Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010444182025
2026:CGHC:36406-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ARBA No. 73 of 2025
Hriday Narayan Singh Died Through Legal Heir
1. Ganesh S/o Hriday Narayan Singh Aged About 60 Years
2 - Dev Narayan S/o Hriday Narayan Singh Aged About 52 Years
3 - Vyas Narayan S/o Hriday Narayan Singh Aged About 43 Years
All are R/o Village Singhiya Tahsil Podi Uproda District Korba C.G.
--- Appellants
versus
1 - Union Of India Through Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction) South East
Central Railway Bilaspur C.G.
2 - Sub Divisional Officer Revenue Cum Land Acquisition Officer Podi Uproda
District Korba C.G.
--- Respondents
For Appellants
: Mr. Vikas Pandey, Advocate
For Respondent No.1
: Mr. Ramakant Mishra, DSGI
For State/Respondent No.2
: Mr. Atanu Ghosh, Dy.Govt. Advocate
Division Bench
Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
Hon'ble Shri Sachin Singh Rajput, Judge
Order On Board
Per Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
BALRAM
PRASAD
DEWANGAN
Digitally
signed by
BALRAM
PRASAD
DEWANGAN
14.08.2026
1.
This arbitration appeal is filed against the judgment/order dated
05.03.2025, passed in MJC Case No. 290 of 2022, passed by 2 nd
District Judge (Commercial Court), District Judge Level District Bilaspur
(C.G.) arising out of the order dated 07.04.2022, passed by the
Arbitrator/Additional Commissioner, Bilaspur Division, Bilaspur (C.G.)
in case No.09/A-82/2021-2022.
2.
Facts relevant for the disposal of this appeal are that appellants are
legal representatives of deceased Hridaya Narayan Singh, whose land
bearing Kh. No. 53/2 and 75/3 area 0.178 and 0.020 hectare total area
0.198 hectares situated at Village Singhiya, P.H. No.34, R.I. Circle Podi
Uproda, District Korba was acquired by Indian Railways for
construction of Gevera Road to Pendra Road under East Rail Corridor,
Special Rail Project of Government of India under the Indian Railways
Act, 1989. Land Acquisition Officer, determined the compensation and
awarded compensation of Rs.6,37,814/- in favour of father of
appellants vide order dated 02.06.2016. Feeling aggrieved by the
quantum of compensation awarded, father of appellants filed an
application
before
the
Arbitrator-cum-Additional
Commissioner,
Bilaspur Division, Bilaspur, seeking enhancement of the award amount
under Section 20F the Railways Act, 1989. The Arbitrator, after
considering the grounds raised by appellant has allowed the
application for enhancement of compensation awarded by Land
Acquisition Officer holding that the compensation assessed by the
Land Acquisition Officer was not in accordance with the prevailing
market rate. Aggrieved by the award dated 07.04.2022 passed by the
Arbitrator, the respondent No.1 thereafter filed an application under
Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (In short ‘the
Act of 1996’) before the Court of District Judge, Bilaspur, which was
entertained by the said Court and notices were issued to the
respondent. However, on 07.02.2024 in light of the notification dated
20.12.2023 issued by the State Government through the Law and
Legislative Affairs Department, it was held that since the value of the
present dispute falls in between 10 lakhs to fifty lakhs, transferred the
case to Commercial Court (District Judge Level), Bilaspur. Vide
impugned order dated 05.03.2025,
learned 2nd Additional District
Judge, Commercial Court (District Judge Level), Bilaspur allowed the
application filed by respondent No.1 U/s. 34 of the Act of 1996, set
aside the order of Arbitrator dated 07.04.2022.
3.
Learned counsel for the appellants would submit that the impugned
order passed by the 2nd Additional District Judge, Commercial Court
(District Judge Level), Bilaspur, setting aside the order of the Arbitrator,
is bad in law and erroneous. He also submits that order impugned
passed by the Commercial Court is not sustainable on the ground of
jurisdiction of Commercial Court under the Commercial Courts Act,
2015 as the proceeding before the Commercial Court is arising out of
the dispute of disbursement of compensation against acquisition of
land. He contended that dispute is not of commercial dispute,
therefore, Commercial Court is not having jurisdiction to consider the
case as filed by respondent No.1/herein because the respondent No.1
dissatisfied with the enhancement of the award by the Arbitrator in
favour of appellants has filed an application U/s. 34 of the Act of 1996.
In support of his contention, he placed reliance upon the decision of
Coordinate Bench of this Court in case of Anand Khedia & Ors. Vs.
