Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-37413-2025 (O&M)
(1)
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
1.
CWP-37413-2025 (O&M)
ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company Limited
… Petitioner
Versus
National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission & others
... Respondents
Respondent
2.
CWP-37415-2025 (O&M)
ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company Limited
… Petitioner
Versus
National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission & others
... Respondents
Respondent
Date of Decision: 02.04.2026
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE GURVINDER SINGH GILL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR
Present:
Mr. Hitender Kansal, Advocate,
for the petitioner.
Mr. Arjun Kundra and Mr. Prateek Singh, Advocates,
for respondent No.4.
GURVINDER SINGH GILL, J.
1.
This order shall dispose of aforementioned two writ petitions filed on behalf
of the petitioner – ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company Ltd. assailing
ing
common order dated 19.08.2025 (Annexure P
P-15) passed by the National
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC), whereby Revision
evision
Petition No.1936 of 2024 and Revision Petition No.1937 of 2024 filed by the
petitioners challenging common order dated 05.03.2024 (Annexure P-1
14)
VIMAL KUMAR
2026.04.09 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-37413-2025 (O&M)
(2)
passed by the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (SCDRC) in
Appeal No.A/314/2023 filed on behalf of respondent No.4 and Appeal
No.A/82/2024 filed on behalf of the petitioner
petitioner, have been dismissed.
2.
A few facts necessary to notice for disposal of both the petitions are that the
petitioner – Insurance Company had issued a master policy under ‘ICICI Pru
Group Loan Secure Policy’
Policy bearing number 234435996
234435996, wherein Amandeep
Singh Sra had also been insured. However, said Amandeep Singh Sra died
within 10 months of issuance of said policy
policy. Thereafter, respondent No.4 –
Kanwalpreet Kaur i.e. the widow of Amandeep Singh Sra
Sra, lodged a
complaint asserting accidental death, but the same was declined by the
petitioner – Insurance Company
ompany on the premise
premises that it was a case of suicide
within one year. Respondent No.4 - Kanwalpreet Kaur consequently filed a
complaint before the District Consumer Dispute
Disputes Redressal Commission,
Chandigarh which was partly allowed vide order dated 01.09.2023
Chandigarh,
(Annexure
nnexure P-13).
P
The operative part of the said order is reproduced hereinherein
under:
“15.
Hence, the present complaint deserves to be partly allowed and the
same is accordingly partly allowed. OP No.1 is directed to release an
amount of Rs.46,80,329/Rs.46,80,329/ (Rs.47,93,516/
(Rs.47,93,516/- minus Rs.1,13,187/- already
paid by OP No.1 to OP No.2 i.e. 80% of the total premium amount)
along with interest @ 9% p.a. from the date of repudiation of the claim
i.e. 04.06.2020 till the date
date of actual refund/release to OP No.2 towards
the balance outstanding principal loan amount account No.844903. OP
No.2 is also directed to accept and adjust the above said amount
towards settlement of the Housing Loan Account No.844903 and issue
an acknowledgement/loan
acknowledgement/loan settlement to the complainant after receiving
the balance loan amount, if any (in case the loan amount is excessive
than the awarded amount) or pay the balance amount to the
VIMAL KUMAR
2026.04.09 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-37413-2025 (O&M)
(3)
complainant, if any (in case the loan amount is lesser than awarded
amount).”
3.
Aggrieved against the said order dated 01.09.2023 (Annexure P
P-13), both
respondent No.4 – Kanwalpreet Kaur as well as the petitioner – Insurance
Company preferred separate appeals i.e. Appeal No.A/31
No.A/314/2023
/2023 and Appeal
No.A/82/2024
/82/2024 respectively, before the SCDRC
SCDRC. The SCDRC vide common
order dated 05.03.2024 (Annexure P-14)
14), while dismissing the appeal
(Appeal No.A/82/2024) filed by the petitioner – Insurance Company and
partly accepting
accept
the appeal (Appeal No.A/314/2023) filed
ed by respondent No.4
– Kanwalpreet Kaur,
Kaur issued the following directions:
“30.
In view of above, Appeal No.314 of 2023 "Kanwalpreet Kaur Vs.
ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.", stands partly
accepted. The orders of the Learned District Commission are modified
and Respondents/Opposite Parties are directed as under:
under:(i)
Opposite Party No.1 is directed to make the payment of entire
loan amount outstanding, along with upto date interest accrued
thereon, out of the death benefit of ₹47,93,516/- (minus
₹1,13,187/- already paid by OP No.1 to OP No.2 i.e. 80% of the
total premium amount) and additional accidental death benefit of
₹47,93,516/- payable to the Complainant/ Appellant and
thereafter,
the
balance
amount
shall
be
paid
to
the
Appellant/Complainant
Complainant along with interest @ 9% p.a. from the
date of death i.e. 06.06.2019 till realization.
(ii)
Opposite
Party
No.2
is
also
directed
to
issue
an
acknowledgement/loan settlement to the complainant after
receiving the balance loan amount forthwith.
(iii)
This order be complied with by the Opposite Parties jointly and
severally, within 60 days from the date of receipt of its certified
copy, failing which, the awarded amount shall carry interest
@12% p.a., instead of 9% p.a. from the date of death i.e.
