Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/22
GAHC010247082019
2026:GAU-AS:9360
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7757/2019
HASINA BEGUM
W/O- GIAS UDDIN AHMED, VILL- 1 NO. PATAHARTARI, P.S. NAGARBERA,
P.O. NAGARBERA, DIST- KAMRUP (R), ASSAM, PIN- 781127
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 6 ORS.
REP. BY THE SECY. OF THE GOVT. OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF HOME
AFFAIRS, SHASTRI BHAWAN, TILAK MARG, NEW DELHI-01
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
REP. BY THE COMM. AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
HOME DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY-06
3:THE DY. COMMISSIONER
KAMRUP (R)
AMINGAON
P.O. AMINGAON
DIST- KAMRUP (R)
ASSAM
PIN- 781031
4:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
KAMRUP (R)
AMINGAON
P.O. AMINGAON
DIST- KAMRUP (R)
ASSAM
PIN- 781031
Page No.# 2/22
5:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
THROUGH ITS SECY. NIRBACHAN BHAVAN
NEW DELHI-01
6:THE STATE CO-ORDINATOR
NATIONAL REGISTRAR OF CITIZENS (NRC)
ASSAM
BHANGAGARH
GHY-05
7:THE DISTRICT ELECTION OFFICER
KAMRUP (R)
AMINGAON
P.O. AMINGAON
DIST- KAMRUP (R)
ASSAM
PIN- 78103
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN
Advocate for the petitioner(s):
Mr. N. Islam
Advocate for the respondent(s): Ms. S. Baruah, learned CGC:
Mr. A.I. Ali, learned SC,ECI;
Mr. J. Payeng, learned SC
F.T. matters and N.R.C
Mr. P. Sarmah, learned
Additional Senior Advocate
Date on which judgment was reserved :18.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:26.06.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the :
operative part of the judgment?:NA
Whether the full judgment has been :Yes
pronounced?
Page No.# 3/22
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
(Shamima Jahan, J.)
Heard Mr. N. Islam, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Ms. S. Baruah,
learned CGC; Mr. A.I. Ali, learned standing counsel for the ECI; Mr. J. Payeng,
learned standing counsel for the FT matters and NRC; and Mr. P. Sarmah,
learned Additional Senior Govt. Advocate for respondents.
2.
The petitioner by this application has endeavored to invoke the
extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India praying for a writ in the nature of certiorari for setting aside the opinion
dated 15.06.2018 (sic) passed by the learned Member Foreigners Tribunal,
Kamrup (Rural) No.1 in GFT (R) Case No. 25/2018, corresponding to IM(DT)
Case No. 423/2001, by which the petitioner was declared as a Foreigner of post,
25.03.1971 stream.
Facts
3.
It is the petitioner's case that Superintendent of Police (B), Kamrup
instituted the IM(DT) Case No. 423/2001 against the petitioner and on the basis
of the enquiry report of the Enquiry Officer, the matter was forwarded to
IM(DT), Nalbari for determination of the nationality of the petitioner. Thereafter,
in compliance with the judgment passed in Sarbananda Sonowal Vs. Union of
India reported in 2005 (5) SCC 665 case, the matter was sent back to
Foreigners Tribunal, Kamrup (R) No.1 and the said case was registered for
disposal. The Tribunal served a notice upon the petitioner on 18.12.2018 by
showing her father's name as Nayeb Ali. The petitioner on receipt of the said
Page No.# 4/22
notice, appeared before the Tribunal and filed her written statement. She
exhibited 27 numbers of documents during the said proceeding.
4.
Statements in brief made by the petitioner in her written
statement:
(i)
The petitioner stated that she is the daughter of late Gias Uddin Mondal
and is the wife of Gias Uddin Ahmed and that her place of birth is village
Nayapara, Part-I, P.O. Bahati, P.S. Matia in the district of Goalpara, Assam.
(ii)
The petitioner stated that she was born on 26.01.1985 and that she did
her schooling at Nayapara High Madrassa at her place of birth.
