Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl. Petn. No. 18 of 2022 with
Crl. Petn. No. 19 of 2022
Date of Decision: 23.02.2023
Shri. John Vashum
Shri. Hegin Haokip
Vs.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & 2 Ors.
State of Meghalaya & 2 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, AAG, with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA. (R.1-3)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
COMMONJUDGMENT
1.
Two applications under Section 482 Cr.P.C were filed before this
Court by two respective petitioners pertaining to a case arising out of a
single FIR, investigation thereto which was also launched in the same
proceedings and finally a common charge sheet being filed.
2.
As submitted by the parties, the two applications being almost
similar and identical in nature involving the same issues, this Court deems
it proper to address the issues collectively and individually and to pass a
common order.
3.
An FIR dated 14.10.2015 filed before the Superintendent of Police,
East Khasi Hills, Shillong, by Shri. Haseeb Khan (respondent No.4) who is
said to be the Manager (Operations), C3i Consultant India Pvt. Ltd. for
Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L/P and M/s Canon Inc. has set
the criminal proceedings in motion with the registration of Laitumkhrah
P.S. Case No. 199(10)2015, under Section 420/486/488 IPC, r/w Section 63
of the Copyright Act, 1957.
4.
In response to this, Sub-Inspector R.S. Nahar of Laitumkhrah Police
Station along with the said informant conducted a search of the shop named
and styled as M/s Silicon Computer Shop, located at Anderson Arcade,
Laitumkhrah Main Road on 14th October, 2015 at about 6:20 pm and from
the said shop, 4 (four) pieces of Canon Toner Cartridge Model No. 303 (two
pieces) and Model No. 912 (two pieces) were seized from the possession of
Shri. John Vashum.
5.
Another seizure was made by the Investigating Officer (I/O)
wherein 1(one) Laser Toner Cartridge Model No. 12 A and 4(four) Laser
Toner Cartridge Model No. CC 388 AC were seized from Techno Source
Computer Shop, Laitumkhrah, run by Shri. Hegin Haokip.
6.
The matter was then investigated into and after the investigation is
completed, the I/O filed the Final Report Form under Section 173 Cr.P.C
which included the charge sheet stating the prosecution’s story of the case
and in conclusion thereof, a prima facie case has been found well
established, amongst others against the petitioners herein who were
implicated as accused being the proprietor of the said M/s Silicon Computer
Shop and Techno Source Computer Shop respectively.
7.
Accordingly, a formal case was registered as GR Case No. 121(S)
2016, under Section 420/486/488 IPC, r/w Section 63 of the Copyright Act,
1957 in the court of the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Shillong and
the petitioners were directed to stand trial before the said court.
8.
In due course, the matter was fixed for filing of written argument
before charge and the petitioners filed their respective written arguments on
28.06.2017 disputing the charges made by the prosecution and has prayed
for discharge from the case. However, after a lapse of almost four years, the
impugned order dated 12.03.2021 was passed, rejecting the prayer of the
respective petitioners and further directing that charges be framed in the
case.
9.
Maintaining that the petitioners have committed no offence as
alleged, this petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C is accordingly preferred
before this Court with a prayer to set aside and quash the proceedings in GR
case pending before the said Judicial Magistrate First Class, Shillong.
10.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Sr. counsel appearing for the
petitioners has submitted that the seizure list dated 14.10.2015 would show
that from the shop of the petitioner, Shri John Vashum, four numbers of
cartridges of Canon made were seized on the complaint lodged by the
complainant Shri. Haseeb Khan.
11.
From the certificate issued by the C3i Consultants India Pvt Ltd., it
is seen that the company was authorized by M/s Hewlett-Packard
Development Company, L.P. to assist/file complaints before any court
towards protecting the companies Intellectual Property such as Trade Mark,
Copyrights and Patent. The company then authorized Shri. Haseeb Khan,
who has been trained by M/s Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P.
to identify counterfeit Hewlett-Packard products.
12.
The learned Sr. counsel has also submitted that the complainant in
his statement before the police had maintained that he is the Manager
(Operations) of C3i Consultants India Pvt. Ltd. and is authorized by M/s
Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P and M/s Canon Inc, 30-2
Shimomaruku 3-Chrome, Ohta-ku, Tokyo 146-8501, Japan for checking
and detecting spurious and counterfeit Hewlett-Packard and Canon
Computer materials. However, the complainant although has produced
documents to show that he is authorized by Hewlett-Packard as far as their
products are concerned, has never produced any authorization letter to show
that he is an official representative of Canon Company. The Investigating
Officer has also failed to produce any proof to confirm that the complainant
is or was authorized to represent Canon Company.
