Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:SHC:53
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 3rd June, 2025
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON‟BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.31 of 2024
:
Petitioner
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd.
versus
Respondent
:
Mount Distilleries Limited
Writ Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Pramit Chhetri, Advocate for the Petitioner.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Advocate with Mr. Adarsh Gurung, Advocate for
the Respondent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioner herein, who was the Plaintiff before the
Learned Commercial Court, East Sikkim, at Gangtok, filed a Suit for
Infringement, Passing off of Trade Mark, Infringement of Copyright,
Injunction and other consequential reliefs, under Sections 28(1) and
of
the
Trade
Marks
Act,
1999,
against
the
Defendant/
Respondent. The Suit was valued at ₹ 1,00,00,000/- (Rupees one
crore) only.
2.
The original Plaintiff was the United Spirits Limited
(USL). The business was later taken over by the present Petitioner
who was thereby transposed as the Plaintiff.
After closure of the
evidence before the Commercial Court and when the matter was
fixed for final arguments, the Petitioner filed a Petition under Order
XI Rule 1(5), read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
(hereinafter,
“CPC”),
dated
28-09-2023,
pertaining
to
2025:SHC:53
WP(C) No.31 of 2024
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd.
vs. Mount Distilleries Limited
disclosure, discovery and inspection of documents in suits, vide
which, the Petitioner sought to file the following documents;
(i)
Original certificate for use in legal proceedings for the
trade mark registrations 296836 dated 12-06-1974;
544357 dated 15-12-1998; 949492 dated 05-01-2004
and 2000458 dated 27-11-2015;
(ii)
Certified copy of Design Registration No.216986 dated
03-07-2008;
(iii)
C.A. Certificate showing sales incurred by the Plaintiff in
respect of brandy under the trade mark Honey Bee; and
(iv)
Usership Agreement, dated 01-01-2015, between USL
and the Defendant.
3.
Advancing the plea that the Petition be allowed, Learned
Counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the Suit was filed in the
year 2018.
The entire evidence of the litigating parties was
recorded and completed in June, 2022. The USL was taken over by
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd., the present Petitioner Company on 3009-2022, who stepped into the shoes of the original Plaintiff. The
present Petitioner, while examining the documents handed over to it
by the USL and relied on in the dispute, applied for the “certified to
be true copies” of the documents from the Trade Mark Registry,
located at New Delhi, which were accordingly made available. The
Petitioner then sought to file the documents before the Commercial
Court, but their Petition under Order XI Read with Rule 5(1) supra
was rejected vide the impugned Order dated 24-11-2023, in I.P.R.
Suit No.01 of 2018.
That, disallowing the Petitioner to file these
documents would be to their prejudice, as the original Plaintiff had
failed to take necessary steps and the Petition ought to be allowed
to rely on the documents to substantiate their case. Hence, the
impugned Order be set aside and the instant Petition be allowed.
2025:SHC:53
WP(C) No.31 of 2024
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd.
4.
vs. Mount Distilleries Limited
Learned Counsel for the Respondent, Defendant before
the Commercial Court, in the first instance raised the question of
maintainability of the Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India by relying on the decision of Rajendra Diwan vs. Pradeep
Kumar Ranibala and Another
wherein the Supreme Court has inter
alia held that, the powers under Article 227 of the Constitution is to
be used sparingly and only when there is a perversity, arbitrariness
or unreasonableness, in the order of the Courts below.
That, the
writ jurisdiction of the High Court cannot be converted into an
alternative appellate forum in the absence of provision of appeal in
the eyes of law.
That, documents sought to be furnished now as
“certified to be true copies”, were in fact submitted before the
Commercial Court as photocopies along with the Plaint. That, during
the entire course of trial the Petitioner failed to take steps to furnish
certified copies. The evidence of both parties have since concluded
and the matter fixed for final arguments. The Petitioner, who has
stepped into the shoes of the original Plaintiff, cannot now claim
ignorance of the non-filing of certified copies or put forth grounds of
difficulties in obtaining the certified copies. That, the defence of the
Defendant has been disclosed in its entirety during the trial and
should these documents now be allowed, it would be prejudicial to
the Defendant, as the Petitioner‟s attempt is to fill the loopholes in
their case. The Petition thereby deserves a dismissal.
5.
Having heard the Learned Counsel for the parties in
extenso and perused the documents, it is relevant to refer to the
statutory provision in the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (hereinafter,
“the Act”), Section 8 of the Act provides as follows;
(2019) 20 SCC 143
2025:SHC:53
WP(C) No.31 of 2024
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd.
vs. Mount Distilleries Limited
“8. Bar against revision application or petition
against
an
interlocutory
order.─Notwithstanding
anything contained in any other law for the time being
in force, no civil revision application or petition shall be
entertained against any interlocutory order of a
Commercial Court, including an order on the issue of
jurisdiction, and any such challenge, subject to the
provisions of section 13, shall be raised only in an
appeal against the decree of the Commercial Court.”
