Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/22
GAHC010308382019
2026:GAU-AS:10002
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/9330/2019
HIMEN GOGOI
S/O LT. TUNIRAM GOGOI, R/O BYE LANE -8, SECTOR, BORDOLOI NAGAR
DIST. TINSUKIA, ASSAM, PIN-786125
VERSUS
THE ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LTD. AND 9 ORS.
REP.BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR, BIJULI BHAVAN, PALTAN BAZAR,
GUWAHATI-1
2:THE ASSAM POWER GENERATION COMPANY LTD.
REP.BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR
BIJULI BHAVAN
PALTAN BAZAR
GUWAHATI-1
3:THE CHAIRMAN
APDCL
APGCL
AEGCL
BIJULEE BHAVAN PALTANBAZAR
GUWAHATI-1
4:THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LTD. BIJULI BHAVAN
PALTAN BAZAR
GUWAHATI-1
5:THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
ASSAM POWER GENERATION COMPANY LTD. BIJULI BHAVAN
PALTAN BAZAR
GUWAHATI-1
Page No.# 2/22
6:CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER (HRA)
ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LTD. BIJULI BHAVAN
PALTAN BAZAR
GUWAHATI-1
7:CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER (HR)
ASSAM POWER GENERATION COMPANY LTD. BIJULI BHAVAN
PALTAN BAZAR
GUWAHATI-1
8:CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER (GENERATION)
ASSAM POWER GENERATION COMPANY LTD. BIJULI BHAVAN
PALTAN BAZAR
GUWAHATI-1
9:CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
TINSUKIA ELECTRICITY CIRCLE
ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LTD. TINSUKIA ELECTRICAL
CIRCLE
TINSUKIA
ASSAM
10:ASSISTANT GENERAL MANAGER
T AND C DIVISION
TINSUKIA
ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LTD. TINSUKIA ELECTRICAL
CIRCLE
TINSUKIA
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. S BARTHAKUR, MR. K MOHAMMED,MR R SENSUA
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, APDCL,
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
14/07/2026
Heard Mr. S Borthakur, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. D Gogoi, for
the petitioner and Mr. S P Sarma, learned Standing counsel, APDCL, for the
Page No.# 3/22
respondent Nos. 1, 3, 4, 6, 9 and 10. None has appeared for the respondent
Nos. 2, 5, 7 & 8.
2.
The petitioner in the present writ petition has presented a challenge to an
Office Order dated 05.12.2019, by which, the respondent APDCL, had rejected
the claim of the petitioner for inclusion of his name in the Seniority List
published of the incumbents holding posts in the cadre of Deputy Manager,
APDCL, by holding that he was not an employee of APDCL. The petitioner has
further prayed for a direction upon the APDCL authorities, for inclusion of his
name in the seniority list of the incumbents in the cadre of Deputy Manager,
APDCL.
3.
As projected in the writ petition, the petitioner on his selection, in
pursuance to an advertisement issued by the erstwhile Assam State Electricity
Board
for
recruitment
against
the
posts
of
Junior
Engineer
(Electrical/Mechanical/ Instrumentation), was included in select list so published
for the purpose. Thereafter, vide an order dated 10.09.2005, the petitioner was
appointed by the Assam Power Generation Corporation Limited (in short,
APGCL) as a Junior Engineer and was posted to Namrup Thermal Power Station
(NTPS).
It is to be noted that by the time, the petitioner was so appointed vide the
order dated 10.09.2005, erstwhile Assam State Electricity Board was already
unbundled into three distinct companies, i.e., Assam Power Generation
Corporation Limited, Assam Power Distribution Company Limited and Assam
Electricity Grid Corporation Limited.
The petitioner by virtue of his appointment being effected, vide order
Page No.# 4/22
dated 10.09.2005, was placed in the services of the Assam Power Generation
Corporation Limited (in short, APGCL). The petitioner had taken over the charge
of his appointed post on 17.10.2005, by submitting his joining report and charge
taking over report before the authorities of the APGCL. Thereafter, the
petitioner, along with one Brojen Saikia, had submitted applications for their
mutual transfer.
