Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 17th September, 2025
Pronounced on: 12th January, 2026
%
+
CRL.M.C. 1756/2017 & CRL.M.C. 1781/2017
HARNAM SINGH
R/o 66, Hemkunt Colony,
Opposite Nehru Place
New Delhi -110048
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Mudit Jain and Ms. Mahima
Malhotra, Advs.
Versus
1. STATE
Through: Standing Counsel
NCT of Delhi (Department of Prosecution)
High Court of Delhi, New Delhi
.....Respondent No. 1
2. MOHINDER PAL SINGH
S/o Shri Amrik Singh Sahni
R/o P O Box No 20986, Code 13070
Kuwait
.....Respondent No. 2
Through:
Mr. Shoaib Haider, APP for State
with SI Sukhbir Singh, PS: Tilak
Marg.
Mr. Arvind Kumar Gupta, Mr. Arun
Bhattacharya and Mr. Ishan Parashar,
Advs. for R-2.
CRL.M.C. 4554/2017
HARNAM SINGH
R/o 66, Hemkunt Colony,
Opposite Nehru Place
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
New Delhi -110048
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms. Mahima Malhotra and Mr. Harjas
Singh Gujral, Advocates.
Versus
MOHINDER PAL SINGH SAHNI
S/o Shri Amrik Singh Sahni
R/o P O Box No 20986, Code 13070, Kuwait
Also at:
House No. 29, Street No 3
Area 3, Mishref, Kuwait
And at:
D-1/II, Model Town,
New Delhi
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Shoaib Haider, APP for the State.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The Petitioner/Harnam Singh has filed the aforesaid Petition in Crl.
M.C. No.4554/2017 under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 („Cr.P.C.‟) to challenge Orders dated 16.05.2016, passed by the Ld.
MM whereby the Complaint bearing CC. No. 207/1/2015 filed by the
Petitioner, was dismissed.
2.
The Crl. M.C. No. 1781/2017 has been filed to challenge the Order
dated 05.11.2016 of ASJ who set aside the Order of summoning of the
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
Respondent Mohinder Pal Singh (accused) of the Ld. MM, whereby the
Respondent was discharged in Charge Sheet filed in FIR No. 308/2005.
3.
Crl. M.C. No. 1756/2017 has been filed by the Petitioner against the
Order of discharge dated 05.11.2016 of ASJ, whereby no Charge has been
framed in respect of Complaint CC No.57/2/2013 that was tagged with the
FIR.
4.
CRL.M.C. 4554/2017 pertains to dismissal of the Complaint case No.
207/1/15, wherein the allegations were made about the forgery in the two
Letters, both dated 27.04.2007, wherein the contents had been forged.
5.
All the Petitions stem from an alleged forgery and fraudulent use of
Medical Certificates dated 20.05.1999 and 07.06.1999; resubmission of
these Medical Certificates with forged Signatures of the Doctor submitted
along with Letter dated 05.04.2013, and Letter dated 22.05.2007 submitted
by the Respondent/Accused, Mohinder Pal Singh Sahni, filed at different
stages of the Criminal proceedings .
6.
Briefly stated, the Petitioner/Complainant, Harnam Singh, and the
Respondent/Accused, Mohinder Pal Singh Sahni (“MPS”), became
embroiled in protracted litigation following the revocation of a Power of
Attorney granted by MPS to the Petitioner in August 1997.
7.
The Petitioner had filed a Complaint against Respondent No. 2/MPS
under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, in September
1997 before the Learned Metropolitan Magistrate (Ld. MM), New Delhi. In
this case, MPS was summoned as an accused. On 26.05.1999, Respondent
No. 2 moved an Application seeking exemption from personal appearance,
enclosing a photocopy of a medical certificate dated 20.05.1999 -
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
purportedly issued by Dr. Ibrahim Y. Al-Deeb of Kuwait in English, bearing
a single signature.
8.
He filed another exemption application on 10.06.1999 through his
counsel, enclosing a photocopy of another medical certificate dated
07.06.1999, also in English and allegedly issued by the same doctor, again
bearing only a single signature.
9.
In 1999, the Petitioner filed an Application under Section 340 Cr.P.C.
before the Ld. Trial Court, alleging that Respondent No. 2 had used forged
Medical Certificates. Despite court orders, no reply was filed by the
Respondent for nearly three years. The said Section 340 Application was
eventually withdrawn by the Petitioner in 2003, with liberty to file a police
Complaint.
10.
