The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. So far as the challenge to the impugned tender is concerned, which is also laid upon another point, in our view, has become mere academic after we quash and set aside the said tender and, therefore, we do not delve to make any observation in this regard.
19. In view of the discussions made hereinabove, these writ petitions are disposed of. (Harish Tandon) Chief Justice (M.S. Raman) Judge Sisira W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch Reason: Authentication Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch
W.P.(C) No.36703 of 2025
….
Haldhar Mishra
Petitioner
-Versus….
Opposite Parties
W.P.(C) No.11138 of 2025
….
G. Manju Services Pvt. Ltd., Cuttack
Petitioner
State of Odisha and others
-Versus….
Opposite Parties
W.P.(C) No.14048 of 2025
….
Petitioner
State of Odisha and others
Sanjukta Sethi
-Versus….
State of Odisha and others
Opposite Parties
Advocates appeared in these cases:
For Petitioners
For State/Opp. Party
: Mr. Pitambar Panda, Advocate
In W.P.(C) No.36703 of 2025
: Mr. Sukanta Kumar Dalai, Advocate
In W.P.(C) No.11138 of 2025
: Mr. S. Radhakrishnan, Advocate
In W.P.(C) No.14048 of 2025
: Mr. Saswat Das, Addl. Govt. Advocate
For Balasore Municipality/
Opp. Party
: Mr. Karunakar Rath, Advocate
For Opp. Party No.4
: Mr. Sougat Dash, Advocate
In W.P.(C) No.14048 of 2025
W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch
CORAM:
HON’ BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MURAHARI SRI RAMAN
JUDGMENT
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of hearing and Judgment: 28th January, 2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------HARISH TANDON, CJ.
1.
All these writ petitions are taken up together as the
respective writ petitioners intend to achieve the common goal,
though taking a different route.
2.
A tender was floated by Balasore Municipality and District
Administration inviting bids from different service providers for
proper sanitization, sweeping and parking facilities nearby the daily
markets and the collection of a minimum amount of tolls affordable
to the labour and the person having a low income. A prelude to the
said tender is felt necessary in order to complete the sequel of
events and to decide the points raised in the respective writ
petitions.
3.
Previously, a tender was floated for the same purpose but
could not be pursued for one reason or another and amidst the same,
a fresh tender is floated by the said Municipality containing a clause
W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch
which put a permanent embargo into such service provider, if he has
been blacklisted and/or debarred earlier.
4.
One of the writ petitioners has taken a different route in
challenging the said tender that unless the earlier tender is expressly
cancelled, the authority cannot float a fresh tender. However, one of
the public-spirited persons has filed the writ petition in the nature of
the Public Interest Litigation seeking a mandamus upon the
Municipality to provide the sanitization, sweeping and collection of
sairat in providing of parking facilities in the daily markets by
publishing a new tender.
5.
The reason for analogous hearing of the aforesaid writ
petitions is not only to avoid the prolixity of repetition of the facts
but also to consider the points so raised and, in the event, the tender
impugned in the writ petitions is quashed and set aside, the
consequential directions that would be passed would subserve the
purpose.
6.
The writ petition challenging the clause, which put a
complete embargo in participation of the service provider who had
suffered a blacklisting/debarment order, is taken up for the limited
purpose as to whether such clause offends the core ethos of a
W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch
fundamental right enshrined under Article 19(1)(g) of the
Constitution of India and the judicial declaration of law in a catena
of decisions rendered by different Courts of the country.
7.
Before we embark our journey on such terrain, it would be
apposite to quote the said clause, which runs thus:
"15. The Bidder must not have been ever blacklisted or
debarred either by the tender inviting authority or by
any State Govt. or Govt. of India organization or by
any PSUs or by any other department. The agency
shall submit the affidavit from Executive Magistrate
Only regarding the same on Non-Judicial Stamp paper
of Rs. 100/-. If it is detected in the course of bidding
evaluation that, a bidder has ever blacklisted /
debarred from anywhere in India, then the bidder shall
be disqualified on that ground. Revocation of
blacklisting /termination / debarment is not allowed.
(To be filled up in the given format)"
8.
