The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. 11.2023 in which it was reported that working of the petitioner has not improved and her professional behaviour with staff members and patients has not improved. It was also reported that the petitioner is not conducting daily programmes and is not reporting the same on the portal. The Committee also found that PRI members and local population are not satisfied with the behavior of the petitioner as she is not well behaved and punctual. Accordingly, the committee recommended suitable necessary action members against the petitioner. 13) Pursuant to the aforesaid report of the Committee, respondent No. 2 proceeded to issue impugned order dated 12.02.2024 thereby terminating the contractual services of the petitioner. It seems that the petitioner, through her counsel, had served a legal notice upon the respondents for reconsideration of the matter but no action was taken by the respondents on the said legal notice. 14) The petitioner has challenged the impugned termination order on the grounds that the same has been passed without affording any opportunity of hearing to her. It has been contended that the petitioner was not associated with the enquiry proceedings and she was not allowed to cross-examine the witnesses and to put up a proper defence. It has also been contended that respondent No. 4 had issued a certificate of good character in favour of the petitioner on 26.09.2023,…
01. 08.2025] to press home his contention that because the impugned order passed against the petitioner is stigmatic and punitive in nature, therefore, she was entitled to an opportunity of defending the accusations/allegations made against her in a full-fledged enquiry. 20) In the above context, it is to be noted that the petitioner was not working as a regular employee against a civil post but she was engaged on contractual basis. As per the format of agreement relating to contract of appointment of the petitioner, a copy whereof has been produced by learned counsel for the petitioner during the course of hearing, the contract was valid for one year extendable upto not more than three years subject to satisfactory performance. The safeguards available to an employee appointed on a civil post as contained in Article 311 of the Constitution of India and the Jammu and Kashmir Civil Service (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1956 are not available to the petitioner. The terms and conditions of engagement of the petitioner are governed by the contract of appointment executed by the parties. 21) As per Clause (4) of the service agreement, the employer has a right to rescind the contract before completion if the performance of the employee has been found to be unsatisfactory. As per Clause (16) of the said agreement, the engagement of the employee would stand terminated if he/s…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKHAT
JAMMU
Reserved on: 29.01.2026
Pronounced on: 06.02.2026
Uploaded on: 06.02.2026
Whether the operative
part or full judgment is
pronounced:Full
WP(C) No. 2950/2024
Himani Sharma
...PETITIONER(S)
Through: -
Mr. Antriksh Sharma, Advocate.
Vs.
…RESPONDENT(S)
U T OF J&K & ORS.
Through: -
Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1)
The petitioner has challenged order No. 291 of 2024
dated 12.01.2024 issued by respondent No. 2 whereby the
contractual services of the petitioner as Mid-Level Health
Provider (hereinafter to be referred to as “MLHP”) under
National
Health
Mission
has
been
terminated
with
immediate effect.
2)
Briefly stated case of the petitioner is that in terms of
order No. 10 of 2021 dated 16.04.2021 issued by
respondent No. 2, she was engaged as MLHP with her
proposed place of posting at HWC-SC Kagrore block
WP(C) No.2950/2024
Basholi district Kathua.
It appears that the petitioner
pursuant to the aforesaid order joined her place of posting
whereafter
she
Commissioner,
lodged
a
complaint
Kathua
with
regard
with
to
Deputy
lack
of
infrastructural facilities and non-cooperation of the staff
at her place of posting.
3)
On
05.07.2021,
respondent
No.
sought
an
explanation from the petitioner for her absence from
duties. On 24.08.2021, respondent No. 4 again sought an
explanation from the petitioner for not having attended the
monthly meeting that was held in the office of said
respondent on 24.08.2021. Thereafter a communication
was addressed by respondent No. 4 to the petitioner
whereby
a
final
explanation
was
sought
from
her
regarding her conduct and summary of allegations was
incorporated in the said communication.
As per these
allegations, on 05.07.2021 the petitioner was found to be
absent from duty when respondent No. 4 visited her place
of posting. It is further alleged in the said communication
that when respondent No. 4 visited the place of posting of
the petitioner on 12.08.2021 she was again found to be
absent from duty w.e.f., 07.08.2021.
Another allegation
recorded in the said communication is that the petitioner
had tampered with attendance register. It has also been
WP(C) No.2950/2024
alleged that the petitioner has always been irresponsible
towards her duties and that she had not responded to the
phone
calls
of
respondent
No.
during
covid-19
pandemic.
4)
The record shows that another explanation was
sought by respondent No. 4 from the petitioner on
31.03.2022 for not attending the meeting on 31.03.2022.
