Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:9600
NAFR
AVINASH
SHARMA
AVINASH SHARMA
Date: 2026.02.26
10:10:35 +0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 8743 of 2023
Hirendra Kumar Singh Rana S/o Late Shri Mahesh Singh Rana Aged
About 60 Years Assistant Grade II, Posted At Tahsil Office Bhaiyathan,
District Surajpur (C.G.) Presently Attached At Collectorate Office At
Surajpur, District Surajpur (C.G.)
... Petitioner.
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Revenue Department,
New Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar New Raipur, District
Raipur (C.G.)
-
Collector
Surajpur,
District
Surajpur
(C.G.)
3 - Joint Director Treasury Accounting And Pension, Surguja Division,
Ambikapur, District Ambikapur (C.G.)
4 - Treasury Officer District Treasury At Surajpur, District Surajpur (C.G.)
5 - Tahsildar Bhaiyathan, District Surajpur (C.G.)
... Respondents.
For Petitioner
: Shri Vaibhav Goverdhan, Advocate.
For State/ Respondent : Shri Yashwant Thakur, Addl AG.
Hon’ble Shri Amitendra Kishore Prasad, Judge
Order on Board
24/02/2026
1.
This Writ Petition has been filed by the petitioner against the
impugned recovery order (Annexure P/1) dated 23.03.2023
passed
by
the
Respondent
No.5,
whereby
recovery
of
Rs.8,98,459/- for the period from 01.01.2006 to 28.02.2023 has
been sought against the petitioner on account of excess payment
made due to wrong pay fixation.
2.
The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:1] That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to quash the impugned order of recovery dated
23.03.2023 (Ann.P-1) passed by the respondent
no. 5 herein.
2] That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to direct the respondent authorities to pay the
amount, which, they have already recovered, in
pursuance
23.03.2023.
of
the
impugned
order
dated
3] That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to grant any other relief(s), which is deemed fit
and
proper
in
the
aforesaid
facts
and
circumstances of the case.
3.
Brief facts of the case, are that the on 06.09.1988, the petitioner
was appointed on compassionate ground, to the post of Second
Grade -2 Clerk. It is submitted that, after appointment of the
petitioner, he was discharging his duties to the utmost satisfaction
of the respondent authorities and has never given any chance of
complaint till date. It is submitted that, after completion of 1 year of
service, the petitioner was given increment, but, vide order dated
05.01.2006, it is ordered that, since the petitioner's date of birth is
30.01.1963 and he has not passed Hindi Typing examination,
therefore, in such case, the petitioner is entitle for increment, w.e.f.
30.01.2004, i.e. after one year from him attaining the age of 40
years. In pursuance of this order, the department has started
recovering the amount paid to the petitioner from earlier years. It is
submitted that, being aggrieved by the order dated 05.01.2006,
the petitioner filed W.P.S. No. 4124/2006 before the Hon'ble Court,
which came to be allowed on 02.02.2017 and the order dated
05.01.2006 is quashed. It is submitted that after passing of the
order by the Hon'ble Court, vide order dated 26.05.2017, the
learned Upper Collector, directed the Tahsildar, Bhaiyathan, for
payment of increments and arrears to the petitioner. It is submitted
that, thereafter, the petitioner was given the benefit of increment
and arrears have also been paid to him. At present, the petitioner
is drawing basic salary of Rs. 47,500/- and his net salary is Rs.
54,640/-. ANNEXURE P-6 is the salary slip of the petitioner for the
month of December 2022 and January 2023 filed herewith
collectively. It is submitted that, all of sudden, out of nowhere, on
23.03.2023, the respondent no. 5 has passed the impugned order,
without issuing any show cause notice, without assigning any
reason, without providing any opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner; in order to overreach the order passed by this Hon'ble
Court in W. P. S. No. 4124/2006, dated 02.02.2017, and has
directed for recovery of Rs. 8,98,459.00/- against the excess
payment made to the petitioner from 01.01.2006 to 28.02.2023. By
way of the impugned order, it is directed that, per month Rs.
10,000/- would be deducted from February 2023 to January 2025,
from the salary of the petitioner in 24 installments and thereafter
remaining amount would be deducted from the retiral dues of the
petitioner. It is submitted that, after passing of the impugned order,
with immediate effect, the respondent authorities have started
deducting near about 20,000/- from the salary of the petitioner. Out
of which, Rs. 10,000/- is against the head of recovery and
remaining amount is not being paid, towards the increment and
arrears, and as such, the petitioner is being paid Net Salary of Rs.
