Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010271752017
2026:GAU-AS:7777
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP(IO)/322/2017
HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD. HUDCO
A FINANCIAL INSTITUTION REGD UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956
HAVING ITS REGD OFFICE AT HUDCO BHAWAN, INDIA HABITAT CENTRE,
LODHI ROAD, NEW DELHI- 110003 AND HAVING ITS GUWAHATI ZONAL
OFFICE AT HOUSEFED COMPLEX, RUKIMINI GAON, G S ROAD,
GUWAHATI- 781022 AND REP. BY THE REGIONAL CHIEF HUDCO,
GUWAHATI
VERSUS
M/S. UPASANA BUILDERS PVT. LTD. and 4 ORS.
REP. BY SRI PRANJAL BHORALEE, MANAGING DIRECTOR, 2ND FLOOR,
AARTI PLAZA, CHANDMARI, GUWAHATI- 781003 IN THE KAMRUP METRO
DIST, ASSAM
2:ON THE DEATH OF PRANJAL KUMAR BHORALEE
HIS LEGAL HEIRS
2.1:MS. UPASANA BHORALEE
D/O LATE PRANJAL KUMAR BHORALEE
2ND FLOOR
ARATI PLAZA
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI- 03
3:CHABBI BHORALEE
W/O- SRI PRANJAL KUMAR BHORALEE
DIRECTOR OF M/S UPASANA BUILDERS PVT. LTD
2ND FLOOR
ARATI PLAZA
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI- 781003
Page No.# 2/7
RESIDING AT NIRUPAM APARTMENT
NEAR ABC
TARUN NAGAR
GUWAHATI- 781006
KAMRUP METRO DIST
ASSAM
4:ON THE DEATH OF ARUN BORAH HIS LEGAL HEIRS
NA
4.1:AMIT BORAH
S/O Late Arun Borah
R/O Barowary
Guwahati
781001
Dist. Kamrup (M)
Assam
5:PALLAVI BORAH
D/O- SRI ARUN BORAH
R/O- BAROWARY
GUWAHATI- 781001
DIST- KAMRUP METRO
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR.G BHARADWAJ, ABBASH U AHMED,MR. K
BHATTACHARJEE,MR.A C SARMA
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. P K KALITA (R-4.1,5), MR G J SAIKIA (R-5),MR. K R
BOROOAH (R-4.1),MR. N DAS (R-4)
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
ORDER
03.06.2026
Heard Mr. K. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also head
Mr. P.K. Kalita, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. G.J. Saikia, learned
counsel for the respondent nos. 4 and 5. There is no representation for the
respondent nos. 1, 2 & 3.
Page No.# 3/7
2.
Aggrieved by the order dated 19.09.2017 passed by the learned Presiding
Officer, Debts Recovery Tribunal, Guwahati (DRT) in O.A. No. 56/2012, this
application has been filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
3.
As per the provision of Section 20 of the Recovery of Debts and
Bankruptcy Act, 1993 [formerly Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial
Institutions Act, 1993], any person aggrieved by an order made by the Debts
Recovery Tribunal may prefer an appeal before the Debts Recovery Appellate
Tribunal having jurisdiction. Thus, appeal would lie against any order of the
Debts Recovery Tribunal, whether interlocutory or final. Thus, there being
alternative statutory remedy available, the petitioner is prima facie not entitled
to any relief in this case. Nonetheless, in view of the nature of issue raised, the
merit of the case has also been examined.
4.
The petitioner in this application is the applicant in O.A. No. 56/2012,
which is pending disposal before the DebtsRecovery Tribunal, Guwahati. The
learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the respondent Nos. 4 and
5 had raised an objection regarding forgery in creating security documents
based on which a loan was availed by the respondent nos. 1, 2 and 3 to the
extent of Rs.2.90 crore for construction of an apartment building known as
“Gyanashram” at a location in Uzan Bazar, Guwahati. The said application was
filed under Section 75, read with Order 26 Rule 10A of the CPC, read with
Section 45 of the Evidence Act for verification of documents by handwriting
/Forensic Expert.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that when the
petitioner had filed O.A. No. 56/2012, all the original documents of the
application by the petitioner corporation were submitted before the learned DRT.
However, the Report of the Forensic Science Laboratory was based, amongst
Page No.# 4/7
others, on 6 exhibited documents, being, (1) certified copy of Development
Agreement bearing Deed No. 7394/2005 (Ext.A2), (2) certified copy of Power of
Attorney, being Deed No. 4215 (Ext. A4), (3) Letter of Offer (Ext. A6), (4)
Undertaking signed by the landowners (Ext.A9), (5) Loan Agreement dated
31.05.2005 (Ext.A10), and (6) 3rdAmendment to the Loan Agreement dated
10.04.2007 (Ext.A31). It is submitted that when the expert of the Forensic
Science Laboratory was cross-examined, he was put a question as to the nature
of documents exhibited and examined by him and the said authority had
admitted that the two documents i.e. Ext.A2 and Ext.A4 which were examined
by him were the certified copy of the Development Agreement (Ext.A2) and the
Power of Attorney (Ext. A4). Accordingly, it is submitted that instead of sending
the original documents, the learned DRT had sent certified copies, which cannot
be said to bear the original signatures of the respondent Nos. 4 and 5.
Accordingly, it is submitted that as the Forensic Science Laboratory had
examined the certified copies, the report of the Forensic Science Laboratory
could not have been accepted by the learned DRT. Accordingly, in terms of the
prayer made in this application, the petitioner, i.e., the Financial Institution, has
prayed for setting aside the order dated 19.09.2017, passed by the learned DRT
in O.A. No. 56/2012, by which prayer made by the petitioner for passing
appropriate orders that the Forensic Science Laboratory Report dated
08.05.2017 was not applicable to Ext. Nos. A2, A4, A6, A9 and A10, was
rejected.
