Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:315
KUNAL
DEWANGAN
Digitally
signed by
KUNAL
DEWANGAN
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRR No. 1290 of 2022
Ibteshar Ahmed Khan S/o Shri Hazi Iftekhar Ahmed Khan Aged About 47
Years R/o- Kharmora, Korba, Tahsil - Korba, District - Korba Chhattisgarh
... Applicant(s)
versus
1 - Shabana Khan D/o - Mohammad Hanif Khan, Aged About 38 Years
R/o - Infront Of Petrol Pump, Rajendra Path, Vaishali, Nagar, Kusmunda,
Tahsil - Katghora, District - Korba Chhattisgarh
2 - Kumari Sumaila Parveen, D/o Ibteshar Ahmed Khan, Aged About 8
Years 06 Months, R/o - Infront Of Petrol Pump, Rajendra Path, Vaishali,
Nagar, Kusmunda, Tahsil - Katghora, District - Korba Chhattisgarh
... Non-applicant(s)
For Applicant
:
Ms. Ruchi Nagar, Advocate
For Non-applicant
:
None
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Order on Board
05.01.2026
1. By way of this revision, the applicant has prayed for following relief:
“It is therefore prayed that this Hon’ble Court may kindly
be pleased to allow this revision and set aside the
impugned order dated 07.09.2021 passed by the learned
Judge, Family Court, Korba, District-Korba (C.G) in
Miscellaneous Criminal Case No. 41/2019 in the case
title “Ibteshar Ahmed Khan Vs. Shabana Khan and
another” (AnnexureP/1) in the interest of justice.”
2. Brief facts of the case are that it is an admitted fact that the non-
applicants filed an application under Section 125 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure seeking maintenance, which was registered as
Case No. 15/11, and vide order dated 17.10.2014, a total sum of Rs.
8,000/- per month was awarded as maintenance. Thereafter, the
non-applicants preferred an application under Section 127 Cr.P.C.
for enhancement of maintenance, registered as Case No. 236/16,
and vide order dated 08.08.2017, the maintenance amount was
enhanced to Rs. 11,500/- per month.
Except for the aforesaid admitted facts, the remaining
allegations are specifically denied. The case of the applicant, as set
out in the present application, is that upon obtaining information
under the Right to Information Act, it was revealed that non-applicant
No. 1 had not admitted any girl named “Sumaila Parveen” in any
school, nor was such child studying in any school. Despite this, the
applicant has been paying an amount of Rs. 3,500/- per month to
non-applicant No. 2 towards education and maintenance. Since nonapplicant No. 2 is not studying in any school, continuation of the said
expenditure is wholly unwarranted and deserves to be stopped
forthwith. It is further contended that non-applicant No. 1 does not
have any daughter named Sumaila Parveen, nor is she educating
any such child, whereas Sumaila Parveen is, in fact, the biological
daughter of the applicant, and maintenance has been awarded by
the learned Family Court expressly in her name. The applicant
asserts that non-applicant No. 1 is employed as a teacher at Beacon
School, Kusmunda, from where she earns approximately Rs. 4,000/per month, with a clear possibility of future increments, and therefore
she is not entitled to receive any maintenance. The applicant has
further pleaded that Sumaila Parveen is his daughter and that after
non-applicants No. 1 and 2 started living separately from him since
the night of 01.10.2010 and after divorce on 23.04.2011, nonapplicant No. 1 gave birth to another daughter in the year 2013,
whom she named “Kumari Laiba Khan”. However, with an intention
to mislead the Court, non-applicant No. 1 falsely showed the date of
birth of Laiba Khan as 02.08.2010, whereas the applicant’s daughter
Sumaila Parveen was born by surgical operation on 02.08.2010 at
D.K. Hospital, Korba. In contrast, the birth certificate of Laiba Khan
was obtained showing her birth at Vaishali Nagar, Kusmunda, on the
basis of afÏdavits, panchanama and hospital records, thereby
committing fraud upon the Court.
It is alleged that by suppressing true facts and misrepresenting
identity, non-applicant No. 1 has been illegally recovering
maintenance for herself and for a child to whom she is not legally
entitled. The applicant further submits that no birth certificate of the
child allegedly studying in school has been submitted to the school
authorities, and the entire claim of education expenses is based on
falsehood. Thus, non-applicant No. 1 has committed gross fraud,
and therefore the entire maintenance amount of Rs. 8,000/- per
month being deducted from the applicant’s salary along with Rs.
3,500/- paid in cash towards alleged arrears deserves to be stopped
immediately, and the amount recovered from 17.10.2014 till date be
directed to be refunded to the applicant. The applicant has further
averred that he has no knowledge as to the present whereabouts of
his daughter, who has never been produced before the Court, nor
has he been afforded any opportunity to see or interact with her
despite repeated requests. The applicant has contracted a second
marriage and has a minor daughter aged about one year and six
months, whose maintenance expenses are also being borne by him.
