Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
[ 34el ]
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY SEVENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
JUSTICE
THE HONOURABLE SRI
WRIT APPEAL NO: 1006 OF 2024 AND WRIT PETITION No.20890 OF 2023
W.A.NO: 1006 OF 2024
writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Lefters Patent Filed against the order
Dated-10/03/2023 in writ petition No.5413 of 201 5 on the file of the High court.
Between:
S/o. Gokari, Age 51 years, Occ- Pvt. works, Rl/o.Kondair
Harijan Karna,'Mandal,
(Mahabubnagai dist) (presently Jogulambha Gadwal
Village, Itikyal
District.
Ha rijan Lalanna, S/o. Gokari. Age 53 years, Occ- Pvt. works, Rl/o.Kondair
Village, ttikyal H,iandal, (Mahabu6nagar-dist) (presently Jogulambha Gadwal
District.
...APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS NO.4 & 5
AND
M. Sreekanth Goud, S/o. Late M. Raman Goud, Aged- 40 years, OccAgricultu re, N o. 7 -4-85t 1, Pedda Agraharam, Gadwal Town, ( fi'lahabubnagar
dist) (presently Jogulambha Gadwal District.
...RESPONDENT/ WRIT PETITIONER
2. State of Telangana, Rep By its. Secretary (Revenue Department), Secretariat,
Hvderabad
3. T6e Revenue Division Officer, Gadwal Division, Gadwal Town.
(Mahabubnaqar dist) (presently Jogulambha Gadwal District'
+. iiie fanasitdir, ltiky'ai'Mandal, (Va-naOuUnagar dist) (presently Jogulambha
Gadwal District
...RES'.NDENTS/ RES'.NDENTS No.1 To 3
Counsel for the Appellants: SRI G.L.NARASIMHA RAO
Counsel forthe Respondent No.1: SRI D.JAGAN MOHAN REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 TO 4: GP FOR REVENUE
W.P.NO: 20890 OF 2023
Between:
i. Harijan Karna, S/o. Gokari, Age 51 years, Occ. Pvt works, Rl/o Kondair
Gadwal
Village, Itikyal Mandal, (MahabJbnagai dist; (presentlv . lgulambha
District.
2. Harijan Lalanna, S/o. Gokari, Age 53 years, Occ. P'r1. works, R/o.Kondair
Village, Itikyal tVandal, (Mahabu6nagar dist) (presently. ogulambha Gadwal
District.
...PETITIONERS
AND
,
. The State of Telangana, rep by its Chief Secretary Secre t rriat. Hyderabad.
2. The State of Telangana, rep b, its Prl. Secretary (For Re r lnue, Registration
and Stamps Dept) Secretariat, Hyderabad.
3. The Commissioner and lnspector General, Stamps and ri -'gistration
Telangana Stale, Hyderabad
4. The Hbnble District Collector, Gadwala Jogulamba Distrc .
5. The District Registrar, Gadwala Jogulamba District.
6. The Sub Registrar, Alampur Gadwala Jogulamba Distrlct
7. M. Sreekanth Goud, S/o. Late [tI. Raman Goud, Aged.4[ Years, Occ.
Advocate, Fyo 7-4-8511 , Pedda Agraharam, Gadwal To't r, (Mahabubnagar
dist) (presently Jogulambha Gadwal District
...RES'ONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lnd z praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the ligh Court may be
pleased to issue an order, direction particularly one in tht: nature of WRIT OF
CERTIORARI or any other appropriate writ (i) call for th,: records pertain the
Doc.No. 1675 of '1997 86 1676 of 1997 Dt.27-12-199-,'registered at SRO,
Alampur, where as no such rights or power to the execubr, further well knowing
the same as no flow of title to the 7th respondent as such rrr rights confer to hrm
for the petitioners owned lands in Sy. No. 155 and, 156, ai neasuring an Extent
of Ac 15-29 gts Situated at Konderu Village ltikyala l'4andal of Gadwal
Jogulambha district earlier in N/habubnagar Dist and QUAS- the Doc.No. 1675 of
1997 and 1676 of '1997 Dt. 27 -12-1997 registered at SRO, /\ rmpur is as abuse of
process of law as actual owners of the such property is petit )ners by virtue of the
Registered Sale deeds vide document No.204 of 1980 36 205 of 980 dt.