5)
It seems that respondent No. 4, in terms of order
dated
05.07.2022,
constituted
a
committee
of
five
members to conduct preliminary enquiry in respect of the
allegations leveled against the petitioner. The committee
recorded the statements of the witnesses and concluded
that the petitioner has consistently been absent from work
and she has tampered with the attendance register.
It
was also concluded that behavior of the petitioner has not
been appropriate towards her staff members and that she
has been careless, irresponsible and negligent towards her
duties. The committee also opined that there is no hope of
petitioner mending her ways.
6)
On 02.08.2022, another show cause notice was
issued by respondent No. 4 to the petitioner for not having
furnished monthly reports.
It seems that the petitioner
responded to the show cause notice informing respondent
WP(C) No.2950/2024
No. 4 that she is not attending her duties regularly
because of medical reasons. She also forwarded copies of
prescriptions issued by Hindurao Hospital, Delhi.
7)
On 30.09.2022, again explanation was sought from
the petitioner for not attending the monthly meeting and
for not reporting on NCD portal.
On 29.11.2022,
respondent No. 4 again sought an explanation from the
petitioner informing her that on the said date, while she
visited her place of posting, the petitioner was found
absent from duty w.e.f., 26th to 29th of November, 2022.
Respondent No. 4 also addressed a communication to
respondent No. 3 on the same date informing him that
salary of the petitioner has been withheld because of her
unauthorized absence from duty and also because of her
unsatisfactory performance.
8)
It seems that another enquiry was conducted by a
three member committee in respect of the conduct of the
petitioner and on 15.12.2022, the Committee framed its
report. As per the report, when the Committee visited the
place of posting of the petitioner on 15.12.2022, she was
found absent from duty and her whereabouts were not
known to the staff. It was also found that the petitioner is
habitual of remaining absent from duty. The Committee
WP(C) No.2950/2024
also found that the petitioner has not made even a single
entry in her NCD ID, as such, her performance on NCD
portal is NIL. The Committee, upon enquiry, found that
the petitioner has not been punctual towards her duty and
it was also reported by the staff that the furniture of the
office had been damaged by the petitioner. The staff also
complained that the petitioner misbehaves with them.
Similar complaints were also received from the general
public.
9)
After the holding of enquiry, respondent No. 3, vide
his communication dated 10.01.2023, forwarded the
enquiry report along with documents to respondent No. 2
with a recommendation to take necessary action in the
matter.
Pursuant to the aforesaid communication of
respondent No. 3, respondent No. 2 issued show cause
notice
dated
17.01.2023
to
the
petitioner
seeking
explanation as to why action as warranted under rules be
not taken against her.
10)
Reply to the aforesaid show cause notice was
submitted by the petitioner vide her communication dated
24.01.2023.
allegations
In her reply, the petitioner denied the
with
regard
unprofessional conduct.
WP(C) No.2950/2024
to
her
rude
behavior
and
It was contended by the
petitioner in her reply that two enquiries conducted
against her are biased and the conclusions made by the
enquiry committees are without any evidence.
It was
submitted by the petitioner that she had informed her
immediate superiors on numerous occasions in writing
about the lack of infrastructure in the office and lack of
facilities in the hospital but no action was taken by her
superior officers. She denied the allegation that she was
responsible
for
causing
damage
to
the
furniture.
According to the petitioner, she had informed her senior
officers telephonically as well as through whatsapp
messages about the reasons for her absence from duty
which was due to issues relating to transport and her
health.
11)
It
seems
that
respondent
No.
had
asked
respondent No. 3 to monitor the behavior of the petitioner,
however,
vide
communication
dated
02.03.2023
respondent No. 3 informed respondent No. 2 that there
has been no improvement in the performance and attitude
of the petitioner. Updated work and conduct report with
respect to the petitioner was forwarded by respondent
No. 3 to respondent No. 2 from time to time vide his
communications dated 13.10.2023 and 28.11.2023.
WP(C) No.2950/2024
12)
It seems that another committee of five members was
constituted for submitting a report with regard to the
status of petitioner. A fresh report was submitted by the
Committee
after
its
visit
to
HWC
SC
Kagrore
on
25.11.2023 in which it was reported that working of the
petitioner
has
not
improved
and
her
professional
behaviour with staff members and patients has not
improved. It was also reported that the petitioner is not
conducting daily programmes and is not reporting the
same on the portal. The Committee also found that PRI
members and local population are not satisfied with the
behavior of the petitioner as she is not well behaved and
punctual.
Accordingly,
the
committee
recommended
suitable
necessary
action
members
against
the
petitioner.