06.06.2019 till realization.”
VIMAL KUMAR
2026.04.09 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-37413-2025 (O&M)
(4)
4.
Still aggrieved, the petitioner - Insurance Company filed separate revision
petitions before the NCDRC challenging order dated 05.03.2024 (Annexure
P-14), which also came to be dismissed vide impugned order dated
19.08.2025 (Annexure P-15),
P 15), which is being assailed before this Court
Court.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner while assailing the impugned order dated
19.08.2025 (Annexure P-15)) vehemently argued that it is admittedly a case
where the deceased Amandeep Singh
Singh Sra had committed suicide, as was
rightly reported in a newspaper and as is also found from the post-mortem
mortem
report, which shows that there was an entry wound on the one side of skull of
the deceased and an exit wound on other side of skull of the deceased and
such like shot could not have been accidentally fired. Learned counsel in this
context has drawn the attention of this Court to the copy of the post
post-mortem
mortem
report (Annexure P-17).
P 17). The relevant extract from the post-mortem
mortem report is
reproduced herein-under:
Examination of External Injuries
Sr.
No.
Injuries
1.
Entry wound with blackening around its margins in the No
form of lacerated punctured wound 0.5 x 0.5 cm
present on right temporal area of head. Margins were
inverted clotted blood present. On dissection extra
cranial haemoloma present on fronto parieto temp
temporal
area on right side. Fracture of frontal, right parietal
and right temporal bone present. Infiltration of blood
present at fracture ends. On removing the cranial vault
beveling of inner cable of skull present. Meninges
torn, lacerated wound present on right temporopanial
area. Tracking of wound present towards left parieto
temporal area, corresponding exist wound with
beveling on its outer lable of skull and facerated
punctured wound with size 0.6 x 0.6 cm on the left
side of head.
VIMAL KUMAR
2026.04.09 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Marked
Injury
Number
CWP-37413-2025 (O&M)
(5)
6.
ha also referred to a copy of news item annexed with the
Learned counsel has
petition.
It has further been submitted that the matter had been got
investigated by the investigator of the Insurance Company, who had found
that it was a case of suicide and not of accidental fire.
7.
We have considered the aforesaid submissions raised on behalf of learned
counsel for the petitioner and have also gone through the entire petition
petitions as
well as the documents annexed therein.
therein
8.
In the present case, the matter was duly investigated by the police and
pursuant to the investigation, it was found that A
Amandeep
mandeep Singh Sra had died
due to accidental firing from his licensed weapon and consequently a closure
report (Annexure P-11)
P 11) was submitted, which was duly accepted by the Sub
Divisional Magistrate, Mohali.
Mohali We find that it is investigating agency of the
State,, which had duly examined the matter and upon investigation had found
the case to be a case of accidental firing and had filed closure report, which
was duly accepted by the Sub Divisional Magistrate
Magistrate.. Such like report cannot
be discarded solely on the
the basis of some news report or some investigation
conducted by the investigator of the Insurance Company itself. Thus, we do
not find any infirmity in the findings recorded by the NCDRC.
9.
In any case, the scope of interference in writ jurisdiction so as to assail the
said order would be very limited i.e. if there is some sheer perversity in the
impugned order or if there is some sheer misreading of evidence, which is not
there in the instant case. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in M/s Garment Craft
Vs. Prakash Chand Goel, AIR 2022 SC 422
422,, while defining the scope of
interference under Article 227 of the Constitution, held as under:
“18.
VIMAL KUMAR
2026.04.09 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Having heard the counsel for the parties, we are clearly of the view that
the impugned order is contrary to law and cannot be sustained for
CWP-37413-2025 (O&M)
(6)
several reasons, but primarily for deviation from the limited jurisdiction
exercised by the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India. The High Court exercising supervisory jurisdiction does not act
as a court of first appeal to reappreciate, reweigh the evidence or facts
upon which the determination under challenge is based. Supervisory
jurisdiction is not to correct every error of fact or even a legal flaw
when the final finding is justified or can be supported. The High Court
is not to substitute its own decision on facts and conclusion, for that of
the inferior court or tribunal. The jurisdiction exercised is in the nature
of correctional jurisdiction to set right grave dereliction of duty or
flagrant abuse, violation of fundamental principles of law or justice.
The power under Article 227 is exercised sparingly in appropriate
cases, like when there
there is no evidence at all to justify, or the finding is so
perverse that no reasonable person can possibly come to such a
conclusion that the court or tribunal has come to. It is axiomatic that
such discretionary relief must be exercised to ensure there is no
miscarriage of justice.”
justice.
10.
Examining the impugned order in the light of ratio of law laid down in M/s
Garment Craft’s case (supra),
(supra) wee do not find any perversity or illegality in the
impugned order so as to warrant any interference in exercise of writ
jurisdiction. Finding no merit in the instant petition
petitions, the same are hereby
dismissed.
11.
A photocopy of this order be placed on the connected file.
(GURVINDER
GURVINDER SINGH GILL
GILL)
JUDGE
02.04.2026
Vimal
(YASHVIR
YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR
RATHOR)
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned:
Whether reportable:
VIMAL KUMAR
2026.04.09 10:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review