Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010208742021
2026:GAU-AS:3406
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Principal Seat at Guwahati
MACApp./77/2022
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd.,
having its Registered Office & Head Office at ICICI Bank Towers,
Bandra Kurla Complex, Mumbai 400051, its Zonal Office at Apeejay House, 15
Park Street, 7th Floor, Kolkata-700016, and a Branch Office at 3rd floor, office No.
305 and 306, Kamkhya Tower, G. S. Road, Guwahati-781005, Assam.
……..Appellant
-Versus1.
Smti Gopa Das
W/o Late Bhupesh Ch. Das
2.
Sri Joydeep Das
S/o Late Bhupesh Ch Das
Both are residents of:
R/o-Village-Nilibari
P.O. Simlaguri, P.S. Dhaligaon
District: Chirang, BTAD, Assam.
Pincode: 783385.
3.
On the Death of Santala Basumatary his Legal Heirs (Deceased)
S/O Late Soni Ram Basumatary,
Resident of Village Gossaigaon, P.O. Ranchaidham,
Dist. Chirang, Assam, 783372.
[Owner of the Vehicle No. AS-19/H-0349 (M/C)]
3.1. Bharati Basumatary (Wife),
Resident of Village Gossaigaon, P.O. Ranchaidham,
Dist. Chirang, Assam, 783372.
3.2. Dwitun Basumatary,
Resident of Village Gossaigaon, P.O. RANCHAIDHAM,
Dist. Chirang, Assam, 783372.
3.3. Manoranjan Basumatary,
Resident of Village Gossaigaon, P.O. Ranchaidham,
Dist. Chirang, Assam, 783372.
3.4. Bishnu Jyoti Basumatary,
Resident of Village Gossaigaon, P.O. Ranchaidham,
Dist. Chirang, Assam, 783372.
4.
Tabra Brahma,
S/o Late Abath Brahma,
R/o. Village-South Kajolgaon,
P.O. Simlaguri, District: Chirang, BTC, Assam,
Pincode:783381.
[Driver of the Vehicle No. AS-19/H-0349(M/C)]
5.
State of Assam, represented by…
…….Respondents
- B E F O R E-
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
Advocate for the appellant
:
Mr. R. Goswami
Advocate for the respondents
:
Mr. M. Khan (for R-1&2);
Ms. D. Devi, on behalf of
Mr. K.R. Patgiri (for R-3.1 to 3.4);
Ms. D.D. Barman, Addl. Sr. G. A.
(for R-5).
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
23.02.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment?
:
N/A
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
Yes
:
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. R. Goswami, learned counsel for the appellant. Also
heard Mr. M. Khan, learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 and 2;
Ms. D. Devi, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr. K.R. Patigiri,
learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 3.1 to 3.4; and Ms. D.D.
Barman,
learned
Addl.
Senior
Government
Advocate
for
the
respondent No. 5. None appears for the respondent No. 4.
2.
This appeal, under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988, is directed against the judgment and award dated 07.09.2021,
passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Bongaigaon, in MAC Case No. 63/2016.
3.
It is to be noted here that vide impugned judgment and award
dated 07.09.2021, the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Bongaigaon („Tribunal‟, for short) has directed the appellant
herein i.e. ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. to pay a
sum
of
Rs.26,77,358/-,
being
the
compensation
to
the
claimants/respondent Nos. 1 and 2 herein, with interest @ 6% per
annum, from the date of filing of the claim petition, till the date of its
realization.
Background facts:4.
The background facts leading to filing of the present petition is
briefly stated as under:“On 07.07.2015, Bhupesh Chandra Das, since deceased
was coming from Tuniapar market towards his home,
situated at Nilibari by riding his bi-cycle. Then the driver of a
motorcycle, bearing registration No.AS-19/H-0349, which was
coming in rash and negligent manner, knocked down said
Bhupesh Chandra Das, from behind, on the main road, near
Ram Mandir, B.G. Colony. As a result, Bhupesh Chandra Das
had sustained grievous injuries over his head and other part
of his body and his bi-cycle also got damaged.
