Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/18
GAHC040012202025
2026:GAU-AP:167
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/331/2025
Hano Moda
Son of Shri Hano Talang, presently residing at DFO Quarter, Opposite to DC
Bunglow, Komlighat Road, Pasighat, PO and PS Pasighat, East Siang District,
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 2 Ors
represented by the Principal Secretary, Department of Environment, Forest and
Climate Change, (EF and CC), Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
2:The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests and Head of Forest Force
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:Neeraj Tamuk
Age: 0
Occupation :
Assistant Conservator of Forest (on Probation) ACF Mobile Squad
CAC
Pasighat
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner : Khoda Tama, Radhe Sumpa,Tasso Dodung,R Barman,Khoda
Yubey,Jambey Tsering,T Lampung,Hinti Jeram
Advocate for the Respondent : Nikita Danggen; Kamal Saxena; Oken Duggong; Kirpi Nyorak;
Phurpa Wangmu; Nani Kuru; GA (AP), Kamal Saxena
Page No.# 2/18
Linked Case : WP(C)/445/2025
Hano Moda
Age: 40
Occupation :
Address:Son of Hano Talang
presently residing at DFO Quarter
Opposite to DC Banglaw
Komlighat Road
Pasighat
PO and PS Pasighat
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 2 Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the Principal Secretary
Department of Environment
Forest and Climate Change
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Pradesh
Itanagar.
2:The Principal Chief Conservator of Forest and Head of Forest Force
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:Neeraj Tamuk
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Assistant Conservator of Forest (on probation) ACF Mobile Squad
CAC
Pasighat
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
-----------Advocate for : Khoda Tama
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for The State of AP and 2 Ors: Advocate ,
Page No.# 3/18
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
18.02.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
18.02.2026
:
N/A
:
Yes
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Heard Mr. K. Tama, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Ms. G.
Ete, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate for the State respondent
Nos. 1 & 2 and Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel for the respondent No.3.
2.
The challenge made in this writ petition is to the order of transfer dated
16.07.2025, passed by the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (PCCF) & Head
of Forest Force (HoFF), [Environment, Forest & Climate Change (E, F & CC)],
Government of Arunachal Pradesh, whereby as many as 15 (fifteen) State
Forest Officers, including the petitioner and Respondent No. 3, have been
transferred and posted to different places of posting and also to the subsequent
order dated 05.09.2025, passed by the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests
(PCCF) & Head of Forest Force (HoFF), [Environment, Forest & Climate Change
(E, F & CC)], Government of Arunachal Pradesh, by which the representation of
the petitioner seeking retention at Pasighat has been rejected and the petitioner
Page No.# 4/18
has been directed to report to his new place of posting as Divisional Forest
Officer (DFO), Silviculture Division, Itanagar.
3.
The case, in brief, is that the petitioner is an Arunachal Pradesh Forest
Service Officer (APFS) serving in the cadre of Additional Deputy Conservator of
Forests (ADCF) and is presently posted as Divisional Forest Officer (DFO),
Pasighat Forest Division, Pasighat, pursuant to the transfer order dated
13.07.2023. While the petitioner was serving as DFO, Pasighat Forest Division,
vide order dated 16.07.2025 passed by the PCCF & HoFF (E, F & CC), as many
as 15 officers of the Forest Department, including the petitioner and Respondent
No. 3, have been transferred to different places of posting. The petitioner has
been transferred and posted as DFO, Silviculture, Itanagar and Respondent No.
3, who is serving as Assistant Conservator of Forests (ACF) on probation, has
been posted as DFO, Pasighat Forest Division, in place of the petitioner.
4.
