The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. However, the petitioner cannot be allowed to go scot free as he has clearly been guilty of breach of conditions of his service in Air Force. Therefore, appropriate conditions need to be attached for permitting the petitioner to seek discharge and continue his service as an officer of the J&K Administrative Service.
24. For the foregoing discussion, the writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the respondents to issue NOC and discharge certificate in favour of the petitioner subject to deposition of Rs. 3,00,000/- (Rupees Three Lacs) with the Air Force authorities within two months of receipt of copy of this judgment. In case, any amount is due to the petitioner from the Air Force, the aforesaid amount shall be set off against the dues.
25. Disposed of accordingly.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
Reserved on: 06.02.2026
Pronounced on : 13.02.2026
Uploaded on : 13.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Himmat Kumar Raina
Through:-
….Petitioners
Mr. Sunil Sethi, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Vaibhav Gupta, Advocate.
V/s
Union of India & Ors
Through:-
…..Respondents
Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Sumant Sudan, Advocate.
\
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The petitioner, through the medium of the present
petition, has challenged order dated 01.11.2019 issued by
respondent No. 2 whereby his request seeking his discharge
from Air Force has been rejected. The petitioner has also
sought a direction upon respondents No. 1 to 7 to release him
from
Air
Force
service
by issuing necessary
discharge
certificate so as to enable him to continue in Junior Scale of
the Jammu and Kashmir Administrative Service.
A further
direction, restraining respondents No. 1 to 7 from taking
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
disciplinary action against the petitioner for joining gazetted
service of Junior Scale KAS, has also been sought by the
petitioner.
02.
The facts emanating from pleadings of the parties
are that the petitioner was enrolled in the Indian Air Force on
27.06.2006 and his regular engagement with Indian Air Force
is due to expire on 26.06.2026. It appears that the petitioner
had
joined
the
Indian
Air
Force
after
acquiring
the
qualification of intermediate as a Medical Assistant. It further
appears that during the course of his employment, the
petitioner completed his graduation in the year 2010. In the
year 2016, the petitioner, in response to notification dated
18.06.2016 issued by J&K Public Service Commission, filled
up his form for competing in the J&K Combined Competitive
Examination, 2016.
03.
It further appears that vide his application dated
20.06.2016, the petitioner had sought permission from the
competent authority of the Air Force for submission of his
application to participate in the J&K Combined Competitive
Examination, 2016. However, the permission was not granted
by the competent authority as the post for which the petitioner
had applied does not fall under Group-A. It appears that
despite this, the petitioner proceeded to sit in the examination
and qualified the same. A select list was issued by the J&K
Public
Service
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
Commission
vide
notification
No.
PSC/Exam/47-1/2019 dated 07.08.2019 wherein name of the
petitioner was figuring.
04.
Upon his selection as a Junior Scale KAS Officer,
the petitioner submitted an application dated 27.08.2019
seeking his discharge from Air Force on the ground of his
selection to the civil post of J&K Administrative Service.
It
seems that the said application was returned to the petitioner
without forwarding the same to the Commanding Officer
because he had been selected to a Group ‘B’ and not Group ‘A’
post. In the meantime, the petitioner came to be appointed as
an Officer in the Junior Scale of J&K Administrative Service
vide Government order No. 1015-GAD of 2019 dated 13-092019 and he was asked to join the service within twenty one
days of the issuance of the said order.
05.
After issuance of the appointment order in favour of
the petitioner, he again made application dated 16.09.2019
before respondent No. 7 for his discharge from Air Force on the
ground
of
his
appointment
to
the
civil
post
in
J&K
Administrative Service. Respondent No. 7 is stated to have
recommended the discharge of the petitioner and his release
from service. The said respondent also recommended waiver of
non-compliance to AFO 4/2012 and AFO 33/2017.
06.
The
petitioner,
however,
did
not
receive
the
discharge order and in the meanwhile his request for extension
in joining the fresh service was refused by respondent No. 9.
The petitioner, therefore, proceeded to join the service on
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
01.10.2019 and it appears that he continues to serve as an
Officer
of
J&K
Administrative
Service.
On
01.11.2019,
impugned order came to be issued by respondent No. 2
whereby the petitioner was informed that his request for
discharge has not been approved and that the same has been
rejected by the competent authority.
07.
The petitioner has challenged the impugned action
of the respondents No. 1 to 7 on the grounds that AFO No.
16/2008
dated
19.09.2008
has
not
been
taken
into
consideration by the respondents while issuing the impugned
order. According to the petitioner, the said order provides for
discharge from service on compassionate grounds or for any
other valid personal reasons. It has been further contended
that the petitioner had already completed seven years of
regular service with the Indian Air Force, therefore, he was
fully eligible to be granted permission to leave the service. It
has also been contended that even though the grade pay of
Junior Scale KAS Officer is only Rs. 4800/- yet the similar
posts carry grade pay of Rs. 5400/- in some other states like
Gujarat, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh. Therefore, the post
on which the petitioner was appointed cannot be termed as
Group-B
post.
