Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
OWP/439/2018
Reserved on: 24.09.2026
Pronounced on:28.09.2026
Uploaded on: 29.09.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
1. Mst. Haleema (aged 60 years)
W/o Ghulam Jeelani
R/o Jamia Masjid Srinagar.
…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s).
2. Mst. Asiya Hamid Khan
(aged 40 years)
D/o Abdul Hamid Khan
R/o Nawab Bazaar, Srinagar.
Through their duly authorized
representative
Ghulam Jeelani Chatt S/o
Assadullah Chatt
R/o Zahidpora, Hawal,
Srinagar.
Through:
Mr. Manzoor Ahmad Dar, Advocate
Vs.
1. State of Jammu and Kashmir
through
Commissioner/Secretary, Public
Health Engineering, Civil
Secretariat Srinagar/Jammu.
...Respondent(s).
2. Chief Engineer, PHE, Kashmir
Province Srinagar.
3. Superintending Engineer,
Hydraulic, Baramullah, head
Quarter Sopore.
4. Executive Engineer, PHE, MP
Division Srinagar.
5. Deputy Commissioner,
Baramullah.
Through:
1 | Page
Mr. Jahangir Ahmad Dar, GA
OWP/439/2018
CORAM:HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
JUDGEMENT
28.09.2026
1. The petitioners have approached this Court through their authorized
representative, namely, Sh. Ghulam Jeelani Chatt S/o Assadullah Chatt R/o
Zahidpora, Hawal, Srinagar. Petitioner No.1 is the wife and petitioner No.2
is the daughter-in-law of the authorized representative.
2. The brief facts of the case, as projected in the petition, are that the
petitioners, on the strength of sale deeds executed in their favour, claim
ownership and possession over land measuring 10 kanals and 16 marlas
comprised in Survey Nos. 645-min, 960, 961 and 962, situated at Mouza
Dewar, Tehsil Pattan.
3. It is pleaded that, for providing water supply to the villagers falling within
Tehsil Pattan, the respondents laid water pipes of different dimensions over
the parcel of land owned and possessed by the petitioners. Some of the water
pipes were laid underground, while others were laid above the ground. The
respondents are also stated to have constructed small rectangular concrete
structures for controlling the water supply to the inhabitants of the area.
4. It is further pleaded that, upon the petitioners making a representation for
removal of the water pipes from their land, they were informed that an
alternative parcel of land had been identified, which would be utilized by the
department for the purpose of providing water supply to various villages, and
2 | Page
OWP/439/2018
that the petitioners would be appropriately compensated for the use of their
land by the PHE Department.
5. It is stated that, noticing inaction on the part of the respondents, the
petitioners submitted a written representation dated 26.12.2013 through their
duly constituted attorney, namely, Ghulam Jeelani Chatt S/o Assadullah
Chatt R/o Zahidpora, Hawal, Srinagar. The said representation was
forwarded to the offices of the Superintending Engineer and Executive
Engineer for submission of a report. A copy of the representation containing
the endorsement made thereon has been appended with the petition as
Annexure-8.
6. The petitioners claim to have thereafter approached respondents 3 and 4 for
taking necessary steps. It is pleaded that the authorized representative of the
petitioners was informed that appropriate steps were being taken either for
removal of the water pipes or, in the alternative, for taking recourse to the
relevant provisions of law governing acquisition/requisition of the property
from its owners. According to the petitioners, despite repeated visits to the
offices of the respondents, no effective action was taken and the matter
remained pending at different levels.
7. It is further pleaded that, in view of the alleged continued use of the
petitioners' land by the respondents, the petitioners issued a notice of demand
dated 23.02.2018, which was sent to the respondents through registered post,
calling upon them to take appropriate action in the matter. The petitioners
claim to have sought removal of the water pipes, payment of
rentals/compensation for use of the land and, in the alternative, initiation of
appropriate proceedings for acquisition/requisition of the property.