39,623/- instead of Rs. 54640/- ANNEXURE P-7 is the copies of
the salary slip of the petitioner for the month of March 2023 to
June 2023 filed herewith collectively. It is submitted that after
passing of the impugned order, the petitioner being low paid
employee, has many time approached the respondent no. 2 & 5,
and requested to look after the matter, and the respondent
authorities have assured the petitioner that, it was mistake, which
would be corrected very soon, but as no positive action is taken,
the petitioner has given the representation to the learned
Commissioner and Collector, but till date, nothing has happened.
It is submitted that, by way of the impugned order, again, the
respondent authorities are recovering the amount paid to the
petitioner, against the increment and arrears, which is illegal,
erroneous and contrary to the order passed by this Hon'ble Court
in W.P. S. No. 4124/2006. It is submitted that, the order passed by
this Hon'ble Court in W.P.S. No. 4124/2006 was never called in
question by the respondents and same has attained finality and
therefore the impugned order is nothing but an attempt of the
respondent no. 5 to overreach the order passed by this Hon'ble
Court and therefore, same is liable to be quashed, hence this writ
petition. It is submitted that the order passed by the respondent
no. 5 is illegal, erroneous and contrary to law, it is therefore liable
to be set-aside.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the petitioner
was initially appointed as Second Grade -2 Clerk on 06.09.1998
and he has been serving the respondent authorities with utmost
sincerity. To the utter shock of the petitioner, Respondent No.5
issued the impugned order dated 23.03.2023 directing recovery of
alleged excess payment said to have been made from 01.01.2006
to 28.02.2023 on account of wrong pay fixation. It is contended
that the petitioner had no role whatsoever in fixation of his pay.
The fixation was made by the competent authorities from time to
time in accordance with the prevailing rules. It is submitted that the
amount of increment which was paid to the petitioner is being
recovered by the respondent authorities by way of the impugned
order. If recovery is now effected after a lapse of more than 15
years, it would cause grave financial hardship and irreparable loss
to the petitioner.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner urged that any error in fixation,
if at all, is solely attributable to the respondent authorities and not
to the petitioner. In this regard, reliance is placed on the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Punjab and others v.
Rafiq Masih, (2015) AIR SCW 501, wherein it has been
categorically
held
that
recovery
of
excess
payment
is
impermissible in certain categories, including where excess
payment has been made for a period exceeding five years, and
recovery from the employees belonging to Class III service and
where such recovery would be harsh, arbitrary, and inequitable.
The case of the petitioner squarely falls within clause (i) and
clause (iii) of the said judgment.
6.
It is also submitted that this Court, in Bare Lal Uike v. State of
Chhattisgarh & others, WPS No.6009 of 2018, following the law
laid down in Rafiq Masih (supra), has quashed similar recovery
orders, holding that when the employee is not responsible for
erroneous fixation or excess payment, recovery cannot be made.
7.
Learned counsel would submit that the impugned order is wholly
arbitrary, malafide, and unsustainable in law, as it seeks to saddle
the petitioner with recovery for a period of near about 17 years
without any fault on his part. It is, therefore, prayed that the
impugned order
dated 23.03.2023 be quashed, and the
respondents be restrained from effecting any recovery from the
petitioner.
8.
Reliance has been placed upon the judgments of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Thomas Daniel v. State of Kerala and others,
2022 SCC OnLine SC 536, and Jogeswar Sahoo and others v.
District Judge, Cuttack and others, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 724,
wherein it has been held that when excess payment is made to an
employee on account of an employer’s erroneous interpretation of
rules, and not on account of any fraud, misrepresentation, or
suppression of facts by the employee, recovery of such excess
payment is impermissible. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has further
observed that any such recovery, more particularly after retirement
and without affording an opportunity of hearing, would be
inequitable, arbitrary, and unsustainable in law.
9.
Further reliance has been placed on the decisions of this Court in
Shankar Narayan Chakrawarty v. State of Chhattisgarh and
others, WPS No.9716/2019, decided on 30.01.2020, and N.N.
Dwivedi
v.
State
of
Chhattisgarh
and
others,
WPS
No.6218/2023 and analogous cases, decided on 26.11.2024. In
the aforesaid cases, this Court has held that in the absence of any
statutory rule, an undertaking furnished by the employee cannot
be treated as binding in order to justify recovery of alleged excess
payments.
10.
Per contra, learned State counsel opposes the submissions made
on behalf of the petitioner and submits that the impugned order
dated 23.03.2023 has rightly been passed by the competent
authority after due scrutiny of the service records of the petitioner.