It is to be noted that said Brojen Saikia, at the relevant point of time, was
posted under the control of the APDCL. The said request was accepted and vide
order dated 21.03.2007, the petitioner was transferred from Namrup Thermal
Power Station to Tinkhong Electric Sub-Division, in his capacity as a Junior
Engineer. The order was so issued by the authorities of the Upper Assam
Electricity Distribution Company Limited, which is placed under the APDCL. The
petitioner, accordingly, joined his services at Tinkhong Electric Sub-Division.
It is to be noted that the petitioner having proceeded to assume the
charge of a post in APDCL organization, his Last Pay Certificate was issued by
the APGCL authorities. The petitioner is found to have thereafter, continued in
his services in APDCL. The petitioner, having joined his services on 17.10.2005,
with a stipulation in his appointment order that he would remain on probation
for a period of 2 (two) years, the APDCL authorities, at the relevant point of
time, the petitioner being placed under their control, proceeded to issue an
order dated 17.10.2007, declaring the services of the petitioner during the
probation period to be satisfactory. The pay and allowances of the petitioner,
upon his completion of the period of probation, was also accordingly fixed by
the APDCL authorities. The petitioner, at the relevant point of time, was also
declared to be eligible for appointment as Assistant Engineer by the Assam
Page No.# 5/22
State Electricity Board, vide a Notification dated 07.02.2007.
Thereafter, the petitioner submitted an application before the Chairman,
Assam State Electricity Board for promoting him from the post of Junior
Engineer to Assistant Engineer, by highlighting that he had the requisite
qualification and had successfully completed 4 (four) years of service as a Junior
Engineer in the Board. Pursuant to a DPC held in the matter, the petitioner
being recommended, the APGCL authorities vide an order dated 17.02.2010,
proceeded to appoint the petitioner provisionally as Assistant Manager
(Instrumentation) and posted him in the establishment of the General Manager,
NTPS, APGCL, Namrup, with effect from the date of taking over charge. A fresh
probationary period of service also came to be stipulated for the petitioner vide
the order dated 17.02.2010. The petitioner in terms of the appointment effected
in his case against the post of Assistant Manager, vide order dated 17.02.2010,
assumed the charge of the said post, by submitting a joining report dated
11.03.2010, before the General Manager, Namrup Thermal Power Station. The
petitioner continued in his services as an Assistant Manager and after
completion of 4 (four) years of satisfactory service as an Assistant Manager
(Instrumentation) (Electrical/ Mechanical), vide Office Order dated 30.06.2014,
the petitioner came to be designated as a Deputy Manager (E/M) by the APGCL
authorities.
The petitioner projects that on account of his family problems, including
the ailments suffered by his mother, he had submitted a request before the
authorities for consideration of his posting on transfer to Tinsukia in the APDCL
organization. The said request of the petitioner was considered and the Chief
General Manager (HRA), APDCL, vide order dated 08.12.2016, proceeded to
Page No.# 6/22
transfer the petitioner and posted him in the T&C Division, APDCL, Tinsukia. The
petitioner complied with the said order of transfer and assumed the charge of
post as assigned to him by APDCL vide a Certificate of Transfer of Charge dated
17.12.2016. The petitioner, thereafter, submitted a representation before the
APDCL authorities for inclusion of his name in the Seniority List published of the
incumbents in the cadre of Deputy Manager. Thereafter, the APDCL authorities
published a Seniority List of the incumbents in the cadre of Deputy Manager
(Electrical/Mechanical). However, the name of the petitioner was not included,
therein.
Raising a grievance with regard to non-inclusion of his name in the
Seniority List of Deputy Managers, working in APDCL, the petitioner submitted a
representation dated 15.06.2019, praying for inclusion of his name in the
Seniority List of Deputy Managers, APDCL. The said representation submitted by
the petitioner was vide a communication dated 31.07.2019, rejected by the
APDCL authorities, by projecting that the petitioner was an employee of APGCL
and only on the ground of his transfer to APDCL on humanitarian grounds, he
cannot be treated to be an employee of APDCL and he continued to be an
employee of APGCL. The said communication dated 31.07.2019, was followed
by an Office Order dated 04.11.2019, by which the petitioner was reverted back
to his parent company, i.e., the APGCL with immediate effect. The earlier order
of his transfer dated 08.12.2016 came to be cancelled.
