Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In Re: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
Vs.
1.
State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
The Secretary,
Department of Animal Husbandry Livestock,
Fisheries & Veterinary Services,
Government of Sikkim,
Krishi Bhawan, Tadong, East Sikkim.
3.
The District Magistrate,
District Administrative Centre,
Government of Sikkim,
Mangan, North Sikkim.
4.
The Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
District Administrative Centre,
Government of Sikkim,
Chungthang, North Sikkim.
...
RESPONDENTS.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, J.
Mr. Jorgay Namka and Ms. Tashi Doma Sherpa,
Advocates as Amici Curiae.
For the respondents :
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Additional Advocate General,
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate,
Mr. Thupden Youngda, Government Advocate,
Mr. S. K. Chettri, Assistant Government Advocate,
Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
13-11-2019.
Date of judgment
:
26-11-2019.
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
JUDGMENT
Arup Kumar Goswami, CJ.
The 12th May, 2019 publications of The Hindu, Himalayan
Mirror, Sikkim Express, हा्ो ्ቚजाशक्ति (Humro Prajashakti), Summit
Times and The Telegraph, all daily newspapers, reported death of around
300 yaks due to starvation. It is necessary, at the very outset, to take note
of the headlines:
Summit Times - “Around 300 yaks starve to death in North
Sikkim”
Himalayan Mirror – “300 yaks starve to death in North
Sikkim”
Sikkim Express – “Unrelenting snowfall trap yaks since
December, scores found starved to death in North Sikkim”
The Telegraph - “300 STARVE TO DEATH IN SIKKIM
SINCE DECEMBER.
Melting snow bares yak tragedy”
Humro Prajashakti – “भारर हहमपािको कारण ऱगभग िीन सय
चौंरीको मत्ृ यु”
(rough translated version)
Death of about 300 yaks because of heavy snowfall”
The Hindu – “300 Himalayan yaks starve to death in Sikkim”
2.
The headlines noted above eloquently and poignantly
encapsulated the enormity of the event due to which this Court
considered it appropriate to take up the issue suo-moto on the judicial side
and accordingly, this instant Public Interest Litigation (PIL) was
registered on 10.06.2019.
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
3.
Mr. Jorgay Namka and Ms. Tashi Doma Sherpa, learned
counsel practising in this Court, were requested to be Amici Curiae and
they had readily consented to contribute to the proceedings. They have
filed a report dated 19.10.2019 and also placed suggestions in the form of
an affidavit dated 04.11.2019.
4.
From the materials on record it is noticed that yak is a large
member of the cattle family.
They thrive at higher altitude and in cold
weather and are prone to suffer from heat exhaustion above 15°C (59°F)
as they have a thick layer of subcutaneous fat and as functional sweat
glands are almost absent. Yaks consume the equivalent of 1% of its body
weight daily and it crunches on ice or snow as a source of water. Lack of
winter feed leads to heavy weight loss to the extent of 25% to 30% overall
during that period, requiring recovery and weight gain during the
summer months. According to the report of the Amici Curiae, yak
population in the Indian Himalayan region, which is on the decline, is
estimated to be over 76,000 and yak rearing states of India are Arunachal
Pradesh, Sikkim, Uttar Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh and Union Territory
of Jammu & Kashmir. Yaks can survive up to minus 40°C (- 40°C). Yak
rearing is an eco-friendly livelihood for nomads who migrate to higher
altitude during summer and return to lower altitude of about 3000 meters
above mean sea level during winter. In Sikkim, yaks are now found only
in Lachen and Lachung regions of North Sikkim, under two types of
transhumance migration pattern. Yaks in Lachen region are generally of
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
Tibetan yak variety which normally stays away from human settlement
and they move higher up towards colder region as winter sets in. There
are about 7 to 9 families of herders each having about 100 to 150 yaks.
The base of the herders of Lachen region is stated to be Thangu and while
some of them move towards Muguthang region, some move towards
Gurudongmar/Tso Lhamo region. LHO yak is predominantly found in
Lachung region and they remain in contact with human settlement and it
moves down from colder region during winter towards its base at
Yakshey and Domang. There are about 8 to 10 families of herders each
having 80 to 100 yaks of LHO yak variety.
5.
Though the report of the Amici Curiae deals with certain
other aspects like breeding, diseases and socio-economic causes for
decline of yak population, having regard to the issue for which this PIL
was registered, we are not dealing with those aspects of the matter in the
present PIL. It is, however, noted that in the report dated 19.10.2019, the
learned Amici Curiae mentioned that local population of North Sikkim
depend to a huge extent on Army personnel stationed at different regions
of North Sikkim and that the State Government should be in touch with
the Army so that they can assist the local people and the administration
in times of need.