'1
16.04.1980 are very much available on his records, as suc" those 2nd registered
documents without title are liable to set-a-side as those ar ) not for the law and
got by mischief, played fraud without any title to the resport ent No. 7 as there is
no such rights conferred to the executants as per the law cr under the law, as per
the Settled law of the Hon'ble Apex Court judgment squ rely covered in Civil
Appeal No. 27 52 and 27 53 of 2022 DaIed. 4-3-2022 basing on the representation
daled 221612023 made by the petitioner
lA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to
Direct the official respondents not to make/entertain any further registrations from
the flow of wrong title holders Doc.No. 1675 of 1997 and 1676 of 1997 D|.27-121997 registered at sRo, Alampur pending disposal of the writ, pending disposal
of the above writ petition.
lA NO: 2 OF 2023
Between:
l.HariianKarna,S/o.Gokari,Age5lyears,OccPvtworks,FI/oKondair
'rVinoat,
Gadwal
Vild'g", itiivar
(Mahablbnagai dist) (presentlv Jogulambha
District.
s/o. Gokari, Age 53 years, occ. Pvt, works, R/o.Kondair
z.
- nariijn Lalanna,
-nirvri
Jogulambha Gadwal
ViffjJ",
M"noit, (MahabuSnagar'dist) (presently
District.
...PETITIONERS/PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana, rep by its Chief SecretaryTecretariat, Hyderaba,d.
2. The state of Telangana, rep by rts Prl. secretary (For Revenue, Registratlon
and Stamps Dept) Secretariat, Hy{erabad
^
and Registration
s. ine Commissioh6r and lnspectoi General, Stamps
Telanoana State, HYderabad
-Collector,
Gadwala Jogulamba District'
4. The Hinble District
Jogulamba District'
Gadwala
5. The District Registrar,
Jogulamba District
Gadwala
Alampur
SuO Regisirar,
O. fh"-Sreet.ant"h
Aged 40 Ye-a1s.' Qcq
RamariGoud,
M.
S/o.'Late
Goud,
7. rr/.
Advocate,R/o,7-4-85ll,PeddaAgraharam,GadwalTown,(Mahabubnagar
dist) (presenttv Jogutambha Gadwal r'.,tlL,iaaro*DENTS/RESpoNDENTS
B- Sri Karnam Ram Rao, S/o Chinna Subba Rao' Aged about 78 years' Occ:
Aoriculture, R/o. Konderu (V), itikyala (M), (lt/ahbubnagar) Presently
Jotulamba Gadwal District.
s.
SiiKiihin nJo, S/o. Chinna Subba Rao, Aged about 68 vears' occ:
- AgriCJltrie,
R/o. Konderu (V), ltikyala (M), (lMahbubnagar) Presentlv
Jogulamba Gadwal District.
(The names and addresses as per their sale deeds)
...RESPONDENTS/PROPOSED RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the cirr umstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cou 1 may be pleased to
implead the proposed respondents Nos. 8 and 9 as respon J )nts Nos. 8 and 9 in
the Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI G.L.NARASIMHA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: GP FOR GENERAL ADl, NISTRATION
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 TO 6: GP FOR REVENt, :
Counsel for the Respondent No.7: SRI D.JAGAN MOHAN ll :DDY
The Court made the following: COMMON JUDGMENT
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELAN GANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
WRIT APPEAL NO.1OO6 OF 2024 AND WRIT PETITION NO.2O89O
oF 2023
DATE:27.02.2o26
W.A.NO.1006 0F 2024
Between:
Harijan Karna,
S/o. Cokari and Another.
Appe IIan ts
Aud
M. Sreekanth Goud,
S/o. Late M Raman Goud and Three Others
Respondents
Mr. G.1,. Narasimha Rao, learned counsel appearing for the appellants.
Mr. l). Jagan Mohan Reddy, Iearned counsel appearing for the resPondent No- I in
W.A.No. 1006 of 2O24 aod for the respondent No.7 in W.P.No.20890 of 2023.
COMMON JUDGMENT:
l.