It is urged that the petitioner had been drawing salary in excess of
his entitlement on account of erroneous fixation of pay, which was
later detected during audit and verification. Once such irregularity
came to the notice of the authorities, it became incumbent upon
them to rectify the pay fixation and recover the excess amount, in
order to prevent undue loss to the public exchequer. He further
submits that the principle of “no one should be unjustly enriched at
the cost of the State” squarely applies in the present case. The
petitioner has enjoyed financial benefits for more than 16 years
and, therefore, cannot now turn around and contend that the State
is estopped from recovering the excess payments. It is further
contended that furnishing of undertakings at the time of fixation
and acceptance of benefits thereunder binds the petitioner to
abide by any subsequent correction made by the authorities. He
also contends that the judgments relied upon by the petitioner are
distinguishable on facts inasmuch as in those cases recovery was
sought either after retirement or without affording any hearing,
whereas in the present case the petitioner was to retire on
31.01.2025 whereas impugned recover order was issued on
23.03.2023 and ample opportunity has been granted to him by
way of representation. It is further submitted that the doctrine of
unjust enrichment, as well as the obligation of the Government to
safeguard public funds, outweighs the plea of hardship raised by
the petitioner. Accordingly, no interference is called for in the
impugned order.
11.
I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and
perused the documents annexed with the writ petition.
12.
Very recently, in the matter of Jogeswar Sahoo (supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as follows :“8. The law in this regard has been settled by
this Court in catena of judgments rendered
time and again; Sahib Ram vs. State of
Haryana, (1995) Supp (1) SCC 18, Shyam
Babu Verma vs. Union of India, (1994) 2 SCC
521, Union of India vs. M. Bhaskar, (1996) 4
SCC 416 and V. Gangaram vs. Regional Jt.
Director, (1997) 6 SCC 139 and in a recent
decision in the matter of Thomas Daniel vs.
State of Kerala & Ors., (2022) SCC OnLine
SC 536.
9. This Court has consistently taken the view
that if the excess amount was not paid on
account of any misrepresentation or fraud on
the part of the employee or if such excess
payment was made by the employer by
applying a wrong principle for calculating the
pay/allowance or on the basis of a particular
interpretation
of
rule/order,
which
is
subsequently found to be erroneous, such
excess
payments
of
emoluments
or
allowances are not recoverable. It is held that
such relief against the recovery is not
because of any right of the employee but in
equity, exercising judicial discretion to provide
relief to the employee from the hardship that
will be caused if the recovery is ordered.
10. In Thomas Daniel (supra), this Court has
held thus in paras 10, 11, 12 and 13:
“10. In Sahib Ram v. State of Haryana,
this
Court
restrained
recovery
of
payment which was given under the
upgraded pay scale on account of wrong
construction of relevant order by the
authority
concerned,
misrepresentation
on
without
any
part
the
of
employees. It was held thus:
“5. Admittedly the appellant does not
possess
the
qualifications.
required
educational
Under
the
circumstances the appellant would not
be entitled to the relaxation. The
Principal erred in granting him the
relaxation.
Since
the
date
of
relaxation, the appellant had been
paid his salary on the revised scale.
However, it is not on account of any
misrepresentation
made
by
the
appellant that the benefit of the higher
pay scale was given to him but by
wrong construction made by the
Principal
for
which
the
appellant
cannot be held to be at fault. Under
the circumstances the amount paid till
date may not be recovered from the
appellant. The principle of equal pay
for equal work would not apply to the
scales prescribed by the University
Grants Commission. The appeal is
allowed partly without any order as to
costs.”
11.
In
Col.
B.J.
Akkara
(Retd.)
v.
Government of India, this Court considered
an identical question as under:
“27.
The
last
question
to
be
considered is whether relief should be
granted against the recovery of the
excess payments made on account of
the
wrong
interpretation/understanding
of
the
circular dated 7-6-1999. This Court
has consistently granted relief against
recovery of excess wrong payment of
emoluments/allowances
from
an
employee, if the following conditions
are fulfilled (vide Sahib Ram v. State
of Haryana [1995 Supp (1) SCC 18 :
1995 SCC (L&S) 248], Shyam Babu
Verma v. Union of India [(1994) 2 SCC
521 : 1994 SCC (L&S) 683 : (1994) 27
ATC 121], Union of India v. M.
Bhaskar [(1996) 4 SCC 416 : 1996
SCC (L&S) 967] and V. Gangaram v.
Regional Jt. Director [(1997) 6 SCC
139 : 1997 SCC (L&S) 1652]):
(a) The excess payment was not
made
on
account
of
any
misrepresentation or fraud on the part
of the employee.