Commissioner-cum-Arbitrator, Bilaspur, Division Bilaspur, in
Arbitration Appeal No. 26 of 2025, decided on 22.04.2026.
4.
Learned counsel for respondents opposes the submission of learned
counsel for appellants and supports the impugned order. They
however, submits that in absence of any notification issued by the
Central Government under Section 2 (1) (c) (xxii) covering arbitration
dispute governed by the provisions of the Act of 2015, the proceedings
initiated by the respondent No.1 under Section 34 of the Act of 1996
were not maintainable before the Commercial Court, and that the
appropriate authority competent to consider the application filed U/s.
34 of the Act of 1996 would be the Principal District Judge, Bilaspur.
5.
We have heard learned counsel for parties and also perused the
records of this appeal.
6.
Perusal of record of MJC No.290 of 2022 would show that on
08.07.2022, Principal District Judge, Bilaspur had registered the case
filed by appellant therein under Section 34 of the Act of 1996
challenging
the
order
of Arbitrator-cum-Commissioner,
Bilaspur
Division, Bilaspur in case No.09/A-82/2021-2022, dated 07.04.2022.
During the course of proceedings, Principal District Judge, Bilaspur in
its order-sheet dated 07.02.2024 considering the letter/circular dated
21.12.2023, has transferred the case to the Commercial Court (District
Judge Level) Bilaspur and accordingly the proceedings was concluded
and impugned order is passed.
7.
Similar facts came up for consideration before the Coordinate Bench of
this Court in which one of us (Justice Sachin Singh Rajput) was
member, in case of Anand Khedia (supra), wherein it observed
thus :“6.
The short question involved for consideration in this
appeal is, “whether the award passed by the Statutory
Arbitrator under Section 3G(7) of the Act of 1956 can be
questioned through an application under Section 34 of the
Act of 1996 ? If yes, which would be the competent Court to
hear and decide the said application ?”
7.
In order to consider the plea raised at the Bar, it
would firstly be appropriate to notice the provisions
contained under the National Highways Act, 1956. The Act
of 1956, being a complete code in itself, provides for a
grievance redressal mechanism. Sections 3G (5), (6) and
(7) of the Act of 1956 directly relates to calculation of
compensation related grievances and state as under :“3G. Determination
compensation. –
(1) to (4)
of
XXX
amount
payable
as
XXX
(5) If the amount determined by the competent authority
under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) is not
acceptable to either of the parties, the amount shall on
an application by either of the parties, be determined by
the arbitrator to be appointed by the Central
Government.
(6) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the provisions of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996)
shall apply to every arbitration under this Act.
(7) The competent authority or the arbitrator while
determining the amount under sub-section (1) or subsection (5) as the case may be, shall take into
consideration (a) the market value of the land on the date of
publication of the notification under section 3A;
(b) the damage, if any, sustained by the person
interested at the time of taking possession of the land,
by reason of the severing of such land from other
land;
(c) the damage, if any, sustained by the person
interested at the time of taking possession of the land,
by reason of the acquisition injuriously affecting his
other immovable property in any manner, or his
earnings;
(d) if any, consequences of acquisition of the land, the
person interested is compelled to change his
residence or place of business, the reasonable
expenses, if any, incidental to such change.”
8.
As per Section 3G(5) of the Act of 1956, if the
amount determined by the competent authority is not
acceptable to either of the parties, the amount shall on an
application by either of the parties, be determined by the
arbitrator to be appointed by the Central Government. In
the instant case, the Commissioner, Bilaspur Division has
been appointed to be Statutory Arbitrator for resolving the
dispute under Section 3G(5) of the Act of 1956. Sub-section
(6) of Section 3G clearly mentions that subject to the
provisions of the Act of 1956, the provisions of the Act of
1996 shall apply to every arbitration under the Act of 1956.
Meaning thereby, that the order passed by the Statutory
Arbitrator can be made subject matter of proceeding under
Section 34 of the Act of 1996. There is nothing in the
scheme of Section 3G of the Act of 1956 to exclude the
application of Section 34 of the Act of 1956 vis-a-vis the
award of the Statutory Arbitrator passed under Section
3G(5) of the Act of 1956. As such, it is apparently vividly
clear that the award by the Statutory Arbitrator can be
questioned before the Court of competent jurisdiction under
Section 34 of the Act of 1996, like any other award by an
Arbitrator. The first point is answered accordingly.
9.
