
ambit,
growth,
development,
industrialization,
investments,
business
activities, the strength of the currency, the
position of the sensex etc. The expression
‘economic interest’ in the 2017 amendment
cannot be given a narrow interpretation to mean
individual banking relationship between the
borrower and the bank and non payment of the
borrowed sum. The expression should be read
in the context of bilateral relations and strategic
interest of India.
40. The office memorandum dated October 4,
2018, inter alia, stated as follows:“(a) Issuance of LOCs in respect of Indian
citizens and foreigners is governed by
Instructions contained in the Ministry of Home
Affairs (MHA)'s OM dated 27.10.2010, as
amended by MHA's OM dated 05.12.2017.
(b) Paragraph 8 (b) of MHA's OM dated
27.10.2010 lists those authorities of minimum
rank, with whose approval the request for
opening of LOC must be issued. The list does
not include officers of banks at present.
(c) As per the amended Paragraph 8(j) (amended
through MHA's OM dated 05.12.2017),
‘In exceptional cases, LOCs can be issued even
in such cases, as would not be covered by the
guidelines above, whereby departure of a person
from India may be declined at the request of any
of the authorities mentioned in clause (b) of the
above-referred OM, if it appears to such
authority based on inputs received that the
departure of such person is detrimental to the
sovereignty or security or integrity of India or
that the same is detrimental to the bilateral
relations with any country or to the strategic
and/or economic interests of India or if such
person is allowed to leave, he may potentially
indulged in an act of terrorism or offences
against the State and/or that such departure
ought not be permitted in the larger public
interest at any given point in time.’
(d) It is, therefore, clear that the guidelines
enable LOCs against persons who are
fraudsters/persons who wish to take loans,
willfully default/launder money and then
escape to foreign jurisdictions, since such
actions would not be in the economic interests
of India, or in the larger public interest.
2 Therefore, as suggested by CBI, MHA is
requested to kindly amend the OM dated
27.10.2010 and include in the list of authorities
under Paragraph 8(b) another category, as
follows:
‘(xiv) Chairman (State Bank of India)/Managing
Directors and Chief Executive Officers (MD &
CEOs) of all other Public Sector Banks’."
41. The Chairman/Managing Directors/Chief
Executive of all Public Sector Banks were
included in the list of originating agencies, by
office memorandum dated October 12, 2018
issued by the Director (Immigration) under
clause-(xv)
of
sub-paragraph
8(b).
The
Chairman/Managing Directors/Chief Executive
Officers of the banks on receipt of specific
inputs that the departure of a person would be
detrimental to the sovereignty or security or
integrity of India or detrimental to the bilateral
relations of India with any country or harmful to
the strategic and/or economic interest of India,
could request for opening a LOC.
42. This Court has already observed earlier
that the expression ‘economic interest’ cannot
be read in isolation but must be read into the
context in which it has been used in the policy
of 2010 as amended. It cannot be given a
narrow interpretation to mean and include the
conduct of business between the bank and a
defaulter. In the absence of any input that such
borrower was likely to flee India and such
departure would disrupt or adversely affect the
economy of the country or jeopardize the
bilateral business relationship and/or the
strategic relationship of India with other
countries, such request could not be made.
Sub-paragraph (j) of paragraph 8 had to be
satisfied.
43. The consolidated guidelines for issuance of
LOC in respect of Indian citizens and foreigners
found its final expression in office memorandum
dated February 22, 2021. The guidelines of
2010 which were modified in 2018 were
reviewed. Paragraph 6 sub-paragraphs H to L
provide the general circumstances under which
opening of LOC could be requested by the
originating
agency
which
include
the
Chairman/Managing Director/Chief Executive
Officer of all public sector banks. For
convenience sub-paragraph H, I, and J are
quoted below:“(H). Recourse to LOC is to be taken in
cognizable offences under IPC or other penal
laws. The details in column IV in the enclosed
Proforma regarding ‘reason for opening LOC’
must invariably be provided without which the
subject of an LOC will not be arrested/detained.
(I). In cases where there is no cognizable offence
under IPC and other penal laws, the LOC
subject cannot be detained/arrested or
prevented from leaving the country. The
originating agency can only request that they be
informed about the arrival/departure of the
subject in such cases.