(b) Such excess payment was made
by the employer by applying a wrong
principle
for
calculating
the
pay/allowance or on the basis of a
particular interpretation of rule/order,
which is subsequently found to be
erroneous.
28.
Such
recovery
relief,
of
restraining
excess
back
payment,
is
granted by courts not because of any
right in the employees, but in equity, in
exercise of judicial discretion to relieve
the employees from the hardship that
will
be
caused
if
recovery
is
implemented. A government servant,
particularly one in the lower rungs of
service
would
emoluments
he
spend
whatever
receives
for
the
upkeep of his family. If he receives an
excess payment for a long period, he
would spend it, genuinely believing
that he is entitled to it. As any
subsequent action to recover the
excess payment will cause undue
hardship to him, relief is granted in
that behalf. But where the employee
had knowledge that the payment
received was in excess of what was
due or wrongly paid, or where the
error is detected or corrected within a
short time of wrong payment, courts
will not grant relief against recovery.
The matter being in the realm of
judicial discretion, courts may on the
facts
and
circumstances
of
any
particular case refuse to grant such
relief against recovery.
29. On the same principle, pensioners
can also seek a direction that wrong
payments should not be recovered, as
pensioners
are
disadvantageous
in
a
more
position
when
compared to in-service employees.
Any attempt to recover excess wrong
payment would cause undue hardship
to them. The petitioners are not guilty
of any misrepresentation or fraud in
regard to the excess payment. NPA
was added to minimum pay, for
purposes of stepping up, due to a
wrong
understanding
by
the
implementing departments. We are
therefore
of
the
view
that
the
respondents shall not recover any
excess
payments
made
towards
pension in pursuance of the circular
dated 7-6-1999 till the issue of the
clarificatory circular dated 11-9-2001.
Insofar as any excess payment made
after the circular dated 11-9-2001,
obviously the Union of India will be
entitled to recover the excess as the
validity of the said circular has been
upheld and as pensioners have been
put on notice in regard to the wrong
calculations earlier made.”
12. In Syed Abdul Qadir v. State of Bihar,
excess payment was sought to be recovered
which was made to the appellants-teachers
on
account
of
mistake
and
wrong
interpretation of prevailing Bihar Nationalised
Secondary
Rules,
School
1983.
(Service
The
Conditions)
appellants
therein
contended that even if it were to be held that
the appellants were not entitled to the benefit
of additional increment on promotion, the
excess amount should not be recovered from
them, it having been paid without any
misrepresentation or fraud on their part. The
Court held that the appellants cannot be held
responsible in such a situation and recovery
of the excess payment should not be ordered,
especially
when
the
employee
has
subsequently retired. The court observed that
in general parlance, recovery is prohibited by
courts
where
there
exists
no
misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the
employee and when the excess payment has
been
made
by
applying
a
wrong
interpretation/understanding of a Rule or
Order. It was held thus:
“59. Undoubtedly, the excess amount
that has been paid to the appellant
teachers was not because of any
misrepresentation or fraud on their part
and
the
appellants
also
had
no
knowledge that the amount that was
being paid to them was more than what
they were entitled to. It would not be out
of place to mention here that the
Finance Department had, in its counteraffidavit, admitted that it was a bona fide
mistake on their part. The excess
payment made was the result of wrong
interpretation of the Rule that was
applicable
to
them,
for
which
the
appellants cannot be held responsible.
Rather,
the
whole
confusion
was
because of inaction, negligence and
carelessness of the officials concerned
of the Government of Bihar. Learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellant
teachers
submitted
that
majority of the beneficiaries have either
retired or are on the verge of it. Keeping
in
view
the
peculiar
facts
and
circumstances of the case at hand and
to avoid any hardship to the appellant
teachers, we are of the view that no
recovery of the amount that has been
paid in excess to the appellant teachers
should be made.”
