Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 10th JANUARY, 2022
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DIVISION BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Advocate as Amicus Curiae.
Ms. Yeshi Wangmo Rinchhen, Government Advocate for the StateRespondent No.1 (The State of Sikkim through the Chief
Secretary).
Ms. Yeshi Wangmo Rinchhen, Government Advocate with Ms. Rita
Sharma, Advocate for State-Respondent No.2 (The Forest,
Environment and Wildlife Management Department, Government
of Sikkim).
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Central Government Counsel for Respondent
No.3 (The Union of India through Ministry of Road, Transport and
Highways).
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Central Government Counsel for Respondents
No.4 (The National Highways & Infrastructure Development
Corporation Limited).
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Central Government Counsel for Respondents
No.5 (The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change).
Ms. Yeshi Wangmo Rinchhen, Government Advocate for StateRespondent No.6 (The Urban Development and Housing
Department, Government of Sikkim).
Dr. (Ms.) Doma T. Bhutia, Advocate for Respondent No.7
(Gangtok Smart City Development Limited).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
“Trees are Poems that the Earth writes upon the Sky”
– Kahlil Gibran
1.
The genesis of this Writ Petition (PIL) lies in a letter
petition dated 08-06-2020. The Petitioner, Kailash Pradhan, an
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
Architect from Sikkim, being deeply troubled by the callous way
that the trees in the city were being felled, averred that besides
providing clean air, stabilising climate, binding soil and supporting
other forms of biodiversity, trees are an intangible part of the
collective memories of the residents, and give meaning to
everyday urban existence. That, he was aware that the trees are
required to be cleared for essential human activity and that the
felled trees could not be resurrected, however, the Government
could be made to acknowledge that trees are important and ought
to be valued and saved. That, felling should be only for a good
purpose after rendering serious consideration. Besides, the general
public were not made aware of a plan of widening the National
Highway for which the trees were being felled. That, the merits of
a plan that warranted felling so many trees required questioning.
That, the Government had justified their action by stating that for
every felled tree 10 (ten) trees would be planted in another
location, but for city dwellers the trees in the city cannot be
compared to those in a forest. Hence, the prayer that this Court
recognise the gravity of what is at stake and to do what is best for
Gangtok and its citizens.
2.
Besides the Respondent No.1 (The State of Sikkim
through the Chief Secretary); Respondent No.2 (The Forest,
Environment and Wildlife Management Department, Government of
Sikkim); Respondent No.3 (The Union of India through Ministry of
Road, Transport and Highways) and Respondent No.4 (National
Highways and Infrastructure Development Corporation Limited);
the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, was
arrayed as Respondent No.5 vide Order dated 23-06-2020. On the
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
submissions of Learned Advocate General, the Urban Development
and Housing Department was impleaded as Respondent No.6, while
on the submissions of the Learned Amicus Curiae, the Gangtok
Smart City Development Limited was impleaded as Respondent
No.7 vide Order dated 29-06-2020.
3.
Learned
Amicus
Curiae
submitted
that
after
interactions with the Petitioner, retired Forest Officials, Architects
of the town and other local persons certain suggestions were put
forth which were brought to the notice of the Court.
That, the
Respondent No.2 was duty bound to get clearance for the felling of
trees from the Central Government which the concerned Officers
deliberately bypassed as no clearance would have been granted by
the Central Government.
That, the Respondent No.2 is to look
into the interest and to protect the indiscriminate felling of trees
which are young and healthy despite adverse public opinion.
Reference was made by the Learned Amicus Curiae to the Royal
Parks, a charity created in London, United Kingdom, to support and
manage 5000 acres of Royal Park land across London. Reference
was also made to efforts worldwide and pledges by different
countries to plant trees. It was urged that trees have to be saved
and the protection of the environment be given priority.
