Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 78 of 2020 with
WP(C) No. 79 of 2020
WP(C) No. 80 of 2020
WP(C) No. 81 of 2020
WP(C) No. 82 of 2020
WP(C) No. 83 of 2020
WP(C) No. 84 of 2020
WP(C) No. 85 of 2020
WP(C) No. 86 of 2020
Date of Decision: 28.03.2023
Shri Paul Lyngdoh Nonglait
Vs.
Shri Artones Lyngdoh
Vs.
Smti Ephilinda Lyngdoh Mawnai Vs.
Smti Bunsity Lyngkhoi
Vs.
Smti Saradadeihun K. Buki
Vs.
Shri Rockcliff John Nongrum
Vs.
Smti Simple Marbaniang
Vs.
Smti Listina Basaiawmoit
Vs.
Smti Iamonlang Marbaniang
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. R. Gurung, Adv.
Ms. A.A. Sangma, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Ms. S. Bhattacharjee, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
These writ petitions being similar and based on identical
facts, are being disposed by this common Judgment and Order.
2.
The facts in brief are that the writ petitioners were appointed
in Grade-IV posts temporarily in different Community Health Centres and
Primary Health Centres in West Khasi Hills, Meghalaya, as detailed in the
table below.
Sl.
No
1.
Name & Designation
Appointment
letter No. & Date
No. NST/1-7/
2014-15/3014, Dt.
19.06.2014
No. NST/1-7/
2013-14/8708, Dt.
05.12.2013
No. NST/1-7/
2013-14/8624, Dt.
03.12.2013
Place of
Posting
Nongstoin
CHC
No. NST/1-7/
2012-13/5113, Dt.
27.08.2013
Smti Saradadeihun K. No. NST/1-7/
Buki, Peon
2013-14/7407, Dt.
04.11.2013
Shri Rock Cliff John
No. NST/1-7/
Nongrum, Ward
2012/532,
Attendant
Dt. 01.04.2013
Smti Simple
No. NST/1-7/
Marbaniang, Stretcher
2012-13/3713,
Bearer
Dt. 5.07.2013
Smti Listina
No. NST/1-7/
Basaiawmoit, Ward Girl 2012/557,
Dt. 02.04.2013
Smti Iamonlang
No. NST/1-7/
2012-13/3583,
Marbaniang, Stretcher
Bearer (Compassionate
Dt. 02.07.2013
Ground)
Shri Paul Lyngdoh
Nonglait, Handyman
2.
Shri Artones Lyngdoh,
Cook
3.
Smti Ephilinda L.
Mawnai, Ward
Attendant
(Compassionate
Ground)
Smti Bunsity Lyngkhoi,
Ward Girl
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Last renewal
15.07.2017
Laitdom PHC
16.10.2018
Laitdom PHC
21.06.2017
Mawkyrwat
CHC
17.06.2017
Mawthawpdah 31.05.2017
PHC
Mairang CHC
19.10.2018
Mairang CHC
11.10.2017
Mairang CHC
07.07.2017
Mairang CHC
04.08.2017
As can be seen from the table, their appointments were
renewed from time to time, but after 2017/18, there was no further renewal.
The petitioners being aggrieved with the non-renewal of their
temporary/officiating appointments, apart from the allegations that in their
place new ad-hoc appointees have been accommodated, are therefore
before this Court by way of the instant writ petitions.
3.
Mr. R. Gurung, learned counsel for the petitioners while taking
up the first writ petition, has argued that the non-renewal of the services of
the writ petitioners is based purely on extraneous considerations, inasmuch
as, on an earlier occasion, on the non-release of their salaries, the writ
petitioner and the other writ petitioners, in all the other connected writ
petitions, had approached this Court, which by order dated 15.11.2018,
directed the respondents to release the due salary for the period that duties
had been discharged. It is submitted, that this resulted in the writ petitioners
being targeted for hostile treatment, whereby by the impugned letter dated
19.02.2019, issued by the respondent No. 3, instructions were given to the
District Medical & Health Officer, West Khasi Hills District, Nongstoin not
to make new appointments, or to renew such appointments, without the
approval of the competent authority. The learned counsel contends that the
non-renewal of the petitioners’ employment is therefore punitive in nature.
4.
It has also been further submitted that, after the appointments
had been discontinued in the case of the writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 78
of 2020, WP(C) No. 79 of 2020, WP(C) No. 80 of 2020, WP(C) No. 81 of
2020, WP(C) No. 83 of 2020 WP(C) No. 84 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 86 of
2020, fresh ad-hoc appointees have been appointed in the place of the writ
petitioners by various orders, ranging from 24.06.2019 to 15.07.2019. This
he submits is against all canons of settled law, as an ad-hoc cannot replace
another ad-hoc. Submissions have also been made that in the case of two
writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 80 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 86 of 2020, whose
appointments were on compassionate grounds, their services had also not
been renewed. He therefore prays that necessary orders may be passed to
set aside the impugned orders and to reinstate the writ petitioners into their
posts.
5.
Ms. S. Bhattacharjee, learned GA, has submitted that the writ
petitioners have no semblance of any right, as the appointments were purely
temporary on a 3-month basis, and that having accepted the terms of
temporary appointments, the petitioners are estopped from seeking any
extension or regularization. With regard to the allegation of one ad-hoc
replacing another, it has been submitted that the same were not made in lieu
of the writ petitioners, and the private respondents were allowed to officiate
in certain posts on being appointed by the competent authority, pending the
recommendation of regular staff by the District Selection Committee.