Coming to the second point, the order dated
13/09/2021 (Annexure A/9) passed by the Statutory
Arbitrator, Commissioner, Bilaspur Division under Section
3G(7) of the Act of 1956 was challenged by way of
application under Section 34 of the Act of 1996 before the
District Judge, Bilaspur, however, by order dated
07/02/2024, in light of the notification dated 20/12/2023
issued by the State Government through the Law and
Legislative Affairs Department, the District Judge
transferred the matter to the 2nd Additional District Judge,
Commercial Court (District Judge Level) for hearing and
disposal in accordance with law holding that the matter at
hand is a commercial dispute and therefore, Commercial
Court would be competent to resolve the said dispute.
10. At this stage, it would be appropriate to notice the
object of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 as well as the
provisions contained thereunder. The Act of 2015 is an act
to provide for the constitution of Commercial Courts,
Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division in
the High Courts for adjudicating commercial disputes of
specified value and matters connected therewith or
incidental thereto. Section 2(1)(c) of the Act of 2015 defines
commercial dispute, which states as under :-
“2. Definitions. – (1) In this Act, unless the context
otherwise requires, (a) XXX
(b) XXX
(c) “commercial dispute” means a dispute arising out of
(i) ordinary transactions of merchants, bankers,
financiers and traders such as those relating to
mercantile documents, including enforcement and
interpretation of such documents;
(ii) export or import of merchandise or services;
(iii) issues relating to admiralty and maritime law;
(iv) transactions relating to aircraft, aircraft engines,
aircraft equipment and helicopters, including sales,
leasing and financing of the same;
(v) carriage of goods;
(vi) construction and infrastructure contracts, including
tenders;
(vii) agreements relating to immovable property used
exclusively in trade or commerce;
(viii) franchising agreements;
(ix) distribution and licensing agreements;
(x) management and consultancy agreements;
(xi) joint venture agreements;
(xii) shareholders agreements;
(xiii) subscription and investment agreements
pertaining to the services industry including
outsourcing services and financial services;
(xix) exploitation of oil and gas reserves or other
natural resources including electromagnetic spectrum;
(xx) insurance and re-insurance;
(xxi) contracts of agency relating to any of the above;
and
(xxii) such other commercial disputes as may be
notified by the Central Government.”
11. Further, Section 3 of the Act of 2015 provides for
constitution of Commercial Courts. Section 6 of the Act of
2015 speaks about the jurisdiction of Commercial Court
and states that the Commercial Court shall have
jurisdiction to try all suits and applications relating to a
commercial dispute of a specified value arising out of the
entire territory of the State over which it has been vested
territorial jurisdiction.
12. A matter will fall under the jurisdiction of the
Commercial Court or the Commercial Division of the High
Court on the following two factors :(i) it shall be a commercial dispute within the meaning
of Section 2(1)(c) of the Act of 2015; and
(ii) such commercial disputes are of a specified value
as per Section 2(i) of the Act of 2015.
13. Thus, from the scheme of the Act of 2015, it is
apparent that only a commercial dispute can be tried by a
commercial Court. For a dispute to qualify as commercial
dispute, it must fall within one of the clauses of Section
2(1)(c) of the Act of 2015. A dispute will not become a
commercial dispute merely because it is an arbitration
matter and and jurisdiction in respect with an arbitration
matter has been dealt with separately under Sections 10
and 15(2) of the Act of 2015. Every application filed under
Section 34 of the Act of 1996 cannot be transferred to the
Commercial Court under Section 15(2) of the Act of 2015
and only such applications will be required to be
transferred, which are relating to a commercial dispute of a
specified value covered under Section 2(1)(c) read with
Section 2(i) of the Act of 2015.
14. Admittedly, the dispute involved in this matter is not
covered by Section 2(1)(c) clauses (i) to (xxii) of the Act of
2015. Clause (xxii) of Section 2(1)(c) of the Act of 2015
enables the Central Government to include any other
dispute in the definition of ‘commercial dispute’ by
notification. In the instant case, this Court passed the
following order on 21/04/2026 :“Mr. Ramakant Mishra, learned Deputy Solicitor
General is requested
to
obtain
instructions
from the
Central Government as to whether any
notification under Section 2(1)(c)(xxii) of the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 has been issued. He is
further requested to seek instructions on whether
disputes arising out of land acquisition for the purpose
of construction of highways have been notified as
commercial disputes by the Central Government.”
15. Today when the matter is taken up for hearing, Mr.
Ramakant Mishra, learned Deputy Solicitor General of
India, has produced the e-mail in which the Central
Government has sent him the following information :“1. No notification under Section 2(1)(c)(xxii) of the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 has been issued by the
Ministry of Road Transport & Highways.