4.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Respondent
No.2
while
attempting to convince this Court that all relevant Rules had been
complied with by the Department, referred to the Report dated 2706-2020 and submitted that on receipt of an application dated 1903-2019 from the Nodal Officer of the Respondent No.7 under Rule
4 of the Sikkim Private and Other Non-Forest Lands Tree Felling
Rules, 2006 (for short, the ―Rules of 2006‖), requesting felling of
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
trees to improve the 9 (nine) Junctions in line with the Gangtok
Smart City proposal, i.e., (a) Zero Point Junction; (b) Development
Area Junction; (c) High Court Junction; (d) Hospital Dara Junction;
(e) Ganju Lama Dwar Junction; (f) Smoke Test Junction; (g) Amdo
Golai Junction; (h) Sikkim Jewels Junction; and (i) CRH (Manipal)
Junction, the Joint Director, East Territorial Division of the
Respondent No.2, on 05-09-2019, in terms of the process provided
under the Rules of 2006, directed the Range Officer (T), Gangtok
Territorial Range, to coordinate with the Nodal Officer of the
Respondent No.7. The Range Officer submitted a Report dated 1510-2019 after site verification of three Junctions, i.e., Zero Point
Junction, Development Area Junction (I, II and III) and High Court
Junction, identifying 121 (one hundred and twenty one) numbers
of trees of different species and BHG, viz., 64 (sixty four) number
of poles (trees with smaller girth and less height) and 147 (one
hundred and forty seven) number of plants for removal for the said
three Junctions in due consideration of Rules 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the
Rules of 2006.
Respondent
That, on this Report the Joint Director of the
No.2
vide
letter
dated
22-10-2019
Compensatory
Afforestation
Management
Rs.4,70,879/-
(Rupees
lakhs,
four
Plan,
seventy
prepared
a
amounting
to
thousand,
eight
hundred and seventy nine) only, under the Rules of 2006 and sent
it to the Conservator of Forest. On 13-12-2019, the proposal for
felling of 121 (one hundred and twenty one) numbers of trees,
removal of 64 (sixty four) number of poles and 147 (one hundred
and forty seven) numbers of plants, was approved by the
concerned Minister. Following this approval, the felling of the trees
and removal of poles and plants were ordered by the Respondent
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
No.2 on receipt of payment of Rs.4,70,879/- (Rupees four lakhs,
seventy thousand, eight hundred and seventy nine) only, from the
Respondent No.7, on 20-01-2020, on which day the trees identified
were also hammer marked.
Auction Notice was issued on the
same date for 121 (one hundred and twenty one) trees and 64
(sixty four) poles with the offset price of Rs.7,66,183/- (Rupees
seven lakhs, sixty six thousand, one hundred and eighty three)
only, and one K. B. Gurung who offered the highest bid of
Rs.7,67,900/- (Rupees seven lakhs, sixty seven thousand and nine
hundred) only, was handed over the trees and poles. As per the
Compensatory Afforestation Plan the Respondent No.7 will have to
plant 1210 (one thousand and ten) tree saplings at locations
identified by the Respondent No.2. The attention of this Court was
invited to the Report dated 27-06-2020, the Smart Cities Mission
Statement & Guidelines and the communication and Rules referred
to hereinabove along with approval orders of felling of trees, bid
documents, etc. Learned Counsel urged that there had been active
application of mind by the Respondent No.2 to ensure that the
barest minimum trees were felled and the Principal Secretary-cumPCCF in his Note pointed out that the felling had to be minimized.
5.
It was next contended that in another Report dated 15-
07-2020 of the Respondent No.2 that the 2 (two) Junctions, i.e.,
Development Area Junction and the High Court Junction, were, vide
Notification dated 07-11-1985, declared notified Green Belt Areas
within the Gangtok town.
Vide Notification dated 29-01-2018
(Denotification Notification) the majority of the area of the three
Junctions, i.e., Zero Point Junction, High Court Junction and
Development Area Junction, were denotified and excluded from the
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
Green Belt Area.