According to the petitioner, the service conditions of the Arunachal
Pradesh Forest Service are governed by the Arunachal Pradesh Forest Service
Rules, 2019 (in short, the APFS Rules, 2019). As per Rule 3(2) thereof, there are
four grades of cadre, namely, Entry Grade, Senior Grade, Selection Grade and
Administrative Grade. The post of Assistant Conservator of Forests (ACF) falls
under the Entry Grade, whereas the post of Additional Deputy Conservator of
Forests (ADCF) is a Senior Grade post. A person appointed or promoted to the
Entry Grade of the service is required to undergo probation for a period of two
years. Schedule-I to the APFS Rules, 2019 prescribes the cadre strength of each
of the four grades of service. As per Schedule-I C, there are 19 posts of ADCFs
(Senior Grade), which include one post in the Pasighat Forest Division.
Schedule-I D provides for 22 posts of ACFs (Entry Grade), designated as
attached officers in various Forest Divisions.
Page No.# 5/18
5.
It is the contention of the petitioner that the Respondent No. 3 being an
ACF, an officer in the Entry Grade and that too on probation, is not eligible to
hold the post of DFO, Pasighat Forest Division, as the post of DFO, Pasighat
Forest Division is to be manned by the cadre of ADCF (Senior Grade). The
Respondent No. 3 has been promoted to the post of ACF (Entry Grade) only on
25.03.2025 and is still on probation for 2 years. Therefore, he is not even a
member of the regular service in the cadre of ACF. Even if his service is
confirmed as ACF, the Respondent No. 3 cannot be allowed to be posted and
hold the post of DFO as the same is to be mandatorily held by an officer in the
cadre of ADCF (Senior Grade).Therefore, the transfer of the petitioner, who is
entitled to hold the post of DFO, Pasighat Forest Division, by replacing him with
Respondent No. 3, who is an officer on probation and lower in the cadre, is not
permissible under law as it violates the service conditions provided in the APFS
Rules, 2019.
6.
Aggrieved by the impugned transfer order dated 16.07.2025, the petitioner
submitted a written representation on 19.07.2025, inter alia, stating that the
post of DFO, Pasighat is earmarked under Schedule I of the APFS Rules, 2019
for an officer of the Senior Grade, namely ADCF, to which cadre he belongs and
that his replacement by an officer lower in rank and not entitled to hold the said
post is illegal and therefore, sought retention as DFO, Pasighat.
7.
On his representation not being responded to, the petitioner filed WP(C)
No. 331/(AP) 2025. During the pendency of the writ petition, vide the
subsequent impugned order dated 05.09.2025, the IFS, PCCF & HoFF (E, F &
CC) disposed of the representation of the petitioner by directing him to report to
his new place of posting as DFO, Silviculture Division, Itanagar. Hence, the
present WP(C) No. 445/(AP) 2025 has been filed.
Page No.# 6/18
8.
Mr. K. Tama, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the impugned
transfer order dated 16.07.2025 is wholly illegal, inasmuch as the petitioner is
sought to be replaced by Respondent No. 3, who is only an ACF on probation
and is not legally eligible to hold the post of DFO, Pasighat, a post earmarked
for a Senior Grade officer in terms of the APFS Rules, 2019. The Rules clearly
provide that only officers in the Senior Grade, i.e., ADCF, can be appointed to
the post of DFO, Pasighat Forest Division. He further submits that the
subsequent rejection of the representation of the petitioner, vide order dated
05.09.2025, by the PCCF is equally arbitrary and illegal, as it was rejected
mechanically without considering the objections raised by the petitioner.
Therefore, since the very foundation of the impugned order is contrary to the
statutory provisions, the impugned transfer order is not sustainable.
9.
Mr. Tama, learned counsel, while referring to the judgment and order
passed by this Court in the case of Mori Riba vs. State of Arunachal
Pradesh& Ors., in WP(C) 76/(AP) 2025, dated 19.05.2025, submits that
this Court has already held that an ACF on probation cannot be posted as DFO
to a post earmarked for Senior Grade and had set aside a similar transfer order
as being illegal and arbitrary. He submits that the ratio of the said decision
squarely applies to the case of the petitioner, yet the authorities have ignored
this binding precedent and have allowed the illegality to perpetuate.
10.