(iii)
The petitioner got married with Gias Uddin Ahmed on 19.01.2001 and
since her marriage, she has been permanently residing at village No.1.
Palahartari, P.S. Nagarbera in the district of Kamrup, Assam.
(iv)
The grandfather of the petitioner, namely Karim Mandal @ Abdul Karim
Mandal was residing at her birth place and that he had moveable and
immovable property in the said district i.e. Goalpara and that Khatian being
Khatian No.73, Tauji No. 54 of Habraghat in the district of Goalpara was issued
in his name in the year 1960-1961.
(v)
Her father namely Gias Uddin Mondal was enrolled in the NRC for the year
1951.
(vi) Her grandfather's name appeared in the voters list of 1966, 1970 and 1979
and that further, her father's name was also shown in the subsequent voters list.
(vii)
After her marriage in 2001, she appeared in the voters list of 2005 along
Page No.# 5/22
with her husband namely Gias Uddin Ahmed and also that in the subsequent
voters list, her name appeared.
(viii) She also appeared in the draft NRC list dated 30.07.2018 along with her
family members.
(ix)
Her grandfather namely Abdul Karim Mandal had a property within the
Goalpara area, out of which he sold a portion in the year 1963, 1968 as well as
in 1971 by way of sale deeds.
(x)
Her father namely Gias Uddin Mondal also had a landed property within
the Goalpara area and had sold a portion of it in 1984 by way of sale deed.
(xi)
After the death of her father, she had acquired the land property and her
name was mutated in the land records, being the legal heir of her father.
(xii) She placed a certificate issued by the Village Head Man i.e. Gaonburah of
Palahartari Gaon, wherein it was stated that the said Gaonburah knew her and
that she was staying at the stated matrimonial place.
(xiii) She has in her possession the Elector voter ID issued by the Election
Commission of India.
(xiv) She declares that there is some mistake in the spelling of her name but
she is the one namely Hasina Begum, daughter of Gias Uddin Mondal and that
some mistakes were also there with regard to her father's name.
(xv)
She was suspected to be a foreigner and a case was referred but her
other family members were not classified as foreigners.
Page No.# 6/22
Examination of Defence Witnesses
5.
Apart from the aforesaid written statement, the petitioner had filed her
evidence on affidavit as DW1 and in the said affidavit she had reiterated most of
the statements which she had stated in the written statement. The petitioner
exhibited the following documents for consideration by the Tribunal:
i.
Exhibit No.1, certificate issued by Secretary,
Sidhabari Gaon Panchayat.
ii.
Exhibit No.2, certificate issued by Secretary,
Sidhabari Gaon Panchayat.
iii.
Exhibit No.3, School Certificate issued by the
Superintendent, Nayapara High Madrassa.
iv.
Exhibit No.4, Khatian No.73, which was issued to
her grandfather.
v.
Exhibit No.A, the NRC details in respect of her
father and grandfather of the year 1951.
vi.
Exhibit No.5, voters list of 1966, wherein her
grandfather's name was reflected as well as her father's.
vii.
Exhibit No.6, voters list of 1970, wherein her
grandfather's name was reflected as well as her father's.
viii.
grandmother.
Exhibit No.7, voters list of 1979 showing father with
Page No.# 7/22
ix.
Exhibit No.8, voters list of 1985 showing father with
x.
Exhibit No.9, voters list of 1989, showing her
mother.
parent's name.
xi.
Exhibit No.10, voters list of 1993, showing father's
name along with his mother.
xii.
Exhibit No.11, voters list of 1997 showing father's
name along with his wife/mother.
xiii.
Exhibit No.12, voters list of 2005 showing father's
name with mother and brother.
xiv.
Exhibit No.13, voters list of 2010, showing father's
name with mother and brother.
xv.
Exhibit No.14, marriage certificate.
xvi.
Exhibit No.15, voters list of 2005, showing her
name with her husband.
xvii.
Exhibit No.16, voters list of 2010, showing her
name with her husband.
xviii.
Exhibit No.17, voters list of 2015, showing her name
with her husband.
xix.
