The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. It appears that a sham challenge to the amending Acts was made out for the purpose of stalling the proceedings initiated by the impugned order dated May 18, 2023. Since there is no basis to the challenge to the amendments, WP (C) No.172 of 2023 is dismissed with full prejudice to the petitioner for its consequences.
19. There will, however, be no order as to costs. (W. Diengdoh) Judge (Sanjib Banerjee) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.172/2023
Date of Order: 10.07.2023
Hewingson A. Sangma
Coram:
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
: Ms. S. Alam, Adv (VC) with
Ms. S. Marpna, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, Addl.Sr.GA
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
Mr. S. Jindal, Adv for R/2-4
Mr. P.T. Sangma, Adv for R/5
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
This petition is in desperation and is somewhat akin to the devil
citing the scriptures.
2.
A frivolous challenge has been made to the amending Acts of
2019 and 2021 by which the original provisions of the Meghalaya
Lokayukta Act, 2014 have been substantially altered. In essence, what has
been done by the impugned part of the amending Acts is to have the body
called Lokayukta, originally intended to be headed by a Chairperson and
consisting of several other members, to be complete upon the Chairperson
being appointed. The grievance of the petitioner is that the two
amendments are completely arbitrary, ultra vires Article 14 of the
Constitution and they have taken away rights that may have accrued to the
petitioner in the interregnum. None of the contentions holds any water.
3.
The Act of 2014 was not passed under any constitutional
provision nor does it refer to any other statute or material in such regard.
Lokayukta Acts have been enacted in several States to check the
functioning of public servants and take speedy action where some form of
wrongdoing is discovered. A preliminary investigation is conducted to
look into the credibility of the charges brought and, if the preliminary
investigation reveals some prima facie basis, a regular investigation is
required to be conducted, whether by a special investigation team or by
the regular machinery. In terms of the Act, opportunities are afforded to
an accused or against any other person that the Lokayukta may decide to
proceed at several stages, particularly at the time of adjudication.
4.
There is also a provision in Section 50 of the Act that protects a
public servant against complaints brought against him when he has acted
in good faith in discharging the duties of his office.
5.
The petitioner claims that the original complaint was not
directed against the petitioner but, following a preliminary inquiry, a
notice was issued to the petitioner on March 14, 2023 to which the
petitioner responded orally.
6.
The immediate challenge herein is to the propriety of an order
dated May 18, 2023 by which the Lokayukta has required charge-sheets
to be filed under Sections 7 and 12 of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988, inter alia, against the petitioner. The matter is at such preliminary
stage. Following the May 18, 2023 order of the Lokayukta passed by only
its Chairperson and not as a part of any bench, a special court in Tura has
taken cognizance of the matter by an order dated May 23, 2023 required
summons to be issued against all the persons named in the order dated
May 18, 2023, including the petitioner herein.
7.
At the time that this petition was received in this Court, the
petitioner questioned the validity of the amending Acts and claimed that
the principles of natural justice had been completely violated. On June
12, 2023, this Court received the petition and provided in its order of such
date as follows:
“The investigation will continue in terms of the order
impugned, without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the
petitioner herein. However, if the need arises to arrest the
petitioner, such arrest may not be made without leave of this
Court”.
8.
According to the petitioner, the entire scheme of the original
Act has been turned on its head and though the State Legislature initially
intended a serious matter as a complaint against a public servant
discharging his official duty to be considered by a body which was to be
called the Lokayukta, the amendment has stripped the body down to a
solitary person. This, according to the petitioner, is completely arbitrary
and apparently not in consonance with Article 14 of the Constitution.
Several provisions of the original statute have been placed, including
those pertaining to the constitution of the body known as the Lokayukta,
the procedure for appointment of the Chairperson and members of such
body and the selection committee which would recommend the names for
the appointments to be made therefrom.
9.
On merits, Section 21 of the Act has been copiously placed to
submit that before proceeding against any person other than an accused,
notice has to be issued to such person and such person’s views obtained.
10.
Section 20 of the original Act has also been placed to
emphasise that upon receipt of a complaint it was the body of the
Lokayukta which had to call for a preliminary inquiry and by the
amendments, particularly the amendment contained in Section 2 of the
amending Act of 2019, Section 5 of the Act may have been altered but
Section 20 of the statute remains unaffected.
11.
Particular objection has been taken to Section 2 of the
amending Act of 2021 both in its first and the fifth sub-sections. In effect,
the amendment provides for the Lokayukta to be run singly by its
Chairperson, even without the assistance of any member if no member
has been appointed.
12.
There is no dispute that it was the State Legislature which
enacted the original statute in 2014 and such Legislature had due
authority to alter or amend the provisions thereof. Just as the State
Assembly deemed it fit originally for the Lokayukta to be a body of
several persons, it could have, provided for a Lokayukta to be a singleperson authority. There was neither any impediment at the initial stage
nor at any subsequent stage on the State Assembly to decide on the
constitution and composition of the Lokayukta and merely because it had
once indicated that the Lokayukta would be a body of persons would not
stand in the way of the State Assembly altering its original position to
provide for a one-member Lokayukta.
13.
Further, since the State Legislature had due authority to amend
its own Act in such manner as it thought fit, the introduction of the
proviso to Section 5 by the 2019 amendment would be all pervasive and
cannot said to be confined to Section 5 alone.
14.
Section 5 of the Act in its original form requires appointments
to vacant posts to be made. By adding the proviso, the Legislature
clarified that if the body that was contemplated to be the Lokayukta was
not complete upon vacancies not being filled up, that would not stand in
the way of the available persons in the organisation continuing with the
activities as empowered. As a consequence, the proviso would have an
effect on all the other provisions of the original statute, including Section
20 which provides for members sitting along with the Chairperson to
require a preliminary investigation or inquiry to be made.
15.
There does not appear to be any arbitrariness in the State
Legislature having amended the Act that was of the same Legislature’s
doing. No prejudice on the ground of Article 14 has been demonstrated
except by referring to such constitutional provision.
16.
In this case, a complaint was made in respect of certain matters
involving the use of public funds. A preliminary inquiry was called for by
the Lokayukta which resulted in several other names coming up apart
from the person or persons originally complained against. At the time of
preparing the preliminary report, due notice was issued, in compliance
with the principles of natural justice, to the petitioner herein whereupon,
the petitioner claims to have made an oral representation after receiving
the notice of March 14, 2023 by presenting himself before the body
charged with the task of making the preliminary investigation.
17.
At the highest, the best arguable case of the petitioner is that the
order dated May 18, 2023 passed by the Lokayukta may have been
without notice to the petitioner and without affording the petitioner an
opportunity of being heard. However, such notice causes no prejudice to
the petitioner since the matter has been referred to the special court for the
special court to file charge-sheets under certain provisions. There is no
doubt that the petitioner will be heard as summons have already been
issued. At any rate, if there is any grievance in such regard or any
infraction that the petitioner can rightfully complain of, this is not the
forum for such purpose.
18.
It appears that a sham challenge to the amending Acts was
made out for the purpose of stalling the proceedings initiated by the
impugned order dated May 18, 2023. Since there is no basis to the
challenge to the amendments, WP (C) No.172 of 2023 is dismissed with
full prejudice to the petitioner for its consequences.
19.
There will, however, be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
10.07.2023
“Lam DR-PS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review