The petitioner being aggrieved by the reversion effected in his case, vide
order dated 04.11.2019, had approached the APDCL authorities, praying for
cancellation of the same. The same not having been considered, the petitioner
had approached this Court by way of instituting a writ petition, being WP(C) No.
Page No.# 7/22
8371/2019.
A Co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 15.11.2019, noticing
the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties to the proceeding
as well as a policy decision of the APDCL authorities as contained in the Office
Order dated 08.04.2016, wherein, the inter-company movement of officials at
any level was directed to be not permitted, proceeded vide an order dated
15.11.2019 to dispose of the said writ petition, requiring the petitioner to submit
an appeal before the Managing Director, APDCL, raising his grievances, therein.
The Managing Director, APDCL was directed to dispose of the said appeal. It
was further provided that on the filing of the appeal, within the time frame
prescribed, the APDCL authorities till disposal of the appeal preferred by the
petitioner, would not give effect to the order dated 04.11.2019, reverting the
petitioner to NTPS, Namrup, if not already released.
Thereafter, on the submission of an appeal by the petitioner in the matter,
the APDCL authorities vide an Office Order dated 05.12.2019, proceeded to
examine the claim of the petitioner raised in his appeal and on such examination
by contending that the petitioner being never absorbed in the services of APDCL
and his appointment and promotion upto the post of Deputy Manager being
given effect in APGCL, the claim of the petitioner to include his name in the
seniority list of Deputy Managers of APDCL was held to be not acceptable.
Accordingly, the petitioner’s further claim for absorption in APDCL service was
held to be not permissible to be so considered.
The petitioner being aggrieved by the Office Order dated 05.12.2019 as
well as non-inclusion of his name in the Seniority List of Deputy Managers of
APDCL, has instituted the present writ petition.
Page No.# 8/22
4.
Mr. S Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner, by reiterating
the facts noticed hereinabove, at the outset, has submitted that the question
raised by the respondent APDCL that the petitioner was not an employee of
APDCL, would stand rebutted on a mere perusal of the order dated 17.10.2007,
passed by the APDCL authorities, declaring the completion of probation period
by the petitioner. He submits that the said order would go to reveal that the
petitioner, at that relevant point of time, was considered to be an employee in
the APDCL service. He submits that in the event, the petitioner was not
considered to be an employee of APDCL, at the relevant point of time, there
would have not arisen any occasion for the APDCL authorities to confirm his
service and thereafter, also to fix his pay in the manner required after such
confirmation.
4.1
Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner, has submitted
that the petitioner, on his initial transfer to the APDCL service effected vide
order dated 21.03.2007 and during his continuation in APDCL, at no point of
time, was informed that he was only working in APDCL, on a temporary basis
and his parent department continued to be APGCL.
4.2
Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
Departmental Promotion Committee of the erstwhile Assam State Electricity
Board, having considered the case of the petitioner for recruitment to the post
of Assistant Manager (Instrumentation) and on such recommendation being
made, the APGCL authorities vide order dated 17.02.2010, having appointed the
petitioner provisionally as Assistant Manager (Instrumentation), the petitioner
was forced to accept the same, although, he had submitted an objection to the
said appointment, now being effected in his case in APGCL.
Page No.# 9/22
4.3
Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner further submits
that APGCL authorities as per the norms prevailing in all the three companies,
on the petitioner completing 4 (four) years of satisfactory service as Assistant
Manager (E/M), declared him as a Deputy Manager vide an order dated
30.06.2014.
4.4
It is submitted that the petitioner had, thereafter, considering the
necessity of his presence at his home, made a request before the authorities for
his transfer to a post in APDCL in the District of Tinsukia, i.e., his native district.
The said application was duly considered in the manner required and vide order
dated 08.12.2016, the petitioner was transferred and posted in T&C Division,
Tinsukia, APDCL.
