The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
29. In line with the decision of this Court in Rattan Mallik (supra), we are of the view that a finding of the absence of possession of the contraband on the person of the respondent by the High Court in the impugned order does not absolve it of the level of scrutiny required under Section 37(1)(b)(ii) of the NDPS Act. In addition to that, he also few other citations of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana in Ranjit Singh versus State of Punjab [CRM-M25526-2023] dated 17.07.2023 wherein in para No.9 the said High Court observed as under : “9. When there are multiple FIRs against a person over a significant period of time (in this case 18 years), then even though he may have been acquitted in some of those cases, the twin conditions as envisaged under Section 37 of the NDPS Act that he has not committed an offence and was not likely to commit an offence cannot be satisfied.” (5) He referred another citation of the same High Court in connection with Case No.CRM-M-42482-2023 dated
21. 09.2023 [Mohammad Rayyan Ansari versus State of Haryana] wherein in para No.13 the said High Court observed as under : “13. In fact, when there are multiple FIRs against an accused over a significant period of time, then the twin conditions as envisaged under Section 37 of the NDPS Act that he had not committed an offence and was not likely to commit an offence cannot be satisfied. Further, the limitation to the grant of bail under Section 37 of the NDPS Act are in addition to those prescribed under Cr.P.C. or any other law in force on the grant of bail. Thus, a habitual offender is not entitled to the grant of bail even under the provisions of the Cr.P.C. keeping in view his criminal antecedents. On the contrary, in such cases, the custodial interrogation is certainly necessary even though the accused may have joined investigation at an earlier stage.” Further, he referred another citation in connection with Case No.CRM-M-31645-2022 dated 20.10.2022 [Soni Singh @ Chamkaur Singh versus State of Punjab] wherein in the last part of the judgment the said High Court observed as under : “Admittedly, the petitioner in the present case is named in the disclosure statement of the arrested accused. Subsequently thereto 3 Kgs of Poppy Husk was recovered at his instance which is a non commercial quantity. It may be relevant to mention here that limitations to the grant of bail under Secti…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A.No.33 of 2025
Hriday Ali (Age-29 years),
son of Jangsar Ali,
resident of Purba Mog Pushkarani,
P.O.-Abani Riyangpara, P.S.-R.K.Pur,
District-Gomati Tripura
----Petitioner on behalf of Custody Accused Person
Jangsar Ali (Age-50 years),
son of late Asmat Ali,
resident of Purba Mog Pushkarani,
P.O.-Abani Riyangpara, P.S.-R.K.Pur,
District-Gomati Tripura
---- Applicant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
(to be represented by the Secretary,
Home Department), Government of Tripura
----Respondent(s)
______________________________________________________
For Applicant(s)
: Mr. Janardhan Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Mr. Sajib Ghosh, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
_________________________________________________________
[---
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
14/05/2025
This bail application under Section 483 of BNSS read with Section
37 of NDPS Act is filed for releasing of the custody accused namely Jangsar Ali
on bail in connection with Khowai P/S Case No.2024/KHW/062 under Section
20(b)(ii)(C)/25/29 of NDPS Act.
[02]
Heard Mr. J. Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel appearing on behalf
of the accused in custody and also heard Mr. R. Datta, Learned P.P. appearing
on behalf of the State-respondent. As ordered earlier, Learned P.P. has
produced two numbers of CDs. One is relating to this case and another is
regarding Ambassa P/S Case No.29/2024. Also received the LCRs.
(2)
[03]
Taking part in the hearing, Mr. J. Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the accused in custody submitted that this present
accused is not FIR named. No contraband items were recovered from his
possession and furthermore, no incriminating evidence revealed against him
during investigation. Learned counsel further submitted that this accused is not
FIR named accused in connection with Ambassa P/S Case No.29/2024 nor he is
arrested in connection with that case. Furthermore, he is lodging in jail since
last 167 days. Learned counsel again submitted that the principal accused of
this case has already been granted bail and there is no scope to refuse the bail
application of this accused and urged for releasing the accused on bail in any
condition considering the period of his detention in custody.
