The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. In view of the aforesaid circumstances, we are of the considered opinion that necessary directions given by this Court pertaining to relief and rehabilitation measures of affected people of the landslide area including construction of Bridges have been complied with. WP (PIL) No.05 of 2016 In Re : Debacle in Upper Dzongu
12. Nothing further remains for adjudication and hence, the matter stands disposed of with liberty granted to the Learned Amici Curiae to approach this Court, if and when the need so arises. Sd/( Satish K. Agnihotri ) Chief Justice 27-06-2018 Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai ) Judge 27-06-2018 Approved for reporting : No Internet : Yes ds
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 27th June, 2018
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DIVISION BENCH : THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CHIEF JUSTICE
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(PIL) No.05 of 2016
In Re : Debacle in Upper Dzongu
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamannna Chhetri and Ms. Mali
Sharma and Mr. Suraj Chhetri, Advocates as Amici Curiae.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate with Mr. Thinlay
Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate, Mr. S. K. Chettri and Mrs.
Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocates for the State.
Dr. (Mrs.) Doma T. Bhutia, Advocate as Intervenors.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
S. K. Agnihotri, CJ
1.
On 13-08-2018, at around 01.30 p.m., a landslide of
colossal proportions occurred at Upper Dzongu, North Sikkim,
leading to the creation of a natural dam in the Kanaka river, thereby
blocking its natural flow. One village came to be submerged while
several wards were marooned.
In the light of the said situation this
Court took up the matter suo motu on 17-08-2016 with the
observation that the judiciary is under an obligation to extend social
justice to the people of the area.
Public Interest Litigation (PIL).
The matter was registered as a
WP (PIL) No.05 of 2016
In Re : Debacle in Upper Dzongu
Notice was issued to the Chief Secretary, Government of
2.
Sikkim and the District Collector, North Sikkim, to submit a status
report indicating steps taken by them for relief and rehabilitation in
extending
necessary
help
to
affected
people
of
that
area.
Necessary status reports came to be filed by the Chief Secretary
while Learned Amicus Curiae put forth suggestions with regard to
provisions for immediate coordinated action for rescue, relief and
rehabilitation, installation of telephone booths at appropriate places
for regular communication, provision for medical facilities and
gratuitous relief for all the concerned persons where the calamity
had befallen. Learned Amicus Curiae also suggested that in view of
the damage caused to the Passingdong Senior Secondary School by
the landslide, a provision be made to re-start the school at an
appropriate place so that the children of the locality who are already
admitted in the school do not suffer or their academic session go to
waste.
That a long term solution be found for access to the area
particularly access to the other side of the dam.
3.
The Secretary-cum-State Relief Commissioner, Land
Revenue & Disaster Management Department (LR&DM Department),
Government
of
Sikkim,
reported
verbally
in
the
Court
that
immediate steps were taken to provide shelter, food and medicines
to the affected inhabitants of the area.
A part of the land in
question has been acquired by the Government and the owners of
the houses thereon have been allotted plots and houses elsewhere
while temporary shelter homes have also been provided by the
WP (PIL) No.05 of 2016
In Re : Debacle in Upper Dzongu
Government which has taken a decision to provide permanent
shelters.
4.
Subsequent reports which followed, inter alia, detailed
that the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA), National
Hydroelectric Power Corporation Limited (NHPC), Central Water
Commission (CWC), Department of Mines, Menerals and Geology,
Government of Sikkim, Ex-Chief Geologist, NHPC, all expert bodies,
had unanimously recommended emptying the lake at the earliest.
This Court in terms of the said recommendations of the expert
bodies directed the Government authorities to take remedial
measure to ensure that nothing untoward occurs and to ensure that
the people living in Dikchu and other towns downstream were
informed in advance of any lurking danger.
5.
In response thereto, by an Affidavit dated 08-10-2016,
the Chief Secretary stated that the public of the area had raised a
demand to retain the lake and the Government had decided to
observe the situation for some more time and take necessary steps
in accordance with the recommendations of the expert bodies.
It is
was informed that several precautionary measures have been taken,
viz., by regularly monitoring the water level at the river Kanaka on
an hourly basis at two locations downstream of the lake. An alarm
system had been installed by the NHPC Stage V authorities at
Phidang, upstream to Dikchu in order to alert the public in advance
in case of likelihood of breach of dam.