The Denotification process was carried out and
conducted by the Respondent No.6. That, while the Notification of
Green Belt is a matter of policy in given circumstances it is possible
for the Government to decide Denotification as well.
That, the
Hon‘ble Supreme Court in T. N. Godavarman Thirumulpad vs. Union of
India and Others
has held that the term ―forest land‖ occurring in
Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (which does not
contain any definition of the term ―forest land‖) will not only
include (a) ‗Forest‘ as understood in the dictionary sense; but also
(b) any area recorded as forest in the Government record
irrespective of ownership. That, in light of this pronouncement, a
few acres around a traffic junction would not qualify as a ‗Forest‘
nor can it be treated or equated to ‗Forest‘ or ―forest land‖. It was
further urged that most of the trees to be removed were
Cryptomeria japonica (Dhupi) and Alnus nepalensis (Uttis). That,
the
‗Dhupi‘
is
known
to
suppress
indigenous
undergrowth,
adversely affecting biodiversity, leading to increased surface runoff and soil erosion. It was also clarified that the Rules do not
provide for any process or procedure to be followed for Auction of
the trees felled under the rules and the Department has followed
precedents and issued Notice for public Auction.
In the instant
matter, due to the non-availability of Experts and machineries for
felling of trees, the trees were disposed of through open Auction in
its standing form and the felling was carried out by the successful
bidder.
That, after the civil work is completed in the project sites
of the Smart City at three Junctions identified, herbs and shrubs of
aesthetic importance will be planted in the first few rows from the
(1997) 2 SCC 267
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
road as avenue plantation to prevent threat to life and moving
vehicles.
Small to medium size trees with high air Pollution
Tolerance Index (APTI), fast growing, high oxygen releasing and
high dust accumulating species will be planted around the Project
affected area. The work would be executed by the East Territorial
Division of the Respondent No.2, as per approved plan, hence the
stay ordered by this Court vide Orders dated 29-06-2020 and 1707-2020 be vacated.
6.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Respondent
No.7
while
referring to its Report dated 15-07-2020 sought to explain the
aims and objectives of the Smart City Mission. That, feedback was
sought from the various stakeholders for Gangtok Smart City
proposal
by
holding
consultative
meetings
with
elected
representatives and three rounds of consultation were done in the
Area Based Development (ABD) wherein various aspects were
explained to citizens in a simplified manner to enable them to
understand the concepts.
consultative process.
Their opinions were sought in the
That, the major issues brought out by
citizens after three consultative meetings through direct or indirect
participation pertained to water supply, street lights, inadequate
road infrastructure, lack of public transport, traffic congestion,
indifference
to
mobility
of
differently-abled
footpaths and pedestrian connection.
person,
lack
of
These issues are sought to
be addressed by the Mission Document of Smart City Gangtok.
The felling of trees at the Zero Point Junction, Development Area
Junction and High Court Junction fall in the allotment of the
proposed widening of the road and shifting of the footpath.
Thereafter, necessary steps have been taken for felling of the trees
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
in tandem with the Respondent No.2.
That, the project has
considered the aspect of sustainable development and the Detailed
Project Report has been prepared by the experts based on
sustainable
development
and
larger
compromising on environmental issues.
public
interest
without
Learned Counsel has
relied Narmada Bachao Andolan vs. Union of India and Others2; Balco
Employees’ Union (Regd.) vs. Union of India and Others
and Research
Foundation for Science Technology and Natural Resource Policy
vs.
Union of India and Others , in support of her submissions.
7.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Respondent
No.6
while
pointing out to its Report dated 18-08-2020, by and large
reiterated the arguments advanced by the Learned Counsel of the
Respondent No.2 and Respondent No.7 and had no specific
independent point to emphasis.