(Per Hon'bte Justice Moushumi Bhattachar-va)
The Writ. Appeal arises out of an order dated 10.03.2023
passed in W.P.No.S413 ol 2015 by a learned Single Judge of this
Court, allowing the Writ Petition hled by the respondent No.l for
setting aside a Notice dated 31.01.2015 issued by the respondent
No.3/ Revenue Divisional Officer, Gadwal Division, Gadwal Town,
Mahabubnagar District to the writ petitioner, asking the writ
petitioner to appear before the Revenue Divisional Officer, Gadwal on
07.O2.2OI4 at 03:OO P.M . to adduce evidence in sup tort of his claim
in an 'Appeal' liled by the appellants herein be i re the Revenue
Divisional Officer, Gadwal
we hrsr *'ish to nore thar the Notice dated 3l o1.2or5 should
have been set aside on the sole ground that the u r t p<:titioner was
askcd to appear before the Revenue Divisional OII:er, Gadwal,
on
07.O2.2OI4, rvhereas the Notice for the writ petitit,r er,s appearance
is dated 31.01 .20 1S.
3.
The learned Single Judge allowed the Wri petrtion on the
ground that as per section g(2) of The Andhra F r rdesh
Rights in
Land and Patradar pass Books Act, 1971 (,the 1971 ActJ,
respondent Nos.4 and 5 (appellants herein) are reqrr red
the
to approach
the competent Civil Court to redress their grievance,;
4.
The appcllants, u,ho were the respondent No,;4 and
respondents in rhe Writ petition, opposed the
S/private
1r.i 1,er of the writ
petitioner, who is the respondent No.1 herein, ltr:
tre the learned
Single Judge.
5.
We havc heard learned counsel appearing fo- the parties
and
find substancc in the contention made on be I rlf of the
writ
petitioner that the Revenue Divisional Officer, (ir
twal, treated a
representation dated Og.0g.2012 made by the
appellants for
--correction of revenue records and issuance of pattadar passbooks
and title deeds, as an APPeal.
6.
The learned Single Judge in the impugned order dated
10 .O3.2O23
, held that the representation of the appellants dated
O8.O8.2O12 cannot be treated as an Appeal by the concerned
authority as it is not in the proper format.
7.
The statutory provision pertaining to the institution o[ an
Appeal is contained in section 5 of the 1971 Act which pertains to
the Amendment and Updating of Record of Rights'' Clause (5)
thereof, provides that an Appeal shall lie to such authority as may be
prescribed, against every order of the recording authority either
making an amendment in the Record of Rights or refusing to make
such an amendment, within a period of sixty days from the date of
communication of the said order.
8.
Further, Rule 21 of The Andhra Pradesh Rights in Land and
Pattadar Pass Books Rules, 1989 ('the 1989 Rules') outlines the
procedure to be followed for instituting an Appeal under section 5(5)
of the 1971 Act. Sub-Rule(l) thereof, provides that Appeals against
orders of the Mandal Revenue Officer, either making an
amendment in the Record of Rights or refusing to make
such amendment, would Iie lo the Revenue Divisional
Officer/ sub-Collector/Assistant Collector or such authority as may
\'-'-
a-E
qtr3arq:'
--'
be notihed by the Commissioner. Sub-Rule (2) thereo
prescribes the
manner in which an Appeal is to be filed i.e., the Alr real must be in
writing and contain the grounds of Appeal, besides rescribing sixty
days from thc clate of communication of the order: s the limitation
period lor filing the same. Under sub-Rule (3) the - of, a Court fee
stamp of Rs. 5/ - is to be affixed to the Appeal.
9.
From a bare reading of section 5(5) of the 1!' 1 Act and Rule
2llll ot the 1989 Rules, it is clear that an Appeal to the Revenue
Divisional Officer, is provided against every order ,l' the recording
authority either making an amendment in the Re: ,rd of Rights or
refusing to make such an amendment. However in the case on
hand, in the representalion dated 08.08.2012 to t re Ofhce of the
Revenue Divisional Of[rcer, Gadwal, the appellants lr Lve simply made
a request for the implementation of their names it the Record of
Rights and Pahanis by conducting a formz L inquiry and
subsequently, the issuance of valid Title Decrl , and Pattadar
Passbooks with respect to the land in Survey Nos. 1li i and 156.
10. A perusal of the record i.e., the inquir reports of the
respondent No.4/Olfice o[
the Tahsildar, rikyal Mandal,
Mahabubnagar District dated 12.12.2013 and O( . )1.2014, reveals
that lands in Survey Nos. 155/A to the extent of Ar:. 5.06, 155/AA to
the extent of Ac. 5.O7 and 156/Al to the extent of :. 5.26 had been
^
W
H.
r)/
purchased by the respondent No. I from its previous pattedars vide
registered Sale Deeds in 1997 , pursuant to which the name of the
respondent No. l was implemented in the Revenue Records in the
same year, and since then the respondent No. t has been in
possession and enjoyment of the said lands. However, the
representation dated 08.08.2012 neither mentions nor challenges
the entries in the Revenue Records made in favour of the respondent
No.1.