6.
In the report filed on 06.07.2019 by the Principal Director,
Department of Department of Animal Husbandry Livestock, Fisheries &
Veterinary Services (for short, A.H.L.F.&V.S.), Government of Sikkim, it
is stated that in the month of February, 2019, verbal report of prolonged
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
and heavy snowfall was received from the local Pipon and herders who
were residing in the valley of Lachung, Lachen, Muguthang and Phalung.
Arrangements were made for averting feed and fodder shortage by
distributing feed to the yak herders. Relief items consisting of chaffed
hay/kutti and crushed maize/bhus were distributed to yak herders of
Lachen and Lachung in the first week of March.
However, road
transportation to Muguthang was cut-off due to a thick blanket of snow,
as a result of which, relief materials could not be delivered to the yak
herders in those areas. The areas near about Muguthang and Lashyar
Valley could be accessed only in the first week of May, 2019 and then
only, the loss of yak lives came to light. The information was shared with
the District Collector, North. Veterinary Officers and Paravets along with
officials from B.A.C., Chungthang were deputed to provide necessary
relief and treatment to the surviving weak and ailing animals and also to
ascertain the actual loss. Annexure-R1 to the said report goes to show
that a note was prepared by the Additional Director (North), Department
of A.H.L.F.&V.S., indicating that local Pipons had reported, which was
confirmed from the sub-divisional level officers and area field
functionaries, that the nomadic herders as well as their animals were
passing through a very stressful climatic condition without adequate feed
and fodder, leaving both the livestock and the herders at the mercy of
nature and that some young calves and few ailing animals had died due
to starvation. The note proceeds to say that timely and requisite relief
items in the form of feed, fodder and other essential items are to be
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
provided to the herders to see them through the crisis. It is also seen that
by a letter dated 23.02.2019 issued by the District Collector, North to the
Commanding Officer, 13 Battalion, ITBP, Lingdong, request was made
for supply of 50 bags of Atta and 50 bags of Mustard oil cake to the yak
herders. It was indicated in the said letter that it was reported to him that
there had been unprecedented snowfall in the higher regions of North
Sikkim and due to such heavy snowfall, the yak herders were unable to
find fodder and grass for their yaks and as snowfall had been continuing
for more than a month, lack of fodder had led to high mortality among
the yaks. It was also indicated in the said letter that though fodder was
procured by District Administration, as the road transportation had been
cut-off due to the blanket of snow, the same could not be delivered to the
yak herders. It is also indicated that one Sita Ram would be in touch with
the Army stationed at Muguthang.
7.
A report, which is not dated but which covers a period from
January to April, 2019, prepared by the Additional Director (North),
A.H.L.F&V.S. Department, was also enclosed wherein it is stated that
there was a blanket cover of over 4 feet or 5 feet height of snow all over
the available pasture lands and most of the herders decided to abandon
their herd and they proceeded to the permanent habitats for safety,
fearing depletion of their winter stock of ration, as a result of which the
yaks were exposed to the wrath of nature. However, 5 members of
nomadic herders stayed back despite inclement weather and they were
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
able to provide some care and assistance to the yaks with the aid of the
Indian Army and I.T.B.P. personnel stationed in that area. As a result,
lives of about 800 numbers of yaks had been saved. It is also stated in the
said report that the team of Animal Husbandry Department could gain
access to the area in the first week of May, 2019 and the report published
in the social media, etc. regarding the death of yaks was based on the
WhatsApp
message
forwarded
by
Additional
A.H.L.F&V.S. Department to the District Collector.
Director
(North),
The report dated
06.07.2019 also discloses that a total of 51 households had been affected
and ex-gratia of Rs.45.90 lakh was payable to the affected households.
8.
It is seen from Annexure-R1 to the affidavit dated 16.08.2019
that construction of ITBP road from Lugnak-La to Muguthang was
awarded to the successful tenderer at an amount of Rs.48,0037,185.24
(Rupees Forty Eight crore Thirty Seven thousand One hundred Eight Five
and Paise Two Four) only by an order dated 07.06.2018 and the time of
completion of 24 (Twenty Four) months would be reckoned from 22nd
day from 07.06.2018. From the Annexure-R2 letter dated 10.11.2016 to the
said affidavit, it is seen that notice to proceed with the work was issued to
a Government Contractor for execution of work “RCR from NSH to Yak
farm Denga and 2 other works Package 8/Phase XI in North Sikkim,
amounting to Rs.1,175.93 lakh by Rural Management & Development
Department, Government of Sikkim. Materials on record, however, do
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
not indicate if there is any progress in the construction of the roads, in
question.