Thereafter, the Petitioner instituted a private criminal complaint by
way of Complaint Case (CC) No. 1113/2004, alleging that three Medical
Prescription
Slips
dated
20.05.1999,
07.06.1999,
and
30.06.1999,
purportedly issued by Dr. Ibrahim Y. Al-Deeb of Mubarak Al-Raz
Orthopaedic Hospital (not “Mubarak Al-Kabeer Hospital”), Kuwait, were
forged and fabricated documents submitted to mislead the court. The Ld.
Magistrate issued a summoning order against the Respondent on
01.03.2005.
11.
Aggrieved, the Respondent challenged the Summoning Order before
this Court in Crl. M.C. No. 3193/2005. The Court observed that the original
Medical Certificates were never produced or seized, and that the opinion of
the handwriting expert (GEQD) - based solely on photocopies - was
insufficient to sustain criminal charges. The Court further held that the
Medical Slips appeared “legal, valid and genuine,” and that the continuation
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
of the Complaint amounted to a “gross abuse of the process of court,”
motivated by personal vendetta. Consequently, the Petition was allowed, and
both the Complaint and the Summoning Order were quashed vide order
dated 30.05.2013.
12.
The Petitioner’s challenge to this order before the Supreme Court was
unsuccessful; the Apex Court dismissed the Appeal, rendering the dismissal
of Complaint No. 1113/2004 final and binding.
13.
Separately, on the basis of a Complaint dated 25.06.2005 (received by
police on 07.07.2005) - containing allegations identical to those in CC No.
1113/2004 - an FIR, being FIR No. 308/2005, was registered at PS Tilak
Marg, New Delhi, on 29.07.2005, under Sections 420, 468, and 471 IPC
against Respondent No. 2 for using forged Medical Certificates dated
20.05.1999 and 07.06.1999, each bearing only a single signature of the said
Kuwaiti doctor.
14.
During the course of investigation, the Police received a
communication dated 27.11.2012, from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs,
Kuwait, routed through the Indian Ministry of External Affairs (MEA),
confirming that the aforementioned Medical Certificates were not genuine.
The Kuwaiti authorities stated that the certificates lacked mandatory
attestations by two doctors and the hospital director, as required under
Kuwaiti ministerial regulations, and noted that the official seal referenced
had been lost prior to 1999.
15.
In April/May 2013, an Arabic-to-English translated copy of the said
27.11.2012 communication was formally received by the Investigating
agency. It reiterated that the Medical Certificates dated 20.05.1999 and
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
07.06.1999 were not genuine and further confirmed that no corresponding
medical files existed in the hospital records for these Certificates.
16.
In response to the investigation, the Accused submitted a Letter dated
05.04.2013 to the Investigating Officer, enclosing photocopies of the same
Medical Certificates dated 20.05.1999 and 07.06.1999. However, these
newly submitted copies bore double signatures of the doctor- contradicting
the single-signature versions originally filed in court in 1999.
17.
The Police Status Report filed during Bail proceedings in June 2013
highlighted this discrepancy. The Investigating Officer noted that, in an
apparent attempt to counter the MEA’s finding that the 1999 Certificates
were forged due to lack of proper attestations, the Accused had submitted
altered versions of the same certificates in 2013 - now bearing two
signatures instead of one.
18.
The Petitioner characterized this conduct as a “continuing forgery”
and filed a second criminal complaint CC No. 57/2/2013 arguing that if the
Certificates filed in court in 1999 (with one signature) were genuine, then
the submission of materially altered versions in 2013, with an added
signature, constituted a fresh and independent act of forgery and fabrication
of evidence. The Petitioner sought separate prosecution of the Accused for
this distinct offence.
Complaint CC No. 207/1/15:
19.
The Accused had submitted two Medical Certificates along with a
Letter dated 27.04.2007 to the Investigating Officer (IO). As recorded in the
Police file and reproduced in the Chargesheet in FIR No. 308/2005, the
relevant portion of this Letter read:
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
“Upon my Arrival in India, I immediately contacted IO Mr.
Sanjay Singh and furnished all documents which were in
my possession”.
20.
However, in the version of the same Letter filed before this Hon’ble
Court as Annexure P-6 to his Bail Application No. 1017/2013, the text was
altered to read:
“Upon my Arrival in India, I immediately contacted IO Mr.
Sanjay Singh and furnished all three documents in original
which were in my possession”.
21.