After the accident, Bhupesh Chandra Das was taken to
Lower Assam Hospital & Research Centre, Bongaigaon. Then
on being advised, he was shifted at Hayat Hospital,
Odalbakra, Langanesh, Guwahati-34. But on 08.07.2015 at
about 11:30, after necessary treatment, the Doctor declared
him dead. Later on, the autopsy of the dead body was done
at G.M.C. Guwahati.
In connection with the accident, one Joydeep Das,
respondent No.2 herein, had lodged one FIR with the OfficerIn-Charge on 19.08.2015, upon which Bongaigaon P.S. case
No. 675/2015, u/s 279/304(A) IPC was registered against the
driver of vehicle bearing registration Nо.АЅ-19/Н-0349 (Hero
Glamour Motorcycle). Thereafter, investigation was carried
out, which culminated in submission of charge sheet against
the driver of the vehicle bearing registration Nо.АЅ-19/Н0349.
Thereafter, the respondent No.1 and 2 herein, being
the wife and son have filed a claim petition before the
learned tribunal claiming compensation on account of death
of
Bhupesh
Chandra
Das.
The
appellant
and
other
respondent herein had entered appearance and contested
the claim petition by filing written statement.
Thereafter, vide impugned judgment and award, the
learned tribunal had directed the appellant herein, i.e. ICICI
Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd., to pay a sum of
Rs.26,77,358/-,
being
the
compensation
to
the
claimants/respondent Nos. 1 and 2 herein with interest @ 6%
per annum, from the date of filing of the claim petition till the
date of its realization.”
5.
Being aggrieved, the appellant herein, has preferred the present
appeal on several grounds, specially on the ground of fraud.
Submissions:6.
Mr. Goswami, learned counsel for the appellant, submits that
immediately after the accident, the
matter was reported to
Bongaigaon Police Station, upon which G.D. Entry No.330, dated
07.07.2015, at 8:20 p.m., was recorded by the Officer-in-Charge of
the P.S. and traffic S.I., R. Bhuyan, was endorsed to investigate the
matter. Accordingly, S.I.- R. Bhuyan, had visited the place of
occurrence and upon returning, he reported that a motorcycle, bearing
Registration No.AS-16A-4510, had knocked down a person, who was
proceeding in the same direction on his bicycle, as a result of which
the rider of the bicycle as well as of the motorcycle, both, sustained
injuries and the people of the locality had sent both of them to Lower
Assam Hospital for treatment by 108 and he also took the motorcycle,
bearing Registration No.AS-16A-4510, to the police station for
examination. On the basis of the said report, G.D. Entry No.334, was
recorded at approximately 10:05 p.m. on 07.07.2015. Mr. Goswami
further submits that after 42 days of the said accident, an FIR was
lodged with the Officer-In-Charge of Bongaigaon Police Station, upon
which Bongaigaon P.S. Case No.675/2015, dated 19.08.2015, was
registered under Section 279/304A IPC and in the said FIR, the
number of the motorcycle has been mentioned as AS-19H-0349.
Thereafter, investigation was carried out and charge-sheet was
submitted against the driver of the said motorcycle.
6.1. Mr. Goswami further submits that a claim petition was filed by
the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 herein, before the learned Member,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Bongaigaon and after hearing both
the parties, the learned Member, MACT, vide judgment and order
dated 07.09.2021, allowed the claim petition and directed the
appellant/respondent No.1, the Legal Manager, ICICI Lombard GIC
Ltd. to pay a sum of Rs.26,77,358/-, being the compensation, and
being aggrieved, the appellant/respondent No.1 has approached this
Court by filing the present appeal.
6.2.