Exhibit No.B, voters list of 2019, showing her name
with her husband.
Page No.# 8/22
xx.
Exhibit No.C, draft affidavit copy of NRC, 2018.
xxi.
Exhibit No.18, sale deed of 1963.
xxii.
Exhibit No.19, sale deed of 1968.
xxiii.
Exhibit No.20, sale deed of 1971.
xxiv.
Exhibit No.21, copy of the patta.
xxv.
Exhibit No.22, copy of the patta.
xxvi.
Exhibit No.23, sale deed of 1984.
xxvii.
Exhibit No.24, the copy of zammabandi.
xxviii.
Exhibit No.25, certificate issued by Gaonburah.
xxix.
Exhibit No.26, the voter ID card of the petitioner.
xxx.
Exhibit No.27, the affidavit sworn by the petitioner
declaring anomalies in the name of herself and her father.
6.
The petitioner was cross-examined by the prosecution and during the said
examination, she stated that her grandfather expired before she was born and
that her father expired in the year 2015 and that her mother is still alive. She
stated that in the voters list of 1966, the name of her grandfather, grandmother
and uncles were enlisted. She further stated that she did not go to receive the
GaonBurah certificate and that it was received by her mother and further that
Exhibit No.2 i.e. Gaon Panchayat certificate was received by her younger
brother. She further stated that she does not know in which year, she took
admission in High Madrassa and that she studied in Nayapara High Madrassa till
Page No.# 9/22
1999. She stated that she received a school certificate from the said High
Madrassa in the year 2013. She also stated that she got married when she was
17 years of age and that her father had received a Kazi certificate. She
thereafter stated that her father's name was inserted in the land documents and
that her father had given her one katha land by way of gift. However, she stated
that she does not know as to how her father obtained the said land.
7.
Apart from the petitioner being examined as DW1, there are more
defence witnesses and they are DW2, the husband of the petitioner, DW3,
Sonowar Rahman, who was working as Lower Division Assistant in Nayapar High
Madrassa School, DW4, Sarbesh Ali, the Sarkari Gaonburah and DW5, Bilifang
Basumatary, the Secretary of Sidhabari Gaon Panchayat.
8.
The husband of the petitioner was examined as DW2 and he stated that
he got married with the petitioner on 19.01.2001 and since the day of his
marriage, he and petitioner has been permanently residing at village No.1,
Palahartari, P.S. Nagarbera in the district of Kamrup. He further stated few of
the statements already made by his wife i.e. the petitioner. He also exhibited
few documents which were already exhibited by the petitioner. This witness
was cross-examined and during the said examination, he stated inter alia that
his father in law's name was Gias Uddin Mondal and that his father in law died
in the year 2015. He also stated that he did not know as to when the name of
his father in law appeared in the voters list for the first time and he expressed
his ignorance as to when his father in law entered India and other facts related
to his father in law.
9.
DW3, who was working as the LDA of Nayapara High Madrassa stated that
the petitioner took admission in the said Madrassa in Class-VIII in the year 2000
Page No.# 10/22
and that Exhibit No.3 i.e. school certificate was issued by the then
Superintendent of the School on 23.02.2003 namely Mohabbat Ali Mandal. The
said witness was cross-examined and during the said examination, he stated
that he was working as an LDA in the school since first day of February, 2016
and that the then Superintendent of the school, who issued the certificate
retired on 31.01.2019 and that he had not carried the register book of issuing
certificate on the day of his examination. He further stated that he had not seen
the certificate and that he has carried the school register book with him on the
said day. He also stated that he did not know whether petitioner studied in the
said school and that he had submitted only on the strength of the permission
letter as well as the authority letter given to him by the Superintendent of the
school.
10.
The Government Gaonburah was examined as DW4 and he stated before
the Tribunal that he had given the certificate to the petitioner and that the
father of the petitioner was Gias Uddin Ahmed. He also stated that petitioner
got married and she has been staying in the place where he resides. This
witness was cross-examined and during the said examination, he stated that he
had issued the certificate but he had not brought the issue register with him. He
also stated that he joined as a Gaonburah in 1987. He stated that while issuing
the certificate, he had not verified the same with any office from where the said
papers were issued but only on the information given by the petitioner, he had
issued the same.