6.
The scope and ambit of Section 8 of the Act is explicit
and specifically bars revision, application or petition against an
interlocutory order of a Commercial Court, including an order on the
issue of jurisdiction. The Section elucidates that any such challenge,
subject to the provisions of Section 13, shall be raised only in an
Appeal against the decree of the Commercial Court, meaning
thereby that any challenge to an interlocutory order must be raised
through an Appeal, against the final decree of the Commercial
Court.
7.
However, it is clarified herein that, the bar engrafted in
Section 8 of the Act will not apply to the supervisory jurisdiction
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
In this context,
relevant reference is made to the observation of the Gujarat High
Court in State of Gujarat vs. Union of India and Others2 wherein it was
observed that the bar contained in Section 8 of the Act against
entertaining of civil revision application or petition provided under
any other law for the time being in force, shall not be applicable with
respect to the petitions under Article 227 of the Constitution and it
shall not affect the rights of the aggrieved party to invoke the
jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution.
(i)
The High Court of Madras in Ramanan Balagangatharan vs.
Rise East Entertainment Private Limited, rep by its Authorized Signatory
2018 SCC OnLine Guj 1515
2025:SHC:53
WP(C) No.31 of 2024
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd.
Easwara
Chandra
Vidyasagar
vs. Mount Distilleries Limited
Pentala
emphasised that the bar
engrafted in Section 8 of the Act will not apply to the supervisory
jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution.
(ii)
A Division Bench of this High Court in Glenmark
Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India and Others
observed as
follows;
“10. It is relevant also to notice that the
doctrine of judicial comity or amity, requires the Court
not to pass an order which would be in conflict with
another order passed by a competent court of law. In
India Household and Healthcare Ltd. vs. LG Household and
Healthcare Ltd. the Supreme Court observed that;
“19. A court while exercising its judicial
function would ordinarily not pass an order which
would make one of the parties to the lis violate a
lawful order passed by another court.”
The above judgment was taken note of and
considered by one of us (Biswanath Somadder) in
Nirendra Kumar Saha & Ors. vs. Steel Authority of India Ltd.
and Ors. .
(i)
In Yashita Sahu vs. State of Rajasthan and
Others the Supreme Court observed as follows;
“19. We are of the considered view that the
doctrine of comity of courts is a very healthy
doctrine. If courts in different jurisdictions do not
respect the orders passed by each other it will lead to
contradictory orders being passed in different
jurisdictions. No hard-and-fast guidelines can be laid
down in this regard and each case has to be decided
on its own facts. We may, however, again reiterate
that the welfare of the child will always remain the
paramount consideration.”
In light of the above circumstance, this Court is in agreement with
the observation of the High Court of Gujarat and High Court of
Madras on the issue of Section 8 of the Act and Article 227 of the
Constitution as already elucidated above.
8.
Under Article 227 of the Constitution, the High Court is
to examine whether the concerned Court had jurisdiction to deal
2022 SCC OnLine Mad 1300
2025 SCC OnLine Sikk 48
(2007) 5 SCC 510
(2009) 2 CHN 306 = (2009) 2 Cal LT 367 = 2009 SCC OnLine Cal 619
(2020) 3 SCC 67
2025:SHC:53
WP(C) No.31 of 2024
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd.
vs. Mount Distilleries Limited
with the matter and if so, whether the impugned Order is vitiated by
procedural irregularity.
The power of revision under Article 227
would also be exercised albeit sparingly, to interfere in cases of
grave dereliction of duty or flagrant violation of law, error of
jurisdiction where grave injustice would occur, unless the High Court
interferes.
9.
The position of law having thus been settled, it appears
that the standoff between the litigating parties was on account of
the fact that the Plaintiff is the registered proprietor of the trade
mark “Honey Bee”, and manufacturing brandy under the said trade
mark. The product was being sold in Sikkim for more than a decade,
through the Defendant its erstwhile bottler, a Limited Company with
its registered office in Sikkim who was aware of the Plaintiff‟s use of
the trade mark “Honey Bee” since 1973. Sometime in June, 2018, it
came to the knowledge of the Plaintiff that the Defendant had
adopted the trade mark “Honey Gold”, in respect of brandy which
was packaged and sold in bottles identical to that of the Plaintiff.
The products were openly sold in the markets of Sikkim.
The
Defendant was thereby infringing, passing of, falsifying, misusing,
forging and/or counterfeiting the established trade mark “Honey
Bee”.
Hence, the prayers in the Plaint inter alia for perpetual
injunction restraining the Defendant from using the name “Honey
Gold” to trade mark their product.
10.
