Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:9929
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(C) No. 5608 of 2022
……
Harendra Nath Kewat S/o Late Jageshwar Nath Kewat
aged about 85 years, R/o Village-Kewatpara, Tin Bazar,
P.O. and P.S.-Dumka, Dist.-Dumka. …. Petitioner(s)
-VERSUS1. The State of Jharkhand through its Commissioner,
Sathal Pargana Division, officiating from his office at O/o
of the Ld. Commissioner, (SP) Division, P.O. and P.S., DistDumka.
2. Deputy Commissioner, Dumka, officiating from his
office at O/o of Ld. Deputy Commissioner, Dumka, P.O.
and P.S., Dist.-Dumka.
…..Respondent (s)
……
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondent (s)
……
: Mr. Parth Jalan, Adv
: Mr. Mohan Dubey, A.C. to A.G.
10/12.03.2026
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The relief sought by the petitioner is reproduced as
under:
For the issuance of an appropriate writ(s), order(s) or direction (s) for
quashing of the order dated 20th of April 2022 in RMR 237 of 18-19
(Annexure-7), wherein Respondent No. 1 has been pleased to direct
the demolition of all structures over Plot No. 1120 and further cancel
the mutation of the name of Bhagwania Khewatin; the predecessorin-interest of the Petitioner and enter the land in the Anaabad Khata
as the same is perverse, illegal and without any jurisdiction;
For the issuance of an appropriate writ(s), order(s) or direction(s) for
quashing of the order dated 3rd of June, 2014 passed in RMP Case
No. 2 of 2012-13, (Annexure-4) wherein it has been stated that any
document for transfer of within Plot No. 1120 should not be
accepted, as the same is entirely illegal and without jurisdiction.
For the issuance of an appropriate writ (s), orders) or direction(s) for
quashing of the order dated 28th of July 2015 passed in RMP Case
No. 2 of 2012-13, (Annexure-5) wherein the case being RMP Case
No. 2 of 2012-13 was adjourned with respect to the land marked as
2026:JHHC:9929
Plot No, 1120, despite the fact that the WP(C) 1305 of 2014 was
with respect to Plot No. 1121 and as such the same is perverse and
passed in a routine and mechanical manner.
For the issuance of such other writ (s), order(s), or direction(s) as
this Hon'ble Court may think just and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the case doing conscionable justice to the
petitioner.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner purchased the property falling within MouzaKuruwachak ragunath Ganj No. 5/9 in the Anchal-Dumka,
Thana-Dumka
Nagar,
appertaining
to
Plot
No.
admeasuring an area of 1 Acre, 3 decimals and 2/3 dhurs
for a consideration of ₹ 18,700/- (INR Eighteen Thousand
Seven Hundred Only) vide registered sale deed dated
2.5.1997 from one Bhagwantia Keotin. The property of the
petitioner is part of a larger property admeasuring a total of
4 bighas 7 decimal and 3 dhurs which stood recorded in the
record of right in the name of one Shafali Bala Dey.
After the settlement of the land in the favour of
Shafali Bala Dey, rent receipts were issued in her name
pursuant to the case being jamabandi no. 63/10. A part of
the property admeasuring an area of 3 Acre and 10 decimals
was sold to one Bhagwania Keotin vide registered sale deed
dated 12.4.1972 for a consideration of ₹ 4,000/- (INR Four
Thousand Only). A mutation case, being Mutation Case no.
2026:JHHC:9929
54 of 1972-73, was initiated by Bhagwania Keotin. The same
was allowed vide the order dated 30.1.1973.
Ld. Counsel for the petitioner has drawn the
attention of this Court to a report dated the Circle Officer,
wherein it is clearly stated that the name of Shafali Bala
Dey, is recorded as a tenant. The report further states that
the possession of the land is with Bhagwania Keotin and
there was no objection from the 16 anna raiyat if mutation is
allowed.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits
that after mutation, Bhagwanti Keotin filed an application
before the Settlement Officer, Dumka for correction of the
settlement entry. The said case was registered as MP Case
No. 3 of 1983, which was decided in her favour on
26.3.1984. The right, title and interest of Shafali Bala Dey
over the property was recognized as evident in the order
dated 26.3.1984, wherein her name was confirmed as
basauri
raiyat,
and
accordingly,
a
correction
in
the
settlement entry was allowed in favour of Bhagwanti Keotin.
