Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC040017282025
2026:GAU-AP:488
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/496/2025
Hage Mima
Son of Late Hage Tago, a permanent resident of Village Hari, PO Ziro, Lower
Subansiri District, Arunachal Pradesh and presently residing at Naniyas Abode,
Legislative Assembly Road, ESS Sector, Itanagar, PO Itanagar, Papum Pare District,
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
1.0The Chairman Arunachal Pradesh State Electricity Regulatory Commission
office at OT Building, 2nd Floor, Niti Vihar Market, TT Marg Niti Vihar, Itanagar, PO
Itanagar 791111
2:The Member of Arunachal Pradesh State Electricity Regulatory Commission
office at OT Building
2nd floor
Niti Vihar Market
TT Marg Niti Vihar
Itanagar
PO Itanagar 791111
3: Marjum Karlo
Age: 49
Son of Late Tamar Karlo
serving as Personal Secretary to Arunachal Pradesh State Electricity Regulatory
Commissioner
Office at OT Building
2nd Floor
Niti Vihar Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh 79111
Page No.# 2/10
Advocate for the Petitioner
: PD Nair, Tar Torum, Nabam Taro,Kara Parang, G. Mamu
Advocate for the Respondent : Dilip Saikia, Licha Tatam,Neelam Taje
Date on which Judgment was reserved : N/A
Date of pronouncement of Judgment
: 20.05.2026
Whether the pronouncement is
of the operative part of the Judgment ? : N/A
Whether the full Judgment has been
pronounced ?
: Yes
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
JUDGMENT & ORDER (Oral)
Dated: 20.05.2026
Heard Mr. P. D. Nair, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. G. Mamu,
learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Saikia, learned counsel for
the respondents No.1 and 3 as well as Mr. N. Taje, learned counsel for the
respondent No.2.
2.
Aggrieved by the appointment order dated 28.08.2025,issued by the
Secretary
(In-Charge),
Arunachal
Pradesh
State
Electricity
Regulatory
Commission (in short, ‘APSERC’), Itanagar, whereby the petitioner is appointed
as Secretary in APSERC to the extent of appointing him for a period of only one
Page No.# 3/10
year, the petitioner has filed this present petition.
3.
The case of the petitioner, in brief, is that pursuant to the
advertisement/vacancy circular dated 27.09.2024, issued by the Secretary,
APSERC, Itanagar, inviting applications for the post of Secretary on deputation
on Foreign Service Terms Basis from officials of the Central, State Government,
Public Sector Undertakings, Autonomous Bodies, etc., on contract basis for a
period of two years, the petitioner applied for the said post. The
advertisement/vacancy circular stipulated that the contract period of two years
would be extendable on satisfactory performance.
4.
The petitioner was issued a call letter and appeared in the interview on
22.11.2024, and thereafter, the respondent authorities published the selection
list on 20.12.2024, wherein one Dr. Umakanta Panda was selected and the
petitioner was placed at Waiting List No. 1. However, the said Dr. Umakanta
Panda refused to join the post due to certain personal reasons. Thereafter, the
petitioner was called by the respondent authorities and, after negotiation, it was
finalized that the petitioner would be appointed as Secretary, APSERC, on a
monthly salary of Rs.2,00,000/-.When no formal appointment order was issued,
the petitioner submitted a representation requesting for issuance of the
appointment order. Aggrieved by the inaction of the respondent authorities and
as his representation was not responded to, the petitioner approached this
Court by way of a writ petition, being WP(C) No.376/2025. During the pendency
of the said writ petition, the respondent authorities issued the appointment
order dated 27.08.2025 appointing the petitioner for a period of one year, with a
condition that the service of the petitioner shall stand terminated as and when
any officer is deputed by the Secretary (Power), Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, before completion of one year period. Upon such appointment, the
Page No.# 4/10
aforesaid writ petition was closed as infructuous.
5.
The petitioner, being aggrieved by his appointment for a period of only
one year on contractual basis, contrary to the advertisement/vacancy circular
which provided for a term of two years with an option of further extension
based on satisfactory performance, has filed the present petition.
6.
Mr. P. D. Nair, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner, submits that the
appointment order dated 27.08.2025 is clearly in contradiction to the
advertisement/vacancy circular, wherein it is stipulated that the appointment to
the post of Secretary in APSERC shall be for a period of two years, with an
option for further extension on satisfactory performance, as the petitioner has
been appointed only for a period of one year, with a condition that he may be
released before completion of one year in the event an officer is deputed from
the Power Department, Government of Arunachal Pradesh. Therefore, the
appointment
being
in
violation
of
the
prescribed
conditions
in
the
advertisement/vacancy circular, the same warrants interference, and a direction
may be issued to the respondent authorities to modify the appointment order by
providing a tenure of two years strictly in terms of the advertisement/vacancy
circular dated 27.09.2024.
