The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the delay in filing the appeal was on account of non-availability of Category Code for filing Commercial Appeal in this Court. This fact, however, was not taken in the application for condonation of delay preferred along with the Commercial Appeal. This Court would, therefore, be indulgent to treat the explanation urged herein as a ‘sufficient reason’ as per Order 47, Rule 1 of CPC to review the impugned judgment as otherwise the appellant/review petitioner herein would suffer irreparably. Learned counsel for the petitioner has tried to draw our attention to the merits of the findings of the learned Commercial Court to impress that they suffer from serious errors in appreciation of the case of the parties as borne out from the pleadings and evidence on record and also from serious errors of law. Therefore, the review petition may be allowed in the interest of justice.
4. We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the petitioner and taken note of the grounds urged in the instant review petition. The grounds for review are enumerated under Order 47, Rule 1 of CPC which is quoted hereunder: “1. Application for review of judgment - (1) Any person considering himself aggrieved (a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but from which no appeal has been preferred, (b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is allowed, or (c) by a decision on a reference from a Court of Small Causes, and who, from the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence was not within his knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the decree was passed or order made, or on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reason, desires to obtain a review of the decree passed or order made against him, may apply for a review of judgment to the Court which passed the decree or made the order. (2) A party who is not appealing from a decree or Order may apply for a review of judgment notwithstanding the pendency of an appeal by some other party except where the ground of such appeal is common to the applicant and the appellant, or when, being respondent, he can present to the Appellate Court the case on which he applies for the review. …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
REVIEW PET. 47 OF 2023
Hindustan Steelworks Construction Limited
[A Government of India Undertaking], Tripura Unit, having its
Office at Jackson Gate Building, 3rd Floor, Lenin Sarani,
Agartala, Pin 799001.
….Petitioner/applicant.
Vrs.
Sri Dilip Kumar Kar,
S/o Late Makhan Lal Kar,
Resident of Agartala-Assam Road.
Math Chowmohani, P.O. Dhaleswar,
P.S.-East Agartala, Agartala, West Tripura.
… Respondent-Opposite Party.
Present:
For the
Petitioner/applicant
For the Respondent
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. Jit Roy, Advocate.
: None.
: 05.10.2023
: Yes
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard learned counsel for the review petitioner.
2.
The instant petition seeks review of the judgment and order dated
4th July, 2023, passed in I.A. 01 of 2022 in Commercial Appeal No.02 of 2023
by this Court, whereby the Commercial Appeal preferred by the review
petitioner was dismissed as being barred by limitation. The operative part of
the judgment is quoted hereunder:
“7.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties. We have also
taken note of the explanation or cause sought to be showed by the
petitioner/appellant-Company for condonation of delay of 101 days. Be it
indicated here that before the learned Commercial Court, the present
appellant was defendant in the instant Commercial Suit No.10/2016 and
was the plaintiff in Commercial Suit No.06/2016 against the same party
i.e. the private respondent herein. The suit (Commercial Suit No.10/2016)
was decreed partly on contest in favour of the plaintiff/private respondent
herein. The common judgment of the learned Commercial Court was
delivered on 16.02.2022. The limitation for preferring an appeal as
prescribed under Section 13(1-A) is sixty days from the date of the
judgment or order. The appellant applied for obtaining the certified copy
of the judgment only on 16.06.2022, which was finally collected on
28.06.2022 after it was ready on 27.06.2022. By that time itself, the
appeal was barred by delay. Even if the period of limitation is reckoned
excluding the period of 90 days from 28.02.2022 in view of the order
passed by the Apex Court in Suo Motu WP(C) No.03/2020, the appeal has
been filed after 101 days thereof. The law in this regard has been well
settled by the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Government of
Maharashtra (Water Resources Department) represented by Executive
Engineer v. Borse Brothers Engineers and Contractors Private Limited
reported in (2021) 6 SCC 460. The Apex Court has considered the
interplay of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 with the provisions of
Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended and
Section 5 of the Limitation Act read with Article 116 and 117 of the
Schedule attached thereto and held as under at Para 63 thereof which is
reproduced hereunder:
“63. Given the aforesaid and the object of speedy disposal
sought to be achieved both under the Arbitration Act and the
Commercial Courts Act, for appeals filed under Section 37 of
the Arbitration Act that are governed by Articles 116 and 117
of the Limitation Act or Section 13(1-A) of the Commercial
Courts Act, a delay beyond 90 days, 30 days or 60 days
respectively, is to be condoned by way of exception and not
by way of rule. In a fit case in which a party has otherwise
acted bona fide and not in a negligent manner, a short delay
beyond such period can, in the discretion of the court, be
condoned, always bearing in mind that the other side of the
picture is that the opposite party may have acquired both in
equity and justice, what may now be lost by the fist party’s
inaction, negligence or laches.”
8.
It is not in dispute that the appeal has not been filed within
the 60 days period. The appeal has been preferred after 101 days beyond
the period of limitation of 60 days. The instant appeal does not arise from
an award passed under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and,
therefore, no question of applying the logic of 90 days as under Section
37(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 would arise.
However, it may also be noted that the Apex Court, in the case of Borse
Brothers (supra), has also held at Para 43 that the decision rendered by
the Apex Court in N.V. International v. State of Assam and others
reported in (2020) 2 SCC 109 did not notice the provisions of the
Commercial Courts Act and can be said to be per incuriam on this count.