11.
Gaon Panchayat Secretary was examined as DW5 and he stated before
the Tribunal that he had issued the certificate to the petitioner but then he
stated that he had not written with his own hand, the contents of the same and
Page No.# 11/22
that he had issued the certificate on the information given by the mother of the
petitioner. He also stated that he has no personal knowledge about the contents
and it was only based on the information given by the petitioner and her
mother. He further stated that on the basis of the voters list shown to him by
the petitioner, he prepared the certificate.
These are the evidence produced
by the petitioner to establish her citizenship, in this case. The learned Tribunal
had considered the said evidences and had given the following findings:
i)
There were many discrepancies in the names of the petitioner as well as
her projected father, which was sought to be clarified by the petitioner by filing
an affidavit but the same having no evidentiary value was not considered by the
Tribunal.
ii)
The petitioner had not submitted the birth certificate.
iii)
In the evidence of the petitioner, specially during her examination, the
facts were contradicted and the oral evidences and documentary evidences did
not support her statement.
iv)
None of the family members of the petitioner except her husband had
appeared as a witness in the instant case.
v)
The petitioner as such has failed to establish the linkage with her
projected father and projected grandfather, whose names are stated to have
appeared in the voters list of 1966 and 1970 as well as patta and sale deeds,
respectively.
12.
Considering the entire materials on record, the learned Tribunal was of the
considered opinion that evidence of the petitioner is not trustworthy and that
Page No.# 12/22
she had failed to discharge her burden of proving herself as an Indian Citizen. It
was further held by the learned Tribunal that the petitioner having failed on all
counts was stated to have entered into the Country illegally after 25.03.1971
from the specified territory and the petitioner was declared as a Foreigner.
Submissions
13.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner had
exhibited the voters list of 1966 wherein her grandfather appeared as a voter
namely Abdul Karim Mandal, son of late Saha Mamud Mandal at serial no.127.
He further submitted that the father of the petitioner also appeared in the said
voters list at serial no. 131. Thereafter, he relied on the voters list of 1989,
wherein the petitioner's fathers name was shown along with her grandmother
namely Sundari Beya and further that the father of the petitioner was shown as
son of Karim Mandal. He thereafter relied on subsequent voters list where
similar position surfaced. He thereafter relied on the voters list where the name
of the petitioner appeared along with her husband namely Gias Uddin, son of
Lokman. He thereafter relied on the zamabandi exhibited as Exhibit No.24, by
which it was reflected that as per order dated 27.11.2018, the legal heirs of late
Gias Uddin Mandal were included and their names were mutated as the
inheritors of the said land situated at village Nayapara Part-I, Mouza: Matia in
the district of Goalpara. He placed that the name of the petitioner namely
Hasina Begum was mutated in the land of her father after his death. He also
relied on the certificate issued by the Government Gaonburah by which it was
stated that petitioner, wife of Gias Uddin Ahmed had seen staying at the place
mentioned in the said certificate. He also placed reliance on the voter ID card as
well as the certificate issued by the Secretary, Gaon Panchayat. He further
Page No.# 13/22
submitted that the petitioner by filing a written statement as well as by giving
evidence on affidavit had proved her case that she is the citizen of India.
14.
On the other hand, Mr. J. Payeng, learned Standing Counsel for FT and
Border matters submitted that the petitioner could not establish the link with
her ancestor before the cut off date of 25.03.1971. He stated that although the
name of the projected father of the petitioner appeared along with the
projected grandfather of the petitioner in the voters list of 1966 but she could
not place any voters list in which her name appeared along with her father. He
also submits that the petitioner had not stated about her siblings in the written
statement neither had stated in her evidence on affidavit nor in the crossexamination. In absence of the same, she could not establish her identity as an
Indian Citizen. Further he submits that the certificate issued by the Gaonburah
had the State Emblem and the same cannot be relied on and also due to the
fact that the Gaonburah had issued the certificate only on the basis of the
information given by the petitioner and her mother. As far as the school
certificate is concerned, the learned Counsel submits that the issuing authority
was not examined and that the LDA of the said school had stated that he did
not bring the school register for issuing certificates and that he had submitted
only on the authorization given by the Superintendent of the School. He also
submits that in absence of the names revealed by the petitioner with respect to
her brothers and sisters, zamabandi cannot be believed.
