Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 28TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 2879 OF 2025 (INJ)
BETWEEN:
HEBRON CHURCH (REGD.)
RELIGIOUS CHARITABLE TRUST
G.B.J. 447/4, NEAR WATER TANK,
MARATHAHALLI, BENGALURU - 560 037.
REPRESENTED BY ITS VICE CHAIRMAN
MR. D. ANDREWS
S/O LATE DB RAJARATHNAM,
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
R/AT NO D-24, OLD TOWNSHIP
HAL COLONY, BENGALURU - 560 017.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. UMESH B.N, ADVOCATE)
Digitally signed
by AL BHAGYA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
AND:
1.
THE SOCIETY OF TRUSTEES OF
INDIGENOUS CHURCHES IN INDIA
H. NO 1-1-574,
GOLCONDA CROSS ROADS
HYDERABAD - 500 020.
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORIZED
REPRESENTATIVE SRI. R. VEERACHARY.
2.
THE INDIGENOUS CHURCHES IN INDIA TRUST
H. NO. 1-1-574,
GOLCONDA CROSS ROADS
HYDERABAD - 500 020.
-2NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN
AND FOUNDER TRUSTEE
SRI. F.C.S. PETER.
3.
SRI. SUNEEL BABU
S/O YESAIAH
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
R/AT NO 120, LORDS HOUSE,
2ND MAIN, RANGANATHAPURA
KAMAKSHIPALYA, BANGALORE - 560 079.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. H. MALATESH, ADVOCATE)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC,
AGAINST
THE
ORDER
DATED
11.11.2025
PASSED
ON
PRELIMINARY ISSUE (ISSUE NO.3) IN OS.NO.1525/2025 ON
THE FILE OF THE VIII ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS
JUDGE, BENGALURU, DISMISSING THE SUIT AS BARRED BY
PRINCIPLES OF RES-JUDICATA.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
ORAL JUDGMENT
The captioned appeal is by the unsuccessful plaintiff,
who is aggrieved by the order of the Trial Court passed on
preliminary issue No.3, wherein the Trial Court, while
answering preliminary issue No.3 in the affirmative, has
-3NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
held that the present suit is clearly hit by a principle of res
judicata in view of the judgment and decree passed in
O.S.No.10116/1998 and the judgment rendered by this
Court in RFA.No.1543/2023. The said order is impugned
before this Court.
2. For the sake of brevity, the ranks of the parties
are referred as per their ranking before the Trial Court.
3. The facts leading to the case are as under:
The
plaintiff–Hebron
Church
has
instituted
the
present suit in O.S.No.1525/2025 seeking the relief of
injunction simpliciter. The case set up in the plaint is that
the plaintiff claims to have constituted a trust and, on that
basis, asserts a right to manage and administer the affairs
of the Hebron Church. Proceeding on the said premise, the
plaintiff asserts that it is in lawful possession and
enjoyment of the church premises and alleges that the
defendants are unlawfully interfering with its right to
-4NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
administer the church, thereby necessitating the filing of
the present suit.
4. Upon service of summons, the defendants entered
appearance and filed their written statement, specifically
contending that the present suit is barred by the principles
of res judicata. It is pleaded that the issues sought to be
reagitated have already attained finality in view of the
judgment and decree passed in O.S.No.10116/1998, as
affirmed by this Court in RFA.No.1206/2010, and more
recently by the judgment rendered in RFA.No.1543/2023,
arising out of O.S.No.1368/1997, wherein the suit filed by
the present plaintiff was dismissed.
5. The Trial Court, after framing issues, treated Issue
No.3 as a preliminary issue. Upon consideration, the Trial
Court dismissed the suit holding that the present bare suit
for injunction is clearly hit by the doctrine of res judicata,
having regard to the final adjudication between the parties
-5NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
in O.S.No.10116/1998 and the judgment rendered by this
Court in RFA.No.1543/2023.
6.
This
appearing
for
Court
has
heard
the
plaintiff
and
the
learned
counsel
the
learned
counsel
appearing for the defendants. This Court has also carefully
perused
the
judgments
and
decrees
rendered
in
O.S.No.10116/1998 and RFA.No.1543/2023, arising out of
O.S.No.1368/1997, instituted by the present plaintiff.
