The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. In the light of aforesaid flaw attending the preventive detention of the petitioner, this Court has no iota of doubt as to the fact that the petitioner’s detention cannot remain any further salvageable.
27. Accordingly, detention order No.DMB/PSA/04 of 2025 dated 26.04.2025 issued by respondent No.2-District Magistrate Budgam read with approval/confirmation/extension order/s passed by the respondent No.1 are hereby quashed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
HCP No. 95/2025
Pronounced on: 01.07.2026
Imtiyaz Ahmad Bhat
…Petitioner(s)
Through:
Mr. Wajid Mohammad Haseeb, Advocate
Vs.
Union Territory of J&K and Ors.
...Respondent(s)
Through:
Mr. Bikramdeep Singh, Dy. AG
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well
as learned counsel for the respondents.
2.
Perused the writ pleadings and documents
annexed
therewith.
Also
examined
the
detention
record produced from the end of the respondents
relating to the detention of the petitioner.
3.
Institution of this writ petition came to take
place on 14.05.2025 by the petitioner-Imtiyaz Ahmad
Bhat, acting through his father-Fayaz Ahmad Bhat,
HCP No. 95/2025
thereby seeking issuance of writ of habeas corpus from
this Court in terms of jurisdiction under article 226 of
the Constitution of India for release of petitioner from
his preventive detention custody being suffered by him
under J&K Public Safety Act, 1978.
4.
The facts of the case go like this that the Senior
Superintendent of Police (SSP), Budgam profiled the
petitioner to be indulgent in activities prejudicial to the
security of State and, therefore, prepared a dossier of
his alleged activities which he submitted by his letter
No.
PSA
Cell/Dossier/2025/441-44
dated
07.04.2025 to the respondent No.2-District Magistrate
Budgam thereby soliciting a preventive detention order
against the petitioner.
5.
Acting on the basis of said dossier, the
respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Budgam, at his
end, came to formulate grounds of detention wherein
the petitioner came to be referred as repeated violator
of law having no respect for the law of land suggesting
his relentless pursuit of leading terrorist in the area.
Criminal antecedents of the petitioner
HCP No. 95/2025
came to be
highlighted by his involvement in FIR No. 02 of 2019
of
the
Police
Station
Charar-i-Sharief
involving
commission of offences under sections 7/27
of the
Arms Act, 1959, section 307 RPC and sections
18/19/20/38 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
Act, 1967.
6.
In addition, the petitioner is also said to have
been bound down several times, on 05.08.2024,
30.08.2024,
12.01.2025,
14.02.2025
and
18.03.2025 under relevant provisions of law without
disclosing said relevant provisions of law but still the
petitioner is reported in the grounds of detention not
to have mended his indulgences and continuing with
his illegal activities to support terrorist activities in the
area.
7.
The petitioner is even said to have managed to
establish contact with the terrorists speaking volumes
about his deep and clandestine links as an OGW of a
terrorist organization working as an active aide of
terrorist of LET outfit in the area.
HCP No. 95/2025
8.
The petitioner along with unnamed associates
is alleged to have facilitated ferrying of terrorist group
to escape from a cordon off and search operation at
Haji Bagh Koker-khal, Charar-i-Sharief. The petitioner
is said to have dug a fabricated hideout for terrorists.
9.
On the basis of said grounds of detention, the
respondent No.2-District Magistrate Budgam came to
have a purported subjective satisfaction that the
petitioner warrants to be confined in preventive
detention custody, and, thus, Order No. DMB/PSA/04
of 2025 dated 26.04.2025 came to be passed ordering
preventive detention of the petitioner under section 8
of
the
J&K
Public
Safety
Act,
and
his
confinement to be in the District Jail Kathua for a
period to be specified by the Government.
10.
The issuance of the aforesaid detention order
by the respondent No.2-District Magistrate Budgam
led to the arrest and detention of the petitioner on
30.04.2025 when ASI Mohd Sidiq of Police Station
Khansahib took the petitioner into his custody and
HCP No. 95/2025
delivered his person to the Assistant Superintendent,
District Jail Kathua.
11.
