Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Criminal Writ Jurisdiction Case No.3315 of 2025
======================================================
In view of minutes dt- 17.12.25 of Hon'ble The A.C.J. based on SLP(Crl) No.
529/21 Bihar
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
The State of Bihar through Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Patna Bihar
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s
For the Respondent/s
:
:
Mr.Xxxxx
Mr.A.A.G. 3
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BIBEK CHAUDHURI
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE CHANDRA SHEKHAR JHA
CAV JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BIBEK CHAUDHURI)
Date : 18-09-2026
1. Pursuant to the order of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court dated 04.11.2025 passed in SLP (Crl.) No. 529 of 2021
(arising out of Suo Motu Writ Petition (Crl.) No. 4 of 2021),
this Court registered the present suo motu writ petition and
framed the following questions for adjudication:
(i)
What is the method of calculation of ordinary
remission?
(ii)
When the Remission Committee consists of the
Superintendent, Additional Superintendent and Deputy
Superintendent of Correctional Home, whether the
benefit of remission may be selective in case of
convicts?
(iii)
If Rule 428 & 429 of Bihar Prison Manual, 2012 are
read conjointly, it appears that special remission of 30
days in a year can be granted to a convict who has
rendered special assistance to the prison and
correctional services department in its drive to
improve the educational standards of prisoners or for
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
2/12
imparting vocational training to the prisoners.
(iv)
What will then happen to the prisoners who are not
educated or having no vocational knowledge?
(v)
Whether the relevant rules laid down in Bihar Prison
Manual, 2012 with regard to remission is absolutely
selective or not giving excessive and inclusive power
to the executive branch of the Government to decide
the issue of remission?
2. After receiving the case record being assigned by
the Hon’ble the Acting Chief Justice, this Court appointed Mr.
Pratik Kumar Sinha, Advocate as Amicus Curiae to assist the
case. Mr. P.K. Verma, Learned Additional Advocate General
supported by Mr. Saroj Kumar Sharma represented the State
of Bihar.
3. We have heard the learned Amicus Curiae and the
learned counsel appearing for the State, assisted by the
Inspector General of Prisons and Correctional Services. We
have also perused the detailed written submissions filed on
behalf of both sides and the relevant provisions of the Bihar
Prison Manual, 2012 (hereinafter “the Manual”).
4. Question (i): Method of calculation of ordinary
remission
(i) Ordinary remission is governed by Rules 409, 411,
414, 415 and 417 of the Manual. Eligible convicted prisoners
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
3/12
(those undergoing rigorous imprisonment of two months or
more, and certain other categories who volunteer for work)
are entitled to ordinary remission on the following scale:
(a) two days per calendar month for thoroughly good
conduct, participation in institutional activities and
meticulous observance of prison regulations;
(b) two days per calendar month for performance of
assigned work according to prescribed standards; and
(c) one day per calendar month for work performed on
Sundays and holidays for prison maintenance, kitchen or
hospital duties.
(ii) The maximum ordinary remission admissible is
seven days in a calendar month and eighty-four days in a year.
Ordinary remission is calculated from the first day of the
calendar month next following the date of sentence. No
ordinary remission is admissible for the broken period of the
month of sentence. Periods spent outside the prison on leave
or parole that are counted towards the sentence do not
interrupt the continuity of calculation. Prisoners unable to
work for reasons beyond their control continue to earn the
conduct component on the scale of the preceding month,
provided their overall conduct so warrants.
(iii) The Remission Committee examines the monthly
record of conduct and work and recommends the grant. The
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
4/12
Superintendent thereafter sanctions the remission and causes
the same to be entered in the History Ticket. The process is
required to be undertaken on a quarterly basis. We direct that
henceforth every prisoner shall be supplied with a duplicate
copy of the History Ticket reflecting the remission earned or
forfeited, so that the prisoner is fully informed and can seek
rectification if necessary.
5. Question (ii): Whether the composition of the
Remission Committee renders the benefit selective
(i) Rule 406 constitutes the Remission Committee
comprising
the
Superintendent
Superintendent
(Chairman),
(Member-Secretary)
and
Deputy
Assistant
Superintendent (Member). The Committee’s function is to
assess eligibility on the basis of objective criteria of conduct
and work performance laid down in Rule 411 and to make
recommendations to the Superintendent. The Superintendent’s
decision is final under Rule 408.
