The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. On the facts of this case, this Court is of the considered view that merely because the Appellant-Insurance Company had taken out an Application under Section 170 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1986, to contest the Claim Petition and raise all the defences that are open to them under the statute and when the owner of the vehicle had remained ex parte, it cannot be construed that it is the burden of the Insurance Company to prove the negative, i.e., that the vehicle was not insured with them at the time of accident. The Claimants have failed to establish that there was valid Insurance Policy, on the date of accident and in such circumstances, the Insurance Company is not statutorily liable to pay compensation to the Victims. In view of the above, the liability fastened on the Appellant-Insurance Company, to pay the compensation is set aside.” Relying upon the aforesaid citation, it appears that the respondent claimant petitioner before the Tribunal has failed to establish that there was valid insurance policy of the offending motor bike on the day of accident and as such, the present appellant Insurance Company is not statutorily be liable to pay compensation to the respondent claimant petitioner. Thus, it appears that the judgment and award delivered by Learned Tribunal below was perverse and not based on any sound reasoning.
12. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby allowed. The judgment and award delivered by Learned Member, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala (Tribunal No.2) dated 13.07.2021 in connection with Case No.TS (MAC) 164 of 2017 is hereby set aside. The matter is remanded back to the Tribunal below to issue notice upon the claimant petitioner and upon the owner of the offending bike to appear and to produce the policy document. The appellant Insurance Company is also asked to appear before the Learned Tribunal on 31.07.2025. In the event of availability of valid insurance policy document the same be duly marked by the Learned Tribunal below and thereafter shall deliver a fresh judgment in accordance with law at an earliest convenience. With this observation, this present appeal stands disposed of. Send down the record to the Learned Tribunal below along with a copy of this judgment. Supply a copy of this judgment/order to Learned Counsel for the appellant Insurance Company. Pending application(s), if any, is accordingly stands disposed of. Amrita 18:08:41 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
M.A.C. App. No.92 of 2024
Iffco Tokio General Insurance Company Ltd.
Corporate address Iffco Tower
Plot No.3
Sector – 29, Gurgaon
Haryana – 122001
(Insurer of the vehicle bearing Registration
Number – TR-01M-5186 Motor Bike)
......Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Sudip Kumar Das,
S/O-Sri Sudhan Ch. Das
Of Shyamaprasad Colony
PO- Anandanagar, PIN- 799004
PS- Srinagar, Dist.- West Tripura
…...Claimant-Respondent(s)
2. Sri Koushik Roy,
S/o. Lt. Kusum Roy
Of Suryamaninagar, PIN-799130
PS- Amtali, Dist.- West Tripura
(Owner of the vehicle bearing Registration
No.TR-01M-5186 Motor Bike)
3. The National Insurance Company Ltd.
Akhaura Road, Agartala,
PS-West Agartala
Dist.- West Tripura.
PIN-799001,
(Insurer of Vehicle Registration
No.TR-01 M-5186 Motor Bike)
……Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Asim Kumar Deb, Adv.
Date of Hearing &
Delivery of
Judgment and
Order
:
11.07.2025
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order(Oral)
This appeal is preferred challenging the judgment
and award dated 13.07.2021 delivered by Learned Member,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala
(Tribunal No.2) in connection with T.S. (MAC) 164 of 2017.
2.
Heard Learned Addl. G.A., Mr. K. De appeared on
behalf of the appellant-Insurance Company. Also heard
Learned Counsel, Mr. A. Kr. Deb appeared on behalf of the
respondent-National Insurance Company. But none appeared
on behalf of the respondent-claimant petitioner and also
none appeared on behalf of the owner of the offending Motor
Bike bearing No.TR-01M-5186.
3.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
appellant first of all drawn the attention of the Court that in
this case no insurance certificate could be produced and
proved before the Tribunal either by the claimant-petitioner
or by the owner of the offending motor bike but the Tribunal
below in absence of policy document of the vehicle allowed
the claim petition and fastened the liability of payment of
compensation
upon
the
Insurance
Company.
Learned
Counsel for the appellant further drawn the attention of the
Court referring Para No.15 of the written statement filed
before
the
Tribunal,
wherein
the
appellant
Insurance
Company specifically denied that no such vehicle (TR-01M-
5186 Motor Bike) was ever insured with the appellantInsurance Company at any point of time and furthermore,
the claimant-petitioner before the Tribunal did not produce
any policy document of the vehicle at the time of accident
nor the OP owner produced any policy document of the
vehicle. Situated thus, in absence of policy document the
judgment and award delivered by Learned Tribunal below
cannot be sustained in the eye of law and accordingly,
Learned Counsel urged for allowing this appeal by setting
aside the judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal
below.
4.