This altered version was relied upon by the Accused during the
hearing of his Bail Application in 2013 before this Court. The Petitioner
contended that by inserting the words “three” and “in original,” the
Accused deliberately fabricated the document to create a false impression
that the original Medical Certificates had already been surrendered to the
police as early as 2007 - thereby attempting to preclude the need for
custodial interrogation for recovery of the originals.
22.
The Investigating Officer strongly opposed the Bail Application
through a Status Report dated 06.06.2013, explicitly stating that the original
Medical Certificates had never been recovered, and that the photocopies
submitted by the Accused were not genuine; claim directly contradicting
made in the altered Letter.
23.
Although this forged Letter formed part of the Accused’s defense in
the Bail proceedings, it gave rise to a separate and independent cause of
action for the Petitioner. Accordingly, on 15.04.2015, the Petitioner lodged a
written Complaint with the SHO, P.S. Tilak Marg, specifically alleging that
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
the insertion of the words “three” and “in original” constituted a deliberate
act of forgery and fabrication intended to fraudulently secure Bail.
24.
When the police failed to register an FIR based on this Complaint, the
Petitioner instituted a third Criminal Complaint case bearing Complaint
Case No. 207/1/15 - which is the subject matter of the present Criminal
Miscellaneous Case No. 4554/2017.
25.
The Ld. Magistrate took cognizance and recorded the pre-summoning
evidence. The Petitioner examined three witnesses, as under:
(i)
CW-1/Sh. Sunil Kumar, JJA, Delhi High Court produced the
record of Bail Appl. No. 1017/2013 containing the allegedly
forged letter.
(ii)
CW-2/Sh. Manoj Singh Negi, Ahlmad, produced the record of
FIR No. 308/2005 (Charge-sheet), verifying the original letter
received by the police.
(iii)
CW-3/Petitioner deposed about the forgery of Letters/Medical
Certificates, as stated in his Complaint.
26.
The Ld. MM, vide the impugned Order dated 16.05.2016, observed
that the Letter marked Ex. CW1/4, filed by the Accused in the Hon’ble High
Court as Annexure P-6 to his Bail Application, bore a Police Station receipt
stamp dated 22.05.2007, whereas the version of the same Letter forming part
of the Chargesheet in FIR No. 308/2005 (Ex. CW2/2) bore a receipt stamp
dated 23.05.2007.
27.
On this basis, the Ld. MM concluded that these were “two different
documents though having similar contents.” The Court held that mere
similarity in content did not establish forgery, and that the filing of Ex.
CW1/4 instead of Ex. CW2/2 did not constitute offences under Sections
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
420, 465, 468, or 471 IPC. The allegations were dismissed as “patently
absurd and inherently improbable,” such that no prudent person could
conclude there were sufficient grounds to proceed with the Complaint.
28.
Accordingly, the Ld. MM held that there was no sufficient ground
for summoning the Respondent and dismissed Complaint Case No.
207/1/15.
29.
Parallel to these proceedings, investigations in FIR No. 308/2005
registered on 29.07.2005, concerning the alleged forgery of medical
certificates dated 20.05.1999 and 07.06.1999 were ongoing. The
Chargesheet in this FIR was filed on 09.02.2015. However, by Order dated
27.06.2015, the Ld. M.M directed that Complaint Case No. 57/2/2013
(pertaining to the “double signature” forgery) be tagged with the main FIR
file, as the Chargesheet had already been filed.
30.
In the interim, the Accused had filed Crl. M.C. No. 2196/2013
seeking quashing of FIR No. 308/2005. This Court, by Order dated
19.01.2015, dismissed the Petition, noting that the investigation was
complete and the Chargesheet had been filed, and granted liberty to the
Accused to raise his contentions at the stage of framing of charges.
31.
Thereafter, the Ld. M.M, finding a prima facie case based on the
Chargesheet, including the MEA (Kuwait) report dated 27.11.2012
confirming the Certificates were forged, directed the framing of Charges
under Sections 420, 468, and 471 IPC against the Accused, vide Order
dated 13.07.2016. However, this Order did not separately address the
distinct offence of “continuing/another forgery” involving the submission
of doubly-signed Medical Certificates in 2013, as alleged in the tagged
Complaint Case No. 57/2/2013.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
32.
The said Order was challenged by the Accused through Crl. Rev. No.
8762/2016, seeking discharge. Simultaneously, the Petitioner/Complainant
filed Crl. Rev. No. 8895/2016, urging the framing of an additional and
separate charge for the “double signature” forgery under CC No.
