Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
APHC010609472018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3547]
MONDAY,THE FIFTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2358/2018
Between:
1. HARI @ NARA HARI AND ANOTHER, R/O. SANKARAYYAGUNTA,
CHITTOR DISTRICT-A.P
2. AMMULU, R/O. KATTAMANCHI
MANDAL, CHITTOR DISTRICT A.P
HWADA,
BANGARUPALYAM
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Rep., by Public Prosecutor, (A.P) High
Court at Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying that the High
Court may be pleased to to present this Memorandum of Grounds of Appeal
questioning their conviction and sentence in Judgment dated 13.01.2018 in
S.C No. 393 of 2009 on the file of the Court of the IX Additional District and
Sessions Judge, Chittoor, A.P
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 135 days in preferring the appeal against the Judgment
dated 13.01.2018 in S.C No. 393 of 2009 on the file of the Court of the IX
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Chittoor, A.P
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
fix an early date of hearing of in CrI.A.No. 2358 of 2018 and to pass
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. A GAYATRI REDDY
2. Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH :: AMARAVATI
MONDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF JANUARY, TWO THOUSAND AND
TWENTY SIX
SPECIAL DIVISION BENCH
PRESENT
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
And
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBBAREDDY SATTI
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.2358 of 2018
JUDGMENT: (Per Justice K. Suresh Reddy)
Both the accused in Sessions Case No.393 of 2009 on the file of the
Court of IX Additional District and Sessions Judge, Chittoor, are the
appellants. They were tried by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Chittoor
under the following charges.
(i) First charge was under Section 457 IPC against both the accused.
(ii) Second charge was under Section 380 IPC against both the accused
(iii) Third charge was under Section 302 IPC against both the accused
and
(iv)
Last charge was under Section 411 IPC against both the
accused.
2. Substance of the charge is that on the night of 11.04.2009, both the
accused, trespassed into the house of R. Kanthamma (hereinafter referred to
as „the deceased‟) situated at Municipal Colony, Chittoor, and committed theft
of M.Os.1 to 4 and caused her death, thereby committed offences punishable
under Sections 457, 380, 302 and 411 IPC.
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
3. After completion of trial, the learned Additional Sessions Judge
convicted both the accused under Section 302 IPC and sentenced each of
them to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for “LIFE” and also to pay a fine of
Rs.500/- each,
in default to undergo Simple Imprisonment for a period of
three (3) months each. The learned Additional Sessions Judge further
convicted both the accused under Section 457 IPC and sentenced each of
them to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for three (3) years and also to pay a
fine of Rs.100/- each, in default to undergo Simple Imprisonment for a period
of one month each. The learned Additional Sessions Judge further convicted
both the accused under Section 380 IPC and sentenced each of them to
undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for three (3) years and also to pay a fine of
Rs.100/- each, in default to undergo Simple Imprisonment for a period of one
month each. All the substantive sentences were directed to run concurrently.
4. Case of the prosecution, briefly, is as follows:
Both the accused as well as the material prosecution witnesses are
residents of Chittoor. The deceased was also resident of Chittoor. Accused
No.2 is the second wife of Accused No.1. P.Ws.1 and 5 are sons and P.W.6 is
daughter of the deceased respectively. The deceased was residing alone in
her house. P.W.5 was living at Bangalore, whereas P.W.1 was staying at his
in-laws’ house at Vellore. P.W.1 was practising as an RMP Doctor at Chittoor
and was running a clinic near Renuka Kalyana Mandapam.
(ii) On 12.04.2009, P.W.1 attended his clinic in the morning and
thereafter proceeded to the house of the deceased at about 3.15 p.m. He
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
found the door of the house locked from inside and opened the same with the
key available with him. Upon entering the bedroom and calling his mother,
there was no response. He then noticed that the deceased was lying dead
and that blood was oozing from her mouth. He further observed that the gold
chain and ear studs worn by the deceased were missing. At about 4.20 p.m.
on the same day, P.W.1 approached the Police Station and lodged a report.
(iii) P.W.23- the then Inspector of Police, C.C.S. Chitoor, received
Ex.P1-report from P.W.1 and registered a case in Crime No.70 of 2009 under
Sections 302 and 379 IPC. He issued copies of FIR to all the concerned.
Ex.P27 is the FIR. Immediately he summoned Clues Team and Dog Squad to
the scene of offence. At about 5.15 p.m., P.W.23, along with his staff, visited
the scene of offence, secured the presence of P.W.1 and recorded his
statement. By then, the Clues Team had reached the scene of offence.
(iv) P.W.22, the then Inspector of Police and In-charge of the Finger
Print Unit of the Clues Team, Chittoor, collected chance fingerprints from the
side door of the kitchen. The chance prints were marked as Ex.P22 and the
chance report as Ex.P21. He also obtained the fingerprints of A1 and A2,
which were marked as Exs.P23 and P24 respectively. Finger Print Report was
marked as Ex.P25 and Ex.P26 is the Comparison Chart. The chance prints
obtained from the scene of offence were tallied with the admitted fingerprints
of A1.