7. Upon a meticulous examination of the plaint
averments in the present suit and a comparative analysis
of the findings recorded by the competent Civil Court and
this Court in the earlier rounds of litigation, the following
points arise for consideration:
(i)
injunction
Whether
the
present
suit
for
filed
by
the
plaintiff
in
O.S.No.1525/2025 is barred by the principles of
res judicata in view of the judgment and decree
rendered in O.S.No.10116/1998 and affirmed by
-6NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
this Court in RFA.No.1543/2023, arising out of
O.S.No.1368/1997?
(ii)
Whether the institution of the present
suit amounts to a misuse of the due process of
law by repeatedly filing suits on the same cause
of action, thereby constituting an abuse of
process of Court, warranting dismissal of the suit
with exemplary costs?
(iii) What order?
Finding on point No.(i):
8. Before this Court proceeds to examine the
correctness of the reasons assigned by the Trial Court in
dismissing the present suit on the ground that it is barred
by the principles of res judicata, it is both necessary and
apposite to advert to the nature, scope, and legal effect of
the declaration granted in the earlier round of litigation.
The record unmistakably discloses that the first defendant
herein had instituted a comprehensive suit for declaration
-7NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
and
consequential
injunction
in
O.S.No.10116/1998
against the present plaintiff–Hebron Church. In the said
suit, the first defendant specifically sought a declaration
with regard to the right of management and control of the
Hebron Church, as well as a declaration invalidating the
Trust Deed dated 24.04.1987, which forms the very
foundation of the present plaintiff’s claim.
9. The Civil Court, upon a full-fledged trial, was
pleased
to
decree
O.S.No.10116/1998,
recording
a
categorical finding that the Hebron Church is managed and
administered by the first defendant–society and further
holding that the Trust Deed dated 24.04.1987, on which
the present plaintiff bases its alleged right to administer
the Church, is illegal and not binding. The declaration so
granted is not incidental or collateral in nature, but is a
substantive and conclusive adjudication on the core issue
of management and control of the Hebron Church, which
lies at the heart of the present lis.
-8NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
10. The legal effect of the said declaration is that the
very juridical foundation of the present plaintiff’s claim to
administer the Hebron Church stands negated by a binding
decree passed by a competent Civil Court. The said
judgment has attained finality, having been affirmed in the
multiple rounds of litigation, and therefore operates as a
complete bar against any attempt by the present plaintiff
to reassert the very same rights, albeit in the guise of a
suit for injunction simpliciter.
11. In order to appreciate the binding nature and
operative
effect
of
the
declaration
granted
in
O.S.No.10116/1998, this Court deems it appropriate to
extract the operative portion of the judgment, which reads
as under:
"The suit of the plaintiff is decreed. It is hereby
declared that Hebron church formed under the
Trust Deed dated 24.4.87 registered as Document
No. 53 of 1987-88 in the Office of the SubRegistrar, Bangalore is illegal. It is hereby declared
further that defendants and their previes have no
-9NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
right or interest in the management and control of
the
Hebron
church
situated
at
GBJ.447/4,
Marathahalli, Bangalore 560 037. The defendants
and their previes are hereby restrained by an order
of permanent injunction from interfering in any
manner with the conduct of administration control
and management of the schedule church. The
defendants 1(a) to 1(h) are also directed to restore
the moveable properties of the church, to the
plaintiff. Under the circumstances, no order as to
costs."
EMPHASIS SUPPLIED
12. A careful reading of the operative portion of the
judgment
rendered
in
O.S.No.10116/1998
leaves
no
manner of doubt that the Trust Deed dated 24.04.1987,
on the strength of which the present plaintiff asserts its
right to control, administer, and manage the affairs of the
Hebron Church, stood conclusively negatived. The Civil
Court, by a reasoned judgment, granted a clear and
unequivocal declaration holding the said Trust Deed to be
illegal, thereby putting a complete quietus to the very
foundation of the present plaintiff’s claim. The said decree
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
was
carried
in
appeal
by
the
present
plaintiff
in
RFA.No.1206/2010, and this Court, by judgment and
decree dated 05.01.2012, dismissed the appeal and
affirmed
the
findings
recorded
by
the
Trial
Court.