9.
By an order dated 18.09.2019, this Court had directed the State-
respondents to inform the Court, by way of a report, the budget set aside
for the welfare of the yaks and the steps taken by the Department for the
yaks for the ensuing winter season.
This Court also directed the
Department to acquire readymade feed from the Indian Council of
Agriculture Research (ICAR) - a National Research Centre (NRC) on Yak,
Dirang, Arunachal Pradesh and to make available the same to all yak
owners and herders. In view of it, a report dated 30.09.2019 was filed
before this Court on 01.10.2019. However, this Court by an order dated
04.10.2019, observed that the report was grossly inadequate, and
accordingly, the Government was directed to submit a detailed report as
to how the yaks are going to be fed and sheltered during the winter and
how medical assistance would be given to protect and prevent repetition
of the tragedy of the death of 300 yaks last winter. This Court also noted
that the breed of the yak and other considerations, which had been
highlighted in the report, are irrelevant for the purpose in hand.
10.
In the affidavit dated 01.10.2019 filed by the Chief Secretary
to the Government of Sikkim, it is stated that an amount of Rs.26,09,000/(Rupees Twenty Six lakh and Nine thousand) only had been kept aside in
the financial year 2019-2020 for the welfare of yaks and that the said fund
would be utilised for purchase of feed and fodder (complete feed block)
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
and also for purchase of ambulance, medicines & equipment,
procurement of tents & other contingency expenditure. As an interim
relief, a fund to the tune of Rs.18,10,000/- (Rupees Eighteen lakh and Ten
thousand) only has been arranged, out of which Rs.9,20,000/- (Rupees
Nine lakh and Twenty thousand) only is to be used for purchase of
complete feed block for 20 MT and a sum of Rs.8,89,000/- (Rupees Eight
lakh and Eighty Nine thousand) only is to be used for purchase of an
ambulance. It is stated that the Planning and Development Department
has committed to provide fund in the supplementary budget. Dealing
with the steps taken by the Department for yaks for the ensuing winter
season, it is stated that the Department of A.H.L.F&V.S., Government of
Sikkim had organised an interactive meeting on 20.09.2019 with the
concerned stakeholders, primarily, the yak herders, yak owners and
Pipon of Lachen Dzumsa wherein they had been requested to make
optimum use of the available infrastructures like Hay Godown and Yak
Shelter. It is stated that 10 nos. of Hay Godown-cum-Yak Shelters at
Lachung, Talam-Lachen, Denga-Lachen, Lachen, Samdong-Lachen,
Rabum-Lachen, Yakthang-Lachen, Tsangtha-Lachen, Zeema BustyLachen and ongoing work at Byamzi-Lachen had been constructed and
two Yak centres at Chopta and Zema in Lachen have also been
established under the yak conservation programme. The ICAR – NRC on
Yak, Dirang, Arunachal Pradesh, in collaboration with Department of
A.H.L.F&V.S., Government of Sikkim on 27.09.2019 had distributed
concentrated yak feed, complete feed block, chelated mineral mixture,
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
etc. to the yak herders. The ICAR was also requested to supply 20 MT
ready-made complete feed blocks in order to mitigate the feed and fodder
scarcity for the coming winter months and for this purpose budget
provision has been kept.
The Department of A.H.L.F&V.S., Government
of Sikkim in collaboration with International Centre for Integrated
Mountain Development and ICAR – NRC on Yak, Dirang, Arunachal
Pradesh had undertaken periodical exposure tour of yak herders and
they had been taken to Dirang - Arunachal Pradesh, Nepal, Bhutan and
China to make them aware of scientific methods and good practices of
yak rearing, management, feeding methods, prevention and treatment of
diseases. While the construction of permanent shelters for the population
of yaks was not considered to be practical and feasible, it is stated that for
care and management of weak, pregnant, mulching and young yaks, the
herders built semi-confined areas (Kraal) along their migration routes. It
is further stated that having regard to large number of death of yaks that
had occurred in the winter of this year, the Department was exploring the
possibilities of constructing paddock and providing other essential items,
such as tents, etc. Annexure-R1 of the said affidavit goes to show that the
Managing Director, Sikkim Motors was requested to arrange to supply
one number of Bolero Camper PS 4 WD for use as ambulance for welfare
of yaks in North Sikkim by the Director (Piggery & Yak Development),
Department of A.H.L.F&V.S., Government of Sikkim by letter dated
28.09.2019.