Therefore, in view of the fact that non-applicant No. 1 gave birth to
another daughter after divorce, the applicant prays that the entire
maintenance amount be stopped and the recovered amount be
refunded.
3. In reply, the non-applicants admitted only the facts stated in
paragraph 02 of their reply and denied all other allegations. They
contended that the applicant has been regularly paying maintenance
and asserted that when the case was initially filed, the name of their
daughter was mentioned as “Kumari Sumaila Parveen”, being a
newborn, and later her school name was recorded as “Laiba Khan”,
with the applicant’s knowledge. It was claimed that the applicant
never objected earlier, and that presently the child, known as
Sumaila Parveen alias Laiba Khan, is studying in Class IV at Beacon
School, Kusmunda. It was also stated that non-applicant No. 1 was
working as a temporary teacher and was called only as and when
required. The non-applicants further stated that non-applicant No. 1
has no permanent employment, has not contracted any second
marriage and that the present application has been filed by the
applicant solely with an intention to avoid payment of maintenance. It
was pleaded that the applicant had earlier also initiated proceedings
to evade maintenance and that the present application, being based
on false and concocted facts, is not maintainable. It was further
contended that the non-applicants have no independent source of
income and rejection of the applicant’s application is necessary in
the interest of justice, failing which they would suffer irreparable loss.
4. After appreciating the documents and material available on record
and on the basis of the aforesaid analysis of evidence and the
conclusions reached on the points for consideration, it is found that
the applicant has failed to substantiate his application. Accordingly,
the applicant’s application was rejected. Hence, this revision.
5. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the learned Family
Court has erred in law as well as on facts while passing the
impugned order dated 07.09.2021, as it failed to properly appreciate
the material placed on record. It is contended that, pursuant to
information obtained under the Right to Information Act from the
ofÏce of the Principal, Beacon English Higher Secondary School,
Kusmunda, District Korba (C.G.), it has been categorically stated
that non-applicant No.1 has neither admitted non-applicant No.2, her
alleged daughter, in the said school nor is she studying there, as
evidenced by the letter dated 12.02.2019 (Annexure-P/2). Despite
this, non-applicant No.1 is receiving a sum of Rs.3,500/- per month
towards the educational expenses of non-applicant No.2, and since
non-applicant No.2 is not studying in any school, the continuation of
maintenance awarded in her favour is wholly unjustified. It is further
submitted that non-applicant No.1 has no daughter in the name of
Sumaila Parveen studying in the said school, whereas Sumaila
Parveen is, in fact, the real daughter of the applicant and the learned
Family Court has erroneously awarded maintenance in her favour, as
is evident from its own order. The learned Family Court also failed to
consider that non-applicant No.1 is working as a Teacher at Beacon
School, Kusmunda, drawing a salary of Rs.4,000/- per month with
prospects of increment, thereby disentitling her from claiming
maintenance from the applicant. It is further submitted that the nonapplicants have been living separately from the applicant since
01.10.2010 and, after divorce on 23.04.2011, continued to reside
separately, that a daughter born in the year 2013 was named Kumari
Layba Khan, whose date of birth was falsely shown as 02.08.2010
with an intention to mislead the Court, whereas the applicant’s real
daughter was born on 02.08.2010 at D.K. Hospital, Korba, which is
clearly established from the medical certificate, statements of nonapplicant No.1 and the birth certificate filed collectively as AnnexureP/3. It is thus submitted that non-applicant No.1 suppressed material
facts and obtained the order of maintenance by misrepresentation,
ignoring the documents which clearly demonstrate that Sumaila
Parveen is not the daughter on whose behalf maintenance could
have been claimed. She further submits that detailed written
arguments highlighting these facts were filed before the learned
Family Court on 02.09.2021, clearly stating that out of the two
daughters of non-applicant No.1, only non-applicant No.2 is alleged
to be the real daughter of the applicant, a copy whereof is filed as
Annexure-P/4. Accordingly, she prays that the impugned order is
illegal and perverse and is liable to be set-aside.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the applicant, perused the
impugned order and other documents appended with revision.
7. From perusal of the impugned order it transpires that the learned
Family Court has duly considered the pleadings of the parties and
properly appreciated the oral and documentary evidence on record,
including the income, employment and capacity of non-applicant
No.01, as well as the evidence relating to the identity and
maintenance of the minor child. The learned Family Court has rightly
recorded that the applicant failed to establish that the minor child is
not his daughter or that the non-applicants are having sufÏcient
independent income to maintain themselves.
8.
Considering the submission advanced by the learned counsel for the
applicant and perusing the impugned orders and the finding
recorded by the learned Family Court, I am of the view that the
learned Family Court has not committed any illegality or infirmity or
jurisdictional error in the impugned order warranting interference by
this Court.
9. Accordingly, the revision being devoid of merit is liable to be and is
hereby dismissed.
10. OfÏce is directed to send a copy of this order to the concerned Family
Court for necessary information and compliance.
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
Kunal
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review