8.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent No.5 for his part
referred to Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and
the ratio of the Supreme Court in T. N. Godavarman Thirumulpad
(supra). That, the Supreme Court in Samatha vs. State of A.P. and
Others
had observed that a large wooded area having a thick
growth of trees and plants, the trees in such an area, resembling a
large wooded area, especially in density, was a forest. That, the
areas where the trees were felled and are to be felled, considering
the density of trees could well be considered forest areas. That, the
Government of Sikkim vide its letter dated 15-07-2020 informed
the Respondent No.5 that no permission was sought for felling of
trees from them as the status of land where the trees are felled, as
(2000) 10 SCC 664
(2002) 2 SCC 333
(2007) 15 SCC 193
(1997) 8 SCC 191
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
per cadastral records is a ―Government land‖ and not a ―Forest
land‖.
That, Article 48A of the Constitution of India however
mandates that it is the duty of the State to protect and improve
the environment and safeguard forest and wildlife which the State
Government ought to have given due consideration.
That, the
State Government is to comply with the doctrine of sustainable
development to maintain ecological balance as held by the Hon‘ble
Supreme Court in Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action vs. Union of
India and Others .
Learned Counsel also drew strength from the
ratiocinations in M. C. Mehta vs. Union of India7; N. D. Jayal and
Another vs. Union of India and Others ; State of NCT of Delhi and
Another
vs. Sanjeev alias Bitto9 and Lafarge Umiam Mining Private
Limited vs. Union of India and Others
9.
.
On 13-11-2020, Respondents No.1, 2 and 6 filed
written submissions on behalf of the Learned Advocate General to
bring on record certain materials that would be essential to
contextualise the present issues and its adjudication.
10.
An additional Report dated 14-09-2021 was filed by the
Respondents No.2 and 6 jointly placing on record certain pages
which were missing in the earlier Reports.
11.
On 22-09-2021 another Report was placed by the
Respondent No.7 to queries raised by this Court, vide its Order
dated 15-09-2021.
(1996) 5 SCC 281
(1996) 4 SCC 351
(2004) 9 SCC 362
(2005) 5 SCC 181
(2011) 7 SCC 338
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
12.
On 25-10-2021, the Respondent No.7 filed a Joint
Inspection Report carried out with the Respondent No.2 in
compliance to the Order of this Court dated 24-09-2021.
13.
On 17-11-2021 a Report on behalf of the Respondents
No.1, 2 and 6 was again filed informing that with regard to the
remaining 6 (six) Junctions that were identified for extension, the
Respondent
No.2
has
received
fresh
applications
from
the
Respondent No.7, dated 18-10-2021, for felling of trees in the
remaining 6 (six) Junctions which also includes the Development
Area Junction.
That, fresh trees proposed to be felled in these
Junctions are independent of the previously mentioned 121 (one
hundred and twenty one) trees. That, the applications have been
filed as per the Rules of 2006 and hence, the total number of trees
that are proposed to be felled have now added up to 163 (one
hundred and sixty three).
That, the applications are under
consideration of Respondent No.2 and the process under law will
be scrupulously followed after a decision is taken.
14.
Learned Counsel for the parties were heard at length
on 06-12-2021 and 07-12-2021.
The Learned Advocate General
who was representing the Respondents No.1, 2 and 6 remained
absent and the Learned Government Advocate made submissions
in his stead.
All the Reports filed by the parties have been duly
perused by us and due consideration afforded to the verbal
submissions.
15.
The core question for consideration is whether the
administrative decisions were tainted by illegality, irrationality or
procedural impropriety.
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
16(i).
Before dealing with the merits of the matter, it is
apposite to cite a Poem which poignantly comes to mind, On Killing
a Tree, by Gieve Patel.
The poem is relevantly reproduced
hereinbelow;
“On Killing a Tree
It takes much time to kill a tree,
Not a simple jab of the knife
Will do it. It has grown
Slowly consuming the earth,
Rising out of it, feeding
Upon its crust, absorbing
Years of sunlight, air, water,
And out of its leprous hide
Sprouting leaves.