57/2/2013, which had been lawfully tagged with the FIR.
33.
The Ld. ASJ disposed of both Revision Petitions by a common
Order dated 05.11.2016. The Ld. ASJ allowed the accused’ Revision, set
aside the framing of charges, and discharged him in FIR No. 308/2005. In
doing so, the Court relied on earlier judgment dated 30.05.2013 of this
Court in Crl. M.C. No. 3193/2005, wherein the Medical Certificates were
held to be “legal, valid and genuine.” The Ld. ASJ concluded that the Ld.
MM committed a “grave illegality” by framing Charges based on the same
documents previously upheld as genuine.
34.
The Ld. ASJ also dismissed the Petitioner’s Crl. Rev. No.
8895/2016, holding that once a Complaint is tagged with a Police case under
Section 210 Cr.P.C., it must be tried together as if instituted on a Police
report, and thus, no separate charge could be framed.
35.
Thus, the events surrounding the investigation and Bail proceedings
in 2013 gave rise to three distinct offshoots of litigation: one challenging the
original Medical Certificates Dated 20.05.1999 and 07.06.1999 filed in the
Complaint Case under S.138 in 1999, as forged; second regarding doublesignature Certificates (CC 57/2/2013) and the third, challenging the altered
Letter dated 27. 04. 2007 submitted by the Counsel of the Respondent to the
IO, which is the subject matter of Complaint Case No. 207/1/15.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
Crl. M.C. 1781/2017 & Crl. M.C. 1756/2017:
36.
These two Petitions challenge the common impugned Order dated
05.11.2016. Crl. M.C. No. 1781/2017 assails the discharge of the Accused
in FIR No. 308/2005. Crl. M.C. No. 1756/2017 challenges the dismissal of
the plea to frame a separate charge for the distinct offence of “double
signature” forgery under CC No. 57/2/2013, which had been duly tagged
with the FIR.
37.
The grounds of challenge are that the Petitioner was not impleaded
as a party in the Accused’s Revision petition, thereby violating the principle
of audi alteram partem and denying him the right to be heard.
38.
The Ld. ASJ erred in disregarding the Chargesheet and the Official
communication from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Kuwait (via MEA,
dated 27.11.2012), which categorically stated that the Medical Certificates
were not genuine due to missing attestations and the loss of the Doctor’s seal
prior to 1999. This verification by MFA Kuwait was not available to the
High Court when it passed the order on 30.05.2013 in Crl. M.C. No.
3193/2005. The findings in the earlier private Complaint - which was based
solely on photocopies and quashed in 2013 - cannot override a Police
Chargesheet supported by diplomatic confirmation of forgery.
39.
The Accused allegedly suppressed material evidence by not placing
the Chargesheet before the Revisional Court. The Ld. ASJ fell into error by
discharging the Accused based solely on the 2013 Order, which predated the
crucial MEA report.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
40.
Moreover, this Court, in its Order dated 19.01.2015 in Crl. M.C. No.
2196/2013, had refused to quash FIR No. 308/2005 and expressly left it
open for the trial court to consider the merits at the stage of charge.
41.
It is submitted that the impugned Revision Order effectively overrules
this binding direction, amounting to judicial impropriety.
CRL.M.C. 4554/2017:
42.
This Petition challenges the impugned Order dated 16.05.2016,
whereby the Ld. MM dismissed CC No. 207/1/15. The Complaint alleged
that the Respondent fraudulently altered the Letter dated 27.04.2007 originally submitted to the IO, by inserting the phrase “all three documents
in original” when filing it as Annexure P-6 to his Bail Application No.
1017/2013 before this Court, thereby falsely suggesting full cooperation and
surrender of originals.
43.
The Petitioner has challenged this Impugned Order on the grounds
that the Ld. M.M. failed to appreciate that the Accused materially altered the
document to mislead this Court. The Letter originally submitted to the IO
stated the accused furnished “all documents”, whereas the Status Report
filed in this Court for bail was altered to read “all three documents in
original”.
44.
This act constitutes a distinct offence of forgery under Section 464
IPC, as it involved dishonestly making a false document to cause damage or
support a legal claim. Unlike the 1999 forgery, this was committed in 2013
during judicial proceedings. Under Section 218 Cr.P.C., every distinct
Offence requires a separate charge. The Ld. ASJ erred in conflating this with
the main FIR and refusing to direct framing of a separate charge.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
45.