3 | Page
OWP/439/2018
8. The petitioners further plead that, during a spot inspection conducted by the
officials of the respondent department in the year 2013-14, it was noticed
that the water pipes had been laid around the parcel of land in such a manner
that the petitioners were unable to use the land for any purpose. It is alleged
that the network of underground and above-ground water pipes had rendered
the subject land non-usable.
9. It is the further case of the petitioners that, despite the alleged infringement
of their rights and the representations made from time to time, no effective
steps were taken by the respondents for redressal of their grievance,
compelling them to approach this Court by way of the instant petition.
10.The petitioners have, accordingly, sought the following reliefs:
―(a) Issue appropriate writ, order direction aimed at Issuance of writ
of
mandamus
directing
respondents
to
remove
the
underground/above ground water pipes laid, including removal of
concrete structures housing control system for distribution of water
supply over a parcel of land measuring 10 kanals and 16 marlas
located in survey no's 645 min, 960,961 and 962 situated at Mouza
Dewar, tehsil Pattan and allow peaceful user of the subject land by
the petitioners without creating any impediment.
(b) Issue of appropriate writ directing payment of compensation on
account of use and occupation ofthe subject land by the respondent
state and its officials in relation to subject parcel of land.
(c) Alternatively issue a writ directing the official respondents to
take recourse to provisions of law providing for acquisition/
requisition of the property.‖
11.The respondents have filed their reply, wherein they have raised preliminary
objections to the maintainability of the writ petition. It is contended that none
of the legal, constitutional or statutory rights of the petitioners has been
4 | Page
OWP/439/2018
infringed by the respondents and, therefore, the writ petition is liable to be
dismissed in limine.
12.It is further contended that the petitioners have not approached this Court
with clean hands and have misrepresented and suppressed material facts. On
this ground also, the respondents submit that the writ petition deserves to be
dismissed.
13.The respondents have also questioned the existence of any cause of action in
favour of the petitioners, contending that no genuine or legitimate cause of
action has accrued to them against the respondents so as to maintain the
present writ petition.
14.On merits, the respondents state that the department has been providing
water supply to the villagers within Tehsil Pattan and that water pipes of
different diameters had been laid over the subject piece of land decades ago,
when, according to the respondents, the land was vacant.
15.It is further stated that the petitioners purchased the subject land only in the
year 2012 and, therefore, according to the respondents, they ought to have
been aware of the existence of the pipeline at the time of purchase.
16.The respondents contend that there is no provision for payment of
compensation to a landowner merely on account of a pipeline having been
laid through his land under the provisions of the Jammu and Kashmir Water
Resources (Regulation & Management) Act, 2010. Reference has been made
to Chapter V of the said Act, which, according to the respondents, provides
for compensation in respect of standing crops, trees or structures in case of
5 | Page
OWP/439/2018
damage caused thereto, and it is contended that the said provisions have no
application to the facts of the present case.
17.It is, accordingly, the stand of the respondents that the claim of the
petitioners for compensation in respect of a pipeline which had allegedly
been laid decades before their purchase of the land is not sustainable.
18.The respondents have also denied the contention of the petitioners that any
additional portion of the land was identified for being utilized for water
supply to various villages. They have further denied that any assurance or
representation was made by their officers regarding removal of the water
pipes or initiation of proceedings for acquisition of the subject land.
19.The respondents have thus denied the allegations made by the petitioners and
have sought dismissal of the writ petition.
20.The writ petition came to be admitted by this Court vide order dated
13.08.2024. Despite availing the last and final opportunity, the respondents
failed to file their counter affidavit, whereafter, vide order dated 29.05.2025,
their right to file the same was closed. Subsequently, respondent No. 4 filed
an application, being CM No. 4534/2025, seeking permission to place on
record the counter affidavit, which application came to be allowed by this
Court vide order dated 27.11.2025.