13.
Again, it was submitted that the I/O while filing the charge sheet,
has also indicated the witnesses who will prove the prosecution’s case and
accordingly, a list of 11 witnesses was drawn up. Of the first three
witnesses, the first is the complainant Shri. Haseeb Khan, Manager
(Operations) of C3i Consultants India Pvt. Ltd. The second and third
witnesses are Investigators of C3i Consultants India Pvt. Ltd., the rest are
Salespersons and an Engineer working in the shop of the petitioner and
other shops. The last witness is the I/O.
14.
The learned Sr. counsel has submitted that as pointed out, the C3i
Consultants Company is a company under Hewlett-Packard Company
which is not connected with Canon Company and in the absence of any
technical expert as a witness of the Canon Company, it would be difficult
to prove the case of the prosecution in this respect. It is also on record that
the petitioner had purchased the seized items from one shop named and
styled as “Datamation Services” G.S. Road, Ulubari, Guwahati which is the
authorized dealer of Canon products, however, the proprietor of this shop
was never made a witness or summoned to prove the allegation made in the
complaint.
15.
Coming to the case of the petitioner in Crl. Petn. Case No. 19 of
2022, the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that the case relates to the same
FIR dated 14.10.2015 filed by the complainant Shri. Haseeb Khan and the
I/O has carried out a combined investigation along with the case of
petitioner, John Vashum and a common charge sheet was filed indicating
that there is prima facie evidence to proceed against this petitioner, Hegin
Haokip.
16.
However, there is a slight difference as far as the facts involving the
two petitioners/accused persons are concerned inasmuch as in the case of
Hegin Haokip, the seized materials include one Laser Toner Cartridge
Model No. 12 A and four pieces of Laser Jet Toner Cartridges Model No.
CC 388 AC.
17.
In the charge sheet filed by the I/O, reference was made to a letter
received from Lt. Col. Pratap Rawat for C3i Consultants India Pvt. Ltd.
informing him that the shop run by the petitioner, Hegin Haokip is not
authorised to deal in products of Hewlett-Packard. Reference was also made
to the order passed by the learned Magistrate in this regard wherein vide
order 12.03.2021 the learned Magistrate has noted that the prosecution has
admitted that during the course of investigation the HP products,
particularly 4 out of 5 cartridges seized from the shop of the petitioner were
found to be genuine except one cartridge which is said to be of spurious
quality.
18.
This, according to the learned Sr. counsel is not a violation of
Section 63 of the Copyright Act as the petitioner had procured the product
from an allegedly genuine source and has not knowingly infringes any
provision of the said Copyright Act and therefore, the offence and penalty
imposed under Section 63 is not applicable to him.
19.
In support of his contention, the learned Sr. counsel has cited the
following case laws.
i)
Dr. Sharda Prasad Sinha v. State of Bihar: (1977) 1 SCC
505, para 2, 3 and 4;
ii)
State of Karnataka v. L. Muniswamy & Ors.: (1977) 2 SCC
699, para 7 and 10;
iii)
Madhavrao Jiwajirao Scindia & Ors. v. Sambhajirao
Chandrojiroa Angre & Ors: (1988) 1 SCC 692, para 7;
iv)
M/s. Pepsi Foods Ltd. & Anr. v. Special Judicial Magistrate
& Ors.: AIR (1988) SC 128, para 4, 16, 17, 28 and 29;
v)
Paramjeet Batra v. State of Uttarakhand & Ors.: (2013) 11
SCC 673, para 12.
20.
It is, therefore, prayed that the petitions referred to herein may be
allowed and the proceedings in GR Case No. 121(S) 2016 under Section
420/486/488 IPC read with Section 63 of the Copyright Act, 1957 be set
aside and quashed.
21.
Per contra, Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, learned AAG, speaking for the
State respondent has submitted that this is an application under section 482
of the Code of Criminal Procedure and as such, this Court cannot appreciate
the merits and demerits of the evidence in the case as that is outside the
scope and purview of the provision of Section 482 Cr.P.C.
22.
On the submission made by the learned Sr. counsel for the
petitioner, the learned AAG has submitted that the petitioner has firstly
questioned the locus standi of the complainant, secondly, the credibility of
the witnesses was questioned inasmuch as they are but employees of the
petitioner’s establishment, thirdly, that the FIR does not say which way the
product is spurious and fourthly, that no expert has been examined to prove
that the product is genuine or spurious.