The Ld. ASJ further ignored the Status Report dated 06.06.2013,
wherein the IO explicitly noted that the Accused, upon learning that the
single-signature certificates were deemed forged, submitted new versions
with double signatures - an act described as “another forgery.”
46.
The Petitioner submits that Section 210(2) Cr.P.C. mandates that a
tagged Complaint be tried together with the police case, but it does not
extinguish the Complaint or permit the court to ignore distinct offences not
covered in the Chargesheet.
47.
Additionally, the standard of proof in a private Complaint differs from
that in a police Complaint, where the police possess broader investigative
powers and access to evidence from departments such as MEA.
48.
Dismissing the revision solely on the procedural ground of “tagging”
resulted in a failure of justice, as the substantive offence of the second
forgery remains uncharged and unpunished.
49.
The impugned Order is also non-speaking and fails to comply with
Section 203 Cr.P.C., which requires the Magistrate to briefly record reasons
for dismissing a Complaint.
50.
The Ld. M.M erroneously conducted a mini-trial, evaluating the
defence and documentary discrepancies, rather than applying the correct
prima facie standard applicable at the summoning stage.
51.
Whether the documents were “different” or “forged” is a question of
fact for trial, not for pre-summoning determination. The Court’s role at this
stage is not to assess conviction prospects, but to determine if sufficient
grounds exist to proceed.
52.
The Petitioner relies on Shri Chand Gupta v. Sanjosh Kumar & Anr.
(Crl.M.C. No. 5113/2013) for the proposition that the standard for private
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
Complaints may differ, though it should be noted that the prevailing view
favours prima facie scrutiny regardless of origin.
53.
Also, the Apex Court in Divine Retreat Centre vs. State of Kerala &
Ors., 2008 (3) S.C. 223, observed that “investigation in cognizable cases is
a power conferred exclusively on the police officers. So long as that power
is not abused, it would not be interfered with. The said power should be
exercised in strict compliance with Chapter XII of the Code.” Similar view
has been taken by this Court in Amrit V. vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi 2010
(171) DLT 607.
54.
It is submitted that the present Petition is maintainable in view of the
law laid down by the Apex Court in Dharwal Tobacco Products Ltd. &
Others Vs. State of Maharashtra & Another 2009 (2) SCC 370.
55.
Further, in Krishnan & Another vs. Krishnaveni & Another, 1997 (4)
SCC 241, the Apex Court has held that the High Court is justified in
interfering with the Order to prevent miscarriage of justice and in setting
aside. Further reliance is placed upon Shakuntala Devi and others Vs.
Chamru Mahto & Another 2009 (3) SCC 310.
56.
In Crl. M.C. No. 4554/2017, the Petitioner specifically challenges the
dismissal of CC No. 207/1/15 on the erroneous finding that the two Letters
were merely “different” due to receipt dates. The core allegation that the text
was altered to fabricate compliance - was corroborated by the IO’s Status
Report and the testimony of three witnesses (CW-1, CW-2, and CW-3).
Dismissing the Complaint without addressing this specific evidence amounts
to a failure to exercise judicial mind.
57.
Thus, it is prayed that the Petitions be allowed and impugned Orders
be set aside.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
58.
The Respondent/Mohinder Pal Singh Sahni, has filed a Counter
Affidavit raising the contentions that the petition is an abuse of the process
of law and that the Petitioner has filed multiple litigations on the same cause
of action, to harass him. The Respondent asserts that Petitioner’s actions as
arm-twisting tactics designed to extract money from an NRI settled in
Kuwait for 47 years.
59.
A preliminary objection is taken that the present Petition under
Section 482 Cr.P.C., is essentially a second Revision against the Order of
the Ld. Trial Court, which is barred under Section 397(3) Cr.P.C. The
Petitioner cannot bypass this statutory bar by invoking inherent powers.
60.
The Respondent has asserted that the Medical Certificates were
genuinely issued by Dr. Ibrahim Y. Al-Deeb in 1999, copies of which were
submitted in the Court of Ld. MM in the Complaint filed under S.138 NI
Act. Addressing the core allegation of “continuing forgery,” the Respondent
explained that during the investigation, the IO insisted on the documents.
61.
Consequently, the Respondent took the second signatures of the
doctor on the Medical slips during the investigation and submitted them to
the IO. Therefore, he stated that there was no question of forgery, as the
signatures were obtained to satisfy the IO.
62.