4.5
By referring to the order dated 08.12.2016, Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior
counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner was transferred in the
interest of works. He submits that a transfer can occasion only between posts
held to be equivalent and in respect of the service, wherein, the employee
concerned is placed. He submits that the manner in which he was brought to
the T&C Division, Tinsukia, APDCL, vide order dated 08.12.2016, would reveal
that although, he was appointed as Assistant Manager and thereafter, redesignated as Deputy Manager in APGCL, the APDCL authorities had continued
to treat the petitioner as an employee figuring in the service of APDCL.
4.6
Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner, while continuing as a Deputy Manager in APDCL, a Seniority List of
incumbents in the cadre of Deputy Manager was published on 27.05.2019. The
petitioner, although, holding a post of Deputy Manager within the cadre strength
of Deputy Manager, as existing in the APDCL organization, his name was not
Page No.# 10/22
included in the said Gradation List and accordingly, the petitioner after having
submitted objections to the Seniority List so published, vide notice dated
27.05.2019, had approached this Court by way of instituting a writ petition,
being WP(C) No. 8371/2019, raising grievances in this connection.
4.7
Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that this Court appreciating the contentions raised before it by the learned
Senior counsel for the APDCL, including the reliance placed on a policy decision
as brought into effect with regard to inter-company movement of officials vide
an Office Order dated 08.04.2016, had required the respondent authorities to
consider the appeal, which was directed to be filed by the petitioner in the
matter.
4.8
Mr. Borthakur, submits that the petitioner in his appeal had in details
raised the manner in which his services was so considered after he was so
appointed vide order dated 10.09.2005 as a Junior Engineer.
4.9
Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
respondent authorities vide an order dated 05.12.2019, proceeded to reject the
claim made by the petitioner in his appeal only on a superficial examination of
the service status of the petitioner. He submits that the respondent authorities
have not considered the manner in which the petitioner was initially transferred
to the APDCL organization, vide the order dated 21.03.2007 and the subsequent
confirmation of the services of the petitioner effected vide an order dated
17.10.2007.
4.10 Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
confirmation/declaration of completion of probationary period of service by the
Page No.# 11/22
petitioner, was permissible to be so done only by invoking the provisions of Rule
17 of the HR Manual of APDCL. He submits that in the event the services of the
petitioner was confirmed in APDCL, the petitioner for all intent and purpose on
the date of confirmation, must be deemed to be an employee of APDCL and not
APGCL. He submits that a similar order confirming his services was not passed
by the APGCL authorities. Accordingly, the petitioner after 16.10.2007, being
treated to be a confirmed employee, who had satisfactorily completed his
probationary period of service, such consideration being extended to the
petitioner in APDCL, for all intent and purpose, the petitioner has to be deemed
to be an employee of APDCL and not APGCL.
4.11 With regard to his promotion to the subsequent appointment to the post
of Assistant Manager and also his re-designation as Deputy Manager, Mr.
Borthakur, submits that the said benefits were required to be conferred upon
the petitioner, in view of the fact that he had the requisite qualification and had
completed the minimum requisite services, for being extended the said benefits.
He submits that although, the said appointment was made by the authorities of
APGCL, the subsequent developments taking place in the matter and the
petitioner being again transferred to APDCL, would reveal that the petitioner
was actually an employee of APDCL and was temporarily posted to APGCL. He
submits that the confirmation effected in respect of the petitioner by the APGCL
authorities, cannot be ignored, inasmuch as, the same had given a permanency
in service to the petitioner in APDCL and the subsequent steps taken in respect
of the petitioner till he was again brought back to the APDCL, vide order dated
08.12.2016, which again was in the interest of works, would reveal that the
petitioner’s parent company, after his initial posting to APGCL, was all along
being considered to be APDCL and not APGCL.