Mr. Tama, learned counsel, submits that the impugned orders dated
16.07.2025 and 05.09.2025, not only violate the APFS Rules, 2019, but also
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India, as the respondent authorities
have sought to equate unequals by arbitrarily replacing the duly eligible Senior
Grade officer with an ineligible probationary Entry Grade officer. Accordingly, the
impugned orders dated 16.07.2025 and 05.09.2025 are manifestly arbitrary and
Page No.# 7/18
therefore, liable to be set aside and quashed.
11.
On the other hand, Ms. G. Ete, learned Additional Senior Government
Advocate for the State respondent Nos. 1 & 2, submits that it is true that
Respondent No. 3 was promoted to the post of ACF, Entry Grade, on 25.03.2025
and is on probation. However, there is no statutory provision under the APFS
Rules, 2019 which debars an APFS officer in the rank of ACF (Entry Grade), who
is on probation, from being transferred and posted to hold charge of DFO. She
submits that Pasighat Forest Division, being a cadre division, the post of DFO is
to be held by an IFS cadre officer. Due to non availability of sufficient IFS cadre
officers, the State Government, being the competent authority, may consider
posting a non cadre officer. She submits that transfer and posting is a normal
and routine exercise, which is essentially an administrative order for ensuring
optimal functioning and service delivery. It is the prerogative of the respondent
authorities to transfer their employees on administrative exigencies.
12.
Ms. G. Ete, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate, submits that
the petitioner, having completed his normal tenure, has been posted in the
same rank of DFO from Pasighat Forest Division to the Silviculture Division at
Itanagar as DFO. She contends that no legal right, much less any fundamental
right has been infringed and no prejudice has been caused to the petitioner.
Therefore, merely posting an officer below the cadre of the petitioner cannot be
termed illegal or arbitrary, as no right of the petitioner has been violated.
Accordingly, she submits that the writ petitions have no merit and are liable to
be dismissed.
13.
Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel for Respondent No. 3, while subscribing
to the submissions of the learned Additional Senior Government Advocate,
Page No.# 8/18
submits that as per Rule 27 of the APFS Rules, 2019, any member of the APFS
can be posted to a duty post as per the exigencies of service. As per Rules 25
and 26, even a non-member of the APFS can be appointed to hold a post on an
officiating basis in the event of a lack of adequate numbers of officers.
Therefore, it is not a hard and inviolable rule that the duty post at Pasighat
Forest Division is to be held only by the petitioner merely because he belongs to
the ADCF cadre. She submits that the Pasighat Forest Division is to be manned
by a Deputy Conservator of Forests (DCF), which is a cadre post for members of
the IFS. The petitioner, being an ADCF under the APFS, was also not originally
eligible to hold the post of DFO. However, due to the shortage of cadre posts of
DCF/IFS, the petitioner was allowed to hold the post, although he was not
eligible. Now, having been transferred after completing the normal tenure of
two years, he cannot claim that he cannot be transferred, in view of the fact
that no right of the petitioner has been violated.
14.
Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel, while placing reliance on the judgment
and order in the case of Er. Taban Tabing vs. The State of Arunachal
Pradesh & 2 Ors., dated 19.06.2025, passed by the Division Bench of this
Court in WA No. 21/(AP)2025, submits that so far as the reliance on the
order of this Court in Mori Riba (supra) by the learned counsel for the
petitioner is concerned, the facts and circumstances of that case are completely
different from the present case, as it involved frequent transfer. She submits
that the Division Bench, while considering the order in Mori Riba (supra), held
that, although it may be correct that normally inter se transfer between officers
who are not similarly placed may not be permissible, there is no complete bar to
transferring an officer serving on In-Charge, Officiating, or Functional basis in a
higher post, unless it causes prejudice or affects the service condition of the
Page No.# 9/18
officer who is being transferred to a different place of posting with the same
rank, status and benefits, depending on administrative exigencies. In the
present case, she submits that the petitioner has not made out any case for
interference by this Hon’ble Court, as no prejudice has been shown to have
been caused by the impugned transfer order. There is nothing on record to
indicate that his service conditions have been affected. In fact, the new place of
posting as DFO, Silviculture Division, is also a cadre division and the transfer
does not amount to a demotion or affect his service conditions. Therefore, she
submits that the writ petitions are liable to be dismissed.