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
11.
The Minutes of the Meeting with the local residents of
Lachen and yak herders of Lachen on 20.09.2019 goes to show that fodder
could not be carried to the pasture area where yaks were stranded during
heavy snowfall.
The yaks (Tibetan variety) were taken upwards
anticipating that snowfall would be as usual each and every year, which
was not so and because of such heavy snowfall, ground was not exposed
for yaks to graze, as a result of which the animals had died of starvation.
12.
In the affidavit filed by the Chief Secretary on behalf of the
respondent no. 1, the State of Sikkim, dated 19.10.2019, which was filed
pursuant to the direction of this Court dated 04.10.2019, it is stated that as
per latest survey and enumeration conducted by the A.H.L.F.&V.S.,
Government of Sikkim in the second week of October, 2019, there are 79
yak herding households under North District with a total yak population
of 3230 numbers of which 1184 are male, 1585 are female and 461 are
young calves. It is also indicated in Annexure-R2 of the said affidavit
that there are six yak rearing zones in North Sikkim, which are (1)Muguthang Valley (Lachen Dzumsa),(2) Lashyar
Dzumsa),
(3)Yumthang
/Yumesamdong
Valley
(Lachung
(Lachen
Dzumsa),(4)
Sebu/Domang (Lachung Dzumsa),(5)Chyakhung (Naga Forest) and (6)
Tholung (Upper Dzongu).
The maximum numbers of yak herding
households are in Muguthang Valley with 48 nos., followed by Lashyar
Valley with 30 nos. of yak herding households. Migration pattern of yak
rearing in Muguthang Valley and Lashyar Valley is shown to be towards
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
higher altitude during winter.
zones
such
as
The migration of yaks in yak rearing
Yumthang/Yumesamdong
(Lachung
Dzumsa),
Sebu/Domang (Lachung Dzumsa), Chyakhung (Naga Forest) and
Tholung (Upper Dzongu) is towards lower altitude during winter. The
numbers of yak herding households in Yumthang/Yumesamdong
(Lachung Dzumsa), Sebu/Domang (Lachung Dzumsa), Chyakhung
(Naga Forest) and Tholung (Upper Dzongu) are 7, 8, 2 and 1 respectively.
It will be relevant to quote paragraphs 3, 5 and 6 of the said affidavit:
“3.
PROVISON OF FEED & FODDER DURING
THIS COMING WINTER MONTH:
i)
For feeding Yaks in a critical winter season,
adequate feed in terms of Complete Feed Block has been
arranged, already 9375 Kgs and 1000 Kgs of Chelated
Mineral mixture have already been distributed to the
Yak herders. There would be no dearth of feed to feed
yak in the event of the calamities.
Department have
made full preparation to meet the challenges in order to
prevent the repetition of tragedy.
ii)
The feed & fodder assistance package as aid from
the Government has been so planned, assuming the
ground reality that the package shall focus on the feed
requirement of the vulnerable animal
particular.
group, in
The stakeholders (Yak owners) have also
agreed to arrange for timely stock of local dry doffer and
feed as a participatory contribution from their end and
store them in the hay go-downs built by the Government
at different locations for community utility purpose. The
Department of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary
Services has already issued the supply order for 20 M.T
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
(Metric ton) of Complete Feed Blocks (CFB weighing 1.8
Kg each/block) to the National Research Center on Yaks,
ICAR, Dhirang-Arunachal Pradesh, which is likely to be
delivered by the 1st week of November 2019 in two
consignments. This consignment of CFB, along with the
herder‟s contribution of local feed & dry fodder and
buffer stock of recent distribution programme would
adequately suffice the much needed balanced and
subsistence diet.
iii)
Also, a buffer stock of feed & fodder procurement
fund will also be set aside under Natural Calamity fund
of D.C (North) as a contingency plan to ensure that such
unprecedented strategy as witnessed last winter, is not
repeated in future, duly honouring the directives of the
Hon‟ble High Court.
iv)
That during the last meeting held on 20/09/2019
with Lachen Pipon, Yak Owners and Yak herders, it was
expressed that traditionally the Yak owners and the Yak
herders conserve the fodder in the form of hay starting
from the month of November, which is primarily the
main source of diet during lean season apart from
grazing. It was also expressed by some herders that the
hay from the previous season is still in stock.
XXX
XXX
XXX
XXX
5.