Mr. Goswami submits that in fact, in the said accident the
motorcycle bearing Registration No.AS-16A-4510 was involved, as per
the G.D. Entry No.334, which was exhibited before the learned
Member, MACT, as Exhibit-B. But, subsequently, the vehicle number
was changed in the FIR, wherein a different vehicle bearing
registration No. AS-19H-0349, was shown to have been involved and
after investigation, charge sheet was submitted against one Tabra
Brahma, the driver of the motor cycle No. AS-19H-0349. Mr. Goswami
further submits that the I.O. of the case had also been examined in
the claim petition as D.W.2, and he also admitted to the registration of
the G.D. Entry No.334, dated 07.07.2015, but he stated that due to
inadvertence, the number of the vehicle had been wrongly mentioned
in the G.D. Entry No.334, but such explanation, according to Mr.
Goswami, is far from satisfactory and it indicates commission of fraud
and the same is required to be investigated.
6.3.
It is worth mentioning in this context that vide order dated
19.09.2024, considering the G.D. Entry No.334, dated 07.07.2015,
which was exhibited before the learned Tribunal as Exhibit-B, and
having found substance in the submission of Mr. Goswami, learned
counsel for the appellant, the State of Assam was impleaded as
respondent No. 5 in the appeal and also notice was issued to the said
respondent, and one Mr. S. Baruah, learned Government Advocate
entered appearance for the respondent No. 5. Thereafter, the case
diary of Bongaigaon P.S. Case No.675/2015, as well as the original
General Diary of Bongaigaon P.S. commencing from 07.07.2015, till
31.12.2015, and also the G.R. Record relating to Bongaigaon P.S. Case
No.675/2015 were called for and the same had been received.
Thereafter, vide order dated 17.06.2025, this Court was pleased to call
for the scanned copy of the charge-sheet of Bongaigaon P.S. Case No.
675/2015, from the Court of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Bongaigaon.
6.4.
Thereafter, on 17.02.2026, during the course of the hearing,
Mr. Goswami again submits that in the alleged accident, one
motorcycle, bearing Registration No. AS-16A-4510, was involved as
per G.D. Entry No.334, dated 07.07.2015, but subsequently, on the
basis of FIR, another vehicle was shown to have been involved i.e. AS19H-0349, and after investigation the Bongaigaon P.S. Case No.
675/2015, was charge-sheeted, and he also submits that a fraud has
been committed by the Investigating Officer upon the learned
Tribunal, and as such, the judgment and award passed by the learned
Tribunal is vitiated, and therefore, the impugned judgment and award
dated 07.09.2021, may be set aside and the matter may be referred to
the Special Investigation Team, constituted in the State Assam,
pursuant to the observation made by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
the
case
of
Safiq
Ahmad
Vs.
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. & Others, in
Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 1110 of 2017, for being
investigated commission of fraud in motor accident claim cases.
6.5.
Mr. Goswami also pointed out that pursuant to the order of
this Court, Ms. Barman, learned Addl. Senior Government Advocate for
the respondent No. 5 had received written instructions regarding
details of the owner of registration of the motorcycle bearing No. AS16A-4510, from the District Transport Officer, Bongaigaon, vide letter
dated 12.08.2025, and the said letter indicates that one Jakariya
Champramary, son of Jahan Champramary, resident of Pub Domgaon
of Village:- Coto Nilibari, under Basugaon P.S., district Chirang, is the
owner. Mr. Goswami also submits that the matter may be remanded to
the learned Tribunal to proceed against the said owner, also arraying
him as a respondent in the MAC Case No. 63/2016, and thereafter to
proceed with a claim petition in accordance with the law and to
pronounce a fresh judgment and award, after ascertainment of the
actual vehicle involved in the accident.
7.
Mr. Barman, learned Addl. Senior Government Advocate for the
respondent No.5, has also subscribed to the submission advanced by
Mr. Goswami, learned counsel for the appellant. She submits that as
per the letter dated 12.08.2025 of the District Transport Officer,
Bongaigaon, in the particulars of the vehicle bearing Registration No.
