The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
38. Accordingly, detention this order Court holds the preventive No.15/DMP/PSA/25 dated
30. 04.2025 passed by the respondent No.2- District Magistrate Pulwama confirmation/extension read with approval/ Government order/s operating against the petitioner’s personal liberty as illegal and are hereby quashed.
39. The petitioner is directed to be restored to his personal liberty by his release from the concerned Jail for which the Superintendent concerned to carry out obedience and compliance.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 26.02.2026
Pronounced on: 02.04.2026
HCP No. 143/2025
Hilal Ahmad Wagay
…..Petitioners
Through: Mr. M. Ayoub Bhat, Advocate.
Vs.
Union Territory of J&K and others
.….Respondents
Through: Mr. Furkan Yaqoob Sofi, GA.
Coram :
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Habeas Corpus petition is a petition of distress
through the medium of which a person having lost his
personal liberty is given a constitutional right of
approaching a Constitutional Court with a deep
seated belief and hope of seeking restoration of his
personal liberty which is a most cherished of all
fundamental right amongst all the fundamental rights
figuring in Part-III of the Constitution of India.
2.
The institution of present writ petition bears same
distress call whereby the petitioner-Hilal Ahmad
Wagay is seeking indulgence of this Court to restore
him to his personal liberty by having petitioned this
Court on 27.5.2025 adjudication whereof is taking
place through the medium of this judgment.
3.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well as
for the respondents. Perused the respective side
pleadings and the documents available on the record
of this File. Also perused the detention record.
4.
By virtue of a dossier submitted by the Senior
Superintendent of Police (SSP), Pulwama vide his
letter No. CS/PSA/25/25-28 dated 28.04.2025, the
respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Pulwama was
solicited to take notice of the alleged reported
activities of the petitioner being reckoned to be
prejudicial to the security of the State so as to inflict a
preventative detention order upon him under the J&K
Public Safety Act, 1978.
5.
The dossier so submitted referred the petitioner as
‘Imam’ of the Jamia Masjid, Nowpora, Chadoora. The
purported field reports are said to have suggested the
petitioner working as potential OGW to an active
terrorist-Asif Ahmed Sheikh providing him shelter
and other logistic support.
6.
It is worth reproducing herein one particular line
referring to the petitioner and same reads as, “The
subject is also providing ass sort of assistance to the
active terrorist for his movement from one place to
another place.” This Court needs not to say or observe
any further on the quality of reading of text by its
author.
7.
The dossier refers to the reports that the petitioner
while
performing
ritual
prayers
was
giving
objectionable sermons about ‘Jihad’ for luring the
young generation to get them involved and to join
terrorist ranks. The petitioner, being a resident of
hilly area, is said to be fully aware of the topography
of the area enabling him to provide logistic support to
other local/foreign terrorists for their movement from
one place to another. The petitioner is referred to be
so radicalized that he is waiting for an opportunity of
weaponry snatching so that he may join the terrorist
folds.
8.
The petitioner is said to have been subjected to
preventive custody under sections 126 and 170 BNSS
on 11.04.2025 and 17.04.2025.
9.
It is by reference to the alleged profile of the
petitioner that a case for his preventive detention was
put
into
process
from
the
end
of
the
Senior
Superintendent of Police (SSP), Pulwama.
10. The respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Pulwama,
purportedly applying his mind to the dossier and the
material therewith, formulated purported grounds of
detention therein referring that the petitioner, who is
the resident of the village Abhama Tehsil Rajpora,
District Pulwama, is ‘Hafiz-e-Quran’ of 2014 on the
basis whereof he got appointed as ‘Molvi’ at ‘Markazi
Jamia Masjid’, Abhama for the period 2015 to 2024
whereafter
shifted
to
Nowpora,
Chadoora
and
pursuing his occupation as ‘Imam’.
11. The grounds of detention refer petitioner being
working as OGW of active terrorist-Asif Ahmed Sheikh
providing him logistic support to carry out subversive
activities in congenial atmosphere.
12. The petitioner’s delivery of Friday ritual religious
sermons has been reckoned to be inciting the youth
of the area to join ‘Jihad’ by joining the terrorist
ranks.