(v) At the same time, P.W.3-Head Constable attached to the Dog
Squad and handler of the dog, visited the scene of offence. According to
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
P.W.3, the dog tracked from the scene of offence to the thatched hut of A1
and A2. Dog Squad Mahazar was marked as Ex.P2.
(vi) P.W.23 made enquiries with the owner of the brick kiln, who stated
that both the accused were residing in the said thatched hut. He prepared a
rough sketch-Ex.P29 at brick kiln premises. He recorded statements of
witnesses present there. Thereafter, he returned to the scene of offence and
recorded statements of P.Ws.4 and 19. On the following day, he again visited
the scene of offence and recorded statements of P.Ws.5 and 6. He held
inquest over the dead body in the presence of her blood relatives and
mediators-P.W.14 and another. Inquest Report was marked as Ex.P10. After
conducting inquest, he seized the clothes worn by the deceased and
thereafter sent the dead body for postmortem examination.
(vii) P.W.11, the then Civil Assistant Surgeon, Government Hospital,
Chittoor, conducted autopsy over the dead body of the deceased. He opined
the cause of death was due to asphyxia caused by throttling or strangulation.
He issued Preliminary Postmortem Certificate-Ex.P7. After receiving RFSL
Report -Ex.P8, he gave his final opinion under Ex.P9.
(viii) On 29.04.2009, P.W.23 apprehended both the accused near
Mangalam area at Tirupati in the presence of mediators-P.W.17 and another.
Both the accused said to have confessed about the commission of offence.
Pursuant thereto, P.W.23 seized an amount of Rs.9,300/- and two receipts
marked as Exs.P4 and P13 from A1 under a seizure mahazar marked as
Ex.P14. He also seized a mobile phone-MO.3, from A2. In consequence of the
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
said confession, MO.1 gold chain belonging to the deceased was recovered
from the shop of the pawn broker-P.W.9, under a cover of panchanamaEx.P5, in the presence of P.W.8 and another. P.W.23 also recorded
statements of P.Ws.9 and 10. Thereafter, pursuant to the confession, MO.2
ear studs were recovered from Raghavendra Jewellers, Bazar Street,
Chittoor, under a cover of panchanama Ex.P15, in the presence of mediators.
(ix) On 30.04.2009, P.W.15 conducted a Property Test Identification
Parade, in which P.W.1 identified MOs.1 and 2. Identification proceedings
were marked as Ex.P11. On 03.05.2009, P.W.23 sent the blood-stained
clothes to FSL, Hyderabad, and the FSL Report was marked as Ex.P33. On
08.05.2009, P.W.21, the then Special Judicial Magistrate of First Class for
Excise, Chittoor, conducted a Test Identification Parade of the accused, in
which P.W.9 identified both the accused. The proceedings thereof were
marked as Ex.P19.
(x) P.W.23 also forwarded the thyroid cartilage and hyoid bone for
expert opinion to the Forensic Professor, S.V. Medical College, Tirupati. RFSL
Report was marked as Ex.P33. After collecting all the documents and after
completition of investigation, P.W.23 laid the charge sheet.
5. In support of its case, the prosecution examined PWs.1 to 23, got
marked Exs.P.1 to P.33, apart from exhibiting MOs.1 to 5.
6. When the accused were examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C., they
denied the incriminating evidence found against them from the prosecution
witnesses.
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
7. Accepting the evidence of prosecution witnesses, the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, convicted and sentenced accused Nos.1 and 2 as
aforesaid.
8. Heard Smt. A.Gayatri Reddy, learned counsel for the appellantsaccused Nos. 1 and 2 as well as Sri Marri Venkata Ramana, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor for the respondent-State. We have carefully
analyzed the entire evidence on record.
9. Admittedly, the prosecution case rests entirely on circumstantial
evidence, as there are no eye witnesses to the occurrence.
10. The first circumstance relied upon by the prosecution is the “last
seen theory.” In order to establish the said circumstance, the prosecution
examined P.W.4. In his evidence, P.W.4 stated that he was acquainted with
both the appellants/accused and that, on the fateful day at about 8.30 p.m.,
after supplying milk to the residents and while returning to his house situated
near the house of the deceased, he noticed both the appellants/accused
present near the house of the deceased, chitchatting with each other. Though
P.W.4 was cross-examined by the defence, nothing adverse has been elicited
to discredit his evidence. Therefore, the prosecution has been able to
establish that both the appellants/accused were seen near the house of the
deceased at the relevant point of time.
11. The second circumstance relied upon by the prosecution pertains to
the fingerprints found at the house of the deceased. In order to establish this
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
circumstance, the prosecution examined P.W.22- the then Inspector of Police
and In-charge of the Finger Print Unit of the Clues Team, Chittoor.
12. P.W.22, in his evidence, categorically stated that he collected
chance prints from the side door of the kitchen of the house of the deceased.