15.
These are the submissions of learned Counsel for the parties.
Analysis and Findings
16. At the outset, this Court would like to deal with the written statement
Page No.# 14/22
submitted by the petitioner, the same being the basic document to prove a case
under Section 9 of the Foreigners Act. In the written statement filed by the
petitioner as has been stated above, the pleadings only in respect of the voters
list wherein the projected father and the projected grandfather of the petitioner
were shown as voters as well as the voters list, where the petitioner was shown
along with her husband, were highlighted. In the said written statement, the
alleged landed property belonging to the projected grandfather and projected
father of the petitioner were also mentioned and further that sale affected in the
year 1963, 1968, 1971 and 1984. The further statements made in the written
statement was that the petitioner was the legal heir to her projected father and
that land was mutated in her name and further that she possessed certificates
issued by the Gaonburah and Secretary, Gaon Panchayat as well as the elector
voter ID card. There are no pleadings in the said written statement to the effect
as to who were the brothers and sisters of the petitioner, the place of birth and
citizenship of the parents of the proceedee as well as the details about other
relatives etc.
In Sarbananda Sonowal Vs. Union of India reported in 2005 (5) SCC
665, the Hon’ble Supreme Court had held as follows:
"There is good and sound reason for placing the burden of proof upon the person
concerned who asserts to be a citizen of a particular country. In order to establish
one's citizenship, normally he may be required to give evidence of (i) his date of birth
(ii) place of birth (iii) name of his parents (iv) their place of birth and citizenship. Some
times the place of birth of his grand parents may also be relevant like u/s 6-A(1)(d) of
the Citizenship Act. All these facts would necessarily be within the personal knowledge
of the person concerned and not of the authorities of the State. After he has given
evidence on these points, the State authorities can verify the facts and can then lead
evidence in rebuttal, if necessary. If the State authorities dispute the claim of
citizenship by a person and assert that he is a foreigner, it will not only be difficult but
almost impossible for them to first lead evidence on the aforesaid points. This is in
accordance with the underlying policy of Section 106 of the Evidence Act which says
that when any fact is especially within the knowledge of any person, the burden of
Page No.# 15/22
proving that fact is upon him."
17.
Further this Court in Rashminara Begum, wife of Manirul Islam Vs.
Union of India reported in 2017 (4) GLT 346, this Court had held as follows:
"Written statement is the basic statement of defence of a proceedee
before the Foreigners Tribunal. Keeping in mind the mandate of Section 9
of the Foreigners Act,1946, it is incumbent upon the proceedee to
disclose at the first instance itself i.e., in his written statement all
relevant facts specially within his knowledge having a material bearing
on his claim to citizenship of India. Material facts pleaded in the written
statement are thereafter required to be proved by adducing cogent and
reliable evidence. It is also trite that a party cannot traverse beyond the
pleadings made in the written statement."
Admittedly, the relevant facts specially within the knowledge of the
petitioner which has a material bearing on the case of the petitioner to
establish her citizenship, were not placed in the written statement filed in
the present case.
18.
The endeavor by the petitioner to substantiate her claim for citizenship
was made by placing the school certificate which was issued by the then
Superintendent of the School namely Mohabbat Ali. However, it is seen that the
Lower Division Assistant, who was examined to prove the contents of the school
certificate stated as DW3 that he was not the issuing authority and that he had
not carried the register book for issuing certificate on the date when his
examination was conducted. It is no res integra that to prove a certificate and to
prove the contents of the certificates are two different things. It has been held
by this Court that in order to prove the contents of the certificate, the issuing
authority should be examined. In the instant case, the Lower Division Assistant
was examined for the prove of the contents of the certificate but he was not the
issuing authority as required under the law.