The
petitioner
has
also
relied
upon
judgments/orders passed by the Delhi High Court in a few
cases whereby the petitioners therein in somewhat similar
circumstances have been permitted to be discharged from
service.
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
08.
The respondents have contested the writ petition by
contending that any person inducted in the Indian Air Force is
subjected to training in phases/modules spanning 2 to 3 years
before they are deployed independently on operational duties.
It has been submitted that Indian Air Force invests heavily on
its work force in moulding the Airmen to meet the operational
needs of IAF and the security requirements of the nation. It is
in this background that Airmen are permitted only in
exceptional cases to apply and seek premature discharge from
service at their own request.
Respondents No. 1 to 7 have
relied upon AFO No. 04/2012 which provides eligibility
conditions for seeking permission to apply for civil posts.
These eligibility conditions include seven years of regular
service and that the Airman should be applying for Group-A
or equivalent posts. As per para 11 of AFO No. 4/2012, the
request for NOC is liable to be rejected where individual has
not obtained prior permission while applying for the post.
09.
According to the respondents, the petitioner was not
fulfilling the criteria inasmuch as he had not applied for
Group-A or equivalent post as the post for which he had
applied falls in Group B. Thus, permission could not have been
granted to him for applying for the said post.
It has been
further contended that once permission was refused to the
petitioner, NOC and discharge from service could not have
been accorded in his favour in terms of the rules and
guidelines in vogue.
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
10.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case.
11.
So far as the factual aspects of the matter are
concerned, the same are not in dispute.
The petitioner had
participated in the selection process for selection to the J&K
Administrative Services and at the time of applying for the
same, he had sought permission from the relevant authorities
of the Air Force. However, the said permission was rejected on
the ground that the post for which he had applied did not fall
in Group-A.
12.
As already stated, paragraph 6 of AFO No. 4 of 2012
which governs such cases, provides that an Airman of the
Indian Air Force is eligible to apply for civil post if he has
completed seven years of regular service and the post for
which
he
applies
Governments
and
falls
in
Group
A
in
equivalent
posts.
The
Central/State
petitioner
had
completed seven years of regular service when he applied for
J&K Administrative Services. However, the post for which he
had applied was carrying grade pay of Rs. 4800/- with
maximum pay of Rs. 34,800/-.
13.
Respondent No. 9 has filed its report in compliance
to order dated 29.11.2022 passed by this Court, whereby the
said respondent was directed to demonstrate the classification
of the posts of J&K Administrative Services. In the said reply,
the said respondent has clearly stated that the post for which
the petitioner had applied falls in Group B when it is equated
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
with the pay scales applicable to employees of the Government
of India. Thus, the contention of the petitioner that the post
for which the petitioner had applied falls in Group-A as similar
posts in some other states fall in the said group is without any
basis. Thus, the petitioner did not fulfill the eligibility criteria
for being permitted to apply for the post of Junior Scale
Administrative Officer in Government of J&K. The competent
authority was, therefore, right in rejecting the application of
the petitioner.
14.
It appears that when the appointment order was
issued in favour of the petitioner, he again applied for
discharge
from
service
and
on
his
application,
a
recommendation was made by respondent No. 7 that the
petitioner may be granted release from service.
In the said
recommendation, respondent No. 7 had noted that AFO No. 33
of 2017 has redefined the criteria to apply for release of
Airman and allowed employment in civil for Group A as well as
Group B posts. It is recorded in the recommendation that the
said order supersedes AFO No. 4 of 2012.
However, the
recommending officer has also noted that in AFO No. 33 of
2017, it is mentioned that Airman should have skill grade A for
release after seven years of service but the petitioner does not
meet the said criteria. On this ground, the petitioner is not
eligible. Thus, even under AFO No. 33 of 2017, the petitioner
does not fulfill the eligibility criteria for being permitted to
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
apply for the post for which he has been appointed or for being
allowed to be discharged from service.
15.
So far as the contention of the petitioner that the
Competent Authority has ignored AFO No. 16/2008 is
concerned, it is to be noted that the said order cannot be made
applicable to the case of the petitioner. AFO No. 16/2008 does
not apply to cases relating to selection to civil posts. Para (6) of
the aforesaid order is very clear about it. Thus, the contention
of the petitioner in this regard is without any merit.
16.
In the face of aforesaid situation, the impugned
action of the respondents when analyzed strictly in the light of
the rules holding the field cannot be faulted.
The Supreme
Court in the case of Amit Kumar Roy Vs. Union of India and
Ors, 2019 (7) SCC 369 has, while discussing a similar issue,
held that a person serving in the Indian Air Force does not
have an unqualified right under Article 19(1)(g) of the
Constitution to leave the service. While holding so, the
Supreme Court made the following observations:
“15
We
are
unable
to
accept
the
submission
of
Mr
Sankaranarayanan that the appellant had an unqualified
right under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution to leave the
service of the Air Force. The provisions of the Air Force Act,
those contained in the rules and the terms of engagement of
the
appellant
belie
such
an
assertion.