13)
Pursuant to the aforesaid report of the Committee,
respondent No. 2 proceeded to issue impugned order
dated 12.02.2024 thereby terminating the contractual
services of the petitioner.
It seems that the petitioner,
through her counsel, had served a legal notice upon the
respondents for reconsideration of the matter but no
action was taken by the respondents on the said legal
notice.
WP(C) No.2950/2024
14)
The
petitioner
has
challenged
the
impugned
termination order on the grounds that the same has been
passed without affording any opportunity of hearing to
her.
It has been contended that the petitioner was not
associated with the enquiry proceedings and she was not
allowed to cross-examine the witnesses and to put up a
proper defence.
It has also been contended that
respondent No. 4 had issued a certificate of good character
in favour of the petitioner on 26.09.2023, as such, the
allegations that behavior and conduct of the petitioner has
not been up to the mark stands contradicted. It has been
further contended that the petitioner was harassed by the
respondents by serving show cause notices upon her
which resulted in physical and mental harassment to her.
It has been contended that because the impugned order of
termination is stigmatic in nature, as such, without
holding a regular departmental enquiry, it was not open to
the respondents to terminate her engagement.
15)
The respondents have contested the petition by filing
the reply in which they have contended that the petitioner
has been given fair opportunity of being heard and as
many as three enquiries have been conducted by the
respondents before passing the impugned order.
It has
been submitted that repeated show cause notices have
WP(C) No.2950/2024
been issued to the petitioner to explain her conduct but
most of the times, she failed to respond to these show
cause notices.
According to the respondents, the
petitioner, being a contractual employee, cannot be
equated with a government employee holding a civil post
and claim that she cannot be terminated without a regular
departmental enquiry.
16)
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused the record of the case including the record
produced by the respondents.
17)
As is clear from the pleadings of the parties, the
petitioner has been served with repeated show cause
notices by the respondents and preliminary enquiries into
her conduct have been held, on as many as three
occasions before taking impugned action against her. It
is, however, clear from the record produced by the
respondents that the petitioner has not been afforded an
opportunity of cross-examining the witnesses who have
deposed before the enquiry committees.
The petitioner
has been permitted to respond to the final show cause
notice
and
to
project
her
side
of
the
story.
The
respondents have considered her reply and after feeling
dissatisfied
with
WP(C) No.2950/2024
the
explanation
tendered
by
the
petitioner, they have proceeded to pass the impugned
order of termination.
18)
The question that falls for determination is as to
whether the petitioner, who is a contractual employee, is
entitled to be subjected to a regular departmental enquiry
before terminating her services particularly when the
order of her termination is stigmatic in nature.
19)
Learned
counsel for
the
petitioner
has
placed
reliance upon the judgment of Supreme Court of India in
the case of U.P State Road Transport Corporation & Ors
Vs. Brijesh Kumar and anr, 2024 SCC Online SC 2282,
and judgments of this Court in the cases of Feroz Ahmad
Sheikh & Ors Vs. UT of J&K & ors [WP(C) No.
2260/2022 decided on 16.12.2023] and Dr. Shazia Salam
Vs. UT of J&K & Ors [WP(C) No. 494/2023 decided on
01.08.2025] to press home his contention that because
the impugned order passed against the petitioner is
stigmatic and punitive in nature, therefore, she was
entitled
to
an
opportunity
of
defending
the
accusations/allegations made against her in a full-fledged
enquiry.
20)
In the above context, it is to be noted that the
petitioner was not working as a regular employee against a
WP(C) No.2950/2024
civil post but she was engaged on contractual basis. As
per the format of agreement relating to contract of
appointment of the petitioner, a copy whereof has been
produced by learned counsel for the petitioner during the
course of hearing, the contract was valid for one year
extendable upto not more than three years subject to
satisfactory performance. The safeguards available to an
employee appointed on a civil post as contained in Article
311 of the Constitution of India and the Jammu and
Kashmir Civil Service (Classification, Control and Appeal)
Rules, 1956 are not available to the petitioner. The terms
and conditions of engagement of the petitioner are
governed by the contract of appointment executed by the
parties.
21)
As per Clause (4) of the service agreement, the
employer has a right to rescind the contract before
completion if the performance of the employee has been
found to be unsatisfactory. As per Clause (16) of the said
agreement, the engagement of the employee would stand
terminated if he/she absents from duty for seven working
days without taking permission from the competent
authority. As per Clause (22) of the agreement, employer
has a right to terminate the services of an employee if
he/she has committed irregularities and impropriety of
WP(C) No.2950/2024
administrative and financial nature, negligence of care,
unsafe practices, inefficiency and insincerity, professional
misconduct or false reporting of information or fabrication
of
date
in
the
maintained
records
or
any
other
inappropriate action. Thus, it is clear that services of the
petitioner were terminable at any time on the basis of her
poor performance, negligence, inefficiency, insincerity or
professional misconduct.