(ii) The composition of the Committee is entirely
executive. That circumstance, however, does not by itself
render the grant of ordinary remission selective or arbitrary.
The scales are fixed, the criteria are conduct and work based,
and the process is recorded in the History Ticket. Any
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
5/12
deviation from the prescribed criteria or discriminatory
application is amenable to judicial review under Articles 14
and 21 of the Constitution. The mere fact that the
recommending body consists of prison officers does not, in
our view, introduce an element of prohibited selectivity. We,
however, accept the suggestion of both the Amicus and the
State that a formal internal appeal mechanism against
incorrect calculation or denial of ordinary remission should be
provided, and we direct the State to incorporate such a
provision within three months.
6. Questions (iii) and (iv): Special remission under
Rules 428 and 429 and the position of uneducated or nonvocationally trained prisoners
(i) Rule 427 enumerates the grounds on which special
remission may be granted. Rule 428 empowers the
Superintendent to grant up to thirty days and the Inspector
General up to sixty days of special remission in a year. Rule
429 provides an additional incentive of a maximum of thirty
days (by the Inspector General) to long-term prisoners who
render special assistance in improving educational standards
or imparting vocational training.
(ii) The State has clarified, and we accept, that Rule
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
6/12
428 is available to all convicted prisoners without any bar
based on educational qualification. Rule 429 is purely
motivational and does not exclude any prisoner from the
benefit of ordinary remission or of special remission under the
other clauses of Rule 427. The overall ceiling of one-third of
the sentence under Rule 405 continues to apply. Consequently,
an uneducated or non-vocationally trained prisoner remains
fully entitled to ordinary remission and to special remission
for any of the meritorious acts enumerated in Rule 427. The
additional incentive under Rule 429 does not create a class of
permanently disadvantaged prisoners.
(iii) Nevertheless, to remove any possible perception
of inequality, we direct the State to examine and, if necessary,
frame an alternative pathway enabling illiterate prisoners to
earn
comparable
reformative
or
additional
remission
through
institutional
contributions.
Until
other
such
amendment is notified, the existing scheme shall continue to
operate, subject to the overarching one-third ceiling and the
non-discrimination mandate of Article 14.
7. Question (v): Whether the remission rules are
absolutely selective or confer excessive power on the
executive
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
7/12
(i) The scheme of Chapters XIII and XV-B of the
Manual is structured and not absolute in its selectivity.
Ordinary remission operates on fixed quantitative scales.
Special remission is guided by enumerated considerations.
Premature release of life convicts is regulated by Rules 474 to
487, the parameters laid down in Laxman Naskar v. Union of
India, (2000) 2 SCC 595, and the obligation of the State to
consider every eligible case suo motu in terms of the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 18.02.2025.
(ii) The executive is necessarily vested with a measure
of
discretion
in
assessing
individual
conduct,
work
performance and suitability for premature release. That
discretion, however, is neither unfettered nor immune from
scrutiny. It is controlled by the ceilings in the Manual, the
requirement of reasoned orders, the right of the prisoner to be
informed, the principles of natural justice before forfeiture,
and the supervisory jurisdiction of this Court under the present
suo motu proceedings. Any exercise of power that is arbitrary,
discriminatory or contrary to the policy is liable to be struck
down.
(iii) We therefore answer Question (v) by holding that
the rules are not “absolutely selective” and do not confer
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
8/12
excessive or unbridled power on the executive. The residual
concerns regarding transparency, timelines and grievance
redressal stand substantially addressed by the suggestions
jointly emerging from the Amicus and the State, which we
adopt as directions hereinafter.
8. Recommendations
Having regard to the comprehensive submissions of
the learned Amicus Curiae and the Inspector General of
Prisons, and keeping in view that the rule-making prerogative
rests with the State Government, this Court makes the
following consolidated recommendations for consideration
and appropriate action by the State Government:
(i)
The process of obtaining reports from various
authorities regarding proposals for premature release
of eligible prisoners shall be initiated at least six
months before the prescribed eligibility date by the
concerned Jail Superintendent.
(ii)
Fixed time-limits shall be prescribed for submission of
reports by the concerned authorities (Probation Officer
- 15 days; Superintendent of Police - 30 days;
Presiding Officer - 15 days). Responsibility for timely
submission shall rest with the concerned authority. In
the event of non-submission within the prescribed
time, the report may be treated as favourable.
