Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010450682025
2026:CGHC:30434
NAFR
The date
The date
The date when the order is uploaded on the
when the
when the
website
order is
order is
reserved
pronounced
07-07-2026
17-07-2026
Operative
Full
-
17-07-2026
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
REVP No. 392 of 2025
Hitachi Energy India Limited 70/401, 8th Floor, Brigade Opus,
Kodigehalli Main Road, Bengaluru (Karnataka). Hitachi Energy India
Limited, Corporate Office- 17th Floor, Tower 1, M3M, IFC, Gurugram
(Haryana) Pin Code 122002. Through Its Authorised Representative
Kshitij Raj, Lead Legal Counsel.
--- Petitioner
(Respondent in MA No.72/2006)
versus
1 - M/s Sarda Energy And Minerals Limited Having Its Registered
Office At 73-A, Central Avenue, Nagpur 440 018 & Office Address at :
P-49, Industrial Area, Urkura, Raipur 493 221. (Original Appellant in MA
No.72/2006)
2 - ABB Limited (Formerly Known As Asea Brown Bowery Limited)
Having Its Registered Office At Khanija Bhavan, 2nd Floor, East Wing,
49, Race Course Road, Bangalore, 560001. (Formerly At Plot No. 22,
Shah Industrial Estate, Andheri (West), Mumbai 400053.)
--- Respondents
REVP No. 362 of 2025
Hitachi Energy India Limited 70/401, 8th Floor, Brigade Opus,
Kodigehalli Main Road, Bengaluru Karnataka (As Per Cause Title)
Corporate Office 17th Floor, Tower - 1, M3M IFC, Gurugram (Haryana)
Pin Code 122 002 Through Its Authorised Representative Kshitij Raj,
Lead Legal Counsel
---Petitioner
(Substituted Appellant In M.A. No. 1456/2005)
Versus
1 - ABB Limited, (Formerly Known As Asea Brown Bowery Limited)
Having Its Registered Office At Khanija Bhavan, 2nd Floor, East Wing,
49, Race Course Road, Bangalore 560 001 (Formerly At Plot No. 22,
Shah Industrial Estate, Andheri (West), Mumbai 400 053) (Original
Appellant In M.A. No. 1456/2005)
2 - M/s Sarda Energy And Minerals Limited Having Its Registered
Office At 73-A, Central Avenue, Nagpur 440 018 And Office Address At
P-49, Industrial Area, Urkura, Raipur 493 221 (Original Respondent In
M.A. No. 1456/2005)
--- Respondents
For Petitioners
:
Mr. Manoj Paranjpe, Sr. Adv. with Mr. K. Rohan
and Mr. Sujoy Sur, Advocates.
For Respondent-
:
Mr. Sumesh Bajaj with Mr. Rishabh Bajaj,
ABB Ltd.
Advocates.
For Respondent-M/s
Mr. Sabyasachi Bhaduri, Advocate.
Sarda Ltd.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi, J
CAV ORDER
Since both these review petitions arise out of a common order
dated 03.04.2025 passed by this Court in MA No.1456/2005 and MA
No.72/2006 involving the same parties, they are heard analogously
and being disposed of by this common order.
02.
The Registry has raised objection in respect of maintainability of
the review petitions on the ground that since both the miscellaneous
appeals are also pending consideration before this Court, separate
application for recalling of the order dated 3.4.2025 ought to have been
filed in those appeals and as such, the instant review petitions are not
maintainable.
03.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents herein also
supported the aforesaid objection.
