Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC040008352024
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : IA(C)/192/2026
Hayeng Mangfi
Age: 49 Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tangu Mangfi
resident of Nari Camp Village
PO Sawa
PS Chayang Tajo
East Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
Kompu Dolo
Age: 62 Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tagung Rebe
resident of Village Rebe
PO Chayang Tajo
East Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
-----------Advocate for : Mudang Opo
Advocate for : Takar Bagang appearing for Kompu Dolo: Advocate appearing for
respectively.
Linked Case : Election Pet./1/2024
Kompu Dolo Son of Late Tagung Rebe, resident of Village Rebe, PO and PS Chayang
Tajo, East Kameng District, Arunachal Pradesh 790102
VERSUS
Hayeng Mangfi Son of Late Tangu Mangfi, resident of Nari Camp Village, PO Sawa,
PS Chayang Tajo, East Kameng District, Arunachal Pradesh 790102
Page No.# 2/11
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
Advocates for the applicant
: Mr. S. K. Deori
Mr. M. Opo
Advocates for the Opposite Party: Mr. S. Dutta, Sr. Adv.
Mr. R. Shekhar
1. Date on which judgment is reserved: 09.09.2026
2. Date of pronouncement of judgment: 28.09.2026
3. Whether the pronouncement is of the operative part of the judgment? NA
4. Whether the full judgment has been pronounced?
YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER(CAV)
Heard Mr. Sandi K. Deori, learned counsel assisted by Mr. Mudang Opo,
learned counsel for the applicant/returned candidate. Also heard Mr. Sishir
Dutta, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. R. Shekhar, learned counsel for
the Opposite Party/election petitioner.
2.
The applicant/returned candidate has filed the present application under
Order XI Rule 14 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
seeking direction for preservation and production of the CCTV footage relating
to the scrutiny of nomination papers conducted on 28.03.2024 in the office of
the
Returning
Officer,
9th
Chayang
Tajo
(ST)
Assembly
Constituency,
particularly for the period from 11:00 A.M. to 3:00 P.M.
3.
Notice of the application was issued earlier. The Opposite party/Election
petitioner has filed his objection/reply.
4.
Learned counsel for the Opposite Party/Election Petitioner has opposed
the application primarily on the ground that the application is misconceived
and not maintainable under Order XI Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908. It is contended that the District Election Officer, from whom production
Page No.# 3/11
of CCTV footage is sought, is not a party to the election petition and therefore
no direction can be issued against him under Order XI Rule 14 of Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908.
5.
It is further submitted that the application does not disclose the source or
basis for the assertion that the entire scrutiny proceedings were continuously
recorded by CCTV or videography. According to the election petitioner, no
particulars have been furnished regarding the number or location of the
cameras, the system used for recording, the agency operating the system, the
retention period of the recording.
6.
Learned senior counsel for the election petitioner further submits that the
respondent/returned candidate did not plead in his written statement about
the alleged CCTV recording, DVR, data logs or other electronic evidence and
did not refer to such material in his list of document/material. It is therefore
contended that the present application is an attempt to introduce a new
factual foundation and to fill up a lacuna in the defence at the belated stage. It
is also submitted that the applicant has not identified which particular pleading
in the written statement is sought to be proved by the CCTV footage and that
the expression "exact timeline and occurrences" is vague and omnibus. The
prayer for the entire CCTV footage from 11:00 A.M. to 3:00 P.M., along with
the DVR/storage drive, data logs and master storage, is stated to be
excessively broad and amounts to a roving and fishing enquiry.
7.
Learned senior counsel further submits that the prayer for a certificate
under Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 is premature and
that the issue of admissibility and proof of electronic evidence can arise at the
appropriate stage. Reliance has been placed upon the decisions reported in
(2010) 1 SCC 466 [Kattinokkula Murali Krishna vs. Veeramalla Koteswara Rao &
Ors.] and (2000) 8 SCC 191 [ Ravinder Singh vs. Janmeja Singh & Ors.],
particularly the observations regarding the necessity of material facts and the
Page No.# 4/11
impermissibility of introducing a new case through evidence. Learned senior
counsel while referring to the above cases submits that, it is an established
proposition that no evidence can be led on a plea not raised in the pleadings
and that no evidence can cure defect in the pleadings.
8.
Learned senior counsel also submitted that the election petition is
required to be tried expeditiously and that the present application would
unnecessarily delay the proceedings. The election petitioner therefore seeks
dismissal of the application with costs.
9.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the applicant/ respondent submits
that the application was filed well before completion of the petitioner's
evidence and, therefore, the allegation that the application is a belated
attempt to fill up a lacuna is factually incorrect. Learned counsel for the
applicant submits that the issue in the election petition pertains to the scrutiny
and alleged improper acceptance of the nomination paper of the returned
candidate. Therefore, he submits that the CCTV footage sought for relates
directly to the said scrutiny proceedings. It is submitted that the applicant is
not seeking to introduce any new issue in the election petition filed by the
election petitioner. It seeks production of the best available contemporaneous
record relating to an issue already arising from the election petition.