Page No.# 12/22
4.12
Mr. Borthakur, has further submitted that while the petitioner was
transferred to APDCL, vide order dated 21.03.2007, another employee Brojen
Saikia, who was an employee of APDCL was transferred vide the same order to
the APGCL service. He submits that although, the petitioner was required to
move between the 2 (two) companies, said Brojen Saikia, w.e.f. the date he had
assumed charge against a post in APGCL, in pursuance to the transfer order
dated 21.03.2007, was continued in the services of APGCL, without there being
any further order issued towards absorbing his such service in APGCL. He
submits that Brojen Saikia has been given all his service benefits, including
further movement to the higher grades in APGCL service itself, without raising
any issue as is now being raised in respect of the petitioner by the APDCL
authorities.
4.13
In this connection, Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner, has placed on record an order passed in respect of Brojen Saikia, on
his completion of 4 (four) years of service as Assistant Manager, which is again
contended to have been effected by the APGCL authorities, declaring him as
Deputy Manager. He submits that the initial appointment of Brojen Saikia was in
APDCL and not in APGCL. Accordingly, in view of the benefits extended to said
Brojen Saikia, Mr. Borthakur submits that the inclusion of the petitioner’s name
in the Seniority List of Deputy Managers in APDCL, was permissible. However,
he submits that taking a hyper technical view in the matter, the APDCL
authorities proceeded to take steps prejudicial to the interest of the petitioner,
herein, while such steps have not been taken in respect of said Brojen Saikia
and thereby, a discrimination came to be meted out to the petitioner.
4.14
In the above premises, Mr. Borthakur, learned Senior counsel for the
Page No.# 13/22
petitioner submits that the order dated 05.12.2019, would mandate an
interference from this Court, with a direction for continuing the services of the
petitioner in APDCL and for inclusion of his name in the Seniority List of the
Deputy Managers, working in APDCL.
5.
Per contra, Mr. S P Sarma, learned Standing counsel, APDCL, has
submitted that by the time, the selection of the petitioner against the post of
Junior Engineer, had occasioned and an order appointing him was issued, the
erstwhile ASEB was already unbundled into three distinct companies. The
petitioner’s services was placed on his such selection with the APGCL authorities
and it is for that reason, vide order dated 10.09.2005, the petitioner was
appointed as a Junior Engineer in the services of the APGCL.
5.1
Mr. Sarma, learned Standing counsel, APDCL submits that the initial
appointment of the petitioner, being so effected in APGCL, he for all intent and
purpose continued to be a member of the service of APGCL. Mr. Sarma, submits
that basing on a request received from the petitioner for a transfer and posting
at Tinsukia, such request being channelized through the APGCL authorities, the
APDCL authorities had proceeded to issue an order dated 21.03.2007, posting
the petitioner at Tingkhong Electric Sub-Division. He submits that the said
transfer effected in respect of the petitioner was so effected on humanitarian
grounds.
5.2
Mr. Sarma, learned Standing counsel, APDCL submits that the declaration
of the petitioner’s services as confirmed, effected vide order dated 17.10.2007,
was only as a matter of course and the same cannot be deemed to have the
effect of absorbing the services of the petitioner in APDCL.
Page No.# 14/22
5.3
Mr. Sarma, learned Standing counsel, APDCL submits that even if, it is
held that vide order dated 17.10.2007, the services of the petitioner must be
deemed to have been absorbed in APDCL, the subsequent appointment effected
in respect of the petitioner, along with a probationary period being attached
thereto, as Assistant Manager, being so effected by the APGCL authorities and
the petitioner accepting the said appointment and joining again in the APGCL
service, at least, w.e.f. 17.02.2010, the petitioner, w.e.f. 17.02.2010 must be
deemed to be an employee of APGCL. Although, he submits that since the date
of the initial appointment of the petitioner, the petitioner was always an
employee of APGCL and not APDCL, although, there was an intermittent posting
effected in his case on humanitarian grounds in APDCL.
5.4
Mr. Sarma, learned Standing counsel, APDCL, referring to the plea taken
by the petitioner with regard to the continuation of Brojen Saikia in APGCL,
submits that Brojen Saikia was also similarly appointed as an Assistant Manager,
along with a probationary period on his such selection, by the APGCL authorities
and accordingly, he also w.e.f. the date of his such appointment deemed to be
absorbed in the services of the APGCL. Mr. Sarma, submits that both the
petitioner and said Borjen Saikia were thereafter designated as Deputy
Managers. He submits that Borjen Saikia, being now deemed to be absorbed in
the services of APGCL, was continued in his services with the APGCL authorities.