(iii)
All procedures relating to the required reports should
ordinarily be completed at least two months before the
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
9/12
convict completes the prescribed period (14 years of
actual imprisonment / 20 years including remission),
so that sufficient time is available for consideration by
the State Sentence Remission Review Board.
(iv)
Wherever approval of the Ministry of Home Affairs,
Government of India, is required, such approval or
rejection should be obtained within thirty days. The
State may consider the consequence of silence on the
part of the Ministry.
(v)
All recommendations for premature release shall be
made strictly in the light of the parameters laid down
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Laxman Naskar
(Supra).
(vi)
A provision may be inserted fixing a reasonable outer
time-limit for decision on cases of life convicts upon
completion of the prescribed period of actual custody,
together with fixation of responsibility on a designated
authority.
(vii) The History Ticket shall be maintained in two copies –
one to remain in the prison office and the other to be
given to the prisoner – with clear entries of remission
granted or seized. The prisoner shall be entitled to seek
rectification or prefer an appeal if dissatisfied with the
calculation.
(viii)
Before any deduction or seizure of remission already
granted, the prisoner shall be afforded an opportunity
of hearing and a reasoned order shall be passed. An
appellate mechanism against such seizure, to be
decided by a reasoned order within thirty days, may be
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
10/12
provided.
(ix)
A formal mechanism enabling a prisoner to file a
complaint against any discrepancy in the calculation or
non-grant of remission may be incorporated.
(x)
The State Sentence Remission Review Board may be
expressly empowered to recommend premature release
subject to appropriate, reasonable and non-oppressive
conditions having regard to the nature of the offence,
age of the prisoner, and the reports received.
(xi)
Suitable provisions may be inserted for cancellation or
withdrawal of
permanent
remission
only after
affording an opportunity of hearing and recording
brief reasons.
(xii) Remission earned during the under-trial period shall
be appropriately counted and set off against the
sentence after conviction, in terms of Rule 424 or by
suitable clarification/amendment.
(xiii) The provisions of Rules 428 and 429 may be
examined so as to ensure that illiterate prisoners are
not placed at a disadvantage; the State may consider
providing an alternative pathway for such prisoners or
suitable modification of the educational/vocational
criterion.
(xiv)
The State may consider placing prisoners involved in
serious SC/ST cases, certain information-technology
offences (including those relating to obscene material
or cyber-crime involving abetment of suicide/death),
mob lynching, acid-attack cases, and such other
categories as it deems appropriate, in the category of
ineligible for premature release, and may also examine
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
11/12
addition of further categories under Rule 481(i) and
Chapter XIII.
(xv) The continued need for sub-clauses (iv) and (v) of
Rule 481 may be examined in the light of the
decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of
India v. V. Sriharan, (2016) 7 SCC 1, and Ramasrey @
Fakkad
v.
State
of
Uttar
Pradesh,
MANU/SC/0757/2026.
(xvi) Calculation of remission in the case of prisoners
transferred from one State to another shall continue to
be in accordance with the provisions of the State in
which the prisoner is serving the sentence.
(xvii) The list of all life convicts, with details of actual
custody, remission earned (month-wise and year-wise),
case particulars, likely date of consideration by the
Board, and the final order of the Board, may be
uploaded on a dedicated portal or the official website
of the Home Department for the information of the
convicts and their families.
9. The State Government is requested to examine all
the above recommendations in a comprehensive manner, take
an appropriate policy decision, and effect necessary
amendments to the Bihar Prison Manual, 2012, or issue
suitable executive instructions, as it may consider proper.
10. The State Government shall place on record within
four weeks the updated list of the thirty-two pending cases
before the State Sentence Remission Board, together with the
Patna High Court CR. WJC No.3315 of 2025 dt.18-09-2026
12/12
dates on which each convict completed the prescribed period
of incarceration. The State Government shall also file a
compliance report before this Court within a period of four
months from today, indicating the decisions taken on each of
the recommendations and the steps taken for their
implementation.
11. Let a copy of this judgment be sent to the Chief
Secretary, Government of Bihar, and to the Principal
Secretary, Home Department, Government of Bihar, for
necessary action and compliance.
12. With the recording of the answers to the five
questions and the recommendations made above, the present
suo motu writ petition stand disposed of.
(Bibek Chaudhuri, J)
Chandra Shekhar Jha, J: I agree.
( Chandra Shekhar Jha, J )
uttam/AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
NAFR
02.09.2026
18.09.2026
18.09.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review