7.
Mr. Nair, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the respondent authorities
are not permitted to change or alter the terms and conditions of selection as
stipulated in the advertisement after completion of the selection process,
inasmuch
as
the
advertisement/vacancy
circular
clearly
provides
for
appointment for a period of two years on contractual basis, with an option for
further extension on satisfactory performance. He submits that once the
selection process is initiated and concluded on the basis of the terms contained
Page No.# 5/10
in the advertisement/vacancy circular, the respondent authorities are bound by
the same and cannot unilaterally reduce the tenure of appointment to one year
or incorporate additional conditions contrary to the advertisement. In support of
his submissions, Mr. Nair, learned Senior Counsel, has placed reliance on the
judgment of the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Tej Prakash Pathak & Ors. Vs. Rajasthan High Court & Ors. , reported in
(2025) 2 SCC 1.
8.
Mr. N. Taje, learned counsel for the respondent No. 2, while narrating the
facts and supporting the case of the petitioner submits that the petitioner is
entitled to be appointed for a period of two years in terms of the
advertisement/vacancy circular dated 27.09.2024.
9.
Mr. D. Saikia, learned counsel for the respondents No. 1 and 3, submits
that considering the paramount interest of the Commission and recognizing the
urgent need for an experienced regular senior officer to streamline the
administrative and establishment works in harmony with the rules and
regulations of the State Government, the respondent authorities deliberated
with the Secretary (Power) Department, Government of Arunachal Pradesh. On
the basis of such deliberation, the respondent authorities requested the
Government to depute an officer in the rank of IAS or a senior APPSC officer, as
are being done in other Commissions in the State.
10.
Mr. Saikia, learned counsel submits that the petitioner was not selected
initially, but was placed in the waiting list. Upon non-acceptance of the offer by
the selected candidate and after negotiation, the petitioner was appointed vide
order dated 27.08.2025. He further submits that in the process of deliberation
and consideration for appointment, a considerable time had elapsed after
Page No.# 6/10
completion of the selection process, therefore, the petitioner has been
appointed for a period of one year with a consolidated remuneration of
Rs.2,00,000/- per month in terms of the advertisement/vacancy circular, purely
in the interest of the Commission. Since the petitioner was not the selected
candidate but was offered the post being a wait-listed candidate, is not entitled
to claim that his appointment should be for two years to a post which is purely
on contractual basis.
11.
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties
and also perused the materials available on record.
12.
Pursuant to the advertisement/vacancy circular dated 27.09.2024, one Dr.
Umakanta Panda was selected and an appointment order was issued vide order
dated 23.12.2024 by the Secretary (I/c), APSERC. Owing to non-acceptance by
the said Dr. Umakanta Panda, the case of the petitioner, who was placed at
Waiting List No. 1 was considered. After negotiation, the respondent authorities
decided to appoint the petitioner on negotiated terms and conditions, including
a consolidated remuneration of Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakh) per month.
Accordingly, the petitioner has been issued with the appointment order dated
27.08.2025 for a period of one year, effective from the date of joining as
Secretary, APSERC, inter alia, providing that the appointee may exercise the
option either to receive pay minus pension as admissible under the Government
of Arunachal Pradesh rules applicable to retired Government employees, or to
opt for a consolidated remuneration of Rs.2,00,000/- only per month inclusive of
all allowances. The Note to the appointment order reflects that in case the
Secretary (Power), Government of Arunachal Pradesh forwards and deputes an
official for the post of Secretary, the contractual appointment of the petitioner
shall stand terminated by serving one month’s notice in advance or by payment
Page No.# 7/10
of one month’s salary in lieu thereof, even before completion of the stipulated
one-year term, upon the appointment/joining of a regular Secretary to APSERC
by the Government.
13.
The advertisement/vacancy circular dated 27.09.2024 lays down various
terms and conditions, including that the selected candidate shall be taken on
deputation basis initially for a period of two years with an option for further
extension based on satisfactory performance and as may be deemed fit by the
Commission. It further stipulates that the contractual service shall initially be for
a period of two years and thereafter may be extended on a year-to-year basis
depending upon the performance of the contractual officer/official.
14.
