Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC010281012023
2026:GAU-AS:9316
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Test.Cas./5/2023
HEMLATA KALITA
D/O LATE MANIK KALITA
RESIDENT OF HAHARA, PS KAMALPUR, DIST KAMRUP , ASSAM 782402
VERSUS
SURATH KALITA AND 2 ORS
S/O LATE MANIK KALITA,
RESIDENT OF HAHARA, PS KAMALPUR, DIST KAMRUP , ASSAM 782402
2:SMTI RENUKA KALITA MAHANTA
W/O SRI KRISHNA KANTA MAHANTA
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE GERIMARI NEW TOWN
PS MANGALDOI (UNDER MOWAMARI GAON PANCHAYAT ) DIST
DARRANG
ASSAM 784125
3:SMTI JNANSHREE KALITA DEKA
W/O SRI BHUPENDRA NATH DEKA
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KOROIBARI
PS RANGIA
DIST KAMRUP
ASSAM 78113
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. A BISWAS, MR R KALITA
Advocate for the Respondent : MR P K BASU (r-2,3),
Page No.# 2/14
–B E F O R E –
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
For the Petitioner
: MR. A BISWAS, MR. R. KALITA, MR. N. LAHKAR
For the Respondent(s)
: MR. P K BASU FOR R- 2 & 3.
Date on which judgment
is reserved
: N/A
Date of pronouncement
of judgment
:
23.06.2026.
Whether the pronouncement
is of the operative part
of the judgment ?
:
No.
Whether the full judgment
has been pronounced
:
Yes.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. A Biswas, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Mr. P K Basu,
learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 & 3.
2. It appears from the order dated 14.08.2024 that, as per the affidavit of service dated
Page No.# 3/14
04.03.2024 filed by the appellant, notice in dasti mode was tendered to respondent No. 1
and was received by him. However, despite service, none appeared on behalf of the said
respondent and accordingly, the appeal proceeded ex parte against respondent No. 1.
3. The present appeal has been preferred under Section 299 of the Indian Succession
Act, 1925 (for short, “the Succession Act”) assailing the judgment dated 15.09.2023 and
decree dated 03.10.2023 passed by the learned District Judge, Kamrup, Amingaon in
Probate Title Suit No. 02/2018, whereby the probate suit filed by the appellant came to
be dismissed.
4. The case of the appellant, in brief, is that she had instituted an application under
Section 276 of the Succession Act before the Court of the learned District Judge, Kamrup,
Amingaon seeking grant of probate in respect of the last Will and testament of her late
father, Manik Kalita, allegedly executed on 07.03.2011 and registered on 08.03.2011
before the Sub-Registrar, Rangia. According to the appellant, the said Will had been
executed in the presence of three witnesses, namely, (i) Smti. Jnanshree Kalita, (ii) Sri
Nirendra Kumar Nath and (iii) Omar Faruk. The said application was initially registered as
Misc. Probate Case No. 03/2017.
5. Upon issuance of notice, the opposite parties, who are the brothers and sisters of the
appellant, entered appearance. However, except respondent No. 1, none of the other
respondents contested the Will. As respondent No. 1 raised objection to the grant of
probate, the proceeding was converted into a contentious cause and was thereafter renumbered as Probate Title Suit No. 02/2018.
6. During the trial, the appellant examined three witnesses, namely, herself as PW-1,
Omar Faruk, one of the attesting witnesses to the Will, as PW-2, and Krishna Kanta
Mahanta, the husband of respondent No. 2, as PW-3. The appellant also exhibited the
original Will and other documents in support of her case. All the said witnesses were
cross-examined by respondent No. 1.
7. On the other hand, respondent No. 1, in support of his defence, examined himself as
DW-1 and one Samiran Deka as DW-2.
Page No.# 4/14
8. Upon completion of the evidence, the learned Trial Court framed the following issues:
1. Whether late Manik Kalita executed any Will in favour of the plaintiff?
2. Whether the probate petition filed by the plaintiff is barred by limitation?
3. Whether the application for probate filed by the plaintiff is maintainable?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to probate as prayed for?
