Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(PIL) No. 09/2019
IN RE: VILLAGES IN UPPER DZONGU MAROONED DUE TO COLLAPSE OF A
BRIDGE AT MANTAM LAKE, NORTH SIKKIM.
Date: 20/06/2020
CORAM :
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, J.
…
(ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ)
This matter is taken up through V.C.
2.
Heard Mr. Tashi Rapten Barfungpa, learned Amicus Curiae as well as
Mr. Vivek Kohli, learned Advocate General, Sikkim.
3.
This Suo Motu Public Interest Litigation was registered on the basis of
newspaper reports. A news article captioned “Newly constructed bridge in
Dzongu overflowed, 13 villages affected” was published on 05th May, 2019
issue of Sikkim Express, wherein it was stated that due to heavy rainfall in
North Sikkim, water level of Kanaka river had risen resulting in submersion
of the bailey bridge, which was built over the river at Dzogu. Similar news
with the caption “Heavy rainfall submerge Mantam bridge” was also reported
in Summit Times on its 05th May, 2019 issue.
4.
A news item was published on 19th June, 2019 issue of Sikkim
Express, under the headline “13 Villages Marooned”. Summit Times, on its
19th June, 2019 issue reported the events under the headline “Rain scare
sends jitters along Teesta”.
5.
At the very outset, it is relevant to be noticed that as a result of heavy
landslide on 13.08.2016, natural flow of Kanaka river was blocked resulting
in formation of a lake - one village was submerged and several wards were
marooned.
6.
This Court had taken cognizance of the aforesaid incident on
17.08.2016 and had registered a suo motu writ petition, registered as WP
(PIL) No. 05 of 2016, titled “In Re: Debacle in Upper Dzongu”.
7.
The aforesaid Public Interest Litigation was disposed of by an order
dated 27.06.2018. Paragraphs 9, 10, 11 and 12 of the aforesaid order reads
as follows: “9. Over the months, the Task Force undertook the task of controlled
blasting for draining the artificial lake. So far as the construction of
Bridge is concerned, the LR&DM Department undertook to furnish
technical details about the possibility of constructing a Suspension
Bridge to accommodate one vehicle in place of the Foot Bridge which
was proposed then. It was brought to the notice of this Court that the
Government had taken a decision to establish a two lane permanent
RCC Bridge connecting the people living on the other side of the lake
for which a sum of Rs.49,05,75,000/- (Rupees forty-nine crores, five
lakhs and seventy-five thousand) only, have been sanctioned. In the
meanwhile, a Suspension Foot Bridge would be installed to facilitate
the movement of goods and basic necessities to people who stranded
are on the other side of the lake. On 25-04-2018 the State
Government in its Affidavit submitted that the Suspension Foot Bridge
would be completed by the end of May, 2018, while financial bid was
being examined for the two lane RCC Bridge, the technical evaluation
being completed.
10. Today, it is submitted before this Court that the Suspension Foot
Bridge is now complete and is being used by people for their daily
thoroughfare, installation of wire mesh on the sideways of the Bridge
would
be
completed
in
two
weeks.
That,
tender
process
for
construction of two lane RCC Bridge is completed and the process of
award of work is underway. The Amici Curiae submit that total
completion of the Suspension Bridge including painting would take
about one month, however, he concedes that presently the Bridge is
ready for use.
11. In view of the aforesaid circumstances, we are of the considered
opinion that necessary directions given by this Court pertaining to
relief and rehabilitation measures of affected people of the landslide
area including construction of Bridges have been complied with.
12. Nothing further remains for adjudication and hence, the matter
stands disposed of with liberty granted to the Learned Amici Curiae to
approach this Court, if and when the need so arises.”
8.