13. In State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White
Washer) wherein this court examined the
validity of an order passed by the State to
recover
the
monetary
gains
wrongly
extended to the beneficiary employees in
excess of their entitlements without any fault
or misrepresentation at the behest of the
recipient. This Court considered situations of
hardship caused to an employee, if recovery
is directed to reimburse the employer and
disallowed
the
same,
exempting
the
beneficiary employees from such recovery. It
was held thus:
“8. As
between
two
parties,
if
a
determination is rendered in favour of
the party, which is the weaker of the two,
without any serious detriment to the
other (which is truly a welfare State), the
issue resolved would be in consonance
with the concept of justice, which is
assured to the citizens of India, even in
the Preamble of the Constitution of
India. The right to recover being pursued
by the employer, will have to be
compared, with the effect of the recovery
on the employee concerned. If the effect
of the recovery from the employee
concerned would be, more unfair, more
wrongful, more improper, and more
unwarranted, than the corresponding
right of the employer to recover the
amount, then it would be iniquitous and
arbitrary, to effect the recovery. In such a
situation, the employee's right would
outbalance, and therefore eclipse, the
right of the employer to recover.
xxxxxxxxx
18. It is not possible to postulate all
situations
of
hardship which
would
govern employees on the issue of
recovery,
where
payments
have
mistakenly been made by the employer,
in excess of their entitlement. Be that as
it may, based on the decisions referred
to hereinabove, we may, as a ready
reference, summarise the following few
situations, wherein recoveries by the
employers, would be impermissible in
law:
(i)
Recovery
from
the
employees
belonging to Class III and Class IV
service (or Group C and Group D
service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees,
or the employees who are due to retire
within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when
the excess payment has been made for
a period in excess of five years, before
the order of recovery is issued.
(iv)
Recovery
in
cases
where
an
employee has wrongfully been required
to discharge duties of a higher post, and
has been paid accordingly, even though
he should have rightfully been required
to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court
arrives at the conclusion, that recovery if
made from the employee, would be
iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such
an extent, as would far outweigh the
equitable balance of the employer's right
to recover.”
11. In the case at hand, the appellants were
working on the post of Stenographers when
the subject illegal payment was made to
them. It is not reflected in the record that such
payment was made to the appellants on
account of any fraud or misrepresentation by
them. It seems, when the financial benefit
was extended to the appellants by the District
Judge, Cuttack, the same was subsequently
not approved by the High Court which
resulted in the subsequent order of recovery.
It is also not in dispute that the payment was
made in the year 2017 whereas the recovery
was directed in the year 2023. However, in
the meanwhile, the appellants have retired in
the year 2020. It is also an admitted position
that the appellants were not afforded any
opportunity of hearing before issuing the
order of recovery. The appellants having
superannuated on a ministerial post of
Stenographer were admittedly not holding
any gazetted post as such applying the
principle enunciated by this Court in the
above quoted judgment, the recovery is found
unsustainable.”
13.
Reverting to the facts of the case, this Court is of the view that the
controversy involved in the present case is no longer res integra.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih (supra) has
categorically held that recoveries of alleged excess payment
cannot be made in cases where such payment was not
occasioned by any misrepresentation, fraud or suppression on the
part of the employee, but was solely on account of an error
committed by the employer while fixing the pay. The principle has
been reiterated in Thomas Daniel (supra) and Jogeswar Sahoo
(supra), wherein it has been emphasized that recovery after a long
lapse of time, particularly when the employee has arranged his
financial affairs on the basis of the pay fixed by the competent
authority, is inequitable, arbitrary and unsustainable in law.
14.
In the present case, it is not in dispute that the petitioner was
appointed in 1988, thereafter his pay fixation from time to time was
carried out by the competent authorities. At no stage was it
indicated to him that such fixation was erroneous or that he may
be liable to refund any alleged excess payment. For more than
sixteen years, the petitioner has been drawing salary in terms of
such fixation. There is also nothing on record to even remotely
suggest that the petitioner had played any role in misleading the
authorities, or that he was guilty of fraud, misrepresentation, or
suppression of material facts. In these circumstances, fastening
liability upon the petitioner at this belated stage would be wholly
unjust and contrary to the principles of fairness, equity and good
conscience as recognized in the aforesaid binding precedents.
15.
Moreover, the recovery directed against the petitioner not only
overlooks
the
settled
legal
position
but
also
causes
disproportionate hardship. Ordering recovery of alleged excess
payments spanning sixteen years would result in grave prejudice
and irreparable financial loss, which the law does not permit in
absence of any fault on the part of the employee.
16.
For the aforesaid reasons, this Court is of the firm opinion that the
impugned order dated 23.03.2023 passed by the Respondent
No.5 vide Annexure P/1, directing recovery of the alleged excess
payment, cannot be sustained in law and deserves to be set aside.
17.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The impugned order
dated 23.03.2023 is hereby quashed. The respondents are
restrained from effecting any recovery from the petitioner on
account of alleged excess payment.
18.
It is made clear that if any recovery has already been made from
the petitioner pursuant to the impugned order, the same shall be
refunded to him within a period of three months from the date of
production of certified copy of this order. There shall be no order
as to costs.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Avinash
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review