The Respondent supported the Ld. ASJ’s reasoning that under Section
210 Cr.P.C the Complaint case CC No. 57/2/13 merged with the Police
case FIR No. 308/2005. Since the Chargesheet had already been filed in the
FIR, and the Complaint was tagged with it, the Complaint became
redundant. The Respondent contends that the two Courts provided correct
legal justification for not framing a separate Charge based on the tagged
Complaint.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
63.
The Respondent reiterated that the Petitioner is filing Complaints one
after another i.e. CC No. 1113/2004, FIR 308/2005, and CC No. 57/2/13
based on the same “3 Medical Prescription Slips,” solely to harass him.
64.
The Respondent has heavily relied on the Order of the coordinate
Bench of this Court dated 30.05.2013 in Crl. M.C. No. 3193/2005 to state
that this Order had already adjudicated the genuineness of the three Medical
Prescription Slips dated 20.05.1999, 07.06.1999, and 30.06.1999 and held
them to be “legal, valid and genuine”. Since the FIR was based on two of
these same medical Certificates, the FIR became otiose following the High
Court's findings. The Petitioner has concealed the adjudication regarding the
validity of the Medical Slips in the earlier Crl. M.C. No. 3193/2005, thereby
misleading the Court.
65.
Moreover, that the Petitioner had filed Special Leave Petition (SLP)
before the Apex Court to challenge the Order dated 30.05.2013 of this
Court, which was dismissed in limine. Therefore, the issue of the validity of
the Certificates could not be agitated again.
66.
The Respondent states that the Ld. ASJ’s Order suffers from no
infirmity as it has correctly relied on this Court’s findings that the
documents were genuine.
67.
The Respondent has further explained the two Letters submitted in the
Bail Application, were two separate Letters; one received in the Police
Station on 22.05.2007 and another on 23.05.2007. Merely because one of
the Letters received by the Police was filed with the Bail Application, it does
not make the document forged or fabricated. The Respondent relied on the
Ld. MM’s finding that the documents had only a “minor difference of
words” and that the sense of both was almost the same.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
68.
Relying on the judgment in State of Haryana vs. Bhajan Lal, 1992
Supp. (1) SCC 335 the Respondent asserted that the proceedings were
maliciously instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance due to
the cancellation of the Power of Attorney.
Submissions Heard and Record Perused.
I.
Preliminary Objection:
69.
The Respondent raised a preliminary objection that the Petitions -
being challenges to the Ld. ASJ’s common Order dated 05.11.2016 in Crl.
M.C. Nos. 1781/2017 and 1756/2017, and to the Ld. MM’s order dated
16.05.2016 in Crl. M.C. No. 4554/2017 - amount to second Revisions and
are therefore, barred under Section 397(3) Cr.P.C.
70.
This contention is not tenable. The inherent power of the High Court
under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is distinct from its revisional jurisdiction under
Section 397 Cr.P.C. While such power must be exercised sparingly and with
caution, it remains available even where a second revision is statutorily
barred - particularly to prevent abuse of process or secure the ends of justice.
71.
The fundamental purpose of Section 482 Cr.P.C. is to prevent the
abuse of the judicial process and to secure the ends of justice. Where the
High Court discerns a grave miscarriage of justice, or suppression of
material evidence, it is not only empowered but duty-bound to intervene.
72.
Given the gravity of the allegations, including the submission of
forged medical certificates and the deliberate alteration of Court documents
to mislead judicial authorities, the objection regarding maintainability is
misconceived.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
73.
These acts directly impugn the integrity of judicial proceedings,
warranting the exercise of inherent powers.
II.
Offence of Forgery, and Fabrication:
74.
FIR No. 308/2005 was registered at PS Tilak Marg, New Delhi, on
29.07.2005, under Sections 420, 468, and 471 IPC, based on a Complaint by
the Petitioner. The FIR pertains to two forged Medical Certificates dated
20.05.1999 and 07.06.1999, submitted by the Respondent along with
Applications seeking exemption from personal appearance in Complaint
Case No. 343/1997 filed under Section 138 of the NI Act. A communication
dated 27.11.2012 from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Kuwait, routed
through the Indian MEA, confirming that the said Medical Certificates were
not genuine. During investigations, the respondent enclosed two Medical
Certificates dated 20.05.1999 and 07.06.1999 along with Letter dated
27.04.2007, bearing a Police Station Receipt stamp dated 22.05.2007, now
bearing two signatures, contradicting the single-signature versions originally
filed in court in 1999.
75.
After investigations, the Chargesheet under Sections 420/468/471 IPC
was accordingly, filed on 09.02.2015.
76.