5. To what relief(s), if any, are the parties entitled?
9. By the impugned judgment dated 15.09.2023, the learned Trial Court though held the
issue Nos. 2 & 3 in favor of the appellant plaintiff, however, upon holding the issue Nos. 1
& 4 respectively against the appellant plaintiff and in favor of the respondent defendant,
dismissed the suit and consequently, the decree was drawn on 03.10.2023. Aggrieved
thereby, the present appeal has been preferred.
10. Mr. Biswas, learned counsel for the appellant, submits that the learned Trial Court fell
into manifest error in holding that the Will had not been proved in accordance with
Section 63 of the Succession Act read with Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
According to the learned counsel, the evidence on record clearly establishes that the
testator executed the Will in the presence of the attesting witnesses and that the
mandatory requirements of law stood duly satisfied. It is further submitted that the
evidence also discloses that the testator was physically capable of attending the office of
the Sub-Registrar for registration of the Will and that there is no cogent material to
support the defence plea that he was bedridden or incapable of movement.
11. Learned counsel for the appellant further submits that the Will in question is a
registered Will and therefore, registration is a relevant circumstance which lends
assurance to the genuineness of the document, though proof in terms of Section 63 of
the Succession Act and Section 68 of the Evidence Act is nevertheless required. In
support of the aforesaid submissions, reliance has been placed on the decisions of the
Apex Court in Prem Singh & Ors. vs. Birbal & Ors., reported in (2006) 5 SCC
353, Vimal Chand Ghevarchand Jain and Ors. -Vs- Ramakant Eknath
Jadoo, reported in (2009) 5 SCC 713, and Daulat Ram & Ors. -Vs- Sodha &
Page No.# 5/14
Ors., reported in (2005) 1 SCC 40.
12. Mr. P. K. Basu, learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos. 2 and 3, supports the
stand of the appellant and submits that the Will in question was validly executed by the
testator and the learned Trial Court was not justified in dismissing the probate suit.
13. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have perused the records of the
case, including the evidence adduced before the learned Trial Court.
14. Since the present appeal arises under Section 299 of the Succession Act, it would be
apposite to reproduce the said provision:
“299. Appeals from orders of District Judge.— Every order made by a District
Judge by virtue of the powers hereby conferred upon him shall be subject to appeal
to the High Court in accordance with the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 applicable to appeals.”
15. A plain reading of Section 299 of the Succession Act makes it clear that an appeal
from an order of the District Judge in a probate proceeding is to be considered in
accordance with the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure applicable to appeals. The
present appeal, therefore, partakes the character of a first appeal, in which this Court is
entitled to re-appreciate both facts and law.
16. The Apex Court in Laliteshwar Prasad Singh & Ors. -Vs- S.P. Srivastava
(Dead) Through Legal Representatives reported in (2017) 2 SCC 415, has
reiterated that a first appellate Court, being the final Court on facts, is required to
consider the evidence on record and record reasons on the points arising for
determination. It is, therefore, necessary for this Court to independently evaluate the
evidence brought on record.
17. Upon consideration of the pleadings, evidence and the grounds urged in appeal, the
following points arise for determination in the present appeal:
(i) Whether the appellant has proved the due execution and attestation of the Will
dated 07.03.2011 in accordance with Section 63 of the Succession Act and Section 68
of the Indian Evidence Act?
Page No.# 6/14
(ii) Whether the learned Trial Court was justified in holding that the Will had not been
proved in accordance with law and in dismissing the probate suit?
(iii) Whether the impugned judgment and decree call for interference by this Court?