11.
Further, the reprcsentation is not in the format as prescribed
under sub-Rules (2) and (3) of Rule 2l of the 1989 Rules as it lacks
the grounds for Appeal and the afhxation of the requisite Court fee
sEmp. It is also evident that as per section 5(5) of the 1971 Act read
with Rule 2l (21 of the 1989 Rules, the representation has neither
been filed within the prescribed limitation period of sixty days nor
has any application for condonation of delay been fiied, so as to
occasion the representation dated O8.O8.2O12 being entertained as
an Appeal.
12.
In the present case, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants concedes that the representation made by the appellants
to the Revenue Divisional Officer, Gadwal, on O8'O8'2O12 is not an
Appeat but a representation and that the appellants have also not
Iiled any Appeal zrs contemplated- under section 5(5 rl the 1971 Act
read with Rule 2 I of the 1989 Rules.
13.
Hence, it is clear that the Revenue Division:rl )fficer, Gadwal,
could not have treatecl the representation as an A 1 peal within the
contemplation of the statutory framework under tlr: 1971 Act and
the 1989 Rules and summoncd the u,rit petitioner r r a hearing and
to clefend his claim.
74.
Thus, we do not hnd any reason or basis for t re appellants to
be aggrieved by the impugned order dated 10.03.20, 3 passed by the
learned Single Judge. It is left oper-r to the a1r ellants to take
recourse to the statutory remedies provided under tli : 1971 Act.
15.
W.A.No.1006 of 2024 is found to be u'ithout r nv merit and is
accordingly dismissecl. lnterim orders, if any, shi I stand vacated.
'lhere shall be no orders as to costs.
16.
The Registry is directed [o post Writ petition r r.2Og9O of 2023
before the Court having the relevant Roster.
SD/. P.CI'NAGABHUSHAMBA
IIEPUW REGISTRAR
(7
//TRUE COPY/'
To
1. The Secretary (Revenue Department)' Secretariat'
SECTION OFFICER
Hyc :rabad' State of
Telanoana.
Division' Gadi'tz Town'
,' il5R%1;re Division officer, Gadwal
Jogulambha Gadwal I istrict'
iffiil;il;;;iiiJittl ,lpr"t",itlv
(r .esently Jogulambha
3. The Tahasildar, ltikyal Mandal. (Mahabubnagar dist)
Gadwal District.
State of elanqana
+. ifrJ'i-ni""t's"Jietary Secretariat. Hvderabad'
Revenue' Regist'' tion and Stamps
Prl. Secretary , se.i"1,,iat if&
' The
Dept), Hvderabad. State of Telanqana'
6. The Commissioner and lnspector General, Stamps and Registration
Telangana State, Hyderabad
7. The Hon'ble District Collector, Gadwala Jogulamba District.
8. The District Registrar, Gadwala Jogulamba Disirict.
9. The Sub Registrar, Alampur Gadwala Jogulamba District.
10.The Registrar (Judicial-l), High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad.
11.The Section Officer, ER Section, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad.
12.The Section Officer, Writ Non-Service Section, High Court for the State of
Telangana, at Hyderabad.
'l 3. The Section Officer, Posting Section, High Court for the State of Telangana,
at Hyderabad.
14.One CC to SRI G.L.NARASIMHA RAO, Advocate [OPUC]
15. One CC to SRI D.JAGAN MOHAN REDDY, Advocate [OPUC]
16.Two CCs to GP FOR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad. [OUT]
17. Two CD Copies
PSK
TKS
b-
HIGH COURT
DATED:2710212026
\
\
NOTE: Registry is directed to post vl P.No.20890 0f
2023 before the court havinq the tt rlevant Roster
'Itit:
:
/..t
S
.i\'
COMMON JUDGMENT
WA.No.1006 of 2024
AND
WP.No.20890 of 2023
',r
.J
{ I Ail ?YF
*
o-
-n:
)i-
DISMISSING THE WRIT APPEAL AND 'OSTING THE
WP.No.20890 OF 2023 BEFORE THE (l OURT
HAVING THE RELEVANT ROSTER
WITHOUT COSTS
cl"
aO sTl
Y(e
a!
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review