In this proceeding, a report in the form of an affidavit was filed by the
Chief Secretary and the Principal Chief Engineer-cum-Secretary, Roads &
Bridges Department, Government of Sikkim, i.e. respondent nos. 1 and 4,
respectively, on 19.09.2019, admitting that due to heavy downpour on
18.06.2019, the foot suspension bridge over river Kanaka at Mantam, Upper
Dzongu had been damaged and the bridge had collapsed. It is stated that a
cane bridge was constructed and opened for public on 02.09.2019 so that no
inconvenience is caused to the public of Tingbong GPU, Sakyong Pentok GPU
and Laven GPU. It is stated that a steel bridge downstream of the foot
suspension bridge connecting Lingthem to Tingvong, Kusong, Lingzya and
other adjoining villages falling on the left bank of the river Kanaka had also
been damaged by the floods and as the volume of the water in the lake is
very high and volatile, restoration of temporary bridge for vehicular traffic
can be taken only after the monsoon is over.
9.
In the affidavit, it is stated that in order to address the issue of
connectivity permanently, a proposal was sanctioned for construction of a
permanent bridge over river Kanaka at a cost of Rs.88.54 crores and the
work order had been issued to National Projects Construction Corporation
Limited on 28.01.2019 and the scheduled completion time is January, 2021.
10.
Learned Amicus Curiae, after visiting the site, had submitted a
report/suggestions on 01.11.2019. In the report/suggestions of the learned
Amicus Curiae, it is stated that the road leading towards Mantam village
connecting Lingthem GPU is in a pathetic condition. Similarly, the road on
the other side of river Kanaka towards the cut off villages was also pathetic.
In the report/suggestions, learned Amicus Curiae had stated that a ropeway
had been constructed by the Public Works Department, Roads and Bridges,
Government of Sikkim for the purpose of transportation of goods. However,
after inauguration of the same sometime in the year 2002, it had remained
mostly inoperative. Earlier, when the same was operational, villagers were
allowed to use it during day time for transportation of goods provided they
arranged diesel for the machine. It is further stated that presently in times
of need, the villagers are making use of the ropeway by manually pulling it
with their hands. In the report/suggestions learned Amicus Curiae had put
on record that villagers had indicated to him that if the ropeway was made
operative, it would solve their problem to a certain extent while transporting
rations and items of their daily use from the other side of the river (Ruklu
Kayam, under Lingthem GPU) across to 6th mile Tingvong, through the
ropeway. Learned Amicus Curiae had suggested the following temporary
measures for mitigating the suffering of the villagers on the other side of the
lake and river:
“I.
Since the conditions of the roads are not only Pathetic but
dangerous and is a serious concern voiced by majority of the
villagers, there is a dire need for immediately improving the road
condition on both the sides of the river.
II.
The path leading to the Bamboo Cane Bridge needs to be made
more stable and comfortable for people of all age and gender to
commute through. The logs as depicted in the pictures annexed
herewith should be replaced with strong wooden planks for
balance and stability.
III.
Since the bridge could be used during the nighttime as well, the
area in and around the bridge needs to be provided proper
lighting. Arrangements for street lights needs to be made
immediately on both the sides of the river as well as on the
bridge. With winters approaching and the days being replaced by
longer nights, proper lighting over and across the existing
Bamboo Cane Bridge becomes all the more essential.
IV.
The State respondents could make immediate arrangements to
make the rope-way operative which connects Ruklu Kayam
village under Lingthem – Lingdem GPU to 6th Mile Tingvong on
the other side of the river. The functioning of the rope way shall
ease the problems of the people of the cut off villages in
transporting rations and goods required for their day to day use
including
raw
materials
required
for
private
as
well
as
government construction works being carried out in these
villages.
V.
Looking at the terrain and the site where the work for the
construction of permanent bridge is being carried out, the
Amicus as well as the villagers have serious doubt that the same
shall be completed within the scheduled time i.e. January 2021,
therefore in order to make sure that the Temporary Bridge that
the Government is to construct does not meet the same fate of
being washed away by the river like the previous suspension
bridge, the Respondents could take some expert suggestion and
look at the option of River Training so that the flow of the river
towards a certain direction is controlled which could eventually
help in permanently protecting the bridge for the use of public
till the construction of the permanent bridge is completed and
even thereafter.
VI.