(J) The LOC opened shall remain in force until
and unless a deletion request is received by BoI
from the Originator itself. No LOC shall be
deleted automatically. Originating Agency must
keep reviewing the LOCs opened at its behest on
quarterly and annual basis and submit the
proposals to delete the LOC, if any, immediately
after such a review. The BOI should contact the
LOC Originators through normal channels as
well as through the online portal. In all cases
where the person against whom LOC has been
opened is no longer wanted by the Originating
Agency or by Competent Court, the LOC
deletion request must be conveyed to BoI
immediately so that liberty of the individual is
not jeopardized.”
44. Thus, analysing the policy which existed
from 2010 and which were amended from time
to time and ultimately found its expression in
the memorandum dated February 22, 2021, this
court is of the view that only in exceptional
cases LOCs could be issued even if the
parameters quoted hereinabove were not
covered. Sub-paragraph (L) of the 2021 policy
lays down the exceptions. The same is quoted
below:“(L) In exceptional cases, LOCs can be issued
even in such cases, as may not be covered by
the guidelines above, whereby departure of a
person from India may be declined at the
request of any of the authorities mentioned in
clause (B) above, if it appears to such authority
based on inputs received that the departure of
such person is detrimental to the sovereignty or
security or integrity of India or that the same is
detrimental to the bilateral relations with any
country or to the strategic and/or economic
interests of India or if such person is allowed to
leave, he may potentially indulge in an act of
terrorism or offences against the State and/or
that such departure ought not be permitted in
the larger public interest at any given point of
time.”
45. The bank had to establish that the
departure of the petitioner on the basis of
intelligence reports would be detrimental to the
sovereignty, security and integrity of India,
detrimental to the bilateral relation of India with
any other country or detrimental to the
economic interest of India. Although clause (d)
in the office memorandum dated October 4,
2018 issued by DFS, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India
provided that those
persons who were fraudsters or had taken
loans, wilfully defaulted in repayment of the
same or laundered money and then tried to
escape to a foreign jurisdiction should be
included in the category of subjects whose
departure would be harmful to the economic
interest of India, the policy of 2021 did not
make a separate category under the exception
clause for such persons who were either
fraudsters or wilful defaulters and had
laundered money and were trying to escape to
foreign jurisdiction. Sub-paragraph (L) of
paragraph 6 of the policy of 2021 is a verbatim
reproduction of sub-paragraph (j) of paragraph
8 of the amended policy of 2010. In the opinion
of the court, persons who had taken loan from
public sector banks and had laundered money
and whose actions had caused disruption to the
economic stability, shares and stock market or
had affected the current economic growth of the
country, would come within the exception
clause.”
11. Having considered the background with regard to the
reasons and the policy behind issuance of LOCs, we find
that, this case is not covered by the memoranda . The
only reason cited by the bank seeking issuance of the
LOC, was declaration of the account of the company and
the writ petitioners as wilful defaulters. The relevant
portion is quoted below :“Dear Sir,
This has reference to your letter dated
08/02/2023 received by us on 09/02/2023. In
this regard, we wish to inform that based on
the classification of account M/s Ceebuild
Company Private Limited and you as Wilful
Defaulter, Lookout Circular has been issued by
Bureau of Immigration on the request of our
Bank.”
12. The request for LOC is to be made in a particular
proforma. The information against each column and subhead are required to be filled up. We do not find from the
said proforma that, any separate column had been
provided, requiring the details of wilful default i.e., date
of NPA, quantum of loan, failure to repay the loan etc.
Clause 11 of the said proforma requires the details of the
criminal case pending against the persons against whom
the LOC is sought to be issued. Thus, reading the various
parameters, on the basis of which LOC can be issued
harmoniously, we hold that mere declaration of wilful
default itself, cannot be a ground for origination of the
LOC against the defaulting borrowers. The offence has to
be graver. The economic offence has to be such that, the
departure of the persons prior to recovery of the money
through due process of law, would destabilise the
economy of the country. Issuance of LOC cannot be a
recovery mechanism for the defaulted amount. The
actions of the persons against whom the LOCs are issued,
should reflect that, they are involved in a crime, are
either evading arrest or trial and that their departure
would cripple the Indian economy. Injury to the
economic
interest
of
India
should
be
evident.
Commission of the alleged offence of default must be of a
high degree so as to shake the growth, cause instability,
affect business transactions and bilateral trade relations
with other countries. A possibility of change in the
market conditions, i.e. in the investments stock markets
should be demonstrably available. There is no evidence
before us which would show that the nature of the
allegations in this case, necessitated issuance of the LOC.