Learned Counsel, Mr. A. Kr. Deb appearing on
behalf of the National-Insurance Company Limited submitted
that the Insurance Company Limited has nothing to say in
this regard as the said Insurance Company has no role in
this appeal and urged for passing appropriate order. In this
case, the respondent-claimant Sudip Kumar Das filed one
claim petition before the Tribunal alleging inter alia that on
15.04.2015 in between 4.30 PM to 5 PM when the claimant
petitioner along with his wife were proceeding towards his inlaw’s house at Dukli by riding a motor bike bearing No.TR01M-5186 (Yamaha YBR 125), that time on the way when
they reached near bypass road at Roypara Rabindranagar
that time one offending Motor Bike bearing Registration
No.TR-01Q-5171 (TVS Apache M/C) being driven by OP No.1
came from the opposite direction with excessive speed and
due to rash and negligent driving suddenly dashed against
the motor bike of the claimant-petitioner resulting which the
claimant-petitioner fell down on the road and received severe
injuries. Immediately thereafter the claimant-petitioner and
his wife was shifted to AGMC and GBP Hospital and
undergone treatment as an indoor patient. The claimantpetitioner has undergone surgery of his right leg at Ortho
Care & Related Centre, Kalyani, Agartala under Dr. J. K. Nag
and was admitted therein from 04.05.2015 to 12.05.2015.
This is the subject matter of the claim-petition and in this
regard East Agartala, P.S. Case No.08 of 2016 under Section
279/338 was registered.
5.
It was further submitted that, the claimant-
petitioner was a businessman and his monthly income was
Rs.30,000/- (Rupees Thirty Thousand) per month. Hence he
filed the claim petition. In obedience to the notice issued the
OP No.1, i.e. the owner of the offending motor bike bearing
No.TR-01Q-5171 (TVS Apache M/C) did not appear before
the Tribunal. So the case preceded ex-parte against him. The
OP No.2 i.e. the Insurance Company that is the present
appellant herein appeared and also denied the assertions of
the claimant-petitioner and submitted that the claim petition
was subjected to strict proof. No written statement was
submitted by OP No.3 i.e. the National Insurance Company
Limited. Upon the pleadings of the parties following issues
were framed:ISSUES
I.
Is the claim maintainable in its present form and
nature?
II.
Had the claimant petitioner suffered grievous injury
in any road traffic accident? If so, has there been
any rash and negligent driving on the part of the
driver of offending vehicle?
III.
Is
the
Claimant
petitioner
entitled
to
get
compensation as prayed for? If so, who shall be
liable to pay the compensation?
IV.
To what other relief or reliefs the claimant petitioner
is entitled?
6.
To
substantiate
the
issue
the
claimant-
petitioner was examined as PW-1 and relied upon the
following documents:1)
Certified copy of FIR, ejahar, charge sheet in
connection with East Agartala PS Case No.86 of 2015 in 14
sheets-Ext.1(i) to 1(xiv);
2)
Original
copy
12.05.2015-Ext.2;
3)
Discharge
certificate
dated
Original copy of bill for Rs.40,000/- - Ext.3;
4)
Cash memo
Rs.800/-- Ext.4;
5)
of
towards
cost
of
CT
scan/MRI
for
Money receipt dated 04.05.2015 for Rs.3210/-- Ext.5;
6)
Cash memo and money receipt in 13 sheets- Ext.6(i)
to 6 (xiii);
7)
4 nos. of money receipt towards consultation fees of
Rs.1200/- - Ext.7(i) to 7(iv);
8)
Original prescriptions in two sheets- Ext.8(i) to 8(ii);
9)
Photocopy of driving license in one sheet-Ext.9
respectively.
OP
Nos.1
and
did
not
produce
any
oral/documentary evidence on record.
7.
Finally,
Learned
Tribunal
below
by
the
judgment and award dated 13.07.2021 allowed the
claim petition. The operative portion of the order runs as
follows:ORDER
“In the result, claim is awarded in following
terms:Claimant petitioner is entitled to get the award
of Rs.1,15,000/- (Rupees one lac fifteen thousand)
only with 6% Simple interest per annum from the date
of registration of claim i.e., w.e.f. 06.09.2017 till the
date of realization thereof.
The OP No.2, Iffco Tokio General Insurance Co.
Ltd. shall, within 30 days of the date of this award,
deposit the entire amount as awarded, in favour of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura,
Agartala.
OP No.2, shall be at liberty to recover the
amount from the OP No.1 in accordance with law.
Supply a copy of this award free of cost to the
parties by not later than 15 days from the date of the
award.”
8.
Challenging
that
judgment,
the
appellant
Insurance Company has preferred this appeal. I have heard
Learned Counsel for the appellant Insurance Company and
perused the record and the judgment delivered by Learned
Tribunal below. In Para 7 of the Judgment, the Learned
Tribunal below observed that the OP No.1 being the owner of
the offending motor bike did not appear to contest the case.
As such the Learned Tribunal below came to the observation
that there was no evidence from the side of the said OP that
the vehicle was duly insured with OP No.2.
9.