18. Before adverting to the evidence on record, it is necessary to notice the scope of
enquiry in a probate proceeding. The jurisdiction of the probate court is limited to
examining whether the document propounded is the last Will and testament of the
testator, whether it was duly executed and attested in accordance with law, and whether
at the time of execution the testator was in a sound disposing state of mind. Questions
relating to title to the properties covered by the Will do not ordinarily fall for adjudication
in such proceedings. In this regard, reference may be made to the decision of the Apex
Court in Ishwardeo Narain Singh vs Sm. Kamta Devi & Ors., reported in AIR
1954 SC 280.
19. Section 63 of the Succession Act prescribes the mode of execution of an unprivileged
Will. Clause (c) thereof provides that the Will shall be attested by two or more witnesses,
each of whom has either seen the testator sign or affix his mark to the Will, or has
received from the testator a personal acknowledgment of such signature or mark, and
each of such witnesses must sign the Will in the presence of the testator.
20. Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act provides that a document required by law to be
attested shall not be used in evidence unless at least one attesting witness has been
called for the purpose of proving its execution, if such witness is alive and capable of
giving evidence.
21. The legal position is thus well settled that in order to prove a Will, the propounder
must establish that the testator signed or affixed his mark to the Will; that such signature
or mark was intended to give effect to the writing as a Will; that the Will was attested by
at least two witnesses in the manner contemplated under Section 63(c) of the Succession
Act; and that at least one attesting witness has been examined to prove such execution in
terms of Section 68 of the Evidence Act. At the same time, if suspicious circumstances are
alleged, the propounder must dispel such suspicious circumstances by satisfactory
Page No.# 7/14
evidence.
22. In Daulat Ram (supra), the Apex Court held that in order to assess whether a Will
has been validly executed and is genuine, the propounder has to show that the Will was
signed by the testator, that he had signed the testament of his own free will, that he was
at the relevant time in a sound disposing state of mind and understood the nature and
effect of the dispositions, and that the Will was duly attested in the manner known to law.
It was further held that once these elements are established, the burden resting on the
propounder stands discharged, subject, however, to removal of any suspicious
circumstances if such circumstances exist.
23. Keeping the aforesaid legal position in mind, the evidence on record may now be
examined.
24. PW-1, namely, the appellant herself, deposed that during the lifetime of her father,
late Manik Kalita, he executed a registered Will on 07.03.2011 which was registered on
08.03.2011 before the Sub-Registrar, Rangia in the presence of the witnesses, namely,
Smti. Jnanshree Kalita, Nirendra Kumar Nath and Omar Faruk. She further deposed that
the said Will represented the last testamentary disposition of her father and that the
properties described in the schedule were bequeathed in her favour. She proved the
original Will as Exhibit-1 and also identified the signatures/thumb impression appearing
thereon.
25. PW-1 further deposed that the testator had bequeathed his property in her favour in
consideration of the care and service rendered by her to him in his old age and out of
love and affection towards her. She stated that the testator had come to live with her as
respondent Nos. 1 and 2 did not look after him properly. She also proved the land
documents relating to the scheduled property as well as the death certificate of the
testator.
26. It appears from the cross-examination of PW-1 that she denied the suggestion that
her father had been secretly taken away by her or that he was not in a position to move
without assistance. She also stated that, except Nirendra Kumar Nath, the other two
Page No.# 8/14
attesting witnesses had accompanied her father to the office of the Sub-Registrar on
08.03.2011 and that she and her elder sister had taken him there. She further stated that
it was her father who had expressed his intention to execute the Will.
27. PW-2, Omar Faruk, is one of the attesting witnesses to the Will. His evidence
assumes significance for the purpose of Section 68 of the Evidence Act. He deposed that
during the lifetime of the testator Manik Kalita, the latter executed the registered Will
dated 07.03.2011, which was registered on 08.03.2011 before the Sub-Registrar, Rangia
in the presence of the witnesses, including himself. He proved the original registered Will
and identified his signature thereon as well as the signatures/thumb impression of the
testator.
28. In cross-examination, PW-2 denied the suggestion that the testator did not come to
the office of the Sub-Registrar on the date of registration or that he was bedridden and
did not visit the said office.
29. PW-3, Krishna Kanta Mahanta, though not an attesting witness to the Will, supported
the case of the appellant and deposed that the testator had executed the registered Will
in the presence of witnesses and had bequeathed his properties in favour of the
appellant. In cross-examination, he denied the suggestion that the testator was not in a
position to sign at the time of execution of the Will.