04.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, referring to the judgment of
the Full Bench of this Court in the matter of Ajay Gupta Vs. State of
CG and others, reported in 2017 SCC OnLine Chh 111, would
contend that while dealing with the issue of maintainability of appeal
under Section 2(1) of CG High Court (Appeal to Division Bench) Act,
2006, against an interlocutory order, the Full Bench of this Court held
that though proviso to Section 2(1) of this Act bars appeal against
those interim orders which are totally interlocutory in nature, do not
decide matters of moment and do not have an element of finality
attached to them, but if the order vitally affects rights of the parties
having bearing on final adjudication of case, it cannot be termed as
interlocutory order and appeal would lie against such order. Further, it
was held that appeal would also lie against those orders which cannot
be undone at the time of final hearing and which have element of
finality attached to them. He submits that in the present case, the order
impugned has already attained finality in relation to the respondentABB Ltd. and in consequence thereof, the petitioner has been
substituted in place of respondent-ABB Ltd. Thus, the order impugned
vitally affects rights of the petitioner having bearing on final adjudication
of case. Being so, the objection raised by the Registry deserves to be
overruled and the instant review petitions be held to be maintainable.
05.
This Court finds substance in the aforesaid argument of learned
counsel for the petitioner. Since in compliance of the impugned order
dated 3.4.2025, name of the respondent-ABB Ltd. has already been
deleted from both the appeals and in place thereof, the petitioner has
been substituted, it vitally affects the rights of the petitioner and has
bearing on the final adjudication of the case, and that the impugned
order has attained finality in relation to the respondent-ABB Ltd., hence
in the considered opinion of this Court, both the review petitions
preferred against the impugned order dated 3.4.2025 are maintainable.
Consequently, the objection raised by the Registry stands waived.
06.
Heard on IA Nos.02/2025, applications for condonation of delay
in filing the review petitions.
07.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that in MA
No.1456/2005 and MA No.72/2006, the present petitioner was not a
party. For the first time, the petitioner received a notice on 14.5.2025 in
respect of both these appeals. Since they were not aware in respect of
the orders passed by this Court, therefore, no application for review
was filed at earlier point of time. Even otherwise, delay, if any, in filing
these review petitions ought to be computed from 14.5.2025. He
submits that the petitioner had to obtain and review the entire record of
the case in order to understand the background and issues involved.
The case record is voluminous, comprising 12 separate volumes of
documents
accumulated
over
years
of
arbitration
and
court
proceedings. All of these documents and proceedings were entirely
new and unfamiliar to the petitioner who had never been involved in
the matter before. The petitioner only after obtaining and studying the
relevant materials drafted the review petition articulating the grounds
for review, and all this consumed precious time and contributed to the
delay.
08.
Learned counsel would further submit that the petitioner applied
for certified copy of the Court record on 12.8.2025 and the same was
provided to the petitioner on 28.9.2025. Given this, it is submitted that
the time period of 48 days ought to be deducted from the total period of
delay at the petitioner’s end. Thus, there exists sufficient cause for
condonation of delay, if any, in filing these review petitions. Learned
counsel for the petitioner would submit that the fact remains that the
petitioner was not heard before passing the impugned order on the
application for substitution. Since the order impugned was ultimately
passed against the petitioner, no malafide can be attributed to the
petitioner and there was no occasion for the petitioner to file review
petitions belatedly. He submits that delay so occurred was neither
willful nor intentional or malafide but entirely beyond the control of the
petitioner. The petitioner has been diligent and sincere in pursuing the
matter once it came to its knowledge.
09.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would next submit that even
after Scheme of Arrangement entered into between the parties, the
respondent-ABB Ltd. had made various communications with regard to
the liability arising from both the appeals which have been categorically
denied by the petitioner vide letter dated 30 th May, 2022 (Annexure
A/5), letter dated 14th September, 2023 (Annexure A/8) and letter dated
3rd March, 2025 (Annexure A/11). Hence, in view of above submission,
the delay occurred in filing the review petitions may be condoned,
these petitions may be allowed; the impugned order dated 3.4.2025 be
recalled
and
the
respondent-ABB
Ltd.
be
restored
as
appellant/respondent in the respective appeals and substitution
applications (IA No.04/2025) be decided after affording opportunity of
hearing to the petitioner herein.