CONSTRUCITON OF PERMANENT SHELTER
FOR YAK HERDERS & YAKS:
Majority of the Yak herders in North Sikkim do not
possess any plot of land registered against their name in
the highland Yak rearing areas and hence they have
since resided in the temporary stone walled dwellings,
guarding their flock of animals in the vicinity. However,
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
as submitted in our earlier affidavit, the department has
indeed made an earnest effort thus far, by constructing 7
Nos. of Hay storage go-downs at different locations
under Lachen & Lachung Dzumsa and 3 Nos. of Cold
community Yak shelter cum Feed & Fodder Storage Godowns
at
Lachen
Departmental
lands
&
Lachung
in
Community/
to
provide
shelter
to
the
milking/old/young calves and ailing animals mainly
during winter months. Nevertheless, the Government
shall explore all possible ways and means to address this
pertinent issue as desired by the Hon‟ble High Court of
Sikkim.
The detailed list of Cold community Yak shelter-cumFeed & Fodder Storage Go-downs at different locations
under Lachen & Lachung Dzumsa may kindly be seen
below:
Sl.
Type of
No. Infrastructure
1. Hay storage Godown
2. Hay storage Godown
3. Hay storage Godown
4. Hay storage Godown
5. Community Yak
shelter
6. Community Yak
shelter
7. Hay storage Godown
8. Hay storage Godown
9. Community Yak
shelter
10. Hay storage Godown
Location
No.
Rabum
Dengna
Temchi
Samdong
Talam
Byamzey
Thangu
Muguthang
Namdosa
Leema
Status of
Jurisdiction of
Land
Dzumsa
AH&VS
Lachen Dzumsa
Deptt.
Community Lachen Dzumsa
land
AH&VS
Lachen Dzumsa
Deptt.
Community Lachen Dzumsa
land
Community Lachen Dzumsa
land
Community Lachen Dzumsa
land
Community Lachen Dzumsa
land
Community Lachen Dzumsa
land
AH&VS
Lachung Dzumsa
Deptt.
Community Lachung Dzumsa
land
The photograph depicting the ongoing construction of
community yak shelter-cum-Feed & Fodder Storage
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
Infrastructure at Byamzey under Lachen Dzumsa, North
Sikkim is annexed and marked herewith as Annexure-R-2.
The Department of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary
Services has proposed to construct inter-connected
animal grazing paddocks built in M.S pipes with R.C.C
supported posts in between with M.S bolt system gates
interconnecting each grazing paddock/enclosures to the
other.
The department intends to take up this pilot
venture at the departmental land located at Zeema-II in
Lachen
for
consideration
which
in
a
proposal
is
under
active
the
Planning
&
Development
Department.
6.
PROVISION OF
HEALTH CARE TO YAK:
The
Animal
Department
Husbandry
under
the
VETERINARY
&
Veterinary
technical
AID
&
Services
supervision
of
Veterinary Officer, Sub-divisional Veterinary Hospital,
Chungthang, Livestock Inspector and technical field
assistants posted under Lachen & Lachung Veterinary
dispensaries have been conducting health care services
from time to time.
This year also, the North district
administration has already set aside a fund of
Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only from the fund
provided by the Sikkim Livestock Development Board
(SLDB) Cell of the Department to conduct 4 Nos. of such
Health Camps at the Yak Herder‟s Backyard in 4
different locations under Lachen and Lachung area. The
Department has also constituted a medical team of
North Sikkim to provide treatment and care to the yaks
during the time of exigency.
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
Additionally, one Bolero Camper PS4 WD is getting
ready at the workshop which will have accessory items
such as Siren & Loud speaker. The nomenclature of the
vehicle would be „Highlanders S.O.S Vehicle‟ which
would bear the Contact Nos. of the Head of District
(H.O.D), concerned area Veterinary Officer & Livestock
Inspector.
The second seat provision in the vehicle
provides ample scope for a team of 4-5 departmental
officials to move as a Task force/QRT, while the open
dickey at the back aids in transportation of medicines,
feed/fodder and other essential relief items. The siren
and loud speaker fitted in the vehicle will enable the
QRT to transmit/convey message of their arrival to the
distressed herders scattered across different location in
the valleys. Availability of such a vehicle would greatly
help in saving valuable time and render quick delivery
of services at the nick of time.
13.