[04]
On the other hand, Mr. R. Datta, Learned P.P. appearing on behalf
of the State-respondent strongly opposed the submission and referring the
case diary of this present case and the Ambassa P.S. case as noted above
submitted that in a case of this nature, it is not always necessary that the
contraband items should be seized directly from the possession of a person
and if it is found that any person directly or indirectly involved with any
offence, in that case, during investigation there is no scope to grant privilege
of Section 37 of NDPS Act. He further submitted that in Ambassa P/S Case
notice was issued to the accused but he did not comply with that and from the
statement of the witnesses it is clear that the offending vehicle of that case is
belonging to his wife being a lady and the accused taking this advantage using
that vehicle for carrying contraband items and since he was lodging in Khowai
P/S, so, he could not be produced in connection with that case. Regarding the
involvement of the present accused in connection with this case, he submitted
that the defence story cannot be believed because he took the offending
vehicle of the owner on hire rent and used the same for carrying contraband
items. So prima facie all though there is no direct evidence that he possessed
contraband items but his conspiracy or involvement cannot be ruled out in this
(3)
case. He also referred few citations which would be discussed later on and
finally urged for rejection of the bail application.
[05]
I have heard both the sides at length and perused the case diary
of both the cases. In this present case the prosecution was set into motion on
the basis of an FIR laid by one Inspector Jugal Charan Tripura on 03.10.2024
to O/C Khowai P/S alleging inter alia that on 03.10.2024 morning at about
0550 hrs. P.S. GD Officer received an information that one white coloured
Maruti Suzuki numberless vehicle was going toward Kamalpur side via Khowai
road with concealing huge quantity of Ganja in the secret chamber of the said
vehicle which was driven by Rajani Debbarma. On this information the matter
was entered in GDE and the same was informed to O/C, Khowai P/S and after
that, the O/C Khowai P/S informed the matter to higher authority in reference
to Khowai P/S GDE No.06. Accordingly they were asked to Cherma Naka Point
when they found that the vehicle was detained by police. In the meantime
Deputy S.P. reached there when the driver of the vehicle disclosed his name as
Rajani Debbarma and confessed that he was carrying 47.5 kg. dry Ganja
concealing in the door chamber and back side light chamber of the vehicle.
Accordingly, said Rajani Debbarma was taken into custody and FIR was
accordingly laid and the case was registered.
[06]
In course of investigation, the IO recorded the statement of so
many witnesses in connection with the case and from the statement of the
owner of the vehicle it appears that he (accused) took the vehicle from the
owner of the offending vehicle on hire/rent and using that vehicle he used to
supply contraband items to different areas and on 03.10.2024 the vehicle was
detained which was being taken on hire/rent by the accused in custody and the
vehicle of his wife was also detained in Ambassa P/S. Similar statement was
made by some other witnesses also. On perusal of the records it transpires
that another Rajani Debbarma was granted default bail. I have also perused
the Ambassa P/S case. It transpires that in that case on so many occasion
notice was served upon him under Section 67 of NDPS Act and in that case
(4)
total 87 kg of dry cannabis was seized from Maruti Suzuki bearing No.TR05 G
1691 and the rest Gaja was seized from another vehicle bearing No.TR05 G
1854 (BOLERO PIK-UP) out of 232 kgs. of dry cannabis. From the statement of
the witnesses it also appears that he used to hire vehicles for carrying
contraband items and the seized offending BOLERO PIK-UP van is belonging to
his wife and he being the husband of the owner of the vehicle used to look
after the management of the said vehicle as the wife cannot drive the vehicle.
Admittedly in this case although notice was issued under Section 67 of NDPS
Act but he could not be arrested or taken into custody since by this time the
accused in custody was lodging in connection with this Khowai P/S case.
[07]
In course of hearing, Learned P.P. relied upon the citation of
Hon’ble Apex Court in Union of India through Narcotics Control Bureau,
Lucknow versus Md. Nawaz Khan reported in (2021) 10 SCC 100 wherein
in para Nos.28 & 29 the said Apex Court observed as under :
28. As regards the finding of the High Court regarding absence
of recovery of the contraband from the possession of the
respondent, we note that in Union of India v. Rattan Mallik :
(2009) 2 SCC 624, a two-judge Bench of this Court cancelled
the bail of an accused and reversed the finding of the High
Court, which had held that as the contraband (heroin) was
recovered from a specially made cavity above the cabin of a
truck, no contraband was found in the „possession‟ of the
accused. The Court observed that merely making a finding on
the possession of the contraband did not fulfil the parameters
of Section 37(1)(b) and there was non-application of mind by
the High Court.