In support of his contention, learned counsel for the petitioner
placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
matter of Haryana Suraj Malting Ltd. vs Phool Chand reported in
(2018) 16 SCC 567 in which the Hon’ble Supreme Court has explained
what should be termed as sufficient cause and limitation will not come
in the way if sufficient cause is shown by the party for filing a related
application. To buttress his contention that the impugned order
deserves to be recalled, he placed reliance on the judgments of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the matters of Grindlays Bank Ltd. Vs. Central
Government Industrial Tribunal and others, 1980 Supp SCC 420
and Kapra Mazdoor Ekta Union Vs. Birla Cotton Spinning and
Weaving Mills Ltd. and another, (2005) 13 SCC 777.
10.
The respondent-ABB Ltd. has filed it reply. Learned counsel for
the respondent-ABB Ltd., referring to its reply, would submit that the
impugned order was passed on 3.4.2025 and both these review
petitions have been filed by the petitioner on 6.10.2025 i.e. after 163
days from the date of passing of the order. He submits that it is the
contention of learned counsel for the petitioner himself that dispute
persists with regard to liability in respect of both the appeals since
2022. He further submits that though copy of IA No.04/2025 was not
sent to the petitioner by the Court but it was sent by the respondentABB Ltd. on its own, therefore, contention made by learned counsel for
the petitioner that they were not aware of pendency of the instant
appeals as well as the substitution application is wholly incorrect. Even
after passing of the impugned order by this Court, copy of the order
was sent by the respondent-ABB Ltd. to the petitioner through currier
vide letter dated 17.4.2025 as also through email, and this fact has
also been admitted by the petitioner in para 6(XX) of the review
petitions. This apart, even if the date of information is supposed to be
14.5.2025 when the petitioner received notice, in that case also there is
125 days delay in filing the review petitions. Despite that, wrong facts
have been mentioned in the applications for condonation of delay that
review petitions have been filed within limitation.
11.
Learned counsel for the respondent-ABB Ltd. would further
submit that the petitioner filed application for getting certified copy of
the record on 12.8.2025 whereas information about passing of the
impugned order was conveyed to the petitioner by the respondent as
well as by this Court in the month of April, 2025 itself. Since the
respondent-ABB Ltd. had already informed the petitioner about filing of
the substitution application, the order passed by this Court and Sarda
Energy & Minerals Ltd. did not raise any objection in respect of the
contention made in the said application, therefore, issuance of notice to
the petitioner was not required at all. Learned counsel further submits
that in the substitution application, prayer of the respondent-ABB Ltd. is
that name of the petitioner Hitachi Energy India Ltd. be substituted in
place of the respondent/appellant-ABB Ltd. therein in the respective
appeals in compliance of the order passed by NCLT or name of the
respondent-ABB Ltd. may be deleted from the memo of appeals. He
vehemently argues that if the respondent-ABB Ltd. does not want to be
a party in those appeals, then it cannot be compelled to be a party in
the same.
Reliance has been placed on the decisions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the matters of Sunil Gupta Vs. Kiran Girhotra and
others, (2007) 8 SCC 506; Hari Mohan Sharma and another Vs.
Charanjeet Singh Rekhi and others, (2019) 12 SCC 412; Gurmit
Singh Bhatia Vs. Kiran Kant Robinson and others; (2020) 13 SCC
773; and Small Industries Development Bank of India Vs. SIBCO
Investment Private Limited, (2022) 3 SCC 56.
12.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent-Sarda Energy &
Minerals Ltd. would submit that he has nothing to say in the instant
review petitions as the disputes relates to the petitioner and
respondent-ABB Ltd.
13.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record.
14.
ABB Limited was the operational company under the Companies
Act approved by National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Bangalore
Bench. The Power Grid Business including Transformer Business was
transferred/demerged to ABB Power Products and System India Ltd.
Subsequently, ABB Power Products and System India Ltd. was
renamed as Hitachi Energy India Ltd. (Petitioner herein).
15.