The petitioner is said to have been delivered a
compilation of 15 leaves inclusive of order of detention,
grounds of detention and other documents which are
said to have been read over to the petitioner in the
language understood by him and in acknowledgement
thereof, a receipt also fetched from him.
12.
As per the Execution Report, the petitioner was
also informed of his right to make a representation to
the Government against the order of detention and
said fact is confirmed from the Receipt fetched from
the petitioner with respect to delivery of compilation of
15 leaves by the detention warrant executing officer
ASI Mohd Sidiq of Police Station Khansahib.
13.
The Superintendent District Jail, Kathua, by
virtue of his communication No.DJK/DS/2970-75
dated
01.05.2025
Commissioner
addressed
(Additional
to
the
Chief
Financial
Secretary)
Government Home Department J&K apprised about
the execution of the detention order qua the petitioner
HCP No. 95/2025
and also about the fact that the petitioner, as
a
detenu, has been informed about his right to make a
representation
to
the
Government
and
District
Magistrate Budgam against his detention, meaning
thereby, the Superintendent District Jail Kathua is in
contradiction to the Execution Report of ASI Mohd
Sidiq of Police Station Khansahib as per whom the
petitioner
was
only
apprised
of
right
to
make
representation to the Government.
14.
On behalf of the petitioner, his father came to
pen
down
a
representation
dated
06.05.2025
submitted to the respondent No.2 District Magistrate,
Budgam thereby seeking revocation of detention of the
petitioner
on
the
grounds
asserted
in
the
representation.
15.
Said representation in writing was admittedly
received in the office of the respondent No.2-District
Magistrate Budgam on 07.05.2025.
16.
The
preventive
detention
Order
No.
DMB/PSA/04 of 2025 dated 26.04.2025 came to be
lend an approval in terms of Government Order No.
HCP No. 95/2025
Home/PB-V/775
of
dated
05.05.2025
accompanied with forwarding of the case for the
opinion of the Advisory Board which came to be
tendered by an Opinion Report dated 19.05.2025
wherein the Advisory Board came up with the opinion
that the petitioner’s detention is based on justifiable
grounds. The Advisory Board, in its report, comes up
with a recital that the petitioner, as a detenu, was
informed of his right to make a representation to the
Government as well as to the detention order making
authority which recital is again contrary to the
Execution Report submitted by ASI Mohd Sidiq of
Police Station Khansahib, who actually dealt with the
petitioner in the context of taking him to custody,
handing over compilation of 15 leaves to the petitioner,
explaining
him
about
the
contents
detention, grounds of detention
of
order
of
and notice
of
detention but not apprising him about right to make a
representation against his preventive detention to the
detention order making authority, i.e the respondent
No.2-District Magistrate Budgam.
HCP No. 95/2025
17.
The Advisory Board’s Opinion Report dated
19.05.2025 facilitated confirmation of the petitioner’s
preventive detention by issuance of Government Order
No.Home/PB-V/999 of 2025 dated 22.05.2025 with
period of detention at first instance being from
30.04.2025 to 29.10.2025 and place of confinement
continuing to be the District Jail Kahtua.
18.
The petitioner’s detention period is said to have
been extended from time to time to last for full two
years w.e.f. 30.04.2025.
19.
By
virtue
of
a
Government
Order
No.
Home/PB-V/1925 of 2025 dated 24.10.2025, the
period of detention fastened upon the petitioner in
terms of Government Order No. Home/PB-V/999 of
2025 dated 22.05.2025, came to be extended for a
further period of six months w.e.f 30.10.2025 till
29.04.2026.
20.
The petitioner, in his writ petition, has assailed
his detention order on the grounds as set out in para 3
(i) to (xiv).
HCP No. 95/2025
21.