The order of this Court dated 23.10.2019 indicates that the
learned Additional Advocate General had submitted that the affidavits
filed so far on behalf of the State Government had not addressed certain
issues, such as how and what manner the information of any natural
calamity would percolate down to the District Administration or to the
State functionaries, which is the first step that would propel initiation of
remedial measures and, accordingly, her prayer for filing an additional
affidavit was accepted. This Court observed that as the winter season has
almost set in, it is time that the State Government comes out with a
detailed affidavit so that this Court may make appropriate consideration
at an early date. Subsequent thereto, an affidavit dated 11.11.2019 was
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
filed by the Secretary, Department of A.H.&V.S., Government of Sikkim.
It is stated therein that in normal circumstances, the available pasture in
up-migration route and fodder reserves for vulnerable animals used to be
sufficient during winter months. It will be relevant to quote paragraphs 4
and 5 on the issues of (i) percolation of information of any natural
calamity to the District Administration and State functionaries and (ii)
remedial measures for upcoming winter respectively.
“4. PERCOLATION OF INFORMATION OF ANY
NATURAL
CALAMITY
TO
THE
DISTRICT
ADMINISTRATION AND STATE FUNCTIONARIES:
A. North
District
Management
Administration/District
Authority
and
Disaster
Sub-divisional
Administration/ Disaster Management committee
have been activated for the preparedness of upcoming winter season.
B. The Department of Animal Husbandry & Veterinary
Services,
North
communicated
to
District
Indo
Administration
Tibetan
Border
has
Police
(I.T.B.P.) for relay of first-hand information on the
prevailing weather condition of the high-altitude
areas for effective monitoring of the health of the
animals.
The Paramilitary forces particularly ITBP
were very helpful during the crises in April-May
2019. The Yak Harders will be in constant touch with
the I.T.B.P. in the event of inclement weather and
possible calamity.
A copy of letter written to the Commanding Officer/
Commandant, 13 Battalion, I.T.B.P., Lingdum, Ranka
in regards to communication of prevailing weather
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
condition in high altitude areas of North Sikkim &
acknowledgment letter from I.T.B.P. are annexed and
marked herewith as Annexure-R-1 (colly).
B. In the event of disaster, the I.T.B.P. will communicate
directly to the North District Administration/District
Disaster Management Authority and Sub-divisional
Administration/Disaster
Management
committee
and vice-versa.
C. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate of Chungthang Subdivision has also been instructed to devise a protocol
for suitable mechanism for such situations. An interdisciplinary meeting was held on 9th November 2019.
E. For the weather forecast, the Department sought a
short and long-term weather forecast especially on
Snowfall from Metrological Department.
The
Metrological Department has provided the local
webside (www.imdsikkim.gov.in) and for further
interpretation of the information, they will be in
constant
touch
with
the
Department.
The
information will be relayed further on to the
concerned District and Sub-divisional functionaries.
A copy of letter from Metrological Department
alongwith various data is annexed and marked
herewith as Annexure-R-2 (colly).
F. Apart
from
aforementioned
communication
arrangement, the Department of Animal Husbandry
and Veterinary Services
has also posted two
dedicated staff in Muguthang and Lashyar Valley
(Gurudongmar) who will be stationed with the
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
Herders for dissemination of information and firstaid. The names of the staff are – Mr. Tshering Ongyal
Lachenpa
for
Muguthang
and
Mr.
Tamding
Chewang Bhutia for Lashyar Valley (Gurudongmar).
5. REMEDIAL MEASURES FOR UP-COMING WINTER:
A. FEED & FODDER ASSISTANCE
FROM THE GOVERNMENT:
PACKAGE
Yaks are semi-wild animals, thrifty and hardy by
nature which requires human assistance for their
continued existence. They have the ability to survive
under stressful environmental conditions, without
food and water for over 15 days‟ period. However,
unlike the agile and normally healthy adult male
Yaks,
the
female
Yaks
which
are
either
in
pregnancy/nursing stage, old/senile animals, young
growing calves and ailing animals are in most
instances lie vulnerable to the unexpected winter
climatic conditions, particularly during the upward
migration period.
Various photographs of Muguthang Valley/I.T.B.P
camp & Lonak La Pass (Muguthang Pass) are
annexed and marked herewith as Annexsure-R-3
(colly).
Considering the frequency of heavy and prolonged
snowfall and the information/s gathered from the
locals, it has been learnt that such event like last
incident had occurred approximately after a gap of
twenty-five long years and has not been observed
annually. Thus, taking into account of location viz
land-locked nature of Muguthang region which has
been
identified
as
most
vulnerable
area,
the
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
Department has estimated and made provision of
stocking of Feed and Fodder for sixty days at the rate
of 1.5 kg per animal for 933 nos. of Yaks of
Muguthang area which comes to 84 M.T.