29. In line with the decision of this Court in Rattan
Mallik (supra), we are of the view that a finding of the
absence of possession of the contraband on the person of the
respondent by the High Court in the impugned order does not
absolve it of the level of scrutiny required under Section
37(1)(b)(ii) of the NDPS Act.
In addition to that, he also few other citations of the High Court of
Punjab and Haryana in Ranjit Singh versus State of Punjab [CRM-M25526-2023] dated 17.07.2023 wherein in para No.9 the said High Court
observed as under :
“9. When there are multiple FIRs against a person over a
significant period of time (in this case 18 years), then even
though he may have been acquitted in some of those cases,
the twin conditions as envisaged under Section 37 of the
NDPS Act that he has not committed an offence and was not
likely to commit an offence cannot be satisfied.”
(5)
He referred another citation of the same High Court in connection
with
Case
No.CRM-M-42482-2023
dated
21.09.2023
[Mohammad
Rayyan Ansari versus State of Haryana] wherein in para No.13 the said
High Court observed as under :
“13. In fact, when there are multiple FIRs against an accused
over a significant period of time, then the twin conditions as
envisaged under Section 37 of the NDPS Act that he had not
committed an offence and was not likely to commit an offence
cannot be satisfied. Further, the limitation to the grant of bail
under Section 37 of the NDPS Act are in addition to those
prescribed under Cr.P.C. or any other law in force on the grant
of bail. Thus, a habitual offender is not entitled to the grant of
bail even under the provisions of the Cr.P.C. keeping in view
his criminal antecedents. On the contrary, in such cases, the
custodial interrogation is certainly necessary even though the
accused may have joined investigation at an earlier stage.”
Further, he referred another citation in connection with Case
No.CRM-M-31645-2022 dated 20.10.2022 [Soni Singh @ Chamkaur
Singh versus State of Punjab] wherein in the last part of the judgment the
said High Court observed as under :
“Admittedly, the petitioner in the present case is named in the
disclosure statement of the arrested accused. Subsequently
thereto 3 Kgs of Poppy Husk was recovered at his instance
which is a non commercial quantity. It may be relevant to
mention here that limitations to the grant of bail under
Section 37 of the NDPS Act are in addition to those prescribed
under Cr.P.C. or any other law inforce on the grant of bail as
has been set out by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Satpal Singh
Vs. State of Punjab 2018(5) RCR (Criminal) 152. In the
present case, the petitioner is involved in two other cases
under the NDPS Act. Thus, as he is a habitual offender, he is
not entitled to the grant of bail even under Section 439 Cr.P.C.
keeping in view his antecedents. Even otherwise, assuming
that the rigors of Section37 of the NDPS Act did not apply to
the petitioner, that by itself would not ipso facto lead to the
grant of bail to the petitioner.
In view of the above discussion, I find no merit in the present
petition and the same is therefore dismissed.”
[08]
Here in the case at hand after hearing both the sides and after
perusal of the CD of both the cases it appears that admittedly in this case,
nothing was seized from the possession of the accused and this accused is also
not FIR named either in this case or in Ambassa P/S case. But from the
statement of material witnesses the involvement of accused cannot be ruled
out at this stage since the investigation is going on. Furthermore, nothing was
found from the possession of the accused cannot be a sole ground for
consideration of bail application of the accused. Rather from the statement of
(6)
witnesses it appears that in one case he was using the vehicle which was
purchased in the name of his wife for carrying contraband items and in another
case he on taking the vehicle on hire/rent was using the same for the purpose
of carrying contraband items and in one case the vehicle was seized from his
wife and in another case the vehicle of the owner who led the vehicle on rent
to the accused was seized from where a huge quantum of contraband items
were recovered.
Situated
thus,
considering
the
aforesaid
citations
and
the
materials on record I do not find any scope to consider release of the accused
on bail in view of the provision provided under Section 37 of NDPS Act and as
such, his bail application stands rejected. The accused is to remain in jail
custody as before.
Send down the LCRs of both the cases along with a copy of this
order.
Send down the Case Diary to the IO of this case through Learned
P.P. along with a copy of this order.
With this observation, the bail application stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMITA Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2025.05.17
DATTA Date:
04:47:01 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review