23.
On the reliance of the petitioner on the statement of the witnesses
recorded under section 161 Cr.P.C, the learned AAG has submitted that
such statement is not admissible in law but can only be used by the defence
for contradiction at the trial when evidence is led. These statements cannot
be used in an application under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
24.
Submitting further on this point, the learned AAG contends that the
credentials of the witnesses cannot be disproved by the court. Even an
employee of a shop can be able to distinguish the genuine product from the
spurious and an expert opinion is not required to prove the prosecution’s
case. The court may believe or disbelieve the evidence adduced by the
witnesses or even the expert witness. In this regard, the court under the
provision of Section 311 Cr.P.C. can summon any person as witness and as
such, in course of trial, if so required, the court can resort to such provision
to summon an expert.
25.
On the FIR, the learned AAG has submitted that what is recorded
therein is that information was received that the petitioner along with others
have been using spurious products instead of genuine products of the
company. It is well settled that an FIR is not the final piece of evidence but
based on such information stated therein, investigation will reveal the
evidence collected which will be proved at the time of the trial.
26.
It is also submitted that from the seizure list, what is seen that some
materials have been seized and investigation has proved that these items are
spurious for which the charge sheet has been filed in this regard. Therefore,
it cannot be said that there is no case for the prosecution to proceed for trial.
27.
On the issue of locus standi, the learned AAG has submitted that
the concept of locus standi is foreign in criminal law because when a crime
is committed, it is deemed to have been committed against society at large
and as such, any person can file an FIR while reporting an offence having
been committed. Section 156 Cr.P.C. does not speak of locus standi. In this
respect, the case of A. R. Antulay v. Ramdas Sriniwas Nayak & Anr. (1984)
2 SCC 500, para 6 was referred.
28.
The learned AAG has also cited the following cases in support of
his contentions:
i)
State of Haryana & Ors. v. Bhajan Lal & Ors.: 1992 Supp (1)
SCC 335, para 102 and 103;
ii)
Kaptan Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.: (2021) 9 SCC
35, para 9.1 and 9.2.
29.
This Court has given due consideration to the case of the parties and
have also perused the petitions. An application under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
is to seek the exercise of the inherent power of the High Court, which
inherent power although exhaustive, is normally confined under three main
parameters, that is, to give effect to any order under the code of criminal
procedure, to prevent abuse of the process of any Court and lastly, to secure
the ends of justice.
30.
On an analysis of the facts and circumstances cited by the
petitioners, the exercise of the inherent powers of this Court can be tested
on the anvil of the well settled proposition of the principles thereto and the
guidelines laid down in what is now considered as one of the landmark
judgment of the Supreme Court found in the Bhajan Lal case.
31.
In the case of Bhajan Lal (supra), relied upon by the State
respondent at para 103, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has cautioned the courts
that the exercise of this power to quash a criminal proceeding is to be done
sparingly and with circumspection and that too in the rarest of rare case.
However, at para 102 of the same judgment, the Supreme Court has laid
down some illustrative guidelines in about seven categories which will
enable the High Court to weigh and balance the strength and weaknesses of
a prayer for quashing an FIR or the criminal proceedings incidental to the
filing of an FIR.
32.
Before proceeding further with the discussion on the above vis-à-
vis the case of the petitioners herein, it would be profitable to refer to one
of the cases cited by the petitioner, that is, the case of Dr. Sharda Prasad
Sinha (supra) at para 2 wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that:
“2. It is now settled law that where the allegations set out in the
complaint or the chargesheet do not constitute any offence, it is
competent to the High Court exercising its inherent jurisdiction
under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to quash the
order passed by the magistrate taking cognizance of the offence…”
33.
While examining the case of the petitioner, John Vashum, the
allegations made in the FIR is that the complainant being an authorized
representative of the HP Company and Canon Company has, during a
search and seizure operation along with the police, seized four cartridges of
Canon made, from the said petitioner. However, investigation would reveal
that the said complainant has not been able to produce any authorization
from Canon Company authorizing him to carry out such search and seizure.
The I/O has also failed to rope in any reliable witnesses from the Canon
Company to corroborate the allegations made in the said FIR that the Canon
products seized are spurious or counterfeited ones. The statement of the
witnesses which will be produced by the prosecution to prove its case are
also experts or authorized personnel who can identify only HP products and
nothing is said about their competency to identify or check if the said seized
Canon products are genuine or not.