Consequently, the declaration attained finality inter partes
and became binding on the present plaintiff.
13. Notwithstanding the binding nature of the decree
in O.S.No.10116/1998, as affirmed by this Court in
RFA.No.1206/2010, it is both surprising and disturbing to
note that the present plaintiff had already approached the
Civil Court by instituting O.S.No.1368/1997, seeking a
declaration that it is a religious and charitable trust and
that its Board of Trustees is entitled to administer the
affairs and activities of the Hebron Church, coupled with
an allegation that the first defendant has interfered with
such administration. The reliefs sought in the said suit,
though
couched
in
different
language,
unmistakably
disclose an attempt to reassert the very same right of
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
management and control, which already stood adjudicated
against the present plaintiff in the earlier suit.
14.
The
institution
of
present
suit
in
O.S.No.
1525/2025 , after having suffered an adverse and final
decree in O.S.No.10116/1998, coupled with reversal of
decree in OS 1368/1997 by this court in RFA 1543/2023 is
a clear instance of re-litigation on an identical cause of
action and amounts to a deliberate attempt to circumvent
the binding declaration rendered by a competent Civil
Court. Such successive suits, seeking to reopen settled
issues by merely altering the form of relief or the
phraseology of pleadings, strike at the very root of judicial
finality and certainty.
15. In order to demonstrate that the reliefs claimed
in O.S.No.1368/1997 substantially overlap with, and are
founded upon, the very same assertions which stood
conclusively negated in O.S 10116/98, this Court deems it
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
appropriate to extract the prayer of O.S.No.1368/1997, as
mentioned in the judgement, which reads as under:
"This is a suit filed by the plaintiffs against the
defendants for permanent injunction restraining
them, their agents, workers, henchmen etc., from
entering into the Hebron Church premises and
interfering in any manner with the rights of the
plaintiffs in performing the Church Services and
other religious observances of the Hebron Church at
No.GBJ 447/4, Near Water Tank, Marathahalli,
Bangalore and also for declaration that monies of
the offertory box offered by the congregation of the
Holy Services of
the
Church
and
the
monies
collected on the name of the Church are the fund of
the Hebron Church Trust."
16. Though the suit filed by the present plaintiff in
O.S.No.1368/1997
was
initially
decreed,
the
said
judgment did not attain finality. Aggrieved by the decree,
the
first
defendant
preferred
an
appeal
in
RFA.No.1543/2023, and a co-ordinate Bench of this Court,
upon a detailed re-examination of the entire matter,
allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit filed by the
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
plaintiff in O.S.No.1368/1997. While doing so, this Court
once again reiterated the settled position that the claim of
the plaintiff to exercise control and administration over the
Hebron Church is entirely founded on the Trust Deed dated
24.04.1987, which had already been declared illegal and
unenforceable in the earlier comprehensive suit filed in
O.S.No.10116/1998.
17. This Court, in RFA.No.1543/2023, categorically
held that once the very foundation of the plaintiff’s claim,
namely
the
Trust
Deed
dated
24.04.1987,
stood
invalidated by a binding decree in O.S.No.10116/1998, the
plaintiff could not be permitted to re-assert the same right
of management and administration in a subsequent suit,
either directly or indirectly. Consequently, the appeal was
allowed and the suit in O.S.No.1368/1997 was dismissed
by judgment and decree dated 09.01.2018, thereby
reaffirming the earlier declaration and restoring finality to
the adjudication between the parties.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
18. Despite having suffered two adverse judgments
in two comprehensive rounds of litigation namely O.S No.
10116/1998 and reversal of decree in O.S No. 1368/1997
by this Court in RFA No. 1543/2023 wherein the decree
granted in O.S No. 1368/1997 was reversed and the suit
filed by present plaintiff was dismissed , the present
plaintiff has once again made a feeble attempt to resurrect
the very same claim by instituting the present suit for
injunction simplicitor, ostensibly relying upon the alleged
withdrawal of a suit said to have been filed by the first
defendant in O.S.No.8628/2012. The defendants have
seriously disputed the maintainability of the said suit by
contending
that
it
was
not
instituted
with
due
authorization and in the absence of any valid Board
resolution.