So hack and chop
But this alone won't do it.
Not so much pain will do it.
The bleeding bark will heal
And from close to the ground
Will rise curled green twigs,
Miniature boughs
Which if unchecked will expand again
To former size
No,
The root is to be pulled out —
Out of the anchoring earth;
It is to be roped, tied,
And pulled out — snapped out
Or pulled out entirely,
Out from the earth-cave,
And the strength of the tree exposed
The source, white and wet,
The most sensitive, hidden
For years inside the earth.
Then the matter
Of scorching and choking
In sun and air,
Browning, hardening,
Twisting, withering,
And then it is done.
GIEVE PATEL”
(ii)
The theme of the poem is a confrontation between two
different attitudes, saving and cutting a tree. It is a tirade against
the practice of felling a tree. The poem describes the growth of a
tree, the years of consumption of the earth, absorption of sunlight,
air, water and nutrients from the soil to grow into a mature tree
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
and the pain on its destruction. The poem makes an implied plea
to maintain an ecological balance. The poem is extracted herein
merely to sensitize us into the effort that goes into growing one
tree. We may also look at a poem by Maya Angelou ―When Great
Trees Fall‖ which is rich in its ecological perspective, as also
―Planting a Tree‖ by Joyce Kilmer which praises the planter, these
are not being extracted herein to prevent prolixity.
It is the
visionary planters and foresters of the erstwhile Kingdom of Sikkim
who had planted these trees which have been ruthlessly felled,
these trees had stoically assisted the ecological balance thus far
and stood witness to history unfolding in this State. It is indeed
the bounden duty of every citizen to be sensitised about such
matters and to ensure that each of us play an active role in
ensuring the protection of a tree and to fell it only when no other
option remains.
Every effort should be made to construct
alongside the tree or around it and to prioritise saving it.
17.
The specific argument of the Respondent No.2 has
been that the areas where the trees are felled is not ‗Forest‘ as
defined by the Supreme Court in T. N. Godavarman Thirumulpad
(supra) indeed this may be true, but due attention must be paid to
the fact that deforestation is an environmental issue and the
continuous felling of trees illicit or otherwise has impacted the
environment worldwide in terms of water cycle, soil quality,
biodiversity and other environmental issues. The value of a forest,
nay, a single tree and its utility cannot be over-emphasized.
18(i).
Coming to the case at hand, specific procedure has
been laid down for felling of trees under the Rules of 2006 while in
the Sikkim Forests, Water Courses and Road Reserve Preservation
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
and Protection Act, 1988, ‗forest‘ and ―forest land‖ are defined
under Sections 2(b) and 2(c) respectively, which are as follows;
“(b) ―forest‖ means an extensive tract of land
covered with trees and undergrowth, sometime
intermingled with pastures, alpine scrubs;
(c)
(ii)
―forest land‖ means the land shown as forest
land in the records of right including areas
under perpetual snow, alpine scrubs or alpine
pasture or the land declared as forest land by
the Government, by notification;”
The areas where the trees were felled or proposed to
be felled are not an exclusive tract of ―forest land‖ nor reflected as
‗forest‘ in the Revenue Records or notified by the Government as
such. It also does not fall within the specifics of any of the criteria
laid down in the definition of the Sikkim Forests, Water Courses
and Road Reserve Preservation and Protection Act, 1988. Hence,
we are satisfied that the areas in which the trees have already
been felled or are proposed to be felled do not fall under the
definition of ‗Forest‘. Nevertheless, it must be borne in mind that
such a circumstance does not license anyone to carry out
haphazard deforestation. That having been said, the Rules of 2006
is to be invoked whenever trees are felled in non-forest land. The
documents on record establish that Rules 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the
2006 Rules although not complied with to the letter, have been
adequately complied with by the Respondent No.2. Annexure R-2
(collectively), a letter addressed to the Respondent No.2 by the
Respondent No.7, filed by the Respondent No.2 along with the
Affidavit dated 27-06-2020, also indicates satisfactory compliance.