21.In the counter affidavit filed by respondent No. 4, it is stated that the
petitioners have sought removal of the underground and above-ground water
pipes, along with the concrete structures housing the control system for
distribution of water supply, laid over the subject parcel of land. The
6 | Page
OWP/439/2018
petitioners have also sought compensation on account of the alleged use and
occupation of the subject land by the respondents.
22.It is stated that the land in question was earlier falling within the jurisdiction
of PHE Division Sopore and was transferred to the jurisdiction of respondent
No. 4 in the year 2020. It is submitted that, as per the stand taken by the
concerned division, water pipes of different diameters had been laid over the
subject land decades ago, when the land was reportedly vacant. Reliance is
placed upon the communication of the concerned Tehsildar bearing No.
TS/OQ/2024-25/144-45 dated 06.05.2024, whereby it was verified that the
petitioners had purchased the subject land in the year 2012. On this basis, it
is contended that the petitioners ought to have been aware of the existing
pipeline at the time of purchase and, therefore, their claim for compensation
in respect of a pipeline laid prior to their purchase of the land does not arise.
23.It is further stated that, after the area came within the jurisdiction of
respondent No. 4 in the year 2020, the necessary records were sought from
the parent division, i.e., PHE Division Sopore, vide communications bearing
Nos. PHE/LS/BLA-6758-60 dated 17.09.2022, PHE/LS/BLA-10038-41
dated
12.12.2023,
PHE/LS/BLA-10851-53
dated
15.01.2024
and
PHE/LS/BLA-11566-69 dated 10.02.2024. In response, PHE Division
Sopore informed that no provision for payment of compensation had been
made in respect of the subject land.
24.It is also stated that respondent No. 4 had submitted a report vide
communication No. PHE/LS/BLA-9904-06 dated 06.12.2023, indicating that
the pipeline had been laid through the subject land decades ago and
7 | Page
OWP/439/2018
comprised one pipe of 150 mm diameter and two pipes of 100 mm diameter,
along with two sluice chambers.
25.The respondents further rely upon Chapter V of the Jammu & Kashmir
Water Resources (Regulation and Management) Act, 2010, contending that
the said provisions contemplate compensation in respect of standing crops,
trees or structures in the event of damage caused thereto and, according to
the respondents, have no application to the claim raised by the petitioners in
the present case.
26.On the basis of the aforesaid stand, respondent No. 4 has opposed the claim
of the petitioners for compensation and sought dismissal of the writ petition.
27.Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material available
on record.
28.Before adverting to the rival submissions, it would be apposite to notice the
relevant statutory provisions governing the controversy. Section 12 of the
Jammu and Kashmir Water Resources (Regulation and Management) Act,
2010, insofar as relevant for the present controversy, reads as under:
12.Power to lay and carry pipes.
((1) The Government may lay or carry any pipe for the purposes of
arranging or maintaining the supply of water through, across, under
or over any road, street or a place laid out as, or intended for, a road
or street or any field, orchard, park, garden or other private or
public premises under the control of a local authority, government
department, board or a private owner or occupier and may at all
times do every such act which may be necessary or expedient for
repairing or maintaining such pipes in an effective state :
Provided that such execution of work shall be carried with least
annoyance to the public and within a reasonable time.
8 | Page
OWP/439/2018
(2) For any damage suffered by an owner or occupier or a local
authority as a result of carrying out of operations under sub-section
(1), compensation shall be paid to such owner, occupier or the local
authority, as the case may be, as per the procedure laid down in
Chapter V of the Act
(3) The Executive Engineer shall cause not less than fifteen days’
notice in writing to be given to the owner or occupier or to the local
authority, as the case may be, before commencing any operations
under sub-section (1) :
(4) The Executive Engineer shall cause the pipe lines to be laid
sufficiently underground to safeguard the use of land by the owner
or occupier.