6.
Thus, as stated above, in view of the issue raised, the Court is of the
considered opinion that as this revision petition is pending for disposal for nearly
9(nine) years, the merit of the challenge has been examined under the facts
unique to this case, without intending this to be a precedent in any other case.
Page No.# 5/7
7.
Having heard the learned Senior Counsel for the respondent Nos. 4 and 5,
the Court has perused the records called for from the learned Debts Recovery
Tribunal.
8.
The records reveal that the evidence on exhibit of the petitioner was
sworn by one Songita Daas, the Senior Manager, Law, of the petitioner
corporation filed on 17.07.2013. Amongst others, by way of the evidence-onaffidavit, 39 documents were exhibited. Out of the exhibited documents, Ext. A2
as stated in the evidence-on-affidavit is a “copy” of the Development Agreement
No. 7394/2005 dated 17.06.2005. In respect of Ext. 4, it has been mentioned in
the narration at paragraph 4 of the evidence-on-affidavit that Ext. 4A was a
“copy” of Power of Attorney No. 4215/2005. It is also noticed that in the
narration appended to paragraph 4 of the evidence on affidavit, the petitioner
corporation had exhibited the signature of respondent Nos. 4 and 5 as Ext.
A2(1) and Ext. A2(2) and A2(3) and the signature of respondent Nos. 4 and 5 in
Ext. 4 were exhibited as Ext. A4(1) and A4(2). Similarly, in respect of Ext. A6, in
narration appended to paragraph 5 of the evidence-on-affidavit, it has been
mentioned that the same is a “copy” of Letter Offer dated 08.04.2005 and the
signatures of the respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were exhibited as Ext. A6(6) to
A6(10) and Ext. A6(11) to A6(15). Similarly, in narration appended to paragraph
5 of the evidence-on-affidavit Ext.A9 is stated to be a “copy” of undertaking
dated 30.08.2005 and the signatures of respondent nos. 4 and 5 were exhibited
as Ext. A9(1) and A9(2) and Ext.A9(3) and A9(4) respectively. In relation to
paragraph 6 of the evidence-on-affidavit, a reference to Ext. A10 is made which
is again stated to be a “copy” of Loan Agreement dated 31.05.2005 and the
signatures of respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were exhibited as Ext. A10(122) to
Ext.A10(152) and Ext.A10(153) to Ext.A10(184) respectively. In the narration
Page No.# 6/7
appended to paragraph 12 of the evidence-on-affidavit, Ext.A31 has been
mentioned as a copy of the 3 rd Amendment to Loan Agreement dated
10.04.2017 and the signatures of respondent nos. 4 and 5 were exhibited as
Ext. A31(3) and A31(4).
9.
Thus, when in evidence-on-affidavit, those exhibits were referred to as
“copy”, the Court is unable to accept the statement made by the learned
counsel for the petitioner that along with the original application, being O.A.
No.56/2012, the documents referable to Ext.A2, A4, A6, A9, A10 and A31 were
filed in original. The reason is that if the documents were in original, there was
no necessity for the deponent in the evidence-on-affidavit to refer those original
documents as “copies”. Therefore, in the considered opinion of the Court, the
evidence-on-affidavit of PW-1 itself reflects that “copies” of said documents
were exhibited and the learned Tribunal, upon passing of the relevant order, had
forwarded the exhibited documents to the Forensic Expert.
10.
On a perusal of the records, it is seen that the exhibited documents which
are enclosed with the report of the FSL, they are found to have been separated
from the evidence-on-affidavit. The other exhibited documents remain
appended to the evidence-on-affidavit.
11.
In this case, the petitioner has not annexed to this application, the extract
of the original Mortgage Register or the Memorandum of Mortgage, by whatever
name called. The petitioner has also not produced photocopies of the so-called
original exhibited documents submitted before the learned DRT.
12.
Even assuming that this Court is to believe, what is projected by the
petitioner corporation, it would mean that the learned DRT, despite receiving the
original document Ext. A2, would create in its record “certified to be true copy”
Page No.# 7/7
issued by the Senior Sub-Registrar Officer, Guwahati on 18.06.2005 and similarly
also substitute the original Power of Attorney (Ext.A4) with a “certified to be
true copy” procured from the Office of the Senior Sub-Registrar, Guwahati,
issued on 18.06.2005. The petitioner has to satisfy the Court that the document
exhibited as Ext.A2 and Ext.A4 were in original. It may be stated that there is
no dispute with regard to the referred documents being Ext.A6, Ext.A9, Ext.A10
and Ext.A31 which are in original. Therefore, the dispute is only with regard to
the said exhibited documents. It is most unlikely that certified copies of the
Deed of Agreement and Power of Attorney dated 17.06.2005 could have been
substituted by the learned Debts Recovery Tribunal in lieu of original document,
but that too, by certified copies of Ext.A2 and Ext.A4 issued on 18.06.2005.
13.
Accordingly, the challenge to the impugned order dated 19.09.2017,
passed by the learned Presiding Officer, Debts Recovery Tribunal, Guwahati, in
O.A. No. 56/2012, fails and the application is accordingly dismissed.
14.
The Registry shall send back the records to the learned DRT, Guwahati
along with the copy of this order to be made a part of the record by the said
learned Tribunal.
15.
The interim order dated 01.11.2017 staying with the proceeding in O.A.
Case No. 56/2012 stands revoked.
16.
Both sides are directed to appear before the learned DRT, Guwahati on
22.06.2026 and by producing a certified copy of the order, await for further
orders to be passed by the said learned Tribunal.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review