The first question that falls for consideration is whether the
petitioner has been able to establish "sufficient cause" for condonation
of delay in filing the present review petitions.
16.
It is well settled that the expression "sufficient cause" occurring in
the law of limitation is required to receive a liberal and justice-oriented
construction so as to advance substantial justice, provided the conduct
of the applicant does not disclose negligence, inaction or lack of bona
fides. The Court is not expected to adopt a pedantic approach while
considering an application for condonation of delay, particularly where
refusal to condone the delay may result in denial of an opportunity of
hearing to a person who is directly affected by the order under
challenge.
17.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in the matter of Haryana Suraj Malting
Ltd. (supra), while dealing with the issue whether the Industrial
Tribunal/Labour Court becomes functus officio after 30 days of
pronouncement/publication of the award and loses all powers to recall
an ex parte award on an application made by the aggrieved party after
30 days from the date of the award, held in paras 34 & 35 of its
judgment as under:
“34.
In case a party is in a position to show sufficient
cause for its absence before the Labour Court/ Tribunal
when it was set ex parte, the Labour Court/Tribunal, in
exercise of its ancillary or incidental powers, is competent to
entertain such an application. That power cannot be
circumscribed by limitation. What is the sufficient cause and
whether its jurisdiction is invoked within a reasonable time
should be left to the judicious discretion of the Labour
Court/Tribunal.
35. It is a matter of natural justice that any party to the
judicial proceedings should get an opportunity of being
heard, and if such an opportunity has been denied for
want of sufficient reason, the Labour Court/Tribunal
which denied such an opportunity, being satisfied of the
sufficient cause and within a reasonable time, should
be in a position to set right its own procedure.
Otherwise, as held in Grindlays, 1981 SCC (L&S) 309,
an award which may be a nullity will have to be
technically enforced. It is difficult to comprehend such a
situation under law.”
18.
In the present case, it is not in dispute that the petitioner was not
originally a party to MA No.1456/2005 and MA No.72/2006. The
impugned order dated 03.04.2025 was passed on an application for
substitution whereby the petitioner came to be substituted in place of
respondent-ABB Ltd. Consequently, the petitioner became directly
affected by the said order without having participated in the
proceedings leading to its passing. Although the respondent-ABB Ltd.
has contended that the petitioner had knowledge of the substitution
application and the order prior to issuance of notice by this Court, mere
knowledge of the proceedings cannot be equated with an obligation to
institute review proceedings immediately. The petitioner has explained
that upon receiving notice and becoming aware that its rights and
liabilities stood directly affected, it was required to obtain the complete
record, examine the legal implications arising out of the demerger
approved by the NCLT, and ascertain the factual background of
arbitration proceedings spanning several years. The explanation
furnished that the record comprised twelve volumes and required
detailed examination cannot be said to be inherently improbable or
lacking in bona fides.
19.
It has also been explained that certified copy of the record was
applied for on 12.08.2025 and supplied on 28.09.2025. Though the
respondent-ABB Ltd. has questioned the necessity of obtaining
certified copies, it cannot be overlooked that a litigant seeking review of
a judicial order is ordinarily expected to proceed on the basis of
authenticated
records,
particularly
when
the
order
concerns
substitution consequent upon a corporate restructuring involving
transfer of liabilities. The time consumed in obtaining certified copies,
therefore, deserves due consideration while examining whether
sufficient cause exists.
20.
More importantly, the impugned order has the effect of
substituting the petitioner in place of respondent-ABB Ltd., thereby
potentially fastening upon the petitioner the consequences arising out
of pending proceedings. The petitioner seeks restoration of the
substitution application for fresh consideration after being afforded an
opportunity of hearing. Thus, the review petitions raise an issue
concerning observance of the principles of natural justice. Ordinarily,
where a person alleges that an order adversely affecting its rights has
been passed without affording an opportunity of hearing, the Court
ought to lean in favour of adjudicating such grievance on merits unless
the conduct of the applicant is demonstrably mala fide or grossly
negligent.