The question that arises before this Court is whether the Respondent
was rightly discharged by the Ld. M.M. in the said Chargesheet vide Order
dated 13.07.2016, which was upheld by the Ld. ASJ vide Order dated
05.11.2016.
77.
The first ground of challenge is that the Ld. ASJ erroneously relied on
the judgment dated 30.05.2013 in Crl. M.C. No. 3193/2005, which had
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
quashed Complaint Case No. 1113/2004 - a private Complaint based solely
on photocopies and lacking diplomatic verification.
78.
The genesis of the dispute lies in a Complaint under Section 138 NI
Act filed by the Petitioner in September 1997, in which the Respondent was
summoned as an accused. To seek exemption from appearance, the
Respondent filed two Applications on 26.05.1999 and 10.06.1999, supported
by the contested Medical Certificates - triggering litigation spanning over 26
years.
79.
The first criminal proceeding was Complaint Case No. 1113/2004,
wherein the Petitioner alleged that the Medical Certificates dated 20.05.1999
and 07.06.1999 were forged due to lack of dual signatures. This Complaint
was quashed by the coordinate Bench of this Court on 30.05.2013, and the
Petitioner’s Appeal before the Supreme Court was dismissed, rendering the
order final.
80.
The Chargesheet also noted that during investigation, the Respondent
submitted new versions of the same Certificates with double signatures in
2013 along with a Letter dated 27.04.2007, giving rise to two additional
Complaints.
a. CC No. 57/2/2013 (for “double signature” forgery); and
b. CC No. 207/1/2015 (for altering the 27.04.2007 Letter).
81.
The core issue before this Court is whether the Ld. ASJ was justified
in discharging the accused in FIR No. 308/2005 and in holding that the
tagged Complaint bearing CC No. 57/2/2013 stood extinguished - despite
the existence of new, independent evidence, including diplomatic
confirmation of forgery and subsequent acts of document manipulation, that
was never before the Court in 2013.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
82.
This Court in its Judgment dated 30.05.2013, while quashing the first
Complaint CC No. 1113/2004 raising the issue of alleged forged Medical
Certificates submitted before Ld. MM, considered in detail the rival
contentions of the parties and quashed the Complaint with the following
observations:
“16. The photocopies of the medical certificates were filed
while seeking exemption on 26.05.1999, 10.06.1999 and
01.07.1999. It appears that relying upon the certificates the
accused/ petitioner was granted exemption by the Court. It
is unclear if at the time of seeking exemption on behalf of
the petitioner, the complainant had raised any objection or
suspected the genuineness of the medical certificates. The
present complaint case was filed in July, 2002 after a
considerable delay of about three years. The complainant
has failed to explain the inordinate delay in filing the
complaint case. It is not clear if the complainant
challenged the exemption granted to the petitioner in the
said proceedings. It has come on record that the
complainant had earlier moved applications under Section
340 Cr.P.C. However, he opted to withdraw the said
applications. There is no finding of the Court concerned
that the petitioner sought exemption on forged or
fabricated documents. The original medical certificates
were not on record. The handwriting expert merely
examined the photocopies of the medical certificates. The
Trial Court had no cogent material except the bald
statement of the complainant to form its, prima facie,
opinion that the medical certificates filed along with the
exemption applications were forged or fabricated. No
coercive action was taken by the Court concerned against
the petitioner for filing the alleged forged or fabricated
medical certificates. Complainant had no reasonable belief
that the certificates were forged and fabricated. It is
relevant to note that the complainant registered FIR
No.308/2005 dated 29.07.2005 at PS Tilak Marg, under
Sections 420/467/468/428 IPC against the petitioner for
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
allegedly filing the said medical certificates in the
proceedings instituted under Section 138 Negotiable
Instruments Act. The complainant opted to withdraw the
complaint case under Section 138 Negotiable Instruments
Act. The complaint case in which the exemption was sought
and the petitioner was summoned vide Order dated
11.11.1998 has been quashed by a separate order. The
complainant has lodged numerous criminal litigations
against the petitioner apparently to drag him in unending
litigations. The Trial Court without application of mind
summoned the accused. The whole case of the
complainant is based upon surmises and conjectures. The
complaint case does not show any worthwhile material to
proceed against the petitioner and it is an abuse of the
process of the Court. The complaint case „Harnam Singh
vs. Mohinder Pal Singh Sahni‟ and summoning order dated
01.03.2005 are quashed. The petition is allowed.”
83.