However, the petitioner again having made a request for a posting under APDCL
at Tinsukia, considering his family issues, the APDCL authorities on the said
request being channelized to it from the APGCL authorities, had issued the order
dated 08.12.2016.
5.5
Mr. Sarma, further submits that after the issuance of the order dated
Page No.# 15/22
08.12.2016, there is no material brought on record to demonstrate that the
petitioner’s service was absorbed in APDCL. It is submitted that the petitioner
was continuing in his services in APDCL, in terms of the order dated 08.12.2016,
till passing of further orders in this connection by the concerned authorities.
Accordingly, Mr. Sarma, submits that the petitioner was held to be ineligible for
inclusion of his name in the Seniority List published of Deputy Managers working
in APDCL. Mr. Sarma submits that on the matter being placed before the Joint
Consultative company of the three companies, the services of the petitioner was
reverted back to APGCL, vide an order dated 04.11.2019, with a further
stipulation that the order dated 08.12.2016, transferring him to APDCL stood
cancelled. He submits that any mistake committed by the APDCL authorities in
the process of posting the petitioner in APDCL service, stood rectified in
pursuance to the order dated 04.11.2019.
5.6
Mr. Sarma, learned Standing counsel, APDCL has further submitted that
the competent authority of the APDCL, after a direction was issued by this Court
vide order dated 15.11.2019 in WP(C) No. 8371/2019, to dispose of the appeal
preferred by the petitioner. Mr. Sarma, submits that the authorities after
examining the service status of the petitioner in details and also considering the
fact of appointment of the petitioner as Assistant Manager in APGCL in the year
2019 and his subsequent re-designation as Deputy Manager, therein, by also
appreciating the fact that the petitioner was, thereafter, never absorbed in the
service of APDCL, proceeded to reject his claim for inclusion in the rank of
Deputy Manager. Mr. Sarma, accordingly, submits that the order dated
05.12.2019, being so passed after taking into consideration all relevant factors,
the same would not mandate an interference from this Court.
Page No.# 16/22
5.7
By referring to a notice dated 29.05.2019, Mr. Sarma, learned
Standing counsel, APDCL has submitted that subsequent to his reversion to the
APGCL, the name of the petitioner has been duly included in the Seniority List of
Deputy Managers working in APGCL at the appropriate position.
5.8
In the above premises, Mr. Sarma, learned Standing counsel, APDCL
submits that the claim made in the writ petition would not mandate an
acceptance and the writ petition would be mandated to be dismissed.
6.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
materials brought on record.
7.
The petitioner in pursuance to his selection for appointment as Junior
Engineer by the erstwhile ASEB, was appointed in such capacity by the APGCL
authorities, vide an order dated 10.09.2005. Such appointment came to be so
effected by the APGCL authorities, inasmuch as, in the meanwhile, erstwhile
ASEB was unbundled into 3 separate companies and the petitioner on his
selection was so placed in APGCL.
8.
The petitioner was thereafter, vide order dated 21.03.2007, transferred
and posted from Namrup Thermal Power Station under APGCL to Tingkhong
Electric Sub-Division in place of one Brojen Saikia, who was transferred from
Tingkhong Electric Sub-Division to Namrup Thermal Power Station. The
petitioner in terms of his said order of transfer assumed the charge of his post
at Tingkhong Electric Sub-Division and continued his services therein.
9.
The initial appointment of the petitioner as a Junior Engineer, effected
vide the order dated 10.09.2005, being so effected with a condition that he
would remain on probation for a period of 2 (two) years, the petitioner having
Page No.# 17/22
successfully completed his probationary period, and he on the date of
completion of his probationary period being posted in APDCL, the APDCL
authorities vide order dated 16.10.2007, proceeded to declare that the service
of the petitioner during his probationary period was found to be satisfactory and
was permitted to continue to draw his annual increments, w.e.f. 16.10.2007.
10.