In the
Muguthang region (Tsangtha) the Department has a
storing facility (Hay Godown) with a plinth area of 31
ft x 31 ft which can store 36 Metric Ton. For storage
of remaining stock, the Herders have already been
communicated by the Sub-divisional officials and
found to have enough storing facility.
B. Of the total requirement of 104 M.T of Feed and
Fodder, the I.C.A.R-National Research on Yak,
Dirang, Arunachal Pradesh is able to supply only 34
M.T within the end of November.
The remaining
stock will be procured locally as per the formulation
prepared by I.C.A.R-National Research on Yak.
C. For the provision of Feed and Fodder for other areas
in the event of any calamity, a buffer stock of 20 M.T
has been provisioned at Rabum, North Sikkim which
is centrally located for both Lachen and Lachung axis.
D. Apart from Feed and Fodder assistance from the State
Government, the stakeholders (Yak owners) have
also communicated through their Pipon stating that
there are some fodder reserves at their disposal.
A copy of correspondence from Pipon, Lachen
Dzumsa and Yak Herders on routine and traditional
practices and availability of fodder is annexed and
marked herewith as Annexure-R-4.
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
E. In the event of such calamity and insufficiency of
Feed and Fodder provision made by the Department,
for the back-up, the required assistance will be
provided from the N.C fund of D.C (North) as a
contingency plan by any means.
F. ARRANGEMENT OF SPS UTILITY VEHICLE:
One dedicated multi-purpose Bolero Camper has
already been provided to the Sub-division Veterinary
Hospital, Chungthang which is fitted with fog lights
and siren and requisite fabrication, as a means of
distress signal to attend to emergency veterinary
need of the yak herders. The said vehicle is equipped
with all necessary medicines and equipment for onthe spot Veterinary treatment.
Monitoring and
patrolling of all Yak herding areas have already
started.
Photographs showing patrolling and monitoring by
the team is annexed and marked herewith as
Annexure-R-5 (colly).
G. The Sub-division Veterinary Hospital, Chungthang
under the Department of Animal Husbandry and
Veterinary Services has also formed a Yak Health
Care and Rapid Response Team (RRT) which would
consist of the following members: 1 Veterinary
Officer, 1 Livestock Inspector, 1 Junior Stockman
(Para-veterinarian) and additional ten Sub-ordinate
staff. The team will be supported by District level
and State level Disaster Management Team.
This
team will have a range of duties and powers
primarily
for
preventive
and
curative
health
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
management, relief, rescue and rehabilitation during
calamities. The RRT team shall also be responsible
for pre-emptive measures prior to any calamity. A
WhatsApp group of local R.R.T has also been created.
A copy of office order dated 11/11/2019, constitution
of Rapid Response Team at the Field level is annexed
and marked herewith as Annexure-R-6.
H. PROVISION OF VETERINARY AIR & HEALTH
CARE TO YAKS:
As is the routine practice, the AH&VS department
under the technical supervision of Veterinary Officer,
Sub-divisional
Veterinary
Hospital
Chungthang,
Livestock Inspector and technical field assistants
posted
under
dispensaries
Lachen
have
been
&
Lachung
Veterinary
conducting
vaccination
programmes as per schedule mainly against the Foot
& Mouth Disease (FMD) to which Yaks are found to
be most susceptible. Basic health care facilities and
other necessary services are also extended to the
herders from time to time as per reports and verbal
appraisals. The department has also been organizing
ambulatory
clinics
annually
in
the
month of
November-December, which involves reaching out to
the grievances and treatment of different Yaks
ailments and de-worming programs at the Yak
herder‟s backyard including training and awareness
camps. Over the years, it has been seen and observed
that this programme has been widely appreciated by
the yak herders. In addition, the team from NRC on
Yaks-ICAR has also been gracious enough to visit the
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
area and distribute Yak First-Aid Kits to the Yak
herders.”
14.
The affidavit in the form of suggestions has also been placed
on record by the Amici Curiae. In paragraph 3 of the said affidavit, it is
stated that around 1000 yaks along with its herders will be in and around
Muguthang region and approximately same number of yaks will be in
and around Gurudongmar and, therefore, the State Government should
immediately make provision to supply complete feed block and chelated
mineral mixture fodder enough to last for 3 months (approximately
1,80,000 kg) to the yak herders at Muguthang and Gurudongmar, which
should be taken as a short term measure and the same should be done
before the end of November, 2019.
They also suggest use of local
materials, such as stones and wood, for any construction to be made with
regard to yak related activities.
15.