It is further submitted that the petitioner intended
to sell a portion of the land to one Pinky Devi; however,
when the sale deed dated 16.1.2019 was presented for
registration, the same was not done. Upon enquiry, the
2026:JHHC:9929
petitioner came to know about the order dated 3.6.2014
passed in RMP Case No. 2 of 2012-13, by which Respondent
No. 2 has barred the registration of any deeds/documents
for Plots Nos. 1120 and 1121.
The petitioner assailed the order dated 3.6.2014
passed in RMP Case No. 2 of 2012-13 by filing an
application before Respondent No. 1. The petitioner’s
application was registered as RMR No. 237 of 2018-19.
Albeit an initial stay was granted by Respondent No. 1, the
application was ultimately dismissed on 20.4.2022, wherein
the jamabandi of the petitioner and his predecessor-ininterest (Bhagwantia Keotin) was annulled, and it was stated
that all the structures over the land be demolished.
5.
On the basis of the aforesaid facts, the Ld. Counsel
for the petitioner submits the jamabandi of the petitioner
has been running for a long time. The jamabandi of the
petitioner’s
immediate
predecessor-in-interest
(i.e.,
Bhagwantia Keotin) is running since 1973 i.e. for more than
50 (fifty) years. The jamabandi of the predecessor-in-interest
of Bhagwantia Keotin (i.e., Shafali Bala Dey) is running from
an even longer period as jamabandi no. 63/10.
He further submits that the settlement of the land
in the name of Shafali Bala Dey and thereafter in the name
2026:JHHC:9929
of Bhagwantia Keotin is conclusive proof of their right, title
and interest. As the petitioner has purchased the property
forming the subject matter of the instant petition by virtue of
a registered deed from Bhagwantia Keotin; the right, title
and interest of the petitioner cannot be doubted. Reliance is
made to the case of Dhani Gope v. State of Jharkhand
and Ors (WP(C) 4258 of 2023), wherein this Court has held
that long-standing jamabandi cannot be cancelled.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner lastly submits
that the act of registration of a deed/document is ministerial
in nature and Respondent, while exercising powers under
the Registration Act, 1908 could not have passed a blanket
order curtailing registration of certain lands. The Ld.
Counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on the case of
Vinod Shankar Jha v. State of Jharkhand (WP(C) 3103
of 2020) and analogous cases wherein a co-ordinate
Bench of this Court had held that while registering a
document under the Registration Act, 1908, the authorities
are not vested with any quasi-judicial powers; rather, their
actions are ministerial in nature.
7.
Per contra, the Ld. Counsel for the State has
vehemently opposed the prayer of the petitioner. He submits
that land was recorded as a pond, therefore any settlement
2026:JHHC:9929
made in favour of a private individual is barred. Ld. Counsel
has placed reliance on para-12 of the counter-affidavit to
demonstrate that on this ground the settlement in favour of
Shefali Bala Dey has been rejected by the Assistant
Settlement Officer and the same has attained finality.
8.
Learned counsel representing the State, further
submits that the sale deeds executed in the favour of
Bhagwantia Keotin and the petitioner are forged documents,
which have been prepared fraudulently and cannot be said
to bestow any right, title and interest upon the petitioner. He
submits that the scheduled land is a valuable piece of land
situated in the middle of the town of Dumka, and the
petitioner is making attempts to sell the land by forging
documents with the aid of certain officers.
He further submits that as the land is recorded as
‘Anabad Khata’ the land is government land and as such the
order is in accordance with law.
9.
In rejoinder, the Ld. Counsel representing the
petitioner submits that all the issues raised by the
respondents are seriously disputed and cannot be proved in
summary
proceedings.
He
further
submits
that
the
submission of the respondents that settlement in the favour
of Shafali Bala Dey was rejected and it attained finality is
2026:JHHC:9929
contrary to the records of the case as is evident from the
order dated 26.3.1984, which recognised the predecessorsin-interest of the petitioner (i.e., Shafali Bala Dey and
Bhagwantia Keotin) as basauri raiyats.
Further, the order on which reliance is placed by
the Respondent-State is also set aside by the order dated
26.3.1984. He further submits that ‘Anabad Khata’ is not
government land, and even if the land is recorded in the
‘Anabad Khata’, the petitioner’s right cannot be diluted.