19. Be that as it may, this Court is of the considered
view that the institution and subsequent withdrawal of
O.S.No.8628/2012 is wholly inconsequential and cannot,
by any stretch of imagination, dilute or nullify the binding
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
effect
of
the
comprehensive
O.S.No.10116/1998,
as
RFA.No.1206/2010,
and
decree
affirmed
by
further
rendered
this
Court
reiterated
in
in
in
RFA.No.1543/2023 arising out of O.S.No.1368/1997.
20. The cumulative effect of the above adjudications
unmistakably demonstrates that the plaintiff’s claim of a
right to manage and administer the affairs of the Hebron
Church
on
the
strength
of
the
Trust
Deed
dated
24.04.1987 stands conclusively negatived. The said Trust
Deed has been declared illegal in O.S.No.10116/1998, and
the said finding has been consistently reaffirmed in the
subsequent rounds of litigation. In view of these two
elaborate and independent judgments rendered between
the same parties, the present suit is clearly barred by the
doctrine of res judicata, and Section 11 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908, squarely applies. This Court, therefore,
has no hesitation in holding that the Trial Court was fully
justified in dismissing the suit as barred by res judicata.
Accordingly, Point No.(i) is answered in the "Affirmative".
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
Finding on Point No.(ii):
21. The record unmistakably reveals that the present
plaintiff has been consistently asserting a right to manage
and administer the Hebron Church solely on the basis of
the Trust Deed dated 24.04.1987. The said Trust Deed
was
the
subject-matter
of
adjudication
in
O.S.No.10116/1998, wherein it was categorically held to
be illegal, coupled with a clear declaration that the present
plaintiff has no right, title, or interest in the management
and control of the Hebron Church. The said judgment was
affirmed by this Court in RFA.No.1206/2010, thereby
lending finality to the declaration.
22.
Notwithstanding
the
said
final
and
binding
adjudication, the present plaintiff once again instituted
O.S.No.1368/1997, seeking substantially identical reliefs,
thereby compelling the first defendant-society to defend a
second round of litigation on the very same issues. Though
the plaintiff initially succeeded in the said suit, this Court,
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
in RFA.No.1543/2023, after adverting to the judgments
rendered in O.S.No.10116/1998 and RFA.No.1206/2010,
allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit. The judgment
rendered in RFA.No.1543/2023 has attained finality and
continues to operate against the present plaintiff.
23. The material on record further reveals that the
plaintiff has succeeded in keeping the litigation alive for
nearly 28 years, notwithstanding repeated and categorical
findings rendered against it. The first defendant-society,
despite succeeding in the first comprehensive suit, has
been repeatedly dragged into successive litigations and
compelled not only to defend proceedings before the Trial
Court but also to contest appeals before this Court,
including RFA.No.1206/2010 and RFA.No.1543/2023. Such
conduct, in the considered view of this Court, clearly
amounts to a gross abuse of the process of law.
24. Though the Trial Court was justified in answering
Issue No.3 in the affirmative and dismissing the present
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
suit by applying the principles under Section 11 CPC, it
failed to impose costs despite the plaintiff’s conduct being
demonstrably vexatious and oppressive. The present suit
for injunction simplicitor is yet another attempt to reagitate settled issues on the very same pleadings and on
the strength of the very same Trust Deed which has been
declared illegal long ago. In the considered opinion of this
Court, this is a fit case to deter such frivolous and
repetitive litigation by imposing exemplary costs.
25. Accordingly, this Court holds that the conduct of
the plaintiff warrants imposition of costs, and therefore,
the plaintiff is directed to pay costs of ₹1,00,000/(Rupees One Lakh only) to the first defendant-society.
Accordingly, point no.(ii) is answered in "Affirmative".
Finding on Point no. (iii)
26. For the forgoing reasons, this Court passes the
following:
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:4712
RFA No. 2879 of 2025
HC-KAR
ORDER
The regular first appeal is dismissed with
cost of ₹1,00,000/- payable to the first
defendant-society.
Draw decree accordingly.
Sd/(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
HDK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review