15.
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsels for the parties
and also perused the materials available on record.
16.
The petitioner is an ADCF cadre officer in the APFS, whereas Respondent
No. 3 is an ACF cadre officer on probation, a cadre post below the ADCF. By the
impugned order dated 16.07.2025, the respondent authorities transferred as
many as 15 officers of the APFS, including the petitioner and Respondent No. 3.
17.
Essentially, the petitioner challenges the impugned transfer order in
respect of Respondent No. 3 on the ground that the post of DFO, Pasighat
Forest Division, has been earmarked for an ADCF cadre officer. Being an ADCF
cadre officer himself, the petitioner contends that Respondent No. 3 is not
eligible to hold the post of DFO in his place and that the replacement violates
Schedule-I C of the APFS Rules, 2019, as both officers are not similarly placed.
18.
To appreciate the matter, it is apposite to refer to the relevant provisions
of the APFS Rules, 2019, which is reproduced hereinbelow:
“...3. Constitution of service and its classification:
(1) There shall be constituted a State Forests Service to be known as Arunachal
Page No.# 10/18
Pradesh Forest Service.
(2) The service shall have the following 4(four) grades namely:(a) Entry Grade
(b) Senior Grade
(c) Selection Grade
(d) Administrative Grade
(3) The posts specified in all Grades shall be State Civil Services Group-"A"
(Gazetted) posts.
(AUTHORISED PERMANENT STRENGTH OF THE POSTS)
4.Strength of the Service:
The authorised permanent strength of the service and the posts included
therein shall be as specified in Schedule-I.
(i). The number of posts in Senior Grade of the service shall be 30% of the
duty posts inclusive of Deputation Reserve, Training Reserve and Leave Reserve.
(ii). The number of posts in Selection Grade of the service shall be 20% of the
duty posts inclusive of Deputation Reserve, Training Reserve and Leave Reserve
mentioned in Schedule-I.
(iii). The strength of the posts in the 'Administrative Grade' shall be as specified
in Schedule-I. (However, this strength should not exceed 15% of the duty posts,
inclusive of Deputation Reserve, Training Reserve and Leave Reserve).
(iv). Subject to such conditions and limitations as may be specified by the
Government, duty posts for such period by order may be created.
(v). The Government may, in consultation with the Commission, include in the
service, any posts other than those included in the said schedule.
(vi). The Government may, in consultation with the Commission, appoint to the
service the regular incumbent of such post which has boon included in the
service to permanent or temporary capacity, as may be deemed fit. The
suitability of such officers for appointment shall be assessed by the
Departmental Promotion Committee constituted under Rule-14.
(vii). Notwithstanding, anything contained in sub-rule (iv) and (v) of these
Rules, in case any regular Incumbent of such post which has been included in
the service under sub-rule (v) is not found suitable for appointment to the
Page No.# 11/18
service under sub-rule (vi), he will continue to hold the post and for the
purpose, the post will be treated to have been excluded from the service till it is
held by such incumbent. Such person may be reconsidered by the Committee at
appropriate occasions.
25. Selection for officiating appointment:
If at any time the Government is of the opinion that the number of
officers available in the list referred to in sub-rule (7) of Rule-15 for
appointment to duty posts is not adequate having regard to the vacancies in
such posts, it may direct the committee to consider the case of officers who
have officiated for a period of not less than 5 (five) years in any of the posts
mentioned in Schedule-I and prepare a separate list of officers selected. The
selection for inclusion in the list shall be based on merit and suitability in
respects for officiating appointments to duty posts with due regard to seniority.
The provision of sub-rule (3) to (8) of Rule-15 shall apply mutatis-mutandis in
the preparation of the list under this rule.