10.
Having heard the parties and perused the record
and the impugned order, the following issues are framed for
the consideration of this Court: (i) Whether long-standing jamabandi running in the
favour of the petitioner (through his predecessor-ininterest) can be rejected on allegations of fraud ?
(ii) Whether the respondent is empowered to direct a
complete ban of registration of deeds/documents in
respect of a plot of land ?
11.
Coming to the first issue, the petitioner’s assertion
that a Jamabandi was created and running in the favour of
his predecessor-in-interest, i.e., Shafali Bala Dey and
Bhagwantia
Keotin,
is
not
disputed.
The
immediate
predecessor-in-interest of the petitioner, namely Bhagwantia
2026:JHHC:9929
Keotin, had a jamabandi running in name since 1973.
Before that jamabandi was running in the name of Shafali
Bala Dey as jamabandi no. 63/10. The State has accepted
rent from them and rent receipts have also been issued in
their favour. Once long standing jamabandi running in the
name
of
the
petitioner’s
predecessors-in-interest
is
established; the respondent-state can neither annul the
jamabandi running in the name of the predecessor-ininterest, nor the jamabandi running in the name of the
petitioner.
12.
It is trite law that the revenue authorities have no
jurisdiction to cancel a jamabandi, let alone a long-standing
jamabandi. In the case of Dhani Gope v. State of
Jharkhand
and
Ors
(WP(C)
of
2023),
while
adjudicating the scope of Section 4(h) of the Bihar Land
Reforms Act, 1950. This Court held that the power to annul
a long standing jamabandi lies only with the Ld. Civil Court
of competent jurisdiction. The jurisprudence behind lies in
the settled principle of law that decision of long standing
based on which persons have arranged their affairs should
not be disturbed lightly. The relevant portion of the
judgment is as under:“7……Moving on, when the revenue authority has no jurisdiction to
cancel the jamabandi, it cannot disturb a long standing jamabandi
created in favour of an individual. The jurisprudence behind not
2026:JHHC:9929
13.
disturbing a long standing jamabandi lies in the settled principle of
law that a decision of long standing based on which persons have
arranged their affairs should not be disturbed lightly. The Division
Bench of this Court in the case of The State of Jharkhand and
Ors. vs. Izhar Hussain (supra) held that long standing jamabandi
cannot be annulled only by the civil court of competent jurisdiction.
The relevant portion of the judgment is reproduced as under for
ready reference:“It is further settled that long running Jamabandi cannot be
cancelled, save and except by filing a suit before the
competent Court of Civil Jurisdiction, as has been held by
Hon'ble Apex Court in Ramayan Yadav & Ors. Vs. State of
Bihar & Ors. reported in MANU/BH/0374/2013 : (2013) 3
PLJR 533”
The State has tried to justify its above argument on
the basis that the application for settlement in favour of
Shafali Bala Dey was rejected by the Assistant Settlement
Officer, and as such, the Jamanabadi running in the favour
of the petitioner and his predecessors-in-interest has been
done on the basis of fraud and forged documents.
14.
This Court does not find much force in this
argument for two reasons. Firstly, the argument of the State
that the settlement in the name of Shafali Bala Dey was
rejected is contrary to what the records suggest. The order
dated 26.3.1984 passed in M.P Case No. 2 of 1983
(Annexure-SA/4) shows that the order of the Assistant
Settlement Officer by which the settlement in the name of
Shafali Bala Dey was disputed was set aside. Shafali Bala
Dey was recognised as basauri raiyats and therefore, a
correction of the settlement entry was made in favour of
Bhagwantia Keotin as he had purchased the land from
2026:JHHC:9929
Shafali Bala Dey. Bhagwantia Keotin sold the scheduled
land to the petitioner.
15.
Secondly, the mere allegation ‘fraud’ is not sufficient
to ignore the past proceedings and annul the jamabandi
running in the name of the petitioner and his predecessorin-interest. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of C.S.
Ramaswamy v. V.K. Senthil & Ors reported in (2022 SCC
Online SC 1330) has held that mere allegation of fraud is
not enough; rather it needs to be supported by specific
averment as how the fraud transpired. The relevant portion
of the judgement is reproduced as under:“ 31. Even the averments and allegations in the plaint with
respect to fraud are not supported by any further averments
and allegations how the fraud has been committed/played.