30. On the other hand, DW-1, respondent No. 1, deposed that the appellant had taken
away his father and taking advantage of his old age, managed to get the Will executed.
He further deposed that when he found his father missing, he lodged an FIR and later
found him in the house of his sister (appellant).
31. However, in his cross-examination, DW-1 admitted that after his father had gone
missing, he was later found at the house of his elder sister (respondent No. 3) at
Karaibari village, whereafter the matter was informed to the police. The testimony of DW1, therefore, does not support the plea that the testator was wholly immobile or incapable
of movement. On the contrary, it indicates that after leaving the house of respondent No.
1, the testator had moved elsewhere and was staying away from him. Significantly, the
Page No.# 9/14
testator was found not in the house of the appellant, but in the house of respondent No.
3. This circumstance also probabilises the appellant’s case that the testator had left the
house of respondent No. 1 and was thereafter residing away from him.
32. DW-2, Samiran Deka, a neighbour of respondent No. 1, deposed that the testator
was old, unwell and bedridden and that he had been secretly taken away by the
appellant. However, DW-2 was neither an attesting witness to the Will nor a person
connected with its execution or registration. His evidence is, therefore, only of a general
nature and cannot by itself dislodge the evidence of the attesting witness or the
surrounding circumstances appearing from the record.
33. It is true that the probate petition was accompanied by declarations of two attesting
witnesses in terms of Section 281 of the Succession Act. However, such declarations, by
themselves, do not constitute substantive evidence of due execution and attestation of
the Will unless the makers thereof enter the witness box or the contents thereof are
otherwise proved in accordance with law. Therefore, the said declarations cannot, by
themselves, be treated as independent proof of execution of the Will.
34. At the same time, it is relevant to note that one of the attesting witnesses to the Will,
namely, Omar Faruk, who had also furnished a declaration in terms of Section 281 of the
Succession Act, entered the witness box as PW-2 and deposed in support of the execution
of the Will. Therefore, while the declaration by itself is not substantive evidence, the fact
remains that the said attesting witness was examined before the Court and the due
execution of the Will has to be assessed on the basis of his testimony read with the other
evidence on record.
35. The issue as to proof of the Will must, therefore, be determined primarily on the
basis of the oral and documentary evidence legally adduced during trial, particularly the
testimony of PW-2 as an attesting witness, read with the evidence of PW-1 and the
attendant circumstances brought on record.
36. On an overall appreciation of the evidence of PW-1 and PW-2, this Court finds that
the Will in question has been proved in accordance with law. PW-2 is one of the attesting
Page No.# 10/14
witnesses to the Will. His testimony clearly establishes that the testator executed the Will
and that the Will was registered before the Sub-Registrar, Rangia in the presence of the
witnesses, including himself. He identified the Will, his signature thereon and the
signatures/thumb impression of the testator. Nothing substantial could be elicited in his
cross-examination to discredit his testimony.
37. The evidence of PW-1 also supports the case of the appellant as regards the
circumstances in which the Will came to be executed and registered. Though PW-1 is not
an attesting witness and cannot by herself prove the attestation of the Will, her evidence
is nevertheless relevant to the surrounding facts, including the fact that the testator had
gone to the office of the Sub-Registrar and that the Will was executed and registered in
the presence of the attesting witnesses.
38. The learned Trial Court discarded the Will on the ground that neither PW-1 nor PW-2
had expressly stated, in so many words, that the testator signed the Will in the presence
of the attesting witnesses and that the attesting witnesses signed the Will in the presence
of the testator. In the considered opinion of this Court, the learned Trial Court adopted an
unduly hyper-technical approach in appreciating the evidence on record.
39. The evidence of an attesting witness is not to be read in a truncated or pedantic
manner. What is required is that the evidence, read as a whole, must satisfy the essential
ingredients of Section 63(c) of the Succession Act and Section 68 of the Evidence Act.