Secondly, it is correct to note that the period 90 days plus 30 days and not
thereafter mentioned in Section 34(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act cannot now apply, since the limitation period for filing of appeals
under the Commercial Courts Act being 60 days and not 90 days. Thirdly,
the argument that absent a provision curtailing the condonation of delay
beyond the period provided in Section 13 of the Commercial Courts Act
would also make it clear that any such bodily lifting of the last part of
Section 34(3) into Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 would also be unwarranted. The Apex Court in the case of Borse
Brothers (supra), therefore, rejected the argument that a mere casus
omissus which can be filled in by the Court cannot be expected. However,
as observed hereinabove, the instant appeal arises purely from a
Commercial Suit; and reckoning the period of 60 days of limitation
prescribed under Section 13(1-A) thereof, the appeal is grossly barred by
delay.
9.
The appellant has sought to explain the initial delay in
making an application for obtaining the certified copy of the impugned
judgment on 13.05.2022 attributable to the erstwhile learned counsel. By
that time itself, the limitation of 60 days had expired. If the extended
period of limitation under the orders passed by the Apex Court in Suo
Motu WP(C) No.03/2020 is counted till 28.05.2022, the certified copy of
the judgment was received only on 30.05.2022 and reckoning the period
from 30.05.2022 also, the appellant has not been able to show sufficient
cause for condonation of the gross delay of 101 days thereafter. The
narration of the events in the delay condonation petition only shows that
the appellant-Company was consuming time at its own sweet will in
taking decisions on the question of filing of the appeal or preparation of
the memo of appeal, discussion on issues raised by the learned counsel
for the appellant-Company, being completely oblivious of the rigors of the
limitation provided under Section 13 (1-A) of the Commercial Courts Act,
2015 in view of the judgment rendered by the Apex Court in Borse
Brothers (supra). No exception can be made on the ground that the
appellant is an instrumentality of the State as has also been specifically
observed by the Apex Court in the above case. The rigors of the law,
therefore, have to operate in full force. The appellant having failed to
explain sufficient cause for condonation of delay of 101 in preferring the
memo of appeal, this Court is of the considered view that no exception
can be made in such matters relating to appeals arising out of the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 in view of the categorical judgment of the
Apex Court in the case of Borse Brothers (supra).
10. As such, the delay condonation application (IA No.01/2022) is
dismissed. Consequently, the Commercial App. No.02/2023 also stands
dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of.”
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the delay in filing
the appeal was on account of non-availability of Category Code for filing
Commercial Appeal in this Court. This fact, however, was not taken in the
application for condonation of delay preferred along with the Commercial
Appeal. This Court would, therefore, be indulgent to treat the explanation
urged herein as a ‘sufficient reason’ as per Order 47, Rule 1 of CPC to review
the impugned judgment as otherwise the appellant/review petitioner herein
would suffer irreparably. Learned counsel for the petitioner has tried to draw
our attention to the merits of the findings of the learned Commercial Court to
impress that they suffer from serious errors in appreciation of the case of the
parties as borne out from the pleadings and evidence on record and also from
serious errors of law. Therefore, the review petition may be allowed in the
interest of justice.
4.
We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
petitioner and taken note of the grounds urged in the instant review petition.
The grounds for review are enumerated under Order 47, Rule 1 of CPC which
is quoted hereunder:
“1. Application for review of judgment - (1) Any person considering
himself aggrieved (a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but
from which no appeal has been preferred,
(b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is allowed, or
(c) by a decision on a reference from a Court of Small Causes,
and who, from the discovery of new and important matter or evidence
which, after the exercise of due diligence was not within his
knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the
decree was passed or order made, or on account of some mistake or
error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient
reason, desires to obtain a review of the decree passed or order made
against him, may apply for a review of judgment to the Court which
passed the decree or made the order.
(2) A party who is not appealing from a decree or Order may apply
for a review of judgment notwithstanding the pendency of an appeal
by some other party except where the ground of such appeal is
common to the applicant and the appellant, or when, being
respondent, he can present to the Appellate Court the case on which
he applies for the review.
[Explanation-The fact that the decision on a question of law on which
the judgment of the Court is based has been reversed or modified by
the subsequent decision of a superior Court in any other case, shall
not be a ground for the review of such judgment.]”
5.
The review petitioner does not contend that the instant plea if at
all a tenable plea to explain the delay, was not within its knowledge despite
due diligence at the time of filing of the Commercial Appeal and the delay
condonation application. Apart from that, we are otherwise also not satisfied
that the plea relating to non-availability of Category Code for filing
Commercial Appeal has resulted in delay in filing the Commercial Appeal. It
goes without saying that in urgent matters where the limitation is going to
expire, the parties are permitted to file even at the eleventh hour to save the
appeal from being barred on grounds of limitation. Apparently, the ground is
not tenable and appears to be an ingenuous novel ground to get over the rigors
of the Order 47, Rule 1 of CPC and the ratio rendered by the Apex Court in
the case of Government of Maharashtra (Water Resources Department)
represented by Executive Engineer Vrs. Borse Brothers Engineers and
Contractors Private Limited, reported in (2021)6 SCC 460 relying upon
which the Commercial Appeal was dismissed as being barred by delay of 101
days whereas, the period of limitation prescribed under Section 13(1A) of the
Commercial Courts Act is only 60 days. Apart from what has been held
hereinabove learned counsel for the petitioner has not been able to show that
the impugned judgment suffer from any errors apparent on the face of record.
As such, we do not find any grounds to review the impugned judgment and
order.
The
instant
review
petition
stands
dismissed.
Pending
application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(ARINDAM LODH),J
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH),CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review