Page No.# 16/22
19.
The petitioner further relied on the certificate issued by the Secretary of
the Gaon Panchayat, who had again stated before the Tribunal that he had
issued the certificate only on the basis of the information given by the petitioner
and her mother and also on perusal of the voters list. The same do not induce
any authenticity to the said certificate issued by the Secretary, Gaon Panchayat.
20.
The further, certificate issued by the Government Gaonburah also does
not create confidence in view of two reasons, first: A bare perusal of the said
certificate shows that the State Emblem was used in the said certificate, which
again is impermissible under the law. Secondly, the Gaonburah, who was
examined as DW4 had stated that while issuing the certificate, he had not
verified with any Government records and that he had issued the same only on
the information given by the petitioner.
21.
This Court in Afuja Begum @ Afruja Begum Vs. Union of India
passed in W.P.(C) No. 7340 of 2016 delivered the judgment holding inter alia
that under Section 1 of the State Emblem of India (Regulation of Use Rules),
2007 framed under Section 11 of the State Emblem of India (Prohibition of
Improper Use) Act, 2005, a Gaonburah is not a authorized authority to use the
said emblem and the use of the same makes a document inadmissible in law.
The relevant portion in the said judgment is reproduced hereinbelow:
"That apart, we also notice that the State Emblem of India was embossed at the
top of the certificate issued by the Gaonburah. Under Schedule 1 of the State
Emblem of India (Regulation of Use) Rules, 2007 framed under section 11 of
the State Emblem of India (Prohibition of Improper Use) Act, 2005, a
Gaonburah is not an authorized authority to use the State Emblem in a
certificate issued by him. Rule 10 clearly provides that no person other than
those authorized shall use the State Emblem in any manner. Such unauthorized
use of the State Emblem would render Ext-3 inadmissible in evidence.
Moreover, the State Emblem of India embossed in any official document has to
conform to the design as set out in Appendix I or Appendix II to the aforesaid
Page No.# 17/22
Act. The motto “Satyameva Jayate” written in Devanagri script below the profile
of the Lion Capital is part of the State Emblem of India. In both Appendix I and
Appendix II, the motto “Satyameva Jayate” is written in bold and straight
Devanagri Script and not in italics. In Ext-3, the motto “Satyameva Jayate” is in
italics, which is a dear give away that it is not genuine, besides being
inadmissible."
22.
This Court by another judgment delivered in Ramila Khatun Vs. Union
of India reported in 2018 (4) GLT 373 had held that in absence of
examination of the issuing authority, the certificate cannot be relied on. The
relevant portion is extracted hereinbelow:
"It is trite that documentary evidence would have to be proved on the basis of the
record and the contemporaneous record must substantiate and prove the contents of
the document. Proof of document is one thing and proof of contents is another. Not
only the document would have to be proved but its contents would also have to be
proved. That apart, the truthfulness of the contents of the document would also have
to be established from the record. A document or the contents of the document
cannot be proved on the basis of personal knowledge. ..."
23.
The further reliance by the petitioner on the NRC details of 1951 is also
not admissible in law as laid down in a catena of decisions by this Court. One of
them is the judgment delivered in Abdul Mojid Vs. Union of India and Ors.
reported in 2019 (2) GLT 45. This Court had held that documents are not
admissible in evidence if they are computer generated statements and in
absence of authentication and certification by competent officer of the
department as required under Section 65 B(4) of the Evidence Act, 1972, no
reliance can be placed on such documents. Further, it was held that the NRC
documents being at the draft stage is yet to be completed and that no finality
can be attached to such documents and as such, the same is not applicable in
law.
24.
The voters list which is sought to be relied upon by the petitioner to
exemplify the fact that her father and her grandfather was in the voters list of
Page No.# 18/22
1966 and 1970 cannot , however, establish the link in absence of her name
along with her father. She had placed the voters list of herself with her husband
and his family. It is a settled position of law that the proceedee has to establish
the linkage with his or her ancestor through documents prior to 25.03.1971.