Since some of the villagers were of the opinion that the
abutment of the previous bridge not being constructed at the
right place could be one of the reason for the bridge not being
able to withstand the pressure of the river, the government,
before
the
construction
of
the
bridge
could
consult
the
Panchayats and the residents of the area who could have better
knowledge about the terrain and quality of the land.
The Amicus Curiae seeks the liberty of this Hon’ble Court to
allow the Amicus to place any further reports or suggestions as and
when the same is required.”
11.
Subsequent to filing of the aforesaid report/suggestions of the learned
Amicus Curiae, respondent nos. 1 and 4 filed an affidavit dated 03.12.2019
stating as follows: “That the Roads and Bridges Department has instructed the concerned
field Officers in North Sikkim to take up the works Vide letter no.
loose/ACE/N/E/R& B /36 dated 7/11/19 and accordingly as directed by
the High Court many steps have already been taken up to mitigate the
issues. A copy of the letter is annexed and marked herewith as
Annexure- R 1.
I.
That the road on right bank of the river has been temporarily
restored and riding quality has been considerably improved and
loaded vehicles are plying comfortably on this stretch of the
road. The temporary restoration of road on left bank of the river
will be taken up after completion of temporary bridge which is
under construction.
(A copy of the recent Photographs of restored roads is annexed
and marked herewith as Annexure – R 2).
II.
With regard to the temporary measures as directed, the Path
leading to the Cane Bridge has been made comfortable and
stable for people of all ages and gender to commute through to
the possible extent. Once the construction of the temporary
vehicular bridge is completed and all pedestrian as well as
vehicular
traffic
is
diverted
through
the
bridge
further
improvement works would be taken up because as of now due to
continuous use of the bridge by the people works are hindered
now and then.
(A copy of photographs been annexed and marked herewith as
Annexure – R3).
III.
As directed for proper lighting in and around the bridge the same
has been carried out by providing lighting over and across the
existing bamboo Cane Bridge.
(A copy of the photographs has been marked and annexed
herewith as Annexure – R4).
IV.
With regard to the ropeway operation as directed it is to submit
that as per the records it was constructed under the funding by
the
SJEWD,
sponsored
by
the
Ministry
of
Tribal
Affairs,
Government of India in the year 2002. It is found that the onus
of maintenance of the ropeway falls under the purview of LRDM
Department. As of now the Ropeway is in operation status.
V.
With regard to the construction of a permanent bridge, the
foundation
work
for
the
abutments
is
ongoing
and
simultaneously the fabrication of bridge parts is also nearing
completion. The bridge will be completed within the schedule
time i.e. January 2021.
VI.
Men and Machineries are engaged for erection of a temporary
vehicular bridge across the river for easy movement of vehicles
during the lean period. The work for the same is underway on
war-footing and would be completed positively in all respects by
12/12/2019.
Further,
it
is
to
submit
that
delay
in
commencement of this work is mainly attributed by the land
disputes in the initial stage of the site where the work was to be
taken up. The concerned Gram Panchayat has given a certificate,
certifying
the
dispute,
settlement
and
completion
of
the
temporary vehicular bridge.
(A copy of the certificate is annexed and marked herewith as
Annexure – R5).
(A copy of photographs of progress of the work of construction
of temporary vehicular bridge has been enclosed for reference at
Annexure – R6).”
12.
By an order dated 05.12.2019, this Court directed the matter to be
listed on 19.02.2020 to take note of further developments. A report in the
form of an affidavit was filed by respondent nos. 1 and 4 on 15.02.2020. It
is stated therein that the construction of the temporary bridge for all
pedestrian as well as vehicular traffic across river Kanaka was completed on
12.12.2019. With regard to the construction of permanent bridge, it is stated
that excavation in foundation work for both the abutments at Tingbong and
Kayum side were completed for 2-lane bridge over Kanaka river. The
fabrication of steel bridge parts had been completed at the workshop and
transportation and stacking at work site is under process and stacking of the
reinforcing bars had been completed. It is stated that the concrete works for
the abutments will be completed within the scheduled time.
13.