AFO
14/2008
emphasizes aspects such as the criticality of the trade and
the exigencies of service. They need to be verified and
assessed before permission is granted. A person who has
been enrolled as a member of the Air Force does not have an
unqualified right to depart from service at his or her will
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
during the term of engagement. Such a construction, as
urged on behalf of the appellant, will seriously impinge upon
manning levels and operational preparedness of the armed
forces.
With
the
rapid
advancement
of
technology,
particularly in its application to military operations, there
has been a reconfiguration of the human and technological
requirements of a fighting force. The interests of the service
are of paramount importance. A balance has been sought to
be drawn between the interests of the service with situations
involving requests by persons enrolled to take civilian
employment. This balance is reflected in the provisions
contained in the Air Force orders, in this case AFO 14/2008.
A person enrolled cannot assert a general right to act in
breach or defiance of those orders.”
17.
After rendering the aforesaid observations, the
Supreme Court exercised its equitable jurisdiction under
Article 142 of the Constitution and issued a direction to the Air
Force authorities that a final NOC and discharge be issued in
favour of the appellant therein so as to do complete justice in
the said matter.
18.
Similar orders have been passed by Delhi High in
several cases, details whereof are given thereunder:
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
Deepak Rajak Vs. Union of India and Ors [WP(C) No.
7526/2012 decided on 04.12.2012]
Charan Singh Bhanvariya Vs. UOI and Ors [ WP(C) No.
3257/2010 decided on 28.07.2010]
CPL. MD. SA Ansari Vs. UOI and Ors [WP(C) No.
5073/2013 decided on 09.10.2014]
CPL. Manoranjan Kumar Vs. UOI & ors [ WP(C) No.
494/2017]
CPL N.K. Jakhar Vs. UOI & ors [WP(C) No. 9088/2008
decided on 21.10.2009].
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
19.
In all the aforesaid cases, the Courts have shown
indulgence on basis of peculiar circumstances of those cases.
The
question
arises
as
to
whether
in
the
facts
and
circumstances of the present case, a similar approach needs to
be adopted by this court.
20.
In the above context, if we have a look at the
pleadings of the parties, it appears that the petitioner belongs
to a far flung village of district Doda, that was militancy
infested at the time when he was undergoing schooling. It has
been pleaded by the petitioner that both his parents were
uneducated hailing from an economically weaker background
as such he has undergone studies after facing acute hardships
and difficulties. It is because of these adverse conditions that
the petitioner could not continue the studies in a college in a
regular mode and instead he had to join employment with
Indian Air Force so as to feed himself and his family.
The tenacity and courage of the petitioner can be gauged from
the fact that even while he was performing his job with Indian
Air Force, he continued to work hard and completed his
graduation. Not only this, due to his brilliance, the petitioner
without any formal coaching and without any regular studies,
obtained the requisite merit in the Combined Competitive
Examination and made it to J&K Administrative Service. This
attitude of the petitioner and his urge to attain higher goals
and excellence in his career is required to be appreciated and
encouraged.
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
21.
As per the recommendations made by respondent
No. 7 in respect of the petitioner, even while performing his
duties with Air Force, the petitioner had shown great
dedication. It is recorded in the said recommendation that the
petitioner had no disciplinary violations in his service meaning
thereby that while performing the job as an Airman, he has not
given scope for any complaints.
22.
In the face of aforesaid conduct of the petitioner and
having regard to the fact that he has potential to attain great
heights in his career, denying him permission to continue his
service as an Officer of the J&K Administrative Service would
work very harshly against him and in fact would discourage
and dishearten him immensely, that would lead to wastage of
a great talent. Apart from this, it to be noted that the petitioner
has left Air Force in the year 2019 and since then about seven
years have elapsed, therefore, no purpose will be served in
directing his re-induction in the Indian Air Force as the same
would expose him to disciplinary action and would also end
his excellent career in J&K Administrative Service.
23.
However, the petitioner cannot be allowed to go scot
free as he has clearly been guilty of breach of conditions of his
service in Air Force. Therefore, appropriate conditions need to
be attached for permitting the petitioner to seek discharge and
continue his service as an officer of the J&K Administrative
Service.
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
24.
For the foregoing discussion, the writ petition is
disposed of with a direction to the respondents to issue NOC
and discharge certificate in favour of the petitioner subject to
deposition of Rs. 3,00,000/- (Rupees Three Lacs) with the Air
Force authorities within two months of receipt of copy of this
judgment. In case, any amount is due to the petitioner from
the Air Force, the aforesaid amount shall be set off against the
dues.
25.
Disposed of accordingly.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
13.02.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes
Naresh Kumar
2026.01.29 03:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
WP(C) No. 4190/2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review