10. Learned counsel for the applicant has also drawn the attention of this
Court to the evidence of PW-6, the Returning Officer. According to the
applicant, the PW-6 has stated during his examination at para-112 that the
proceedings of scrutiny were recorded under CCTV surveillance. It is
submitted that, in view of the said statement of the Returning Officer (PW-6),
the existence of the CCTV recording of the scrutiny is not merely a matter
concerns only upon the applicant's assertion.
11.
Learned counsel for the applicant further submits that the electronic
Page No.# 5/11
record/CCTV footage comes under documents. It is in the custody of the
election authorities and the same cannot ordinarily be obtained by a private
party by way of RTI application. According to the learned counsel, the
applicant is therefore seeking a direction of the Court for production of the
record. It is also submitted that the relevant electronic record constitutes a
document/electronic record and it can be produced before the Court pursuant
to the direction of the Court. He further submits that the question of the
admissibility of such document/material and proof may be considered at the
appropriate stage.
12. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and the rival submissions
have been considered.
13. Under Section 87 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, every
election petition is to be tried by the High Court, subject to the provisions of
the Act and the Rules made thereunder, as nearly as may be in accordance
with the procedure applicable to the trial of suits under the Code of Civil
Procedure. Thus, the procedural powers of the Court under the CPC, insofar as
they are consistent with the special provisions governing election petitions, are
available for securing relevant evidence/document in connection with the case.
14. Order XI Rule of 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, empowers the
Court, during the pendency of the proceedings, to direct production of
documents relating to any matter in question in the proceedings/suit,
however, subject to the requirements of the provision. It is well settled that
the power is discretionary and that the Court must consider the relevance,
necessity and justness of production of the evidence. At the same time, in an
election petition, the Court must not permit a party to embark upon a roving
enquiry for discovering a new ground or to fish out material in support of a
case which has no foundation in the pleadings.
Page No.# 6/11
15.
Here the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Basanagouda v. Dr. S.B.
Amarkhed, reported in (1992) 2 SCC 612, may be referred, whereby, while
considering an application for production of election records under Order XI
Rule 14 and Order XVI Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, read with
Section 87 of the Representation of the People Act, it recognizes that the
Court possesses power to summon/order for production of the relevant
election records. But cautioned, that the discretion must be exercised having
regard to the expediency, justness and relevancy of the documents to the
matter in issue. The Supreme Court also cautioned against permitting a roving
enquiry to fish out grounds which have no adequate foundation in the
pleadings.
16. The principle relating to pleadings relied upon by the election petitioner is
undoubtedly well settled. A party cannot, by means of evidence, introduce a
new case which has no foundation in its pleadings. However, there is a
distinction between introducing a new material fact and producing evidence in
support of an existing issue. Every piece of evidence by which a pleaded fact is
sought to be established need not necessarily be specifically pleaded in the
pleadings. What is impermissible is to introduce altogether a new factual
foundation, the evidence which was not already in issue arising for
adjudication in the matter.
17.
In the present case, the controversy regarding the scrutiny of the
nomination paper on 28.03.2024 is admittedly part of the election dispute.
The applicant, through the present application, is not seeking, to introduce an
entirely independent ground concerning an unrelated occurrence. The CCTV
footage is sought to be produce in relation to the very scrutiny proceedings
which are already the subject matter of the election petition.
18.
The applicant has drawn the attention of the Court to the evidence of
PW-6, the Returning Officer, who has stated, during his examination, that the
Page No.# 7/11
scrutiny proceedings were recorded under CCTV surveillance. In view of the
deposition of PW-6 in this regard, the factual foundation regarding the
existence of such recording is not only based merely upon an assertion made
by the applicant/respondent for the first time in the interlocutory application.
The statement is material for the limited purpose of determining whether
production and preservation of the electronic record as prays for ought to be
directed. The objection that the applicant did not specifically plead in his
written statement that CCTV footage existed cannot, in the circumstances of
the present case, by itself defeat the application. The existence or otherwise of
the CCTV footage is essentially a matter directly related to the availability of
evidence relating to the scrutiny proceedings. The applicant cannot himself be
expected to produce an electronic record which is stated to be in the custody
of the election authorities.
19.
The objection that the District Election Officer is not a party to the
election petition also requires consideration. Strictly speaking, Order XI Rule
14 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, contemplates production by a party of
documents in his possession or power. Therefore, to the extent the prayer
seeks to compel a non-party authority solely under Order XI Rule 14 of the
CPC, the provision may not, by itself, furnish the complete procedural basis.