Complete Feed Block Technology is a latest development of
feed technology to exploit the potential of locally available animal feed
resources besides using non-conventional feed resources in a better way
that makes livestock farming an economically viable enterprise.
Complete feed block is an intimate mixture of processed ingredients
including roughages and concentrates designed as the sole source of feed
in compressed form. In an article “Indigenous Traditional Knowledge of
Yak Rearers” published by the Director, NRC on Yak, Dirang, Arunachal
Pradesh in August 2009, in the context of seasonal migration and grazing
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
pattern, it is stated that the seasonal migration and grazing pattern is
based on yak keepers traditional knowledge which takes into account
thermo neutral zone for yaks and gives time for growth of grass.
Traditional yak husbandry system involves migration in search of better
pasture.
In India and other neighbouring countries like Nepal and
Bhutan, the farmers practice two pasture utilization strategy. During the
summer, yaks are taken to higher altitude alpine pasture (4,500 m and
above) and in winter, they return to pockets nearer to the villages located
at mid altitude (3,000 m above mean sea level). Grazing in summer
pasture is from May to September while in December to February, winter
pastures are utilized and the rest of the period is spent on transit from
winter pasture to summer pasture.
16.
From the materials on record, it has emerged that there had
been an unprecedented snowfall in the higher regions of North Sikkim
and the same had occurred after a gap of about 25 years. As such a
phenomenon is not an annual event, the administration as well as the yak
herders were caught off guard and were least prepared to deal with the
situation. It is also noticed that Muguthang region has been identified as
the most vulnerable area. Though relief materials were collected, the
same could not reach Muguthang and Lashyar Valley because the areas
remained inaccessible.
17.
From the reports and affidavits of the respondents, it appears
that after this Court had taken up this Suo Motu PIL, the respondents had
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
engaged their attention for welfare of the yaks and some steps have been
taken to that effect. It is categorically stated that there will be no dearth
of feed to feed yaks in the event of a natural calamity and that the
respondents are fully prepared to meet any challenge. It is noticed that a
Yak Healthcare and Rapid Action Team had been formed which will be
supported by the District level and State level Disaster Management
Team. A multi-purpose Bolero Camper had also been provided to attend
to emergency veterinary need of the Yak herders. Two dedicated staff
had been posted in Muguthang and Lashyar Valley to act as an interface
of the administration with the Yak herders for dissemination of
information.
It is noticed that assistance and help of ITBP would be
sought for obtaining first hand information relating to prevailing weather
conditions and the respondents had also taken the Metrological
Department on board.
18.
Though Hay Godown-cum-Yak Shelters numbering 10 are
stated to have been constructed, it does not appear that any such facility
has been constructed in Muguthang and Lashyar area.
To avert a
situation of the kind which was witnessed in the last winter, should there
be snowfall like the previous year, respondents shall consider whether it
will be advisable to set up a couple of such facilities in those two areas as
the past experience had shown that neither the yaks can come down nor
relief materials can reach when it is most needed because of thick blanket
of snow. As stated in the affidavit dated 01.10.2019, the respondent shall
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
take a decision with regard to construction of paddock and supply of
essential items, such as tents.
19.
In a matter of the present nature, it is the State which has to
adopt and formulate strategies to combat a disaster. As indicated earlier,
the Court had to step in because of the calamity and to nudge the
respondents to come up with appropriate measures to tackle the situation
should there be a recurrence of unprecedented snowfall for a prolonged
period. While some steps, as noted hereinabove, have been taken, it will
be necessary for the respondents to be vigilant and they must take
immediate rear-guard action with no loss of time by implementing the
decisions in the field.
20.
We also notice that some decisions such as the decision to set
up a buffer stock of feeder and fodder procurement under the Natural
Calamity Fund of Dy. Commissioner, North, as a contingency plan, has
not actually been implemented. The State respondents are directed to
implement in letter and spirit the decisions taken and steps
contemplated, as indicated in the reports and the affidavits.
21.
We further notice from the affidavit dated 06.07.2019 that ex-
gratia of Rs.45.90 lakh, though stated to be payable on account of death of
Yaks due to starvation, the same does not appear to have been paid to the
rightful recipients of the amount.
The respondents are directed to
W.P. (PIL) No. 08 of 2019
In RE: 300 Yaks Starve to Death in North Sikkim
disburse the aforesaid amount within a period of four months from this
date.
22.
With the above observations and directions, the PIL is
disposed of.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting : Yes/No
Internet
: Yes/No
pm/avi
( Arup Kumar Goswami )
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review