AS-16A-4510, has mentioned nothing about the insurer of the said
vehicle, and that might be the reason for planting another vehicle, in
place of the actual vehicle.
8.
However, Mr. Khan, learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1
and 2, has opposed the submission, so advanced by Mr. Goswami,
learned counsel for the appellant and by Ms. Barman, learned Addl.
Senior Government Advocate. According to Mr. Khan, in the
Bongaigaon PS case No. 675/2015, charge sheet has already been
filed after due investigation and the witnesses have also been
examined, and none of the witnesses deposed about investigation of
the vehicle mentioned in the GD Entry No. 334, dated 7-07-2015, and
this is nothing but an error of clerical in nature, and as such, the
evidence adduced during the trial of MAC Case No. 63/2016 will prevail
and as such, he has contended to dismiss this appeal by affirming the
impugned judgment and award of the Tribunal.
8.1.
In support of his submission, Mr. Khan has referred to the
following decisions:
(i)
Geeta Dubey and Ors. VS. United India
Insurance Co. Ltd. and Ors., in Civil Appeal
of 2024 [@Special Leave Petition (Civil) No.
8551 of 2024].
(ii) National
Insurance
Company
Ltd.
vs.
Chamundeswari and Ors., in Civil Appeal No.
6151 of 2021.
(iii) Smti. Chuto Gaur and 3 Ors. Vs. National
Insurance Company Ltd. and Ors., in MACApp.
No. 437/2018.
(iv) Janabai WD/o Dinkarrao Ghorpade and Ors. vs.
ICICI Lambord Insurance Company Limited,
reported in (2022) 10 SCC 512.
(v) Bimla Devi and Ors. Vs. Himachal Road Transport
Corporation and Ors., reported in (2009) 13
SCC 530.
9.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the
parties, this Court has carefully gone through the memo of appeal and
the grounds mentioned therein, and also perused the record received
from the learned Tribunal and also the original G.D. registers, received
from Bongaigaon P.S. and produced by Ms. Barman, learned Addl.
Senior Government Advocate before this Court, and also gone through
the record of Bongaigaon P.S. Case No. 675/2015, and this Court finds
sufficient force in the submission of Mr. Goswami, learned counsel for
the appellant.
10.
It is not in dispute that the accident took place on 07.07.2015,
at about 07:20 p.m., and the said accident was reported to the Officer
In-charge of Bongaigaon P.S., upon which G.D. Entry No.330, dated
07.07.2015, at 8:20 p.m. was recorded by him, and thereafter, he
endorsed traffic S.I., R. Bhuyan to investigate the matter. Accordingly,
S.I. R. Bhuyan, had visited the place of occurrence and thereafter, he
returned to the police station taking the motorcycle, bearing taking
Registration No.AS-16A-4510, involved in the accident with him and
reported that the said motorcycle had knocked down a person, who
was proceeding in the same direction on his bicycle, and the rider of
the bicycle as well as of the motorcycle both sustained injuries and the
local people had sent both of them to Lower Assam Hospital for
treatment by 108, and on the basis of the said report, G.D. Entry
No.334, 07.07.2015, at about 10:05 p.m. at night was recorded.
11.
But, interestingly, after 42 days of the said accident, one FIR
was filed with the police station, wherein the number of the
motorcycle involved in the said accident, was mentioned as AS-19H0349, upon which Bongaigaon P.S. Case No.675/2015, dated
18.08.2015 was registered, under Sections 279/304A IPC and after
investigation, charge-sheet was submitted against the rider of the said
motor cycle bearing registration No. AS-19H-0349.