In the grounds of detention, the petitioner
assails his detention as being illegal pleading that the
grounds of detention have no nexus with the cause for
subjecting the petitioner to suffer preventive detention
custody. The petitioner refers that the detention is a
case of mistaken identity in the sense that he has
never been involved in alleged activity as referred in
the grounds of detention as well in the dossier. The
petitioner assails the grounds of detention to be vague,
non-existent on the basis whereof no prudence can
generate
a
subjective
satisfaction
for
a
District
Magistrate to order a preventive detention of the
petitioner. The reference to the petitioner’s involvement
in criminal case of 2019 is being assailed as too
distant to afford any basis for a preventive detention
order being passed in the year 2025 and, more
particularly, when petitioner is on bail by reference to
the said criminal case on the terms and conditions
which the petitioner has always acted in compliance.
The respondent No.2-District Magistrate Budgam is
alleged to have acted as a borrower of the dossier to
HCP No. 95/2025
repeat the same as it is in the name of his grounds of
detention, and pass detention order against the
petitioner in a mechanical manner without involving
any independent application of mind on the part of
respondent No.2-District Magistrate Budgam.
22.
The petitioner in ground (xii) of para 3 has
categorically come up with an averment that his
representation
submitted
on
07.05.2025
before
respondent No.2-District Magistrate Budgam has gone
waste without any consideration being accorded to it.
23.
In
response
to
the
writ
petition,
the
respondents in general and the respondent No.2District Magistrate Budgam in particular, in the
counter affidavit submitted on 30.09.2025 come
forward defending the preventive detention of the
petitioner. The respondents are pleading that all the
procedural formalities and safeguards were followed to
the fullest and, thus, the petitioner cannot be heard to
have any grievance against his preventive detention
custody on the basis of subjective satisfaction drawn
HCP No. 95/2025
by the respondent No.2-District Magistrate Budgam
from the material on record.
24.
The fate of this writ petition and also of the
petitioner shall not detain this Court much longer as a
singular
flaw
attending
the
preventive
detention
custody of the petitioner is staring from the detention
record to quash the preventive detention of the
petitioner and that flaw is why the petitioner’s
representation received by respondent No.2-District
Magistrate
Budgam
on
07.05.2025,
was
not
forwarded to the Advisory Board for its consideration
for the reasons best known to the respondent No.2District Magistrate Budgam or for that matter to the
respondent No.1- Home Department Government of
Jammu
and
Kashmir
and
this
fact
is
earning
confirmation from the recital in the Opinion Report
dated 19.05.2025 of the Advisory Board
in para 4
stating that no representation seems to have been
made by the petitioner as no such representation
is lying on the material placed before us.
HCP No. 95/2025
25.
It appears that the respondent No.2-District
Magistrate
Budgam,
representation
from
despite
the
end
having
of
received
the
petitioner
submitted by his father on 07.05.2025, acted at his
own leisure and forwarded the same to the Home
Department Government of Jammu and Kashmir as it
is
only
by
virtue
of
a
communication
No.DMB/PSA/2025/62-64 dated 15.05.2025 when it
occurred to the respondent No.2-District Magistrate
Budgam that he needed to forward the representation
of
the
petitioner
for
the
consideration
of
the
Government, by which time, the Advisory Board was
yet to come up with its Opinion Report dated
19.05.2025.
Thus, even the Home Department
Government of Jammu and Kashmir is found acting
with
leisure
in
not
forwarding
the
received
representation of the petitioner so forwarded by the
respondent No.2-District Magistrate Budgam for the
immediate notice of the Advisory Board.
26.
In the light of aforesaid flaw attending the
preventive detention of the petitioner, this Court has
HCP No. 95/2025
no iota of doubt as to the fact that the petitioner’s
detention cannot remain any further salvageable.
27.
Accordingly, detention order No.DMB/PSA/04
of 2025 dated 26.04.2025 issued by respondent
No.2-District
Magistrate
Budgam
read
with
approval/confirmation/extension order/s passed by
the respondent No.1 are hereby quashed.
28.
The petitioner is directed to be released from
his preventive detention custody from the concerned
Jail wherever the petitioner is being confined to which
effect Superintendent concerned Jail shall immediately
release the petitioner.
29.
Detention record perused being in photostat
form needs not to be returned and is to be retained on
the file for record.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR:
01.07.2026
“Manzoor”
Whether the judgment is speaking
:
Yes / No
Whether the judgment is reportable
:
Yes / No
HCP No. 95/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review