Order of this Court dated 19.02.2020 goes to show that Mr. Kohli had
submitted that though temporary vehicular bridge had been constructed and
was functional, with the onset of monsoon, the bridge has to be dismantled
as the surging water of river Kanaka will submerge the temporary bridge
and during the period of monsoon, the bamboo bridge, which was in
existence, would have to be used by the villagers and others. He further
submitted that the bamboo bridge may be required to be strengthened
before the onset of monsoon. He further submitted that the ropeway, which
was at that point of time operated manually, might have to be made
functional to operate in a mechanized way.
14.
In the aforesaid order dated 19.02.2020, this Court had taken note of
the submission of Mr. Barfungpa that the motor of the ropeway was not in
working condition and that is why the same was required to be operated
manually. The order goes to show that the learned Advocate General had
submitted that he would look into all aspects of the matter and would file a
comprehensive report relating to strengthening of the bamboo bridge and
mechanized operation of the ropeway.
15.
Though, by the aforesaid order dated 19.02.2020, the case was
directed to be listed on 23.04.2020, due to lockdown, the same could not be
listed and the matter came to be listed on 10.06.2020. Till then, because of
lockdown, the report was not filed and on a prayer made by the learned
State Counsel, while granting seven days’ time to file an affidavit, the matter
was directed to be listed today.
16.
Accordingly, an affidavit dated 18.06.2020 in the form of a report was
filed by respondent nos. 1 and 4.
17.
In the said affidavit, it is stated that the temporary bamboo cane
bridge was strengthened using a ten ton capacity winching machine to pull
the main cable to minimize the sagging. After the sagging was minimized,
the damaged bamboo decking was replaced ensuring that there was no gap
in between and after such replacement of the decking, the gap between foot
bridge and the river, at the minimum, is 8 feet. It is further stated that the
ropeway has been mechanized and the villagers are using the same. With
regard to construction of the permanent bridge, it is stated that though very
little progress was achieved during the period of lockdown on account of
COVID-19 pandemic, the scheduled completion date had not been revised
from the earlier scheduled date, which is 21.01.2021.
18.
Mr. Barfungpa has submitted that though the bamboo bridge has been
constructed, as the same is the lifeline for the villagers of Tingvong GPU,
Sakyong Pentok GPU and Laven ward under Lingthem GPU, respondent
authorities should regularly monitor the condition of the bamboo bridge and
whenever required, strengthen the same so that the villagers are not cut off
from the rest of the world. Mr. Barfungpa further submits that a direction
may also be issued to improve the condition of the road leading towards
Mantam village and further connecting Lingthem GPU and the condition of
the road towards the cut off villages. He further submits that the Public
Interest Litigation may be disposed of by directing the respondent
authorities to keep the ropeway functional in mechanized form and to ensure
that the permanent bridge is constructed without any delay and within the
scheduled completion date.
19.
Mr. Kohli has submitted that in view of the steps taken by the
respondents, nothing further survives for consideration in this case and the
petition may be disposed of with a liberty to the learned Amicus Curiae to
approach this Court again if the occasion arises.
20.
Considering the matter in its entirety and taking note of the
submissions as well as the affidavits/reports on the record, we dispose of
this Public Interest Litigation with the following directions:(i)
The respondents shall regularly monitor the condition of the
temporary bamboo cane bridge to ensure safety of villagers
crossing the bridge and to ensure that the bridge remains
functional so as to not cause any inconvenience to the affected
villagers. The bamboo cane bridge, as and when required, is to
be appropriately strengthened.
(ii)
Respondents will keep the ropeway functional in mechanized
form.
(iii)
Condition of the road on the other side of Kanaka river, i.e.
towards the cut off villages i.e. Tingvong GPU, Sakyong Pentok
GPU and Laven ward under Lingthem GPU shall be improved so
that the villagers of the remote corners of the State have better
connectivity.
(iv)
Respondents shall ensure completion of construction of the
permanent bridge within the schedule time.
21.
While disposing of the petition, we grant liberty to learned Amicus
Curiae to approach this Court, if need so arises in future.
Judge
jk/
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review