The testimony of PW-2, when read in its entirety, unmistakably indicates that the testator
executed the Will in the presence of the witnesses and that PW-2 was one of the attesting
witnesses thereto. He has also proved the Will in original and identified the
signatures/thumb impression appearing thereon. In the facts of the present case, the
evidence of PW-2, read with the testimony of PW-1 and the attendant circumstances, is
sufficient to hold that the due execution and attestation of the Will stood proved.
40. It is also relevant that the Will in question is a registered Will. It is settled that
registration by itself does not dispense with proof of execution in the manner required by
law. At the same time, registration remains a relevant circumstance while appreciating the
Page No.# 11/14
genuineness of the document and the surrounding circumstances attending its execution.
In the present case, the registration of the Will, coupled with the evidence of PW-2 and
the absence of any cogent evidence of suspicious circumstances, lends assurance to the
case of the appellant.
In this regard, reference may be made to the decision of the Apex Court in the case
of Metpalli Lasum Bai (Since Dead) & Ors -Vs- Metapalli Muthaih (D) by Lrs.
reported in (2025) SCC OnLine SC 1488, wherein the Apex Court emphasized that a
registered document always carries a presumption of its genuineness. Relevant paragraph
of the aforesaid judgment reads as under:
“9. The Will is a registered document. The defendant-Muthaiah in his evidence,
admitted the signatures as appearing on the said Will (Ext -A1) to be that of his father,
e, M Rajanna The Will distributed the properties in defined proportions between the
plaintiff-Lasum Bai, defendant-Muthaiah and Rajamma (widowed daughter of M
Rajanna) There is ample material on record to establish that M Rajanna anticipated
that the relations between plaintiff-Lasum Bai and defendant-Muthaiah were not
congenial and that is why, in order to avoid future conflicts, he divided his properties
by way of a family settlement and bequeathed a share thereof to plaintiff-Lasum Bai,
while leaving the major share to his son ie, the defendant-Muthaiah The distribution of
the properties, as per the family settlement (regarding which oral evidence was led),
and the registered Will is almost in the same proportions. The Will, is a registered
document and thus there is a presumption regarding genuineness thereof The trial
Court accepted the execution of the Will based on the evidence led before it As the Will
is a registered document, the burden would lie on the party who disputed its existence
thereof, who would be defendant-Muthaiah in this case, to establish that it was not
executed in the manner as alleged or that there were suspicious circumstances which
made the same doubtful However, the defendant-Muthaiah in his evidence, admitted
the signatures as appearing on the registered Will to be those of his father, M.
Rajanna. He also admitted the fact that the plaintiff-Lasum Bai was in possession of 6
acres and 16 guntas of land, which fell into her share as per the Will In this
background, the trial Court was right in holding that M Rajanna made a fair
distribution of his tangible assets amongst his legal heirs by executing the Will dated
24th July, 1974 and so also the oral family settlement We are of the view that the
evidence available on record fortifies the existence and persuasive nature of the oral
family settlement which is countenanced by the factum of the possession of the suit
schedule properties including the disputed property, which was admittedly with the
plaintiff-Lasum Bai and subsequently the purchaser i.e, Janardhan Reddy ”
41. There is another aspect of the matter which also deserves notice. The evidence on
Page No.# 12/14
record indicates that the testator was earlier residing with respondent No. 1 and his wife.
However, it appears that owing to ill-treatment at the hands of respondent No. 1, the
testator left that house and was subsequently found in the house of his elder daughter.
Thereafter, from around the year 2009, he started residing with the appellant in her
rented house.
42. The evidence of PW-1 further shows that the appellant, who is unmarried, had been
taking care of the testator during his old age while he was residing with her. The
materials on record also indicate that respondent No. 1, despite being the son with whom
the father had earlier resided, did not thereafter visit or take care of him. Significantly, the
Will in question came to be executed in the year 2011, that is, after the testator had
already been residing with the appellant for a considerable period of time. The testator
thereafter survived for almost three years and passed away on 10.05.2014.