19.
Admittedly, the Rules of 2006 do not provide for any
process or procedure for Auction of the trees felled.
However,
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
precedence for such Auction was followed by the Respondent No.2
inasmuch as it is stated that–
A Forest Officer not below the rank of Range Officer
determines the offset value of the standing trees as per
notified
volume
table
and
the
notified
rate
of
timber/firewood.
After determination of the offset price, the Forest
Officer issues notice for open public Auction and
publishes it in the notice board of the Range Office,
Division Office or in the Office of the Assistant
Conservator of Forest or any other place as he deems
fit mentioning the date and time of Auction and details
of crop.
People interested in taking part in the Auction may
inspect standing trees and ensure their satisfaction.
Thereafter, open bidding is carried out on the day and
time as per Auction Notice. At least 3 (three) bidders
must be present for the Auction to be conducted. If 3
(three) bidders do not turn up, the Auction is cancelled
and a new date for the Auction is published.
If there are 3 (three) or more bidders, the bidding is
carried out for different rounds and the highest bidder
is considered.
All the bidders shall sign the bid paper along with the
Auction conducting Officer (generally Range Officer).
The highest bidder shall deposit the bid amount in the
dedicated head on accounts of the Government and
take possession of the trees.
Apart from the bid amount, the bidder will have to
deposit 18% GST.
The felling cost or transportation cost shall be entirely
borne by the bidder.
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
20.
Although the documents on record indicate issuance of
Notice of Auction and steps taken pursuant thereto in terms of
what has been extracted hereinabove, however, we are dissatisfied
with the issuance of the Auction Notice being put up only in the
Notice Board of the Respondent No.2. Forest wealth belongs not
only to the Department and the few persons who may have to
access to such Notice, on them visiting the Forest Department, but
should be widely advertised to ensure that the best value is
obtained for the felled tree(s) and not reserved for a favoured few.
21.
That
having
been
said,
from
a
perusal
of
the
documents relied on by the Respondent No.7, we are satisfied that
the necessary consultative process was carried out by the
Government with all stakeholders including the public at large.
22.
It is relevant to reiterate that development must go
hand in hand with the preservation of the forests. In other words,
there must be sustainable development. Vide Order of this Court
dated 29-06-2020, we have already reflected that we deem it
imperative to record that sustainable development is development
that
meets
the
needs
of
the
present
generation
without
compromising on the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs (see Brundtland Report). It also encompasses social
and economic progress along with climate protection.
It may
relevantly be noticed that the Learned Central Government Counsel
while placing reliance on the decisions of the Hon‘ble Supreme
Court in T. N. Godavarman Thirumulkpad (supra); Samatha (supra),
Lafarge Umiam Mining Private Limited (supra),
had submitted that in
view of the definition of ‗Forest‘ given in the ratiocinations supra
and considering that the areas where the trees were felled fall
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
within the ambit of such definition, the State Government had
necessarily to obtain clearance from the Ministry of Environment,
Forest and Climate Change, Government of India, in terms of
Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980. That, this was
bypassed by the State Government.
In the first instance, it is
worth-recording that the Respondent No.5 chose to turn a Nelson‘s
eye on the felling of the trees when it was going on and
subsequently woke up from its slumber only on being impleaded as
a party vide Order of this Court dated 23-06-2020. That apart, the
submissions hold no water in view of the discussions pertaining to
Forest as already elucidated hereinabove.
23.