26. Officiating appointments to duty posts of the service:
(1). If any member of the service is not available for holding a duty post, the
post may be filled on an officiating basis:(a) by the appointment of an officer included in the list referred to in sub-rule
(7) of Rule-15, or
(b) If no such officer is available, by the appointment of an officer included in
the list prepared under Rule-25.
(2). Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules, if the exigencies of
public service so require, a duty post for which a member of the service is not
available, may be filled on an officiating basis with prior consultation with the
Commission by an officer belonging to a Forest Service of any of the State/UT
Government on deputation for such period or periods ordinarily not exceeding 3
(Three) years as the Government may consider it necessary.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules, where appointment to a
duty post is to be made purely as a local arrangement for a period of not
exceeding 6 (Six) months, such appointments may be made by the Government
from persons who are included in the list prepared under sub-rule (7) of Rule15 or who are eligible for inclusion in such a list.
(4) Any appointment made under sub-rule (3) above shall be reported by the
Government to the Commission forthwith.
27.Posting of member of the service:
(i). Every member of the service shall, unless he/she is appointed to an ex-
Page No.# 12/18
cadre post, or is otherwise not available for holding a duty post owing to the
exigencies of public service, be posted against a duty post under the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh in or outside the State by the Government.
(ii). A member in the service shall have compulsorily served a minimum tenure
of period in duty posts as may be specified by the Government from time to
time.
SCHEDULDE-I
C. Post under Additional Deputy Conservator of Forests as attached
Officer in various Forest Division as under (19 posts):
Sl. No. Name of Upgraded post No. of post
of APFS
Pay
Level
in
the Pay Matrix
Level-11,
Rs.
67700-208700
3.
Addl. Dy. Conservator
-do-
of Forests, Pasighat
Forests Division
19. A bare reading of the above rules shows that under the Arunachal Pradesh
Forest Service there shall be four grades, namely, Entry Grade, Senior Grade,
Selection Grade and Administrative Grade. The post of ACF falls under the Entry
Grade, whereas the post of ADCF is a Senior Grade post. The authorised
permanent strength of the service and the posts shall be as specified in
Schedule-I. Schedule-I C provides that posts under Additional Deputy
Conservator of Forests as attach officers in various Forest Divisions comprises 19
posts, including the Pasighat Forest Division, which means that an ADCF may be
attached as an officer in the said Division.
20. Rules 25, 26 and 27 pertain to officiating appointments and the posting of
members of the service on duty post, which, inter alia, provide that in the event
Page No.# 13/18
the Government is of the opinion that the number of officers available for
appointment to duty posts is not adequate having regard to the vacancies in
such posts, may be directed to consider from the officers who have officiated for
5 years, if no member of the service is available. The rules also reflect that
every member of the service shall, unless appointed to an ex-cadre post or
otherwise unavailable for holding a duty post owing to exigencies of public
service, be posted against a duty post under the Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, in or outside the State. Thus, the above rules have no relevancy in the
present case as it only relates to officiating appointments and duty post and
therefore, cannot be pressed into service.
21.
On perusal of Schedule-I C to the APFS Rules, 2019, no doubt, the post
under the ADCF as attached officer includes the Pasighat Forest Division;
however, it does not provide that the post of DFO is to be manned exclusively
by an ADCF cadre officer, as the DFO, Pasighat Forest Division, is fundamentally
a post for the IFS cadre officer, who would be DCF. The post of ADCF may be
attached to such a division; however, it cannot be construed that the DFO of
Pasighat Forest Division is to be held only by an ADCF officer and not by officers
of other cadres. There is no dispute regarding the posting of ADCF and other
cadre officers as DFO of the Forest Divisions and at the same time, certain
Forest Divisions, including Pasighat, are primarily, the posts to be manned by
DCF/IFS cadre officers.