The matter should have rested there, but an FIR No. 308/2005,
registered on 29.07.2005 at PS Tilak Marg, was subsequently registered
after confirmation from the Kuwait Embassy via MEA in April/May 2013,
the Chargesheet was filed on 09.02.2015.
84.
Though the Ld. ASJ relied heavily on the judgment dated 30.05.2013
of the coordinate Bench of this Court in Crl. M.C. No. 3193/2005, since the
allegations made in Complaint Case No. 1113/2004 as well as the FIR were
based on the same two Medical Certificates dated 20.05.1999 and
07.06.1999, which were alleged to be forged and fabricated, some reference
should have been made to the Report received from the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs, Kuwait, dated 27.11.2012, which confirmed that the Certificates
were not genuine due to lack of attestations and absence of the doctor’s seal
since before 1999. The Report did not rely on verification from the
concerned doctor, but rather on administrative protocols of the Hospital.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
85.
The Respondent has cogently argued that two separate Letters existed,
one received by the police on 22.05.2007 with receipt stamp dated
23.05.2007, and another submitted along with his Bail Application as
Annexure P-6 in 2013, which contained altered wording to the effect of “all
three documents in original”.
86.
The Police record itself indicates receipts of one Letter on 22.05.2007
bearing the stamp of Police Station dated 23.05.2007.
87.
Pertinently, therein the Respondent had indicated that, in order to
satisfy the IO, he had obtained double signatures on the photocopy of the
earlier Medical Certificates of 1999 and had submitted the originals to the
IO.
88.
While there may be some confusion, it is clearly evident that the
subsequent Letters submitted by the Respondent at the time of Bail, referred
to the subsequently obtained Medical Certificates with double signatures in
2013, and not to the original Medical Certificates of 1999. It can also not be
overlooked that these two letters were submitted to the IO in 2007, but
emerged during the Bail proceedings in 2013. Furthermore, it has been the
consistent stand of the Respondent that original Medical certificates had
been submitted initially to Io Sanjay Singh in 2007 itself. If the Letters are
read in right perspective, this is what was sought to be conveyed in the two
letters.
89.
There is essentially no forgery in regard to the Letters, as asserted
by the Petitioner.
90.
To sum up, the genesis of this dispute lies in a Complaint under
Section 138 NI Act filed by the Petitioner/Complainant in 1997, nearly three
decades ago. the Medical Certificates were filed in the way back in the year
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
1999, wherein merely to seek exemption on two dates i.e. 26.05.1999 and
10.06.1999, photocopies of the two Medical Certificates were submitted in
court. The reasons given by this Court in its Order dated 30.05.2013, still
hold good. Admittedly, the entire controversy had arisen in the Complaint
under Section 138 NI Act, which itself got withdrawn on 22.09.2003.
91.
There is nothing to show that the exemption granted to the
Respondent in 1999, was ever challenged by the Petitioner.
92.
The records indicate that the criminal machinery has been set into
motion not for the pursuit of justice, but seemingly as a tool for settling a
personal score, stemming from the cancellation of a Power of Attorney.
There is nothing to indicate that the Complainant was aggrieved by the
exemptions so granted to the Respondent.
93.
It is also pertinent to note that the Petitioner is an NRI based in
Kuwait. To subject an individual, particularly an NRI residing abroad for
over 40 years, to continuous Criminal Trials for alleged procedural lapses
(medical slips/letters) occurring in 1999 and 2007, after the underlying NI
Act case was withdrawn in 2003, is a gross abuse of the process of law.
94.
The aforesaid three litigations are clearly an abuse of process of law
continued by the Complainant for about 30 years with no fruitful purpose. It
is clearly a case of abuse and wreaking of vengeance. The Apex Court in
Bhajan Lal (supra) has categorically held that criminal proceedings
instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance or due to private
and personal grudges constitute an abuse of process.
95.
This is a fit case for the Court to intervene to prevent the judicial
process from becoming an instrument of oppression and uphold the
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
dismissal of the Complaint and setting aside of the Summoning Order by the
Ld. ASJ.
96.
There is no merit in the aforesaid three petitions, which are hereby
dismissed.
Order:
97.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, it is held that there is no merit in
the aforesaid Petitions CRL.M.C. 1781/2017, CRL.M.C. 1756/2017, and
CRL.M.C. 4554/2017, which are hereby dismissed.
98.
The pending Applications, if any, are disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 12, 2026/N
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
15:06:51
CRL.M.C. 1756, 1781, 4554 of 2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review