29.A plain reading of Section 12(1) makes it clear that the Government is
empowered to lay or carry pipes for the purposes of arranging or maintaining
the supply of water through, across, under or over the lands and premises
referred to therein. The statutory power so conferred, however, is subject to
the conditions and safeguards contained in the provision itself.
30.More importantly, sub-section (2) of Section 12 specifically provides for
payment of compensation where any damage is suffered by an owner or
occupier or a local authority as a result of carrying out operations under subsection (1). The compensation is to be paid in accordance with the procedure
laid down in Chapter V of the Jammu and Kashmir Water Resources
(Regulation & Management) Act, 2010.
31.Section 12(4), which is also relevant for the present controversy, requires the
Executive Engineer to ensure that the pipes are laid sufficiently underground
so as to safeguard the use of the land by the owner or occupier. The statutory
scheme, therefore, recognizes the right of the Government to undertake the
work of laying water pipelines while simultaneously protecting the interest
of the owner or occupier of the affected property.
9 | Page
OWP/439/2018
32.Since Section 12(2) makes a reference to Chapter V of the Act, it would also
be apposite to notice Section 88 thereof, which deals with the award of
compensation for damage. Section 88, insofar as relevant, reads as under:
―88. Compensation for damage.––
Compensation shall be awarded for the damages caused to any
standing crop, tree, building or any other property by the entry, or in
the execution of any work or operation under section 12, clause (d)
of section 26, sub-section (2) of section 28 and clause (d) of
subsection
(1)
and
sub-section
(3)
of
section77.‖
33.Section 89 of the Act, which provides the mechanism for ascertainment of
the extent of damage and determination/tender of compensation, is also
relevant and reads as under:
―89. Procedure for award of compensation. ––
(1) The Assistant Executive Engineer, or any person on his behalf,
entering any land, building or other property shall ascertain and
record the extent of the damage, if any, caused by such entry, or in
the execution of any work or operation to any crop, tree, building or
any property and the value of material taken or utilised and, within
one month from the date of such entry, compensation shall be
tendered by him to the owner or occupier of the property.
(2) If such owner or occupier is not satisfied with compensation
provided under sub-section (1), he may inform the Assistant
Executive Engineer concerned accordingly and the Assistant
Executive Engineer shall forthwith refer the matter for the purpose
of determining the amount of compensation to the Executive
Engineer.
(3) The prescribed authority may, at any time, or on the application
made by any aggrieved person, revise or modify the order of the
Assistant Executive Engineer under sub-section (1) or the Executive
Engineer under sub-section (2) and its decision thereon shall be
final.‖
34.The statutory provisions noticed hereinabove make it clear that while the
Government is vested with the power to lay and carry water pipelines
through or over private property for the purposes of arranging or maintaining
water supply, such power is not unqualified. Where damage is caused to the
property of an owner or occupier in consequence of such operations, the
10 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
statute itself provides for payment of compensation in accordance with the
mechanism prescribed under Chapter V.
35.In the present case, the respondents do not specifically dispute the existence
of the water pipelines over the subject land. Rather, the specific stand of the
respondents is that the pipelines had been laid decades prior to the purchase
of the land by the petitioners in the year 2012. The report relied upon by
respondent No. 4 itself records the existence of one 150 mm diameter pipe,
two 100 mm diameter pipes and two sluice chambers through the subject
land.
36.The contention of the respondents that the petitioners would not be entitled
to compensation merely because the pipelines were laid prior to their
purchase of the land is not legally tenable. Once the petitioners acquired the
subject property in the year 2012 and the respondents continued to use the
same for maintaining the water supply infrastructure, the claim of the
petitioners with regard to damage and continued use of their property
requires consideration in accordance with the provisions of Transfer of
Property Act. It would be opposite to refer to section 8 of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882 which reads as under:
―8. Operation of transfer.—Unless a different intention is expressed or
necessarily implied, a transfer of property passes forthwith to the
transferee all the interest which the transferor is then capable of passing
in the property and in the legal incidents thereof.