Learned Tribunal came to the observation that since the
said Insurance Company i.e. the appellant did not take the
plea that the offending bike was not insured with the
appellant Insurance Company. So, the Learned Tribunal
below came to the observation that the offending bike was
duly insured with the appellant Insurance Company and
fastened the liability of payment of compensation upon the
appellant
which
in my considered
opinion was
totally
misconceived and without any legal basis because until and
unless the insurance certificate is proved then there is no
scope on the part of the Tribunal to fasten the liability of
payment of compensation to any Insurance Company.
10.
Here in the case at hand neither the petitioner
proved the policy document of the offending bike nor the
owner of the offending bike produced or proved the policy
document of the vehicle to substantiate his defence. Even
from the side of the claimant-petitioner, there was no
request or query to the appellant Insurance Company to
furnish the certified copy of the policy document. Even in the
claim petition also there was no assertion in regard to the
policy number of the offending bike on the day of alleged
accident. Situated thus, it appears that without application of
proper mind, the Learned Tribunal fastened the liability of
payment of compensation upon the Insurance Company. In
this appeal, neither the respondent claimant petitioner nor
the owner of the offending motor bike bearing No.TR-01Q5171 appeared after receipt of notice to the High Court.
11.
Hon’ble the High Court of Madras in New India
Assurance Co. Ltd., Arcot Woodlands Building, No.1,
Bharathi
Road,
Cuddalore-1
Vs.
S.
Sivapathi
and
Others reported in C.M.A. No.415 of 2024 wherein in Para
Nos.17 and 18 observed as under:“17.
In the case on hand, admittedly, the
Claimants/Respondents 1-7 have not furnished
any particulars of the Insurance Policy and it is
bereft of details. As rightly contended by the
learned Counsel for the Appellant-Insurance
Company, it is the duty of the Claimants to furnish
correct registration number of the vehicle, full
Insurance particulars as furnished by the Police
Officer/Investigation
Officer.
Though
it
is
contended by the learned Counsel for the
Claimants/Respondents
1-7
that
they
were
ignorant of the details required to be furnished in
the Application, no steps have been taken by them
to verify the Insurance particulars and when the
Insurance Company after due search in their office
at Cuddalore has positively denied that the
offending vehicle was not insured with them at the
relevant point, they should have taken steps to get
the particulars to prove that the vehicle was
insured with the Appellant-Company. As rightly
contended by the learned Counsel for the
Appellant-Insurance Company, at that relevant
time, it may not be possible for the Insurance
Company to ascertain from all the branches in the
State of Tamil Nadu to verify as to whether the
vehicle was insured with their branch or not. If
some particulars had been furnished in the Claim
Petition, the Insurance Company could have made
efforts to ascertain the necessary particulars from
the Police Officer/Investigation officer concerned
or from the office of the Motor Vehicles Inspector.
In the case on hand, as rightly contended by the
learned Counsel for the Appellant Insurance
Company, it is bereft of details and therefore, to
expect the Appellant-Insurance Company to
ascertain the details, is not proper.
18.
On the facts of this case, this Court is of
the considered view that merely because the
Appellant-Insurance Company had taken out an
Application under Section 170 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1986, to contest the Claim Petition
and raise all the defences that are open to them
under the statute and when the owner of the
vehicle had remained ex parte, it cannot be
construed that it is the burden of the Insurance
Company to prove the negative, i.e., that the
vehicle was not insured with them at the time of
accident. The Claimants have failed to establish
that there was valid Insurance Policy, on the date
of accident and in such circumstances, the
Insurance Company is not statutorily liable to pay
compensation to the Victims. In view of the above,
the liability fastened on the Appellant-Insurance
Company, to pay the compensation is set aside.”
Relying upon the aforesaid citation, it appears
that the respondent claimant petitioner before the Tribunal
has failed to establish that there was valid insurance policy
of the offending motor bike on the day of accident and as
such, the present appellant Insurance Company is not
statutorily be liable to pay compensation to the respondent
claimant petitioner. Thus, it appears that the judgment and
award delivered by Learned Tribunal below was perverse and
not based on any sound reasoning.
12.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
hereby allowed. The judgment and award delivered by
Learned Member, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, West
Tripura, Agartala
(Tribunal
No.2)
dated 13.07.2021
in
connection with Case No.TS (MAC) 164 of 2017 is hereby set
aside.
The matter is remanded back to the Tribunal
below to issue notice upon the claimant petitioner and upon
the owner of the offending bike to appear and to produce the
policy document. The appellant Insurance Company is also
asked to appear before the Learned Tribunal on 31.07.2025.
In the event of availability of valid insurance policy document
the same be duly marked by the Learned Tribunal below and
thereafter shall deliver a fresh judgment in accordance with
law at an earliest convenience.
With this observation, this present appeal stands
disposed of.
Send down the record to the Learned Tribunal
below along with a copy of this judgment.
Supply a copy of this judgment/order to Learned
Counsel for the appellant Insurance Company.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
is
accordingly
stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Amrita
AMRITA
DEB
AMRITA DEB
Date: 2025.07.11
18:08:41 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review