Here there is none. Further, it has been held that voters list per se will not
establish the linkage and that it requires other documents on record. In Aziz
Mia Vs. Union of India reported in 2023 (4) GLT 46, this Court had held
that voters list are not sufficient to prove the nationality of a proceedee and the
relevant portion is hereinbelow:
"We are constrained to observe that a mere claim by a suspected person by referring
to a voters’ list claiming a person therein to be his father is not a conclusive proof and
that by doing so, the person has discharged the burden that he is not a foreigner. This
is because there is also a further requirement to prove that the person who is reflected
in the voters’ list relied upon is actually the father of the person who makes the claim
the claim will have to be substantiated with further material/materials acceptable in
law."
25.
The next point to be considered by this Court is the relevancy of the
marriage certificate exhibited by the petitioner as Exhibit No.14. In the said
certificate, it is seen that Giasuddin Ahmed, son of Lokman Ali married the
petitioner being daughter of Giasuddin Mandal of village Nayapara Part-I under
P.S. Matia in the District of Goalpara and that the marriage was solemnized on
19.01.2001 but the further requirement is not complied with for proving the said
documents to establish the fact that the petitioner is daughter of said Giasuddin
Mandal. The Muslim Marriages and Divorces Registrar i.e. the Sadar Kazi,
Nagarbera was not examined as a witness to prove the contents of the said
certificate. The said certificate could at best prove the shifting of the petitioner
to her matrimonial home. The Supreme Court in Rupajan Begum Vs. Union
of India reported in (2018) 1 SCC 579 held that a certificate itself by no
Page No.# 19/22
means establishes any claim of citizenship of the holder of the certificate and
that it only enables its holder to establish a link between the holder and the
person from whom legacy is claimed and in absence of the examination of the
issuing authority, the same cannot be made applicable.
26.
Furthermore, the sale deeds exhibited by the petitioner were all post 1971
documents which has no role to play in establishing the citizenship of the
proceedee. Furthermore, the zamabandi placed by the petitioner is also post
1971 document and further in absence of her pleadings relating to her siblings,
the same cannot be relied on to establish the case of the petitioner.
27.
It is also no res integra that electoral photo Identity card is not a prove of
citizenship. It has been held in Munindra Biswas Vs. Union of India (Writ
Petition No. 7426/2019) decided on 12.02.2020 that the said documents are
only meant for identification or of availing services and they do not over-ride the
basic legal requirement of citizenship as prescribed under the Act. It is also
noticed in the instant case that an affidavit was sworn by the petitioner stating
inter alia that there are anomalies in the name of her father as well as herself.
However, the same cannot set right the said anomalies as laid down by this
Court as well as by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. A self declaration affidavit
cannot be considered in evidence and the said aspect has been held clearly by
this Court in Jan Nessa Vs. Union of India reported in 2018 (5) GLT 499
and the relevant portion is quoted hereinbelow:
"It is already settled by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Smti. Sudha Devi
v. M.P. Narayanan, reported in (1988) 3 SCC 366 that affidavit filed by a party
sou-motu and not under direction of the Court cannot be termed as evidence.
Affidavit is not included as evidence unless law specifically permits. Affidavit are
not included in the definition of 'evidence' in Section 3 of the Evidence Act and
can be used as evidence only if for sufficient reason Court passes an order
Page No.# 20/22
under Order 19, Rule 1 or 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In view of the
above, Exhibit-T affidavit placed by the petitioner cannot be considered as an
evidence."
28.
It is as such noticed that all the points raised by the petitioner are not
relevant for declaring the petitioner as an Indian Citizen. Furthermore, while
adjudicating the issue involved in the instant petition, we are reminded that a
writ Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India should confine its powers only towards examination of the decision
making process. In the present case, the Tribunal had given its findings based
on facts, and it is a trite law that findings of facts are not liable to be interfered
with, by a writ Court under its certiorari jurisdiction. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
after discussing the previous case laws on the jurisdiction of a Writ Court with
regard to the Writ of Certiorari had held in Central Council for Research in
Ayurvedic Sciences and Another -vs- Bikartan Das; reported in AIR
2023 SC 4011, as follows:"49.
Before we close this matter, we would like to observe something important in
the aforesaid context: Two cardinal principles of law governing exercise of
extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution more particularly when
it comes to issue of writ of certiorari.