It also appears
that the I.O. of Bongaigaon P.S. Case No.675/2015, was examined as
D.W.2 and he admitted the factum of registration of G.D. Entry
No.334, dated 07.07.2015, and the number of motorcycle mentioned
therein, however, he explained that the registration number of the
vehicle had wrongly been mentioned in the G.D. Entry No.334, dated
07.07.2015. This explanation, so offered by the I.O., is found not at all
acceptable, in view of the G.D. Entry No. 334 dated 07.07.2015. And it
raises serious doubt about the very involvement of the motor cycle
bearing No. AS-19H-0349, in the said accident. Mr. Goswami, learned
counsel for the appellant has rightly pointed this out and this Court
find substance in the same.
12. Thus, commission of fraud, either by the informant, who lodged
the FIR, or by the I.0., who investigated the case and submitted the
charge sheet in Bongaigaon P.S. Case No.675/2015, is writ large on
the face of the record. And that being so, fastening of liability upon
the insurer of the motor cycle, bearing registration No. AS-19H-0349,
i.e. the appellant herein, by the learned Tribunal, on the basis of the
charge-sheet and evidence led, appears to be unsustainable in law.
13.
It is well settled in a catena of decisions of Hon‟ble Supreme
Court that fraud vitiates everything. One such decision is Bhaurao
Dagdu Paralkar vs. State of Maharashtra reported in (2005)
7 SCC 605, wherein the foundational understanding of what
constitutes fraud in legal proceedings has been dealt with. The Court's
exposition in paragraph 9 is particularly illuminating and is extracted
herein below: “9. By 'fraud' is meant an intention to deceive;
whether it is from any expectation of advantage
to the party himself or from ill will towards the
other is immaterial. The expression 'fraud'
involves two elements, deceit and injury to the
person deceived. Injury is something other than
economic loss, that is, deprivation of property,
whether movable or immovable or of money and it
will include any harm whatever caused to any
person in body, mind, reputation or such others."
13.1.
This definition reveals several crucial aspects of legal fraud.
First, the motivation behind fraud is irrelevant—whether driven by
greed or malice, fraud remains fraud. Second, fraud requires both
deceptive conduct and resulting injury. Third, injury extends beyond
economic loss to encompass any form of harm, reflecting fraud's
comprehensive corrupting effect.
13.2.
The core principle with remarkable clarity is articulated in
paragraph 11 of the said decision as under:"'Fraud' as is well known vitiates every solemn
act. Fraud and justice never dwell together.
Fraud is a conduct either by letters or words,
which induces the other person or authority to
take a definite determinative stand as a response
to the conduct of the former either by words or
letters.
It
is
also
well
settled
that
misrepresentation
itself
amounts
to
fraud.
Indeed, innocent misrepresentation may also give
reason to claim relief against fraud."
13.3. The phrase "fraud and justice never dwell together" (fraus et
jus nunquam cohabitant) captures the fundamental incompatibility
between deception and justice. This ancient maxim, has never lost its
temper over all these centuries, and continues to guide judicial
thinking. And this has been noted in Meghmala and Ors. vs. G.
Narasimha Reddy and Ors., reported in (2010) 8 SCC 383 by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The Court's observation that even
innocent misrepresentation may constitute fraud demonstrates the
law's concern with protecting the integrity of judicial proceedings
rather than merely punishing malicious conduct. This approach
ensures that courts are not misled, whether through deliberate
deception or careless falsehood.
13.4. Again, Hon‟ble Supreme Court in A.V. Papayya Sastry and
Ors. vs. Govt. of A.P. and Ors., reported in (2007) 4 SCC
221 provided comprehensive exposition of this doctrine. The Court
began by invoking Chief Justice Edward Coke's three-century-old
proclamation: - 4 - "Fraud avoids all judicial acts, ecclesiastical or
temporal." Building on this foundation, the Court held in paragraph 22
as under:“22. It is thus settled proposition of law
that a judgment, decree or order obtained by
playing fraud on the court, tribunal or
authority is a nullity and non est in the eye
of the law. Such a judgment, decree or order—
by the first court or by the final court—has
to be treated as nullity by every court,
superior or inferior. It can be challenged in
any court, at any time, in appeal, revision,
writ or even in collateral proceedings."