Such incidents include, where the property is land, the easements annexed
thereto, the rents and profits thereof accruing after the transfer, and all
things attached to the earth;
and, where the property is machinery attached to the earth, the moveable
parts thereof;
11 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
and, where the property is a house, the easements annexed thereto, the
rent thereof accruing after the transfer, and the locks, keys, bars, doors,
windows, and all other things provided for permanent use therewith;
and, where the property is a debt or other actionable claim, the securities
therefor (except where they are also for other debts or claims not
transferred to the transferee), but not arrears of interest accrued before
the transfer;
and, where the property is money or other property yielding income, the
interest or income thereof accruing after the transfer takes effect.‖
37.A plain reading of the aforesaid provision makes it clear that, unless a
contrary intention is expressed or necessarily implied, the transfer of
property passes to the transferee all the interest which the transferor was
capable of passing in the property and in its legal incidents. In the case of
land, the provision expressly includes “all things attached to the earth”
amongst such incidents.
38.The fact that the petitioners were not the owner of the land when the pipes
were originally laid does not, by itself, disentitle him from claiming
compensation in respect of the impact occasioned to the land.
39.Upon the transfer of the land, the petitioners acquired the interest of his
predecessor-in-title in the property together with its legal incidents. The
respondents cannot rely merely upon the anterior laying of the pipes to
contend that the petitioners, who subsequently acquired the land, has no right
whatsoever to claim compensation in respect of the adverse impact suffered
by the property. Such a consequence does not follow from Section 8 of the
Transfer of Property Act.
40.The relevant consideration is whether the right to compensation is attached
to or arises in respect of the land and whether such right stood excluded by
12 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
the terms of the transfer or by the provisions of the statute governing the
payment of compensation. The mere fact that the pipes were laid before the
petitioners acquired the property cannot, by itself, constitute a ground for
denying him compensation.
41.To hold otherwise would mean that the right or benefit attached to the
property would stand extinguished merely because the ownership changed
after the pipes had been laid, notwithstanding the subsequent transfer of the
land with all the interest and legal incidents capable of passing under Section
8 of the Act.
42. Moreover, the pipelines laid over the petitioners’ land continue to remain in
situ and have neither been removed nor has the use of the land for that
purpose ceased. The use of the land, therefore, is continuing and cannot, by
any stretch of imagination be characterised as a one-time use. The petitioners
acquired the land in 2012, and the continued occupation and use thereof by
the pipelines constitutes a continuing interference with their proprietary
rights. In the absence of any compensation having been paid to the
petitioners for such continuing use, their claim for compensation cannot be
defeated merely on the ground that the pipelines had been laid prior to
purchase.
43.The aforesaid principle must also be viewed in the context of the
constitutional protection accorded to right to property. Right to property is a
constitutional right, and deprivation thereof can only be in accordance with
law and by following the procedure prescribed therein. Where the State
acquires private property, the person deprived of such property is entitled to
just compensation in accordance with law.
13 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
44.In this context, this Court is fortified by the view taken by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in case titled Vidya Devi versus state of Himachal
Pradesh 27 OWP No. 1885/2017 reported in (2020) 2 SCC 569. The
relevant paragraphs are reproduced as under:
―12.1. The Appellant was forcibly expropriated of her property in 1967,
when the right to property was a fundamental right guaranteed by Article
31 in Part III of the Constitution. Article 31 guaranteed the right to
private property, which could not be deprived without due process of law
and upon just and fair compensation.
12.2. The right to property ceased to be a fundamental right by the
Constitution (Forty Fourth Amendment) Act, 1978, however, it continued
to be a human right in a welfare State, and a Constitutional right under
Article 300 A of the Constitution. Article 300-A provides that no person
shall be deprived of his property save by authority of law. The State
cannot dispossess a citizen of his property except in accordance with the
procedure established by law. The obligation to pay compensation, though
not expressly included in Article 300 A, can be inferred in that Article.