22)
The
respondents
have,
before
terminating
the
services of the petitioner, constituted Committees of
officers as many as three times and on all three occasions,
the Committee of officers after visiting the place of posting
of the petitioner and after scrutinizing the records and
recording the statements of the witnesses came to the
conclusion that the petitioner is in the habit of being
absent from her duty unauthorizedly, her behavior
towards staff, local people and the patients has not been
up to the mark and she has even tampered with the
attendance register. The Committees also found that the
petitioner has not uploaded the requisite reports on the
portal and her performance has not been satisfactory.
23)
Although the petitioner in her reply to the show
cause notice has denied most of these allegations but
WP(C) No.2950/2024
nonetheless she has admitted that she has not attended
the office on several occasions.
As per her version, her
absence was due to ill health and due to transport issues.
She had also issues with the infrastructural facilities at
her place of posting.
While illness can be a justified
ground for not attending the duties provided the same is
of such a nature as would prevent an employee to attend
his/her duties, but intimation in this regard has to be
given to the superior officers.
However, in the instant
case, it appears that the petitioner has not cared even to
intimate her superior officers before proceeding on leave.
Issues relating to transport and infrastructure can never
form a justified ground for not attending the duties. Thus,
from the reply to the show cause notice furnished by the
petitioner, it can safely be inferred that she has admitted
the allegation regarding her unauthorized absence from
the duty.
24)
It is for the aforesaid reasons that her reply to the
show cause notice has not been found to be satisfactory
by respondent No. 2, who has proceeded to issue the
impugned order of termination, which is perfectly in
accordance with the terms of contract of service executed
by the petitioner. Once respondent No. 2 had material
before him to show that performance of the petitioner was
WP(C) No.2950/2024
not satisfactory, he was well within his powers to pass the
impugned order of termination. In fact while joining her
service, the petitioner has executed an undertaking
wherein it was agreed by her that in case of unsatisfactory
performance, the respondents would have a right to
terminate
her
services
prior
to
the
expiry
of
the
contractual period without assigning any reason and
without giving one month’s prior notice to her.
25)
So far as the contention of the petitioner that she
was entitled to be subjected to a regular departmental
enquiry is concerned, in this context it is to be noted that
a person appointed on contractual basis does not enjoy
the protection of Article 311 (2) of the Constitution of India
for the simple reason that he/she is not a member of civil
service of the Union or an All India Service or a civil
service of a State or holds a civil post under the Union or a
State.
Reliance in this regard is placed upon the
judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Union
Public Service Commission Vs. Girish Jayanti Lal
Vaghela, (2006) 2 SCC 482.
Therefore, a contractual
employee is not entitled to the protection, which is
available to an employee who is in service of Union or
State on a civil post.
WP(C) No.2950/2024
26)
Reliance placed by the learned counsel for the
petitioner on the judgments delivered by this Court in the
cases of Feroz Ahmad Sheikh and Dr. Shazia Salam
(supra) is misconceived for the reason that in those cases,
there was clear-cut violation of principles of natural
justice while passing the termination order against the
writ petitioners therein. It is in those circumstances that
the writ petitioners, in those petitions, succeeded before
the Court.
In the instant case, the respondents have
followed the principles of natural justice by issuing
repeated show cause notices to the petitioner and giving
her not only the opportunity of hearing but also of
improving her conduct. As many as three enquiries were
conducted
by
the
respondents
before
passing
the
impugned order, which goes on to show that the
respondents have been more than fair in dealing with the
case of the petitioner.
27)
For what has been discussed hereinbefore, it is clear
that termination of the petitioner from her services has
been effected in accordance with the conditions of her
engagement after following the principles of natural justice
and after considering her reply to the show cause notice in
the light of the enquiry reports.
The contention of the
petitioner that she was entitled to a full-fledged regular
WP(C) No.2950/2024
enquiry with a right to participate in the preliminary
enquiry is misconceived having regard to the nature of
engagement of the petitioner.
28)
The
petition,
therefore,
lacks
merit
and
is,
accordingly, dismissed. The respondents shall, however,
release
the
unpaid/withheld
salary,
if
any,
to
the
petitioner for the period during which she has performed
her duties.
29)
The record be returned to the learned counsel of the
respondents.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
JAMMU
06.02.2026
NARESH/SECY
Whether the order is reportable:
Whether the order is speaking:
WP(C) No.2950/2024
Naresh Kumar
2026.01.22 03:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review