22. It is also stated at the Bar that due to the lack of adequate DCF/IFS cadre
officers, the posts of DFO are being allowed to be held by ADCF and other cadre
officers. Thus, it cannot be said that the post of DFO, Pasighat Forest Division, is
exclusively to be manned by an ADCF cadre officer; rather, the post is to be held
by a DCF/IFS officer and in view of shortage of such officers, the post may be
Page No.# 14/18
held by an ADCF officer. Thus, the submission that the impugned order violates
the provisions of the APFS Rules, 2019, cannot be accepted, as the post of DFO,
Pasighat Forest Division, is not exclusively earmarked for the ADCF cadre officer
in which the petitioner is serving.
23.
It is true that, under normal circumstances, inter se transfers of officers
who are not in the same cadre or of equal rank may not be permissible.
However, there is no absolute bar to such transfers if the respondent authorities
allow officers with sufficient experience to be posted to a higher post, provided
that the transfer is in the interest of administrative exigencies and public
service.
24.
The learned counsel for the petitioner, on a pointed query by this Court
during the hearing as to whether any right of the petitioner had been violated,
fairly submitted that no right is infringed as such, however, the transfer of
Respondent No. 3 as DFO, Pasighat Forest Division, amounts to replacement by
an officer of lower rank, which, according to him, is not permissible under law.
The learned counsel for the petitioner having admitted this position and the
petitioner having been transferred as DFO, Silviculture Division, with equal rank
and status after completion of his normal tenure, the Court finds that no
prejudice has been caused to him and no violation of the APFS, Rules, 2019 is
discerned. There is nothing on record to indicate that his service conditions have
been affected, rather the new place of posting as DFO, Silviculture Division,
Itanagar is also a cadre division and it does not affect his service conditions.
25.
Coming to the case of Mori Riba (supra), heavily relied upon by the
learned counsel for the petitioner, it is seen that same has been considered by a
Division Bench of this Court (which this court was a part of), in the case of Er.
Page No.# 15/18
Taban Tabing (supra), which is reproduced hereinunder:
“...17. The case of Hibu Tama (supra) pertains to transfer of a
Superintending Engineer in the Rural Works Department, wherein, the
regular Superintending Engineer was sought to be replaced by functional
Superintending Engineer, whose substantive post was Executive Engineer
and having found that the petitioner and the private respondent being
not similarly placed Officers in the Department, there cannot be an inter
se transfer between the petitioner and the private respondent, and
accordingly, the transfer order was held to be legally unsustainable.
18. The case of Mori Riba (supra), pertains to the transfer of Deputy
Conservator of Forest as Divisional Forest Officer and in his place the
Assistant Conservator of Forest, which is lower in rank was sought to be
retained. The learned Single Bench has made a reference to the
judgment of Niapung Konia (supra) and Hibu Tama (supra), wherein, in
similar circumstances the transfer order was found to be illegal and
interfered with.
19. Perusal of the above judgments of the learned Single Benches of this
Court, shows that the learned Single Benches have held that it is not
permissible to make inter se transfer between Officers who are not
similarly placed Officers in the Department. Having perused the
judgements, we are of the view that it may be correct that normally, it
may not be permissible to make inter se transfer between Officers who
are not similarly placed Officers in the Department. However, there would
not be a complete bar to transfer an Officer serving on Incharge/Officiating or Functional basis in a higher post unless it has
caused any prejudice and affect the service conditions of the Officer, who
is sought to be transferred to a different place of posting with same rank,
status and benefits depending on administrative exigencies. It is true that
the higher Officer cannot be replaced by a junior Officer, who may not be
competent to work in the said post, however, in the given circumstances,
if the Officer is competent, having the knowledge and experience with
his/her considerable length of service, in our view, there would not be a
bar on such transfer and posting. In the present case, there is nothing on
record to show that the junior Officer, who has been allowed to serve as
In-Charge in the higher post for a considerable time cannot be allowed to
serve as In-Charge of that post considering the service experience of the
junior Officer which may have gained in the course of service.