Mere stating in the plaint that a fraud has been played is not
enough and the allegations of fraud must be specifically
averred in the plaint, otherwise merely by using the word
“fraud”, the plaintiffs would try to get the suits within the
limitation, which otherwise may be barred by limitation.
Therefore,
even
if
the
submission
on
behalf
of
the
respondents - original plaintiffs that only the averments and
allegations in the plaints are required to be considered at the
time of deciding the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC
is accepted, in that case also by such vague allegations with
respect to the date of knowledge, the plaintiffs cannot be
permitted to challenge the documents after a period of 10
years. By such a clever drafting and using the word “fraud”,
the plaintiffs have tried to bring the suits within the period of
limitation invoking Section 17 of the limitation Act…….”
16.
In the case at hand, the Respondent seems to have
proceeded in utter haste and concluded that fraud has been
2026:JHHC:9929
committed. This Court has no hesitation in holding that the
conclusion arrived at by the respondents is based on
surmises and conjecture. Even otherwise, when such an
allegation of systematic fraud is alleged, the adjudication of
the same requires taking evidence which cannot be done in
summary proceedings.
17.
Before parting with this issue, it is also important to
point out that even otherwise, the order dated 20.4.2022 is
not passed in exercise of powers under Section 4(h) of the
Bihar Land Reforms Act, 1950; rather, the same is an
application filed by the petitioner by which he has assailed
the order passed in RMP Case No. 2 of 2012-13, as such
Respondent No. 1, stands vitiated, owing to inherent lack of
jurisdiction.
As such, the first issue is decided in favour of the
petitioner, and the order dated 20.4.2020 in RMR 237 of 1819, by which the long-standing jamabandi has been
annulled, is hereby set aside.
18.
The next issue pertains to the powers conferred to
the respondent authorities under the Registration Act, 1908.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Satya Pal Anand
v. State of Madhya Pradesh reported in (2016) 10 SCC
767, has held that the Registration Act, 1908, does not
2026:JHHC:9929
confer the authorities with any quasi-judicial powers.
Further, in the case of Brinda Devi Agarwal Vs. The State
of Jharkhand and Ors (WP(C) 847 of 2023), this Court,
while deciding the issue of inclusion of a property in the
prohibited list, held that denying registration of a document
affects the right of an individual to enjoy his property and
thus vitiates Article 300A of the Constitution of India.
19.
An identical issue came up before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in the case of K. Gopi Vs. The SubRegistrar and Ors (2025 INSC 462) wherein the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that the authorities cannot deny
registration of a document even if the title of the presenter is
disputed. The registration of a document cannot be denied
once all procedural requirements are met. The relevant
portion of the judgement is as under:“ 15. The registering officer is not concerned with the title held by
the executant. He has no adjudicatory power to decide whether the
executant has any title. Even if an executant executes a sale deed
or a lease in respect of a land in respect of which he has no title, the
registering officer cannot refuse to register the document if all the
procedural compliances are made and the necessary stamp duty as
well as registration charges/fee are paid. We may note here that
under the scheme of the 1908 Act, it is not the function of the SubRegistrar or Registering Authority to ascertain whether the vendor
has title to the property which he is seeking to transfer. Once the
registering authority is satisfied that the parties to the document are
present before him and the parties admit execution thereof before
him, subject to making procedural compliances as narrated above,
the document must be registered. The execution and registration of
2026:JHHC:9929
a document have the effect of transferring only those rights, if any,
that the executant possesses. If the executant has no right, title, or
interest in the property, the registered document cannot effect any
transfer.”
20.
In light of the law settled by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, this Court has no hesitation in holding that the order
dated 3.6.2014 passed in RMP Case No. 2 of 2012-13, by
which the registration of deeds/documents for the land
appertaining to Plot No. 1120 and 1121 was barred, is
wholly illegal and as such is set aside. The second issue
stands answered accordingly.
21.
Consequently, the instant writ petition is hereby
allowed. Pending IAs, if any, are closed. No order as to cost.
(Deepak Roshan, J)
12.03.2026
Amardeep/
Uploaded on
AFR/
09.04.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review