A perusal of the advertisement/vacancy circular dated 27.09.2024 clearly
shows that the selection and appointment to the post of Secretary on
deputation shall be initially for a period of two years with an option for further
extension based on satisfactory performance. Thus, the petitioner, although a
wait-listed candidate, having been appointed after completion of the selection
process pursuant to the said advertisement/vacancy circular as Secretary,
APSERC, is entitled to be appointed as per the terms and conditions of the
advertisement/vacancy circular dated 27.09.2024, which includes a tenure of
two years. The respondent authorities, having appointed the petitioner only for
one year with a condition that, in case the Government deputes an officer for
the post of Secretary, the contractual appointment of the petitioner shall stand
terminated before expiry of the one-year term, would be in violation of the
terms and conditions of the said advertisement/vacancy circular pursuant to
which the petitioner has been appointed.
15. The case of Tej Prakash Pathak (supra), as relied upon by the learned
Page No.# 8/10
Senior Counsel Mr. P. D. Nair, has been perused. In the said case, a three-Judge
Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, while accepting the principle that once a
recruitment process commences, the State or its instrumentalities cannot tinker
with the rules of the game insofar as the prescription of eligibility criteria is
concerned, and considering that whether that should apply also to the
procedure for selection and doubting the correctness of the earlier decision in
K. Manjusree Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh, reported in (2008) 3 SCC
512, for not having noticed an earlier decision in the case of State of
Haryana Vs. Subash Chander Marwaha, reported in (1974) 3 SCC 220,
had referred the matter to a larger Bench for an authoritative pronouncement
on the subject. The Constitutional Bench, after considering all the earlier
decisions, concluded as follows, which is reproduced hereinunder:
“65. We, therefore, answer the reference in the following terms:
65.1. Recruitment process commences from the issuance of the advertisement
calling for applications and ends with filling up of vacancies;
65.2. Eligibility criteria for being placed in the select list, notified at the
commencement of the recruitment process, cannot be changed midway through
the recruitment process unless the extant Rules so permit, or the
advertisement, which is not contrary to the extant Rules, so permit. Even if
such change is permissible under the extant Rules or the advertisement, the
change would have to meet the requirement of Article 14 of the Constitution
and satisfy the test of non-arbitrariness;
65.3. The decision in K. Manjusree lays down good law and is not in conflict
with the decision in Subash Chander Marwaha. Subash Chander Marwaha deals
with the right to be appointed from the select list whereas K. Manjusree deals
with the right to be placed in the select list. The two cases therefore deal with
Page No.# 9/10
altogether different issues;
65.4. Recruiting bodies, subject to the extant Rules, may devise appropriate
procedure for bringing the recruitment process to its logical end provided the
procedure so adopted is transparent, non-discriminatory/non-arbitrary and has
a rational nexus to the object sought to be achieved:on the recruiting body;
65.5. Extant Rules having statutory force are binding on the recruiting body
both in terms of procedure and eligibility. However, where the rules are nonexistent, or silent, administrative instructions may fill in the gaps;
65.6. Placement in the select list gives no indefeasible right to appointment.
The State or its instrumentality for bona fide reasons may choose not to fill up
the vacancies. However, if vacancies exist, the State or its instrumentality
cannot arbitrarily deny appointment to a person within the zone of
consideration in the select list.”
16.
Upon careful consideration of the aforesaid authority, I am of the
considered view that the same does not support the case of the petitioner,
inasmuch as the principle laid down therein is not applicable to the facts and
circumstances of the present case. In the said decision primarily deals with
alteration of the selection procedure/criteria after commencement of the
recruitment process, whereas in the present case, the issue pertains to issuance
of an appointment order contrary to the specific tenure stipulated in the
advertisement/vacancy circular. Therefore, the ratio laid down in the aforesaid
judgment does not come to the aid of the petitioner.
17.
In view of what has been discussed hereinabove, I am of the considered
view that the petitioner is entitled to be appointed as Secretary, APSERC for a
period
of
two
years,
in
terms
of
the
conditions
stipulated
in
the
advertisement/vacancy circular dated 27.09.2024, wherein the post of Secretary,
Page No.# 10/10
APSERC is to be filled up on deputation basis initially for a period of two years,
with an option for further extension based on satisfactory performance. Thus,
the appointment of the petitioner as Secretary, APSERC for a period of only one
year, with a condition of termination in the event the Government deputes a
regular officer, would be in violation of the terms and conditions of the
advertisement/vacancy circular dated 27.09.2024. Consequently, the impugned
appointment order dated 27.08.2025, to the extent it restricts the tenure of
appointment to one year and incorporates the aforesaid condition, cannot be
sustained in law.
18.
Accordingly, the respondent authorities are directed to issue a fresh
appointment
order appointing the petitioner
strictly in terms of
the
advertisement/vacancy circular dated 27.09.2024, with effect from 27.08.2025.
19. Writ petition stands disposed of, in terms above.
20. No order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review