All the downstream Police
Outposts had been alerted and sensitized about the situation as also
the Panchayat and public residing downstream. That as and when
WP (PIL) No.05 of 2016
In Re : Debacle in Upper Dzongu
the dam was to be breached all safety recommendations contained
in the various reports including that of NDMA would be complied
with.
The State Government was granted time to examine the
recommendations made by the expert organisation and take into
consideration the impending danger if the lake was not emptied at
the earliest.
6.
The Government thereafter constituted a Committee
comprising of Senior Officers of the Government up to the level of
the Additional Chief Secretary and five other Officers of the rank of
Secretary to consider remedial measures.
This Court directed the
Committee to examine all the difficulties faced by the people living
in and around the
areas. Pursuant thereon, the Committee
constituted a Task Force comprising of eight Government Officials of
various ranks which would be responsible for execution of the Action
Plan under the supervision of the Committee. The Task Force was
constituted vide Notification No.01/Home/2017 dated 24-01-2017
and was handed over the responsibility of preparation of an Action
Plan for carrying out controlled breaching of the dam at the earliest
along with associated activities and appropriate mitigation measures
as well as execution of the Action Plan under its supervision. The
State Government also submitted a report with regard to allotment
of residential accommodation to persons who had lost their houses,
while some persons whose houses were destroyed in the landslip
were already allotted houses, while others had been provided with a
house in the past under the Government Housing Schemes. So far
as the setting up of the destroyed Primary School was concerned,
WP (PIL) No.05 of 2016
In Re : Debacle in Upper Dzongu
steps were initiated for identifying land for construction of the new
building. The road network and restoration of connectivity was also
progressing.
7.
Compensation handed over to the victims was detailed
in the Affidavit dated 04-10-2016 which included compensation from
the National Disaster Relief Fund (NDRF) and the Chief Minister’s
Relief Fund (CMRF). For the time being the school was being run in
a three room ‘pucca’ structure and land was being identified by the
District Collectorate, North Sikkim for allocation to the Human
Resource Development Department (RMDD), Government of Sikkim,
for the purposes of building a school.
8.
In the interim an Application being I.A. No.01 of 2017
was filed by Panchayat of Upper Dzongu level representing the
people therefrom, seeking a direction to preserve the lake formed
due to the landslide or in the alternative to complete the
construction of the road from Mantam to Kayem and also to
construct a Bridge from Kayem to Sebem before breaching the dam.
9.
Over the months, the Task Force undertook the task of
controlled blasting for draining the artificial lake.
So far as the
construction of Bridge is concerned, the LR&DM Department
undertook to furnish technical details about the possibility of
constructing a Suspension Bridge to accommodate one vehicle in
place of the Foot Bridge which was proposed then. It was brought
to the notice of this Court that the Government had taken a decision
to establish a two lane permanent RCC Bridge connecting the people
WP (PIL) No.05 of 2016
In Re : Debacle in Upper Dzongu
living on
the
other
Rs.49,05,75,000/-
side
(Rupees
of the
lake
forty-nine
for
crores,
which a sum of
five
lakhs
seventy-five thousand) only, have been sanctioned.
and
In the
meanwhile, a Suspension Foot Bridge would be installed to facilitate
the movement of goods and basic necessities to people who
stranded on the other side of the lake.
On 25-04-2018 the State
Government in its Affidavit submitted that the Suspension Foot
Bridge would be completed by the end of May, 2018, while financial
bid was being examined for the two lane RCC Bridge, the technical
evaluation being completed.
10.
Today, it is submitted before this Court that the
Suspension Foot Bridge is now complete and is being used by people
for their daily thoroughfare, installation of wire mesh on the
sideways of the Bridge would be completed in two weeks. That,
tender process for construction of two lane RCC Bridge is completed
and the process of award of work is underway.
The Amici Curiae
submit that total completion of the Suspension Bridge including
painting would take about one month, however, he concedes that
presently the Bridge is ready for use.
11.
In view of the aforesaid circumstances, we are of the
considered opinion that necessary directions given by this Court
pertaining to relief and rehabilitation measures of affected people of
the landslide area including construction of Bridges have been
complied with.
WP (PIL) No.05 of 2016
In Re : Debacle in Upper Dzongu
12.
Nothing further remains for adjudication and hence, the
matter stands disposed of with liberty granted to the Learned Amici
Curiae to approach this Court, if and when the need so arises.
Sd/( Satish K. Agnihotri )
Chief Justice
27-06-2018
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
27-06-2018
Approved for reporting : No
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review