12.3. To forcibly dispossess a person of his private property, without
following due process of law, would be violative of a human right, as also
the constitutional right under Article 300 A of the Constitution. Reliance
is placed on the judgment in Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v.
Darius Shapur Chenai, wherein this Court held that: (SCC p. 634, para
6).
―6…. Having regard to the provisions contained in Article 300-A of the
Constitution, the State in exercise of its power of "eminent domain" may
interfere with the right of property of a person by acquiring the same but
the same must be for a public purpose and reasonable compensation
therefor must be paid.‖
45.Further, reliance is placed upon the judgment passed by the Division Bench
of this Court in case titled “Shabir Ahmed Yatoo v. UT of J&K bearing
WP(C) No. 174/2021,” decided on 30.06.2022, wherein it has been held as
under:-
14 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
―5. The aforesaid facts and circumstances clearly reveal that the
private land of the petitioner bas been taken over by the respondents
forcibly without the consent of the petitioner and without taking
recourse to any procedure prescribed in law. It is also an admitted
fact that the petitioner has not been paid any compensation in respect
of the said land though the determination/assessment of the
compensation is under way as per the stamp duty rate. 6. It is well
recognized that Right to Property is a basic human right which is akin
to a fundamental right as guaranteed by Article 300 A of the
Constitution of India and that no one can be deprived of his property
other than by following procedure prescribe in law.‖
46.In the similar facts and circumstances of this case, the Division Bench of this
Court in case titled “Chuni Lal Bhagat vs State of J&K & Anr, 31 OWP
No. 1885/2017 bearing OWP No. 682/2018, decided on 17.03.2023” has
been pleased as held as under:
―47. There is no law permitting the deprivation of the property of the
citizens, the respondents are either to restore the land to the land
owners or pay them the requisite compensation, as no one can be
deprived of his Right to Property except in accordance with law in
force in the State. The petitioners being small land owners are
deprived of their property without payment of any compensation till
date. The petitioners are, thus, entitled to payment of compensation as
it has resulted in fraction of basic rights of Right to Property as
guaranteed under Article-300A of the Constitution of India and are
also entitled to use and occupation charges for the same.
48. In view of the aforesaid discussion, these petitions are also
allowed. The respondents are directed to initiate the steps for
acquiring the land under the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Act, 2013 within a period of eight weeks. The Deputy Commissioner
concerned shall pay rent for use and occupation of the land of the
petitioners‟ from the date, the respondents have taken possession of
the same.‖
15 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
47.This Court in a judgement titled Abdul Majeed Lone versus Union of
India and others decided on 20.11.2024 bearing OWP No. 1081/2014 has
held as under:
"The state in exercise of its power of ―Eminent Domain‖ may
interfere with the right of property of a person by acquiring the same
but the same must be for a public purpose and therefore, reasonable
compensation must be paid. In a democratic polity governed by the
rule of law, the Union of India could not have deprived the petitioners
of their property without the sanction of law and it is obligatory on
part of the Union to comply with the procedure for acquisition,
requisition or any other permissible statutory mode. The State being a
welfare state governed by the rule of law cannot arrogate itself to
status beyond which is provided by the Constitution."It is clear from
the aforesaid Judgements that the right to property, though no longer
a fundamental right, continues to enjoy constitutional protection
under Article 300-A. Consequently, where the State seeks to deprive a
person of the use and enjoyment of his property for a public purpose,
such deprivation must have the sanction of law and must be in
conformity with the procedure prescribed by such law.‖
48.This Court is of the considerate view that the right to access water and the
right to property are not rights that operate in isolation or in conflict with one
another. The State is undoubtedly under an obligation to ensure access to and
supply of water, which constitutes an essential public necessity and
implicates the right to life and human dignity. At the same time, the
constitutional protection of property under Article 300-A cannot be rendered
illusory merely because the property is required for a public purpose. These
rights, therefore, have to be read conjointly and harmoniously.