It is the normal practice that declaration of completion of probationary
period of service is to be so done by his employer. The successful completion of
probationary period of service by the petitioner having been declared by the
APDCL authorities, it can be deemed that the petitioner at the relevant point of
time was reckoned to be an employee under APDCL. Accordingly, the
submission of the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner that on declaration
being made by the APDCL authorities of successful completion by the petitioner
of his probationary period of service, a permanency was given to the petitioner’s
services in APDCL, has merit.
11.
However, what is to be noticed is as to whether the petitioner, thereafter,
also can be construed to have continued as a permanent employee under
APDCL.
12.
The ASEB in its meeting held on 22.01.2007, had incorporated a provision
in the ASEB Engineering Service Regulations, 1973, providing for a progression
in service to Junior Engineer, who have the requisite qualification mandated for
recruitment as Assistant Engineer. Such Junior Engineers were held to be eligible
for appointment to the cadre of Assistant Engineer upon completion of 4 (four)
years of continuous satisfactory service as Junior Engineers.
13.
The petitioner being eligible for appointment as Assistant Engineer, in
Page No.# 18/22
terms of the said policy decision of ASEB, the case of the petitioner was
considered by the Departmental Promotion Committee of ASEB. On a
recommendation being made in favour of the petitioner for such appointment, a
vacancy being available in APGCL for the purpose, the APGCL authorities
proceeded to appoint the petitioner as Assistant Manager and posted him in
such capacity to Namrup Thermal Power Station, vide issuance of an order
dated 17.02.2010. The said appointment was so effected with a fresh period of
probationary service for 1 (one) year.
14.
The petitioner, without any objection accepted the appointment effected
in his case as Assistant Manager, vide the order dated 17.02.2010 and assumed
the charge of the post of Assistant Manager at Namrup Thermal Power Station
and continued his services in such capacity. The petitioner having completed 4
(four) years of continuous satisfactory service as Assistant Engineer, he was
declared as a Deputy Manager, w.e.f. 12.03.2014. Accordingly, the petitioner
upon his appointment as Assistant Manager must be deemed to have again
become an employee of APGCL.
15.
The petitioner after having been declared to be a Deputy Manager, had
submitted an application for his transfer to Tinsukia under APDCL. The said
request of the petitioner was duly considered and he was vide order dated
08.12.2016 transferred and posted to T&C Division, Tinsukia, APDCL.
Accordingly, w.e.f. the date the petitioner joined against the post, he was
transferred to vide the order dated 08.12.2016, his services came to be placed
again under APDCL.
16.
While the petitioner was continuing in APDCL as a Deputy Manager, the
APDCL authorities published a seniority of the incumbents in the cadre of
Page No.# 19/22
Deputy Manager in APDCL. However, the name of the petitioner was not
included, therein. Accordingly, the petitioner approached the APDCL authorities
raising a grievance in this connection.
17.
The APDCL authorities on examining the grievance raised by the
petitioner, proceeded vide a communication dated 31.07.2019, to reject the
claim of the petitioner for inclusion of his name in the seniority list of Deputy
Manager working in APDCL. It was contended in the said communication that
the petitioner having been appointed as an Assistant Manager in APGCL
followed by declaring him as a Deputy Manager by the APGCL authorities, his
claim for inclusion in the seniority list of Deputy Manager working in APDCL
would not mandate acceptance.
18.
Thereafter, vide an order dated 04.11.2019, the petitioner, in terms of the
recommendations made by the Joint Consultative Committee, came to be
reverted back to his parent company APGCL. Further, the transfer and posting
effected in respect of the petitioner vide order dated 08.12.2016 came to be
cancelled.
19.
The petitioner being aggrieved by the non-inclusion of his name in the
seniority list of Deputy Manager, working in APDCL as well as his reversion to
APGCL as ordered vide order dated 04.11.2019, had approached this Court by
way of instituting a writ petition, being WP(C) No. 8371/2019. A Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court vide order dated 15.11.2019, proceeded to dispose of the
said writ petition by directing the Managing Director, APDCL, to dispose of the
appeal preferred by the petitioner in the matter, on 11.11.2019. It was further
provided that till disposal of the said appeal, the order dated 04.11.2019
reverting the petitioner to APGCL be not given effect to, if not already released.