21. In the normal circumstances, it may not be permissible to make a
inter se transfer between Officers who are not similarly placed Officers in
Page No.# 16/18
the Department, but in the attending facts and circumstances of the
present case, we find no reason why the appellant cannot be transferred
from Boleng UD Division to an equivalent post of Surveyor of Works in
the Office of the Chief Engineer at Itanagar, after having been allowed to
serve for 4 (Four) years, whereas, the normal tenure is of 2 (Two) years
and the private respondent No. 3, who is one of the many Officers who
has been allowed to serve as In-Charge of an equivalent post of
Executive Engineer for a considerable period of time cannot be
transferred to a post of an Executive Engineer, in view of the fact that in
the Department, out of 36 (Thirty-Six) posts of Executive Engineers, only
11 (Eleven) Officers are serving on regular basis and the rest are either
allowed to serve as Officiating, Functional or In-charge basis, including
the private respondent No. 3 due to certain genuine reasons.
22. We may refer to some of the settled principle of law on judicial review
in the matters of transfer of Government employees by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court. In the case of N.K. Singh vs. Union of India, reported in
(1994) 6 SCC 98, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the scope of
judicial review in matters of transfer of a government servant to an
equivalent post without any adverse consequence on the service or
career prospect is very limited being only grounds of mala fide and
violation of any specific provision of law.
23. In the case of Rajendra Singh & Ors. vs. State of Uttar Pradesh &
Ors., reported in (2009) 15 SCC 178, the Hon’ble supreme Court has held
which is reproduced herein under:“..8. A government servant has no vested right to remain posted at
a place of his choice nor can he insist that he must be posted at
one place or the other. He is liable to be transferred in the
administrative exigencies from one place to the other. Transfer of
an employee is not only an incident inherent in the terms of
appointment but also implicit as an essential condition of service in
the absence of any specific indication to the contrary. No
Government can function if the government servant insists that
once appointed or posted in a particular place or position, he
should continue in such place or position as long as he desires.
9. The courts are always reluctant in interfering with the transfer of an
employee unless such transfer is vitiated by violation of some statutory
provisions or suffers from mala fides” In Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar this
Court held:
"4. In our opinion, the courts should not interfere with a transfer
order which is made in public interest and for administrative
Page No.# 17/18
reasons unless the transfer orders are made in violation of any
mandatory statutory rule or on the ground of mala fide. A
government servant holding a transferable post has no vested right
to remain posted at one place or the other, he is liable to be
transferred from one place to the other. Transfer orders issued by
the competent authority do not violate any of his legal rights. Even
if a transfer order is passed in violation of executive instructions or
orders, the courts ordinarily should not interfere with the order
instead affected party should approach the higher authorities in the
department. If the courts continue to interfere with day-to-day
transfer orders issued by the government and its subordinate
authorities, there will be complete chaos in the administration
which would not be conducive to public interest.”
26.
In the present case, the petitioner has failed to show any adverse
consequence on his service or career prospects or any prejudice, nor has any
mala fide or violation of any statutory rule been alleged. Admittedly, he has
been transferred after completion of 2 years at Pasighat Forest Division as DFO
to Silviculture Division, Itanagar as DFO to an equivalent post. Thus, this Court
finds no illegality or arbitrariness in the transfer order dated 16.07.2025.
27.
In view of the discussions made hereinabove, this Court finds no ground
to interfere with the transfer and posting order dated 16.07.2025, passed by the
Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & Head of Forest Force (HoFF), (E, F &
CC), Government of Arunachal Pradesh, and the order dated 05.09.2025
rejecting the representation of the petitioner. Accordingly, the writ petitions
stand dismissed.
However, considering that neither the petitioner nor Respondent No. 3 is
entitled to claim the post of DFO, Pasighat Forest Division, the respondent
authorities are at liberty to pass appropriate order posting a DCF/IFS cadre
officer as DFO, Pasighat Forest Division. In the event of a shortage of DCF/IFS
officers, an officer otherwise eligible to hold the post of DFO may be posted, as
Page No.# 18/18
deemed necessary by the competent authority.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review