50.
The first cardinal principle of law that governs the exercise of extraordinary
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, more particularly when it comes to
the issue of a writ of certiorari is that in granting such a writ, the High Court does not
exercise the powers of Appellate Tribunal. It does not review or reweigh the evidence
upon which the determination of the inferior tribunal purports to be based. It
demolishes the order which it considers to be without jurisdiction or palpably
erroneous but does not substitute its own views for those of the inferior tribunal. The
writ of certiorari can be issued if an error of law is apparent on the face of the record.
A writ of certiorari, being a high prerogative writ, should not be issued on mere
asking.
51.
The second cardinal principle of exercise of extraordinary jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution is that in a given case, even if some action or order
Page No.# 21/22
challenged in the writ petition is found to be illegal and invalid, the High Court while
exercising its extraordinary jurisdiction there under can refuse to upset it with a view
to doing substantial justice between the parties. Article 226 of the Constitution grants
an extraordinary remedy, which is essentially discretionary, although founded on legal
injury. It is perfectly open for the writ court, exercising this flexible power to pass such
orders as public interest dictates & equity projects. The legal formulations cannot be
enforced divorced from the realities of the fact situation of the case. While
administering law, it is to be tempered with equity and if the equitable situation
demands after setting right the legal formulations, not to take it to the logical end, the
High Court would be failing in its duty if it does not notice equitable consideration and
mould the final order in exercise of its extraordinary jurisdiction. Any other approach
would render the High Court a normal court of appeal which it is not."
29.
In T.C. Basappa v. T. Nagappa and Another , reported in AIR 1954
SC 440, the Hon’b;le Apex Court had laid down the essential features of a writ
of certiorari. In the said decision, it has been exhaustively explained by B.K.
Mukherjea, J that writ in the nature of certiorari could be issued in ‘all
appropriate cases and in appropriate manner’ so long as the broad and
fundamental principles are kept in mind. It was held as follows:"7. … In granting a writ of ‘certiorari’, the superior court does not exercise the
powers of an appellate tribunal. It does not review or reweigh the evidence
upon which the determination of the inferior tribunal purports to be based. It
demolishes the order which it considers to be without jurisdiction or palpably
erroneous, but does not substitute its own views for those of the inferior
tribunal …..
8. The supervision of the superior court exercised through writs of certiorari
goes on two points, as has been expressed by Lord Summer in King v. Nat Bell
Liquors Limited [(1922) 2 AC 128, 156]. One is the area of inferior jurisdiction
and the qualifications and conditions of its exercise; the other is the observance
of law in the course of its exercise. …. 9. Certiorari may lie and is generally
granted when a court has acted without or in excess of its jurisdiction.”
30.
As such, we observe herein that the certiorari jurisdiction of the writ Court
Page No.# 22/22
being supervisory and not appellate jurisdiction, this Court would refrain from
reviewing the findings of facts reached by the Tribunal although for the ends of
justice, some exercise has been done to the said effect.
31. In the instant case, it is noticed that the voters list did not establish the link
of the petitioner with her projected father and grandfather. Further the
certificates produced by the petitioner were not prove in accordance with law.
Furthermore due to lack of details in written statement, this Court is of the view
that opinion dated 15.06.2018 passed by the learned Member Foreigners
Tribunal, Kamrup(Rural), No.1 in GFT (R) Case No. 25/2018 by which the
petitioner was declared as a Foreigner does not call for any interference.
32.
The interim order passed earlier stands vacated.
33.
The actions consequent upon the opinion rendered by the learned
Tribunal would follow in accordance with law.
34.
The records of the learned Tribunal be returned forthwith along with copy
of this order.
35.
The writ petition stands dismissed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review