Moreover,
the
memoranda
discussed
hereinabove
indicate that the bank should have some information
from the intelligence or other investigating agencies that,
the departure of these persons would be detrimental to
the
economic
interest
of
India.
Admittedly,
no
investigation is pending against the writ petitioners.
13. In the matter of Debanjan Hazra vs The Serious
Fraud Investigation Office & Ors. decided in MAT
474 of 2026, this court had discussed what was meant
by economic interest and what was the consequence of
an LOC on the liberty of an individual. The relevant
paragraph are quoted below:“20. In Vishambhar Saran (supra) the issue of
economic interest has been discussed as follows:
- “50. BOB requested the Bureau of Immigration
to issue LOC. It is not on record whether such
LOC has been issued or not. The Bureau of
Immigration,
Ministry
of
Home
Affairs
(Foreigners Division) and all the other members
of the consortium of banks, apart from PNB were
impleaded as respondents in this proceeding.
None of these respondents have come up before
the Court in support of the request of BOB. They
have not contested the proceedings. Clause 3.1
of the SOP (Annexure P2, Page no. 26 of Writ
petition) states that the responsibility for
requesting issuance of LOC in respect of a
defaulter would be on the leader of the
consortium of banks or on the holder of the
biggest share or exposure amongst them. In this
case, the LOC originated by the lead bank,
having the highest exposure has been quashed
by a Co-ordinate Bench for the reasons which
have already been quoted hereinabove. Default
of the borrower cannot be read into the
expression “detrimental to the economic interest
of the country”. In order to cause injury to the
economic interest of the democracy of India, the
commission of alleged offence of default must be
of high degree so as to shake the growth,
financial
stability,
business
transactions,
bilateral trade relations, investments, stock
markets etc. There is no evidence that on
account of the default committed by the Visa
Power Limited, the economy of India had been
shaken. The bank has not provided any
contemporaneous material against the petitioner
which would satisfy the exceptions clause. The
bank is also silent as to whether any input had
been received from any agency that the
petitioner was likely to flee the country and his
departure would disrupt the economy. 51.
Admittedly, in the facts of this case, no
investigation is pending before any authority. It
is also not a case where the bank had come to a
conclusion on the basis of inputs received from
an intelligence agency or any other agency that
the petitioner was trying to leave India in order
to evade the consequences of the legal actions
that may be taken against him, both under the
civil and the criminal laws.”
21. The legal position governing LOCs is no
longer res integra. In Sumer Singh Salkan
(Supra), it has been held that recourse to an
LOC is permissible only where the person is
deliberately evading arrest, or he is not
appearing before the authorities despite coercive
processes, or he is likely to leave the country to
evade trial. The issuance of an LOC must
therefore be predicated upon cogent and tangible
material, and not on mere conjecture.
***
***
27. The contention of the respondents that the
LOC is justified keeping in view the “economic
interest of India” also does not withstand judicial
scrutiny.
While
economic
offences
are
undoubtedly grave, the mere reference to such
interest, cannot be a substitute for specific and
individual satisfaction regarding the necessity of
restraining a particular individual from travelling
abroad. The materials on record do not disclose
any clear or direct role attributable to the
appellant that would warrant such a drastic
restriction, particularly when the LOC against
the promoter of Elder as we have been informed
by Mr. Tiwari, in the course of this proceeding
does not continue.”
14. Based on the aforesaid discussions and the facts, we are
of the view that the learned Single Judge rightly held that
the LOC in the present case was not sustainable and the
same was rightly set aside. All restrictions on the
personal liberty of a citizen must meet the test of
proportionality.
15. In Menoka Gandhi vs. Union of India, reported in
(1978)
SCC
248,
the
Hon’ble
Apex
Court
unequivocally held that right to travel abroad was an
integral facet of personal liberty under Article 21, and
any restriction thereon must satisfy the test of being just,
fair and reasonable. The impugned LOC prevented the
respondent Nos. 1 to 3 from travelling abroad with their
family and as such constituted a serious invasion of their
rights.
16. Under such circumstances, we are not inclined to
interfere with the order of His Lordship.
17. Accordingly, the appeal and the application stand
dismissed.
18. We direct the Bureau of Investigation to act on the basis
of this order and inform all stakeholders.
19. Urgent photostat certified copy of the order, if applied
for, be given to the parties, upon usual undertakings.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
(Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review