Passing submissions have also been made as to the purported negligence of
the writ petitioners, in attending to their duties. She finally submits that the
writ petitioners having acquired no vested right, the writ petitions are
without any merit and liable to dismissed.
6.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties.
7.
It is noted firstly that the petitioners, whose appointments as
per the table detailed in Para 2 above, commenced from 01.04.2013, in the
case of writ petitioner in WP(C) 83 of 2020, with the last one made in
19.06.2014, of the writ petitioner in WP(C) No. 78 of 2020, were not
renewed after 2017, in the case of 7 writ petitioners, and the 2 others were
not renewed after 2018. It is further noted that as submitted, the same writ
petitioners herein, had approached this Court for non-release of their
pending salaries, wherein this Court observed that the factum of the
petitioners working till the year 2017, was supported by renewal orders
issued by the concerned respondent, and ordered that for the period that
they had been discharging their duties, their salary be released which was
accordingly complied with by the respondents.
8.
Coming to the impugned letter 19.02.2019, which the
petitioners allege, has been the cause for the non-renewal of their services,
the same for the sake of convenience is reproduced hereinbelow: “GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICEC (MI)
MEGHALAYA, SHILLONG
No. HSM/ESTT/NGZT/CC/DIST/31/32408,
From :
Dated Shillong, the 19/2/2019
The Director of Health Services (MI)
Meghalaya, Shillong
To,
The District Medical & Health Officer,
West Khasi Hills, Nongstoin.
Sub :
Judgment and Order dated 15.11.2018
Sir,
In
continuation
of
this
Directorate’s
letter
No.
HSM/ESTT/NGZT/CC/DIST/31, dated 19/2/2019 I request you to comply to the
court order dated 15.11.2018 thereby releasing their pay and allowances only for
the periods as per the appointment orders issued. Further, you are hereby
instructed that no new appointments/renewal of Service will be made without prior
approval from the Competent Authority.
This is for your information and necessary action.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/Director of Health Services (MI)
Meghalaya, Shillong”
A perusal of the letter in the opinion of this Court, does not
support the contentions of the writ petitioners, inasmuch as, apart from
directing for compliance of the order of this Court dated 15.11.2018, it only
further gives instructions to the concerned District Medical & Health
Officer, that any new appointment or renewal of service, was to be done
only with the approval from the competent authority i.e. the respondent No.
3 herein (Director of Health Services, MI). This to the mind of the Court, is
because all the temporary appointments of the writ petitioners had been
done at the District level by the District Medical & Health Officer.
9.
On the other aspect, i.e. the allegation that the writ petitioners
had been replaced by fresh adhoc appointees; on examination of the writ
petitions, it is revealed that the writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 80 of 2020
and
WP(C)
No.
of
have
both
assailed
the
same
appointment order No. HSM/ESTT/NGZT/WKH/Offtng/65/18/10292,
dated 15.07.2019 appointing one Smti Telbi Ryntathiang in their place.
Similarly, in WP(C) No. 84 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 86 of 2020, the writ
petitioners have assailed the same appointment order being No.
HSM/ESTT/NGZT/WKH/Offtng/65/18/10285,
dated
15.07.2019
appointing one Shri Bonyfast Wahlang in their place. In WP(C) No. 82 of
2020, however, no such allegation has been made that any ad-hoc
appointment in place of the petitioner has taken place. The fact that these
appointments have been made in 2019, after a considerable period of time
had lapsed after the expiry of the terms of the writ petitioners’ appointments
cannot be ignored, as also the fact that no concrete nexus has been shown
by the writ petitioners to substantiate their stand, inasmuch as, in 4 of the
writ petitions mentioned above, common challenge has been made to orders
of appointment of 2 persons. With the efflux of time, however, any glimmer
of vested right for continuation in the said posts, on this point raised by the
writ petitioners, to the mind of the Court, has also been extinguished and
become nonexistent.
10.
From the affidavit it has been seen that the respondents have
also made a reference to the deficiencies in the discharge of duties in the
case of the writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 78 of 2020, WP(C) No. 79 of
2020, WP(C) No. 81 of 2020, WP(C) No. 83 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 84 of
2020, but this passing reference will not amount to the accrual of any right
by the writ the petitioners, to demand for a hearing on the non-renewal of
their services, inasmuch as, there are no orders that spell out that the reason
for dis-continuance, is strictly due to their negligence to duties, nor have
the writ petitioners pleaded or taken up this issue in the main writ petition.
11.
On the last point advanced that is that appointments made on
compassionate grounds were also discontinued, it is observed that any
appointment made de hors a scheme or policy, will in no manner cloak the
beneficiaries with any right to continuance of ad-hoc appointment, more so,
with the compassionate scheme for appointment being discontinued in the
State of Meghalaya since 2010.
12.
Accordingly, in view of the facts and circumstances of the case
and as the purely ad-hoc appointments of the writ petitioners having not
been renewed after 2017-2018, no case has been made out for any
interference and all the writ petitions stand dismissed.
13.
There shall however be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
28.03.2023
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review