2. Further, disputes arising out of land acquisition for
the purpose of construction of National Highways
have not been notified as commercial disputes by the
Ministry of Road Transport & Highways.”
16. In view of the aforesaid information provided by the
Central Government through learned Deputy Solicitor
General of India which has been brought on record, we
have no hesitation in holding that the dispute raised by the
appellants firstly before the Statutory Arbitrator and then
before the District Judge under Section 34 of the Act of
1996 is not a ‘commercial dispute’ within the meaning of
Section 2(1)(c) read with Section 2(i) of the Act of 2015 as
a dispute arising out of land acquisition for the purpose of
construction of National Highways under the provisions of
the Act of 1956 has not been notified by the Central
Government as commercial dispute under Section 2(1)(c)
of the Act of 2015 and therefore, learned District Judge
erred in transferring the application filed by the appellants
under Section 34 of the Act of 1996 to the Court of 2 nd
Additional District Judge, Commercial Court (District Judge
Level).
17. The Supreme Court, in the matter of Ambalal
Sarabhai Enterprise Limited v. KS Infraspace LLP
Limited and Anr. (2020) 15 SCC 585, has clearly held
that a matter will be under the jurisdiction of Commercial
Court only if it is a commercial dispute within the meaning
of Section 2(1)(c) of the Act of 2015 and such commercial
disputes are of specified value as per Section 2(i) of the
Act of 2015.
18. The High Court of Uttaranchal, in the matter of
Richa Bisht and Others v. Union of India and Others,
2020 SCC Online Utt 1386, as well as the High Court of
Allahabad, in the matter of Tulsarani and Another. v.
Union of India and Others, 2022 SCC Online All 693,
have taken a similar view which we have taken above and
as such, we are in agreement with the view so taken by
the High Courts of Uttaranchal and Allahabad, as the
appellants’ land has compulsorily been acquired under the
provisions of the Act of 1956 for the purpose of
construction of National Highway, therefore, the dispute
arising out of land acquisition for such purpose cannot be
treated as ‘commercial dispute’ under Section 2(1)(c) of
the Act of 2015.
19. It is made clear that though notification dated
20/12/2023 issued by the State Government through the
Law and Legislative Affairs Department includes arbitration
cases but by virtue of Section 10 of the Act of 2015, where
the subject-matter of an arbitration is a commercial dispute
of a specified value and nature as prescribed therein, only
then the said arbitration case would come within the
jurisdiction of Commercial Court. It is clarified accordingly.
20. In view of the aforesaid legal discussion and
analysis, the final impugned order dated 21/10/2025
(Annexure A/1) passed by the 2nd Additional District Judge,
Commercial Court (District Judge Level), Bilaspur rejecting
the application filed by the appellants under Section 34 of
the Act of 1996 as well as the order dated 07/02/2024
passed by the District Judge, Bilaspur refusing to entertain
the application filed by the appellants under Section 34 of
the Act of 1996 and transferring the matter to the
Commercial Court (District Judge Level) in light of the
notification dated 20/12/2023 issued by the State
Government through the Law and Legislative Affairs
Department, both are hereby set aside. Matter is remitted
to the Court of Principal District Judge, Bilaspur for hearing
and disposal in accordance with law. It is made clear that
this Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of
the matter.
21. Accordingly, this appeal is allowed to the extent
indicated herein-above. No cost(s).”
8.
In the above referred case also award passed by Competent Authority
under Land Acquisition was put to challenge before the Arbitrator, who
passed an award on 13.09.2021 denying to interfere with the award.
The award of Arbitrator was put to challenge before the District Judge
U/s. 34 of the Act of 1996 and it was subsequently transferred to the
Commercial Court considering the notification dated 20.12.2023 of the
State Government.
9.
As the facts of the above referred case are identical to the facts of the
case at hand, we are of the view that the case is covered with the
decision in case of Anand Khedia (supra), therefore, the impugned
judgment/ order dated 05.03.2025, passed in MJC Case No. 290 of
2022, passed by 2nd District Judge (Commercial Court), District Judge
Level District Bilaspur (C.G.) as well as the order dated 07.02.2024
passed by the District Judge Bilaspur transferring the case to the
Commercial Court, in light of the notification dated 21.12.2023, are setaside. Matter is remitted to the Court of Principal District Judge
Bilaspur for hearing and disposal of the case in accordance with law. It
is made clear that this Court is not expressed any opinion on the merits
of the matter.
10.
Accordingly, the appeal stands disposed of.
11.
Send the record of the Court below back, forthwith.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Balram
Sd/(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review