The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. application This Court does not find any reason to allow the for production of additional documents. Unreasonably long delay in filing the application for additional documents is not property explained. And in addition to that, the appeal is also dismissed for non-prosecution in the year 2012. The reasons assigned for condoning the delay in filing the application for restoring the appeal are not satisfactory. -9NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349 RSA No. 1580 of 2005
16. Though the finding of the First Appellate Court that the children of Imambee are necessary parties to the suit is erroneous, the suit is liable to be dismissed for the reasons recorded above.
17. For the aforementioned reasons, this Court does not find any substantial question of law. Accordingly, the application for condonation of delay and the application for recalling the order dismissing the appeal for non-prosecution are rejected. Since, the appeal is also considered on merits, the appeal is also dismissed on merits. Sd/(ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE) List No.: 1 Sl No.: 11 CT:PK
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349
RSA No. 1580 of 2005
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
KALABURAGI BENCH
DATED THIS THE 25TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2024
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 1580 OF 2005 (PAR)
BETWEEN:
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1.
HAZARABEE W/O SHAMEED SAB,
AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O SINDHANOOR-584 101.
2.
MUNNIMA W/O LAL AHMED,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O KALMANGI VILLAGE,TQ. SINDHANOOR-584 101.
3.
HUSSAIN BEE W/O KHAJA SAB,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O SALGUNDA VILLAGE,
TQ. SINDHANOOR-584 101.
4.
MEHABOOB BEE W/O RAMAZAN SAB,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O SINDHANOOR-584 101.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI ARUNKUMAR AMARGUNDAPPA, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
IMAM BEE W/O MEHABOOB SAB,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O PWD CAMP SINDHANOOR-584 101.
2.
BEGUM W/O MEHABOOB SAB,
-2NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349
RSA No. 1580 of 2005
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O PWD CAMP, SINDHANOOR-584 101.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI MAHANTESH PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R1 AND R2)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC
PRAYING TO ALLOW THE APPEAL BY SETTING ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE PASSED BY THE ADDITIONAL
DISTRICT JUDGE AND PO FTC-III, RAICHUR, IN RA.NO.65 OF
2005 DATED 16.04.2005, AND FURTHER THIS HON’BLE COURT
MAY BE PLEASED TO CONFIRM THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
OF THE ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE (JR.DVN) AT SINDHANOOR,
IN O.S.NO.20 OF 2002 DATED 30.06.2004.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE)
I.A. No.1/2023 is filed to condone the delay of 3068 days
in filing the application to recall the order dated 21.09.2022 by
which the appeal is dismissed for non-prosecution.
2. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents have
filed objection to the said application on the premise that the
appellants have not been diligent in prosecuting the appeal, the
application for condonation of delay is not supported by
affidavit disclosing sufficient reasons, the appellants have been
-3NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349
RSA No. 1580 of 2005
grossly negligent and they have prayed for dismissal of the
appeal.
3.
This
Court
has
considered
the
application for
condonation of delay as well as the application for recalling the
order dated 21.09.2012 along with the merits of the case.
4. The suit is one for partition and separate possession.
The suit is filed by the sisters against the brother’s two wives.
The suit is decreed holding that the plaintiffs have 2/3rd share
in the suit schedule properties. The defendants filed the appeal
before the First Appellate Court.
The First Appellate Court
allowed the appeal and set-aside the judgment and decree
passed by the Trial Court and consequently, the suit is
dismissed. Hence, the plaintiffs are before this Court.
5. As already noticed, the appeal was dismissed for nonprosecution on 21.09.2012. The appeal was not yet admitted.
6. Learned counsel Sri Arunkumar Amargundappa taking
through the facts of the case would submit that the property
originally belonged to Imamsab and his wife was Khasimabee.
It is stated that both of them died long back living behind one
-4NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349
RSA No. 1580 of 2005
son Mehabood Sab and four daughters, who are the plaintiffs.
Mehboob Sab died on 26.12.1999.
He had two wives i.e.
Begum and Imambee, who are defendants
1 and 2.
The
plaintiffs claimed that the property belonged to Imamsab and
they had 2/3 share in the suit properties after the death of
Imamsab, and his wife Khasimabee.
Thus, they claimed
partition and separate possession. The Trial Court accepted the
plaintiffs’ plea and decreed the suit.
However, the First
Appellate Court on erroneous assumption of fact and law
dismissed the suit by allowing the appeal.
7. Learned counsel for the appellants also urged that the
First Appellate Court took a view that the children of Imambee,
second wife of Mehaboob Sab are not made parties to the suit
and the suit is not maintainable for want of necessary parties.
It is his submission that the parties being the Mohammedans,
the children of Imambee cannot claim any right in the property
as long as Imambee is alive, as such, the findings that the suit
for partition is not maintainable for want of necessary parties is
erroneous.