13. The long and short of grounds of detention is the
repeat of the text of the dossier to put in simple
perspective.
14. On the basis of said grounds of detention, the
petitioner’s reported alleged state of activities were
read and reckoned by the respondent No.2-District
Magistrate, Pulwama being to prejudicial to the
security of the State
warranting his preventive
detention custody under the J&K Public Safety Act,
1978 on the basis whereof the preventive detention
order No.15/DMP/PSA/25 dated 30.04.2025 came
to
be
passed
thereby
ordering
the
preventive
detention of the petitioner.
15. The petitioner was, thus, ordered to be kept
confined in the District Jail, Udhampur for a period to
be specified by the Government.
16. Pursuant to the preventive detention order, the
petitioner
came
to
be
taken
into
custody
on
01.05.2025
when
S.I
Mohd.
Yousaf
No.
911597/EXK/DPL Pulwama carried out execution of
the detention warrant and of the formalities related
therewith in terms of handing over the order of
detention, grounds of detention and other documents
and also reading and explaining to the petitioner the
grounds of detention to make him understand fully
before being delivered to the Superintendent, District
Jail Udhampur.
17. The petitioner was given a compilation of ten leaves
in order which reads as under:i. Copy of warrant (01 leaf).
ii. Notice of detention (01 leaf).
iii. Grounds of detention (02 leaves).
iv. Dossier (02 leaves).
v. Copies of Istegasa (03 leaves).
vi. Beat report (01 leaves).
18. By virtue of Government Order No. Home/PBV/877/2025 dated 08.05.2025, the detention order
No. 15/DMP/PSA/25 dated 30.04.2025 came to be
approved for enabling the case for examination of the
Advisory
Board
constituted
under
Jammu
and
Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978.
19. By virtue of its opinion report dated 21.05.2025
on file No. Home/PB-V/210/2025, the Advisory
Board reckoned the detention of the petitioner to be
based on justifiable grounds and the process of
passing of detention order and its related compliances
dully followed. As per the Advisory Board’s said
opinion report, there was no representation placed
before it coming from the end of the petitioner against
his preventive detention.
20. By virtue of Government Order No. Home/PBV/1037/2025
dated
27.05.2025,
preventive
detention of the petitioner came to be confirmed with
detention period fixed for a period of six months w.e.f
01.05.2025 to 31.10.2025 at first instance.
21. For the purpose of extending period of detention for
another
six
months
w.e.f
01.11.2025
till
30.04.2026, the Home Department, Government of
UT of Jammu and Kashmir came to pass Government
Order
No.
Home/PB-V/1937/2025
dated
27.10.2025 stating therein that as on the date of
passing
of
Government
Order,
there
was
no
representation received from the petitioner or his
family member against the impugned detention order.
22. It is in the aforesaid facts and circumstances that
the petitioner came forward with institution of the
present writ petition on 27.05.2025 assailing his
detention on the grounds as set out in Para 5 (a) to
(v).
23. The petitioner assails his detention as being an
outcome of colorable exercise of power at the end of
the respondent’s No. 1 to 3 violating his fundamental
right/s
guaranteed
under
Constitution
of
India
particularly in terms of its Article 22.
24. The petitioner challenges that approval to the
original detention order has not been granted within
the stipulated period as mentioned in Section 8(4) of
Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978.
25. The petitioner assails that there has been no
proper application of mind on part of the detaining
authority with respect to the dossier placed by the
Senior Superintendent of Police, (SSP) Pulwama. The
detaining authority is said to have formulated no
grounds
of
detention
on
its
own
independent
application of mind. The petitioner submits that he
has not been provided the dossier at the time of his
detention taking place which seriously affected his
right of making an effective representation. The
petitioner submits that the language used in the
grounds of detention is not known to him more
particularly when hyper technical words have been
used such like OGW in describing the petitioner.
26. The petitioner submits that the alleged incidents
are all conjectured without any iota of factual
content. The grounds of detention framed in passing
the impugned detention order are being assailed as
vague.
27. Alongwith his writ petition, the petitioner has
annexed
impugned
detention
No.
order
15/DMP/PSA/25 dated 30.04.2025, grounds of
detention,
dossier
submitted
by
the
Senior
Superintendent of Police, (SSP) Pulwama.