Having heard Learned Counsel for the parties and
perused all documents including the averments and the impugned
Order of the Commercial Court in IPR Suit No.01 of 2018, it is seen
that the Commercial Court inter alia observed as follows;
“………………………………………………………
2025:SHC:53
WP(C) No.31 of 2024
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd.
vs. Mount Distilleries Limited
The chronology of dates of proceedings would
show that on the day (11.08.2020), when the case was
posted for issues and documents, the plaintiff had filed
copies of the documents relied by them. Inter alia, the
documents mentioned in sl. no. i, ii and iv (of the
application under consideration) had been filed. Due to
the prevalent COVID-19 pandemic the plaintiff was
given an opportunity to file the documents along with
the evidence. However, the same was not complied.
On 18.09.2021, the plaintiff closed their evidence.
During the said period and also at the time of final
arguments (before another Commercial Court), these
documents were neither produced nor permission was
sought to file.
It would be seen that the said documents are not
new documents but those which have already been
disclosed and relied by the plaintiff. Hence, it cannot
be taken as „additional documents‟ within the meaning
of Order XI Rule 1(5) of the CPC, 1908 which permits
the plaintiff, upon establishing reasonable cause to rely
on those documents which are not in their power,
possession, control or custody and not disclosed along
with the plaint.
The case of Sudhir Kumar (supra), clearly forbids
taking documents which the plaintiff intends to file at
this stage as it does not come within the ambit of
„additional documents‟.
I have also noticed that the plaintiff‟s witness
namely Udayan Chatterjee was examined on
17.07.2021 and 24.07.2021 and during his crossexamination, he has mentioned about the data of sale
of the plaintiff‟s product (Honey Bee) and whether any
loss has been caused to the plaintiff. It appears that
this point has also been argued by the parties during
final arguments before another Commercial Court.
Hence, permitting the plaintiff to file the CA certificate
of volume of sale of the said product would clearly be
to explain this short-comings in the plaintiff‟s case.
The same is impermissible at this stage.
……………………………………”
11.
[emphasis supplied]
On due consideration of the Order of the Commercial
Court (supra), it is clear that despite adequate opportunity afforded
to the Petitioner they failed to comply with the orders requiring
them to produce documents.
12.
Order XI Rule 1(5) of the CPC reads as follows;
“ORDER XI
DISCLOSURE, DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS
IN SUITS BEFORE THE COMMERCIAL DIVISION OF
A HIGH COURT OR A COMMERCIAL COURT
1. Disclosure and discovery of documents.—(1)
Plaintiff shall file a list of all documents and
photocopies of all documents, in its power, possession,
2025:SHC:53
WP(C) No.31 of 2024
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd.
vs. Mount Distilleries Limited
control or custody, pertaining to the suit, along with
the plaint, including:—
……………………………………
(5)
The plaintiff shall not be allowed to rely on
documents, which were in the plaintiff‟s power,
possession, control or custody and not disclosed along
with plaint or within the extended period set out above,
save and except by leave of Court and such leave shall
be granted only upon the plaintiff establishing
reasonable cause for non disclosure along with the
plaint.”
13.
It is not the Petitioner‟s case that the documents which
they seek to file, vide the Petition, were not in their power,
possession, control or custody. Order XI Rule 1(4) of the CPC deals
with the filing of “additional documents” in Court within thirty days
of filing the Suit. This Section is being flagged for the reason that,
the Commercial Court has observed that the documents sought to
be filed, “cannot be taken as additional documents within the
meaning of Order XI Rule 1(5) of the CPC”. In fact, Order XI Rule
1(5) of the CPC does not deal with additional documents and it is
Order XI Rule 1(4) of the CPC which is concerned with additional
documents.
Hence, the Commercial Court was in error on this
count. Order XI Rule 1(5) of the CPC is applicable in a commercial
suit, only with respect to the documents which were in the Plaintiff‟s
power, possession, control or custody and not disclosed along with
the Plaint. The grounds for establishing the reasonable cause in
non-disclosure along with the Plaint, may not arise in the case
where “additional documents” are sought to be produced/relied
upon which are discovered subsequent to the filing of the Plaint. In
the instant matter, it is not the Petitioner‟s case that the documents
were not in their possession or control and were subsequently
discovered, as photocopies of the documents have admittedly been
filed with the Plaint. This fact disentitles them from invoking the
2025:SHC:53
WP(C) No.31 of 2024
Inbrew Beverages Pvt. Ltd.
vs. Mount Distilleries Limited
provision of Order XI Rule 1(5) of the CPC. That apart, the evidence
of both the parties have since been completed and the matter fixed
for final arguments before the Court, which means that the entire
defence of the Defendant has already been disclosed. The Petitioner
cannot now seek to improve their case by filling in any loopholes
that may have occurred on account of non-furnishing of the certified
copies of the documents.
14.
For the foregoing reasons, I am not inclined to allow the
Petition which accordingly stands dismissed and disposed of.
15.
It is clarified that, the foregoing discussions are not to
be construed as findings or observations on the merits of the
matter.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
03-06-2025
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds/sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review