-5NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349
RSA No. 1580 of 2005
8. It is submitted that the property originally belonged to
propositus Imamsab and he transferred the property in the
name of his son Mehaboobsab through an application which is
not a valid transfer in the eye of law. Thus, Mehaboobsab was
not the absolute owner of the property and the First Appellate
Court without noticing this fact, only on the basis of record of
rights in the name of Mehaboob sab which were later
transferred in the name of Imambee, erroneously dismissed the
suit.
9.
To substantiate his contention that the property
originally belonged to Imamsab, he has filed an application
under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure wherein
the mutation entry No.38 is produced. From the said mutation,
it is noticed that Imamsab the propositus had transferred the
property in the name of his son Mehaboobsab in the year 1973
by way of a vardhi and without there being any registered
document.
By placing reliance on this document he would
contend that Imamsab was not the absolute owner of the
property, and the plaintiffs also inherited the property.
-6NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349
RSA No. 1580 of 2005
10. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents would
contend that the appeal cannot be restored as it is dismissed
more than 10 years ago and even on merits, it is submitted
that the property was standing in the name of the 2nd
defendant Imambee when the suit was filed. The property was
transferred to Imambee by her husband when he married the
2nd defendant and the plea that the property originally belonged
to Imamsab and he transferred the property through Vardhi to
his son Mehaboobsab was not raised before the Trial Court and
no document is produced before the Trial Court and even
before the First Appellate Court, no such document is produced.
The additional document is produced in the year 2024, almost
21 years after the filing of the appeal and 12 years after the
dismissal of the appeal for non-prosecution.
It is stated that
portion of the properties have been transferred or agreed to be
transferred to third parties
after the dismissal of the appeal
for non-prosecution and no case is made to restore the appeal
or to allow the appeal on merits.
11. This Court has considered the contentions raised at
the bar and perused the records.
-7NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349
RSA No. 1580 of 2005
12. Admittedly, when the suit was filed the property was
standing in the name of Imambee, the second wife of
Mehaboobsab. Mehaboobsab died in the year 1999. The suit
was
filed
in
Amargundappa
the
year
would
2002.
urge
that
Though
the
Mr.Arunkumar
property
originally
belonged to Imamsab - the father-in-law of 2nd defendant,
before the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court no such
document is produced and the document is sought to be
produced for the first time 19 years after the filing of the
appeal to contend that the property originally belonged to
Imamsab and he through Vardhi transferred the property to his
son Mehaboobsab and said transfer is illegal.
13. It is to be noticed that the said transfer is has taken
place in the year 1973. Mohammadan law recognizes oral gift.
14. The contention of Sri.Arunkumar that the plea of oral
gift deed was not raised by the 2nd defendant and it cannot be
said that there is a oral gift in favour of Mehaboobsab cannot
be accepted for the simple reason that 2nd defendant came to
the family of Mehaboobsab in late 1990s.
Defendant No.2
cannot be expected to plead and prove the oral gift which
-8NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349
RSA No. 1580 of 2005
might have taken place in 1973 in favour of her husband. The
husband was not alive when the suit was filed. The transfer of
property in the name of her husband was not questioned in the
plaint. Thus, the defendant had no occasion to plead defending
the said transfer which has taken place in the year 1973. It is
an admitted position that from 1973 onwards the property
stood in the name of Mehaboobsab.
After the death of
Imamsab, the plaintiffs have not chosen to file a suit claiming
share in the property.
Under these circumstances, this Court
does not find any error in the judgment of the First Appellate
Court dismissing the suit on the premise that the property
stood in the name of Imambee when the suit was filed and the
property was not proved to be the joint property of the
plaintiffs and their brother Mehaboobsab.
15.
application
This Court does not find any reason to allow the
for
production
of
additional
documents.
Unreasonably long delay in filing the application for additional
documents is not property explained. And in addition to that,
the appeal is also dismissed for non-prosecution in the year
2012. The reasons assigned for condoning the delay in filing
the application for restoring the appeal are not satisfactory.
-9NC: 2024:KHC-K:7349
RSA No. 1580 of 2005
16.
Though the finding of the First Appellate Court that
the children of Imambee are necessary parties to the suit is
erroneous, the suit is liable to be dismissed for the reasons
recorded above.
17. For the aforementioned reasons, this Court does not
find
any
substantial
question
of
law.
Accordingly,
the
application for condonation of delay and the application for
recalling the order dismissing the appeal for non-prosecution
are rejected.
Since, the appeal is also considered on merits,
the appeal is also dismissed on merits.
Sd/(ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE)
JUDGE
BRN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 11
CT:PK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review