Be that as it may, we may relevantly notice that the
Supreme Court while elucidating the concept of sustainable
development which all States should endeavour to adhere to as an
integral part of ‗life‘ under Article 21 of the Constitution of India,
in N. D. Jayal (supra) observed as follows;
“22. Before adverting to other issues, certain
aspects pertaining to the preservation of ecology and
development have to be noticed. In Vellore Citizens'
Welfare Forum v. Union of India [(1996) 5 SCC 647] and
in M.C. Mehta v. Union of India [(2002) 4 SCC 356] it was
observed that the balance between environmental
protection and developmental activities could only be
maintained
by strictly following the principle of
“sustainable development”. This is a development
strategy that caters to the needs of the present
without
negotiating
the
ability
of
upcoming
generations to satisfy their needs. The strict observance
of sustainable development will put us on a path that
ensures development while protecting the environment, a
path that works for all peoples and for all generations. It is
a guarantee to the present and a bequeath to the future.
All environment-related developmental activities should
benefit more people while maintaining the environmental
balance. This could be ensured only by strict
adherence to sustainable development without which
life of the coming generations will be in jeopardy.
23.
…………………………………………………
24.
…………………………………………………
25.
Therefore,
principle
development
the adherence to sustainable
is
a sine
qua
non for
the
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
maintenance of the symbiotic balance between the rights
to environment and development. Right to environment is
a fundamental right. On the other hand, right to
development is also one. Here the right to “sustainable
development” cannot be singled out. Therefore, the
concept of ―sustainable development‖ is to be treated
as an integral part of ―life‖ under Article 21.
……………………………..”
[emphasis supplied]
24.
Compensatory Plantation is the next point that needs
to be addressed.
On this count, it is necessary to refer to the
letter dated 12-10-2021 addressed to the Divisional Forest Officer,
Territorial (East) of the Respondent No.2, by the Chief Executive
Officer of the Respondent No.7 (Annexure R-1, Page 1170, Paper
Book IV) wherein the Respondent No.2 has been informed that 76
(seventy six) number of trees and 34 (thirty four) numbers of Poles
have already been felled although request had been made for
felling of 121 (one hundred and twenty one) number of trees and
(sixty
four)
numbers
of
poles
at
Zero
Point
Junction,
Development Area Junction and High Court Junction. That, there is
no further requirement for felling of trees at these Junctions as the
improvement of the Junctions were re-designed so as to minimize
the felling of trees during the construction phase. We cannot but
applaud this step taken by the Respondent No.7.
At the same
time, it is worth remarking that we are appalled by the proposal of
Compensatory Plantation placed before us in the Affidavit dated
15-07-2020 of the Respondent No.2 wherein a proposal is placed
for replacing the trees felled with bushes and shrubs.
This does
not tantamount to Compensatory Plantation but is eyewash. The
Respondent No.2 necessarily ought to replace the felled trees by
planting trees of equivalent value and other relevant ecological
factors.
Surely a felled tree cannot be replaced by shrubs or
bushes, it has to be replaced by a tree.
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
25.
That apart, this Court is indeed conscious and aware of
the scope of judicial review without being reminded by the
Respondent No.2 and Respondent No.7, in their averments of the
ambit of judicial review. At the same time, it is worth-reminding
all concerned that the Court has a duty to see that in the
undertaking of a policy decision no law is violated and the
fundamental rights of the public are not transgressed upon except
to the extent permissible under the Constitution of India.
This
obviously is the only area in which this Court is examining the
instant Writ Petition.
26.
From the discussions hereinabove as already noticed
there is no specific written policy for Auction of felled trees which
ought to include Notice to the general public published in a daily
newspaper, both in English and in the Nepali vernacular, for at
least 3 (three) consecutive days.
Let the Forest Department,
Respondent No.2,
(i)
immediately
develop policy guidelines which shall
govern decision making with respect to the Auction of
felled trees.
This shall not be later than 3 (three)
months from today.
(ii)
Eco-sensitive areas shall be given due consideration
when felling of trees are unavoidable, imperative and
are proposed.
(iii)
No tree or pole shall be unnecessarily felled for the
personal enrichment of any person.