21.
The respondent-ABB Ltd. has emphasized that there is a delay
even if limitation is reckoned from 14.05.2025. However, the length of
delay is not decisive; what is material is the acceptability of the
explanation. In the facts of the present case, the explanation offered by
the
petitioner
appears
to
be
plausible
and
supported
by
contemporaneous events. No material has been brought on record to
establish that the petitioner deliberately delayed the institution of the
review petitions with an oblique motive or to secure any unfair
advantage. Further, condonation of delay would not determine the
merits of the controversy relating to substitution. It would merely enable
the Court to examine whether the order dated 03.04.2025 requires
reconsideration after hearing all affected parties. On the other hand,
refusal to condone the delay would foreclose the petitioner's challenge
to an order which directly affects its legal rights without examination on
merits. The balance of justice, therefore, tilts in favour of condoning the
delay.
22.
On the basis of aforesaid discussions, this Court is satisfied that
the petitioner has shown sufficient cause for not approaching the Court
within the prescribed period. The delay deserves to be condoned in
order to advance substantial justice, leaving all questions on merits to
be decided independently without being influenced by the observations
made herein. Accordingly, the applications (IA No.02/2025) for
condonation of delay in filing the review petitions are allowed and delay
in filing these petitions is hereby condoned.
23.
As regards recalling of the order dated 3.4.2025, the application
for substitution was filed by the respondent-ABB Ltd. on the ground
that dispute in aforesaid cases relates to Power Grid Business of ABB
Ltd. which has been transferred to ABB Power Products and Systems
India Ltd.; the said Scheme of Arrangement has been approved by the
NCLT vide order dated 27.11.2019 and after that ABB Power Products
and Systems India Ltd. has changed its name to Hitachi Energy India
Ltd. (petitioner herein). The respondent-ABB Ltd. also filed documents
demonstrating this fact of the Registrar of Companies and contended
that Hitachi Energy India Ltd. being a necessary party is required to be
substituted in place of ABB Ltd. (formerly known as Asea Brown Boveri
Ltd.) in both the appeals.
24.
In the review petitions, the petitioner has stated that earlier the
respondent-ABB Ltd. had made various communications with regard to
the liability arising from both the appeals but they have been
categorically denied by the petitioner vide letter dated 30 th May, 2022
(Annexure A/5), letter dated 14th September, 2023 (Annexure A/8) and
letter dated 3rd March, 2025 (Annexure A/11). However, this fact of
petitioner’s specific denial with regard to the aforesaid liability was not
mentioned in the substitution applications.
25.
In the matter of Grindlays Bank Ltd. (supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed in para 13 of its judgment as under:
“13. We are unable to appreciate the contention that
merely because the ex parte award was based on the
statement of the manager of the appellant, the order
setting aside the ex parte award, in fact, amounts to
review. The decision in Patel Narshi Thakershi v.
Pradyumansinghji is distinguishable. It is an authority for
the proposition that the power of review is not an
inherent power, it must be conferred either specifically or
by necessary implication. Sub-sections (1) and (3) of
Section 11 of the Act themselves make a distinction
between procedure and powers of the Tribunal under the
Act. While the procedure is left to be devised by the
Tribunal to suit carrying out its functions under the Act,
the powers of civil court conferred upon it are clearly
defined. The question whether a party must be heard
before it is proceeded against is one of procedure and
not of power in the sense in which the words are used in
Section 11. The answer to the question is, therefore, to
be found in sub-section (1) of Section 11 and not in subsection
(3)
of
Section
11.
Furthermore,
different
considerations arise on review. The expression “review”
is used in two distinct senses, namely (1) a procedural
review which is either inherent or implied in a court or
Tribunal to set aside a palpably erroneous order passed
under a misapprehension by it, and (2) a review on
merits when the error sought to be corrected is one of
law and is apparent on the face of the record. It is in the
latter sense that the Court in Patel Narshi Thakershi's
case held that no review lies on merits unless a statute
specifically provides for it. Obviously when a review is
sought due to a procedural defect, the inadvertent error
committed by the Tribunal must be corrected ex debito
justitiae to prevent the abuse of its process, and such
power inheres in every court or Tribunal.”