On a bare reading of the said clause, it can be reasonably
gathered that a bidder who has been “ever blacklisted or debarred”
either by a Tender Inviting Authority or by any State Government
or Government of India organization or by any PSUs or by any
other department, shall be debarred from participating in the said
tender process.
W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch
9.
It is no longer res integra that blacklisting or debarring a
person from participating in a public tender has a larger ramification
on the fundamental rights enshrined under Article 19(1)(g) of the
Constitution of India. If the debarment or blacklisting is of
perennial in nature, it invites a complete civil death as the said
person during his lifetime may not be permitted to enter into a
contractual
relationship
with
the
Government
or
its
instrumentalities.
10.
Time and again, the apex Court has discarded the
blacklisting order to operate perpetually and directed such
debarment to be restricted by a particular period of time. One of the
recent judgments originating from this Court in case of State of
Odisha and others v. Panda Infraproject Limited, reported in
(2022) 4 SSC 393, the authorities blacklisted the contractor for an
indefinite period on two-fold grounds. Firstly, there has been a
gross negligence on the part of the contractor in making
construction of a flyover over the railway level crossing, which
resulted into falling of Ten (10) metres slab causing casualty of life
and serious injuries to many; secondly, the contractor continued the
construction work without adhering the design and the specification
approved by the authorities. The said order of perpetual debarment
W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch
and/or blacklisting was challenged before this Court and ultimately
reached to the apex Court.
11.
The apex Court, after taking into account such disturbing
incidents, applied the test of proportionality and held that the
perpetual blacklisting tantamount to a civil death which, in other
words, undermines the fundamental rights guaranteed under Article
19(1)(g) and reduced the same for a period of Five (05) years.
12.
Even this Bench of this Court, in case of Artatran Bhuyan
v. State of Odisha and others, reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Ori
2844, held that the blacklisting of a contractor has an impact on the
privilege and the advantage of entering into a lawful relationship
with the Government or its instrumentalities for his livelihood in the
form of gain. Though the blacklisting is one of the tools to eliminate
such defaulting or a defiant bidder from the selection process in
order to ensure a sense of discipline but putting such debarment to
continue for all time to come offends the core fundamental values
enshrined in the Constitution of India.
13.
Bearing in mind the broad principles of law as enunciated
above, let us examine whether the said Clause 15 of the tender on a
bare look put permanent hindrances to the service provider in
W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch
participating in the tender process. The word 'ever' used in the said
clause in its grammatical meaning applied for all time to come and
cannot be given a restrictive meaning to operate in a particular
period of time. The expression "have been ever blacklisted or
debarred" conveys a laudable message that even a person who has
suffered a blacklisting or a debarment for a limited period is
perpetually debarred from participating in the said tender process,
which impliedly creates an obstacle of permanent in nature.
14.
We are not unmindful of the proposition that the debarment
or blacklisting is an effective tool to be used by an authority against
the defiant or defaulting contractors or the service providers, yet it
should not be used as a tool for a civil death.
15.
The said Clause 15 inculcates a clear and explicit
expression that even a bidder, who suffered an order of blacklisting
for a day, shall be prevented from participating in the said tender
process. Such permanent debarment is opposed to the decisions
rendered by the apex Court in Panda Infraproject Limited (supra)
as well as Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India.
16.
We thus quash and set aside the said tender because of the
stringent terms and conditions which violates the constitutional
W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch
rights. It is open to the Balasore Municipality to float a fresh tender
taking into account the observations made hereinabove and such
exercise shall be undertaken within Fifteen (15) days from the date
of this judgment.
17.
Since the authorities have already taken initiative by
inviting the bid for providing such services, we feel that the issues
flagged in these writ petitions by the respective petitioners are
meted out.
18.
So far as the challenge to the impugned tender is
concerned, which is also laid upon another point, in our view, has
become mere academic after we quash and set aside the said tender
and, therefore, we do not delve to make any observation in this
regard.
19.
In view of the discussions made hereinabove, these writ
petitions are disposed of.
(Harish Tandon)
Chief Justice
(M.S. Raman)
Judge
Sisira
Digitally Signed
W.P.(C) No. 36703 of 2025 & Batch
Signed by: SISIRA KUMAR BEHERA
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 29-Jan-2026 17:36:41
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review