49. The State may legitimately utilise private property for the purpose of
providing essential public services, but such utilisation must have the
authority of law and cannot result in the owner being compelled to bear,
16 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
without lawful compensation, the entire burden of a facility intended to serve
the public at large. The right to provide water and the right to property must
consequently be balanced in a manner which advances the public purpose
while ensuring that the individual owner is not deprived of the substance of
his proprietary rights without due authority of law and just compensation in
accordance with the applicable statutory framework.
50. In the light of aforesaid discussion, the question regarding the actual extent
of damage, the portion of land being used or occupied by the respondents,
and the quantum of compensation payable, therefore, requires determination
by the competent authority in accordance with the statutory mechanism.
51.At the same time, if the respondents intend to continue using the subject land
for the public purpose of maintaining the water supply infrastructure, the
question of lawful continued use and occupation of the petitioners' property
also requires to be addressed. The respondents cannot indefinitely retain and
utilize private property without taking recourse to the procedure prescribed
by law and without addressing the lawful claims of the owner arising from
such continued use.
52.Accordingly, respondent No.2, Chief Engineer, PHE, Kashmir, shall
constitute a Committee in terms of the section 89 the Jammu and Kashmir
Water Resources (Regulation & Management) Act, 2010, comprising of such
officer(s) as provided by the Act, within a period of two weeks from the date
of receipt of a copy of this judgment, for conducting a spot inspection of the
subject land and examining the relevant revenue and departmental record.
17 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
53.The Committee shall determine the extent of the subject land actually being
used or occupied by the respondents on account of the water pipelines and
the concrete/sluice structures and shall assess the nature and extent of
damage, if any, caused to the property of the petitioners in consequence
thereof.
54.The petitioners or their authorized representative shall be afforded an
opportunity of hearing before the aforesaid exercise is concluded. Upon such
determination, the competent authority shall assess and pay the
compensation, if any, found payable to the petitioners strictly in accordance
with Section 12 read with Chapter V of the Jammu and Kashmir Water
Resources (Regulation & Management) Act, 2010.
55.In case the respondents require the subject land to be retained for continued
use for the aforesaid public purpose, the competent authority shall also
examine, in accordance with law, the petitioners' claim for reasonable
rent/use and occupation charges in respect of the portion of the land actually
being used or occupied by the respondents, commencing from the date on
which the petitioners purchased the subject land in the year 2012.
56.Such rent/use and occupation charges shall, subject to determination in
accordance with law, continue to accrue for the period during which the
respondents continue to use and occupy the subject land, unless the land is
duly acquired or otherwise lawfully released from such use.
57.In case the respondents intend to permanently retain the subject land for the
aforesaid public purpose, they shall also examine the necessity of taking
recourse to the applicable provisions of law for acquisition of the land.
18 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
58.The amount of compensation and rent/use and occupation charges, as may be
determined by the competent authority, shall be paid to the petitioners within
the period to be specified in the order. In the event of failure to make
payment within the stipulated period, the amount so determined shall carry
interest at the rate of 6% per annum, subject to the final determination of the
petitioners' entitlement, with effect from the date of their acquisition of the
subject land in the year 2012 till the date of actual payment.
59.The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of six weeks from the
date of constitution of the Committee and a reasoned and speaking order
shall thereafter be passed and communicated to the petitioners.
60.It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion with regard to
the precise quantum of compensation, the extent of damage, the area actually
under use or occupation, or the amount of rent/use and occupation charges
payable. All such aspects shall be determined by the competent authority
strictly in accordance with law and on the basis of the relevant record.
61.The writ petition is, accordingly, disposed of in the above terms, along with
connected applications, if any.
(WASIM SADIQ NARGAL)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
28.09.2026
“Mubashir “
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes
19 | P a g e
OWP/439/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review