28. Counter Affidavit from the end of the respondents
came to be filed on 19.09.2025.
29. In the Counter Affidavit, the respondent No.2District
Magistrate,
Pulwama
has
defended
the
preventive detention of the petitioner tooth and nail.
30. Upon hearings both sides and after perusing the
pleadings and the documents therewith as well as
also the detention record, this Court comes to a selfevident scenario that the petitioner does not have any
criminal antecedents whatsoever and that is the
reason that no such adverse antecedent has been
cited in the dossier as well as in the grounds of
detention viz-a-viz the petitioner. It is only by
purported
reference
to
the
alleged
preventive
proceedings under sections 126 and 170 of Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 which are
said
to
have
been
taken
on
11.04.2025
and
17.04.2025 that a justification for reckoning the
petitioner a potential doer of prejudicial activities
came to be pressed into picture for the purpose of
framing a dossier against the petitioner so as to
warrant his preventive detention custody.
31. A purported reference to the proceedings under
section 126 read with Section 170 of Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 is by no
stretch of legal reference and reliability a complete
reference to constitute as a fact that the law took its
full course in subjecting the petitioner and binding
him with an order passed under section 130 read
with136 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita
(BNSS), 2023 for keeping peace.
32. It is one thing to initiate a proceeding/s under
sections
125,126,127,128
and/or
of
the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023
and it is another thing to conclude it with an order
under
section
130/136
of
Bharatiya
Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 coming into being
whereby an Executive Magistrate takes a judicial call
as to whether the information provided to him has
truth bearing or not and if truth bearing then whether
sufficient to subject a person being enquired against
to be orderd to furnish security for keeping peace for
a given period of time with or without surety bonds.
33. In the present case, if the petitioner would have
been subjected to a final order under Section 136 of
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023
with execution of a bond with or without sureties,
then surely the
petitioner would have suffered
forfeiture of the bond/s on account of breach of the
bond/s by not ensuring security for keeping peace or
public tranquility.
34. Thus, the purported reference to sections to
126/170 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita
(BNSS), 2023 was always and is a half fact which
found the basis for the respondent No.2-District
Magistrate, Pulwama to switch over to more drastic
provision of preventive detention custody under
Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978 against
the petitioner when not even a bond was required
from him at first instance in the proceedings of lesser
effect
under
section
of
Bharatiya
Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023.
35. This Court cannot brush aside the arguments of
Mr. M. Ayoub Bhat, learned counsel for the petitioner,
that the basis of detention of the petitioner is
vagueness and nothing else as in the case if reference
to the purported section 126/170 of Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 is taken out
from the dossier as well as from the grounds of
detention, then there was nothing at the disposal at
the end of Superintendent of Police (SSP), Pulwama as
well as respondent No.2- District Magistrate Pulwama
in considering and ordering the preventive detention
of the petitioner.
36. A dossier as well as grounds of detention are not
meant to be smokescreen for ordering and validating
a preventive detention of a citizen of this country who
by majestic force of Article 21 of the Constitution of
India is entitled to his personal liberty.
37. In the present case, this Court finds that both the
dossier as well as the grounds of detention are
nothing but smokescreen on the basis whereof the
petitioner has come to suffer loss of his personal
liberty thereby impinging his fundamental right to
personal liberty under article 21 of the Constitution of
India which warrants this Court to exercise its
jurisdiction under article 226 of the Constitution of
India to restore the petitioner to his personal liberty.
38. Accordingly,
detention
this
order
Court
holds
the
preventive
No.15/DMP/PSA/25
dated
30.04.2025 passed by the respondent No.2- District
Magistrate
Pulwama
confirmation/extension
read
with
approval/
Government
order/s
operating against the petitioner’s personal liberty as
illegal and are hereby quashed.
39. The petitioner is directed to be restored to his
personal liberty by his release from the concerned Jail
for which the Superintendent concerned to carry out
obedience and compliance.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
Srinagar
02.04.2026
Opinder
Whether the judgment is speaking : Yes / No
Whether the judgment is reportable : Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review