26.
As for the contention of the respondent-ABB Ltd. that nobody
can be compelled and dragged into a litigation which, in that person’s
understanding, is not related to him, upon an overall consideration of
the material available on record, this Court finds that the order dated
03.04.2025, whereby the petitioner was substituted in place of ABB
Ltd., was passed without affording the petitioner an opportunity of
hearing, though the order directly affects its legal rights and liabilities.
The record further reveals that even prior to filing of the substitution
applications, the petitioner had consistently disputed that the liabilities
forming the subject matter of the present appeals stood transferred to it
under the Scheme of Arrangement approved by the NCLT. Such
dispute was neither admitted nor undisputed and, therefore, required
judicial determination after hearing all the affected parties. The
substitution applications came to be allowed without hearing the
petitioner's stand on this crucial aspect, resulting in a procedural
infirmity and violation of the principles of natural justice. The scope of
the present review is confined to correcting this procedural error and
does not extend to adjudicating the merits of the rival claims regarding
transfer of liability.
27.
The contention of respondent-ABB Ltd. that it cannot be
compelled to remain a party to proceedings which, according to it, no
longer concern it, also cannot be accepted at this stage. Although a
litigant is ordinarily the dominus litis, the said principle is not absolute
and cannot be invoked to substitute another entity in its place when
such substitution itself is seriously disputed by the proposed
transferee. Both the miscellaneous appeals arise out of the order
passed by the learned District Judge and the award passed by the
learned Arbitrator, wherein liability has been fastened upon ABB Ltd. If
ABB Ltd. seeks to contend that, by virtue of the Scheme of
Arrangement approved by the NCLT, such liability has stood
transferred to Hitachi Energy India Ltd. (formerly ABB Power Products
and Systems India Ltd.), the said contention necessarily requires
adjudication after impleading and hearing the alleged successor entity.
Until such determination is made, ABB Ltd. cannot be discharged from
the proceedings merely on its own assertion of transfer of liability.
Otherwise, there would be no party before the Court against whom the
respondent, M/s Sarda Energy & Minerals Ltd., could enforce or
defend its rights in the pending appeals, thereby creating a procedural
vacuum and frustrating the effective adjudication of the dispute. The
fact situation of the case law cited by learned counsel for the
respondent-ABB Ltd. is of no help to him in the fact situation of the
instant case.
28.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is of
the considered opinion that, before adjudicating IA No.04/2025 seeking
substitution of the petitioner in place of ABB Ltd., the petitioner ought to
have been afforded an effective opportunity of hearing to place its
objections and submissions on the proposed substitution. However,
such opportunity was inadvertently not extended, and the order dated
03.04.2025 substituting the petitioner in place of ABB Ltd. came to be
passed without hearing the petitioner. Since the impugned order
directly affects the petitioner's rights and liabilities, the failure to afford
an opportunity of hearing constitutes a violation of the principles of
natural justice, warranting recall of the said order.
29.
For the aforesaid reasons, both the review petitions stand
allowed. The impugned order dated 3.4.2025 passed in MA
No.1456/2005 and MA No.72/2006 is hereby recalled. Registry is
directed to restore ABB Ltd. as appellant/respondent in the respective
miscellaneous appeals.
Learned counsel for the parties are directed to remain present at
the time of hearing of both these appeals on the next date of hearing
so that the substitution applications (IA No.4/2025) filed by the
respondent-ABB Ltd. may be disposed of afresh after affording
reasonable opportunity of hearing to all the parties concerned including
the petitioner herein.
Sd/
Digitally signed
MOHD
MOHD by
AKHTAR KHAN
AKHTAR Date:
2026.07.17
KHAN
17:12:15
+0530
Khan
(Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review