34.
In view of the above observation on the factual aspect of the matter,
it can be safely said that since the said Canon cartridges have not pass the
test of forensic examination, as noted earlier, no expert from the Canon
Company being called upon to conduct such test, the benefit of doubt should
ultimately go to the accused/petitioner. As was held in the case of
Madhavrao Jiwajirao Scindia (supra) at para 7 of the same, wherein it was
held that:
“7….where in the opinion of the court chances of an ultimate
conviction is bleak and, therefore, no useful purpose is likely to be
served by allowing a criminal prosecution to continue, the court
may while taking into consideration the special facts of a case also
quash the proceeding even though it may be at a preliminary
stage.”
35.
In the case of Paramjeet Batra (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has held that whether essential ingredients of criminal offence are present
or not, has to be judged by the High Court.
36.
Coming back to the Bhajan Lal case, para 102(3), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held that power under Section 482 can be exercised,
inter alia, where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint and the
evidence collected in support of the same do not disclose the commission
of any offence and make out a case against the accused.
37.
In the case of Kaptan Singh (supra) cited by the State respondent,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court at para 9.1 while discussing the matter in hand
has observed that:
“9.1… From the impugned judgment and order passed by the High
Court, it does not appear that the High Court took into
consideration
the
material
collected
during
the
investigation/inquiry and even the statements recorded. If the
petition under Section 482 CrPC was at the stage of FIR in that
case the allegations in the FIR/complaint only are required to be
considered and whether a cognizable offence is disclosed or not is
required to be considered. However, thereafter when the statements
are recorded, evidence is collected and the charge-sheet is filed
after conclusion of the investigation/inquiry the matter stands on
different footing and the Court is required to consider the
material/evidence collected during the investigation. Even at this
stage also, as observed and held by this Court in a catena of
decisions, the High Court is not required to go into the merits of the
allegations and/or enter into the merits of the case as if the High
Court is exercising the appellate jurisdiction and/or conducting the
trial…
…in order to examine as to whether factual contents of FIR disclose
any cognizable offence or not, the High Court cannot act like the
investigating agency nor can exercise the powers like an appellate
court. It is further observed and held that question is required to be
examined keeping in view, the contents of FIR and prima facie
material, if any, requiring no proof. At such stage, the High Court
cannot appreciate evidence nor can it draw its own inferences from
contents of FIR and material relied on.…”
38.
This Court is well aware of the restrictions and confinement vested
in the High Court in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction which should be
exercised sparingly, carefully and with caution. However, on the factual
aspects of the case of John Vashum and the materials available on record,
it is very apparent that the prosecution will not be able to establish its case
against the said accused/petitioner as regard the seizure of the said 4
cartridges of Canon made in absence of any direct and relevant complaint
in this regard made by any authorised representative of Canon Company,
the complainant having failed to prove that he is, firstly an authorised
representative of the said Canon Company and, secondly that he has been
trained to identify counterfeit or spurious products of Canon Company.
39.
In the absence of any prima facie evidence, the observations made
in the case of Madhavrao Jiwajirao Scindia (supra) at para 7, noted above
would be relevant to the case in hand.
40.
Accordingly, it is the considered opinion of this Court that no case
can be made out against the petitioner, John Vashum and the proceedings
against him in GR Case No. 121(S) 2016 is hereby quashed.
41.
As to the case of the petitioner, Hegin Haokip, the contention of the
learned Sr. counsel that since 4 of the 5 cartridges of HP product are found
to be genuine but since the said petitioner is not the authorised dealer of
the said company, therefore the contention that no case as charged by the
prosecution, including the case under the Copyright Act can be made out
against the petitioner, cannot be accepted by this Court, since there is still
the issue of one alleged fake or spurious product of HP Company which
was seized from the possession of the petitioner and prima facie, the
antecedent of the complainant as regard his authorization and expertise in
HP products is concerned has not been controverted in any manner in
course of investigation or in the proceedings and as such, the prosecution
is to be allowed to prove the charges against the said petitioner.
42.
Therefore, in the case of Hegin Haokip this Court is not inclined to
allow the prayer made and the petitioner is to prove otherwise as regard the
charges filed against him which is a subject matter of the criminal
proceedings in GR Case No. 121(S) 2016 pending before the court of the
learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Shillong.
43.
In view of the above, these two petitions are decided accordingly.
Matter disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
23.02.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review