43. In the aforesaid backdrop, the bequest made by the testator in favour of the
appellant cannot be said to be unnatural, improbable or attended by suspicious
circumstances. On the contrary, the disposition appears to be wholly consistent with the
surrounding facts brought on record, namely, that after leaving the house of the
respondent No. 1, the testator had been residing with the appellant, who was looking
after him in his old age.
44. It is also relevant to note that, apart from respondent No. 1, the other siblings did not
raise any objection to the Will. More importantly, respondent No. 3, one of the daughters
of the testator, not only did not dispute the Will but had also accompanied the testator to
the office of the Sub-Registrar at the time of registration/execution of the Will and had
signed the same as one of the attesting witnesses. This is a significant circumstance
which lends assurance to the genuineness of the Will and to the case of the appellant.
45. The defence of respondent No. 1 is that the appellant had taken advantage of the old
age and alleged ailment of the testator and procured the Will. However, apart from
making such allegation, no cogent evidence was adduced to establish fraud, coercion,
undue influence or want of testamentary capacity. DW-2 merely made a general
Page No.# 13/14
statement that the testator was unwell and bedridden. That by itself is not sufficient to
displace the evidence of the attesting witness, particularly when PW-2 has categorically
stated that the testator had gone to the office of the Sub-Registrar and executed the Will
there.
46. The evidence of DW-1 also does not advance the case of the objector. His own
testimony discloses that after the testator had gone missing, he was found in the house
of his sister (Respondent No. 3). This circumstance rather indicates that the testator was
capable of movement and was not entirely under the control of respondent No. 1. There
is no medical evidence whatsoever on record to establish that on the date of execution of
the Will the testator lacked a sound disposing state of mind or was physically incapable of
executing the Will.
47. In the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is of the considered view that the
appellant has succeeded in proving the due execution and attestation of the Will dated
07.03.2011 in accordance with Section 63 of the Succession Act and Section 68 of the
Indian Evidence Act. The evidence on record also does not disclose any suspicious
circumstance surrounding the execution of the Will. On the contrary, the materials on
record show that the testator had been residing with the appellant since 2009, that she
had been taking care of him in his old age, that respondent No. 1 had not been looking
after him, and that respondent No. 3, one of the attesting witnesses, had accompanied
the testator to the office of the Sub-Registrar at the time of execution/registration of the
Will. The bequest in favour of the appellant, therefore, cannot be said to be unnatural or
improbable.
48. Consequently, Point No. (i) is answered in favour of the appellant. Point Nos. (ii) and
(iii) are also answered in favour of the appellant by holding that the learned Trial Court
erred in dismissing the probate suit and that the impugned judgment and decree are
liable to be set aside.
49. In view of the findings returned above, the impugned judgment dated 15.09.2023
and decree dated 03.10.2023 passed by the learned District Judge, Kamrup, Amingaon in
Page No.# 14/14
Probate Title Suit No. 02/2018 are hereby set aside.
50. Accordingly, the application for probate stands allowed. It is hereby declared that the
WILL executed on 07.03.2011 and registered on 08.03.2011 by the testator Manik Kalita
is the genuine and last WILL of late Manik Kalita. The executor Smti. Hemlata Kalita is
entitled to get Probate of the WILL executed on 07.03.2011 and registered on
08.03.2011, executed by the testator subject to payment of due Court fees on the
properties mentioned in the WILL as per the present market value.
51. The applicant is directed to take steps for submitting an official valuation certificate
for assessing the Court fees.
52. Registry to issue Probate Certificate accordingly in terms of the relevant Schedule of
Indian Succession Act, 1925.
53. Send back the Trial Court records along with the original WILL to the Court of District
Judge, Kamrup, Amingaon by way of special messenger.
54. The original WILL be kept in the safe custody of the CAO/Sheristader of the District
Judge, Kamrup, Amingaon.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
signed
Pranab Digitally
by Pranab
Deka
Kumar Kumar
Date:
2026.06.26
Deka 12:29:03 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review