However, the Court trying an election petition is not powerless to summon
relevant public records from the concerned election authority. The Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908, itself contains provisions for production of documents
by persons who are not parties, and the Court also possesses necessary
incidental powers to secure material evidence relevant to the adjudication of
the election petition. In the case of Basanagouda(supra), the Supreme Court
considered an application seeking production of election documents from the
District Election Officer, invoking Order XI Rule 14 read with Order XVI Rule 6
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, and Section 87 of the Representation of
the People Act, 1951. Thus, the mere fact that the District Election Officer is
Page No.# 8/11
not a party cannot, by itself, be treated as an absolute bar against production
of a relevant election record.
20. The present case is also distinguishable from a situation where a party
seeks production merely on the basis of conjecture or suspicion. The
application was filed before completion of the petitioner's evidence. During the
petitioner's evidence, the Returning Officer (PW-6), has apparently stated that
the scrutiny proceedings were recorded under CCTV surveillance. These
circumstances provide a factual basis for directing preservation and production
of the record, if it is in fact available.
21. The objection that the period from 11:00 A.M. to 3:00 P.M. has been
selected without any basis also does not, in the fact and circumstances of the
case, warrant outright rejection of the application. The period corresponds to
the scrutiny proceedings referred to in the application. However, the
production shall be confined to the CCTV recording concerning the relevant
room/place and the scrutiny proceedings on 28.03.2024 and it shall not
become an unrestricted search of unrelated electronic material recorded of the
entire day.
22. As regards the prayer for production of the DVR/storage drive, data logs
and master storage, this Court is of the view that at this stage it is
unnecessary to direct wholesale production of every storage device or every
data log. The immediate requirement is to secure the relevant original
electronic record and obtain its production before the Court in a manner
preserving its integrity. If any dispute subsequently arises regarding the
source, completeness or integrity of the footage, the Court may issue further
appropriate directions.
23.
The prayer seeking a certificate under Section 63 of the Bharatiya
Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 also does not require rejection of the application.
Page No.# 9/11
The question whether the certificate furnished is legally sufficient, and
whether the electronic record is ultimately admissible and worthy of reliance,
are matters to be considered at the appropriate stage. At this stage, the Court
is concerned only with preservation and production of the record.
24.
The contention regarding delay in the context of the requirement of
expeditious disposal of election petitions has also been considered. However,
the present application was not filed after completion of the petitioner's
evidence. It was filed earlier and was specifically directed to be taken up after
completion of the petitioner's evidence. Therefore, the present consideration
of the application cannot fairly be described as an attempt by the applicant to
deliberately delay the proceedings. At the same time, the directions herein
shall be complied with within a fixed time so that the trial is not unnecessarily
prolonged.
25. The Court is, therefore, satisfied that the CCTV recording, if available, is
potentially relevant to a matter already arising in the election petition and that
the preservation and production of the same would assist the Court in the
proper adjudication of the dispute. The production of the record, however,
shall not be construed as permitting either party to travel beyond the
pleadings or as conferring any right to reopen evidence as a matter of course.
26. Accordingly, the objection filed by the election petitioner is rejected to the
extent indicated above, and the application filed by the respondent/applicant
under Order XI Rule 14 read with Section 151 of CPC is allowed in part, with
the following directions:
(i).
The District Election Officer, East Kameng District, Seppa, shall
forthwith ascertain, secure and preserve the CCTV/video recording,
if available, relating to the proceedings of scrutiny of nomination
papers conducted in the office/room/hall of the Returning Officer,
Page No.# 10/11
9-Chayang Tajo (ST) Assembly Constituency, on 28.03.2024,
particularly for the period from 11:00 a.m. to 3:00 P.M.
(ii).
The concerned authority shall produce before this Court the
relevant CCTV footage in the original/native electronic format in
which it is maintained, or in such other electronic format as
preserves the original recording and its integrity, together with a
readily viewable copy.
(iii). Along with the electronic record, the concerned authority shall
furnish particulars of the CCTV system/camera, DVR/NVR or other
storage medium from which the footage has been retrieved, the
date/time period covered by the recording, and the manner in
which the recording has been retrieved and preserved.
(iv).
The concerned authority shall also state whether the recording
produced is the original electronic record or a copy thereof and
whether the original storage medium containing the relevant
recording is still available.
(v). The original DVR/NVR/storage medium, if available and containing
the relevant recording, shall be preserved intact and shall not be
overwritten, altered or tampered with until further orders of this
Court.
(vi).
The electronic record may be accompanied by the certificate
contemplated
under
Section
of
the
Bharatiya
Sakshya
Adhiniyam, 2023, as applicable. The sufficiency of such certificate
and the admissibility and evidentiary value of the electronic record
are left open for consideration at the appropriate stage.
27. The District Election Officer shall comply with the aforesaid directions and
Page No.# 11/11
produce the relevant electronic record before this Court on or before the next
date of listing.
28. It is made clear that the parties shall be at liberty to raise all legally
permissible objections when the electronic record is sought to be relied upon
in evidence.
29. This interlocutory application stands disposed of in the above terms.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review