(iv)
Need based felling of identified trees in the 6 (six)
remaining Junctions under the Gangtok Smart City
Project may be carried out subject to strict and
meticulous compliance of the relevant Rules.
Due
application of mind by the concerned Officers indicating
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
compliance to the letter of the Rules by the concerned
Officers must be reflected in their notes and orders.
(v)
Once the trees have been felled in the 9 (nine)
Junctions, so far as safety allows there shall be avenue
plantation of trees. In the event of impossibility of tree
plantation
in
any
area,
keeping
in
mind
the
geographical terrain, then shrubs are necessarily to be
planted.
(vi)
The construction of the footpaths shall be made around
the trees wherever possible duly bearing in mind the
decision of the Hon‘ble Supreme Court in Rajive Raturi
vs.
Union
of
India
and
Others
and
taking
into
consideration the movement of physically challenged
persons in Wheelchairs and of the visually challenged,
on the footpaths.
(vii) Afforestation in these areas shall be carried out as
undertaken immediately on completion of the civil
works in the Gangtok Smart City Project, viz., in Zero
Point Junction, Development Area Junction and High
Court Junction.
(viii) The Respondent No.2 in its Report dated 22-06-2020
has stated that a plan with detailed estimates for
Compensatory Afforestation has been prepared and the
location for Compensatory Plantation identified.
locations have not been disclosed.
The
The Respondent
No.2 shall disclose the location to the Petitioner and the
Learned Amicus Curiae within a month from today and
carry out Compensatory Plantation within a period of 1
(one) year from today.
(ix)
Wherever
trees
have
been
felled
Compensatory
Plantation shall be done by planting of trees, viz.; Rani
Champ
(Michelia
populnea),
Buk
excelsa),
(Quercus
Pipli
(Symingtonia
lamellosa),
Badrasay
(Elaeocarpus sikkimensis), Tooni (Toona ciliata), Pumsi
(2018) 2 SCC 413
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
(Machilus edulis), Arupatay (Prunus nepalensis), Kawlo
(Machilus spp.) and Katus (Castonopsis spp.) [these
trees are reflected in the Report of the Respondent
No.2].
(x)
A Committee comprising of 3 (three) senior department
Officers of the rank of Conservator of Forest and above
shall
overlook
the
Project
of
Compensatory
Afforestation. The composition of the Committee shall
be informed to the Petitioner and the Learned Amicus
Curiae within a month from today.
The Committee
shall ensure that every tree felled is compensated by
10 (ten) saplings as undertaken by the Respondent
No.2.
(xi)
We make it clear that should the Compensatory replantation not be completed within the period specified
above, the Petitioner is at liberty to approach this
Court.
(xii) Strict compliance be made by all the Respondents to
the observations of the Supreme Court in M. C. Mehta
vs. Union of India and Others12, in that, the balance
between environmental protection and developmental
activities could only be maintained by strictly following
the principle of ―sustainable development‖. The strict
observance of sustainable development will put us on a
path that ensures development while protecting the
environment, a path that works for all peoples and for
all generations. It is a guarantee to the present and a
bequeath
to
the
future.
All
environment-related
developmental activities should benefit more people
while maintaining the environmental balance.
27.
The stay ordered by this Court vide Order dated 29-06-
2020 wherein the State Government was directed not to fell any
further
trees
(2002) 4 SCC 356
whatsoever,
either
in
Zero
Point
Junction,
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2020
In Re : Recent Felling of Trees in Gangtok
Development Area Junction or High Court Junction or in the
remaining 6 (six) venues as listed in Report dated 27-06-2020 of
the Respondent No.2 and also Order dated 17-07-2020 by
inserting the words ―till further orders of this Court‖, stand vacated
with the hope and trust that all concerned Authorities shall stay
their hands from unnecessary felling of trees under the Smart City
Project.
28.
With these directions, the Writ Petition is disposed of.
Interim Application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
10-01-2022
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
10-01-2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review