Page No.# 20/22
20.
The respondent authorities, thereafter, considered the appeal preferred
by the petitioner and vide order dated 05.12.2019, rejected the claim made by
the petitioner, therein.
21.
A perusal of the order dated 05.12.2019 would reveal that the authorities
of APDCL have held therein, that after the appointment of the petitioner as
Assistant Manager in APGCL and his subsequent declaration as Deputy Manager
in APGCL, the petitioner was not absorbed in the services of APDCL. Accordingly,
it was held that the question of inclusion of the name of the petitioner in the
seniority list of Deputy Manager in APDCL would not arise. Reference was also
made to the clarifications as set out in the communication dated 31.07.2019. In
the said order dated 05.12.2019, it was further highlighted that the matter was
discussed in the meeting of the Joint Consultative Committee, consisting of
representatives of all the 3 (three) companies and it was decided to revert the
petitioner to his parent company, i.e., APGCL.
22.
This Court on a perusal of the order dated 05.12.2019 and the
communication dated 31.07.2019 referred to therein, finds that the authorities
in the APDCL have held that the petitioner on his appointment as Assistant
Manager, followed by his designation as Deputy Manager by the APGCL
authorities, was a member of the service of APGCL. The said reasoning is not
found by this Court to be erroneous, inasmuch as, on his appointment as
Assistant Manager, vide order dated 17.02.2010, issued by the APGCL
authorities, the petitioner is found to have accepted the same. On his joining
against the post of Assistant Manager on probation, the petitioner must be
deemed to have become a member of the service in APGCL. Further, the
petitioner was redesignated as Deputy Manager, in APGCL. The appointment of
Page No.# 21/22
the petitioner as an Assistant Manager, on probation is found to be a fresh
appointment and the same being effected in APGCL for all intent and purpose,
the petitioner is to be deemed to be a member of the service in APGCL. Further,
from the materials brought on record, it is seen that the petitioner has been
included in the seniority list of Deputy Manager serving in APGCL. Accordingly,
this Court holds that the parent company of the petitioner is APGCL and not
APDCL.
23.
In view of the above discussion, this Court is of the considered view that
the transfer of the petitioner to APDCL, as effected vide the order dated
08.12.2016, being so effected on the own request of the petitioner and the
same not being followed by issuance of any order absorbing the petitioner in
the service of APDCL, the said transfer cannot be held to have effected a
change in the parent company of the petitioner and he during his period of
service in APDCL after issuance of the order dated 08.12.2016, must be held to
have continued as a member of APGCL.
24.
At this stage, this Court would consider the plea raised by the learned
Senior counsel for the petitioner with regard to the manner in which the
respondents have considered continuation of said Brojen Saikia in APGCL, after
he was transferred there from APDCL vide order dated 21.02.2007. A
discrimination is projected to have been meted out to the petitioner in this
connection.
25.
From the materials brought on record, this Court finds that said Brojen
Saikia was also appointed as an Assistant Manager by APGCL and on completion
of 4 (four) years of continuous satisfactory service by him, he was designated
by the APGCL authorities as Deputy Manager, vide an order dated 30.10.2024.
Page No.# 22/22
Accordingly, in respect of Brojen Saikia, he having been appointed as Assistant
Manager by APGCL and being subsequently designated as Deputy Manager by
the APGCL authorities, he is also deemed to have been absorbed as an
employee of APGCL and such absorption being done in a manner similar to the
one done in respect of the petitioner, herein, no discrimination is found to be
meted out to the petitioner in this connection. Accordingly, the plea raised by
the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner in this connection stands rejected.
26.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court does not find the reasons
assigned by the respondent authorities in the order dated 05.12.2019 to be
erroneous and accordingly, the said order is held to not mandate any
interference from this Court.
27.
Accordingly, for the reasons assigned hereinabove, the writ petition is
held to be devoid of any merit and consequently, the same stands dismissed.
However, there would be no order as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review