He further stated that he obtained the admitted finger prints of the
appellants/accused from the jail authorities and submitted his report under
Ex.P25. According to him, the chance prints obtained from the side door of the
kitchen of the house of the deceased were tallied with the admitted finger
prints of appellant No.1/Accused No.1. Though P.W.22 was subjected to
cross-examination, nothing material or adverse could be elicited to discredit
his testimony. Hence, the prosecution has been able to satisfactorily establish
the second circumstance.
13. So far as the third circumstance, i.e. the tracking by the Dog Squad,
is concerned, the prosecution examined P.W.3. P.W.3, in his testimony,
categorically stated that the sniffer dog tracked from the scene of offence to
the thatched hut of the appellants/accused. The Dog Squad Mahazar was
marked as Ex.P2. Though the Dog Squad report was brought on record, the
learned trial Judge has held that the said circumstance cannot be made the
sole basis for conviction, in view of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Surinder Pal Jain v. Delhi Administration1.
14. The next circumstance relied upon by the prosecution pertains to
the arrest of the appellants/accused. In this regard, the prosecution examined
AIR 1993 SC 1723
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
P.W.17. P.W.17, in his testimony, categorically stated that both the
appellants/accused were apprehended by P.W.23 in his presence on
29.04.2009 near Mangalam area, Tirupati. He further stated that P.W.23
seized an amount of Rs.9,300/- along with receipts marked as Exs.P4 and
P13 from the possession of appellant/accused No.1. He also stated that both
the appellants/accused made confessional statements with regard to the
commission of the offence. Thus, the prosecution has been able to establish
the arrest of both the appellants/ accused on 29.04.2009.
15. The last circumstance relied upon by the prosecution relates to the
recovery of MOs.1 and 2, namely, the gold chain and gold ear studs belonging
to the deceased, at the instance of the appellants/accused. To establish this
circumstance, the prosecution relied upon the evidence of P.Ws.8 to 10 and
17, coupled with the evidence of P.W.23.
16. P.W.8, in his evidence, categorically stated that on 12.04.2009, the
appellants/A1 and A2 approached him stating that they intended to sell a gold
chain belonging to appellant No.2/A2 and deposit the sale proceeds in the
names of their children. He further stated that on 13.04.2009, he, along with
the appellants/A1 and A2, went to the shop of P.W.9, where the gold chain
was pledged, pursuant to which an amount of Rs.20,000/- was received on
the same day and a further sum of Rs.9,350/- was received on the following
day.
17. P.W.9, the owner of the jewellery shop, corroborated the testimony
of P.W.8 and stated that the appellants/A1 and A2 pledged the gold chain with
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
him and received cash of Rs.29,350/-. He further stated that he issued a
receipt for the said transaction, which was marked as Ex.P4. Pursuant thereto,
P.W.23 seized MO.1 in the presence of mediators-P.W.17 and another.
P.W.10 also deposed that MOs.1 and 2 were recovered at the instance of the
appellants/accused. Though P.Ws.8 to 10 and 17 were subjected to lengthy
cross-examination, nothing adverse has been elicited from their evidence.
Further, MOs.1 and 2 were identified by P.W.1 during the Property Test
Identification Parade conducted by P.W.15. Therefore, the prosecution could
able to prove the recovery of MOs.1 and 2 at the instance of the
appellants/accused.
18. In this connection, it is trite that the Hon’ble Apex Court in a catena
of judgments including the decision in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of
Maharashtra2, has laid down five (5) golden principles, which govern a case
based only on circumstantial evidence:
“(1)
The circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be
drawn should be fully established.
(2)
The facts so established should be consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should
not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the
accused is guilty.
(3)
The circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and
tendency.
(4)
They should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one
to be followed, AND
(1981) 4 SCC 116
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
(5)
There must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave
any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the
innocence of the accused and must show that in all human
probability the act must have been done by the accused.”
19. In view of the facts and circumstances, the prosecution has proved
the guilt of the appellants/accused Nos.1 and 2 beyond reasonable doubt. The
circumstances relied upon by the prosecution form a complete and consistent
chain which unerringly point towards the guilt of the appellants alone, but not
to others. Having analysed the evidence carefully, we have no hesitation to
come to the conclusion that there are no grounds to interfere with the
conviction and sentence recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge.
20.
In the result, the present Criminal Appeal is dismissed confirming
the conviction and sentence passed by the learned IX Additional District and
Sessions Judge, Chittoor, in Sessions Case No.393 of 2009, dated
30.01.2018. Needless to state that the period already undergone by the
appellants/Accused Nos.1 and 2 shall be given set off under Section 428
Cr.P.C.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the Criminal Appeal, shall
stand closed.
________________________
JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
__________________________
JUSTICE SUBBAREDDY SATTI
Date: 05.01.2026
GR
KSR, J & SRS, J
Crl.A.No.2358 of 2018
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
And
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBBAREDDY SATTI
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.2358 of 2018
(Per Hon’ble Sri Justice K. Suresh Reddy)
Date: 05.01.2026
GR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review