13.5.
This principle has extraordinary implications. A fraudulently
obtained order is not merely voidable—it is void ab initio. It never had
legal existence. This nullity can be raised at any stage, in any
proceedings, by any court. No limitation period applies, no principle of
finality protects it.
14.
It is a fact that such a plea of fraud was not taken before the
learned Tribunal, by the appellant herein. But, such plea is taken in
the ground Nos.3, 4 and 5 in the present appeal. And in view of the
dictum in the case of A.V. Papayya Sastry(supra) no fault can be
found with the appellant in raising issue before this Court, in this
appeal. It is well settled that it can be challenged in any court, at any
time, in appeal, revision, writ or even in collateral proceedings. In that
view of the matter, the impugned judgment and award dated
07.09.2021, requires interference of this Court.
15.
In the result, this Court finds sufficient merit in the appeal and
accordingly, the same stands allowed. The impugned judgment and
award dated 07.09.2021, passed by the learned Tribunal in MAC Case
No. 63/2016, stands set aside and quashed.
16. It is worth mentioning in this context that Rule 23-A of Order XLI
CPC allows the remand of a case even when the lower court disposed
of the same on grounds other than a preliminary point, if the appellate
court deems it necessary in the interests of justice. In the instant case,
in view of the submissions of Mr. Goswami, learned counsel for the
appellant and Ms. Barman, learned Addl. Senior Govt. Advocate for the
respondent No. 5, and also in the interest of justice, this Court deems
it necessary and also ordered accordingly to remand the matter to the
learned Tribunal, with a direction to proceed against the owner/rider
of the motor cycle bearing registration No. AS-16A-4510, as mentioned
in the G.D. Entry No. 334, dated 07.07.2015, namely, Jakariya
Champramary, as is apparent from the letter of the District Transport
Officer, dated 12.08.2025, by impleading him as opposite party No.4,
in the said MAC case. And if the particulars of the insurer of the said
motorcycle, bearing registration No. AS-16A-4510 are furnished, then
the said insurance company shall also be impleaded as respondent No.
5. It is further provided that the learned tribunal shall frame an issue
as to which of the motorcycle i.e. motorcycle, bearing registration No.
AS-16A-4510 or bearing registration No. AS-19H-0349, was involved in
the accident and after adjudication of the same, a fresh judgment and
award shall be passed. While adjudicating the issue
reasonable
opportunity of being heard shall also be afforded to both the parties,
and also to lead evidence, if found necessary.
17. This Court has considered the submissions of Mr. Khan, learned
counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 and 2, and also the decisions
referred by him. And in view of the aforesaid discussion and findings,
this Court is unable to record concurrence with the same, due to the
fact that fraud has been pleaded, and also shown to have been played
and it is well settled that fraud vitiates everything.
18.
Further, it is provided that the matter shall also be referred to
the Special Investigation Team, Assam constituted as per the
observation made by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Safiq
Ahmad Vs. ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. &
Others, in Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 1110 of
2017, to investigate commission of fraud in the present case by
planting a different motorcycle bearing registration No. AS-19H-0349,
in place of the motorcycle bearing registration No. AS-16A-4510, which
in fact shown to have been involved in the accident leading to the
death of Bhupesh Chandra Das, as per the G.D. Entry No. 334, dated
07.07.2015.
19.
The Registry shall return the case record to the learned Tribunal
by a special messenger. On receipt of the same, the learned Tribunal
shall proceed with the same as directed herein above and also in
accordance with law, and shall make an endeavour to complete the
hearing as soon as practicable. Further, it is provided that the registry
shall also forward a copy of this judgment and order to the Special
Investigation Team, Assam for compliance of the direction mentioned
in para No. 18 of this judgment and order.
20. In terms of above, this appeal stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review